I RECEIVED A FAKE ALPHA CARD FROM AN OFFICIAL MTG STORE WITH MY ONLINE ORDER!

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 54

  • @Madster_NL
    @Madster_NL 2 роки тому +5

    I thought I knew a thing or two about spotting fake cards, but I learned a lot in this video and your last one. Thanks!

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому +1

      thanks, maddie, appreciate it! i am certainly not an expert and trust my experience with the look and feel of a card a lot, but when in doubt, there indeed are several things i normally check. but still, certainly not as good in spotting things as some others out there. glad i could give you some inspiration! 👊🏻

  • @ownbey58
    @ownbey58 2 роки тому +2

    Great video and information. As soon as you did the light test my first thought was a reback since more fakes pass some sort light through.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      thanks for the kind comment, really appreciate it! good call, you were absolutely right!

  • @sandrostrapazzon1307
    @sandrostrapazzon1307 2 роки тому +2

    Great video. Keep them up, lots of useful info!

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      thanks for the kind comment, sandro, been at it for a while and certainly will keep it up! 😁👊🏻

  • @petervestifrendrup1307
    @petervestifrendrup1307 2 роки тому +1

    Crazy you don't have many more subscribers. Keep it up! Great stuff :)

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      thanks, peter! ahh, it s not about the amount of subs, but about how engaged they are! and the people we have here are very engaged! 😁👊🏻. thanks for the kind comment!

  • @frankjones4807
    @frankjones4807 2 роки тому +1

    quality content, very helpful!

  • @christhemagnif
    @christhemagnif 2 роки тому +1

    I love Alpha Unsummon because of the weird misprint on it. All the weird idiosyncrasies of Alpha make it a lot of fun to collect.
    Stinks that you got the reback disintegrate. First time I’ve seen a reback alpha. Only ever seen this for betas.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      alpha is simply unique, indeed! i am happy i got a couple of them. but the disintegrate sucked indeed. i will have a video up soon to compensate for that loss, though 😂😜!
      it was the first reback i ever got, but i do not buy alpha and beta a lot. hmm, what weird misprint on unsummon!? 🤔

    • @christhemagnif
      @christhemagnif 2 роки тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt instead of saying ‘enchantments on creature are discarded’ it says ‘enchantments on creature are CARD ed’

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      @@christhemagnif oh, wow! i had not even noticed before! now you have said it is right there in front of me. well spotted!!

  • @timtauber5557
    @timtauber5557 2 роки тому +1

    If it’s a rebacked card it will probably weigh differently. You would need a very sensitive scale. The edge of the card can show a distinct line where the Two separate halves were glued together. But the light test was enough for me.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      yeah, i mention weighing it, you re exactly right. reback should weigh about 185-188 mg and a real alpha card should weigh less, about 174-178 mg. i do not have a sensitive enough scale, but i ll buy one. glue line is not always visible well, in my opinion, if the cards is pressed well. what you do see then is a certain tension or wavyness to the card. but the light test is the easiest to do and often very clear, i agree!

    • @bs1919
      @bs1919 2 роки тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt If it was a second compression on the card when glued, it would make sense that applied pressure would warp the backing thus having the card bend like that.
      It's definetly a reback as some glues may reflect light which I would imagine is the reason why you cannot see the light through it. Super sneaky. In all honestly, I get rebacks but going this far to ensure an accurate replica just screams shady to me.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      @@bs1919 totally agree, B S! the store actually aknowledged that it was e reback, took back the card without a problem and they apologized, so the story ended well! 😁. but i indeed was very surprised to get it from that particular store.

  • @Troglodytemtg
    @Troglodytemtg 2 роки тому +1

    Lol a little drunk turns into the worst decisions hahaha

  • @IPlayMagic
    @IPlayMagic 2 роки тому +2

    I found from my experience that Alpha cards feel thinner and more flimsy or delicate than cards from every other set like a different paper stock or just made thinner or something. Not sure if anyone else found that. Shame you got a reback, I hope the store give you a refund or heavy discount. Also it goes to show that the higher prices usually charged by stores really dont offer guarantee of authenticity. On the plus side super nice fog and unsummon !

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому +1

      i have not experience a thinner card personally, with alpha cards. i need to pay attention to that. and the store already refunded me, no worries! i bought an alpha twiddle there for roughly the same price. and they indeed gave me a small part of my next purchase for free to make up for the mistake. indeed, there are no guarantees, but i still prefer a premium store over a private person, when it comes to old cards. it was the first problem i had with them since i buy there and they solved it without hesitation. that s worth a lot to me as well.

    • @IPlayMagic
      @IPlayMagic 2 роки тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt Good point. Stores almost always guarantee that they will fix the problem.

  • @coachesmagic2886
    @coachesmagic2886 2 роки тому +1

    I guessed disintegrate from the shine, you had immediate concerns. Wonder how that slipped through

  • @brandonsmith-wz6hb
    @brandonsmith-wz6hb Рік тому +1

    The unsummonhas an error says CARD ed on it it’s an error unique to the alpha printing sometimes obvious things can also confirm also beta seems thinnerw

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  Рік тому +1

      thanks for the comment, brandon! it is simple sometimes, if you know the little things to look for! 😁👊🏻

    • @brandonsmith-wz6hb
      @brandonsmith-wz6hb Рік тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt I just had a big one happen. My about me profile has my mtg store details if you want to contact and hear about it.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  Рік тому +1

      @@brandonsmith-wz6hb i think i need to check that on a laptop, because on my mobile i can’t find it 😬

    • @brandonsmith-wz6hb
      @brandonsmith-wz6hb Рік тому +1

      Shipped the cut beta card today. Was a rare so there was still value in an inked beta cut with alpha corners

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  Рік тому +1

      @@brandonsmith-wz6hb alright! which one was it?

  • @brandonsmith-wz6hb
    @brandonsmith-wz6hb 2 роки тому +1

    A better reback and used an old back. Water damage was a possibility

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      thanks for the comment, brandon! yeah, indeed. it wasn t obvious on first glance, but when i took a closer look, it got more and more clear it was a reback. store gave me my money back, so that s oke 😁!

  • @stefanchung23
    @stefanchung23 2 роки тому +1

    The shiny one...

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      yeah, you got it right!! 👊🏻

    • @stefanchung23
      @stefanchung23 2 роки тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt Netherlands has a nice mtg community specially for the old cards. I buy most of my cards from your country. Most people are very flexible not like the germans...

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      @@stefanchung23 yeah, scene here is pretty oke. i used to live in germany and have fond memories of the early days in our local magic shop. scene was great. but every german championship or bigger tournament i have been to showed me that it got more and more toxic. i honestly do not play in stores or at tournaments anymore because of that and keep to playing with my brother and close friends and colleagues.

  • @MattcasterMage
    @MattcasterMage 2 роки тому +4

    First

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      ha, matt 😁! awesome you say hi again, thanks, man!

  • @PaulissVegan
    @PaulissVegan 2 роки тому +1

    did you get them from a vendor on cardmarket?

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      hey merch! sorry for the late answer, but youtube never alerted me about your comment. no, i actually got it from an online store.

  • @blakmajk3512
    @blakmajk3512 2 роки тому +2

    Go destiny!

  • @stefosonager1214
    @stefosonager1214 2 роки тому +1

    did you have to return the card or were you just refunded the money?
    I always find it very unfortunate when I see someone rip off a rebacked card because it's fake. It's still wonderfully playable, and in fact I think it's legal, too, because both, the front and back were once real cards. Crystal clear, you can't sell or trade it in to someone for a real original, but you don't have to destroy it shorthand. It would also be enough to make a legible note on the back that it is immediately clear to everyone who gets the card in hand that it is not an unmanipulated original. As I said before, I like such cards because they give me less worries if a deck is stolen while I'm on the toilet, or I leave my commander in the pub in another city out of sheer luck... Ouch that hurt...

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      hey stefos! i fully understand your point and i personally do not have any problems if someone would wanna use rebacked cards. and i get that it is less of a worry.
      personally i wouldnt wanna use rebacked or fake cards. i do not use proxy’s neither and i do not play with any cards i dont own, even if i need them for a deck. but like i said, i get it and i happily play against people that do.
      i gave the card back to the store, yes. they of course wanted to check if i didnt sell them any BS. i probably would have kept it seperate from my collection to compare rebacks and fakes and such.

  • @jinglejangle77
    @jinglejangle77 3 місяці тому +1

    Red dots?

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  3 місяці тому +1

      yes, on the back of the card in the green circle, if you look at that with a jewelers loope, you can find 4 red print dots in the form of an L. really small, and therfor almost impossible to fake. in the vid you can get an idea at minute 18.00.

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  3 місяці тому +1

      @@jinglejangle77 in this video at 6.29mins you can see it better, jinglejangle! ua-cam.com/video/y3FMRVhdz1Q/v-deo.htmlsi=uEEhdMdmPSaPap_9

  • @cheshire147
    @cheshire147 2 роки тому

    Thanks but even if it was a fake thanks to your video I would know where is the “willow 0/0 creature” alpha 1st edition

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      hey cheshire! thanks for the comment! i am not quite sure what you mean with the willow creature, though? 🤔

  • @MTGAttitude
    @MTGAttitude 2 роки тому +3

    2nd

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому +1

      hey dave! matt beat you to it, this time! 😂. thanks for checking in, man!

    • @MTGAttitude
      @MTGAttitude 2 роки тому +1

      @@NerdAndProudOfIt He did...I'm slipping bro, lol

    • @NerdAndProudOfIt
      @NerdAndProudOfIt  2 роки тому

      @@MTGAttitude haha, all good, man! you re busy with pumping out all these vids and doing charity streams 😜! glad to have you around, man!!