Im Bazuno yousafzai from swat. Studing in BS English 1st semester. I have been watching ur videos since i was in 11 Grade. Your videos changed my whole thinking perception conception about religion and politics. Thank you so much Sir i really love u sir. If u ever come to swat please gave me a chance to host you❤❤❤
بہت ہی بہترین طریقے سے اور بہت ہی کم الفاظ میں اسلام کی اتنی وسیع تاریخ کو تیمور رحمان صاحب نے رکھا ہے یہ بےمثال ہے تیمور صاحب تاریخ کا بیحد اہم کام کر رہے ہیں۔ انکے اس کام کو جتنا زیادہ سے زیادہ لوگوں تک پہنچا یا جائے یہ ہم سب کا فرض بنتا ہے۔ Musharraf ali india
Fantastic breakdown of the ideologies, their roots and the counter arguments of that time of history, Every part of which needs to be understood and internalised by all Muslims. It’s extremely powerful and uplifting to know how the ideas of duality and trinitarianism were confronted at the time by the rational minded mutazilites. Intellect is our only instrument by which we can decipher between real and unreal. If this instrument is not used, then you get a belief which is purely that, just a personal belief, which cannot be challenged intellectually. Then, you’re free to believe in anything you like. The beauty of rational mind is that it gives you comprehendable and digestible answers, even to the question that may not be entirely within the realm of our limited intellect.
لَّا تُدْرِكُهُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرُ وَهُوَ يُدْرِكُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرَ ۖ وَهُوَ ٱللَّطِيفُ ٱلْخَبِيرُ No vision can encompass Him, but He encompasses all vision. For He is the Most Subtle, All-Aware.1
Thank you brother for this great introduction to the concept of Tauhid based on the Mu'tazili doctrines. We shall surely hear further from you about how the Mu'tazilis lost to Ashari and Ibn Hanbal's attack on them. They and subsequently Ibn Tammiyah and Abdul Wahhab changed this concept to one which basically anthropomorphic. This has been imposed on the Sunni Ummah by the Saudis. We Muslims are in a state of Jahilyah now.
👍👍👍 Just another fantastic lecture, full of logic and rationality. *"He lives not in a House, but there is no any house where He does not live"* He is Omnipresent 2:115, 57:4, 58:7, 50:16. No leaf falls but He knows it 6:59 وَمَا تَسْقُطُ مِن وَرَقَةٍ إِلَّا يَعْلَمُهَا
,, السلام علیکم و رحمت اللہ ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت سہل اور بہت وضاحت کے ساتھ آپنے نہایت پیچیدہ تاریخ کی وضاحت کی ہے۔ پہلی چار قسطوں کے بغیر یہ مسئلہ سمجھ میں نہیں آ سکتا تھا۔ کئی بار میں نے اس ابہام کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کی لیکن افسوس کہ روایتی اساتذہ نے اسکو فتویٰ کفر و تکفیر سے بوجھل بنا دیا تھا۔ آپنے معروضیت کے ساتھ اسکو تاریخ کے سیاہ و سباق کے ساتھ بیان کردیا ہے۔ شکریہ۔
it is really really a great work and historical and philosophic perspective to better understand the crux of slam. Unfortunately to day it is a missing link due to forced abandonment of argument by the Mullah of the time.
اتنا کہنا چاہوں گا آپ کا شکریہ میں آپ سے پہلے امام شہرستانی کی کتاب کتاب ملل و نحل پرھ رہا تھا وہ میرے اوپر سے گزر رہی تھی پر آپ نے بہت سی الجھنیں دور کر دیں خدا آپ کو سلامت رکھے۔۔
Taimor sb ap nay kamal kar diya hai... I think ye serious ya ye topic py kabhi kisi nay proper bat nai ki thi...or yahi topic Islam ki philosophy ko sai trha samjhne k liye boht zarrori tha jis ko ap nay boht achy tareeqay say study kiya or hum tak phncha rhy hain... I salute you for your research work
You're doing excellent job, I've read about these school of thoughts in different classical works but It was really hard to understand being honest. You have made it easy for the current generation to learn. Looking for more Healthy discussions. Keep the good work up🎉
As Quran says..... Ayatul Kursi..... Allah is Nur of heavens and earth.....so Allah is not limited... He is above and within every thing...everything is within Allah and Allah is everything ( from esoteric perspective)
I don't think that everything is within God because if it is, then everything constitutes the God (i.e. everything is part of God)- that is against the mu'tazili rule.
@@hussainmeghani8785 esoteric and sufi perspectives constitute the concept of wahdat ul wujud & wahdat al shahood, which is also somewhat but not entirely similar to hindu and Christian concepts of God.
Wonderful sir it is ok that you are explaining Motazillah philosophy but I am more interested in history of Motazillah that when it actually orignated or started although you have given history of pre motazillah period it will be more good if you also give history of motazillah how it affected society when it reached at peak and how it diminish and by the way how such strong philosophy diminishes
Kindly make more videos about rise & fall of Ummyad and Abbasid dynasties. What were economic, social & political conditions during their rule? It will help us understand contemporary problems of Muslim world with historical background in mind.
Bilkul sahi kiya. Ab hum ko phir ullama sey philosophy padne ka mauka Mila hai. Mautazila ideology kitni dangerous hai aur ya philosophy kitne gayi guzri hai ya jinab wohi gayi guzri philosophy padane baeitha hai. Tere is kaam sey Islam ko hi fayda hai.
@@gentleman7270 I don't mean "depiction" in the literal sense of the word. I'm using the word in the sense of description. Islam doesn't describe God accurately.
🔥🔥Be khatar kud para aatish-e-Namrood mein ishq Aql hai mehv-e-tamasha-e-lab-e- baam abhi" ". Love jumped into the fire of Nimrod without hesitation Intellect is still absorbed in watching the spectacle from the edge of the terrace"
This only happens in dreams and stories. Why don't miracles happen anymore after the invention of cameras ? Feelings and emotions are important, but we must always use reason when we decide to judge between right and wrong, true and false.
@@sirius3333plz go through the context And And To know what Ishq is u have to know the full history.....of what happened to Ibrahim a.s. It's in Quran jisme koi Shak nhi Tum log isko galat smjte ho toh apna ilag krwao Baqi Hrr jagah reason b kaam ni aata
I really appreciate yours effort, I understand not easy to find out the truth about Muslim Rationalist. I recommend you please write a book about yours research.
Now I am confused. It seems that Mu'tazili's aim for rational thought, but then they cross the boundaries of logic and reality and begin to speculate about God. I am referring to the timestamp 11:30 - 24:00.
Dear Sir - I truly appreciate this phenomenal effort and the intent. But as o had commented before - can you please agree that your assessment is based off of English translations by non- Muslim orientalists in general. This distinction and clarification is essential and ensures intellectual honesty. I have seen how incredibly different a subject can be when approached by a discerning Muslim vs non Muslim
Wonderful, your presentation is awesome, but I think you missed the major reason of motazila school of thought is not debates in Muslims, infact they borrowed it from Eastern orthodox Christianity, and ancient Greek philosophy.
Ikhtlaf hai mujhy mulaqat ho gi tu baaat ho gi kabhi kuch sawalt hain Jo zeyahn ubhary hain Note kar Lia ha main ny in sawalat k jawabat kahain or sy bhi mil sakty hain ya kitabon sy bhi hain lakin main Zaror apsy hi pochon ga
While listening to this series, I still can't reach any decision. Can you discuss Mutzali's versus Imam Ahmed bin Hambal's matters? Regarding the concept of God's location, is He on the Arsh or everywhere? Is the Quran the creation of Allah, or is it eternal?
Im Bazuno yousafzai from swat. Studing in BS English 1st semester. I have been watching ur videos since i was in 11 Grade. Your videos changed my whole thinking perception conception about religion and politics. Thank you so much Sir i really love u sir. If u ever come to swat please gave me a chance to host you❤❤❤
آپکی باتیں اسلئے بھی زیادہ کشش پیدا کرتی ہیں کیونکی آپ بات سمجھاتے وقت سننے والے سے کہیں زیادہ خود enjoy کرتے ہیں //
آپکو سننا ایک نعمت ہی
بہت ہی بہترین طریقے سے اور بہت ہی کم الفاظ میں اسلام کی اتنی وسیع تاریخ کو تیمور رحمان صاحب نے رکھا ہے یہ بےمثال ہے تیمور صاحب تاریخ کا بیحد اہم کام کر رہے ہیں۔ انکے اس کام کو جتنا زیادہ سے زیادہ لوگوں تک پہنچا یا جائے یہ ہم سب کا فرض بنتا ہے۔ Musharraf ali india
نگاہ بلند، سخن دلنواز، جاں پر سوز / یہی ھے رخت سفر میر کارواں کے لیے (اقبال)
Fantastic breakdown of the ideologies, their roots and the counter arguments of that time of history, Every part of which needs to be understood and internalised by all Muslims.
It’s extremely powerful and uplifting to know how the ideas of duality and trinitarianism were confronted at the time by the rational minded mutazilites.
Intellect is our only instrument by which we can decipher between real and unreal. If this instrument is not used, then you get a belief which is purely that, just a personal belief, which cannot be challenged intellectually. Then, you’re free to believe in anything you like. The beauty of rational mind is that it gives you comprehendable and digestible answers, even to the question that may not be entirely within the realm of our limited intellect.
❤🇧🇩
স্যার আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ। আপনার পরিশ্রম স্বার্থক হোক।
❤❤❤🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Brilliant professor a big fan of how simplify complex topics.
It is a privilege to listen to you, sir.
لَّا تُدْرِكُهُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرُ وَهُوَ يُدْرِكُ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرَ ۖ وَهُوَ ٱللَّطِيفُ ٱلْخَبِيرُ
No vision can encompass Him, but He encompasses all vision. For He is the Most Subtle, All-Aware.1
جزاک اللہ ڈاکٹر صاحب کافی کچھ واضح ھوا کم ازکم علم کس طرح اخذ کیا جاتا ھے آپکا لیکچر اس کی بہترین مثال ھے آپ کی تحقیق اور انداز لاجواب ھے
Thank you brother for this great introduction to the concept of Tauhid based on the Mu'tazili doctrines. We shall surely hear further from you about how the Mu'tazilis lost to Ashari and Ibn Hanbal's attack on them. They and subsequently Ibn Tammiyah and Abdul Wahhab changed this concept to one which basically anthropomorphic. This has been imposed on the Sunni Ummah by the Saudis. We Muslims are in a state of Jahilyah now.
حضرت علی کا قول ہے ”جس شخص نے مجھے ایک لفظ سکھایا میں اس کا غلام ہوں
آپ تو میرے بھی غلام ہوئے۔
@Truthbeliever34446 اس سے کیا فرق پڑتا ہے؟
Thank you so much Sir for providing us with this precious knowledge
👍👍👍 Just another fantastic lecture, full of logic and rationality.
*"He lives not in a House, but there is no any house where He does not live"*
He is Omnipresent 2:115, 57:4, 58:7, 50:16. No leaf falls but He knows it 6:59
وَمَا تَسْقُطُ مِن وَرَقَةٍ إِلَّا يَعْلَمُهَا
Can not wait
Taimur: Super on your part. Educational and informative your lectures are.
One of the best series
شاباش شاباش پروفیسر ۔۔۔
,, السلام علیکم و رحمت اللہ
ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت سہل اور بہت وضاحت کے ساتھ آپنے نہایت پیچیدہ تاریخ کی وضاحت کی ہے۔ پہلی چار قسطوں کے بغیر یہ مسئلہ سمجھ میں نہیں آ سکتا تھا۔ کئی بار میں نے اس ابہام کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کی لیکن افسوس کہ روایتی اساتذہ نے اسکو فتویٰ کفر و تکفیر سے بوجھل بنا دیا تھا۔ آپنے معروضیت کے ساتھ اسکو تاریخ کے سیاہ و سباق کے ساتھ بیان کردیا ہے۔ شکریہ۔
بہت خوب ڈاکٹر تیمور، سلامت رہیں
It is a treat to listen to your vlogs/lectures. Truly appreciate the research.
Oye hoye sir g Maza agaya agli video ka intezar rahay ga.Allah pak apko sehat or lambi Umar atta karay
"Understanding Allah SWT's attributes and qualities leads to a sense of inability or distress. This is the essence of understanding."
it is really really a great work and historical and philosophic perspective to better understand the crux of slam. Unfortunately to day it is a missing link due to forced abandonment of argument by the Mullah of the time.
سر اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو اس کا اجر عطا فرمائے آپ نے ماشاءاللہ بہت محنت سے لیکچر تیار کیا ھے ویلڈ ن سر آپ کے لئے دعا گو
تیمور صاحب اس سے زیادہ الفاظ نہیں ہیں میرے پاس جو کہہ سکوں کہ آپ کی کوشش بہت خوب لاجواب،
Beautifully explained. Maestro
Amazing series, this series will be used as reference for long long time.
مختصر مگر معلوماتی ۔بہترین
اللّه بے نیاز ھے کائنات کی ہر ایک چیز سے ۔ اللہ شروع سے ھے اور ہمیشہ رہے گا ۔
Excellent description.
They were more ahead of today Muslim.
Waiting for next episode Sir.
Allah apko khush rakhy❤
بہت خوب ⭐ استاد محترم ❤
Great way to explain
Thanks for this video. It would be nice if u could please do a video on Asharis and Maturadis.. and how these philosophies relate to Mutazili.
Good, and as per the teachings of Dr. Iqbal, mankind also has the capicity to be eternal by building the conection or relationship with God.
Thanks Dr Sahib. Lots of effort as usual to teach us . Really appreciated
good work
Top level ❤
Nice approach for comprehension of subject matter.
اتنا کہنا چاہوں گا آپ کا شکریہ میں آپ سے پہلے امام شہرستانی کی کتاب کتاب ملل و نحل پرھ رہا تھا وہ میرے اوپر سے گزر رہی تھی پر آپ نے بہت سی الجھنیں دور کر دیں خدا آپ کو سلامت رکھے۔۔
Taimor sb ap nay kamal kar diya hai... I think ye serious ya ye topic py kabhi kisi nay proper bat nai ki thi...or yahi topic Islam ki philosophy ko sai trha samjhne k liye boht zarrori tha jis ko ap nay boht achy tareeqay say study kiya or hum tak phncha rhy hain... I salute you for your research work
Taimur sahib, MashaAllah, great videos and work that you are doing
Looking forward to the next video.
استاد جی بہت خوب
Amazing 😮😮😮
OMG
What An Explanation Of Oneness Of God -Allah
Much Appreciated For Putting Together The Different Views
Great Effort
Keep It Up
Sir apka bohat shukria apka ya kam ya mannat humara lia kinni ahmiat rakhti haa
You're doing excellent job, I've read about these school of thoughts in different classical works but It was really hard to understand being honest. You have made it easy for the current generation to learn. Looking for more Healthy discussions. Keep the good work up🎉
Nutshell of deen is very simple but all these debates and books and conspiracy for survival of religion and false rituals
As Quran says..... Ayatul Kursi..... Allah is Nur of heavens and earth.....so Allah is not limited... He is above and within every thing...everything is within Allah and Allah is everything ( from esoteric perspective)
I don't think that everything is within God because if it is, then everything constitutes the God (i.e. everything is part of God)- that is against the mu'tazili rule.
@@saeedahmed5547 you are articulate in literal meaning but my point is from esoteric or Sufi perspective
@@hussainmeghani8785 esoteric and sufi perspectives constitute the concept of wahdat ul wujud & wahdat al shahood, which is also somewhat but not entirely similar to hindu and Christian concepts of God.
no doubt about the work you put in in slides and presentation. hats off.❤
Taimur Sir your lectures are such a blessing in understanding complicated concepts
Thanks for such a critical perspective on the matter
❤So beautifully explained, please make a video on Ibni Arabi's time and cosmology ❤
بقول عالب
کچھ نہ تھا تو خدا تھا، کچھ نہ ہوتا تو خدا ہوتا
ڈبویا مجھ کو ہونے نے نہ ہوتا میں تو کیا ہوتا
such a thought is an essential requirement for renaissance of Muslim world to regain the lost glory........
Sir a great respect to you for doing such a great work for us
you are a very good teacher. I am hooked.
Wonderful sir it is ok that you are explaining Motazillah philosophy but I am more interested in history of Motazillah that when it actually orignated or started although you have given history of pre motazillah period it will be more good if you also give history of motazillah how it affected society when it reached at peak and how it diminish and by the way how such strong philosophy diminishes
Allah ko aankh sey nhi dil sey dekha ja sakta hai.... it means dil ki bhi aamkhain hoti hain.... ab woh dhondna hamara kaam hai.
Kindly make more videos about rise & fall of Ummyad and Abbasid dynasties. What were economic, social & political conditions during their rule? It will help us understand contemporary problems of Muslim world with historical background in mind.
You are really a great teacher. Love you sir
Bilkul sahi kiya. Ab hum ko phir ullama sey philosophy padne ka mauka Mila hai. Mautazila ideology kitni dangerous hai aur ya philosophy kitne gayi guzri hai ya jinab wohi gayi guzri philosophy padane baeitha hai.
Tere is kaam sey Islam ko hi fayda hai.
Thanks brother May Allah blessings upon yourself and family 💐
ہاتھ ہے اللّٰہ کا بندہ ٔ مومن کا ہاتھ
علامہ اقبال
Love you Taimur great discussion.
Brilliant Sir. How the idea of Tawheed in Mutizalites differs from the idea of Tawheed in Sufism. Please throw some light in future videos. Thank you.
Needs a full lecture.
Dear taimur SB check fasoos ul hikam of ibne Arabi @@Taimur_Laal
تمہید ہی بنیاد اور اساس ہے ، جس نے تمہید سمجھا اس نے ساری بات سمجھنے میں معاونت کرتی ہیں، بے حد شکریہ کت مستحق
God is transcendental! Hai, and Qauum.
I envy your eloquence, and appreciate your commitment
a real teacher....mushid
We can't encampase him but he encompasses every thing.
If God does exist, he is unlike any figure depicted in the world religions, including Islam.
@@sirius3333how it's depicted in Islam?
@@gentleman7270 I don't mean "depiction" in the literal sense of the word. I'm using the word in the sense of description. Islam doesn't describe God accurately.
@@sirius3333 Yes it does define God accurately, You should gain more knowledge to understand, are you a Muslim or non Muslim?
🔥🔥Be khatar kud para aatish-e-Namrood mein ishq Aql hai mehv-e-tamasha-e-lab-e- baam abhi" ".
Love jumped into the fire of Nimrod without hesitation
Intellect is still absorbed in watching the spectacle from the edge of the terrace"
This only happens in dreams and stories. Why don't miracles happen anymore after the invention of cameras ? Feelings and emotions are important, but we must always use reason when we decide to judge between right and wrong, true and false.
@@sirius3333plz go through the context
And And To know what Ishq is u have to know the full history.....of what happened to Ibrahim a.s.
It's in Quran jisme koi Shak nhi
Tum log isko galat smjte ho toh apna ilag krwao
Baqi Hrr jagah reason b kaam ni aata
Super! Salute to you! Extraordinary efforts are used to develop these lectures. Educational and free of cost! ❤❤😊😊😊
Ubermench ! your thnk for that quality content
Taimur: Boy! Long Live!💥💥✨✨🌟🌟
I think you enjoyed much more than me to narrating the phenomena of God
Energy❤
Sir great
I really appreciate yours effort, I understand not easy to find out the truth about Muslim Rationalist. I recommend you please write a book about yours research.
maza aya
Janab Allah aapko salamat rakhe..Aaj college chhootne ka sadma jata raha.is waqt mein 73 par hoon
باتیں تو مناسب بلکہ صحیح تھیں متزلہ کی
معتزلہ۔۔۔۔
Love you Taimoor bhai you are amazing
excellent video
Now I am confused. It seems that Mu'tazili's aim for rational thought, but then they cross the boundaries of logic and reality and begin to speculate about God. I am referring to the timestamp 11:30 - 24:00.
Dr Sb, it would be great help for kids growing up in western countries if these lectures can have english subtitles .
Finally 😁
وا جی وا۔
You are just fantastic
As we believe in Allah, inshallah HE will reward you for educating us, thank you
سر آپ کو ابن رشد کو بھی پڑھنا چاہے..
Dear Sir - I truly appreciate this phenomenal effort and the intent. But as o had commented before - can you please agree that your assessment is based off of English translations by non- Muslim orientalists in general. This distinction and clarification is essential and ensures intellectual honesty. I have seen how incredibly different a subject can be when approached by a discerning Muslim vs non Muslim
Wonderful, your presentation is awesome, but I think you missed the major reason of motazila school of thought is not debates in Muslims, infact they borrowed it from Eastern orthodox Christianity, and ancient Greek philosophy.
Great
A historical knowledge to understand muslim humans nature and how developed soceity since then to till date
آپ مکانوں خالی، اس تھیں کوئی مکان نہ خالی
ہر ویلے ہر چیز محمد رکھدا نت سنبھالی
Sir ap may Serseh ko twitter per q block kia jab os nay ap say questions pochay?? May Chahta ho k ap os live confront karay
Ikhtlaf hai mujhy mulaqat ho gi tu baaat ho gi kabhi kuch sawalt hain Jo zeyahn ubhary hain
Note kar Lia ha main ny in sawalat k jawabat kahain or sy bhi mil sakty hain ya kitabon sy bhi hain lakin main Zaror apsy hi pochon ga
یعنی اللہ کو ایسا غیبی بنادیا کہ انسان کا عمل دغل ایک حاکم جیسا بنادیا جو اقتدار و مال و دولت کو جواز بنا کر اللہ کے احکمات کا سپہ سالار بن جاۓ
Naib/khalifa
Sir please make a video on problem of evil and also give it's rebuttal. Thank you ❤
While listening to this series, I still can't reach any decision. Can you discuss Mutzali's versus Imam Ahmed bin Hambal's matters?
Regarding the concept of God's location, is He on the Arsh or everywhere?
Is the Quran the creation of Allah, or is it eternal?
Yes. All that is coming up. Then you can decide.
@@Taimur_Laal Thanks