Islam and Socialism on Private Property
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 кві 2024
- Some people argue that Islam is against socialism because Islam allows private property. This is the response from the left.
*English UA-cam: / taimurrahman1975
*Instagram: / taimur_laal
*Twitter: / taimur_laal
آپکے لیکچرز نے مُجھے تبدیل کر کے رکھ دیا ہے میں خود کو پہچان رہا تھا تو مُجھے سمجھ نہی اتی تھی میں کون ہوں اب میں بہُت حد تک خود کو تلاش کر چُکا ہوں سر آپ کا بہت شکریہ اللہ آپ کو ہمیشہ سلامت اور خوش رکھے آمین
مختصر مگر جامع انداز میں سمجھانا ڈاکٹر تیمور صاحب کا ہی کمال ہے۔ بہت ہی زبردست۔
Now qaisar bhai will be thinking to reply 😂😂😂... He always be like mai hi sab jaanta hai ....
Was really waiting for this reply !!
Sir waiting for further Mutazili parts. Are there more parts to come Or is the series completed??
Very impressive and convincing. But please elaborate about dangers of totalitarianism, one party hegemony in communism. And how would you differentiaye between social democracy and communist philosophy. Communism is only a politico-ecomonic policy or religious/moral philosophy too? Please Make a vlog if possible.
Very good sir keep it up you are doing great
Sir apse ek sawal hai alfarbi ka nazriya muhje socialism or communism ki trah dekhta hai. Mere koi teacher sir please Bata dain muhje
Keep addressing sir ..
Sir phir aik banda socialist society mn investment kahan karayga?
Sir plz G.A.Pervez k point of view about Quran and socialism pr lecture den
According to Quran, Huwallazi khalaqa lakum maa filarze jameehaa--Albaqara.
It means that means of production are only public or collective property according to Islam and not private property
iski tafseer is tarah kis bada faqih na ki ha jo ap kar rahe hain
Whole concept of ZAKAT is based on private property / wealth. One should not accumulate wealth by wrong means or exploitation of others weaknesses.
Is earning interest/profit on bank savings wrong?
Is buying selling stocks/bonds/cryto wrong?
Is earning profit by buying/selling plots wrong?
Is earning profit on buying/selling gold wrong?
Is earning rent on a property/agriculture land which was passed on to you by inheritance wrong?
Is it wrong to get free land through government contract and then removing people already living there from 100s of years then build a housing society there and sell that?
Mu'Tazili episode 7 kab ay ga?
Sir india mein Naxal movement per video banein
Sir ma ap cy milna chata hun.
I am student of lahore leads university
Sir please apki videos say aisa lagta hai k islam ka system socialism hai.
Please make clarification.
I think quran is also not clear on private property issue beacuse aik tarf hukum hai k jo kuch bhi apk pas hai usay Allah kee raah mn day do jab k doosri trf wiraasat kee ayaat bhi hn jahn sy private property rakhna saabit hota h
Sir g capitalism prhayain... Ye banks kaisy dnya ko control krty... Ye sb.. Akhir new technologies any ki. Wja. Sy ye amazon digital currencies.. Bitcoin ye ASAl m haqeqat h kya...
Ghr bethay binance s kmao ye kro wo kro... Pury Pakistan ka dmag confuse h... Jb tk ap jaisy smjdar log hamain smjhayein gy nh... Hamain kya pta real m kya Sach h
Inshallah l will implement it,,, l am planning for two years....
2:25 wonder who this not so subtle jab was for 👀
@Taimur_Laal Sir I've been listening to your podcast since last year and I can assert, without any doubt, that you're the best. Thank you for enlightening us with your knowledge. ❤
It'd be much appreciated if if you could please tell us how socialism treats private property. Since socialism is based on the principle of equality. Is this equality of resources or equality of opportunity. If all people in the society are given same resources, why would someone work more than others. Wouldn't it lead to the collapse of system, if everyone knows that I'll get my share, I don't need to work hard. Besides, how would we determine the capacity of an individual and how would we allocate resources, if that's the case, according to his capacity ?
Bilkul aisa hi ha
❤❤❤❤❤❤ great sir
Sir according to quran, Ushar and Zakat are mandatory on property. So private property is allowed. What do you say on this point???
A religion which gave the concepts of Jizzah ,Mal a Ganmit, Dhimmi, breaking the religious institutions of other religions, making women loondis and selling them in the market places is also encompassing socialism . It enriched my mentation and ideation.
I concede there is a vast difference between "Islamic fundamentalism" and socialism. Socialism will eliminate all discrimination, oppression and exploitation on the basis of cast, class, race, religion and gender.
Taimur Sir have said to you that all the evils of islam are not socialism while socialism may overlapping with few islamic orders in some areas which creates a confusion that socialism is actually islam.
Unfortunately, sir taimur's vlog create a simulation of socialism on islam which is not the case
@@ijazawan7865 Socialism gives rights to others because others are also human beings. Where as Islam maintains that idolaters are pigs, monkeys, dogs, bastards and Nashjit. Every Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, and Jain is an idolater.
How can you entertain socialism in the light of Islam is beyond my comprehension.
Tell napak bhooj that go to baraks not fields
Sir it would have been better if the basis of Hazrat Omar RA decision and his debate on the subject with Hazrat Ali RA was touched upon. It might have supported your conclusion more rationally especially in Pakistan's context i.e. being a conquered land.
Sir please make a video on the Indian elections and Pakistani elections and also about the ways that can make elections free and fair
Make 2 separate videos. But don't do comparative study. Pakistani political parties those are in power are not a political parties. It is only mistresses of establishment. Journalist are worst than politicians. Journalist are just like prostitute.
@@mahalam2391 Nothing wrong with prostitutes. Please don't compare them to politicians.
@@chaivalla with all due respect I agree with you. I don't mean to demean prostitute.
Sir can you pls recommend books on understanding the history of pakistan and the subcontinent
First
1. .Bartanvi samraaj na hamain kese loota by ( Hussain Ahmad madni r.a)
2 .Tehreek e pakistan ka pas manzar by ( Hussain Ahmad madni)
3. taqseem e hindh or ulamay hindh ka siyasi moqaf by (syed Abul Alhassan nidvi)
@@RizwanJalal-sh9dj These are terrible books and mostly historically inaccurate.
- The Loss of Hindustan - The Invention of India by Manan Ahmed Asif.
- A Book of Conquest - The Chachnama and Muslim Origins in South Asia by Manan Ahmed Asif.
- India: A History by John Keay.
- Jinnah of Pakistan by Stanley Wolpert
- Shameful Flight: The Last Years of British Empire in India by Stanley Wolpert.
- Pakistan or the Partition of India by Dr B. R. Ambedkar
- The Great Partition - The Making of India and Pakistan by Yasmin Khan
- Self and sovereignty individual and community in South Asian Islam since 1850 by Ayesha Jalal
- The Struggle for Pakistan by Ayesha Jalal
- The sole spokesman by Ayesha Jalal
ma inko zaati taur pa read kar chuka hn balka inpa kafi saray professors sa bhi behas bhi kar chuka hn
apna inko study kiya ha?
But sir socialism under democracy is a controversy in itself...
Sir,@tamur_Laal, but there are some famous Ismalic scholars such as Javed ghamdi who always says that Capitalism is based on human nature and communism is against human nature!
So sir what is your views regarding such statement and it will be more good if you make a video over this point of view of Ulmah.
This is the link to the video where Gamdhi shares his views about both systems. ua-cam.com/video/Q95XgqP8Wqc/v-deo.htmlsi=YuvUJtc5muXmYb5b
Jar motivator UA-cam p trh trh k platforms ko explain krta.. Ye kr lo ye hjayega.. Akhir ap log kb hamain recent technological advancement ka knca business sahi h ya nh... Wo business like amazon Spotify alibaba.. And many more kon kahan fraud kr ra
. Undue profit lra.. Kahan capitalism ki shakal hai is jaded inventions mein... We have no. Idea
❤
Sir ji kisi ne bola k videos Choti bnao ya Analytics dekh liye. ..?
Just thought I'd give this new format a try. What do you think?
❤❤❤❤❤
your stance looks truthful, but face expressions don't show due concern sir. I regard you a responsible personality in the journey of inqilab, please consider my humble request.
Unlock the Truth: Discover Authentic Quran Translation in English 📖✨
Looking for answers? Dive into the sacred teachings of Islam with our channel's authentic English translation of the Quran. Each video offers profound insights and reflections on the timeless wisdom found in the Quranic verses. If you're seeking clarity and understanding, our channel is here to guide you on your spiritual journey. Visit us today and embark on a path of enlightenment and discovery. Let the truth illuminate your life. 🕊💫 #QuranTranslation #DiscoverIslam
❤🇧🇩
Tu es ka matlb ye hai.. k ab JB Pakistan ne itna sab taxes hm sb pe Laga deye hai.. ab ju hamare Apne thure zameene reh gae us pe be government mulkiyat le aye.. ta k government ye b le k Hume sarkoo pe le aye or ju thura kch reh gya hai wo b government le le😂😂😂😂
آپ آجکل دین میں جو دلچسپی لے رہے ہیں، یہ مبارک امر ہے۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو عربی زبان اور قرآن فہمی کا ذوق بھی بدرجۂ اتم نصیب فرمائے کہ اس کے بغیر اسلام کو سمجھا ہی نہیں جا سکتا کہ یہ قرآن ہی اسلام کی بنیادی کتاب ہے اور یھدی للتی ھی اقوم۔۔۔ ھدایت دیتا ہے اس راہ کی جو سب سے زیادہ سیدھی ہے۔۔۔۔ سر بات یہ ہے کہ آپ مجھے تاریخ و روایات و خرافات سے نہیں بلکہ صرف قرآن سے ذاتی و نجی ملکیت کا ثبوت فراہم کریں۔۔۔ قرآن میں دو آیات ایسی ہیں جو ذاتی و نجی ملکیت کی اصولی طور پر جڑ کاٹ دیتی ہیں: مَا لَـكُمۡ اَلَّا تُنۡفِقُوۡا فِىۡ سَبِيۡلِ اللّٰهِ وَلِلّٰهِ مِيۡـرَاثُ السَّمٰوٰتِ وَ الۡاَرۡضِؕ (57:10) کیا ہے تمہیں (کیا جواز ہے تمہارے پاس) کہ تم نہ دے ڈالو اپنا مال راہِ خدا میں جبکہ زمین و آسمان کی تمام میراث اللہ ہی کی (ملکیت) ہے ۔لِلّٰهِ مَا فِى السَّمٰوٰتِ وَالۡاَرۡضِؕ اِنَّ اللّٰهَ هُوَ الۡغَنِىُّ الۡحَمِيۡدُ
(31:26)
ملکیت ہے اللہ ہی کی جو بھی کچھ آسمانوں میں ہے یا زمین میں ہے۔ بے شک اللہ ہی مالدار ہے لائقِ ستائش و تحسین
(خیر اندیش ڈاکٹر ضیاءاللہ)
ویسے اس موضوع پر ایک جامع و مفصل کتاب نظامِ ربوبیت ہی ہے جو علامہ پرویز صاحب کی شاہکار تصنیف ہے۔
To phir quran mn qanoon e wiraasat kyun bayaan Kia gya hai. Private property Ka saboot qanoon e wiraasat ke ayaat hain
بقول آپ کے۔۔۔۔
1 اگر وہی سب ٹھیک ہے جو حضرت عمر نے کیا تھا تو پھر آپ سوشلزم کی طرف دعوت کیوں دیتے ہیں؟
2 اگر حضرت عمر کے طریقہ کار میں کچھ غلطیاں تھی جو سوشلزم میں نہیں تو آپ نے سوشلزم اور اسلام ازم میں تقابل کیوں نہیں کیا؟
آپ کے اس ویو سے تو ایسا محسوس ہوتا ہے کہ جیسے آپ اسلام ازم اور سوشلزم کو ایک ہی چیز یا قریب قریب سمجھتے ہیں۔
شکریہ
You are true
Sir tamur islamic logon sy viewership lanay k lia shayad aisa KR rhay hn halanky sir tamur ny yh accept Kia hai k islamic fundamentalism aur socialism mn vast difference ha
Sir apse ek sawal hai alfarbi ka nazriya muhje socialism or communism ki trah dekhta hai. Mere koi teacher sir please Bata dain muhje
❤
❤