Dan Markel murder case: Katherine Magbanua testifies (Part 1)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 жов 2019
- Katherine Magbanua testifies in her own defense. She and Sigfredo Garcia are accused of the 2014 murder of FSU law professor Dan Markel.
For complete coverage of the Dan Markel case on Tallahassee.com, visit bit.ly/2VEOtZB.
For more Tallahassee news, follow the Tallahassee Democrat on:
Facebook: bit.ly/2qBpPbU
Twitter: bit.ly/2rFeD2b
Instagram: bit.ly/2n5JnIJ
These lil boys will grow to resent every member of that family.
Bingo
Yes agreed, later in life when they become adults and they look into the hit on their dad. I suspect though, that the ex wife, her brother and their parents, will never confess. Very sad. If my dad was murdered, I would never ever leave one stone unturned.
There is a lot of lawyers and cops getting free dental care in the Miami area.
What a despicable group of people. It is frightening to think these people walk among us.
Eric Standefer exactly
I wonder if heaven's got a ghetto
In all socio-economic classes.
They do walk among us. And they include lawyers, money managers, and even opportunisticly-appointed judges among them. Would only that the FBI made public corruption its highest investigative priority, scams to defraud families - and wipe up the evidence of a crime with a final ‘‘hit’ if necessary - would not be allowed to happen. Sad that such crimes, in progress, fall on deaf ears when they are reported. Sad that the FBI does not take such matters seriously enough to follow-up on, when lives are at stake.
When will Wendi Andelson's mother be arrested and charged with paying for this crime. I read that she paid for it and nothing has happened to her. I knew that she had something to do with this coward, evil crime, the second I started watching 20/20 on ABC.
I don't understand how she hasn't been charged already. There has to be a reason behind the scenes for why
@Elite Soulfly : Correct. Knowing that someone is guilty and proving it beyond a reasonable doubt are two different things. The state, however, can try her (Magbanua) again since the jury could not reach a conclusion as to her guilt.
Come on now... juries differ, for example some juries have hung on a certain case and then the next jury has found the person guilty or acquitted, yet it's pretty much still the same case... I see what you're saying but you must see my point as well... just a certain makeup of a jury, say there were more men or old people (which would be more inclined to want to believe in a female's innocence) are on this particular jury, which I don't know if it was the case or not, they probably felt like this little kitten couldn't have done what she accused of... yet she's the link between the family and the guy that pulled the trigger... like I said am I missing something, how can they find him guilty and her not when there's not even a link between the victim and the murderer if she doesn't exist in this equation.. I don't understand why the jury voted the way they did... put it down to excellent jury selection from the defence and the prosecution really hit out on this one
Daijahrel B money...
@@JimInTally i believe judge set trial date for next yr i believe Mar or April
For 50k and a pair of fakes…. Good god what a waste
Katie is a complete liar when she states she thinks that Dan was in a car accident. UNBELIEVABLE
Could Katie explain the thousands of dollars she received from the Adelson? Certainly it was not for a car accident that never happened.
I am sick & tired of this case. All the parties involved truly deserve each other.
She is 100% guilty/involved.
When the attorney asks her if she had anything to do with he murder... she says no, but nods up and down a big YES. They have her on phone conversations with that other scumbag charlie.... she was the connection! ugh these guys make me sick.
Yeah I just went back and checked that out...she nods yes on the second question about hiring someone to do the murder.
@@samanthaclaw If you watch during her other yes or no questions, she shakes her head when her answer is no.
What’s the timestamp please I missed that
@@1Life2Live007 pretty much the beginning, 1:50
Wow ur right she did nod
I believe that Katie was promised by that Adelsons that if she doesn't reveal anything about them that the entire Adelson family will take care of her 2 kids for their entire life if she keeps quiet.
I agree
Money really talks.
Should've taken the plea deal
@@iamkayhud I agree; however I suspect that Katie fears for her life if she tells the truth about the Adelsons.
No. You're giving these morons way too much credit. This cunt doesn't fucking care about her kids. She's never cared about them. Why else expose them to all this violence? Why have a kid with a gangster to begin with? Because she only cares about herself. She was thinking about the money. That's literally it. Nothing she does is for her kids that's preposterous. You're projecting your own emotions onto someone who thinks differently than you
I used to be very close to katie, she is a sociopath and would mentally manipulate tuto and use Charlie’s wealth to taunt tuto into doing whatever she wanted and poor tuto was actually a nice guy he was just a sucker for Katie and Katie is just a sucker for herself and money.
Yeah you can definitely tell she's an extreme sociopath from this. Her and Charlie deserved each other
I feel sadness for their kids. I hope one day that Tuto talks and gives his perspective of what occurred with the “how, when, and why.” It seems to be manipulation was used by many of the Adelson’s. Money can bring out the worst in people.
How could they be so stupid and think they gonna get away with it? I guess they don't watch crime stories.
Unconsciously nods yes if she has anything to do with the murder
No, there is a massive difference between men and women with head nodding. It's body language. When men nod it's in agreeance, when women nod it's in understanding what you are saying. I am not defending her, but this is a pet peeve I have between men and women and our differences. And men always assume if it's what they think it's what all people think.
Each time she said, "no ma'am" she nodded her head "yes".
It actually is an indicator, look into it.
Looked like to me she was affirming and emphasizing her answer.. Not saying she's innocent at all. But, that movement doesn't prove her guilt, I believe her actions prior are indicative of guilt.
@Philip Tucker ...Body Language Bro.
Never seen a case botched worse than this one. You have phone recordings of Charlie Adelson, you have Katie on your payroll and she doesnt work for you. He couldn't be more guilty!
Its the kinda case you get a "special prosecutor" or risk losing it for ever!
#Florida
Not botched . $ changes everything
did u not see the o j simpson trial!
@@Dudj3 yep. Home of the mentally challenged
She's the connection between the criminals and the family. Her life is screwed!
unbelievable isn't it. She is found not guilty but he is found guilty when she is the obviously link between the two. WOW!
Poor kids of theirs omg. Both their parents are criminals. Sooo tragic😓😓😓
@@daijarel he was found guilty bc circumstancial evidence tied them in plus his accomplice confessed.
She on the other hand hasnt been evidentially connected by the prosecution so we're left with what would be hearsay in a court of law.
Its not whether shes connected or not its whether it can be proven infront of 12 jurors
@@benzocorbynista3321 I bet you are related to her, good on you for sticking up for her. You and I both know you can't have one without the other, there was no phone calls or connection between her estranged de facto and her bosses ex brother-in-law/ son-in-law, so making the connection it's just logical. She was very lucky because again you and I both know different jury could have see the same case and come up with a completely different result.
@@daijarel
Hope youre not a betting person, you wouldve lost $$$$. The allegation is uncalled for and unduly insensitive given its a MURDER case for which the shooter(s) and not ALL the 'killers' have faced justice. Only the "killers" benefited from the act and none of us deserve to be unfairly associated with them w/o evidence.
You missed the word "EVIDENCE" in my post and that makes the difference in interpretation.
By EVIDENCE I mean whats admissable in a court of law. We all have our opinions of what we think happened or how the dots join up (court of public opinion) but theres a different threshold in positing this as EVIDENCE in a court of law.
Rivera pled guilty and confessed bc there was cctv EVIDENCE against them...
Sigfredo was found guilty bc there was powerful witness testimony (Rivera)= EVIDENCE and he was a passenger in the car caught on cctv=EVIDENCE
Katie was 10-2 mistrial most probably bc there was neither enough EVIDENCE to convince 12 jurors nor a witness tying her to the conspiracy. FACT unless you have proof otherwise. Had there been a witness or cctv evidence she would most likely have been convicted.
I'm sure you and I will agree that stating a legal standpoint is different from exonerating or siding with anyone, its simply opinion underpined by legal principles.
Question:
Are you also suggesting the jury were "sticking up for her" when they failed to reach a unanimous verdict?
Put her in jail and dont let her out!
J K I agree.with the rest of people who is accountable for the death of a good father!
I feel sorry for kids. They will never know their father's parents. No telling what they were told about their dad.
Thank god there is the internet and his job at fsu so when they get older they’ll know the truth about their dad
haa haa haa...she didn't approve of Stephanie being around her kids because she's a stripper? She testified that she was basically doing the same thing.... I laugh at hypocrites
A bottle girl and a stripper are definitely two different jobs . Don’t judge someone just because of the way they dress. There’s other jobs that require you to dress sexy and provocative and it’s definitely not only stripping. lol
@@YelenaBlanka fair enough
Katherine Magbanua SUDDENLY looks as 'innocent as an angel' in her appearance here, as to how she normally looked before she became a suspect.
😂🤣
How did she look before you decided she was guilty like you wanted take her home with you have a good night don’t be a hypocrite you don’t know for sure wha5 has happened
watch how she nods “yes” when she answers “ no”. she’s lying
The Adelsons should be carefully watched and investigated...
Looks at this chick! She’s dressed like a librarian. Totally don’t different than before. Smh
that's not how the librarian dress now!...
Ikr. Like jodi arias and casey anthony 🙄
Never seen a librarian with D cups!
Catherine you maybe can get away with this murder conspiracy but i assure you the real trial is waiting for you😡😡
If she's smart she'll turn on the Adelsons, before her re-trial. "Bottle service"? That sounds dirty.
I totally agree w you
estelle patella unfortunately she is not that smart.. she saw a big cash lining up. I hope she goes to jail along with the people involve in this case!
Clus say it all time. U either by liquor at liquor store or get bottle service, clubs, bars, restaurants!!
She's gone from Gansta to Librarian 🙄Tell me what is her attraction?
She was used and dosen't even see it. None of the family is in jail...
She is not nervous it is all drama! She was not nervous killing someone child and a father
Clearly Charlie Adelson has a TYPE, likes to prey on the VULNERABLE🤦♀️
27:00 that shows what type of person she is. What kind of caring mother would leave their kids in that moment, with a upset, aggressive father.
Jennifer Mullins that’s exactly what I was thinking. I have kids and I would of got my kids right away
I knew her very well for a long time she was a sociopathic mother and would leave her kids with random people to go party.
A terrible one. I'm glad this bitch is in jail so maybe her kids might have a fighting chance but I have a feeling she's already fucked them up for life
What ever the case are.He's still the father of those kids.Those kids never get to decides wether their dad should die or not.Their dad the brilliant law professor.....
That's sad that she had to think a while when she asked her how old her kids are? Also the prosecutors reaction when she said she went to college. Like a girl like her couldn't have a college education? Smh
How do you have a college degree but work as a receptionist at a dental office??
It's a online degree in throwing the pussy at Doctor's
Water bottle, their are people with degrees who work at McDonald's.
@@nopoliticanti-beaufsmythos3037 she loved him long time !
@@jazzyp5169
She smoked his cigar longtime...
@@ronblack2700
How long you work at Mc Donald?
She is a definite threat to the Adelsons. She cld change everything in this whole case.
Katie’s lawyer like chalk on the blackboard
Didn't she have bills to pay and had all that money left and no benefits for her kids none of it makes sense I think there is enough evidence to charge her
There is more then enough evidence on here what's wrong with that jury
@@josephinecoale7204No there is not. Just speculation. Crazy that some jury member voted guilty.
I don’t understand why she doesn’t just tell them the truth…that the Adelson’s hired her to murder Dan. She would get out of jail the next day in all likelihood.
Charles was arrested on Thursday in Fort Lauderdale
Why haven't the in laws been charged?????
Why would lawyer even bother asking Katie if her & Wendi Adelson had any detailed conversations. Does lawyer actually believe that Katie would ever admit that her & Wendi conversated. SERIOSLY daaaaa!
Sounds like a real Einstein.
After hearing her later admissions it is remarkable how well she lies.
Attorney: "andddddddddddd, OK, let's move forward to 2014..." Me: Phew
Jeeez!! 22 longest minutes ever!!
The lack of ever feeling real punishment makes people think they can do anything. It's not exclusive to people in wealth and power. I don't wish punishment on anyone but it's as if some time in jail with some of the real hardcore criminals can wake people up before it gets to this point of trying to commit murder. It's as if some pain can be good for you to prevent this. IF you've never had your freedom taken away, had to make ramen crap noodles (and think of that as a huge ass luxury) you never really know how special freedom is until it's been taken away. There are obviously other ways, not everyone tests the boundaries but... yeah. Learn from others mistakes guys
Dear lawyer you dont really believe that Katie would be open & honest & tell all viewers about her conversations w Wendi. She is NOT going to reveal any pertinent info. and we all know this.
She is admitting to tax evasion on the stand. Couldn't she have taken the 5th on those particular questions?
She's a stupid girl.
Admitting that only would benefit her case. She’s trying to say that money she has is saved cash from tips, not being payed off.
She admitted to it because, as the prosecution noted, the statute of limitations has passed on that crime so she can't be prosecuted for it.
Yea is she stupid..they r going to get her for tax evasion..but back then people werent claming tios that came out later that they wanted to also charge ur tips.with thise tips u were making some money, now oaying taxes on those tios ur back to square one. Fkn govt cant let u have a penny meanwhe these big ass companies know all the loopholes.
@@juniorlabelle123 in a sense of she had more money she could say it was from work and not from anyone giving her extra cash for a crime job.
Lied right from the 1st question......
Why even bother asking Katie these ???s she isn't being truthful @ all. Sorry I know you have to ask, it's just sooo very difficult to hear Katie totally holding back all pertinent information..
First two questions, she answers no but nods yes. Telling.
Katie is only focusing on Charlie going off on talking tangents, and remembers this oh so very well, but cant remember any of the pertinent details to the murder. Come on this is disgusting Katie.& lawyers. Can we please move on it's almost 6 yrs.
I have a question, where did the information come from to know the decease car type, number plate that is fact.This informarion not been put into the equation.
You don't go and kill someone without knowing all the facts.
This women had her part to play , it the information that hasn't been considered the car information to do the hit, you don't travel from another state to do a hit without a price tag for it and where the money coming from to do this hit, the source of supply, the motive for the hit.
please call juan martinez to put some pressure on Wendi Adelson. She and Jodi Arias have a lot in common..
The dots seem all connected, so why is Charlie and company(family) still free? She admitted she was involved with the dentist, and the dentist was the brother in law to the professor that was killed by her baby daddy... what am I missing???!!
Some actual proves maybe?
Exactly. It seems completely cut and dry to me. I’m not sure why the jury was deadlocked in this trial.
Oh dear god, now I need to look up the dentist. Why would "the dentist" be prospecting someone like this defendant way under his league. She's sketchy!
He had a particular type. He seemed to have a preference for Latina/Asian American women. Katherine is Filipino.
When people don't believe in God or the hereafter they tend to selfishly pleasure themselves in this life. Taking a life to some means nothing. But In my opinion this family have not gotten away with anything...Karma is real and so is Judgement Day!
She could made a plea deal, got less years and bring that family down with her. But she is so stupid by protecting that family.hopefully they will be arrested soon.
She isn't protecting them but they must be doing something for her family that outweighs the prison time she is looking at.
i surprised i am actually enjoying this. i would be watching part 2
She is lying through her teeth. In every response she says "I believe so, I can't remember"
Katie can give u all the details about her side jobs, ALL THE DETAILS, TOO MUCH yet she cant remember any details related to the murder knock it off Katie
What a horrific joke Katie.
Charlie did not screw and buy implants for this "librarian" looking woman..............lets see REAL KATHY
It’s normal for them to lie. They don’t know when they are lying , it’s a truth or a lie. So obviously what may be a lie might just simply be a truth to her in her mind.
This lot are so busy !!!! Hardly have time for CHILDREN , DATING clubbing , club Working / exotic dancing , dealing , lawyering , dentistry , travelling wow
DRESSING LIKE A SCHOOL GIRL AND WEARING HAIR BRAIDED AND GLASSES DOES NOT A MURDERER HIDE
What??? Speak english.
Does anyone know if they are still investigating the Adelsons? If not, why?
Yes, their still under investigation. I’m from Tally, TPD will not stop trying to get justice. No one would roll over on the Adelson’s, either because of gang repercussions or because the Adelson’s set up her children for life.
@@jenn_gulf_coast4644 Thank heavens! Hope this will be sooner than later.
Her taken the stand is the biggest mistake of her life and why did this looney attorney Kawass. Clown should have told her don’t do it your not a good lier!
She says,” no” while shaking her head “ yes”. 1:50
I wonder if the police have maintained any kind of electronic surveillance on all these players bank accts to watch money movements, thats likely the only way they tie the Adelson's to these crimes
this woman's taste in men is extraordinarily bad
The re-trial has been postponed to February 14th 2022.
This was one of the worst attorneys Katy’s has!!!
This school marm looking manipulator and equally strange sounding attorney did the jury buy this package NO WAY
If she is lying, at least 3 people knows she is lying.
"Were you living with him?". Yes "Who else lived there?"...."my mom". 😔
She’s not the victim they was part of a murder for hire
I bet katherines hair and glasses weren’t like that when periodontist asked about her.
Accidentally this girl will vanish. The Adelson’s will do so.
Wow!
You can clearly tell she's lying she couldn't even look had her bbd in the beginning, also she didn't know what car he drove then states what car he pulled up in... Smh!!
Katherine remains in jail, charged as a co-conspirator, and her retrial is scheduled for April 13, 2020
Good. God is not sleeping. Justice will be served.
Her retrial had to be postponed until 2021 due to COVID19. As far as I know, the official trial date for 2021 hasn’t been released yet. But I’ll be keeping a close eye on it. If anyone knows the official 2021 date, let me know! 🤞🏽
October 4 2021
Guilty
her attorney allowed her to knowingly commit perjury on the witness stand
How come so many americans say ”aks”/”aksed” instead of ”ask”/”asked”?
Cause they're fucking idiots.
Look up Ebonics
Usually it's "axe". We are far down the list education wise. Unfortunately.
Every country has their own accent, thats how u can tell. Latin people have a problem with that small pronounciation.
Katherine’s lawyer is Jamaican not American. It’s common and quite natural for Jamaicans to say “aks” not ask - especially when speaking in patwa.
Can anyone tell what Magbanua female lawyer accent is from??
She is Jamaican (from Portmore, Jamaica).
I am not sure when she immigrated to Florida. She received her law degree from Florida International University College of law in 2007.
so basically Sigfredo didn’t know he was committing a murder for his arch enemy Charlie Adelson ??
is she a filipina?
She is by her accent.
She's arrested driving Charlie's Lexus 🙄
She starts out lying!
“She didn’t have the luxury to go out whenever she can” ... and there we have the motive.
Always Florida.
Look how much better her brain works than of Wendi’s the attorney. She can even remember.
Wendi will get payback, her boys will grow up and put this whole thing into perspective , they too will be wealthy and brainwashed they will find out that they were robbed of a father and all his successes and wealth . They will have their own views and separate themselves from the Adelsons
Her memory, like Wendi Adelson’s, is very selective.
Katie was informed by Wendi that her divorce terms aren't working out for her. Ms. Lawyer you said "if I axed you" poops!
She's a Filipina
Wat wud be the 2 guys motive for killing him other than money?! They wont kill him for no reason. Who will benefit from his death?! Didn’t the other guy already told police that it was wendi who ordered the hit?!
What a detailed lawyer
Michael Far...yes she is. I like the fact that she built that time frame.
Lawyer said axed him???
Lawyer sounds IRISH ☘️
Katherine played both sides of the criminal fence. She was messing around with two different type of criminals...Katherine is not innocent!!!! She could have gone to the police and prevented the Professor from getting murdered. She is just as guilty as the actual murdered.
I can't remember my kid's father car 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 what the fu pppppppppppopiiiippppp jock
I can’t believe this girl is even on trial such a shame only in America 🇺🇸
everyone keeps saying that she's not talking because they probably promised her to take care of her family .. if that's the case they had to have discussed this after she was arrested which should be recorded in jail house calls no ?
I found Luis somewhat believable. He never waived from the attacking attorney. I'm not a gangbanger but man that would be me.
11:30, that lawyer from the back
This woman is a liar. She is the connection between her no good husband and the no good dentist. The wife knew all about it too.
I have to imagine they are going to take good care of the kids so she doesn't flip. They offered her immunity to testify against the family and she won't do it. Or she is gambling on another hung jury and the Prosecution drops it and sneak her way out of it.
Apple Tartin I can’t believe it was a mistrial 😒 Garcia and her trial together was too confusing. The next trial won’t be combined since Garcia was convicted . Hopefully the next jury can focus on her and convict.
@@TarDan20 At this point I wonder if the brother was just very cagey and never actually asked her to do it. But just heavily implied it and she picked up the cues. Thinking If I do this for him he will take care of me and my kids. Along the lines of what Joey Buttafucco did to Amy, he never told her to kill his wife. But went on and on how he can't divorce. But if something happened to her he would marry Amy in a heartbeat. It was a lot of manipulation on desperate women. So she can't really testify that they conspired together. The biggest problem is the DA can't link it together. Other than she got a cushy paid job, never had to go into work and do anything. That's the only link I can see. And I don't think they can touch the ex-wife, and parents there is no proof of her involvement. And they have the money to mount a massive defense.
What is that strange accent of the woman who is doing the questioning?
Its not that strange. Sounds a little like shes cuban (cuz lots of cuban florida) or guyana, or west indies
@maggie millican well thats not a latin name..sounds like indian name.
Magbanua is a Filipino surname
at first it sounded hispanic but hearing her talk more, it sounds kind of jamaican or some type of carribean accent