JustTheVoice this video for me is soo.... NO. Rihanna with miley? Christina, jessie and jennifer highe than jojo and kelly?? Beyonce without a star??... No.. Please react to beyonce resentment live 2018 on the run II ua-cam.com/video/ariHxJV9HtU/v-deo.html
Yonce & Mimi: I'm not sure about Beyonce when compared with the Trinity (including Celine). I know her insane melismata but not sure about her overall technicality and musicality. The author of the rating actually addressed this issue of why she doesn't match up with those at the star level in the comment section. You may check that out.
@jocriss it's not only about belts. When it comes to technique Lara is superior, with belting it's a fair battle, but Celine wins on everything else: lows, head voice, agility, she's just more complete. Lara is a beast tho
@jocriss lara more operatic?! Dude listen to Celine's head voice runs and riffs, most of them are in the Celine, Mariah and Whitney riffs and runs video. Lara is a mezzo she could never pull off those runs.
@jocriss Celine. She has slayed so many operatic runs that Lara with her kind of voice could never do. Celine is way more agile naturally for her vocal fach whether you like it or not.
She can’t blow anyone. She strains above D5, has unballanced mix, raises larynx and has nasality. She is not on the league of Beyonce and Lara, for example.
JustTheVoice you are 100% right with all you said. Especially about Celine. She can outclass anyone in her area. And that she deserves a spot in the vocal trinity is even more clear to me when I see how her level this days is. She is still going stronger and stronger and still is able to sing songs from the early 90s effortlessly.
Celine is always the one that get the short end of the stick! She's always underrated when it comes to her technique. I mean folks the proof is in the fact that she can still sing many of these people under the table even not in her "prime". Plus singing is more than just being able to "resonate" it's about portraying a feeling not just producing notes!
Actually the job of a singer is to make the person listening to them feel some kind of an emotion through their performance of the song it's not just all technique. Yes! technique plays a major role but if the singer doesn't evoke something in listener then what's the point?! We might as well remove the human aspect from it all together! Have auto-tuned robots that always hit the perfect notes. It's all subjective anyway! What I feel or like you might not It's all a matter of opinion.
In my honest opinion, ain't nobody does back-up vocals like the way Lisa fisher does and Mariah Carey! Could you imagine those 2 on a song doing harmonies back in 95 😍😍😍😩 that's the definition of *HEAVENLY VOCALS*
Agree about Céline Dion, and I’m still waiting for a reaction of Florence Welch, because she is well underrated and unknown for her talent. Please react to You’ve got the love, at the Royal Albert Hall.
The pitch might not be there and her lower register while improving still needs work. but at the end of the day . . . That woman has top tier vocal stamina & agility. Top tier breath control, the level at which she can sustain notes is insane. Top tier vibrato, it's an uncontrollable force. and that falsetto knows no competition. She has vocal color and textures that really just provide a lot of " Unf " Some people sing like a storm, but she is a hurricane and a modern legend for rock music.
I 110% agree with you on your opinions on Celine Dion! As always, criminally underrated. Her musicality surpasses EVERYONES on this list and I do mean everyone's and her vocal stamina rival's Patti's and Barbara's. She should definitely be higher up and I also love that you know, understand and appreciate the one, the only, Lisa Fisher! She's two thirds of the vocal trinity in ONE singer lol.
Criminally underrated is giving her B-. But yeah star is fine for her too. A+ and star are very close and calling that criminally underrated...come on.
@@justthevoice4529 she's like a mixture of Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey! 😍 You should react to Luther Vandross live performances and listen to those harmonies!!! Lisa was not playing around 👀💁
It’s absolutely criminal where the original uploader has put Celine on this list. What a ridiculous un-informed ranking. Whether Celine is to your music tastes or not, there is not denying she should at least been top 3. I’m not sure there’s a singer alive who’s qualified to even judge the mastery that Celine possesses. Archi whatever he’s called really needs to check his own ratings 😂😂😂😂
Richard S "failing" is an overreach. They have weakness but failed, nah. Whitney has lows (inconsistent). Mariah has headvoice (underdeveloped) and so as Celine with belting past Eb5.
i just dont see why,either.even know he hates Celine,but that fact is she's a legenday vocalist,he must put her in the place that she should be.
6 років тому+74
I'm starting to think Archiduc De Belgrade has something against Celine, since it ain't the first time he'd make these kind of videos where Celine gets belittled in a "subtle way".
Dont agree about faith and adele i have seen faith also with less consistancy than adele.. obviously celine should be more upthere.. agree she always gets less credit in his videos ..but do agree its better list but
*Thank You for You the reaction, I m very glad that You overall liked it, I do agree that Faith could be higher, as for Celine its not like I gave her a B-, but why not she could be a star, even by listening now it goes better and better vocally, different strokes for different folks, I have lot of comments that Katy sould be A+, ,most problematic in my video by many is Beyonce not getting a star, what do You think about that?*
I think he definitely agrees with Beyonce not being a star vocalist. He adores Beyonce as a vocalist but I noticed that he didn't make a correction about that.
Beyoncé not being in the star category is probably the most glaring, and insulting, "mistake" in your video. I agree about different strokes for different folks, I personally would NEVER put Sohyang in the star category because of her weakass low register and muffled lower chest voice. Maybe you should've made it clearer that ranking was not based at all on people's vocal abilities and technique but on your own taste. You kinda mixed both and it ended up being a hot mess.
It's always interesting to see "vocal critics" like Archiduc De Belgrade trying to downplay and slight Céline in almost all his videos and stating that she doesn't belong amongst the best in the industry. But then again, when the real people and legends from the music industry itself praise her, it contents me that it doesn't matter what some random guy on the internet says about her. Thanks Adam for pointing out that she deserves to be in the so-called "Star Category" of this list and love how your critique is on point and objective
Bey basically has the perfect technique than anyone else in general there. She actually deserves to be higher because the two that you mentioned have "bad performances" something that you will never find on Bey
Man, you actually reacted to this one! I've watched that clip before and yes that's more accurate. I believe, as I've stated on that page as well, Barbra, Lisa, and Rachelle Ferrell (still this list doesn't include this vocal beast) should be the "Technical Trinity" in pop for their almost always flawless performances. They deserve the star. The Vocal Trinity members come next with Lara. I'm not sure about Aretha - whether she should be with Barbra (or Patti). Besides, Minnie Riperton is another woman that deserves a place here, but I'm not sure about her overall level other than her insane super head voice (or whistles occassionally).
You try to advertise her awful song. Her single will flop. It won't reach TOP 40, probably not even TOP 100. You can GTFO if you want to. She is history - accept it! It is too late for her!
Reijo P. Well Mariah's not even trying. She's just putting out album for her fans and for the fact that it's her passion. Well if you have 19 number hits under your belt, you won't be bothered in the slightest way of flopping nowadays. She's experienced the musical peak that nobody will ever surpass.
Welcome to church on a Thursday! I pretty much agree with your opinion's, the travesty that was the first list you reacted to actually angered me! Hon, there's nothing about Lisa Fischer's voice that isn't on another level, she's way times infinity overlooked! Ann Wilson, Patti Labelle, Barbra Streisand, Jennifer Holliday...all my favorites, of course some of my ratings would be different but I'm happy to see some of the older artists that normally don't make these list's finally getting the respect due them, so kudos! Riddle me this, why is it that of the vocal trinity Celine, who in my opinion is the most consistent is also the one most underrated? I can't understand how certain people aren't getting it! The elasticity of Celine's voice (even to date) is crazy good, that in and of itself allows her to do things that 99% of vocalists working today can NOT do...boggles my mind! I must say I'm getting pretty tired of Celine being cheated out of her just due!
ilas everglade Jojo being below Tori and Tori being over Jojo is definitely arguable. In terms of consistency, tori is more consistent due to Jojo being very susceptible to sickness. Everything else is pretty much subjective.
I disagree, not talking about technique she's very consistent with her live vocals. She also outsings her studio vocals a lot of times and she can SANG
well,ppl can say they love Selena,i dont mind that but if they say she's a "singer" i would be annoy already,not even need to say shes a good singer LOL.
I'll be honest I don't know shit about music other than banging my keyboard when I feel like it So when I come across a list like this, as long as So hyang and Mariah are at the very top or just one rank below, I'm good. What comes next is to convince everyone down in the comments how 'objective' the list is Believe me when I say this but absolutely nothing feels better than doing that And I don't know why I even bother with it.... or maybe these are the moments where notions like 'for the good of humanity' were born I wonder
*With the main exception of Celine who should've been in the Star Level* (and the few other things you mentioned ➡ Faith Hill being put higher than Sia & Adele, Miley being switched with Rihanna, this list is quite spot on! P.S. This list isn't simply about technical things like support, lack of strain but things like agility, strength through all their registers, in addition to how well they Excel in their own genres (even ones where they utilize strain masterfully), the emotiveness of their voices to audiences around the world, how hard their songs are for the average person to sing and how the general public/masses regard them as vocalists... Edit: one important factor about the 🌟 list is that they had to completely excel as vocalists with very little to no flaws in addition to revolutionizing vocals in the music industry. (Lisa falls under the former).
I agree! and yeah Lisa falls short compared to the others in the star spot but it's her personal choice to not continue with her career. If she did she would be as popular as Mariah and Whitney in my opinion ❤
Celine Dion! Even though you don't upload as often as before you are still one of my favorite reactors. Can you please react to Dimash new performance in Russia " Sinful passion "? You will hear a different Dimash!
I agree with you in everything - Celine Dion. And I’m adding to your request about Dimash - “Sinful passion” (with Eng sabs) ua-cam.com/video/W9FlDMCo8LU/v-deo.html
SoHyang higher than Celine? SoHayang is not comfortable singing in her lower register. I’m glad Dame Shirley Bassey is there. People always forget her but she is one incredible singer. She’s old now but the clarity and resonance and the overwhelming power is still there.
*I truly dislike this list* , particularly for the fact they put Kelly Clarkson with lesser vocalists such as Christina (as much as I love her) and Ariana. They put Beyoncé and Céline in the A+ category instead of star, but they put Sohyang in that category instead (she's criminally overrated). Additional notes: JoJo and Tori Kelly should be higher than Christina, Ariana and Jessie. I love Leona but even at her prime she was a very flawed vocalist. Gaga and Pink should also be higher than Christina. Sia, Adele and Carrie are placed to high for the flaws they have as vocalists. Lara Fabian belongs in the star category. Barbra is amazing, but a star vocalist? I don't know... PS: I know you said we can't agree on everything, but this was a case of death by a thousand cuts. Too many things that didn't make sense. His criteria for classification was not clear. He overrated some singers (Sohyang) he likes while underrated some that are objectively flawless (Beyoncé). At the end of the day, this list truly upset me. I expected more from someone who claims to know about the technical aspects of singing.
How is Sohyang overrated when over 98% of the people in the world can't tackle her songs successfully. Why should Beyonce be a Star Vocalist; can she sing Mariah & Sohyang's songs successfully. Also how has she revolutionized vocals in the music industry... Plus are you kidding about Barbra 😂 Her technique is literally superior to everyone on the list plus she revolutionized vocals in mainstream music...
I found a Whitney gem a few weeks ago, and I think you would appreciate it a lot. It's I Will Always Love You in 2004 in Bangkok. Specifically, she's wearing a white dress and her arms are up with the mic in one hand. You would really appreciate it, it's amazing for the time it is from.
Awesome video and i agree that some of these female artists should be higher than some but a lot of awesome vocals are included here.. Personal list are Faith Hill, Carrie Underwood, Leona Lewis, and Celine Dion.
Hi there! Highly recommend "Bullfighting" performed by Hua Chenyu on his latest concert. Hua is a talented singer who's specialized in composition and arrangement.He always showcase his particular style in his songs.I've been to his Mars Concert on Sept.8th. It's no exaggeration to say that my heart was deeply shocked when I saw his elaborate works.He showed youth and vitality without reservation in front of audiences, presented a visual feast for us! You'll never be disappointed in his performence!Thx!❤
Miley with rihanna in the samee level?? NO!!! Miley is such a good singer!! Better than rihanna. Faith with sia level??? NO!! P!nk with demi level??? NO!! Jojo, Kelly with arianna level???? NO!! Jessie, jennifer and Christina higher than jojo and Kelly clarckson????? BITCH NO!!! I just can't with this video.... Great reaction!! Please react to Beyonce resentment live in the run tour II (2018)
I'm Totally Agree with this, Lara Fabian deserve the Star P!nk and Kelly Deserve an A+ Jojo and Tori an A Ariana is a A- And Yes, Kelly is better and VERY more Consistence than Xtina.
This list was trash. This guy doesn't know much about vocal pedagogy. he's is just a casual fan. Frankly the original critic of music ratings were far more accurate.
If you fancy delving back in time, three English vocalists whose careers were tragically cut short, two by death and one by vocal chord problems. They mostly sing in a different style than your usual artists but might give you an insight, so it’s like say eating a burger then having some chilled fruit. Anyway, Sandy Denny, listen to “who knows where the time goes”, subtle phrasing. Next, Sam Brown, she can belt with the best. Finally, Nick Drake, totally unique. He made 3 albums before tragically committing suicide.
I don’t understand why this is “more reasonable”. The other one was based on technique not how they sound. They just have different subjects. For example this could’ve been based on melisma and the list would’ve been different
Lisa Fischer!!! Yesss! She is the greatest one hit wonder! lol She was a decided one hit wonder, didn't want the fame just wanted to sing! But that one hit is ETERNAL!!!
The list useless!!! Céline should be at number one! There is so many singers who rank higher than they should! Céline is the best selling female artist of all time and sells tours out in 2-5 minutes! And she not even in her prime any longer.
I just gonna drop my piece and leave. So Hyang should be A/A+ not Star. The original maker of this video could not respond as to why he placed in star, and placed people like Patti labelle, Lara Fabian, Celine Dion and Beyoncé under her. While So Hyang is a great vocalist, the original maker of this video, made it out to down play beyoncé verses mariah's lower register, but couldn't do the same for so Hyang vs Mariah, or So Hyang and Beyoncé's lows. People also try to make this seem like beyoncé has no versatility, forgetting that beyoncé, is versed in operatic, rock, country, emd, rnb, soul, gospel etc. With this downplaying her even further by saying she doesn't have difficult songs like Mariah and whitney and so hyang does. So Hyang maybe alot of things but a star vocalist she is not
I agree! Sohyang should be in A+ because yes she got an excellent technique but she lacks the versatility, agility, lower register and musicality compared to the others in the star spot
@@kingofpop9660 technique is very important in singing but other things such as emotional delivery ( which Sohyang is also good at ) versatility, agility and musicality also are important for a singer/vocalist/artist
@@drewm.2790 sohyang lacks in agility, are u serious? 😂 Omg u. Don't know so hyang, also she sing rap, rock, jazz, opera, gospel and soul, she support C#6 in belt, F6 in HV. For the agility she have like a Wow, go to see I alwais miss u or U raise me up IM2, the agility are not only run and melismas, are vibrato and Dinamics too included in agility
Beyoncé deserved better. She literally has the best technique overall and her acrobatics, consistency,versatility and head voice are insane and she's actually a star rated vocalist. And you see in the list someone like SoHyang there because she can belt for her life.... but her acrobatics and low range are nonexistent so... Btw you can see in the comments in the original video that he doesn't like Bey so
He loves Beyonce but he's right, she's not at Whitney, Mariah and Sohyang's level; we know she can't tackle Mariah & Sohyang's songs successfully. We've seen her attempt "I Will Always Love You" and she conveniently skipped the climax. Are you also going to assert that Adam doesn't adore Beyonce... He obviously does but even he didn't try to assert that Beyonce should be a Star Vocalist.
@@GarageStudio7 SoHyang is NOT a better vocalist than Beyoncé. That's being delusional and beleving the same that says the GP that high notes are a legendary vocalist. I'm talking about the person who did the ratings video
@@jrnj1082 My point is, JustTheVoice (Adam) adores Beyonce yet he also didn't try to correct where Beyonce was placed. An artists' songs' difficulty is a clear indication of how vocally adept they are and Beyonce's songs are nowhere near vocalists like Mariah & Sohyang...
@@GarageStudio7 the person who made the video, based his placement on subjective matters, emotion, tone etc.. He also said that Mariah had better lows that beyoncé (which is one of the reasons he didnt place her there) Using that same arguement, So Hyang lows are basically non existent/barely there/not supported. She has wonderful transition- something that beyoncé is a master of And great upper belt, especially notes that are in her range that aren't in Beyoncé's. I will agree with anybody on whitney and Mariah, but until she So Hyang can do all that they (Mariah and whitney) did, I will never agree with her placement on this list especially above celine, Lara, Patti, and beyoncé
@@GarageStudio7 she conveniently skipped the climax, dude, she doesn't need to sing the climax, especially when it's a mash up of two songs, she sings halo every night, that has a climax that is difficult to sing, especially the adlibbed parts. Come on go look it up. Also Mariah has difficult songs, Whitney has difficult, So Hyang has difficult songs, Beyoncé has difficult songs-and it would be ludicrous to say otherwise.
Hi! Could you please react to Park Hyoshin's Wildflower Live Performance at the PYu Huiyeol's Sketchbook on 2017.07.26? He's a male singer and that is such a emotional performance. I think you'd like it very much!
Avril has a better lower register. ( Though she doesn't use it a lot and I don't know why? ) Regardless maybe that is why? Plus she does have a better falsetto and a pinch more vocal fluidity? Hayley has better pitch and a larger range but idk. I thought Hayley would be higher just because people tend to place pitch and range above other actual skill? I think they should be in the same grade.
They always do Celine dirty! Perhaps coz she's not American and is a Francophone (So, the nasality is at times an issue for others but that's her way to protect the voice. And it has worked very well so far!! But, she can sing without anyway as she did in Divas LIVE) She can do stuff like mimicking instruments, yodels and the longevity is top tier! As the other members of vocal trinity she had: Angelic Tone, Insane Agility, Piercing Belts (Powerful), Range, Head, Falsetto, Lows, Transitions, Versatility & Success!!! Another highly UNDERRATED one here is Tori Kelly! People have a problem with her upper belts times maybe, but the tone is CRYSTAL CLEAR and Angelic!! Especially now that she has been technically improving the UPPER BELTS are at an all time high! She had the lows, the whistles the tone, the range, the transitions, the power, the agility, the consistency! Yet she's overlooked PERHAPS coz she ain't a black singer, perhaps coz she doesn't oversing and shows off (coz people do seem to ignore the musicality in the name of soul a lot of the times) Perhaps coz she LOOKS like a typical blonde and eye candy kinda white singer!! You tell me the prejudices coz reasons don't exist anyway. Let's just break her agility-musicality down here a bit: 1) Complex Runs ✔️ 2) Very Fast Runs ✔️ 3) Creative (Impromptu) i.e. New Things Each Time ✔️ 4) TASTEFUL TRANSITIONS ✔️ 5) Consistent Runs (Not 2 note off have I heard, no sloppiness) ✔️ 6) Musical Restraint (Singers near her calibre in terms of agility, often lose control, sometimes coz they feel it other times to show off!!) At times causes harm to the melody BUT she NEVER does that! Conclusion: Her agility-musicality combo alone is sufficient to put her in the STAR league coz if Shirley Bassey can be there than so can she! Coz she can do stuff that Shirley can (most of it, they are just plain belts objectively speaking) but vice-versa NO CHANCE! Ok if not that then at least at the top of A+ List. Mariah (Daydream) will be my all time fav vocalist with a tone and ease that no one an surpass!! But even Mariah (Aprt from Daydream) has had some off moments and sloppy runs (Before 97) So, Tori purely in terms of Agility is just as good as her or only 2nd to her but NO ONE else on the list. So she really should be at least A+ Lastly Idk, what's the obsession with Belting, like people on the basis of this alone take a singer and put her at the top! While there's so much more there's musicality, enunciation, AGILITY, Dynamics (Vol Control n all) etc But these belting battles just single out the ones who aren't greatest in this area but the greatest overall. The prejudices, biases & stereotypes really need to go. Like here in south east asia the melodic lines are such that the Higher Tessitura suits more! And thick tones were called FAT/Masculine! But in the west it's opposite. We've normalised and given each one their own idk why the west won't?!! Voices like Tori and Celine who are great vocalist but at times put below the rest Physically Hurt Me at this point 😅😂!! Coz of reasons like: 1) Bias of race (If they were black women singing in church and overdoijg the same runs again and at times growling and grunting then they'd be pushed uo higher!) 2) Negligence of nativity: Celine is French that accent appears at time and and go away when she wants it too! (She learnt how) so that shouldn't be a point! She's not bossy or diva-ish so people kinda take her for granted i feel. 3) Dominance of belting and bias against other skills.
Faith Hill is very pitch-y most times. You may have heard the one clip where she sounds good and we only heard a few notes. I'm fairly certain she was shaky in the verses as she usually is. Might look at more of her to make a determination. For my ears, I feel she's ranked higher than she should be.
Love your analysis and I agree. But, I have one question. What was is that you were going to say about jennifer hudson? I feel like your on to something.☺👍🙏
Hello Everyone! What would your ideal vocal ratings be?
JustTheVoice this video for me is soo.... NO.
Rihanna with miley? Christina, jessie and jennifer highe than jojo and kelly?? Beyonce without a star??... No..
Please react to beyonce resentment live 2018 on the run II ua-cam.com/video/ariHxJV9HtU/v-deo.html
JustTheVoice How about Carrie Underwood in Girls Night Out live in Las Vegas. The name of the song is... How Great Thou Art
It was a mess!
Yonce & Mimi:
I'm not sure about Beyonce when compared with the Trinity (including Celine). I know her insane melismata but not sure about her overall technicality and musicality. The author of the rating actually addressed this issue of why she doesn't match up with those at the star level in the comment section. You may check that out.
Ángel Gali:
You're f. right! As a lyric soprano, her power always impresses me thanks to her killer resonance, let alone her other techniques.
“I felt Celine should be with the rest of the Trinity”...the most brilliant observation of all. 👍
Celine is bit lower brilliant than Lara Fabian...
Chris F not true actually
@jocriss it's not only about belts. When it comes to technique Lara is superior, with belting it's a fair battle, but Celine wins on everything else: lows, head voice, agility, she's just more complete. Lara is a beast tho
@jocriss lara more operatic?! Dude listen to Celine's head voice runs and riffs, most of them are in the Celine, Mariah and Whitney riffs and runs video. Lara is a mezzo she could never pull off those runs.
@jocriss Celine. She has slayed so many operatic runs that Lara with her kind of voice could never do. Celine is way more agile naturally for her vocal fach whether you like it or not.
"Incredible set. Beautiful gowns". You just pulled an Aretha 😂😂😂
My sentiments exactly! Chai!
Exactly my thought 😂
Celine is very underrated especially by the Americans, in terms of songs, vocal and her legacy.
Dustin aka dtcsk She isn’t..., that is why she is considered as part of the Vocal Trinity.
I agree with you. Celine must be higher. Nobody like her as you said.
I will never understand why Celine is not a star vocalist...she can blow with anyone on that list
She strains above D5/Eb5
She strains above D5-Eb5. Too heady belts and so on
@@thedivasofsupreme6190 I love Celine, and I like your critics, this is what a critics should be,
She can’t blow anyone. She strains above D5, has unballanced mix, raises larynx and has nasality.
She is not on the league of Beyonce and Lara, for example.
agree with lara but not beyonce
JustTheVoice you are 100% right with all you said. Especially about Celine. She can outclass anyone in her area. And that she deserves a spot in the vocal trinity is even more clear to me when I see how her level this days is. She is still going stronger and stronger and still is able to sing songs from the early 90s effortlessly.
Celine is always the one that get the short end of the stick! She's always underrated when it comes to her technique. I mean folks the proof is in the fact that she can still sing many of these people under the table even not in her "prime". Plus singing is more than just being able to "resonate" it's about portraying a feeling not just producing notes!
Actually you're wrong, singing is about technique. "Portraying feeling" is subjective so irrelevant
Actually the job of a singer is to make the person listening to them feel some kind of an emotion through their performance of the song it's not just all technique. Yes! technique plays a major role but if the singer doesn't evoke something in listener then what's the point?! We might as well remove the human aspect from it all together! Have auto-tuned robots that always hit the perfect notes.
It's all subjective anyway! What I feel or like you might not It's all a matter of opinion.
Nathan Dixon Emotion is subject, I feel Beyoncé better than Celine
In my honest opinion, ain't nobody does back-up vocals like the way Lisa fisher does and Mariah Carey! Could you imagine those 2 on a song doing harmonies back in 95 😍😍😍😩 that's the definition of *HEAVENLY VOCALS*
😍😍😍✨💞
Agree about Céline Dion, and I’m still waiting for a reaction of Florence Welch, because she is well underrated and unknown for her talent. Please react to You’ve got the love, at the Royal Albert Hall.
My favourite singer. Florence Welch
She has a beautiful and unique voice but she's quite often very pitchy.
I wanna hear him react to something from her latest album High As Hope, like Hunger or Big God
The pitch might not be there and her lower register while improving still needs work.
but at the end of the day . . .
That woman has top tier vocal stamina & agility.
Top tier breath control, the level at which she can sustain notes is insane.
Top tier vibrato, it's an uncontrollable force.
and that falsetto knows no competition.
She has vocal color and textures that really just provide a lot of " Unf "
Some people sing like a storm, but she is a hurricane and a modern legend for rock music.
I 110% agree with you on your opinions on Celine Dion! As always, criminally underrated. Her musicality surpasses EVERYONES on this list and I do mean everyone's and her vocal stamina rival's Patti's and Barbara's. She should definitely be higher up and I also love that you know, understand and appreciate the one, the only, Lisa Fisher! She's two thirds of the vocal trinity in ONE singer lol.
P.S. Can you react to the Aretha Franklin tribute on BLACK GIRLS ROCK? It was a great tribute, I loved it!
Not MARIAH
YES Mariah. How did I know an insecure Lamb was going to jump out from the shadows, vomiting their uninformed opinion onto a keyboard -_- ?
Criminally underrated is giving her B-. But yeah star is fine for her too. A+ and star are very close and calling that criminally underrated...come on.
Archiduc De Belgrade But admit it, she deserves a star.
Lisa fisher is a beast!!!!
I'm just honestly glad she's included... she's GOLD!
@@justthevoice4529 she's like a mixture of Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey! 😍 You should react to Luther Vandross live performances and listen to those harmonies!!! Lisa was not playing around 👀💁
@@justthevoice4529 but what you should react to is Babyface *EVERYTIME I CLOSE MY EYES* with Mariah Carey doing background vocals!!!
@@codywalsh2075 I agree! Lisa has Whitney's power in belting and Mariah's transitions but she beats both in head voice in my opinion 💕
@@drewm.2790 not gonna lie there, Lisa does have them both beat in head voice, so beautiful and effortless 😍
It’s absolutely criminal where the original uploader has put Celine on this list. What a ridiculous un-informed ranking. Whether Celine is to your music tastes or not, there is not denying she should at least been top 3. I’m not sure there’s a singer alive who’s qualified to even judge the mastery that Celine possesses. Archi whatever he’s called really needs to check his own ratings 😂😂😂😂
Top 3 is an exaggeration when the likes of Barbara, Aretha, Mariah, Whitney, Lisa are there but she should've been up there with them 😊
Random Person She totally makes up for that in other areas where Whitney and Mariah fail
@@user-el5gh3fd6m Uhmm please what areas would that be?
Richard S "failing" is an overreach. They have weakness but failed, nah. Whitney has lows (inconsistent). Mariah has headvoice (underdeveloped) and so as Celine with belting past Eb5.
It’s only vocal rating it didn’t go in order much when it hits star rated because they are all in their own right the top the vocalists
They play Celine dirty all the time.
i just dont see why,either.even know he hates Celine,but that fact is she's a legenday vocalist,he must put her in the place that she should be.
I'm starting to think Archiduc De Belgrade has something against Celine, since it ain't the first time he'd make these kind of videos where Celine gets belittled in a "subtle way".
Lmfaooooo. It's not his list, it's from the CRITICS OF MUSIC
@@thedivasofsupreme6190 this one is his list
@Ángel Gali GURL, This list is from the CRITICS OF MUSIC see for yourself www.criticofmusic.com/p/blog-page.html?m=1
@@hugooo1788 NO www.criticofmusic.com/p/blog-page.html?m=1
Dont agree about faith and adele i have seen faith also with less consistancy than adele.. obviously celine should be more upthere.. agree she always gets less credit in his videos ..but do agree its better list but
*Thank You for You the reaction, I m very glad that You overall liked it, I do agree that Faith could be higher, as for Celine its not like I gave her a B-, but why not she could be a star, even by listening now it goes better and better vocally, different strokes for different folks, I have lot of comments that Katy sould be A+, ,most problematic in my video by many is Beyonce not getting a star, what do You think about that?*
I think he definitely agrees with Beyonce not being a star vocalist. He adores Beyonce as a vocalist but I noticed that he didn't make a correction about that.
@@GarageStudio7he disagree with like 4 singers which is great I personally really respect his opinion he knows music and singing. 🙂
@@ArchdukeOfBelgrade Exactly! Your video is truly great. The Standoms are the only pressed ones.
Archie, I just wanna say I love you and admire your work! ❤❤❤
Beyoncé not being in the star category is probably the most glaring, and insulting, "mistake" in your video. I agree about different strokes for different folks, I personally would NEVER put Sohyang in the star category because of her weakass low register and muffled lower chest voice. Maybe you should've made it clearer that ranking was not based at all on people's vocal abilities and technique but on your own taste. You kinda mixed both and it ended up being a hot mess.
Toni Braxton and Faith Hill were too low. And I love Adele's music but........................nah
"Incredible set...beautiful gown" You sounded like Aretha Franklin lmao
Definitely agree about Faith Hill needing to be higher. Have you heard her Star Spangled Banner? It's amazing!
I was floored when I heard it... the clarity, resonate, range, diction, and vibrato blew me away!
@@justthevoice4529 Exactly! Completely changed my perception of her. Outstanding singer.
It's always interesting to see "vocal critics" like Archiduc De Belgrade trying to downplay and slight Céline in almost all his videos and stating that she doesn't belong amongst the best in the industry. But then again, when the real people and legends from the music industry itself praise her, it contents me that it doesn't matter what some random guy on the internet says about her. Thanks Adam for pointing out that she deserves to be in the so-called "Star Category" of this list and love how your critique is on point and objective
I also look to see who these experts subscribe to. Says a lot to me.
Wait Beyonce over Chaka and Celiné? I don’t know about that one realllllllllyyyyyyy
Bey basically has the perfect technique than anyone else in general there. She actually deserves to be higher because the two that you mentioned have "bad performances" something that you will never find on Bey
She ain't no Whitney
But Bey's voice isn't even powerful or unique.
jj What does that have to do?
She's not, they're in the same A+ category.
Kelly Clarkson still just grabs my ear and holds on. Just special
Please react to Christina's song "Unless It's With You" from her new album 'Liberation'! 😍😍
Man, you actually reacted to this one! I've watched that clip before and yes that's more accurate. I believe, as I've stated on that page as well, Barbra, Lisa, and Rachelle Ferrell (still this list doesn't include this vocal beast) should be the "Technical Trinity" in pop for their almost always flawless performances. They deserve the star. The Vocal Trinity members come next with Lara. I'm not sure about Aretha - whether she should be with Barbra (or Patti). Besides, Minnie Riperton is another woman that deserves a place here, but I'm not sure about her overall level other than her insane super head voice (or whistles occassionally).
Beautiful lips lmaooooooo!!!!
You try to advertise her awful song. Her single will flop. It won't reach TOP 40, probably not even TOP 100. You can GTFO if you want to. She is history - accept it! It is too late for her!
Reijo P. Well Mariah's not even trying. She's just putting out album for her fans and for the fact that it's her passion. Well if you have 19 number hits under your belt, you won't be bothered in the slightest way of flopping nowadays. She's experienced the musical peak that nobody will ever surpass.
Can you react to- Proof Celine dion is never out of prime? (Posted by celinesvoice channel) 😊
I second this request. Please❤🎶🎶🎶❤
Lisa Fisher and Sohyang 😍😍😍 !!! But Celine go to Star and not A- !!
Welcome to church on a Thursday! I pretty much agree with your opinion's, the travesty that was the first list you reacted to actually angered me! Hon, there's nothing about Lisa Fischer's voice that isn't on another level, she's way times infinity overlooked! Ann Wilson, Patti Labelle, Barbra Streisand, Jennifer Holliday...all my favorites, of course some of my ratings would be different but I'm happy to see some of the older artists that normally don't make these list's finally getting the respect due them, so kudos! Riddle me this, why is it that of the vocal trinity Celine, who in my opinion is the most consistent is also the one most underrated? I can't understand how certain people aren't getting it! The elasticity of Celine's voice (even to date) is crazy good, that in and of itself allows her to do things that 99% of vocalists working today can NOT do...boggles my mind! I must say I'm getting pretty tired of Celine being cheated out of her just due!
"Beautiful Lips" lmao
Ariana was crazy overranked.
ilas everglade Jojo being below Tori and Tori being over Jojo is definitely arguable. In terms of consistency, tori is more consistent due to Jojo being very susceptible to sickness. Everything else is pretty much subjective.
Not really, that petite woman can SANG!
Totally agree
I think so too but maybe she does belong there.
I disagree, not talking about technique she's very consistent with her live vocals. She also outsings her studio vocals a lot of times and she can SANG
Yeah, the list is a mess! 😂 Except The 🌟 singers ;)
Agreed lol
Cody Walsh agreed it’s only missing Celine
Alle TATA If Celine should be there than other singers should too
Daniel Bento yuuuup
Basically tbh
I AM CRINE!!! Did you say beautiful gowns for Taylor? I saw what you did there!!!!
A total slight dig on d down low!
*Great vid as always*
People: “Selena Gomez is a good singer!”
Me: “0:25”
same, she literally started the list 😂
😂
well,ppl can say they love Selena,i dont mind that but if they say she's a "singer" i would be annoy already,not even need to say shes a good singer LOL.
I'll be honest I don't know shit about music other than banging my keyboard when I feel like it
So when I come across a list like this, as long as So hyang and Mariah are at the very top or just one rank below, I'm good. What comes next is to convince everyone down in the comments how 'objective' the list is
Believe me when I say this but absolutely nothing feels better than doing that
And I don't know why I even bother with it....
or maybe these are the moments where notions like 'for the good of humanity' were born
I wonder
I’m here for Miley, Leona, Christina, Kesha, Celine and Mariah
for me Celine,Gaga,Leona,Xtina,Mariah.
Celine is on top of my list. Sorry I really dont care about the others
"Incredible set, beautiful gown"
"incredible set, beautiful gown" LMAO
OMG Sohyang 😍😍😍
I am so happy !
*With the main exception of Celine who should've been in the Star Level* (and the few other things you mentioned ➡ Faith Hill being put higher than Sia & Adele, Miley being switched with Rihanna, this list is quite spot on!
P.S. This list isn't simply about technical things like support, lack of strain but things like agility, strength through all their registers, in addition to how well they Excel in their own genres (even ones where they utilize strain masterfully), the emotiveness of their voices to audiences around the world, how hard their songs are for the average person to sing and how the general public/masses regard them as vocalists...
Edit: one important factor about the 🌟 list is that they had to completely excel as vocalists with very little to no flaws in addition to revolutionizing vocals in the music industry. (Lisa falls under the former).
I agree! and yeah Lisa falls short compared to the others in the star spot but it's her personal choice to not continue with her career. If she did she would be as popular as Mariah and Whitney in my opinion ❤
We gotta remember tamia, fantasia, jasmine Sullivan, Jessica Sanchez, Rachelle Ferrell, brandy
*beautiful gowns* Take one from Aretha's book
Celine Dion! Even though you don't upload as often as before you are still one of my favorite reactors. Can you please react to Dimash new performance in Russia " Sinful passion "? You will hear a different Dimash!
I agree with you in everything - Celine Dion. And I’m adding to your request about Dimash - “Sinful passion” (with Eng sabs) ua-cam.com/video/W9FlDMCo8LU/v-deo.html
I'm here for Mariah Carey 😍😍❤
Prince Clarke I’m here for miss Christina lol
@@tamapajamas I'm here for Mariah and Christina. I love them both. ❤❤❤
Ramon Padilha - I’m much more of a Christina person but both are super talented!
SoHyang higher than Celine? SoHayang is not comfortable singing in her lower register.
I’m glad Dame Shirley Bassey is there. People always forget her but she is one incredible singer. She’s old now but the clarity and resonance and the overwhelming power is still there.
The only thing Celine beats SoHyang in is her lower register, that's it. Let that sink in
So Hyang haters can only talk about her lower register which is just fine. She has improved it in recent years.
@@kingofpop9660 that's true but Celiné 's agility is commendable.
1:19 lol 😆 “beautiful gowns” Aretha shade
*I truly dislike this list* , particularly for the fact they put Kelly Clarkson with lesser vocalists such as Christina (as much as I love her) and Ariana. They put Beyoncé and Céline in the A+ category instead of star, but they put Sohyang in that category instead (she's criminally overrated). Additional notes: JoJo and Tori Kelly should be higher than Christina, Ariana and Jessie. I love Leona but even at her prime she was a very flawed vocalist. Gaga and Pink should also be higher than Christina. Sia, Adele and Carrie are placed to high for the flaws they have as vocalists. Lara Fabian belongs in the star category. Barbra is amazing, but a star vocalist? I don't know...
PS: I know you said we can't agree on everything, but this was a case of death by a thousand cuts. Too many things that didn't make sense. His criteria for classification was not clear. He overrated some singers (Sohyang) he likes while underrated some that are objectively flawless (Beyoncé). At the end of the day, this list truly upset me. I expected more from someone who claims to know about the technical aspects of singing.
Yes Kelly and Lara should definitely be way higher
Sweetie you are very wrong, but that is ok, we dont care
I do agree with everything you said except Barbra...she is definitely a star. Her technique is near perfect
How the heck was Leona "a very flawed vocalist" her main issue was upper belts however she was placed correctly...
How is Sohyang overrated when over 98% of the people in the world can't tackle her songs successfully. Why should Beyonce be a Star Vocalist; can she sing Mariah & Sohyang's songs successfully. Also how has she revolutionized vocals in the music industry...
Plus are you kidding about Barbra 😂
Her technique is literally superior to everyone on the list plus she revolutionized vocals in mainstream music...
Can you please react to that performance of Leona Lewis, her runs are INSANE!
I found a Whitney gem a few weeks ago, and I think you would appreciate it a lot. It's I Will Always Love You in 2004 in Bangkok. Specifically, she's wearing a white dress and her arms are up with the mic in one hand. You would really appreciate it, it's amazing for the time it is from.
"Great set, beautiful gown." 😭
Selenas was totally pitched I saw that performance and she sang EVERY note perfect and her Bb4‘s were perfectly supported
I think they had a lot of things wrong with this video in terms of the range order and I couldn't see what the was writing at the side of the screen
1:39 which Madonna performance of Live to Tell is that one?
Awesome video and i agree that some of these female artists should be higher than some but a lot of awesome vocals are included here.. Personal list are Faith Hill, Carrie Underwood, Leona Lewis, and Celine Dion.
Celine & Toni Braxton should be higher than Adele.
Your reactions are a national treasure
Hi there! Highly recommend "Bullfighting" performed by Hua Chenyu on his latest concert. Hua is a talented singer who's specialized in composition and arrangement.He always showcase his particular style in his songs.I've been to his Mars Concert on Sept.8th. It's no exaggeration to say that my heart was deeply shocked when I saw his elaborate works.He showed youth and vitality without reservation in front of audiences, presented a visual feast for us! You'll never be disappointed in his performence!Thx!❤
Hi JTV; can't wait for your review on GG last performance on AGT. 😍
I mean they ranked Tori Kelly above Toni Braxton...I love Tori but chile Toni can saaaaaang
7:17 Sohyanga♥ :)
Miley with rihanna in the samee level?? NO!!! Miley is such a good singer!! Better than rihanna.
Faith with sia level??? NO!!
P!nk with demi level??? NO!!
Jojo, Kelly with arianna level???? NO!!
Jessie, jennifer and Christina higher than jojo and Kelly clarckson????? BITCH NO!!!
I just can't with this video.... Great reaction!! Please react to Beyonce resentment live in the run tour II (2018)
Yonce & Mimi christina is way better than kelly and jojo, singing is not just belting, thats the only part they win in.
Jaouad Alm OMG you don't say that LOL
I'm Totally Agree with this,
Lara Fabian deserve the Star
P!nk and Kelly Deserve an A+
Jojo and Tori an A
Ariana is a A-
And Yes, Kelly is better and VERY more Consistence than Xtina.
Amore Arusko WTF? Faith is much Better than Sia, for me, even Adele is more Consistency. Sia's Technique is no Good.
This list was trash. This guy doesn't know much about vocal pedagogy. he's is just a casual fan. Frankly the original critic of music ratings were far more accurate.
He is so nice. He just says hmmmm when they suck.
Did he say 'beautiful gown' when Taylor Swift was on the screen?
"Incredible Set, beautiful gown" lol
If you fancy delving back in time, three English vocalists whose careers were tragically cut short, two by death and one by vocal chord problems. They mostly sing in a different style than your usual artists but might give you an insight, so it’s like say eating a burger then having some chilled fruit. Anyway, Sandy Denny, listen to “who knows where the time goes”, subtle phrasing. Next, Sam Brown, she can belt with the best. Finally, Nick Drake, totally unique. He made 3 albums before tragically committing suicide.
Between Amy Winehouse and Annie Lennox there is a trend
3:39 which Faith Hill performance was that?
I love how you go crazy in good voices😂❤️
Ok. We’re not going to look over his shadiness right 😂😂
I get that jessie does a lot of runs and people kinda dislike her for that, but i like her more than aguilera's #sorrynotsorry
I don’t understand why this is “more reasonable”. The other one was based on technique not how they sound. They just have different subjects. For example this could’ve been based on melisma and the list would’ve been different
Because the other one was based on a specific technique instead of accounting for the various technical requirements of different genres...
Lisa Fischer!!! Yesss! She is the greatest one hit wonder! lol She was a decided one hit wonder, didn't want the fame just wanted to sing! But that one hit is ETERNAL!!!
The maker of this video could never defend his position on placing so hyang in star on his video
Are you going to release some covers anytime soon because whew your voice is AMAZING. You have a beautiful gift from god. 🙏🏾❤️
"Incredible set, beautiful gown."😊
"I'm not sure she should be that high to be honest with you."💀
"Faith should DEFINITELY be higher than Adele."😩
The list useless!!! Céline should be at number one! There is so many singers who rank higher than they should! Céline is the best selling female artist of all time and sells tours out in 2-5 minutes! And she not even in her prime any longer.
Incorrect, Madonna is.
•"Should be number 1" is an overstatement.
•"Madonna is the best selling female artists of all time.
I just gonna drop my piece and leave.
So Hyang should be A/A+ not Star.
The original maker of this video could not respond as to why he placed in star, and placed people like Patti labelle, Lara Fabian, Celine Dion and Beyoncé under her.
While So Hyang is a great vocalist, the original maker of this video, made it out to down play beyoncé verses mariah's lower register, but couldn't do the same for so Hyang vs Mariah, or So Hyang and Beyoncé's lows.
People also try to make this seem like beyoncé has no versatility, forgetting that beyoncé, is versed in operatic, rock, country, emd, rnb, soul, gospel etc. With this downplaying her even further by saying she doesn't have difficult songs like Mariah and whitney and so hyang does.
So Hyang maybe alot of things but a star vocalist she is not
I agree! Sohyang should be in A+ because yes she got an excellent technique but she lacks the versatility, agility, lower register and musicality compared to the others in the star spot
Singing is about technique, everything else is subjective. Shes a star and its delusional to think otherwise
So Hyang is definately a Star.
@@kingofpop9660 technique is very important in singing but other things such as emotional delivery ( which Sohyang is also good at ) versatility, agility and musicality also are important for a singer/vocalist/artist
@@drewm.2790 sohyang lacks in agility, are u serious? 😂 Omg u. Don't know so hyang, also she sing rap, rock, jazz, opera, gospel and soul, she support C#6 in belt, F6 in HV. For the agility she have like a Wow, go to see I alwais miss u or U raise me up IM2, the agility are not only run and melismas, are vibrato and Dinamics too included in agility
Beyoncé deserved better. She literally has the best technique overall and her acrobatics, consistency,versatility and head voice are insane and she's actually a star rated vocalist. And you see in the list someone like SoHyang there because she can belt for her life.... but her acrobatics and low range are nonexistent so...
Btw you can see in the comments in the original video that he doesn't like Bey so
He loves Beyonce but he's right, she's not at Whitney, Mariah and Sohyang's level; we know she can't tackle Mariah & Sohyang's songs successfully. We've seen her attempt "I Will Always Love You" and she conveniently skipped the climax. Are you also going to assert that Adam doesn't adore Beyonce... He obviously does but even he didn't try to assert that Beyonce should be a Star Vocalist.
@@GarageStudio7 SoHyang is NOT a better vocalist than Beyoncé. That's being delusional and beleving the same that says the GP that high notes are a legendary vocalist.
I'm talking about the person who did the ratings video
@@jrnj1082 My point is, JustTheVoice (Adam) adores Beyonce yet he also didn't try to correct where Beyonce was placed. An artists' songs' difficulty is a clear indication of how vocally adept they are and Beyonce's songs are nowhere near vocalists like Mariah & Sohyang...
@@GarageStudio7 the person who made the video, based his placement on subjective matters, emotion, tone etc..
He also said that Mariah had better lows that beyoncé (which is one of the reasons he didnt place her there)
Using that same arguement, So Hyang lows are basically non existent/barely there/not supported.
She has wonderful transition- something that beyoncé is a master of
And great upper belt, especially notes that are in her range that aren't in Beyoncé's. I will agree with anybody on whitney and Mariah, but until she So Hyang can do all that they (Mariah and whitney) did, I will never agree with her placement on this list especially above celine, Lara, Patti, and beyoncé
@@GarageStudio7 she conveniently skipped the climax, dude, she doesn't need to sing the climax, especially when it's a mash up of two songs, she sings halo every night, that has a climax that is difficult to sing, especially the adlibbed parts. Come on go look it up.
Also Mariah has difficult songs, Whitney has difficult, So Hyang has difficult songs, Beyoncé has difficult songs-and it would be ludicrous to say otherwise.
Celine and Lara should be as high in this list as the Trinity 😓
Hi! Could you please react to Park Hyoshin's Wildflower Live Performance at the PYu Huiyeol's Sketchbook on 2017.07.26? He's a male singer and that is such a emotional performance. I think you'd like it very much!
Is Glennis Grace one of them? 🎼⭐️
He said beautiful gowns tho😂😂😂😂😂
I love mariah
Can you react to Jennifer Hudson Feeling Good live On The Voice ?! Vocals are insaneee🔥
Avril higher than Hayley Williams?! Is this a joke?
Avril has a better lower register. ( Though she doesn't use it a lot and I don't know why? ) Regardless maybe that is why? Plus she does have a better falsetto and a pinch more vocal fluidity?
Hayley has better pitch and a larger range but idk. I thought Hayley would be higher just because people tend to place pitch and range above other actual skill? I think they should be in the same grade.
I don't know why I am watching some random guy next to his TV. Maybe my life really sucks so much.
XD
WHAT IS THE NAME OF THE LIVE PERFORMANCE FROM ARETHRA’S PART? Please help me out
"Beautiful gown" oh my man! Reminds me of something a certain late Queen of soul said.... 😂😂🤭👌🏼
Is it a natural born thing that you born with a vibrato? I like it when you sing the Beyonce version.
"Love On The Brain" is Rihanna's best performance lol
They always do Celine dirty! Perhaps coz she's not American and is a Francophone (So, the nasality is at times an issue for others but that's her way to protect the voice. And it has worked very well so far!!
But, she can sing without anyway as she did in Divas LIVE)
She can do stuff like mimicking instruments, yodels and the longevity is top tier!
As the other members of vocal trinity she had: Angelic Tone, Insane Agility, Piercing Belts (Powerful), Range, Head, Falsetto, Lows, Transitions, Versatility & Success!!!
Another highly UNDERRATED one here is Tori Kelly!
People have a problem with her upper belts times maybe, but the tone is CRYSTAL CLEAR and Angelic!! Especially now that she has been technically improving the UPPER BELTS are at an all time high!
She had the lows, the whistles the tone, the range, the transitions, the power, the agility, the consistency! Yet she's overlooked PERHAPS coz she ain't a black singer, perhaps coz she doesn't oversing and shows off (coz people do seem to ignore the musicality in the name of soul a lot of the times)
Perhaps coz she LOOKS like a typical blonde and eye candy kinda white singer!! You tell me the prejudices coz reasons don't exist anyway.
Let's just break her agility-musicality down here a bit:
1) Complex Runs ✔️
2) Very Fast Runs ✔️
3) Creative (Impromptu) i.e. New Things Each Time ✔️
4) TASTEFUL TRANSITIONS ✔️
5) Consistent Runs (Not 2 note off have I heard, no sloppiness) ✔️
6) Musical Restraint (Singers near her calibre in terms of agility, often lose control, sometimes coz they feel it other times to show off!!) At times causes harm to the melody BUT she NEVER does that!
Conclusion: Her agility-musicality combo alone is sufficient to put her in the STAR league coz if Shirley Bassey can be there than so can she! Coz she can do stuff that Shirley can (most of it, they are just plain belts objectively speaking) but vice-versa NO CHANCE! Ok if not that then at least at the top of A+ List.
Mariah (Daydream) will be my all time fav vocalist with a tone and ease that no one an surpass!! But even Mariah (Aprt from Daydream) has had some off moments and sloppy runs (Before 97) So, Tori purely in terms of Agility is just as good as her or only 2nd to her but NO ONE else on the list.
So she really should be at least A+
Lastly
Idk, what's the obsession with Belting, like people on the basis of this alone take a singer and put her at the top! While there's so much more there's musicality, enunciation, AGILITY, Dynamics (Vol Control n all) etc
But these belting battles just single out the ones who aren't greatest in this area but the greatest overall.
The prejudices, biases & stereotypes really need to go.
Like here in south east asia the melodic lines are such that the Higher Tessitura suits more! And thick tones were called FAT/Masculine! But in the west it's opposite. We've normalised and given each one their own idk why the west won't?!! Voices like Tori and Celine who are great vocalist but at times put below the rest Physically Hurt Me at this point 😅😂!! Coz of reasons like:
1) Bias of race (If they were black women singing in church and overdoijg the same runs again and at times growling and grunting then they'd be pushed uo higher!)
2) Negligence of nativity: Celine is French that accent appears at time and and go away when she wants it too! (She learnt how) so that shouldn't be a point! She's not bossy or diva-ish so people kinda take her for granted i feel.
3) Dominance of belting and bias against other skills.
Faith Hill is very pitch-y most times. You may have heard the one clip where she sounds good and we only heard a few notes. I'm fairly certain she was shaky in the verses as she usually is. Might look at more of her to make a determination. For my ears, I feel she's ranked higher than she should be.
Can you please do a video reaction of Jotta A Sonda-me!! I know its a old song but Just want to See your reaction😁
1:12 the real ones understand his reference to Aretha's comment about Taylor:)
Thank you. Please react to Dimash's Sinful Passion. Video on his official YT channel with English subtitles.
Aretha is definitely number one. Also Sara Vaughan should've been high on this list. She's always looked over. She's one of the best voices ever.
Love your analysis and I agree. But, I have one question. What was is that you were going to say about jennifer hudson? I feel like your on to something.☺👍🙏
This list is just as messy as the other one. The only thing they did right with this is adding other singers.
Good list, I just have some problems with the A- to A sections...
Beautiful gown, an ever so slight dig my brudda!
You did one of Selena and asked about her vocal range it is D3 - G#5 if you have not gotten it.