How Are Non-Muslims Treated In Pakistan?Tilak Devasher On Past, Present & Future Of Pakistan| TRS336
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 тра 2024
- Check out my Mind Performance App: Level SuperMind
Android - lvl.fit/androiddownload
iOS - lvl.fit/iosdownload
Join the Level Community Here:
linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommu...
Follow Tilak Devasher's Social Media Handles:-
Twitter: / tilakdevasher1
Additional Links:-
1. Pakistan: Courting the Abyss - amzn.eu/d/ewhaGuE
2. The Pashtuns: A Contested History - amzn.eu/d/hqngN1v
3. Pakistan: At the Helm - amzn.eu/d/5U1Qsjp
4. Pakistan: The Balochistan Conundrum - amzn.eu/d/18gtoUF
🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
--
In this episode of The Ranveer Show, we welcome Tilak Devasher, an author, and a retired Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat of the Government of India. He is currently serving as a National Security Advisory Board (NSAB) member and a consultant for Vivekanand International Foundation. He is the author of three widely known books based on Pakistan; ‘Pakistan: Courting the Abyss’ (December 2016), ‘Pakistan: At the Helm’ (July 2018), and ‘Pakistan: The Balochistan Conundrum’ (July 2019).
Today, Tilak Devasher decodes Pakistan’s current situation and also sheds light on what happened during the partition of India & Pakistan. He talks about the history of Pakistan, the real story behind the India & Pakistan Partitions, his honest opinion on present-day India, and what could have been different if the partition didn’t take place. He further dwells upon Muhammad Ali Jinnah and how he led to the partition. Along with that, Tilak sir talked about the present scenario of Pakistan and what is the situation of non-Muslims in Pakistan.
This was an in-depth conversation about the India and Pakistan partition and how it happened. We also talked about the geopolitical scenario of Pakistan. I hope you enjoy this episode as much as I did and tell us your opinions in the comments!
(0:00) - Tilak Devasher x Ranveer Allahbadia begins
(3:10) - Pakistan History 101
(6:39) - How did the India and Pakistan partition happen?
(12:37) - His opinion on present India
(14:54) - Muhammad Ali Jinnah and his intention behind the partition
(34:35) - The History of Pashtuns
(43:37) - Present day Pakistan
(52:33) - Last few days of Muhammad Ali Jinnah
(1:03:02) - Modern day non-Muslim in Pakistan
(1:09:19) - Thank you for watching
(1:10:25) - End of podcast
#pakistan #tilakdevasher
--
✅ Subscribe To Our Other UA-cam Channels:-
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips (English Podcast Highlights):
/ theranveershowclips
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
--
Camera- amzn.to/3tRdGSk
amzn.to/3XsbYVe
Lens- amzn.to/3i5K5SH
amzn.to/3TX9lrj
amzn.to/3Oxwz6h
amzn.to/3i8hWdB
amzn.to/3XkQOZ3
Mic- amzn.to/3XE6Hdl
amzn.to/3TZfIuf
Light- amzn.to/3GDSaYK
Podcast Equiments- amzn.to/3tRZ9pt
amzn.to/3GGQNZs
SSD- amzn.to/3TW4Ltj
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
BeerBiceps by Ranveer Allahbadia is the ULTIMATE self-improvement & self-help channel. We began as a channel only for fitness & health enthusiasts. Eventually, we started covering topics such as fashion, grooming, personal finance, etiquette, meditation, mental health, communication skills & even entrepreneurship.
Today BeerBiceps is the home for The Ranveer Show or TRS. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation on The Ranveer Show is intellectual, deep & informational. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
Check out my Mind Performance app: Level SuperMind
levelsupermind.onelink.me/CsSR/youtube
Join the Level Community Here:
linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommunity
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
hey ram is a one sided hypocrite biased idiotic movie by hypocrite biased idiotic person
Ranveer I have a content idea for you Please bring international youtubers once in a while like ksi, W2S and the sidemen they could be really inspiring for people and don't think that you wouldn't get views because the sidemen ksi and W2S have a very big fanbase like W2S has stopped doing UA-cam but still his channel gets views you can also do Logan Paul and Jake Paul (That may become controversial maybe) and you can also bring pewdiepie or Mrbeast 😁. Please Like this comment so that Ranveer sees this
Some say that Afghanistan was cursed by Ghanthari after the Mahabharata Youdh 37:35
Please call once your broadcast string vinod bro ....he is always talk with proofs
Being a Pashtoon from Kohat I've found this podcast more historically educational and knowledgeable than all of the history of us I've ever heard.
I hope that KPK and Baluchistan become part of Afghanistan
@@wanderingnomad1 not under this extremist Taliban regime.
Bro, this is his side or his perspective, don’t take this as a basis to gain knowledge, this is just one side of the story, try listening your side of the story and build the consensus…
Good luck!!
@@maaz2all brother can you tell me from where I can study "mY SIdE" of the story because that was all vanished by Ali Jinnah at that time and later on in that massive Arabization and Islamisation by Zia.
Don't you know the sufferings of Bacha Khan and his generation, people of tribal agencies who were dragged into that fucking Afghan Jihad, don't you know how much Manzoor Pashteen is struggling for justice of our people and our culture and if you don't know that or you know it but ignoring it due to your IsLAmEeK & PAkiStoNI identity then sorry brother I can't argue you anymore.
@@maaz2all Explain yourself, how is it a one-sided perspective.
I as a Pashtun from Peshawar Khyber Pashtunkawa loved when we were discussed in the Podcast. Sir Tilak book on Pashtuns is recommendable. We had a ancient historical ties with India.
Nice, lets see who gets first ( India Wants POK, you want your original part)
@@_allahu_Akbarkeep dreaming 😂😂
@@cynicalyt2419 I am sure, my dream becomes a reality... How about you?
pakistani army No1 got attacked yesterday, ISI No1, have no information
I have never met a Pashtun who has any ill or bad intentions - always happy to help. But mess with a Pashtun, and you have made an enemy for life.
@@outbackandabout just like Rajputs ❤
Being a Pashtun from Peshawar it made me really happy being discussed in one of the biggest podacst Channel. We in Peshawar usually do book sessions, and Tilak Verma's book was discussed in one of those sessions.
Tilak Verma is Mumbai Cricketer bro😅
I really hope that KPK becomes part of Afghanistan
R u talking about Peshawar circle?
@@fitnessismylife1284 yes
@@fahadyousafzi sorry bro but ap logo k books selection bilkul achi nahi hai buhat he boring books pe sessions karte hai
Ranveer, not only elite people came but commoners too. My Grandfather came from Karachi along with my grandmother, they both were very young at the time of partition. They were threatened by their neighbours and friends whom they considered family to leave the property and run to save there life and dignity. My grandmother never recovered from PTSD of this life changing event.
Being a pashtun from Quetta Balochistan, I agree with everything said regarding the pashtun culture, the Durandline history, but have been enlightened and chilled with the real history of two nation theory, especially the point where Jinahh wanted to go back and live in bombay after partition. It was joyful to understand the real history which was already in place by instinct in every pakistani’s mind. Kudos to you sir Tilak!
Was ro ro pohigo ao u kigo
He needs to worry about khalistan
@@AyanAli-py7cilol, a moment that has zero legs in india😂
buddy khalistan has almost nil support from sikhs, like not more than 80k sikhs support khalistan out of their huge population.
@@AyanAli-py7ci
dont be in revengeful mind.@@AyanAli-py7ci
As a Baloch from Balochistan all of the historical facts quoted by Sir Tilak Devasher are accurate from Jinnah being a lawyer to the Khan and then betraying him in the end
So come how come You know that, that Tilak guy was right in all his sayings?
Tilak Sir missed mentioning the funny part about Jinnah sitting on one side of the weighing scale and asking the Khan of Kalat to give him the amount of gold equivalent to his weight for his legal services... !!! 🙂
@@vinayvipul wait is that real?
@@huzifavesos people who suffer persecution dont forget it and convey it to their future generation so they could be aware of it, kind of thing
Without selfish jinna this place would have been better...
Great podcast. Unbiased analysis of history. As a Pakistani, I haven’t learned these things in our history books. Now people also in Pak are talking about the true history. I hope we can correct our future direction when we know the true history.
I hate Gandhi and Jinnah
Many historical facts and main history has been kept secret nd they dnt want everyone to know abt it.
Change to hinduism
@@ayushsachwani2974
Kar di na bak©hodi...
When you throw kachra logic you get kachra
Histry alwys written by the victor to souit their own justifications.
A suggestion.. Kindly show location of areas mentioned during these kind of conversations on maps.
I agree
Dude... Are you saying sorry to Pakistani people for reciting the truth by your guest? Is your goal is not to hurt anyone or put the facts forward? Man I was a fan but slowly I am loosing confidence. Are you saying that the guests in your show lied? Please don't be diplomatic. What are your views on this issue? I believe You are not a news channel to put each other's views on vedio.
@@shyamaljitsarmah6216well, he's just a podcast host, the host's views do not matter. Technically, podcasts aren't even about telling what is a lie or a truth, it's just about discussing different things and opinions about everything. So, he did his job well. His job was to just put the opinion of the person in front of everyone, whether the opinion is good or bad, it's not his problem. And, especially in a country like India, you need to be diplomatic. Podcast is about the guest. If you like the guest, then watch the episode and if not, don't watch the episode.
Thoda geography padh le bhai
Totally agree
Being Pakistani, i loved the conversation. Such people are treasures not only to India but to the region as well. I would love to see more podcast. Both countries need such true historians.
Conversation based on facts.
@@niladrichoudhury9548 khe Facts
You should try to implement Sharia across your country.
@@OrichalcumHammerwhat on earth is this comment supposed to contribute?
Being a pakistani born in europe and married to an indian thanking you for these informative podcasts..
Love all yoir videos especially your geopolitical episodes
Married indian 😮
@@hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiibtoh kya ho gya🙄
I have never heard vice-verse 🤔, only in Gadar 1 and gadar 2 movies
Need to open the scoring from Indian side
@@yashchaudhary2331Lappu sa Sachin, Zingur sa ladka, NOIDA wala
Hey Ranveer, I am Indian Hindu, living outside of 🇮🇳 and have many friends from 🇵🇰 and my partner who is from 🇺🇸. Podcasts like these help me explain what is the ground reality in 🇮🇳 and what is the truth and why it is the way it is. Thank you again.
India is a gutter under modi , jai shree ram.
To mtlb sir ke hisab se britishers ne create kiya hindu muslims ka jhagda,kya ye baat sach nai ti ki muslims hindu ko kehte te ye to kaale,sabji khane wale log hai hum nai rehskte inke sath,kya ye baat nai ti ki british ke jaane ke baad muslims firse apni satta mang rae te us basis pe ki britishers ke ane se pehle mughals te,kya jitne b muslim rulers aye unhone yaha pe hinduo ko convert nai kiya or jo nai hue unhe kaat diya gaya,uparse britishers ne to hinduo ki jaan bachayi hai jb 1945-46 me hinduo ka katl ae aam ho raha ta dango me congress ne to muh me mung daal di ti or gandhi,nehru to hinduo ko ye kehte te,ki muslims maar rae hai tum maar kha lo par unhe apna bhai samjho,wo to britishers ne ye danga or katl ae aam dekhke fata fat partition krwaya,in 2 saal me 20-30 lakh hindu maare gaye te,or partition hone ke baad b jo kashmiri pandito ke sath hua wo tb to britisher nai te,isly jb 1 pure group of people me hi problem ho to ap dusro pe dosh nai daal skte ho
@@rahulsharma-ht7ut toh hum hindu toh hai hi girre hua dow kodi log, humnay delha kitna saaf hai india kitna ganda politicians hai tatti jaisey desh pe garb karo tum
Literally the same!!
@@rahulsharma-ht7ut perfect example of a baised analysis
As a Pakistani, i am highly motivated to buy and read Sir Talak all books.
Freindly advice to all Pakistanis ( who have obviously not studied in Oxford or Cambridge). The honorific " Sir" is added AFTER a person's name, not before.
When used before the name, it becomes a title. Eg: Sir Don Bradman. Anyone in India who studied in a decent school would NEVER make that mistake. The keyword being decent school.
@@adhirbose9910 Totally useless and irrelevant🤣
Tilak Devasher ... One of the brilliant experts of geo politics and policy. Today am just glad to see him here. Thanks Ranveer ! Big Ups to you and the team.
Tilak Devasher: "Everything was hunky dory between Hindus & Muslims until the British widened the divide between them??!! "
Devasher probably doesn't know Bharat and alarmingly has a very constipated view of Indian sub continent's Hindu Muslim history!!
Partition will always incomplete without full exchanging of two(Hindu & Muslim) communities💯 *don't force secularism on us*
Br ambedkar said that
True
मैं जिन्ना को गांधी नेहरू के ऊपर रखता हूं क्योंकि जिन्ना मुसलमानों को पाकिस्तान ले जाना चाहता था लेकिन गांधी नेहरू ने भारत में मुस्लिम रोको आंदोलन चलाया जिसका नतीजा हम आज भुगत रहे है। जिन्ना ने एक पाकिस्तान मांगा था गांधी नेहरू ने 3 दे दिए।
true, only way to stop hindus from gang raping and slaughtering muslims. heinously violent people gaslighting muslims
jammu massacres, gujrati riots, gulbarg massacre, naroda patiya massacre. shameful.
True but now when we think about Dr APJ my mind is got confused but your statement is true by the way .
Tilak Deveshwar is a surprise. Never knew about this person before but it’s good he has been studying this aspect of our history. Kudos to Tilakji 🙏🏽
Devasher hai gadhe
I love these kind of podcast.. please keep them coming! Love from a Pakistani
History lessons; more authentic than NCERT text books.
History as it is , rather than from the family of Nehru and his slaves (aka Romila Thapar)
@@Hdujwv5146hfb You read and come to your own conclusions. Do not rely on my inputs alone.
@@rajv9921first, this is advanced history. You won’t read this in high school. You will read all of this if you take college level courses in Indian history. Second, what is the need to denigrate Nehru? He was not perfect but he kept the country together. He was a socialist and slowed our country’s growth but he also made sure we had very solid institutions. He built the IITs, he cut down the army power because of which we have not had a coup, when every single neighbour of ours has had one. So, before you look at history, leave your preconceptions behind.
NCERT books are far better than some right wing podcast or WhatsApp forward.
@@neurolancer81well said
Attention Ranveer : hi , Ranveer . I watch most of your podcasts. I am loving it. Learn a lot from the show. I would like to make a huge suggestion that you kindly consider inviting Jamyang Norbu ; a well respected Tibetan activist and a very well known author of several books most recent one being ; “Echoes From Forgotten Mountains”,and one of the older books by the same namely , “The Mandala Of Sherlock Holmes” and many more equally great…He is widely read Tibetan writer I assure you that you will love …
❤❤❤
I am a sikh woman, 36y living in US for past 15-16 yrs and this podcast touched my soul. Thank you for presenting such highly intelligent and riveting conversation
Turbanhead. Chotiyadhari.
@@naveenawadhi6240 Ratio
They need to focus on India being a dump
Lier…wats ur insta id? If u really are what u say!
@@naveenawadhi6240muslim
Being a Pashtun I would say that thanks for mentioning us ♥️🇦🇫😅♥️🎉🇮🇳
Being a pastun and proud pakistani.
@@arslan97d whole gist of this video is that there is nothing to be proud of being a pakistani although being pashtun is a proud thing.4000 years old…woooww!!
When Sir said Baluchistan, I remembered Tarek Fatah Saab. Shanti to him where ever he is 🙏What a guest he would have been!
Yeah.. I still cry remembering him, he was gem of a person.. God bless him wherever hi now..🙏🏻
Who was he brother ❤
@@ShivamGaikwad-zc4lh a wonderful human... please google or YT him
Tarek Fatah Amar Rahe .... Jai Hind
Live in gta n If i can spare some time from work would be happy to spit on his grave. Will give me immense satisfaction
20:00
Jinnah and Muslim League accepted that confederation plan. It was Nehru who stated in his press conference after that meeting that once the Britishers leave and a united Indian government forms, we can amend the constitution as per our will. This angered Jinnah and made him concerned even more for the rights, representation of Muslims in the government. This led to Jinnah calling for the Direct Action Day.
Throwback to that one time when Mr Jinnah was done playing games.
Context:
"We do not want war. If you want war we accept your offer unhesitatingly. We will either have a divided India or a destroyed India."
-Mr Jinnah on 16th August, 1946 aka Direct Action Day.
❤ from 🇵🇰 first time watched your podcast and didn't skip it for a single second till end.
My ancestros were from Quetta and Sindh (Hyderabad). I remember my grandmother had told me so many anecdotes from those days. My family had to sell their ancestral house in cheap price to come to India n settle here but there were many people who left their house keys with neighbours. thinking they would come back as soon as the 'things' calm down and settle back in their space.
I feel disheartening to know about what had happened during that time. I am from Hyderabad, Sindh and most of my friends are hindus. we love each other and respect one another on their stance. It was good to know that you are from Hyderabad. Anytime, you wanted to revisit via video call or want to know your old home. I am here to help. stay blessed!
I just finished reading the book Independence by Chitra Divakaruni Banerjee and saw your podcast on the same subject. It's like an expansion of what i read briefly. Thanks, can't wait for part 2. You're making the subject of history so much more easier and interesting for the present generation. And more accurate.
What an amazing speaker! Loved hearing every minute of it. Looking forward to the part 2 .. Geopolitics has shot up interest in youth like us so much.. We want to know perspectives in every angle possible
Ranveer I have started following your podcast from last two months and I am seriously very happy to see and hear the people from different forte you bring on your show. Great job bro....👏👏👏
Murder of History is one book that made me realize what utter lies are taught to us in textbooks -.thoroughly enjoying this episodes- many thanks and gratitude from Lahore!
Who wrote this book? Lemme search!
Hey ranveer I'm in 10th rn and i have no second thoughts while saying that u r making the world easy for me whatever I'm learning rn despite of not being in my syllabus is an ultimate investment for future
I respect u af
:-Shaurya Sashwat Singh Chauhan
What a beautiful name👌🏻👌🏻
@@universalblessing4856 true, and with an attitude to match! Keep going young man 💪
Thanks bhai mujhe motivate karne ke liye 🙂
Ranveer is just the beginning
@@Chanakya831 what do you mean bro 🤔
One of the best episodes done so far Ranveer!! Kudos. So much of history and aspects many from our generation wouldn't have known!
I always wonder how one person can get this kind of knowledge. Hats off to Tilak Sir. Ranveer & team fetching some class guests here as always 👏
I have a huge crush on this guy , Khair this has been one of the best podcast about history , I want a podcast on the history of balochistan as well , love your every podcast , love from balochistan .
Are you gay bro?
@@ReligioCritic tumko kese pta ye ladki ne comment nhi dia h? Azeeb insaan ho yar😅
@@kharkhuadexor Profile me click kro, Junaid Ahmed naam ki kaun ladki hoti hai? Dimag use krne ko tumhare lingo me ajeeb kaha jaata hai?
@@ReligioCritic sorry I don't do such level of snooping lol. It never occurred to me to go view the profile. But again someone might use their father's or brother's profile to comment, so again not a solid argument. Lkin gay h v to hoga aur, not my concern.
@@kharkhuadexor It's not called snooping, if I'm taking to someone I'll check their name, I'm not gonna talk to their YT ID, I didn't open his profile, I don't know what's inside his profile, I just checked his name, like I do with everyone. Someone might do this, someone might do that, Idc, I just looked at his profile, I saw a male name, I asked a question, I'm not making any argument because you make arguments when you're sure, if I was sure I wouldn't have asked him that question.
Again, you jumped in it by choice, never said you should be concerned if he's gay or not.
Thank you for calling such wonderful guests...I specially look forward to the spiritual podcasts
I hope you enjoy this one ❤
@@BeerBicepsbro
Please do an historical or Gandhi centred interview with Anand rangnathan
He will give eye opening facts
@@BeerBicepsbro called sushant sareen once
@BeerBiceps please once call to your broadcast string vinod sir ....he is always speak with proof and fact .
Political podcast is best Also geopolitical podcasts
Now I'm from Germany watching all your episodes please go ahead with some World history as I'm looking forward
R U German? ☺
Mr Deveshawar is such a great intellect , and India is lucky to get such type of civil servant which shaped the Indian diplomacy and still serving the country by being in advisory board.
Thank you for calling Tilak sir on the podcast. He is indeed a stellar guest. Looking forward for more podcasts with him on your show.
Only channel which I crave for. I learn a lot from here and I'm really grateful to @Ranveer sir for giving us such intellectual content. Thankyou 🙏
Eagerly waiting for the part-2
0:19 DIRECT ACTION DAY WAS HAPPEN ON 16AUG 1946 ON 18 DAY OF ROZA IN THE MONTH OF RAMZAN. SO DON'T FOOL YOUR SELF ON BHAI CHARA FIRST KNOW WHO IS BHAI AND WHO'S CHARA.
Education🙏 this is why we need well read people and of course give them a forum to share the right information which helps the world. Great one TRS🤗
The best guest so far. Always a pleasure to listen to Tilak Devasher ji.
Wow... nice to see your comment, I watch your channel
you should invite him for a conversation @sonam
Sonam didi nice to see you here I am one of your subscribers
I also add a request. Can we have a session with Roopa Pai an amazing novelist who writes on the Gita, Vedas and Upanishads for children. She is a fascinating author and would want to know more about her.
This is the most interesting conversation I have heard 😮 History is just not what we read back at school and nobody told the truth which we got to know when we left school 😢
As a Pashtun from Dir, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. This podcast was more intellectual rather than emotional and sentimental.
Love from my side to you and Thilak Sir. He has written a monumental and enduring masterpiece on the History of Pashtuns.❤
This is one of the best Podcast to know about the History. Tilak sir thank you and thank you to Beerbiceps team.
Excellent guest, Full of knowledge.. A great podcast, very informative.. 👍🏻
I m listening to your podcast early morning rather watching Netflix series . Ranveer u seriously have got quality podcasts which is sort of good enough to enlighten people and know more about existing personalites . U were right about geopolitics podcasts i m loving it and m sure lot others are too. Keep calling guests that can truly provide raw and authentic information about the topic u come up with.
Not making up to a million before retirement is unfulfilled retirement.!! I’m 54 and my wife 50 we are both retired with over $7 million in net worth and no debts. Currently living smart and frugal with our money. No longer putting blames on FED for our misfortunes. Saving and investing lifestyle in the crypto market made it possible for us this early, even till now we earn weekly.
Great job with your wife! I bet you’re living your best life right now.
I really need a nice investment to venture into I'm thinking of Crypto assets, stock or Real estate
all you mention are all good but I’ll advise you venture into crypto first because it will help you grow your portfolio very fast and it require not so much to start
1 btc cost a fortune isn’t this a set back for new investors?
Going into crypto doesn't mean you buy that much. You can start with little invest it and watch it grow to generate profits that's how I have grown my net worth.
Just finished the episode and was craving more. So happy to hear there's a part two. Listening from NZ this podcast is a way to get to understand the culture/geopolitics/current events not just of India but of the whole region. Ranveer does such a great job and I think that the youth of India are blessed to have him.
Here The List of Guest..love to watch:
1.Alakh Pandey (Educational Revolution)
2.Sudhansu Trivedi(Our Culture)
3.K Shivan/S Somanath (Science)
4.Prasant Dhawan (World Affairs)
5.Ravish Kumar/Sudhir Choudhary (Criticism/Praise of Indian Gov.)
6.Mukul Rohtagi(Law)
7 .Cabinet Secretary
Glad to see such a informative conversation...
Thanks Ranveer Bhai 🙏💐🙏
Awesome podcast , nice to hear from Mr.Devashar ,can't wait for part 2
Thankyou Ranveer we Pakistani love you and your country please invite Pakistani guests too.
Sorry
Yaa I will like to watch
At present moment,Visas r not given to Pakistanis due to security reasons but in future, Ranveer may conduct podcasts in neutral places like Dubai where Pakistanis can be invited
You are looking healthier day by day Ranveer❤️ And the podcasts are getting better, my love for Indian politics is growing with such episodes!
Good move.... What a mature choice from a young lad... experience weighs more .... will watch it tonite 😃😃😃😃😁
One of the most intellectual stimulating conversations ever.........
Absolutely loved this show ❤
Awesome Ranveer👍 .. could see your patience throughout the podcast.
Tilak Devasher One of the Most Brilliant Minds of India...❤🙏
Tilak sir is a member of India's National Security Advisory Board & a former Senior Intelligence Officer
And close ally of Ajit doval
tilak devasher is an Indian Citizen or else he would not have been eligible to hold the membership in the Board@@XerxesLangrana
@@harshhooda Sorry, I was replying to a comment about Tarek Fateh, not Mr. Devasher.
@harshhooda My bad. I'm definitely blind. Deleting my comment.
Yep he was special secretary RAW.
Thanks Ranveer! Your podcasts are a extremely educative!
I had an epiphany of my own watching this one in particular. I realized that as soon as you defer your national identity being Pakistani or Hindustani in favor of your ethnic identity being Punjabi or Sindhi, suddenly peace dawns upon you and the rivalry or animosity vanishes.
Tilak Saab is renowned for his expertise in geographic knowledge and research.
Perhaps the best episode ever on history and politics
Hey @beerbiceps, thanks for coming up with great videos! Would love to see some science related video soon.😊
Ranveer Bhai and the guest, Im thankful to your both as I gained lots of knowledge about the situation. Today I spoke with some Afghans my friends were shocked that I knew lots of information about the situation. The Afghans and my friends both were impressed today thank you for everything I learned a lot.
I love ur podcasts. I would even like to see more of other kind of videos. Self improvement, particular topic driven videos.
Thank you for inviting him. Please keep the podcast this way by inviting actual intellectuals and not social media jokers.
Great Going... Worth-Watching Wonderful Work👍👍😇
Excellent podcast bro... Definitely an eye opener.. Request to do such casts more to bring out the actual history and facts...
When can we expect the second part? Great episode, highly educating!
bring
1 - Yogi adityanath ( Topic civilization )
2 - Mayawati ( Caste hurdles and modern day relevance of reservation )
3 - Akhilesh yadav ( Samajwad in the Era of Globalisation )
Ranveer please bring Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed sir, he is a professor at the University of Stockholm and the best person to put forward the Pakistani perspective.
Always great to listen to Devasher sir.
Bring on part 2!Can't wait!
Amazing podcasts. More power to you Ranveer. Tilak sir, kudos to you
There was an Amitabh Bachchan movie about a Pathan taking revenge. The movie is called Khuda Gawah. The movie was shot in Afghanistan in the middle of the Russian invation of Afghanistan
The movie was shot in mountains of Nepal and it was shown as Afghanistan cause it was too unsafe to shoot in Afghanistan then
@@Parina770 Janab Ali Amitabh visited Kabul in 1989 or 90 for shooting
Very good and informative episode....Loved the episode very much.... eagerly looking forward to the next episode with Tilak Sir
One of those podcasts where I'd love to only listen to the guest & not Ranveer blabbering or at the minimum just the questions that's it. Tilak sir is a goldmine of wisdom.
Ranveer blabbering is so cute and genuine curiosity. Which gives a beautiful flavor to podcast.
Seriously Ranveer blabbers too much..
And this is why the British ruled India. Indians jealously 😂
J Sai deepak rightly said they may have differences between each other but when it comes to outsider they will unite
The Brahui-Tamil similarity blew my mind away! Simply wow!
Its dravidian
@@AyanAli-py7ci no such thing as dravidan except maybe in ape communities.
Amazing podcast, amazing education, not what you learn from schools ❤
I am Kamlesh Lavha Meghwar From Umerkot Sindh,Sir I feel very merry to see conversation regarding Pakistan's history.
Indeed one of the best podcasts, what a mature personality Tilak sir is, hats off to him.
Always a pleasure to watch Mr. Devasher. Quality content Ranveer. Thank you!
The best episode. Thank you for calling him.
What a great podcast. Thanks ranveer for this video❤😊
Always great to have Tilak! A man of knowledge!
Bhai thodi izzat dede!! Sir,ji? Kuch tib likhta
@@parkaarpencil7856 Tumhay bund Mey taklif hey sir g
Wonderful episode History lesson of the highest caliber
I identify as a Muslim, a Pashtoon, and a Pakistani, and I approach matters of nationality, ethnicity, and religion with an open mind. Eager to broaden my understanding and explore diverse perspectives, my anticipation for Mr. Tilak's discourse rested on the expectation of well-informed and fact-based insights. Regrettably, my experience left me disillusioned, as it became evident that he was essentially echoing the viewpoints of the Indian Foreign Office.
Rather than offering a nuanced perspective, Mr. Tilak staunchly defended the actions of the Modi government and India's approach to the Kashmir issue. His dismissive stance on the challenges faced by minorities in India, backed by purported surveys but lacking an exploration of the intricate realities on the ground, was disheartening. The overall impression was of an individual closely aligned with Indian state-sponsored narratives.
What struck me even more profoundly was his apparent lack of awareness or willingness to delve into the reasons behind the Indian National Congress's betrayal of Abdul Ghafar Khan during the critical moments of partition. As a Pashtoon, this betrayal holds deep significance for me, and the omission of such a crucial historical aspect left me questioning the credibility of the discourse.
Upon reflection, I find that Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmad, a Pakistani professor based in Stockholm, provides a more critical and logical approach to the examination of Pakistan's past and present. His scholarly contributions offer a potentially more insightful and balanced perspective for those seeking a comprehensive understanding of the region.
U do have a kind of valid point but how can u make a nation on religion
@@prateeksharma6706 I didn't advocate that in my comments!
Amazing Podcast Ranveer, your Volgs are amazing and brings such value to our community.
With every single podcast i learn so much not missed even a single one. U are a nice soul
Superb podcast. Another good one Ranveer!
Eagerly waiting for part 2 of this conversation...
Thank you, Beer Biceps for getting an amazing scholar. How he explained in such a beautiful manner the entire period before & after. Curiosity has been aroused even further for any such topic by Tilak Sir. 🙏🏼🙏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I am currently reading about constituent assembly in my undergraduate. And this is the perfect timing to listen to this podcast to know the background 😊😊😊😊😊💓💓
I listen today. I learn education our history. Good work keep it up.👌
After Smita prakash @ani. I was curious to see tilak devasher giving more insights. It feels so real, no biases. He openly accepts when he doesnt have knowledge. Ppl like tilak sir are the kind who need more attention in society
Super podcast! Tilak Sir explained history so well from Durand line to Partition ...right up to his clarification of CAA !! Extreme clarity of thought along with superb and smooth delivery ! 👍👍
The quality of information this show is spreading is helpful in educating a whole generation, which indeed is remarkable! Ranveer...bro..U r doing a wonderful job... whatever stakes it may hold now or any way in future..I urge u not to pause..here sending good and positive vibes from my end🙏😊
As a pakistani thank you for your unapologetic expressions! You speak with your expressions! As far as the episode goes, thank you for asking the unbiased difficult question. I truly appreciate them. Cant wait to see the 2nd part. But i do want to know when was the last time your prestige guest saw the “qaida” and the textbooks being taught in pakistani public schools!? 🤔
is it not true what Dr Deveshwar said about the books ?
@@rashmisingh3499 Not true. This statement of him has really hurt his credibility in my eyes.
maybe in rural area's mosque's books? I could be wrong.@@ammaduddin6290
Bro…get an intellectual person over here. This needs to be discussed. Are you really fucked??( im neutral while writing this)
Loved the show….very interesting!!!! I would love to hear Tilak sir again !
I look forward to more geopolitical, history and spiritual episodes on your show !!!
I’ve personally learnt so much about geopolitics and developed interest in it from your show ! Amazing, you’re doing a great job! Keep going!