Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Francisco Gil-White: This is What People Who Support Palestine Should Know.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 гру 2023
- Watch the full interview here - • Francisco Gil-White Sh...
In this episode of the Through Conversations podcast, we are joined by expert in the Israel-Palestine Conflict, Francisco Gil-White.
We delve into Francisco's life trajectory, uncovering a surprising connection between Nazism and The PLO (Palestine Liberation Organization). The episode also explores the reasons behind Fransisco's cancellation by UPenn and delves into the complex relationship between the United States and Israel, questioning whether it is an ally or an enemy.
We discuss the potential consequences if Israel were to fall and whether it serves as the last line of defense for democracy.
This episode aims to provide unique insights and perspectives on these very challenging and nuanced topic, making it a compelling listen for those interested in the geopolitics and history of the war.
// LINKS //
Website: throughconvers...
Newsletter: throughconvers...
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / thruconvpodcast
Instagram: www.instagram....
UA-cam: / @throughconversations
Thank you for watching this clip of the full interview with Francisco. Watch the full interview here - ua-cam.com/video/peXAqwS2yqc/v-deo.html
If you want to listen on the go, this episode is also available on Spotify - open.spotify.com/episode/5FVakRZVPbw7JBhyMkqd8T?si=G8YPa5XKT2OrEJPkoDLgnQ
Thank you.
Noam Chomsky would not agree with this dude at all, idk why I subbed to this garbage channel.
How do you publish these things? It's all bee esssss
@@michaelwareing3727FOAD, Nazi filth.
Had the good representative asked "does calling for the genocide of blacks violate your school's code of conduct?", would the woke university presidents still insist that the statement is context dependent?
Well put!
Exactly. That's exactly what I thought when I heard it.
I am totally for free speech, and to combat lies, with truth.
One can say they h8te so and so, but I am not sure Constitutionally, where the line for free speech regarding "genocide" begins, and ends.
Protest or opposition to Israel foreign and domestic policy is not a call for genocide of Jews.
Protest or opposition to US foreign policy with Israel is not a call for genocide of Jews.
Protest in support of Palestine sovereignty, autonomy, and freedom is not a call for genocide of Jews.
Protest in support of Palestinian people is not a call for genocide of Jews.
Protest against university financial ties to Israel is not a call for genocide of Jews.
These efforts to conflate Palestinian support with genocide of Jews, and then smear university officials as "anti-Semitic" is nothing but political theater and character assassination as leverage to suppress free-speech.
Meanwhile, there is real genocide being carried out in Gaza against the Palestinian people. It is openly called for in the US Congress, in Israeli media, and by Israeli officials.The authorities and supporters of Israel do not bat an eye at this open lust for blood and land and the annihilation of a people.
The hypocrisy here is rich.
The ability to gloss over it all with self-delusion is either super-human or sub-human. It is genocidal.
Why not just push this further and include more ethnic groups, like blacks, great idea. People that are on colonized land and for 200 years haven’t even got up and left! They even got a free ride over. These Americans lol. If you’re an immigrant you can stay for another 200 years. But it has to be legal. (In case anyone misunderstands, I’m kidding, making fun of all the hate on pages like this)
@@davidsnyder3799 ”from the river to the sea” is a call for genocide to the ears of any Jew. You wanna keep saying it, we’ll see how well supported Palestinians are in 2-4 months. Chances are since you are already a pariah and you’re going this globally, this will not end well for you. You’re just lucky the west is slow, but they’ll get what you’re doing. Especially with the help of many others
Hopefully one day this truth will prevail. Don't ever give up letting the world know. God is with you.
This is the first time I've heard someone say "There is no civilian infrastructure in Gaza" and I think that is absolutely correct. Thank you for saying that.
That was amazing. It's a military death cult disguised as civilian infrastructure. And unfortunately it works because the world is buying it.
The Collins dictionary defines 'civilian infrastructure' as "The infrastructure of a society, country or organisation consists of basic facilities such as transport, communications, power supplies, and buildings which enable it to function." Gaza had all of that - until Israel deliberately bombed it all away. The tunnels have nothing to do with it. Despite your long-standing occupation, daily oppression, your seiges, your control of their air, space & sea, their right to travel freely, they STILL managed to cope well and function DESPITE Israel's attempts to sabotage it's advancements, & now Israel is trying very hard to ensure there is no 'civillian structure' in a deliberate attempt to make it unlivable for Gazans. So no surprises there ...
@@j.w8680it's funny how people say that Israel "bombed it all away" as if it happened for absolutely no reason
@@olgag9901 Oh, so you admit that Israel DID in fact deliberateúùĥly destroy infrastructure, then?! At least you are being honest... and the 'defense' strategy is a bit jaded now after the attempts by them to clearly starve, dehydrate & deny medication for any Gazans & Palestinians & further denying them any dignity, right to self-determination and murderimg over 10,000 children. There is no earthly justification for all of that. For every bomb you drop you create more hate. Violence begets violence. If what Hamas did was wrong, you can't possibly, with a straight face, justify the killing of 20,000 mostly civilian people. Bombing Gaza into the Stone Age and abusing, torturing, harrassing & arbitrarily arresting other Palestinians & Arabs elsewhere in the West Bank & East Jerusalem does not help your cause. You can't oppress an entire ethnic group and yet expect them to bow their heads and say "Thank you, sir".
When Hamas invaded Israel would you have advocated just waving peace signs at them? I'm not advocating violence on either side, but Gazans do have a right under International law to defend themselves, as you would claim Israel does, except we both know that Israel has also committed grave war crimes with impunity. If you think that Hamas' attacks on civilians was wrong, then you should have no problem using that same moral code for Israel's 'war' also.
If you want peace, have talks & come to mutual agreements, not just a one-sided deal, which is what Israel often has offered in the past. It is not reasonable for one country to subjugate/oppress a whole other ethnic group. There has to be compromise on both sides, & if Israel wants to be recognised as a state they should accept that Palestinians have a right to define themselves, to have their own state, & to run their own affairs. We both know Israel will never accept this despite claiming they are the only 'democracy' in the Middle East. A country that oppresses another can never, itself, be free.
@@j.w8680 That is the prescribed definition. I think the point of that statement was that when a militarized group like Hamas purposefully uses that infrastructure to conduct war, military actions, then those things become targets.
I love Francisco Gil-White because all his arguments are with names, places, dates and evidence.
Francisco is a brilliant mind! I could listen to him for hours. Amazing and so easy to understand. He explains things so well. He is handsome too. ❤
u can listen him for hours. migh be helpful for your neurones
Thank you for explaining all this, in an honest way. I pray that your words of truth are heard, far and wide, to save everyone of us.
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
Exactly right. This is the true history. Thank you for sharing it. I hope it goes viral. Please offer it to the channels which accumulate and share such videos.
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
I agree with this and it reinforces my already held beliefs...thus it is correct.
Jfc.
Thank you Francisco! Just mind blowing! This video should be shown to everyone, as the level of worldwide ignorance is appalling
You believe his propaganda lol. Free advice: Don’t believe anything a Zionist says, the world does not.
How could anyone possibly know if the critical name of that Arab Leader was deleted from all newspapers, news clips, etc. 50+ years.
What's next? World chaos? More than what is already waiting for us without this knowledge? If I did not understand how complicated, tedious, challenging, and mind boggling psychoanalysis is I might have had difficulty believing this truth.😵😧
@colonel1239 As a Jew, this is common knowledge to me, though very well put and very nice to hear especially from someone that isn't Jewish. My question to you is, if the world really knew the Truth as stated here, would it change a single thing? People have chosen their side, or more correctly, who they side with! We Jews used to care so much what the rest of the world thought of us, but that has all changed recently, we are starting to see ourselves vs the rest of the world!
Part of liberal Jews continues supporting palestinian cause.
I want to believe this knowledge would change the mindset of someone in the world (at least).
Those who are not antisemitic in their core.
@@michaelsmullen9891
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
Love this man’s point of view and his intellectual capacity
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
He is very wrong in his view's
you love stupid, ok.
This dude is insane, cero facts in his claims.
@@marcocupul721Cope
What clear words! Very eye opening statements. Here out of the mouth of a representant of the spanish side of humanity. Very appreciated 😊
Yes. I very much appreciate this guy.
So good to see someone in another country besides U.S., Europe, and ME, researching, and studying these things, and speaking in public.
I would love to get the local lefty, pro-Palestinian, Spanish/English college radio station to get him on - HA!
🙂
I wonder of they have ever heard of him.
Yes! I thought all Spanish speaking people are die hard 'Pro Palestine' type. Encouraged to hear that there are who are not deceived by the lies of UN and media.
Too bad he’s a bit of a loon.
Armaments in schools, mosques, hospitals, UN buildings, there is not one place Hammas has not placed some form of military weapon..
And the three churches. Let us not forget
This guy is fantastic. We need him on more podcasts: The hill rising, Making Sense, Lex Friman, Piers Morgan..
Agree with every thing Francisco said. I do not resinate with my tribe any more, in fact I am tribeless and that's okay. I have never wanted to fit in with a group of people who claim they are morally superior because they appear to be supporting or even fighting for the underdogs. It's patronising to the Palestinian people, it's basically saying they can't support themselves, they have to fight, when they could choose peace, prosperity, and autonomy.
I know exactly how you feel. It can get lonely, but if you search out kindred spirits, that's a big help!
❤❤❤
Jews are morally superior as a whole compared to Christians and Muslims. The Jews have done more for western civilization than any other group of people. Laws from the Jews influenced the Romans over 2000 years ago and have influenced western civilization. Liberal democracy came from the Jews. Jews were chosen to bring monotheism to the world but people of all races and beliefs have a place in heaven. The culture of Jews is to take care of their families, to be educated, to contribute to the world. Most of the Nobel prizes have been awarded to Jews. Jews are 1 percent of the world’s population but have contributed more than any other group. Envy and Jealousy is behind hatred for jews
I wish they stand in their own power and get a life!
Both left, right and woke support the Zionist government from the very start. The Zionist are not interested in peace except peace in grabbing more land from the Palestinians.
Best quote: "There is no civilian infrastructure in Gaza."
Wow I've immediately subscribed. The truth matters so much in these days of lies and deceptions. Thank you so much. ❤❤❤
Islam is a political doctrine.Hatred is one of its weapons.
Exactly. It is Fascism with a religious aspect.
Deception and lusting are two others. No moral standards in Islam except 'use for Islam'.
@@heikejohannajahns3257that judism zionism you meant ?
@@manofwar2354 israel's independence declaration(by heart, not correct wording): we stretch our hand out to our neighbours and wish good neighbourhood. Hamas: Israel will exist until Islam obliterates it.
No, he meant islamofascism.@@manofwar2354
Wish you are our history teacher. So enlightening.
Thank you so much.
Hope those ivy colleges students could hear this and do their own research.😱
I am afraid they just copy and paste from the most convenient source. College is an UNTHINKINNG ZONE!
@@144Donn It's supposed to be the opposite!
Some colleges are still quite challenging.
I think instead of listening they are seeing things on social media which is tilting their opinions.
honestly all my friends are consuming all this disinformation on sm that i think km being shunned because i’ve been telling people that i disagree with the narrative :/
They are too lazy.
Mexicans must stand with Israel
💙🇮🇱📜🇲🇽🤍
Mexicans are stuck w/ a corrupt Leftist President, who does nothing about
Drug Cartels, nor S. American Caravans of people, & he loves Venezuela!
🙏🇮🇱♥️🇺🇸
No, we must stand with humanity
@@itzelcampos6316 I do not encourage my people to stand with Israel for the benefit of Israel, but for the benefit of my people.
*📜 Zechariah.2:*
8For this is what the Lord Almighty says: “After the Glorious One has sent me against the nations that have plundered you-for whoever touches you touches the apple of his eye.
. Selah
@@itzelcampos6316the same thing🇮🇱
*17 minutes of common sense.*
Thank you, Francisco, for having the courage to say that black is black and white is white. ✊✊
Anti Semitism is taught in our education system and especially in our Universities. I remember the 70s and the PLO were regarded as victims and not a terrorist group
Because the elite universities are controlled by globalists that want the destruction of Israel same as the Islamic regime…
Few understand the dynamics of the Israel Arab wars than Franscisco Gil White
According to PCPS Palestinian center and poling survey 64 % Palestinian Reject 2 states solution.
most Israelis know this.
It is good to listen.
Israel should be proud of their work in the desert and contributions to technology.
Yes, humanity has benefited from the inventions and discoveries accomplished by the Jewish over the years, despite being the most persecuted and hated people.
Thank You ❤ God Bless You ❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤
If only this true story was known to people …
Well, start talking to more people about it.
That will be a start.
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
Share it
Brainwashed people don't care about the truth!
It is 'common Knowledge amongst the Post War Generation ! However many of us knew veterans as youngsters.
I first heard about Hahnschar(Moslem SS Politzie) and Hussieni fifty years ago,
This truth has been almost completely suppressed.
All politicians should listen to these
Likewise I was in Sigint in Cyprus during the Six Day War. I watched it play out in real-time. I was a supporter of Israel from the day on. Every Jihadi Nation surrounding Israel was defeated. Now we see a repeat of 1967, but the Muslims know Israel may go after Tehran, and internal unrest there may limit the Mullahs. Israel could hasten the end of the "Islamic Republic of Iran".
Agree. Read that only 40% of the Iranians still consider themselves to be Muslims. They have lost the majority which only plays along.
Read an article regarding Husseini, and some old photos which recently surfaced a few years back of him with other leaders touring a concentration camp.
I do not know if they were from before, or after he met with Hitler.
Very interesting article though.
The statement that Gaza is a military facility camouflaged with civilians explains the apportionment of monies away from civilian development and completely into terrorists infrastructure is obvious. The destruction of the Israeli flower business by Fatah made no sense , they could have continued a turn key business for the people.
This fight is spiritual, and Francisco Gil White is in it. I love his heart. 👋
Such a clear and wonderful speaker. Keep up the good work bro 👍
ua-cam.com/video/vE98ZJZSraQ/v-deo.htmlsi=zN4r9TH8lnYdbBeX
It seems there are different views on the borders and responsibilities of Israel. So viewing the resolutions from UN about oppression or apartheid or womens rights, they must assume that Gaza and Westbank are part of Israel. Otherwise it makes absolutely no sense. Especially Gaza that have been self ruled for the last 15 years. Any opression, apartheit or violation of women right must come from their own government. I dont give much for the votes from other totalitarian states, but the democracies that vote to condemn Israel must see all the territory as Israel or it makes no sense at all. So why the talk of two states?
The God of Abraham forbids a two state of the land he gave the Jews according to : The book of Joel 3: 2 .
Israel have gaza under a blockade. Nothing is done except by the Israeli masters. The west bank is also occupied by Israel against international law which they ignore.
In such a congested area, with 80 Thousand Terrorists from many
Factions like Hamas, it seems a Miracle that when this is over, the
IDF managed to not Kill above 75,000 civilians from over 2 Million.
An amazing interview. Good job.
I listened to Gabor Maté and he convinced me much more, because he speaks with wisdom and as a true human being.
Terror only creates more terror.
If we lose our ability to feel compassion humanity is lost. Children lose everybody they have in their life, mothers are searching their dead children under the rubble. That is such an unimaginable suffering. This creates terror and trauma. So there will never be peace also not for the Israelis.
No one has been more terrorize than the Jews, but Jews aren't killing anyone. Bahai and Christians have been terrorized also, and neither are killing anyone. Your views are comical.
And yet somehow holocaust survivors did not go to kill and rape Germans after they were released, so there are ways to go on and build yourself a new life after a major trauma. It all comes down to choice. But you are right about never having peace until the Palestinians completely change their whole value system. I'm not holding my breath
Gabor Mate has zero understanding of Islamism (its anti human)
He doesn't even try to understand the honour shame dynamic of Arab culture that drives this conflict.
They use their own children for optics and money. Theres a cyclical nature to this conflict and its about money.
I agree! Ty for comment. Also Ilan Pape gives a historical perspective we in the west never hear.
@@roseschmidt2478 he does not.
Francisco , thanks for standing for truth with FACTS . Please do this in Spanish too, here in Mexico there is absolute ignorance on this subject .
Thank you, Francisco. Es un gran persona
Virtually every government official rejected the documentation provided by escapees from Nazi concentration camps, while WW2 was being waged. After Nazi Germany had lost the war, the first soldiers to come across the camps had difficulty processing what they were seeing. Even General Eisenhower was ill prepared for what he witnessed on April 12th, 1945, when he first visited the Ohrdruf camp annex of Buchenwald. It is not hard to relate to the average European & North American's unwillingness to process the facts on the ground in Gaza, as tunnel systems are discovered under every single civilian infrastructure facility. Our minds are slow to admit that the internal complexity, huge tunnels and vast rooms with full amenities, were planned with foresight before many civilian building were constructed. Kilometres of tunnels, joining up to levels of infrastructure, going as deep as 50 metres, built with the knowledge and assistance of Palestinian civilians. From janitors to the highest ranking officials, unanimously denied the presence of Hamas, and the tunnels beneath the facilities in which they worked.
We do not want to admit it, but we know the legal definition is aiding and abetting. Hamas' popularity amongst Palestinians has quadrupled since October 7th, 2023. If Gaza is predominately populated by civilians who do not support Hamas in both word and deed, as western legacy media consistently alleges, where are the voices of opposition to Hamas. Where are the Palestinian voices calling for a 2 state solution and the dissolution of Hamas? Outside of the legacy media, where are the voices advocating moderation towards Israel and acceptance of Israel's right to exist? Personally I believe their are Palestinians who despise Hamas and what they have done in their destruction of Gaza. Many of them are part of the 12k -20k Palestinians who were making their way out of Gaza into Israel every day to work, prior to October 7th. Though because they value their lives, and are aware of what has happened historically to those who vocally advocate moderation towards Israel, they will continue to remain the silent minority.
many of those who worked in Israel were Hamas operatives using their access yo collect intel for Hamas. who do you think decided who gets the permits inside Gaza?
don’t fool yourself. 2 States solution is a step towards the Final Solution. there was 2 States solution already, that created an Arab state, carved out of the land dedicated for creation of Jewish homeland, in a breach of all agreements and conditions of the British Mandate, a solution that has left only 1/4 of the land to the Jews, giving 3/4 of it to the Arabs. this state is called Jordan. and this is the state that, during the war of independence conquered and illegally annexed Judea and Samaria, renamed them to West Bank, ethnically cleansed of Jews who lived there, some for many generations, and forcibly repopulated with its own population whom it relocated there. when 19 years later, in 1967 Israel took this land back, it was already full of Arabs who were convinced that it’s theirs and taught their children that they lived there since time immemorial. Israel took the lamd back, yes. but it couldn’t do what Jordan did, and throw these Arabs away. they remained. amd became our problem.
something similar happened with Gaza and Egypt.
btw, one thing was never even tried during these 19 years of Jordanian rule in Judea and Samaria and Egyptian rule in Gaza: there was. no attempt to create a Palestinian state.
also, the modern 2 States narrative always mentions “1967 borders”, as if all of it started only in 1967, when do called “occupation” began. it’s a lie. PLO was created in 1964. how exactly could they aspire in 1964 to “liberate poor Palestinians from evil Israeli occupation” that started in 1967?
Those workers you defend were the very spies who told Ham*as everything they needed to know to commit the atro*cities of October 7, 2023. It is often difficult for westerners, who so wish to see good in those who have been indoctrinated in e*vil since birth, to be blind to the reality that virtually all Palis and Gazans are conspirators with, agents of, and sympathizers with their elected leadership, Ham*as. See them not only for who they are, but for who they proudly tell you they are.
First of all there is no evidence that they build those tunnels before they did civilian infrastructure, just recently the IDF did a mockery of themselves by accusing a hospital of harbouring “terror tunnels” with no evidence as well as using an Arab calendar as “names of Hamas fighters”, it’s almost embarrassing.
You’re being selective bias here, for 70 years the cries of the Arab world went unheard when UN saw it fit to displace the current Arab peoples who have been living off the land and replace it with European Jews who were war refugees running from Hitler and ww2. The Arab people saw no reason as to why anyone would give up their own land to a foreigner for a mishap that wasn’t of their doing. This sentiment was echoed through the entire Arab world, yet were their voices heard? Now you want to come ask where these voices of Palestinians against Hamas are😂. Hamas or the PLO or whatever organisation that Israel brands as terorrists are the only people keeping Palestinians from being fully annexed, talk about being selective bias just to suit your agenda.
Israel is an apartheid state serving as a colonial outpost for US foreign policy in the Middle East. But that support is slowly dying by the day, public opinion is shifting in the younger generation. Israel either makes its peace or suffer the same fate as Rhodesia or White South Africa.
Best explanation I've heard so far. Thank you!
I always have and always will support Israel
AMEN BRO. GENESIS 12 : 1 - 3 People like Napolitano and guest such as Scott Ritter must think that Covenant is no longer in force , it's everlasting.
Same here ..🙏🇮🇱♥️🇺🇸
@@ofrapeters3952not surprised what happened to the Native Americans is what's happening to the Palestinians
The Bible is the biggest myth in history, not to mention the huge scientific errors
An episode full of lies and deception from very stupid evangelical Christians who are obsessed with the Bible
Francisco Gil-White is a true friend of TRUTH !
Amazing! Brilliant! Gorgeous! 🥰🌹
Love hearing truth and insight!
i appreciae all this. BUt human life and civilian life is an ends in itself, and that is being disrespected. With international help and better communication on the part of Israel, maybe we coul evacuate the strip ut there is a real problem of racism in Israel. deal with it!
Excelente análisis
It’s amazing the two of you have a conversation of victimhood when the real genocide is happening in Gaza. If you reflect in the mirror, you understand why people despise the state of Israel at this point, and anyone who supports it.
Bull.
What a load of bullocks.
Great video , full off actual real info👍
You are hundred percent right. All true god bless you
I must be a very bad leftist. I have supported Israel since I was in the 6th grade when I discovered that "Palestine" was not mentioned in the Bible. That Baptist school was very right wing, but they were right in the case of Israel.
Brilliant. Can't wait for session 2.
Fransisco Gil-white IS Right on the money! Hopefully the world hears him!
Who is oppressing the Gaza people? HAMAS. Remember that.
Farge..left is the right the right is the left leaves false plastic woke.
Please, where has the link gone to the full interview, it doesn't seem to be there anymore?
That's so true!
Moral clarity in abundance. Thank you.
and that justifies the killing of women and children, what a load of
Nothing justifies Hamas
Lets get this viral!!
This is fascinating - thank you for history lesson
….. oh so, because the Nazi party had communications with some of the Palestinian leadership during WW2, that makes everything Israel is doing right now okay! 😂
Do you know what sonderkommando means?
This all fits so well to the broader perspective.
The slm cult have become honed along with the eug'ists
How informative please send this tape or video to the ANC minister of foreign affairs we the South African population do not agree on them taking Israel to court they should sort out our problems that’s major all the looting and state capture poverty of our own people etc
Woke is often not Awake BUT one can’t stand for both 🇮🇱 and Basic Human Rights
Quick correction, they didn't "seek refuge in Israel". They were, in fact, granted other people's land in the middle east so that Europe gets them off, in a form of 'kind compensation', then created the state of Israel.
What other people's land? Weren't those lands British, and before that Ottoman?
Quick correction to your incorrect "quick correction", it wasn't "other people's land." Most of the land that became Israel was completely empty arid desert or malaria-infested swampland where no-one had previously lived. And all of it legally belonged to the British, who legally gave it to them. That decision to turn part of the land called "Palestine" (never a nation or state in any sense of the word) into a national homeland for the Jewish people was made as soon as the British took over the territory from the Ottoman Empire at the end of World War One. That was in 1918, 20 years before the Holocaust. That land belonged to the Jewish people; it just took the British 30 years to finally hand it over to them and get the hell out of there. But even throughout the 20s, 30s, and most of the 40s, it was widely understood that British Mandate Palestine was Jewish Palestine, the Jewish people's homeland. The British had already given the Arab Palestinians their own state from over 75% of that land, east of the Jordan River. That was the Kingdom of Trans Jordan (later called Jordan), founded in 1923.
@@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci This is not entirely correct. The British actually had promised a land on this territory to 3 different groups, who actually lived both under the ottomans then the British mandate, who were Arabs, Kurds, and the Jews.
The land was never a vacuum, it was actually inhabited by majority of Arabs (not exclusively Muslims, but also Christians, Bahai, and Druze) and other ethnic minorities. The Arabs allied with the British to revolt against the Ottomans, then the British mandate that created Mandatory Palestine through the league of nations, of which the charter stipulated that it'd have 3 official languages English, Arabic and Hebrew.
@@hend6421 That's absolutely incorrect; nearly all of the Arabs in WWI who took a side in the war fought on the side of the Ottomans. When the British defeated the Ottomans, they took control of Palestine and shortly thereafter handed over 75% of it (all the land east of the Jordan River, which became the nation of Jordan in 1923) to the Palestinian Arabs. That was the Palestinian Arab state. The much smaller section of land west of the Jordan river - which continued to be British Mandate Palestine until 1948 - had been intended for the Jewish homeland, because that was the land of Israel, the historic ancestral homeland of the Jewish people, and where nearly all of the Jewish Palestinians lived (those who lived on the Jordan side migrated to west Palestine or were expelled; no Jews live in Jordan now).There was never any intention to create some kind of multinational single state in which both Arabs and Jews shared power and lived together peacefully; that's ridiculous. The British weren't stupid and knew something like that would never work. What complicated the matter of course was that the Arab population had exploded in west Palestine since the late 1800s because so many had migrated there to take advantage of the burgeoning economy the Zionists had created, and continued to pour into the place (mostly from southern Syria and Egypt) all through the 20s, 30s, and 40s, and most of them bitterly resisted the idea of living in a Jewish-controlled state. The Arabs sided with the Nazis in the Second World War. When, after the war, the Brits proposed partitioning west Palestine into a Jewish state and another Arab state, it was proposed that Jerusalem would be kind of a third multinational city state, to which both the Arabs and the Jews had equal access, and continued to be administered internationally (so the British would still be in charge of it, to some extent) in order to keep the peace. This was the partition plan that the Jews accepted (even thought it left them with only half the land they'd been promised) and the Arabs rejected in 1947, then went to war against the Jewish state. And lost.
lol I hope you don’t live anywhere in the Anglosphere.
With Hamas it is important to remember that the leaders of Hamas that are living in Qatar do not give orders to the Hamas military. The Hamas military is not subordinate to the Hamas leaders in Qatar. The Hamas military do their own planning of operations without consultation or vetoes from the Hamas leaders in Qatar.
So what is this "leadership " even for? What purpose does it serve other than to siphon funds away from the civilians ?
@@helenromanelli2544 From the various websites I've seen the leadership in Qatar deals with funding Hamas and negotiating the ceasefires. Hamas has literally billions of dollars in funding. That money has to be collected, banked, some sent to pay for the needs of the what flows to Gaza such as military hardware and of course cash also goes to Gaza.
One thing I would like Dr. Gil-White to address is the settlements and settler violence in the West Bank. Also, why are the Jews hated around the world since time immemorial?
there are no 'settlements'. Jews have legal right to live throughout historic palestine. Israel prosecutes violence. Jews are only hated by anti-civil rights fascist leaders and their loyal lapdogs. He explains all this. So every gentile must choose: support the laws and values of the Jews, or side with the elite class.
Thank you. More to this.
Even before Hamas, Palestinians were oppressed by Israel….
Yes, since the Arab revolt when they started wanting to eliminate Israel.
Thank you for this video. Oh I listened to Francisco's previous interview with you... I hope it was a previous one, and not part of this, and I've forgotten most of it... anyway, excellent, excellent.
This also needs to start going out on the "shorts" on UA-cam.
So maybe a question here, and I'm really trying to tie this up in a biblical peophetic sense.
What is the underlying reason/root, for the Arab nations, the UN, to keep a people at centre-point in the Middle East (who are actually their slaves -but they don't know it) - who they've promoted as "Palestinian refugees" (and are keeping them that way)?
The terrorist attitude towards Yisra'el was already there, so what would be the reason to set up your own kind (as slaves) and use/abuse them?
Are we speaking of pure evil here, that of a rivalry of two brothers - Esau and Ya'aqob - where Esau is still trying to kill Ya'aqob and retrieve the birthright for himself?
Ya'aqob was the legal first-born, but Esau being stronger, fought his way in the womb, and down the birth canal in order to come out first. That is why Ya'aqob was still holding onto his heel... in order to try and stop him, but Esau was stronger.
So YHWH made a way that Ya'aqob would receive the firstborn double-portion blessing that legally belonged to him, and we all know that account.
Esau hates Ya'aqob.
Esau makes slaves of his own people.
He came out toward Ya'aqob hiding behind 400 (as he still is), trying to show his might, but Ya'aqob walked in the righteousness of YHWH, and came forward to Esau in wisdom (as he still is doing).
The monarchic rulers of planet earth - archetypes from Nimrod- are tyrants who seek to maintain their rulership and pass it to their heirs. This is an ancient fraternity of global tyrants whose persecution and annihilation of God’s war club (Jeremiah 51:20) is an act of existential self preservation ! They know what rabbis refused and forgot to teach, that the Jewish people are not only God’s vanguard of higher God consciousness but also His liberation force to end tyranny and usher in a world brotherhood of all mankind so all creatures can earn and enjoy God’s beneficence and blessings.
What about WHY HAMAS attacked on October 7th!!! Free Palestine!!!!!!!!
When God sent Jesus Christ, his son, to earth to save sinners, Jesus made a NEW COVENANT with his people. Followers of Christ are the New Jerusalem, the New Israelis. The old covenant made with the Jews died when they denied the son of God.
Thank u for this video. I thought all spanish speaking world supports 'Palestinian Cause'.
I can quote several Surah's, w/ verses, advocating violence & beheading, w/ calls
to massacre Unbelievers & "People of the Book" (Jews & Christians), chapter & verses,
from the Quran, but even when I Quote just 2 or 3, in Comments, UA-cam takes it off ASAP.
You are right. If the qur''an would be a product of our time, it would be treated like 'Mein Kampf'. It is hairrising what you find in this book.
😅f
FREE YOURSELVES FROM ALL THE NONSENCE AND MARCHES! IF YOU REALLY CARE SEND MONEY TO RELIEF ORGANIZATIONS...
I have quoted a few and people report them as violence hate speech.
My point exactly! In your American/European context, colonialism / imperialism might be a “catchy, trendy” phrase used by the left, they might even denounce Israel’s colonial practices when ignoring the ones perpetrated by China or Rusia. That happens because you (your context) are so far removed from it, it becomes an abstract concept. A political statement. For us, the ones that have been on the receiving end it’s not about being left or right. It’s about humanity, about life. For us colonial violence is a very real thing. We can recognize and denounce this practices wherever they come from. Be it Israel, China, Russia, USA, Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, Uk, etc. We don’t care about defending no regime cause they are all violent. So the fact that China is stealing African resources doesn’t justify Israel’s violent crimes. 🇮🇱 Now about occupation. Let’s asume all the white people migrating to Israel are in fact indigenous to the Palestinian area. Let’s imagine that. Even if that was true, it’s still occupation because it was an area already populated for years when they “came back” Imagine Mexicans, mass murdering people from Texas, taking their homes and stablishing the Aztec state: Aztlan For the ones that do not know, according to Aztecs sacred records they came from a place in the north, called Aztlan.
There is no point arguing with this people. Reason has no place in their mind. You can't explain the inner working of colonialism to a mind shaped by colonial belifes.
No one stole homes. They purchased land. They provided jobs. And the land, which currently has a population of at least 12,000,000, had a population of about 450,000 in 1880 when the first aliyah (immigration to Palestine) began.
@@adammiller6299 i wish with all my heart that was true. Unfortunately houses and land are being stolen all the time which is heartbreaking, the evidence is there, a few clicks away. I wish for you all the strength let go of what you being taught which is scary I know. And shift your loyalty towards humanity instead of countries, any country.
You’re attempting to labeling things in a black-white context which is not applicable to the Levant.
Ashkenazi Jews are descendants of Jews who migrated to Europe around the first century.
Your argument immediately destroys itself. Yes indigenous peoples have the right to return and liberate their lands. This is what the Jews have done. It doesn’t matter if people were living there or not. They were not thrown out, millions of Arabs still live in Israel. Why perform half the job? Should have thrown out all of them.
You would probably advocate for the destruction of Israel and murder of the Jews by the Arabs. The very thing you accuse the Jews of doing. If original inhabitants don’t have rights to their lands than neither to recent inhabitants.
Personally I think it’s just a cop out. People like you have to justify their Jew hatred while also not contradicting themselves. If you live in America, Canada, Australia, NZ etc you certainly have no moral leg to stand on.
So called Judge Napolitano , his guest and those commentors that think Napolitano is telling the truth should watch this .
Pure propaganda!
There are none so dumb as those who don't WANT to know....
To be fair Wokists just looked at AIPAC cancel methods and took notes
I’m happy that you STRESS critical thinking. I’m hopeful that those who listened to this mostly propaganda, interspersed with a few truths, podcast/Vlog WILL DO their own research to get to the fuller and more nuanced truth. Enjoyed the listen tho.
Could you take an interview with Noam Chomsky about the subject, please?
Why? He’s a far left anti semite. He’s supported all kinds of disgusting causes, long before he jumped on the anti Israel bandwagon. For example in the 1970s he supported the genocidal Pol Pot government in Cambodia, and denied the genocide they committed ever took place. He still hasn’t retracted that. He’s written the introduction for a book by a holocaust denier. He gets away with the anti Jewish sh*t just because he comes from a Jewish family. But Marx came from a Jewish family too and he was one of the most vicious antisemites in history, once writing, “The Jews are the worst of all peoples.” So antisemitism has a long proud legacy on the political left.
ua-cam.com/video/A8ZLiYIvtQ8/v-deo.html
Or norman finkelstein.
I’d love to see that!!!
He is an idiot ..
Just seeking attention to himself..
Eran Efrati also debunked woke Ness very well
I am sick of heirng about the four year old "martyrs" in Gza, as if beig an innocent baby isn;t enough to inspire indignancy and outrge.
Israel blames Hamas, Hamas blames Israel……One side always blames the other and so on. This whole thing is just an outrage.
Precisely.
that's a lie
Thanks!
Calling Willy Brandt an anti-semite, really? I can not take this man seriously.
I consider myself a leftist and a supporter 100 percent of Israel
I stand with Israel so does G -d!!!
The jews were murdered by European colonialism and then they turned around and colonised and murdered Palestinians. Simple as that. There is no contradiction here, and yes, victims can become victimisers. And if you dropped that blindfold of being an eternal victim, you too could clearly see the situation here.
Read just read pick up a book and read here some suggestions 1)The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (2006) 2) Ten Myths About Israel by Ilan Pappé 3) State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel by Thomas Suárez 4) The Biggest Prison on Earth: A History of the Occupied Territories by Ilan Pappé
Very good 👍
Well put.
50 Cent said stop your bubblegum the world have seen everything
i can find three places in the in the Bible where God says to the Jewish people the descendants of Abraham This Is Your Land I can find the name Israel written 2,319 times in the Bible I can't find the word Palestine once I can find in the Bible where Jesus Christ refers to the land as Israel I can find in the Bible where it says where Jesus says if you give a cup of water to the least of my brethren it's as if you have done it to me Jesus loves the Jews I love them too
The Bible is the biggest myth in history, not to mention the huge scientific errors
My mind is not destroyed but Israeli story is weak and getting weaker
Your mind IS destroyed with ante Israel propaganda
The world is so sick with hate. The truth can't be any more obvious, yet the world can't hear it.
If any grandma could front for a terrorist, how dare you say that about Israel? Pure Projection. “Actually it’s Israel”. We all know only one side is this barbaric.