Indian couple's children taken away by Norway authorities
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 гру 2011
- Norway's government-run Child Protective Services took away Sagarika and Anurup Bhattacharya's two children on May 11 this year, saying they were not being brought up properly.
Who came here after watching mrs Chatterjee vs Norway.. really sad story never heard about it.m thanks to the film crew to bring light
Me
Me
Me I cried so much
Me
Who's here after Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway Trailer.
Me
Me
Me
Everyone
99% of the people, good thing that they made the movie, this kind of things should come to light.
My husband works in Norway and we decided to live together as a family but as such horrible things are happening i think i will not risk my daughter, i love her so much and i even cant imagine such horror..
The parents abused the kid and left marks so the kids were taken away from them, I don't see anything wrong in that. I hope you don't physically abuse your kids.
@@dawoodwaris Don't talk bullshit...you don't even personally know the couple...I have seen them...my uncle knows that family personally they resides in our area...so stop spreading lies...liar
@@madhumitadutta6189 The wife got psycho issues and try to physically abuse her husband after this incident. The media covered that up. I am pretty sure Norwegian authorities took away the kids for a reason. And your uncle knows nothing.
@@dawoodwaris most of thes cases happens to black and brown families and other white immigrants because in Norway you can’t spank your kids it’s illegal and at times barneverne get things wrong and let children who needs them stay in terrible homes while taking the children who doesn’t need them a kids aren’t usually pleased with other relatives unlike in America where they might ask other family members to take them in before foster care
@@dawoodwaris ignorant
Here after watching the trailer of Ms Chatterjee vs Norway !! Horrible incident btw but glad they got justice
Same
Anyone here , after Mrs.Chaterjee VS Norway trailer?
nahi
I just watched trailer and search for the movie 😢😢 it’s really sad to know that this movie is based on true story 💔💔💔💔
@@Imran_khan_ke_voter truly....being a Bengali and an Indian i can feel the pain the parents went through.....
Really excited to watch the film...
@@chelseafc5296 no body asked you bruh!
Bruhh it's our culture man I always used to think that Norway is the safest and nice country but after watching this I will think twice for even visiting in this country in future means what the hell means they were doing some domestic violence or something like that they which forces them to take away their children without even informing them it might be in your culture norwegians but not in our india in India we all raised like that only and we are happy with that
Then do so in India, dont do it in Norway.
@@MrCaveman366h yeah, you racist freaks. Your whole fucking govt. runs on foster care money. Care to explain that dumbfu*s
@@MrCaveman366are you kidding? Is feeding your child with hands and making them sleep in the same bed some sort of abuse for you all? And we Indians were slapped for being bratty in the childhood and that's why we were in control otherwise the new parents in India are also going the western way....I teach tuition and see they are extremely pampered by their parents.....the parents never say or do anything when their child misbehaves and slowly they are becoming brats who don't know how to respect their elders and behave with them
@@MrCaveman366 we gladly will. There are thousands of children taken away just like this. And there parents are not always lucky as this one, it's a fucking business now. You guys have forgotten that a child is not justa property you can take and give it others, there are feelings and emotions of the mother and father entangled with there child. I cant imagine how much of a unbelievable and horrifying thing happened, and what the mother has to go through. Truly horrifying. European countries are getting eaten by corruption and you guys are so blind you cannot even see it. Just naming yourself "developed country" doesn't make you developed, the mindset of its citizens is what make you developed.
@@classyart5322 They where supposedly beating their kid with a belt and burning him with a hot spoon, this behaviour is illegal in Norway. If you cant follow the rules of the country you move to why come?
As a breastfeeding mother of one year old daughter, it made me anxious and broke my heart when she said my kid is on breastfeeding in the trailer.... Western culture is suffering in terms of their EQ because they undermine bonding that could take place when children are under 3years of age, their upcoming generations would dread even more due to this. In my experience as a mother, researches does not always hold true for kids as each kid is different and we have to go with our intuitions as a mom and not just push helpless newborns into independence, it would come in a better way once they are emotionally, mentally and physically secure that is why these primitive years hold a lot of significance. India being an ancient civilization has learnt child-rearing through experience and westerners are trying to learn through researches
Did you just Spam same comment on every News Channel the same line "As A Breastfeeding Mother........"???
@@pravindaga661 exactly
I think she is from PR team of the movie.....
@@ManjuSingh_leo and I think you are a keyboard warrior
@@pravindaga661 yes but I wrote it intentionally.... Did not mean to spam.... I felt closely connected to the issue raised in the movie..... The misconception that everything is rosy in Western countries need to change
I want to give advice to everyone if u got troubles with child police and u are foreigner only one solutions is to run from the country if u want to save a baby
They will follow you. There was a famous Romanian case (not the Botnariu family) where they managed to escape and they ran to Sweden. Norwegian authorities tracked them and almost kidnapped their children outside of their country. Fortunately, the family escaped again and settled for Spain.
Something very wrong with your country. A disgrace.
You have to go to a safe country such as poland
I escaped Norway, police still haven't catched me
Move out of the stupid European Union
Who is here after Rani Mukherjee's movie trailer
Shame on Norway and Germany where such practices are being run.Shame.
The police were called for domestic violence on multiple occasions and the wife left her arranged husband. The husband has been sued for harassment. I'm feeling quite confident Norway was not the problem in this case...
@@klakatroll plenty of such cases happening there in that pedo child kidnapping country this is not first, and you dont kidnap her breast feeding child from her mother for calling cops on husband even if that happened??
@@klakatroll Norway IS the problem, i myself have been taken away by the authorities and it sucks, plus immigrants have a higher risk of being taken away then whites do
@@rajeev_dubey Again, if you review all sides of the case the police, the courts and the multitude of other systems in place agreed that the environment was massively hostile and not fit for children. Barnevernet will go to great lengths NOT to separate a family, they're being demonized quite frequently, but if it's gone so far that they take your kids from you, the family situation is insanely fucked up
As a U.S born in no way, shape or form would U.S do something as barbaric as what Norway put this mother through. Yes there's laws, but I've never heard or seen anything like that here. In the contrary, I think U.S doesn't care enough for immigrant families. No mother should go through what she suffered. And I am glad she fought til the end to get her babies back!! ❤
I mean obviously CPS does intervene if it seems necessary but there is no business of selling kids like Norway has done with kids in their country. Europeans are the hypocrites and dystopian. Their minds are fried with all the drugs and loot and they have collected from third world countries.
Youre wrong !!! kids were snatched away from their parents and put in cages by trump / obama admin , just because they were illegal immigrants !!! CPS takes away kids all the time but from “ abusive homes “ theres few reports of baseless allegations by malicious ex and family so it happens all the time in western countries !!!
But u get shot in usa also ..guns are free in schools, colleges ..no safer for kids , students..
The us has done this
I and my parents live in Sweden and they are afraid that a my baby brother might be taken away by some reasons they come up with...
Maa to Maa hoti hai chahe kuch bhi ho apne bacche ke liye kuch bhi kar skti hai 😔😔😔love u Maa 💞❤️
We moved from Norway to Turkey because of these events.
Good for you.
Great decision
Did you personally face racism there?
Turkish ppl don't like foreigners especially desi plus there is Langauge barrier how did u get job
What actually happened??
Seriously how badly they stereotyped the mother in the trailer. She speaks perfect English and they showed as if she cannot speak even a word of English without thick fake Bengali accent. They can use artistic freedom for showing something that isn't documented, but how can they stereotype something that is already in public domain?
Bollywood: “This is business…”
And the father seems quite good. Why is he portrayed so bad in the trailer. He even said he's ready to quit anything.
@@lisasyadom23 exactly
Exactly and they portrayed the father even worse in the trailer as someone who is still concerned about his citizenship than his family... whereas here the real father clearly says he's ready to quit everything..his job ... He just wants his kids back and fly to India..back home.. with his wife and children
@Light ikr they're making it seem like the mother is the only one struggling and she does everything's herself.
Thanx for showing us the bad side of foreign countries 🙏
Oh to bad that children have rigths in norway
@@LasVegarbro... Get your brain checked. i think it has been brain washed by Western thoughts and elitism.
@@LasVegar Yeah... Why don't you just stfu if you can't understand the cultural difference? If they had any problem then they could have just deported them to India. What logic does it make to take a mother's newborn baby away from her?
Its not a bad side!!! its a norm in all the countries including the USA..If the parents aren't caring for the children correctly then the kids will be put into better homes where they will be raised correctly!! Because the kids deserve a better life! But not sure what happen with this family and why the kids were taken.. Doesn't mean that this govt procedure is wrong.. Maybe with this incident there was a misunderstanding.
@@nidhim7632 I’m a norwegian living in Norway and I can confirm Norway is stealing kids for no reason.
Same thing happening in Germany right now
Movie - Mr. and Mrs. Chatterjee.... what happened in the end ? Did they get back their kids ?
Yes
Movie name: Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
Mrs Chaterjee u r so brave and can feel ur pain as a mother.
Here after Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway trailer!
And it's recommended by UA-cam
Who is here after Rani Mukherjee's movie?
Who came here after watching the trailer Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
Is there any particular reason to be so concerned? If yes - your family gotta get outta there, ASAP.
Why does Child protective services keep fucking up?!
It is horrible in America too. The pattern = all western countries.
It's a fucking business
Business is what makes them rich capitalism countries
@@aena5995how is paying more an busniss???
They give zero f about homeless children dying. This is a business.
Came after watching trailer of Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
Came here after watching the movie trailer. Heartbreaking
What is the name
Who has come after watching mrs chatterjee vs Norway movie? 😊
Very brutal act towards parents n children...
How can they separate 4 month breastfeeding baby from his mother...
Whatever may be situation, children are safe with their parents only...
Stop this cheap business in the name of Foster care...
That's why Indian culture is the richest of all.
disagree
@@nidhim7632 why? Don't kids deserve to be with their parents?
@@himanshusuri2424 kids deserve to be treated well. Kids deserve to be NOT ABUSED !! Kids deserve good education!!
@@nidhim7632 Approximately 4000 people who were formerly taken into custody by the child welfare have sought compensation for suffering and abuse while living in orphanages or foster families between 1945 and 1980. Of these, 2637 have received compensation, in total $220 million (2010).
@@nidhim7632 why no reply, keyboard warrior 🪖
im from norway. it is not the utopia you are led to believe. the state is horrible once you get on their wrong side
CAN TELL MORE about flaws in their state?
If you get on their wrong side they'll put you in a prison that feels like a 4 star hotel
It is still being done Norway's NATO secretary and removes scandals from media
It breaks my heart to see this😢... Well done Indian movies , many of us was unaware of such issues happening 😢
I think the father was portrayed wrongly in the movie , here he says he will quit everything in Norway to get back his kids
Truly depressing this case... Norway this is wrong!
@Hale Not true! This usually happens in Nordic countries, especially Norway. I don't think this is the case even for, let's say, Germany.
@@daly9794 Finland, Norweigh, Germany even countries like Poland etc. There are many. According to them, even doing normal house chores like helping in the kitchen and cleaning the house and helping in the family business is seen as a child abuse, these guys have forgotten the meaning of child abuse.
@@rickgolder6818 I really really doubt in Poland and in Germany they will take away your child, especially in an Eastern European country such as Poland that still clings to a "communist" parenting style. I mean I'm an EU citizen myself and I can distinct those type of countries with strict parenting laws and Poland isn't on that list. I don't think Germany makes the list aswell.
@@daly9794 The Germans have literally taken away a child called Ariha, on terms of "sexual abuse". In 2021. Stop defending them
@@daly9794 bruh forgot the jain family case of germany
Horrible system
Mrs. Chatterjee v/s Norway Rani Mukherjee ❤️ Amazing movie
Norway laws ☕ ☕. Good That She Got Justice
Did she got her baby?? Are you sure??
@@anonymousaf7099 get Lost
@@anonymousaf7099 yes she got her babies back after two years of fighting with the Norway govt, then Indian govt had to step in. Salute to the mom that she did not lose hope keep fighting
@@AniketSingh1169 uneducation Mannerless clown
@@DrMdRoFiqUe zad bolo kutaaa
Came here from Rani Mukherjee’s trailer…
I am crying 😭😭😭
Honestly have no words…
I saw this movie teaser that come out 11hours ago and directly see the video that has has com 11 years ago 😶
Came here after watching Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway....
So the movie Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway played by Rani Mukherjee is based upon this incident.
Who's coming after watching the movie trailer...
I'm here After watching the trailer of "Mrs Chatterjee vs. Norway"
All that glitters is not gold
And we thought Norway is safe.
Dont settle in strange countries..
Who is here after watching trailer of mrs bhattacharya vs norway
Who came here after Rani mukerji's New movie on this issue ??
Why the film potray her husband bad in this he is saying that he is ready to quit every thing . Movie me massala dalna jo tha
To dekh na bhai masala, kya prblm h, movie aane to de
@@AyushKumar-eh3qo nope..you can see the news..later husband will say his wife is mentally unstable and file a divorce..the children will sent to India under paternal uncle's custody..she again fought in India to get the custody of her children..you see the news clip in ndtv..in anchor will ask how you got strength to fight again India..she will say thanks to her lawyer and parents Don't brand a movie without knowing complete new..the clip which you see is the initial stage of the case..my the end couple got divorced
@@Halebot pehle movie to Ane de fir judge karna. Ase bohot si andar ki baat hoti hai Jo hum bahar nahi dikha sakte
Never knew how maniac of a country Norway is...
Not just Norway, all Europeans, Canada, Australia and US, they have these stupid laws.
Rani Mukerji's new movie is based on this incident.
Who is here after the movie
Lesson to all people who took pride when their ungrateful sons & daughters go to foreign..
If a great opportunity comes knocking down your door, won't you take it! Its a matter of few months and when they get settled,they could even bring their parents.
@@claytonbigsbyofmodernindia7127 the thing is u born in this great country, u took food from this country,, ur body is made From its' soil...but opportunists are no one's..
& u if u want to settle there fine but whenever trouble came whether its Syria, Yemen,Ukraine, Kuwait,Afghanistan or even Australia, Norway or England,,, why they came back running to this country???
@@subhadeephaldar8189 Yes Subhadeep , everyone those who have sense will come back. Money is good , but not in exchange for your life loved ones and your freedom.
i came here after Rani's new movie ? it is horrifying...
Many persons watching this video after releasing the trailer of Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway
Who came here after watching the trailer?
I am here after watching it on netflix😭
i cried river😭
Who after Mrs chatterji Vs Norway trailer ?
What happened at last.. Did the parents able to get back their childern?
After 2 years of fight. Considering the child was a breastfeeding baby, 2 years is a long time
Those poor parents😟
Did they divorce?
How did they even come to know that details of child upbringing if nobody reported?
They visit the homes for inspection
Here after the trailer 🙏
Mr.Chatterjee vs Norway
Kaun kaun mrs chatarjee ka trailer dekh kr aaya h
Wasn't aware of this reality..until thru ranis movie. So I can imagine how tough must have been..
Do not be one sided everyone. Please look at the other side
Everybody has to take a side you mug there's no in between. The organisation that kidnapped their child were hit by serious allegations of Kidnapping children from Russia too
Acha.... Isi story me movie ban raha hai matlab
I saw the trailer of a film inspired from their life today only. Whatever happened with them was wrong. I'll only recommend that before going to & settling in foreign they must know that country's rules & regulations properly regarding the issue they have to face there.
Bullshit. Foster care systems need to be better, and stop being racist
@@wordinaryeardough9016 I'm not at all racist I just commented that an Indian must know the rules & regulations of a foreign nation before going to & settling there. As rules & regulations of each and every nation are different from each other. Whatever they faced in Norway it was bad but at the same time it all happened due to lack of their knowledge regarding the upbringing of their children in a country like Norway.
@@explorewithkriti8374 I didn't say you were being racist. Apologies for that. I said foreign countries end up being very racist in the way they treat others from varied cultures.
Who comes here after watching the movie trailer? 😀
I am here after watching trailer mrs Chatterjee
How are they now?
Well they got their babies back after two years of fighting
Is this issue now resolved?
Yes. Rani mukherjee's movie is coming on this issue I came to this video after that trailer
Ya it is...the mother got her children back
Here after watching Rani Mukerjii 's new movie trailer .
Norway oh no
I think Mrs Chaterjee vs Norway, Rani Mukherjee's movie is based on this news.
And you're god damn right
And they call themselves developed
Now there is movie in making on this
Shame on you Norway
Norway is unsafe for baby...
East or west India is the best.
After watching the trailer I will never leave India not even for vacation. I m really scared.
Okay the movie is inspired from this incident.
here after Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway tariler ❣❣❣
Mrs. Chatterjee vs Norway ❗❗❗
Mera Bharat mahan🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
You say this like there are no bad things happening here. Poverty, unemployment, racism, castism, corruption, illiteracy, low gdp per capita, and so much more. I'm not saying they are ok for doing this to a family but you are reaching.
@@drunk_taylor poverty and unemployment doesnt seems to exist in the western world and about cast it's a Portuguese word it's called varna system and that has been extinct for a long while and to even compensate that we have quota system so stop fucking around
@@oindrilaroychoudhuri273 doesn't change the fact that indians are very racist towards black people and especially Asian looking people. Using slurs and calling them Chinese. Norway is not the only one being racist here.
Yes
What happend that they had to take children away from parents so weird...there are plenty of druggist parents in europe they never so that..why this indian family had to go through so much
I came here after watching trailer Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway 🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩🙌🙌🙌
They get their kids back??
Yes!😊
After seeing Mrs Chatterjee vs Norway
Mrs Norway chaterjee film itni late BN ri h
Why Norway did that
Fame in Indian media
Here after ranj Mukherjees film trailer
Who came here after MRS. CHATTERJEE vs NORWAY
Don't visit Norway ever
And I thought Norway was a good place to live
I am here after watching mrs. Chatterjii vs norway teaser
Here after watching Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway trailer
Why didn’t they go to the Indian embassy?
No, Indian govt was involved later.
Ofcourse this shows up on the feed today🤣
Husband is unbelievable
Father seems good and mother also speaks well in english then why in movie they showed bad father and stereotypes mother....bad Bollywood creativity....
yeah masala
In real life her husband used to assault her too. Now they are estranged