Difference between Carnatic and Western Violin | Which one is best ? | Tamil | Saravana Violinist

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 123

  • @shwetaravi2696
    @shwetaravi2696 4 роки тому +12

    To all my doubts I got my answers..thanks bruh🤘🔥

  • @krishnasantosh9896
    @krishnasantosh9896 3 роки тому +8

    Bro.. am 27. I wanted to learn violin. I don't have knowledge on music before. Few years back I bought one. And went to course but discontinued after a month as I moved to another city reg. Job.. now I feel I have enough time. I am doubting that will I able to learn it at this age.. plz guide me.

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  3 роки тому +8

      Age isn't a factor to learn music... I have seen people starting to learn Music in 40's..Just do what you love....✌️

    • @Machodave2020
      @Machodave2020 2 роки тому

      As a western classical violinist, I say go for it. I also started late (I started playing at 10, which even though that's still young, that's still late for most violinist). Take some lessons and learn on your own, y'all get their. Adult beginners tend to progress faster than children, so y'all pretty much just pick it right up.

  • @perseusvlasov367
    @perseusvlasov367 3 роки тому +2

    Can you make the same video in English please?

  • @shwethaamrutha1099
    @shwethaamrutha1099 4 роки тому +1

    How to match the vocal and violin tune same ?

  • @meetrathwa3107
    @meetrathwa3107 3 роки тому

    Whats the string name of classical Indian ( Carnatic ) violin and western violin

  • @SUDIRISING
    @SUDIRISING Рік тому

    Pls put english captions also. Can't understand the language 😐

  • @bindhuprakash4116
    @bindhuprakash4116 4 роки тому +1

    Will you help me to buy my first violin?

  • @palanisubramani8865
    @palanisubramani8865 4 роки тому +3

    Anna vibrato Tutorial podunga na try pantu irukan konjam.help panunga

  • @paintwithme5111
    @paintwithme5111 4 роки тому +1

    Same violin 2 type play panna mudiyuma like western and carnatic in same violin

  • @dhanureddy3991
    @dhanureddy3991 2 роки тому

    Is western good for beginners to start with ?

  • @amarjithpk6930
    @amarjithpk6930 3 роки тому

    Can we read indian songs in western Violin.

  • @ponnu2439
    @ponnu2439 Рік тому

    In which style can we play indian songs

  • @udaykumar7791
    @udaykumar7791 3 роки тому +1

    👍 it’s clear

  • @veerakumar6748
    @veerakumar6748 4 роки тому +1

    Bro, If i want to learn both western and Carnatic, which one you suggest to learn first for violin

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +7

      Watch Taylor Davis Violin covers
      And Binesh Babu Violin covers...
      They are my favorite Western and carnatic Violinist..
      Go for what you loved more..

    • @samlopez42
      @samlopez42 3 роки тому

      Bro watch paganini caprice no. 24. Even you haven't decided

  • @Yk-xw8lm
    @Yk-xw8lm Місяць тому

    ❤ Carnatic notes you give, Kanmani. But the player will add mane thene ponmane etc etc.. 😂😂😂

  • @vanivani8782
    @vanivani8782 2 роки тому

    I am karnatic singer but violin kathukarathu nu interest irukku so kettan

  • @rajgcgreets
    @rajgcgreets 4 роки тому

    How long it will take to practice western type? Is it ok Tuning western to carnatic often ? Does Fingering confuse?

  • @kannanb2207
    @kannanb2207 3 роки тому

    Sir ennaku Singer aga viruppam...
    Naan western padicha nalla irukkuma illama Carnatic use aguma sir?
    Please sollunga

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  3 роки тому

      Your wish...edhu learn pannalum proper ah pannanum and Practice nalla pannanum..Unga dedication dhan Unga result..

    • @kannanb2207
      @kannanb2207 3 роки тому

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 okay sir... Naala learn pannuna Endha songs nalum padalam right?

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  3 роки тому

      Yes almost...Unga own style la neenga try panna pada mudium..

  • @balasukumaran1364
    @balasukumaran1364 2 роки тому

    Sir. Eppadi. Seikkiram. Train up. Agalaam

  • @shyambharathi5748
    @shyambharathi5748 3 роки тому

    I am self teaching violin bro
    So enakku ethaavathu book suggest pannunga bro (western)

    • @yes1635
      @yes1635 3 роки тому +1

      I guess suzuki violin book 1 since thats what begginers use

    • @shyambharathi5748
      @shyambharathi5748 3 роки тому +1

      @@yes1635 yeah i practiced that book and just started volume 2

    • @yes1635
      @yes1635 3 роки тому +1

      @@shyambharathi5748 THATS NICEE

  • @SATHYANARAYANANB
    @SATHYANARAYANANB 4 роки тому

    Bro samma bro...english songs la play pana enna mari violin vanganu

  • @PremKumar-ct7rj
    @PremKumar-ct7rj 4 роки тому +2

    1st view😎

  • @deekshanimma7647
    @deekshanimma7647 4 роки тому +1

    Sir explain in English please

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +6

      Western Violin :
      1.Tuning - G-D-A-E.
      2. Scales - 7 flat and sharp scales and 1 natural scale. ( We can add Accidental notes )
      3. No common syllabus or books are followed..( Suzuki method , Honeyman tutor - Some well known Violin books )
      Carnatic Violin :
      1. Tuning - G-D-G-D
      2. 72 Melakartha Ragams ( Parent ragams ) and more than 1000 janya ragams ( Derived from Parent ragams ).
      3. Common syllabus is followed..
      Both are equally appreciable.. Whatever you choose learn happily...

  • @hemasherlyin.j11c79
    @hemasherlyin.j11c79 4 роки тому +6

    Western is the best

    • @invisbile9934
      @invisbile9934 3 роки тому +1

      100%

    • @sattiag4576
      @sattiag4576 3 роки тому +1

      no , Carnatic is best to try it out you will love it and who wants to be more common and to the fact, Carnatic is really difficult that western

    • @gauthamvanhalen8071
      @gauthamvanhalen8071 Рік тому

      Wake up to reality

    • @db_ee92
      @db_ee92 Рік тому

      You can’t say that . Both are best but can’t compare carnatic and violin

  • @JaySriramMUSIC
    @JaySriramMUSIC Рік тому +2

    I am 12. I have been playing violin for a while. I have been trying to play some Carnatic songs by ear. What’s the hardest part for someone with western classical background to play Carnatic music in violin? What’s considered harder to play ? Thank you for these videos

  • @shiburajpanicker878
    @shiburajpanicker878 4 роки тому +4

    Carnatic is the best !

  • @Shonichan86
    @Shonichan86 3 роки тому +3

    Western ട്യൂണിംഗിൽ കാർണാട്ടിക് പ്രാക്ടീസ് ചെയുക.... ലോകത്തിലെ എല്ലാത്തരത്തിലുമുള്ള സംഗീതവും വളരെ എളുപ്പത്തിൽ കൈകാര്യം ചെയ്‌യാം..

    • @voyaging4
      @voyaging4 2 роки тому

      Slip aakunnu bro violin , used to carnatic position . 😑 I feel i am not doing correctly

  • @bindhuprakash4116
    @bindhuprakash4116 4 роки тому +3

    Hey how can one be so sweet and nice like him. Thanks for your information. I like your attitudes. I respect you sir.

  • @raghavareddy4972
    @raghavareddy4972 3 роки тому +4

    Good morning Sir
    Beautiful lecture to violin learners
    I am expecting many more Vedios
    Thank you Sir

  • @Yk-xw8lm
    @Yk-xw8lm Місяць тому

    Super hairstyle . Thanks for the info

  • @invisbile9934
    @invisbile9934 4 роки тому +2

    But in western classical that has above 50000 classical peicess

  • @alexpauljohn1448
    @alexpauljohn1448 Рік тому +2

    Woah u said it so detailed thnx i think i know which one i should choose

  • @remeshkumar7716
    @remeshkumar7716 Рік тому +2

    hi bro, my question is which one is easier to learn classical or western violin? I'm eager to learn it in my 60s!

  • @San_tiagooz
    @San_tiagooz 3 роки тому +1

    Wich is best . Please reply. I don't know tamil

  • @animasnair2193
    @animasnair2193 8 місяців тому +1

    Well said Bro..

  • @amirthaaravinda3503
    @amirthaaravinda3503 2 роки тому +2

    Are there any major structural differences? I've played western for 9 years and am looking to switch to a new model, but violins are expensive where I live. If I buy a violin in India and tune it to my usual pitch will I be able to play like usual and put my shoulder rest on it because ik that some indian models don't have chin rests because they don't use shoulder rests

    • @柳風-x3f
      @柳風-x3f 2 роки тому

      As far as I know the violin design is same for both, and I use dominant strings and bought a separate s.rest. When I went to buy for the first time, the luthier asked me how do i want it to be tuned western or carnatic, but the strings were same.

    • @amirthaaravinda3503
      @amirthaaravinda3503 2 роки тому

      @@柳風-x3f I GOT A VIOLIN FROM INDIA ITS SO GOOD

  • @divyas4973
    @divyas4973 3 роки тому +2

    For beginners which can I choose carnatic or Western

  • @itsmejohnak6841
    @itsmejohnak6841 4 роки тому +1

    Bro online class carnatic ku ungalukku therinjavanga yaravathu irruntha suggest pannunga

  • @invisbile9934
    @invisbile9934 4 роки тому +1

    Classical western is so difficult ears and our techniques well develop that

  • @domtokyo282
    @domtokyo282 4 роки тому +1

    Can you make a video. Showing how to turn karnatic violin into western

  • @enkavidhaigal1707
    @enkavidhaigal1707 4 роки тому +2

    Bro violin'ah westernku yepdi tune panradhunu sollunga bro

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +2

      Search Violin tuner in Playstore...Adhu Android app...adhu use panni G-D-A-E edhuku strings ah tune pannuga...

    • @enkavidhaigal1707
      @enkavidhaigal1707 4 роки тому +1

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 tq nanba

  • @Mario23558
    @Mario23558 4 роки тому +1

    HI DO YOU SCALES FOR CARNATIC

  • @kirubamurali
    @kirubamurali 2 роки тому +1

    Nice anna

  • @sajikuttan5956
    @sajikuttan5956 4 роки тому

    Indian film songs are composed based on raga. Ragas are played better in carnatic because of gamakam. But film songs are better played better in western violin. Why? And do you teach carnatic violin?

  • @sairams1076
    @sairams1076 4 роки тому +1

    Want to learn western music bro.Need best tutor.Kindly help.

  • @4mandavi464
    @4mandavi464 4 роки тому +4

    Please tell in hindi 😭...or english...i can't understand a word 😭

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +3

      Lol..😂😂
      Western Violin :
      1. Violin Tuning - G-D-A-E
      2. Different Books are followed by each Violin tutor.
      3. Limited number of scale and accidental notes can be added to scales.
      4. It takes more time to hold violin in proper position and to play in tune.
      Carnatic Violin :
      1 . Tuning G-D-G-D
      2 . Same syllabus are followed by everyone to teach carnatic music.
      3. 72 parent Ragams and more than 1000 janya Ragams ..
      4. Holding position in carnatic is little bit easier than Western and playing in tune takes less time than Western as you can sing your Carnatic lessons...
      Both are equally appreciable...You can choose anyone... Learn happily...😊

    • @4mandavi464
      @4mandavi464 4 роки тому +1

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 thankyou !!!!

  • @parism555
    @parism555 3 роки тому

    I like your videos but I don’t understand them. And the subtitles are garbled. I am also a violinist

  • @importantlinesquad1728
    @importantlinesquad1728 3 роки тому

    Im confused what to select to practice violin as carnatic or western. please someone help me.

  • @ruganm2178
    @ruganm2178 2 роки тому

    Hiiii bro violin ninga solli Tharuvinagala... Contact number...

  • @drgeokinesis7665
    @drgeokinesis7665 3 роки тому

    Anna vibrato with shifting video plz make

  • @mylifestyleguru459
    @mylifestyleguru459 2 роки тому

    Scales difference pathi soluga bro

  • @vanivani8782
    @vanivani8782 2 роки тому

    Bro violin kathukarathu kastamaa bro🙄🙄🙄🙄

  • @deepthiambati4217
    @deepthiambati4217 2 роки тому

    Can you please keep subtitles for your videos….

  • @deeparam6878
    @deeparam6878 3 роки тому

    Is santana brand is good for Begginers?

  • @bindhuprakash4116
    @bindhuprakash4116 4 роки тому

    Hey how can one be so sweet and nice like him.

  • @pasupathykarpagavalli8973
    @pasupathykarpagavalli8973 4 роки тому

    Beginners eppidi hold panni vasikarathu ...like chin la vacha uh ela carnatic la vasikara maari ya which is better

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому

      Western violin na Western position Carnatic na Carnatic position...apdi dhan practice pannanum

  • @jwilson4894
    @jwilson4894 4 роки тому

    Bro shall i play keyboard notes in violin if the piece is in treble clef? Or i need transposing?. Thanks

  • @susindranpanneer585
    @susindranpanneer585 4 роки тому

    Ur master name naga??

  • @prashanthkumar3834
    @prashanthkumar3834 4 роки тому

    Bro. How do I play Indian songs in western notes. Most of my favorite songs are in Indian classical form

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому

      A Western Violinist can play a song composed in Carnatic and vice versa...
      Only thing differs is Gamakam and Vibrato....
      You can play any songs if you practice your Violin lessons well..

    • @prashanthkumar3834
      @prashanthkumar3834 4 роки тому +2

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 I feel, songs/pieces played in Indian classical are pleasing to hear than western

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому

      Don't compare... Just keep learning... Soon you'll find all your answers on your own..

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому

      I'll try to upload a video for Western players...just keep learning..

    • @prashanthkumar3834
      @prashanthkumar3834 4 роки тому

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 Thanks budd

  • @vedarajarajan3586
    @vedarajarajan3586 4 роки тому +1

    Hi Anna! I've been trying this vibrato quite long time but ennaku both hand coordination varala slip aaguthu. Naa carnatic dhan join paniruken but ennaku western maathri ninnu vachikanum asai how to learn both ways simultaneously btw naa beginner dhan.Plss do give some tips anna.

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +1

      Beginner tuning la play panna concentrate pannuga... Vibrato naraiya time edukum..and epo try panna venam.. Carnatic la Gamakam dhan first..adhuve Geetham la dhan solli kudupanga... Carnatic position la full ah practice pannuga lessons nariya ponadhuku aprm ninnu play panlaam.... Western holding position tough ...
      Epodhiku Tuning la play panna maatum paarunga. ...

    • @vedarajarajan3586
      @vedarajarajan3586 4 роки тому

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 thanks alot Anna ! True getham ippo dhan start pannen adhukulla lockdown,ipo violin tune senji en brigdge odaidhu😔so kept as such..no worries will try again later!

    • @vedarajarajan3586
      @vedarajarajan3586 4 роки тому

      Bridge*

  • @shrividhyaiyer5671
    @shrividhyaiyer5671 2 роки тому +1

    I started learning Western style of Violin, but my shoulders hurt abnormally. Do you think i should learn Carnatic as the posture is different ?

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  2 роки тому +1

      Do not hold your Violin tightly using shoulder/neck..Try using shoulder rest

    • @shrividhyaiyer5671
      @shrividhyaiyer5671 2 роки тому +1

      @@saravanaviolinist1215 i tried using a should rest too. But my shoulders and my arm gets totally numb.. Do you think, one must put up with the pain in order to learn it?

  • @beatmcat8796
    @beatmcat8796 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks brother. I'm very interested in learning to play cinema songs in violin. Does this fall under carnatic or Western classical violin? I'm very interested to learn. But I don't know where to start. Please advise.

    • @saravanaviolinist1215
      @saravanaviolinist1215  4 роки тому +3

      You can play cine songs in both cases.. Watch Western and Carnatic Violin covers..Choose what you loved most.. search for Violin class then get a Violin..

  • @Nutty...
    @Nutty... 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks da for this video.