EVANESCENCE - HELLO BEN MOODY REMIX

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
  • In celebration of "Fallen" turning 20 YEARS OLD, founding former member of Evanescence BEN MOODY reimagines songs from the album.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 170

  • @SashaGolubitskaya
    @SashaGolubitskaya Рік тому +20

    I don't know. I mean as a remix it's solid.
    But the fact this is such a personal song full of pain.
    It's like you touched something sacred that shouldn't have been touched.
    But, Ben, as talented musician as you are I really wish you make some new music. I'm sure it'll be great.
    And I really love evanescence all the way - from the very oldest songs created with David Hodges and you till now. You did a great job together and now Amy is doing great things herself with her music.
    So I just wish you did the same without looking back.

    • @tagflint906
      @tagflint906 Рік тому +1

      💯💯💯

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +8

      The oldest songs were by Amy and Ben. Ev was co-founded by Amy and Ben in 1995 as a duo. Amy and Ben put out two EPs a couple years after that which they made at their houses. David was a random impuIsive hire by Ben 5 years after Amy and Ben had made Ev music, and he was around for only two years. Ben, who hired him, said his exit was because he didn't fit Ev's music and tried to pull it in another direction (which was reported to be Christian music as David's is a devout formally religious Christian and worked within the Christian music scene). He was just one of a number of session/tour players Ben hired back then when Ev was the duo of Amy and Ben. A bunch of demos that they compiled and packaged in 2000 to show record labels when they were looking to get signed (which was labeled "Origin") were songs Amy and Ben had written years before, including Imaginary, My Immortal, Whisper, Even in Death, Where Will You Go.

    • @SashaGolubitskaya
      @SashaGolubitskaya Рік тому +2

      @@carpediemearth wow, you do know their history very well, thanks for sharing!

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +1

      @@SashaGolubitskaya No worries :)

    • @UriBlack
      @UriBlack Рік тому +4

      Go Listen to Chasing Yesterday - Ben Moody
      if you need a Fallen nostalgia that much. Ben and David write together for that song and use the same instruments as in Fallen

  • @martinslucimar
    @martinslucimar Рік тому +60

    What a shame touch this song. So personal. Wtf bro

    • @Gamerbay2017
      @Gamerbay2017 Рік тому +21

      This is seriously insensitive. And he honestly kinda ruined it anyway.

    • @eyhem2518
      @eyhem2518 Рік тому +9

      He never changed. This shows truth about their relationship. Amy was right about him. He's a sadic disturbed narcisistic person

    • @Devforde
      @Devforde Рік тому +2

      @@eyhem2518 Moody’s always been a sociopath. And a woman-beating sociopath too. He said and did so many awful things since the start. If he was well known or if Evanescence had started with him in today’s world,he would’ve been cancelled immediately.

    • @Gamerbay2017
      @Gamerbay2017 Рік тому +2

      @@William_Sorvete But Hello is a very personal song that isn't even played live, so he should have known better than to touch this song.

    • @mauev
      @mauev Рік тому +4

      Relax, fans

  • @hyperballadX
    @hyperballadX Рік тому +17

    Of all the remixes, this is the one that I liked the most. Adds another atmosphere yet it still feels it doesn't change the main "feeling" from the original song. And to the whiney so-called fans complaining about these remixes, grow the fuck up ! Why are you even here ?!

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому +1

      Some genres mesh with certain tracks better than others. If this were a blues/smooth jazz accompaniment I could maybe get behind it. Same with acoustic guitar, or even low fidelity hip-hop beats to mourn to...but...an electronic _dance_ mix? What, is he throwing a rave on this chick's grave? Why drop the beat on her corpse? I mean it's hilarious, but I doubt that was his intention...
      This is the type of creative decision I'd expect from a misguided fan; not the co-founder!

    • @jamie7340
      @jamie7340 Рік тому +2

      because they have a parasocial relationship with Ev and feel a tabloid-like responsibility to follow Ben and bully him wherever he goes

    • @hyperballadX
      @hyperballadX Рік тому +3

      @@jamie7340 That's exactly what I thought. Or they don't have anything interesting in their lives so they waste their time and energy here.

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому

      @@jamie7340 You keep saying this word.
      You know it can apply to you just as much as anyone else, right?

    • @jamie7340
      @jamie7340 Рік тому

      ​@@wisemage0 it's possible to be obsessed with a band without feeling an obsessive personal connection to its members :') my comment also wasn't really targeting you, the top comments on this video were an absolute dumpster fire a few weeks ago

  • @BEEFSERPENT
    @BEEFSERPENT Рік тому +6

    rip bonnie lee

  • @8luezid
    @8luezid Рік тому +7

    Cool, I would love less dubstep, but the breaking of Amy's voice is quite poetic. I know everybody loves the feelings of the original song but this is so interesting, not commercial but cool

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +2

      All these remixes are solely commercial, a rip off of Skrillex by someone who has no idea what he's doing in this genre, randomly throwing everything and the kitchen sink in GarageBand, thinking he's doing something, all to seek attention 😂

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому

      @@carpediemearth Stop, stop! he's already dead! 😫

    • @A-Miracle000
      @A-Miracle000 Рік тому +1

      @@carpediemearth so true, it isn't even stable or idk it's just bad doesn't fit

  • @Igormanoell
    @Igormanoell Рік тому +15

    People came under fire because he are remixing songs from the album he helped to make? Y’all are fucking crazy guys I promised y’all. He’s part of history and helped to produce the intere thing as much as amy lee did. He and Amy did magic together and for unknown reasons he has left the band. He’s trying to get his coins and survive like all of us. Y’all don’t understand the meaning of the songs. Let it go. The amy herself had already set the record strength by quote” I’m better without you”. Let this man alone

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +2

      Amy wrote this song on her piano about her trauma with her little sisters death, and never performed it because it's too painful for her. Just like Like You. Imagine thinking it's ok for him to remix this song just because he has a frauduIent co-credit on it, like many other songs on Fallen he did no writing on.

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому

      _"I hurt myself today..."_
      WUR WUR WUR WUR WAAAAH **drop it**
      Certified hood classic.

  • @Eternalluxx
    @Eternalluxx Рік тому +2

    Não achei muito legal esse nao :(

  • @_dftm1
    @_dftm1 Рік тому +20

    Ben, a remix of Haunted and Whisper is now needed to balance the universe 😅

    • @UriBlack
      @UriBlack Рік тому +1

      I think the next one is Everybody's fool

  • @Gamerbay2017
    @Gamerbay2017 Рік тому +31

    This is so insensitive. If you want to remix a song, why not do Whisper or Imaginary?

    • @cris42bp_
      @cris42bp_ Рік тому +5

      This is just as insensitive as Amy remaking my immortal for synthesis. Like I see your point but Amy did it first

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +5

      @@cris42bp_ In no way is that true. 😂 Fans of this woman-beatIng abuser and teen-fker stop being Iiars. My Immortal is a song about fiction, with fictional lyrics by Ben about a ghost haunting someone that he took from a fictional story. It is not a personal song about anything real. Amy composed the music on piano and later also added the bridge (including the bridge's lyrics). She didn't even like the song as she didn't connect with it, she just wrote the music for him. It was put on Fallen by the label cause the label saw it as an easy pop hit, and the label forced a demo version of the song from when she was a teen that she disliked further cause she hated how her teen voice sounds. She redid it years later in Synthesis because she disliked the teen demo version the label forced on the album and she wanted to do a vocally mature version.
      Hello is a highly personal song of Amy's that she wrote about her trauma with her little sister's death when she was a child, and she never performed it live becasue it was too painful. Ben fans have a spec of decency chaIIenge, but I know it's impossibIe for you Iying misogynlsts as you love manipuIative women-beatIng abusers and gasIighters like this Ioser Ben.

    • @cris42bp_
      @cris42bp_ Рік тому +3

      First of all, it is comparable as my immortal was written by Ben and hello by Amy. There’s also another version that says Ben wrote my immortal about his dead grandfather so… as none of them are confirmed, you can believe whatever you want.
      Moreover, my immortal has always made the cut to be on fallen, the label may have forced them to make it more mainstream and stuff but that’s all. Idek where you got that from. And she doesn’t like my immortal because it’s Ben’s, not because it’s too pop- ish.
      Actually the synthesis version is pretty much the same, the only difference is that there’s an orchestra playing and she got to re-record it as her voice has changed and got deeper, but there aren’t any mayor changes.
      I get what you said on the first place, he shouldn’t have remade hello, but in the end, Amy did it first so…

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +2

      @@cris42bp_ No there isn't. Stop lying. Exactly what I said is directly from their interviews. Ben and Amy both said in interviews that My Immortal's lyrics were fictional lyrics by Ben from a fictional story about a ghost haunting people. Ben never wrote about real stuff. All the other songs were written by Amy, about her real experiences and feelings of things in her own life and real life things in the real world she expressed something about. Including the abuse she suffered from Ben, yet he still did a remix of one those songs (Going Under). Apart from being an abuser, he has never given a rat's ass about all the dlsgusting things he's done and all the damage he's caused muItiple women, including Amy back then.
      2003 interview: ""The lyrics are totally fictional", according to Ben Moody. They evoke a spirit, but he insists the song has nothing to do with God or religion. Moody was still in high school when he wrote the lyric."
      Stop Iying. Amy literally said in muItiple interviews since the start of Ev the exact reasons she never liked My Immortal, despite Ben asking her to co-write it on piano and perform it: the lyrics are fictional and she doesn't relate to it, she doesn't like the song overall, she doesn't like her teen voice in it, and she doesn't like the demo version the label forced on the album (which is why she redid it with her mature voice for Synthesis). And the label's A&R literally said in an interview that they wanted My Immortal on it and saw it as a pop hit. Amy and Ben confirmed the label was deadset on the song since they first heard the demo and wanted it on the album despite them having more songs for the album. The label were worried from the start that originally, before they intervened, the album wasn't marketable at the time, especially led by a woman, and they saw MI as an easy pop hit they could at least get something out of. They also forced the rap rock on BMTL for the same reason (and Amy redid BMTL on Synthesis without the label-forced rap rock too). Ben fans stop being such sad pathoIogicaI Iiars.

    • @cris42bp_
      @cris42bp_ Рік тому

      Calm down, idk there’s no need to call names to someone on the internet that you don’t even know. I’m not misogynistic and I’m just talking about music, not people. I never talked about their past, you brought it up. And yeah okay i take back the Ben’s grandfather thing, I didn’t know about that interview. But It doesn’t change the fact that Amy rewrote all fallen (my immortal included) so imma forgive Ben for this one lmao. Eye for and eye. If you don’t like what Ben does, you’re free to block him. Just ignore him. He doesn’t care about your or anyones comments imo, like he has never answered so having this conversation is more harmful to you than it will ever be to him. I’m trying to be nice, really, if you don’t like him, just block him :)

  • @IsaacEvFan
    @IsaacEvFan Рік тому +12

    This is so disrespectful with Amy Lee and the death of her sister Bonnie. Thumbs down 👎🏻

  • @xthe0nly0nex
    @xthe0nly0nex Рік тому +2

    tf is ur problem 😭😭 this song is too personal man why would you ruin it

  • @guidocoluccia
    @guidocoluccia Рік тому +12

    this should be on synthesis

    • @faked_my_death
      @faked_my_death 8 місяців тому +3

      @guidocoluccia This is exactly what I've been saying. This remix would have fit perfectly on Synthesis

  • @wisemage0
    @wisemage0 Рік тому +7

    Deceased relatives bopping to EDM beats in the Afterlife Dance Club, I suppose.

  • @Anacarolina-cd1kq
    @Anacarolina-cd1kq Рік тому +4

    Muito ruim, desculpe

  • @geovannycastelobranco9364
    @geovannycastelobranco9364 11 місяців тому +7

    I usually find it hard to connect with remix of songs I love, but this is amazing!

  • @joyce4374
    @joyce4374 Рік тому +6

    I prefer the original version, it was not good.

  • @cristianequiteria773
    @cristianequiteria773 7 місяців тому +2

    All for this Ben? Disgusting!

  • @WestCountryGurl
    @WestCountryGurl Рік тому +12

    This remix is a mood.

    • @UriBlack
      @UriBlack Рік тому +4

      One could say it's MOODY 🤣🤣 This is just as good as the fan made one

  • @dragonboots2014
    @dragonboots2014 Рік тому +2

    No. Just No.

  • @prozac_tablets
    @prozac_tablets Рік тому +18

    3:28 and after is awesome. Consider making another we are the fallen album 🤘 thats what we really want ❤️

  • @paulycence
    @paulycence Рік тому +5

    Ben plz, your version of my inmortal🙏

  • @muhammadnissay6324
    @muhammadnissay6324 Рік тому +24

    One of my unfulfilled dreams is watching the true real Evanescence (Ben, Amy, David, Rocky, and John) live. This is literally impossible and it hurts. It really hurts :(

  • @victoriabicca5663
    @victoriabicca5663 Рік тому +6

    that’s so disrespectful 🤮

  • @mostafayassin3354
    @mostafayassin3354 3 місяці тому +5

    Ben Moody, you are Evanescence. And Evanescence is Ben Moody. This will never change. Evanescence is never meant to be no matter how much albums they released, we were there, we witnessed greatness. You came, you played, you conquered. It really one of the saddest stories of true art and music in the 21st century. Evanescence will always be a story of “What could have been”. But hey, we love you man !

  • @carpediemearth
    @carpediemearth 2 місяці тому +1

    To put it mildly, this is not even remotely good. Not even passable. None of the Skrillex-redux remixes of this album's songs are good. Get a job.

  • @jessicaabbott10
    @jessicaabbott10 Рік тому +8

    To everyone calling out Ben for being “insensitive”: Amy could easily be conspired just as insensitive for re-recording “My Immortal” for Synthesis; that was *Ben’s song* dedicated to his late grandpa. Amy should never have touched such a personal song of Ben’s, either.

    • @Ella_song
      @Ella_song Рік тому +2

      Sorry, did he pay you to say this peace of sh!t? This remix is awful is impossible saying its good! It’s just to pick on her or he is getting nuts, that’s why is disrespectful and insensitive. On Synthesis you can see how Amy had care and love with the song “My immortal”, don’t lie to yourself.

    • @Ella_song
      @Ella_song Рік тому

      Ben is really creative and amazing on songs, but this remix is not him, not the professional one. At least, Amy can be professional when we are talking about songs, she respect THE FANS!!!!

    • @carpediemearth
      @carpediemearth Рік тому +1

      😂 No it wasn't. Fans of the abuser Ben as always, without fail, Iying their butt's off and projecting. MI is a song about fiction, with fictional lyrics by Ben about a ghost haunting someone that he took from a fictional story. It is not a personal song about anything real. It has no relation to "Hello", and him messing with such a highly personal song of Amy's that she wrote about her trauma with her little sister's death and that she never performed live because it's too painful for her is just yet another shltty thing he's knowingly done, but you don't care about that given your comment. He also messed with Going Under, one of the songs Amy wrote about his abuse.

  • @SiirJoga
    @SiirJoga 3 місяці тому +2

    this is like Hello but in Synthesis...

  • @tafrionaotomobanho
    @tafrionaotomobanho Рік тому +6

    Brazil here always😂😅

  • @hakantoktas9147
    @hakantoktas9147 Рік тому +8

    Ben, this is AMAZİNG! Man!

  • @tafrionaotomobanho
    @tafrionaotomobanho Рік тому +10

    Thank you so much ben!

  • @adrianashe9364
    @adrianashe9364 Рік тому +7

    I love these remixes, Ben. I really hope you do Haunted

  • @STABATMATTERDOLOROSA
    @STABATMATTERDOLOROSA Рік тому +1

    OK BEN, ALL THE SONGS YOU HAVE RELEASED TO CELEBRATE "FALLEN" ARE GREAT, I GUESS THE ALBUM CHANGED THE LIVES OF ALL OF YOU AND US LISTENERS AT THE SAME TIME; BUT, IF "FALLEN" WAS YOUR PROJECT SO AMBITIOUS AND SUCCESSFUL WHY DID YOU LET IT GO? I FEEL THAT "WE ARE THE FALLEN" WAS AND HAD EVERYTHING TO BE A SUCCESS AND SUCCESS, BUT FINALLY IT HAS ALSO FALLEN, OR AT LEAST THAT'S WHAT THOSE OF US WHO EXPECT (EXPECTED) MORE MUSIC FROM YOU INTERPRET IT. DO YOU HAVE ANY PLAN TO "RAISE" THE FALLEN?

  • @tafrionaotomobanho
    @tafrionaotomobanho Рік тому +7

    Algum br?? Dá like!

  • @pam.camarax3
    @pam.camarax3 Рік тому +9

    Parabéns, nota Dó

  • @NixonCutz
    @NixonCutz Рік тому +4

    My friend! You've done it again! And that last third when it comes back more full than before ... So good!! 🔥🔥 Talk soon man

  • @Beegeezy144
    @Beegeezy144 Рік тому +8

    Awesome, Ben. God bless you, man. 🤘👍

  • @ronniebeumkes4099
    @ronniebeumkes4099 Рік тому +5

    Woww!! Thank you!!

  • @garrettley6353
    @garrettley6353 Рік тому +4

    I’m kind of glad this exists just because it made me listen to this song / the lyrics again. I also loved the beginning. The end was a bit much at times but I think he really showed restraint when necessary and captured the epicness of the original song towards the end. I could hear his intent

  • @ardier
    @ardier Рік тому +4

    This is a solid remix. Unless Amy herself comes out and says that this was uncalled for, I don’t have a problem with it.

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому

      She's probably not interested in keeping this dude's career on life support by beefing with him online.

  • @Viednamitavideos
    @Viednamitavideos Рік тому

    😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

  • @Laureya
    @Laureya Рік тому +4

    ❤❤❤

  • @frequency9666
    @frequency9666 Рік тому +5

    I like, like it! 🤘😬

  • @oartursemh
    @oartursemh Рік тому +4

    Desrespeitoso! Achei baixo.

  • @DiegoCoutinhoGameplays
    @DiegoCoutinhoGameplays Рік тому +2

    Disrespectful. It would be better not touch this one.

  • @jerrycowan5905
    @jerrycowan5905 Рік тому +2

    You did a good job but bro you shouldnt have touched this song

  • @jacquelinedelimaruas
    @jacquelinedelimaruas Рік тому +6

    Amazing. I love you Ben ❤

  • @bastiansalvadorbotello4711
    @bastiansalvadorbotello4711 Рік тому +2

    Awful beat, bad remix, truly disrespectful

  • @rubengutierrez2462
    @rubengutierrez2462 Рік тому +7

    Thank you Ben, this is beautiful 😢❤

  • @evanescence_lover
    @evanescence_lover Рік тому +2

    No. Why did you do that? It's horrible...

  • @deinesehnsucht
    @deinesehnsucht Рік тому +2

    🖤🖤🖤

  • @kademalp9261
    @kademalp9261 Рік тому +2

    amazng !!!!

  • @ЦветанЧовалски
    @ЦветанЧовалски Рік тому +3

    Beautifully done ❤

  • @juanrodriguez-ux4ee
    @juanrodriguez-ux4ee Рік тому +3

    Es demasaido hermosa ♥

  • @_lacrym0sa_
    @_lacrym0sa_ Рік тому +5

    Amaría esto en Spotify

  • @Ella_song
    @Ella_song Рік тому +2

    Really bad, sorry! It supposed to be to the fans or just to pick on someone?This is awful man, you can be better than it, you were creative, what happened? 😦💔

  • @gabrielaortega1823
    @gabrielaortega1823 Рік тому +4

    Me encantaría ver a Evanescence con Ben, David, Amy, John y Rocky.

  • @nickjackson124
    @nickjackson124 Рік тому +3

    This one is much better than the last one. I liked it. Keep up the good work!

  • @SaraStogowska
    @SaraStogowska Рік тому +2

    Wow, I really like it!

  • @EvMusic94
    @EvMusic94 Рік тому +1

    Me encantan!!!gran trabajo musical y de producción me gustan tus reinterptretaciones pero es una lástima que dañes la voz de Amy así, pierde mucha calidad. estos remixes serían mas épicos con su voz limpia.

    • @glifbergs.1341
      @glifbergs.1341 7 місяців тому

      Tu sabes con quién estas hablando con el dueño del circo.. El q creo el grupo

  • @BEEFSERPENT
    @BEEFSERPENT Рік тому +3

    hopefully we'll get that damn halo method album and a new we are the fallen album this year or early next too

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому

      I seriously doubt Ben is even still in contact with Carly, or any of the other We Fell Off members for that matter.

  • @maryamalkuwari2911
    @maryamalkuwari2911 Рік тому +1

    Beautiful💙 Can You Please Upload This Songs In (Remix). (Request).
    In This Moment - The In Between
    My Last Breath x Going Under Evanescence Mashup (The Musical Midget)

  • @gabrielaortega1823
    @gabrielaortega1823 Рік тому +5

    Muchas gracias, me encanta como quedó 🎉

  • @Ashley-GritoHELPmesmo
    @Ashley-GritoHELPmesmo Рік тому +1

    ficou lindo ben, amei. Faça de whisper e my last breath tbm, pfvrrr

  • @edecris19
    @edecris19 Рік тому

    Supera, esquece o Evanescence e a Amy Lee hahaha. XD

  • @Kind_w0lf
    @Kind_w0lf Рік тому

    Is Ben Moody still alive?
    Did he release any new songs?

    • @KC89X
      @KC89X Рік тому +1

      I think hes alive?

    • @wisemage0
      @wisemage0 Рік тому +2

      He is still alive, but only on the outside.
      As far as I'm aware he hasn't released any original tracks since some pop album from about 10 years ago.

    • @Kind_w0lf
      @Kind_w0lf Рік тому

      @@wisemage0 thanx

  • @lavendrow4707
    @lavendrow4707 Рік тому +1

    maybe touching this song is really shameless, but god, this remix touched my heart to tears as much as the original song 😢

  • @UriBlack
    @UriBlack Рік тому +4

    This will be hard to beat but here was a Techo remix back in 2008. Thank you Ben 🔥

  • @wisemage0
    @wisemage0 Рік тому +2

    Beat dropped harder than her sister's casket.

  • @_lacrym0sa_
    @_lacrym0sa_ Рік тому

  • @aliates2259
    @aliates2259 Рік тому

    great job she will wake up soon we will be together again

  • @TheSilentknight1520
    @TheSilentknight1520 Рік тому +4

    One of your best remixes ben

  • @BEEFSERPENT
    @BEEFSERPENT Рік тому

    i'd be fine if going forward the rest of these covers were just instrumentals

  • @razen2002
    @razen2002 Рік тому +4

    You lost to Amy XDD This proves it.