I have tried to block your Chanel from my feed but it keeps showing up, is there a way you can block me from your end?, i would be thankful if you can.
@richardchurch If you're going to make a declarative statement like that, then back it up. You're precisely the person he is talking about. Unwilling to face reality in service of fantasy.
@@gheller2261 Thanks Geller. I am very comfortable being on the opposite side of the argument to this racist genocide supporter. When I stand back and look at the history of Zionism, the documented plan to expel as many Arabs as possible using any and every pretext (Plan Dalet and Ben-Gurion's speeches and writings), what was actually done by the Palmuch and other militia, and how this enterprise of expulsion and ethnic cleansing has continued throughout the short history of Israel there is no doubt in my mind that Israel's attempts to disguise it's history are failing. Let this disgusting racist speak about the people who recognise the truth in whatever manner he likes. There are plenty of blind followers who still believe the lies. And they deserve to be in his company. Israelis dancing and singing 'Burn their villages' is a snapshot of Israel. Do you sing along?
@@gheller2261 My previous reply to you was cancelled by YT it seems. In essence I am very comfortable sitting on the opposite side of the argument to the racist bigot interviewed by 2 racist bigots who proudly announced to the world that they would commit genocide 'in an instant' if given the chance. I refer you to the repeated use of the description of Arabs as 'barbarians'. All the more ironic when you consider the barbarism at the core of Plan Dalet - Ben-Gurion's white paper for ethnically cleansing Palestine. A plan conceived in 1947 and actioned in 1948. The barbarism of the Palmuch and other militia was systematic, deliberate and was the real world expression of the Zionist pillar to create a Jewish only state by expelling the indigenous Arabs. You really should try and understand what your own leaders say, then do. Plan Dalet is still in play today.... Israel still seeks expansion and expulsion. It is in your DNA.
In my 75 years I’ve never listened to a smarter , absolute realistic person than Dr Dan Schueftan . My dream is to invite him for a coffee and have a meaningful conversation with him .
he reminds me my grandfather. (die in early 90s in age 81)he survived holocaust (almost die from malnutrition.) he have 2 children after WW2, he spoke 12 languages , never lose the chess game, he was pharmaceutics, very smart man !!!
Dr Schueftan is absolutely brilliant. His analysis is penetrating on the Israel - Palestinian conflict. He repeats that every democracy is unprepared for war. He emphasises we must become much more realistic about continual danger. Thank you so much for your insightful reminders.
Puh leaze! This Dr Dan has no right to lecture anybody on who is or isn't a barbarian. Where do i begin about the topic. . . perhaps the formation of Israel in '48 by ethnic cleansing and massacres? Theres so much to choose from! Btw I'm the son of a Holocaust survivor, who grew up in South Africa. The apartheid government at the time, under the delightful leadership of former Nazi supporting BJ Vorster, was developing nuclear weapons. And take a guess who was helping them? Yes, that's right!!! ISRAEL!! So please save your opinions Dr Dan - and here's wishing that the SA charge against Israel will gain traction at the ICJ.
Mosab Hassan Yousef spelled it out for me. He said the values of the West are right/wrong & the values of the Islamicists are honor/shame. In the light of this small, affluent, fruitful Israel drives them crazy . . . .
If you are right then it explains EVERYTHING. Because hunger is wrong and plenty is right. Period. Eating can be shameful and starving can be honorable. "He who fights and runs away lives to fight another day." It is a pragmatic saying. The Nervii Belgic tribe thought shameful to retreat. So Julius Caesar wiped out the tribe.
Your point, if any? Pro-Hamas = Pro Genocide of Jews Radical Islam is the snake hiding in the grass. Moderate Islam is the grass hiding the snake. Islam - 1400 years of tradition unhampered by progress. Without lies Islam dies. Am Yisrael Chai @@xhagast
I agree. These two guys are interrupting and are very annoying. Stop trying to control every aspect of the conversation. Let the Dr. lead the conversation.
He reminds me of the American philosopher, Thomas Sowell. He says that there are no solutions, only trade offs. And then he says to pick your pain. What do you want your trade-off to be?
I have to say, after hearing this man speak and knowing that he has the ear of the military strategist in Israel, I feel so much more optimistic about Israel’s future. He’s right on, and his full of common sense.
I love this man! Intellectually and emotionally intelligent, very clearly and rationally sees both the trees and the forest, and has the energy of a lion that protects the sanctity of his home. Three times bravo for this gem of a person 👋👋👋 Am Yisrael Chai! ❤🇮🇱
The man is extreme left. I asked my friends in Israel why did they think Arab in Gaza is a good people ? My friends told me that I am crazy ! My friends knew that people in Gaza barbaric ! People in this kibbutz on the boarder were crazy left and were helping “ civilians “ who killed them. Left ALWAYS DEMONIZED ISRAEL saying that Israel is not good to Arabs in Gaza and West Bank, many of them left Jews from America and Canada. And we need to get clear that Palestinian Arabs is not ethnic group, Jews were Palestinian too. This subhuman Arabs came from Egypt and Syria and Yemen. Arafat was Egyptian. Rashid Tlalb in our government ancestors came from Yemen. Time for them to return to their homes where they belong.
@@deborahbluhm8828 He implicitly gives many reasons himself when he describes the state of Europe. This also applies to Germany. The war in Ukraine may have awakened some of society, but many here still believe that all people are equal and inherently good. You don't want to deviate from this dogma and you can't represent certain positions in political discourse without being canceled for it. On the other hand exactly this drives people into the hands of rightwing populists. Apart from Dr. Schueftan's blunt analysis, his style would be absolutely problematic. He would immediately be branded a racist and an islamophobe. So he's absolutely right when he says (most) Europeans live in Lalaland and therefor his point of view is way too radical 😉
@@schwanzusminimus3321 Thanks. I agree. I didn’t realise it was that bad in Germany though, I’m in the UK and it’s the same here. The Tories right-wing) here just sacked a Tory for being a Tory because she was seen as “too” right wing. You couldn’t make it up 😂 It’s interesting to see how Europe will get a grip of the situation without letting fascism creep back in. Something has to be done before societal values are undermined and defense is effected.
Yes I completely agree with Dr. Dan. This comes from a once bleeding heart liberal who finally woke up and looked around and noticed where my bleeding heart liberal ideals were taking me and my country. I had been believing a lie perpetrated around the world now not just isolated in my area of existence. I have grown up I started seeing things through grown up eyes. Unfortunately I see a lot of grown up eyes that never grew up. That was something of a mind twister but you get the idea and if you don't check because I don't think your eyes are open you're still in la la land as Dr Dan said. Thank you Dr Dan for having the balls to stand up and say what's truth.
Dr Dan is wisdom itself. At last, someone with whom I entirely agree. Thank you, thank you, thank you. (Perhaps this is because my age is 81.) Wish, though, that the Two Nice Jewish Boys would not interrupt as much as they do. Their arguments are childish.
Prof Schueftan is a logical and entertaining speaker. His sense of humor is as developed as his worldview. Thanks for posting this video, I enjoyed it and daresay I learned from it.
I also liked that they asked quesitons, that gave the Prof. the opportunity to clarify and go deeper in his analysis. So many people just let him speak and don't prob deeper.
Don't worry, it's a Jewish\Israeli thing, challenging one's views is not considered disrespectful if done without malice, Dr Schueftan knows they respect him and is not offended by them disagreeing with him. A Jew must have two synagogues, one he goes to, and one he doesn't go to... :)
@@freak.558 Sure, just to clarify, the synagogue saying is a known joke, but it signifies a real attitude among Jews, we are not afraid to disagree, in fact the main Jewish holy text after the Bible, the Talmud, is basically an argument among our ancient wise men about different issues, and you learn about how to reach the true and moral through the different views brought in the text
@@assafelron1oh thank you. I so want to study the Talmud and have been googling a lot but there are so many different books after different authours, I don't know what to choose(Learn Talmud:how to use Talmud" Judith Z. Abrams:"The Talmud for beginners"' The Talmud" Arsene D:"The wisdom of the Talmud" medison c. Deders and so on). Could you maybe be so kind to tell me the title and authours of the original Talmud book or books( maybe a stupid question but I haven't found it or them)? And do you think it's wice to start with the original and then have some guiding book about how to use Talmud on the side? I hope it's okay to ask. I find your culture so beautiful and fascinating:)
@@freak.558 That's a good question, I am not really an expert in the matter, I am from a secular family myself but over the past 20 years found myself finding great wisdom in our ancient texts, but I am far from an expert. I will try to ask a wise Rabbi I know and get back to you. The thing is the Talmud is huge, and pretty complicated to study, so thats a really good question what is the right way for beginners
the two young interviewers are rude and ignorant. The professor is brilliant and right. There are problems which cannot be solved but need to be managed. That is the history of the world
We were in a Jewish museum in Germany and the guide has told us about something he said he witnessed when he himself was on a similar tour with a Jewish group. The guide at that tour tells the local Jewish history of Jews coming, living in the German town. Then there is a pogrom, the Jews are killed, then some time later Jews come back to the town, rebuild, live for some time, then there is a pogrom, the Jews are killed. Then some hundred years later there is another pogrom and so on... A Jewish immigrant to Germany from Eastern Europe then speaks up incredulously: "But why did they keep coming back?" The guide turns to him and says: "But you are back here, too." People want to believe they can live happily and in peace with others. They will forget the danger they are in because it is emotionally more comfortable to go about your day trusting your neighbour than thinking about him waiting for you with his knife around the corner. But that is exactly what happened on October 7. Workers from Gaza have betrayed the Israeli people to terrorists by providing information on the families living there. Never forget - is important.
They ruin their own countries with their own barbaric ways and take it into other countries. Cannot be let in!! Barbarism is certainly inferior behaviour!! We don't want this in our countries!!!
@@2NJBReupload the videos so we can all look at you for what you truly are. The sad thing about you people is you assume we all hate you when frankly we're just deeply disappointed in you. The descendants of the prophets have zero humanity. Zero regard for human life. You enjoy cruelty. Just breaks my heart to see what's become of you and your culture.
They like most people don't know the history of a place well enough before they form an opinion. I understand their hesitation of not having some sympathy with the Palestinians and seeing who is the real threat. It's taken me a very long time to see the threat the collective Palestinians, and the Iranian regime are to the region and thus to the rest of the world.
As an Iranian I wish in west world every country had at-least one strategist like Dr.Schueftan in their decision making process instead of these stupid leftard populists
False belief of who currently owns land. Must work with current times and stop working in the dark ages and living like backward barbarians!! Move forward in peace!!!
Exactly like South Africa... lalaland... our country has been completely destroyed because of lalaland political culture ideology. We have no airforce, no army, no navy... not to mention hospitals, schools, municipalities, in short nothing. Thank you for this open minded, honest and courageous interview with Dr Schueftan calling a spade a spade. To him, you do not look the other way, you face the cards on the table, deal with it and accept the consequences! 💜
Brilliant sage, who is a realist and knows a job has to be done. One thing I know, there is no such thing as a sweet old lady, harm her children and see what happens. Israel was a sweet old nation, now it can’t afford to be. Really enjoyed the debate, learned a lot, talked with honesty, reason and logic. You give me some hope for the future but you can’t reason with unreasonable like Hamas. It’s a completely different mindset. Good to listen to the different generations being able to debate so well and have the freedom to do so. At least they are able to question openly and not suppressed. Appeasement never works. May Israel find peace and build the fantastic country you were doing. ❤
I like your words "Israel was a sweet old nation, now it can’t afford to be. ". No democratic country can afford to be too nice to an unfair aggressor. Aggression can come in different forms.
Dr. Dan Schueftan is an incredible man! May he live a long life and share his wisdom with as many people as possible. This was so enlightening and refreshing, but as some other commenters made the interviewers should try not to interject so much…it gets really annoying bc I’d like hear Dr. Dan without so many interruptions. Thank you for doing this interview though. ❤🇮🇱
Two Nazis, "taken out of context": "If you gave me a button to just erase Gaza, every single living being in Gaza would no longer be living tomorrow. I would press it in a second.” He claimed that “most Israelis” would do the same. “Forgive us if we don’t give a shit if everybody there dies. It’s just the way we feel. It’s just the way Israelis feel,” Weinstein said.
Very interesting insights and I find myself agreeing with Dr. Dan Schueftan. Pity the two hosts kept butting in making stupid statements such as permanently invading Gaza, stating that in 1948 the land was taken by force etc.
It is so cathartic to hear such words of wisdom, common sense and utter truths. Thank you for explaining reality as it is, and not some delusional wishful world. Israel will triumph !
I was in Israel a few years ago in a hotel in Jerusalem. One of the managers in the hotel was an Arab. he was charming and polite. He told me that his son was studying at the Hebrew University. He told me he owned an apartment. He told me he owned land. He then took his phone to show me works of art he had produced. One was of the Via Dolorosa in colours of the Palestinian flag. I asked him why , of all the colours of the flag did he use red for the road. His reply was that liberation must be achieved through shedding blood. Now, I reflected hard on the earlier part of the conversation: Here was a man in a successful position in a well established hotel, children who were educated, owned property and reasonably settled in his manner, yet he harboured an ambition to chuck this all away in favour of committing bloodshed.And this was one ordinary guy.
@@Camille_Anderson 😂😂😂the absurdity of what you’re saying 😂😂😂 Projection: that’s what Israelis and Zionists do all the time. They project ALL THEY DO onto the poor Palestinians
Dr Dan makes a lot of sense. 2 Jewish boys don't seem to be listening and need to stop interrupting and start listening and thinking preferably at the same time.
They don't understand the levels of military thinking. Dr Sheuftan is focused on the strategic level, playing the long game. Nice boys are thinking on the tactical and operational levels. And fantasizing about a solution where everyone sings kumbaya together.
Thank you Dr Schueftan is the most clear, wise man, his truth cuts through all the BS out there. Maybe the interviewers are playing devils advocate...showing the level of what many young peoples' interlectual capacity is. Proving why it's not surprising that so many young people out there are swayed by utter lies and hatred. The world needs more interlectuals like this brilliant man. Thank you for this podcast.
I cannot say how immensely grateful I am to can listen to these discussions. It helps me, to understand the problem a bit more. Dr. Shueftan ist a number on its own. We are very far away to see qualities like him or just this interview on our idiotic public TV here in Germany.
Sorry to say, but Two Nice Jewish Boys need to learn to listen without always interrupting their host. Their interruptions spoiled an otherwise excellent interview.
I am glad the interviewers challenge Dr. Schueftan. "Respect"doesn't mean you just nod your head all the time like a bobble head. He is certainly confident enough to handle questions.
Dr. Dan is a delight as always. Thank you for bringing him back. Some thoughts: The kids born after 9/11 discovered the letter of Osama bin Laden ("message to America") and it went viral. October 7th may be a turning point for the current population of Israel and its views, but in 20 years there will be Peace Raves again with no active memory of the past. Although, was the US is concerned, maybe the youth is just the product of the current educational system. Schueftan noticeable pushes back against "solutions". It was brought up, but i presume his argument is: to solve anything you need all the parties involved. Until then you just can (proactively) manage. Last point: Showing no weakness payed off for Israel in the long run, since more and more neighours are willing to cooperate. I think Oct. 7th was a suidical and barbaric call for attention, for the issue itself and the attention of the Arab neighbours. They may get online support, but in reality there is still no willingness to let them in. Maybe this could be a wake up call for the Palestinians to ask themselves: "how did we get here".
Agree with some other comments...Stop interrupting your guest speaker. We want to hear him and let him finish his points without constantly interrupting him, from UK 🇬🇧
These young men are grappling with a problem which I doubt you have any real idea about and I am not surprised that they are bursting with questions in front of such an interesting Dr.
@@picogangThey’re not just asking questions. They’re inserting their own commentary and derailing the doctor’s well organized presentation in the process.
Bottom line is, we become complacent. We are too eager to believe there is good in everyone and have been taught to forgive so we become targets for bullies over and over again.
The 2 nice boys can't cope with the hard truth Dr. Schueftan is laying out. I forgive you for your shallow arguments because you're young . I just hope you realized the truths your guest rained on you 😊
Asking Jews to reform Islamic Jihad by being kind is an impossible task. I had hope during the Arab Spring and recent Iranian uprisings, but his real politik is painfully true
Support us so that we can do more interviews with Dr. Schueftan and many more fascinating guests>>
www.patreon.com/2njb
😮😊😊😮😮😮😮😮😢😢😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😊😊😮😮😮😮😮😮😢😮😮
Mañana!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jajaja
More interviews? Please don’t, go do creative basket weaving instead please!
I have tried to block your Chanel from my feed but it keeps showing up, is there a way you can block me from your end?, i would be thankful if you can.
Guys, let Dr. DAN speak!!
Exactly my thoughts! Shut up nice boys.You take up precious time.🙄
Yes!
yes
Dr Shueftan's merciless and sober analysis, which is in truth based on humanity, is deeply impressive
Its wonderful listening to an educated, realistic, down-to-Earth man like Dr. Schueftan.
A dark and vindictive soul indeed....
@richardchurch If you're going to make a declarative statement like that, then back it up. You're precisely the person he is talking about. Unwilling to face reality in service of fantasy.
@@gheller2261
Thanks Geller.
I am very comfortable being on the opposite side of the argument to this racist genocide supporter.
When I stand back and look at the history of Zionism, the documented plan to expel as many Arabs as possible using any and every pretext (Plan Dalet and Ben-Gurion's speeches and writings), what was actually done by the Palmuch and other militia, and how this enterprise of expulsion and ethnic cleansing has continued throughout the short history of Israel there is no doubt in my mind that Israel's attempts to disguise it's history are failing.
Let this disgusting racist speak about the people who recognise the truth in whatever manner he likes. There are plenty of blind followers who still believe the lies. And they deserve to be in his company.
Israelis dancing and singing 'Burn their villages' is a snapshot of Israel. Do you sing along?
@@gheller2261
My previous reply to you was cancelled by YT it seems.
In essence I am very comfortable sitting on the opposite side of the argument to the racist bigot interviewed by 2 racist bigots who proudly announced to the world that they would commit genocide 'in an instant' if given the chance.
I refer you to the repeated use of the description of Arabs as 'barbarians'.
All the more ironic when you consider the barbarism at the core of Plan Dalet - Ben-Gurion's white paper for ethnically cleansing Palestine. A plan conceived in 1947 and actioned in 1948.
The barbarism of the Palmuch and other militia was systematic, deliberate and was the real world expression of the Zionist pillar to create a Jewish only state by expelling the indigenous Arabs.
You really should try and understand what your own leaders say, then do. Plan Dalet is still in play today.... Israel still seeks expansion and expulsion. It is in your DNA.
The clearest thinking person I’ve heard about the situation in Israel and the World.
Also check out Yishai Fleisher and Caroline Glick (& her many great guests).
Have a Palestinian on
😊
I discovered this gentleman in the last two days. He is amazing!
same!
Me too
Same. Just today!!
The same here too😊
@@real_MacrocosM Yas
Brilliant man! This needs to be heard by many… Thanks for inviting him! But stop interrupting speakers like him.
In my 75 years I’ve never listened to a smarter , absolute realistic person than Dr Dan Schueftan . My dream is to invite him for a coffee and have a meaningful conversation with him .
Yes--Dr. Dan is realistic. I so much enjoyed this discussion.
He has totally baren worthless mind.
I fully agree with you... from South Africa⚘⚘⚘
Ahh, that’s the feeling of having your guilt assuaged.
he reminds me my grandfather. (die in early 90s in age 81)he survived holocaust (almost die from malnutrition.) he have 2 children after WW2, he spoke 12 languages , never lose the chess game, he was pharmaceutics, very smart man !!!
Dr Schueftan is absolutely brilliant. His analysis is penetrating on the Israel - Palestinian conflict. He repeats that every democracy is unprepared for war. He emphasises we must become much more realistic about continual danger. Thank you so much for your insightful reminders.
White extremlsm
@@abaialsa712😂
Puh leaze! This Dr Dan has no right to lecture anybody on who is or isn't a barbarian. Where do i begin about the topic. . . perhaps the formation of Israel in '48 by ethnic cleansing and massacres? Theres so much to choose from!
Btw I'm the son of a Holocaust survivor, who grew up in South Africa. The apartheid government at the time, under the delightful leadership of former Nazi supporting BJ Vorster, was developing nuclear weapons. And take a guess who was helping them? Yes, that's right!!! ISRAEL!!
So please save your opinions Dr Dan - and here's wishing that the SA charge against Israel will gain traction at the ICJ.
@@abaialsa712 WTF is "white extremism"?
There must be black, and brown extremism too.
Israel unprepared for war? That's ridiculous.
Mosab Hassan Yousef spelled it out for me. He said the values of the West are right/wrong & the values of the Islamicists are honor/shame. In the light of this small, affluent, fruitful Israel drives them crazy . . . .
If you are right then it explains EVERYTHING. Because hunger is wrong and plenty is right. Period. Eating can be shameful and starving can be honorable. "He who fights and runs away lives to fight another day." It is a pragmatic saying. The Nervii Belgic tribe thought shameful to retreat. So Julius Caesar wiped out the tribe.
Your point, if any?
Pro-Hamas = Pro Genocide of Jews
Radical Islam is the snake hiding in the grass. Moderate Islam is the grass hiding the snake.
Islam - 1400 years of tradition unhampered by progress.
Without lies Islam dies.
Am Yisrael Chai
@@xhagast
Dr. Dan logic is so clear and enlightening.
Boys, you should learn how to listen and think. Learn history more too.
And stop interrupting the guest.
I agree...
I agree too. The boys are like little kids.
Ikr. You can tell he's used to talking to college kids who may not be the brightest. He's very patient with them.
I think they do well, & are playing devil’s advocate. Dr Dan is quite capable of dealing with them & does.
Dr schueftan is brilliant. a great mind and a great man.
Thank you, Dear Dr. Dan Schueftan. You are courageous and correct. No appeasement and or placating Hamas or the other enemies against us Jews.
Guys, stop interrupting!!!
You guys are interrupting according to your own agenda! You're so annoying. I highly respect this Dr.
I agree. These two guys are interrupting and are very annoying. Stop trying to control every aspect of the conversation. Let the Dr. lead the conversation.
I didn't like Obama.
Agreed you two are dipsh$t$ compared to this guy…let him speak and learn something.
@@somersetdcwe must’ve watched two completely different videos.. it’s literally the complete opposite
Wow! This was fantastic! I could listen to Dr. Dan Shueftan for hours! Don’t think about solutions. Think about damage control. Sensible.
Called Harm Reduction in addiction treatment.
You acknowledge addiction is a lifelong problem -- there is no solution.
He reminds me of the American philosopher, Thomas Sowell. He says that there are no solutions, only trade offs. And then he says to pick your pain. What do you want your trade-off to be?
Never heard such such a simplistic solution to a complex political problem. Thank you Dr. Schueftan. I agree wholeheartedly.
Not simplistic … clear & to the point.
I just discovered this. Dr Dan speaks truth! Total support from Germany!
Dr. Schueftan is a wonderfully patient communicator.
Great analysis from a common sense approach.
This Guy is a Genius, his clarity on this situation is a breath of fresh air.
Spot on! 😊
I have to say, after hearing this man speak and knowing that he has the ear of the military strategist in Israel, I feel so much more optimistic about Israel’s future. He’s right on, and his full of common sense.
A new discovery for me and very enlightening listen 😊
He understands. And when you UNDERSTAND you can create effective plans. It is the advantage of using realism to calculate things.
I love this man! Intellectually and emotionally intelligent, very clearly and rationally sees both the trees and the forest, and has the energy of a lion that protects the sanctity of his home. Three times bravo for this gem of a person 👋👋👋
Am Yisrael Chai! ❤🇮🇱
Thank you Dr Dan Sheufttan for Another riveting perspective
This man speaks 100% truth
The man is extreme left. I asked my friends in Israel why did they think Arab in Gaza is a good people ? My friends told me that I am crazy ! My friends knew that people in Gaza barbaric ! People in this kibbutz on the boarder were crazy left and were helping “ civilians “ who killed them. Left ALWAYS DEMONIZED ISRAEL saying that Israel is not good to Arabs in Gaza and West Bank, many of them left Jews from America and Canada. And we need to get clear that Palestinian Arabs is not ethnic group, Jews were Palestinian too. This subhuman Arabs came from Egypt and Syria and Yemen. Arafat was Egyptian. Rashid Tlalb in our government ancestors came from Yemen. Time for them to return to their homes where they belong.
Schueftan is always on point
Dr Shueftan's an intelligent and wise-man. Amazing...👏👏👏
What a delight! It would never be possible to hear this kind of analysis in Germany. Looking forward to the next episode with Dr. Shueftan.
Dr. Schueftan is the best combination between rational and solutions,as well as logic conclusions...
Why not? Just being curious 😊
@@deborahbluhm8828 He implicitly gives many reasons himself when he describes the state of Europe. This also applies to Germany. The war in Ukraine may have awakened some of society, but many here still believe that all people are equal and inherently good. You don't want to deviate from this dogma and you can't represent certain positions in political discourse without being canceled for it. On the other hand exactly this drives people into the hands of rightwing populists. Apart from Dr. Schueftan's blunt analysis, his style would be absolutely problematic. He would immediately be branded a racist and an islamophobe. So he's absolutely right when he says (most) Europeans live in Lalaland and therefor his point of view is way too radical 😉
@@schwanzusminimus3321 Thanks. I agree. I didn’t realise it was that bad in Germany though, I’m in the UK and it’s the same here. The Tories right-wing) here just sacked a Tory for being a Tory because she was seen as “too” right wing. You couldn’t make it up 😂 It’s interesting to see how Europe will get a grip of the situation without letting fascism creep back in. Something has to be done before societal values are undermined and defense is effected.
@@deborahbluhm8828 let's hope everyone will come to their senses early enough 👍
Yes I completely agree with Dr. Dan. This comes from a once bleeding heart liberal who finally woke up and looked around and noticed where my bleeding heart liberal ideals were taking me and my country. I had been believing a lie perpetrated around the world now not just isolated in my area of existence. I have grown up I started seeing things through grown up eyes. Unfortunately I see a lot of grown up eyes that never grew up. That was something of a mind twister but you get the idea and if you don't check because I don't think your eyes are open you're still in la la land as Dr Dan said. Thank you Dr Dan for having the balls to stand up and say what's truth.
Dr Dan is wisdom itself. At last, someone with whom I entirely agree. Thank you, thank you, thank you. (Perhaps this is because my age is 81.) Wish, though, that the Two Nice Jewish Boys would not interrupt as much as they do. Their arguments are childish.
Prof Schueftan is a logical and entertaining speaker. His sense of humor is as developed as his worldview. Thanks for posting this video, I enjoyed it and daresay I learned from it.
Why can't these kids listen and learn, don't interrupt the Prof.
They are learning through dialogue, these are the qualities of a free society.
I also liked that they asked quesitons, that gave the Prof. the opportunity to clarify and go deeper in his analysis. So many people just let him speak and don't prob deeper.
These men are talking nonsense.
@@brendakruger2597 can you clarify?
They can’t stop interrupting because they’re Israelis. It’s literally a cultural requirement. Lol 😂
This is possibly the most helpful conversation I've heard since 10/7. Thank you. Subscribing now and hope you have Dr Dan back soon
So much wisdom from Dr. Dan.
Younger generation should learn from older wise generation.
Thank you so much Dr. Dan.
What would you do if you live in israel as an arab
No even 2nd class but 4th class citizen?
Many thanks for giving them water and petrol
I dont think water was stopped in ww2
If u take every thing from people then they have nothing to lose!
@@atharm4120doesn't Islam have dhimmi status for non Muslims? If they're allowed to live at all.
I love the conversation. These 2 young men need to show this gentleman the respect he deserves.
Don't worry, it's a Jewish\Israeli thing, challenging one's views is not considered disrespectful if done without malice, Dr Schueftan knows they respect him and is not offended by them disagreeing with him. A Jew must have two synagogues, one he goes to, and one he doesn't go to... :)
Thank you for explaining that. Didn't know. Cool so that how you cultivate your brains no wonder we are brain limited in the West:)
@@freak.558 Sure, just to clarify, the synagogue saying is a known joke, but it signifies a real attitude among Jews, we are not afraid to disagree, in fact the main Jewish holy text after the Bible, the Talmud, is basically an argument among our ancient wise men about different issues, and you learn about how to reach the true and moral through the different views brought in the text
@@assafelron1oh thank you. I so want to study the Talmud and have been googling a lot but there are so many different books after different authours, I don't know what to choose(Learn Talmud:how to use Talmud" Judith Z. Abrams:"The Talmud for beginners"' The Talmud" Arsene D:"The wisdom of the Talmud" medison c. Deders and so on). Could you maybe be so kind to tell me the title and authours of the original Talmud book or books( maybe a stupid question but I haven't found it or them)? And do you think it's wice to start with the original and then have some guiding book about how to use Talmud on the side? I hope it's okay to ask. I find your culture so beautiful and fascinating:)
@@freak.558 That's a good question, I am not really an expert in the matter, I am from a secular family myself but over the past 20 years found myself finding great wisdom in our ancient texts, but I am far from an expert. I will try to ask a wise Rabbi I know and get back to you.
The thing is the Talmud is huge, and pretty complicated to study, so thats a really good question what is the right way for beginners
I am 1000.000 times AGREE with dr.Schueftan !!!!!!!
I love this guy! Straight forward, no BS talk.
the two young interviewers are rude and ignorant. The professor is brilliant and right.
There are problems which cannot be solved but need to be managed. That is the history of the world
Yes always interrupting....
Thomas Sowell insists on that: There are no solutions, only tradeoffs
They are dumb. 90 percent of Israelis nor the government don't want to return to Gaza.
I was actually shocked at their ignorance of Israel's history.
idiotic comment
We were in a Jewish museum in Germany and the guide has told us about something he said he witnessed when he himself was on a similar tour with a Jewish group.
The guide at that tour tells the local Jewish history of Jews coming, living in the German town. Then there is a pogrom, the Jews are killed, then some time later Jews come back to the town, rebuild, live for some time, then there is a pogrom, the Jews are killed. Then some hundred years later there is another pogrom and so on...
A Jewish immigrant to Germany from Eastern Europe then speaks up incredulously: "But why did they keep coming back?"
The guide turns to him and says: "But you are back here, too."
People want to believe they can live happily and in peace with others. They will forget the danger they are in because it is emotionally more comfortable to go about your day trusting your neighbour than thinking about him waiting for you with his knife around the corner. But that is exactly what happened on October 7. Workers from Gaza have betrayed the Israeli people to terrorists by providing information on the families living there.
Never forget - is important.
‘You can’t handle the truth’ - A FEW GOOD MEN. 1992. Nothing changes. The hard truth hurts. Fantastic episode.
Thank you!!!
They ruin their own countries with their own barbaric ways and take it into other countries. Cannot be let in!!
Barbarism is certainly inferior behaviour!! We don't want this in our countries!!!
I think calling for a ceasefire is immoral after oct7th evil barbaric behaviour!! We must not stand with evil!!!
@@2NJBReupload the videos so we can all look at you for what you truly are. The sad thing about you people is you assume we all hate you when frankly we're just deeply disappointed in you. The descendants of the prophets have zero humanity. Zero regard for human life. You enjoy cruelty. Just breaks my heart to see what's become of you and your culture.
A man that talks common sense .
Two Nice Jewish Boys: become less nice and more introspective and educated.
This was painful whenever either of you talked.
They like most people don't know the history of a place well enough before they form an opinion. I understand their hesitation of not having some sympathy with the Palestinians and seeing who is the real threat. It's taken me a very long time to see the threat the collective Palestinians, and the Iranian regime are to the region and thus to the rest of the world.
@@sbaumgartner9848Israel is more dangerous to the world than Iran
Exactly
They are young and being interactive. He's not on a podium, it's a discussion. Jeez!
As an Iranian I wish in west world every country had at-least one strategist like Dr.Schueftan in their decision making process instead of these stupid leftard populists
False belief of who currently owns land. Must work with current times and stop working in the dark ages and living like backward barbarians!!
Move forward in peace!!!
God will be out judge .it is all Gods land. I wish all people could turn to Jesus for peace.
The left is ruining the West (though the right has done a lot of damage too).
you shoul listen to ex Muslims telling you what is the Islamist mind set if you realy want to understand the world@@veenacriddle1207
Insane conservatards are toxic too.
No solutions
Only trade offs
Manage the situation
Stop looking for solutions - manage and minimize down sides
-
Brilliant man
-
Exactly like South Africa... lalaland... our country has been completely destroyed because of lalaland political culture ideology.
We have no airforce, no army, no navy... not to mention hospitals, schools, municipalities, in short nothing.
Thank you for this open minded, honest and courageous interview with Dr Schueftan calling a spade a spade. To him, you do not look the other way, you face the cards on the table, deal with it and accept the consequences! 💜
Hard to believe that S.A. produced the first heart transplant. I visited your beautiful country in 1986.
Waited for this talk since two months ❤ Thank you guys and thanks to doctor dan😅 Great show 🥰
You might lappreciate Carolyn Glick's shows as well - she has also great guests who have common sense.
The doctor speaks an uncomfortable truth 😔
Yes.
The truth is often unconfortable. Most of the people prefers to live in the confort of Lalaland...
He speaks truth!!
Finally pulling Dr Dan into new territories of conversation. Well done guys!
Thank you!!
Brilliant sage, who is a realist and knows a job has to be done. One thing I know, there is no such thing as a sweet old lady, harm her children and see what happens. Israel was a sweet old nation, now it can’t afford to be. Really enjoyed the debate, learned a lot, talked with honesty, reason and logic. You give me some hope for the future but you can’t reason with unreasonable like Hamas. It’s a completely different mindset. Good to listen to the different generations being able to debate so well and have the freedom to do so. At least they are able to question openly and not suppressed. Appeasement never works. May Israel find peace and build the fantastic country you were doing. ❤
I like your words "Israel was a sweet old nation, now it can’t afford to be. ". No democratic country can afford to be too nice to an unfair aggressor. Aggression can come in different forms.
Dr. Dan Schueftan is an incredible man! May he live a long life and share his wisdom with as many people as possible. This was so enlightening and refreshing, but as some other commenters made the interviewers should try not to interject so much…it gets really annoying bc I’d like hear Dr. Dan without so many interruptions. Thank you for doing this interview though. ❤🇮🇱
Dr Dan Schueftan is brilliant! Thanks for this interview.
Two Nazis, "taken out of context":
"If you gave me a button to just erase Gaza, every single living being in Gaza would no longer be living tomorrow. I would press it in a second.”
He claimed that “most Israelis” would do the same.
“Forgive us if we don’t give a shit if everybody there dies. It’s just the way we feel. It’s just the way Israelis feel,” Weinstein said.
Very interesting insights and I find myself agreeing with Dr. Dan Schueftan. Pity the two hosts kept butting in making stupid statements such as permanently invading Gaza, stating that in 1948 the land was taken by force etc.
A great thinker. Thank you for the interview.
This guy is great. I hope you guys appreciated his wisdom
כל הכבוד
I had a great time listening to your conversation, guys.😊🎉
Thank you! 😃
תודה רבה על שיחה מאלפת ❤❤ החכמתי, תודה רבה לכם ולדר שיפטן המבריק ❤❤❤
It is so cathartic to hear such words of wisdom, common sense and utter truths. Thank you for explaining reality as it is, and not some delusional wishful world. Israel will triumph !
Dr. Dan Schueftan is very practical as well as very wise.
If left was wise Israel would not have October 7 !!
This guy is Israel's national treasure. Thanks god there is people with clear ideas.
Dr Dan was great, these 2 children are well children.
I was in Israel a few years ago in a hotel in Jerusalem. One of the managers in the hotel was an Arab. he was charming and polite. He told me that his son was studying at the Hebrew University. He told me he owned an apartment. He told me he owned land. He then took his phone to show me works of art he had produced. One was of the Via Dolorosa in colours of the Palestinian flag. I asked him why , of all the colours of the flag did he use red for the road. His reply was that liberation must be achieved through shedding blood. Now, I reflected hard on the earlier part of the conversation: Here was a man in a successful position in a well established hotel, children who were educated, owned property and reasonably settled in his manner, yet he harboured an ambition to chuck this all away in favour of committing bloodshed.And this was one ordinary guy.
Incredible story.
@@2NJBsounds incredibly FALSE- just trying to show Palestinians in a bad light as usual
This sounds like a Hasbara TALL TALE!
@@NaJAl-v2lno one has to paint Palestinians in a bad way, their words and deeds are doing it for them.
@@Camille_Anderson 😂😂😂the absurdity of what you’re saying 😂😂😂
Projection: that’s what Israelis and Zionists do all the time. They project ALL THEY DO onto the poor Palestinians
The best analysis of the problem I heard so far!
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Dr Schueftan, I love your mind. Thank you.
The Europeans live on the American sword. Ain’t that the truth.
Islam is from different planet. Not human.
God said a kingdom.will not stand divided. Until we all come to God through Jesus we will be divided!!!
The devil has no place in peace!!
@@veenacriddle1207 It would seem Islam is the devil
@@veenacriddle1207Take your divisive dogma and shove it.
Well, I say it's human, but from a bronze age human barbaric civilization. We are much better than that these days . Let's defend our values.
Islam leading of book Quran is about hate other religion what we have to know.
Dr Dan makes a lot of sense.
2 Jewish boys don't seem to be listening and need to stop interrupting and start listening and thinking preferably at the same time.
They don't understand the levels of military thinking. Dr Sheuftan is focused on the strategic level, playing the long game.
Nice boys are thinking on the tactical and operational levels. And fantasizing about a solution where everyone sings kumbaya together.
so frustrating for the good doctor, he has my sympathies and my admiration for his fortitude and endurence.
I find these 2 guys rather irritating. Dr Dan is a brilliant, highly educated man and they should listen more and interrupt less.
Rather --> Very
Now this a professor I'd like to have. Says it the way it is.
Two nice guys should learn to listen more and interrupt less
Both of this little guys has no class just the way seeding it tells you everything
Dr. Dan is brilliant, thank you for the interview. When is part 2?
And I LOVE Dr. Dan’s humor.🩵🇮🇱
Me too 😊❤
Part 2, with the two nice jewish idiots interviewing? No way!!
I will never forget these faces
absolutely Brilliant , the most sensible and realistic viewpoint out there
Hands up to the wisdom of Dr. Dan. The two boys are talking shit.
Thank you Dr Schueftan is the most clear, wise man, his truth cuts through all the BS out there. Maybe the interviewers are playing devils advocate...showing the level of what many young peoples' interlectual capacity is. Proving why it's not surprising that so many young people out there are swayed by utter lies and hatred. The world needs more interlectuals like this brilliant man. Thank you for this podcast.
I"m more enlightened after this video
Pleasure and privilege to listen and learn from prof. Dr. Dan.
A wise man with profound knowledge and understanding.
Some problems do not have solutions. Took me to be over 40 to realise that.
Thank you for this but plz don't interrupt the interviewee!
Don’t interrupt?, but thats all they know what to do!
Dr Dan is brilliant, but those two know NOTHING about history!! Annoying!!!
Absolutely,,,
@ThinkinAg858 Agreed.
I cannot say how immensely grateful I am to can listen to these discussions. It helps me, to understand the problem a bit more.
Dr. Shueftan ist a number on its own.
We are very far away to see qualities like him or just this interview on our idiotic public TV here in Germany.
שיחה מאלפת ❤❤❤❤
ווואאאא... החכמתי. . תודה רבה לכם ולדר שיפטן המבריק
Dan Schueftan speaks with great logic, clarity and truthfulness...this is a great talk with him!
Sorry to say, but Two Nice Jewish Boys need to learn to listen without always interrupting their host.
Their interruptions spoiled an otherwise excellent interview.
Initially.
I am glad the interviewers challenge Dr. Schueftan. "Respect"doesn't mean you just nod your head all the time like a bobble head. He is certainly confident enough to handle questions.
Dr. Dan is a delight as always. Thank you for bringing him back.
Some thoughts:
The kids born after 9/11 discovered the letter of Osama bin Laden ("message to America") and it went viral. October 7th may be a turning point for the current population of Israel and its views, but in 20 years there will be Peace Raves again with no active memory of the past. Although, was the US is concerned, maybe the youth is just the product of the current educational system.
Schueftan noticeable pushes back against "solutions". It was brought up, but i presume his argument is: to solve anything you need all the parties involved. Until then you just can (proactively) manage.
Last point: Showing no weakness payed off for Israel in the long run, since more and more neighours are willing to cooperate. I think Oct. 7th was a suidical and barbaric call for attention, for the issue itself and the attention of the Arab neighbours. They may get online support, but in reality there is still no willingness to let them in. Maybe this could be a wake up call for the Palestinians to ask themselves: "how did we get here".
Better yet, "Where are we going?"
Palestinian introspection is like a flying unicorn.
Beautiful. Could not agree more. And it is delightful to read so many supportive comments. Thank goodness.
Agree with some other comments...Stop interrupting your guest speaker. We want to hear him and let him finish his points without constantly interrupting him, from UK 🇬🇧
These young men are grappling with a problem which I doubt you have any real idea about and I am not surprised that they are bursting with questions in front of such an interesting Dr.
@@picogangThey’re not just asking questions. They’re inserting their own commentary and derailing the doctor’s well organized presentation in the process.
Bottom line is, we become complacent. We are too eager to believe there is good in everyone and have been taught to forgive so we become targets for bullies over and over again.
Absolutely brilliant
Amazing stuff. Thank you Dr. Dan.
The 2 nice boys can't cope with the hard truth Dr. Schueftan is laying out. I forgive you for your shallow arguments because you're young . I just hope you realized the truths your guest rained on you 😊
They should at least shut up and listen...honetly
To sum up Dr Dan’s philosophy in the immortal words of an 80s cop show , Hill St Blues :
‘ do it to them before they do it to you ‘
I agree 100% with Dr. Schueftan.
Fascinating show! But for his message, I'm afraid people will not get it after hearing it only one time.
I have listened repeatedly.
wow, how refreshing to hear such a brilliant mind! he is so lucid, so articulate, amazing!
First time here. Two Jewish Boys!? This gentile and staunch supporter of Israel approves!
This was excellent. Tbe professor is so smart and incisive.
Asking Jews to reform Islamic Jihad by being kind is an impossible task. I had hope during the Arab Spring and recent Iranian uprisings, but his real politik is painfully true
The Arab spring was the ultimate in naïveté from the West.
This was an absolute gem. Thank you!