seriously. I was so hoping it would be when tool finally allowed their albums to be on there. I had that repeat button ready to go hardcore during my game session on ps5. lol
I think tool will be remembered by this generation as true music and art in sea of manufactured mainstream music. They have integrity, and their music IS revolutionary. No one can, or ever will sound like them. Not to mention their lyrics are amongst the most profound for any band.
Was just talking with my wife about the power in Maynard’s lyrics. I listen them all the time and hearing them, singing along with them……but when I read the lyrics while listening to the music, that’s when the real power and greatness really comes through for me. I don’t know how to explain it, I’ve been listening to this band since I was in the 7th grade and I turned 45 today and there is no other band that still blows me away like it’s the first time….every time.
…… not to mention Adam, Justin and Danny are among the greats of their respective instruments. Put them all together and there’s not really anything this generation, or those that come after, will ever come close to reaching.
@@dougrippe33 39yrs old here and they have been a profound journey for the past 30 years. I had the privilege of hearing them at the age of 9! yes 9 years old! 1993 was a time that I was entranced, mystified and constantly yearning to hear more. Granted they had underground stuff in 1987 when Maynard was with CAD (Children of the Anachronistic Dynasty). But 1990 solidified this absolute gem of a band. 1992s opiate certainly lit the proverbial fire. However in 1993s undertow absolutely enthralled me lol. Anyhow long story short I absolutely understand what you mean , cheers!
Me too. Salt Lake City tour, was too epic. I'm blessed to have seen Tool multiple times in Utah and Vegas, plus Puscifer and A Perfect Circle both in Utah. I'll pay any price to see Maynard
I'm a hard-core led Zep fan since back to 1969 and I have to say this is a righteous cover....I can definitely get into it....Get out those headphones, crank it up , sit back and follow the trip...
I think I read somewhere, that they were approached to do a Zeppelin cover for an upcoming tribute album. They chose this song. When they turn the finished version in, the producers told them to cut the song by 5 minutes. When Tool refused, the producers told them that they would receive the bill for recording. Tool said fine. Thus this was released on Salival.
@Josh Jordan That is correct. I personally agree with Adam Jones. I'm biased but I don't care. No quarter is too beautiful to be in such a vulgar movie anyway.
I love both versions for different reasons. I don't think it can be said that one is "better". I think people should learn to say, "I like one more," rather than, "One is better."
I always tell people Tool are the greatest stadium rock band since Led Zeppelin.....and having seen them live 3 times in sold out stadiums (live in Australia or it would have been a lot more than 3, they didn't get out here all that often) I fucking well stand by that statement. This cover live is like tantric sex for your earballs....and all your other senses for that matter.
I think this track was supposed to debut on a Led Zeppelin tribute cover album. However, the production guys said to Tool "make it shorter". Then Tool refused to publish it on said album, and it got released in Salival instead. This is the story as far as I know.
@@tnix80 if i remember correctly this one was John Paul Jones' project, his baby, as opposed to most of the rest of Zep's music being Page's. Therefore I would only really care for Jones' and perhaps Plant's thoughts on this cover.
After reading a few comments, I have to point out that I'm a Led Zeppelin fan, and I think this is a lovely version of the song. Both Tool and Led Zeppelin kick ass.
i love the original song, but i feel as if this ruins it. it doesn't have the same feel as the old one. when i first heard the original, i was reading Dune (By frank Herbert). when i listened to this song whilst a book like dune, my brain put them together and it turned the song into an instant reminder of Dune. it might not make sense to you, but i have a special connection between this song and the best book ever written. it seems, to me, almost sacrilege to do this to it. i am very fond of heavy metal and classic rock, but i just cant listen to this cover. i can see how it could be so popular. it is all in the eye of the beholder. for example, 99 problems by jayz. i hated that song, but some guy named Hugo did a cover and it is one o my favorite songs now. sorry for the essay!
i love how they kept the qualities of the original song but morphed it to their style. they didnt copy everything from the song note for note, they put their own twist to it which is awesome.
It's crazy how much they changed the lyrics from the original. So much grittier and darker overall. Phrases like "Close the door, put out the light" and "They're wearing steel that's bright and true" have been replaced with *"Lock all the doors, kill the lights"* and *"Dying dreams in me and you"* . It's like a dystopian 'No Quarter', playing out in the mind of someone who's been broken both mentally and physically.
Tool is always going to be Tool....Zepp is one of the best bands in history, but the fusion between their sound and Tools more elaborate, intricate style is priceless....What a truly visionary band Tool truly are. Hats off.
Tool really helps me when I'm sick. I listened to pushit when I had a fever a couple years back. Now I had the stomach flu, and this poped in my mind. I feel better now. This is also a great song to get stoned to, in your room alone.
Careful, I've come to associate certain albums with feeling sick due to hearing them when I was sick. OK computer and Garbages first two albums make me feel weird if I hear them
This is such a brooding rendition... The guitar conveys such a sense of hopelessness and desperation. So evocative and oh so perfect. Only tool could have pulled it off
To all the people comparing the two versions of this song. Make sure you listen to the entire thing. Tool's cover has an extensive breakdown at the end which completely re-invigorates this song. Led Zeppelin's was the original, and for that respect and acknowledgement is due. But don't let that deafen you to the masterful creation you're hearing. Technically this dwarfs the original, but that isn't worth a dime because we're comparing apples and oranges. The Tool sound is defined by complicated, screeching, melodic riffs and incredible layered drum sequences and poly-rhythms. Versus Led Zeppelin's more rhythmic style, amazing guitar solos and Robert Plants snail trail. Honestly the two bands share a lot in common, Tool has obviously been inspired by Zep to some extent, as has any rock musician in the last 40 years, whether they're aware of it or not.
"Technically this dwarfs the original"... and that is exactly why it sucks!! these guys remind me of a very adept high school band. playing 20 chords were only one is necessary to convey the emotion, the feeling. this isnt even on the same planet as the original. thanks for the laugh though!!
I've always found it weird your have to compare originals and covers in a light. They are in a way different tracks. A cover can easily be better than an original, if you build upon an already amazing track you have to add something. This definitely do. Another great example of a cover done right is Jimi Hendrix All along the watchtower. The original is amazing but it is generally accepted that the Hendrix version is superior. So is this. Open your ears.
racer111259 “ 20 chords?” This song is not played with much technicality besides maybe Danny Carey’s drumming. It’s simple overall but done in a more elaborate way.
First heard this on late night radio about 10 years ago . Wasn't really paying close attention and thought it was Zeppelin until I heard Maynard' s voice. Wow! Great cover!
If they did Dogs, I'd jizz in my entire dresser drawer full of pants. Pigs (Three Different Ones) would probably work better for Tool as a band though. Animals is BY FAR, my favorite Floyd album.
Me, too! I always somehow feel ashamed of that, but TOOL's version is so much more dynamic and complex. Plus, the ridiculously excellent production value makes it that much better!
Saying that the original band smokes the cover version? Not such an original statement. I think the whole purpose of doing a cover is to put your own personal fingerprint on a song that moved or inspired you in some way. Otherwise, what's the point? I like this version. That's my opinion.
well put, lota people in this comment section just wanna compare the two bands/songs when I think it's better to analyze it as a new interpretation. I'm thankful tool doesn't cover any songs 1:1
A few months ago, I went through all of TOOL's discography on Spotify without listening to Salival as it's not on there. I never realized that one of my favorite bands covered another one of my favorite bands! Great song choice, and of course, fantastic cover!
zepp never lets anyone do covers, but even Robert Plant when hearing this stopped and said w00w. Extremely, excessively brilliant! This is very hard for me to say, but i have to accept this as my favorite tool song ever, or at least a tie w push it live
That's a bit rich coming from the band who (apart from the Rolling Stones) owe more of their own massive success to covering/borrowing/appropriating/ripping off old blues standards than any other band ever .. as far as I know this is nonsense anyway because anyone can cover anything, they just have to pay royalties to the publishers of course. I don't know where you get your ideas, but a quick search shows up at least 60 Zeppelin songs (over half their total output) covered by various artists over the decades, with most done multiple times in many different styles .. No Quarter alone has been done about 20 times, so basically you couldn't be more wrong :/
"Ripping off" is the real stretch here. Influence and inspiration is the right term, Timmy. No blues group produce anything like the Zepp. Don't get me started with appropriation because covering a band is more towards appreciation.
Almost all the songs from Zeppelin IV onwards were original. And IV, Houses of the Holy, and Physical Graffiti are their best albums. Re-contextualizing traditional blues songs wasn't anything new. Cream, Hendrix, and many many other bands were doing the same thing. Doesn't make them any less great.
Ive seen them live in holland thanks to my great sister who knew i woud appreciate it if she bought tickets, which she did... and i can say in ONE word AMAZING its one of my most favourite memories...!!
Quite a few years ago I stood in the rain in Camden NJ while Tool played. When it was over I said to my brother that it was bullshit man... over already? He laughed and said bro, they've been playing for two and a half hours. I said I could listen two and a half more... he laughed again and agreed.
Brilliant!!! Zeppelin is my heart n' soul so this is huge for me to accept anybody other then Heart doing Zeppelin... Zep must really respect you for giving u the rights to perform No Quarter. Beautifully done!!!
My grandpa was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer and died two weeks later. I couldn't visit him the last week in the hospital, because of covid restrictions. I played this song over and over and it carried me through that week.
Shows that music is a sincere form of art. They are so talented they blow all the mainstream crap away. Thank you Tool for being original even with vintage classics. Please keep producing quality artwork.
There was once a day, a looooong time ago. Before I had heard of Salival. I was sitting here, on the ole interweb and a thought occurred to me. Tool covering Led Zeppelin would be the most amazing marriage of progressive rock/metal to ever exist. Soon after I was drooling over the Box Set and wishing I had it. I am sure I ended up downloading the track before finally buying Salival (with the VHS btw LOL) Also, funny enough, this was also my intro to No Quarter all together. I agree with you 100%
God damnit this is so gorgeously somber and dark, I loved it since they released salival, and after years and years I don’t think I’ll ever stop loving this sweet melody 🤟🏻
Lyrics: Lock the door, kill the light. no one's coming home tonight. the sun beats down and don't you know? all our lives are growing cold, oh... they bring news that must get through. to build a dream for me and you, oh. Locked in a place where no one goes. They ask no quarter they have no quarter. Lock the door, kill the light no one's coming home tonight It's getting colder (7x) locked in a place where no one goes. Lock the door, kill the light no one's coming home tonight They bring news that must get through. dying peace in me and you Locked in a place where no one goes. We have no quarter we have no quarter we ask no quarter Led zeppelin version Close the door, put out the light. no, they won't be home tonight. the snow falls hard and don't you know? the winds of thor are blowing cold. they're wearing steel that's bright and true they carry news that must get through, oooh They choose the path where no-one goes. They hold no quarter. they hold no quarter. Walking side by side with death the devil mocks their every step the snow drives back the foot that's slow the dogs of doom are howling more they carry news that must get through to build a dream for me and you They choose the path where no-one goes. They hold no quarter. they ask no quarter. they hold no quarter. they ask no quarter. The pain, the pain without quarter. they ask no quarter. yeah! without quarter, quarter, yeah! they need no quarter. the dogs of doom are howling more! i hear the dogs of doom are howling more!
I've listened to this for years, but when youtube suggestions brought me back to it, I think I would prefer the non-robotized voice in the beginning and just hear Maynard sing in the regular haunting voice he perfected
![Tool - You Lied (Salival - Live) [Peach Cover]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D8m9SnrjpYY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Tool - You Lied (Salival - Live) [Peach Cover]](/img/tr.png)
This not being on Spotify is like a continuous kick to the balls.
seriously. I was so hoping it would be when tool finally allowed their albums to be on there. I had that repeat button ready to go hardcore during my game session on ps5. lol
Spotify is ass
Seriously....Fuck Spotify
@@scottm7725 cover by grave digger itunes and spotify, memorable version tool.
It would be more of kick to the balls to the people who own this album.
Jimmy Page said this is the only zeppelin cover that he ever heard that left him speechless. if that’s not praise idk what is
Source on that, by chance?
Source?
What other band could produce a really good cover of a zep song? Maybe the deftones?
No Quarter is the most Tool sounding Led Zep song. From muffled mic to Jimmy Page's prog rock guitar. The original just sounds like a Tool song.
Pink Floyd?
Coming from a HUGE Led Zepp fan:
This is fucking INCREDIBLE.
The depth, riffs, aggression, mood that Tool has added in this cover is something no one or band could do.
Sick HEAVYYY
Tool's the only band that could cover a 7 minute long song and turn it into an 11 minute long one
+Daniel Foster Ever seen Zeppelin playing it live? They made it 30 minutes long most of the time
+Alain Velásquez I'm sorry, Tool made it better.
Dave K Hey, that's your opinion.
Alain Velásquez Lol. Yeah…man...
+Daniel Foster Oh man, that gave me a good laugh.
played this with my dogs in the room and they are now bipedal. will keep updating.
So.... I think it's safe to assume you are no longer bipedal? Tool can be that way sometimes.
Do they talk by now? :-)
Are you 46 & 2 yet bruh'? Cmom now let's see if the pieces fit with a blood sample, ticks and leeches will do!
Have they become pneuma yet?
Did you mean to say bipoodle....
I think tool will be remembered by this generation as true music and art in sea of manufactured mainstream music. They have integrity, and their music IS revolutionary. No one can, or ever will sound like them. Not to mention their lyrics are amongst the most profound for any band.
You are spot on as far as I am concerned !
Absolutely 1,000,000,000% agree.
Was just talking with my wife about the power in Maynard’s lyrics. I listen them all the time and hearing them, singing along with them……but when I read the lyrics while listening to the music, that’s when the real power and greatness really comes through for me. I don’t know how to explain it, I’ve been listening to this band since I was in the 7th grade and I turned 45 today and there is no other band that still blows me away like it’s the first time….every time.
…… not to mention Adam, Justin and Danny are among the greats of their respective instruments. Put them all together and there’s not really anything this generation, or those that come after, will ever come close to reaching.
@@dougrippe33 39yrs old here and they have been a profound journey for the past 30 years. I had the privilege of hearing them at the age of 9! yes 9 years old! 1993 was a time that I was entranced, mystified and constantly yearning to hear more. Granted they had underground stuff in 1987 when Maynard was with CAD (Children of the Anachronistic Dynasty). But 1990 solidified this absolute gem of a band. 1992s opiate certainly lit the proverbial fire. However in 1993s undertow absolutely enthralled me lol. Anyhow long story short I absolutely understand what you mean , cheers!
In the first half of the song Tool seem to pay ever due respect to LZ, and then they take the song into their own dark corner and make it their own.
I reckon you're on the money ,that's why TOOL are COOL
I couldnt have said it better myself
Far better than the original
I can't disagree
BegToDiffah right around the 4 min mark it turns into a Tool song. This is hands down one of the best covers ever
I was blessed with the opportunity to see them perform this live ☺️
Same. They played this when I saw them tour w. Primus
Frick man.. The things i would do to see this live
It wasn’t Monster Mash in 2015 when they dressed up as Led Zeppelin was it?
Me too. Salt Lake City tour, was too epic. I'm blessed to have seen Tool multiple times in Utah and Vegas, plus Puscifer and A Perfect Circle both in Utah. I'll pay any price to see Maynard
Same
I'm a hard-core led Zep fan since back to 1969 and I have to say this is a righteous cover....I can definitely get into it....Get out those headphones, crank it up , sit back and follow the trip...
Same with me !! One of the very few covers that I don't shake my head at greetings my friend from Buffalo ny
I wish I could heart react to this because absolutely fucking same.
Respect all comments..great!!
@@Davidjon1946 up
never wear headphones don't want hearing aids
"where no one goes!!!"... *face melts*
Yesss
U mean "where no one goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooes!" :)
Take my horse
This is too, too beautiful
yes
An ad in the middle of this video should be a criminal offense.
Greedy UA-cam! Is there no quarter from these ads?
As a lifelong Led Zep fan and a newish Tool fan I must say this cover is absolutely superb,made the hairs on the back of my old neck stand up.
I think I read somewhere, that they were approached to do a Zeppelin cover for an upcoming tribute album. They chose this song. When they turn the finished version in, the producers told them to cut the song by 5 minutes. When Tool refused, the producers told them that they would receive the bill for recording. Tool said fine. Thus this was released on Salival.
My golly i did not know that... Thank you kind person 😁
@Josh Jordan
They decided not to let Stern have it for his movie. Tool has been on Sterns shit list ever since 😳😳
Nice I hope that’s true fuck the record industry
@Josh Jordan
That is correct. I personally agree with Adam Jones. I'm biased but I don't care. No quarter is too beautiful to be in such a vulgar movie anyway.
Rubaida Allen the notes are tattooed
Regardless of which version is better, it's super fuckin' awesome that Tool covered Led Zeppelin!!
a perfect circle covers when the levee breaks too if you're looking for another manyrd led zep cover ;)
so true
As my friend Elijah put it, no one asked for the cover, but both are necessary!
I love both versions for different reasons.
I don't think it can be said that one is "better".
I think people should learn to say, "I like one more," rather than, "One is better."
Righteous! Big shoes filled by BIG feet! Wah
Once again, Maynard's voice gives me the chills.
+Adelin LaRose (AdLaRO) chills i tell you
Me as well 👍😊
Every freakin time I listen to him, wich is everyday
Love love love
Anyone else who gets chills when he sings is my people. Maynard has a gift.
Fuck. I'm so glad to have been alive and had the privilege of experiencing this band in their prime. It was fucking great.
That makes two of us!
Adam Jones. Wow. Beautiful. I bet jimmy page is proud.
i cant believe i only just found this masterpiece im in awe
same like wtffff
their cover's are always interesting. here are a few others.
ua-cam.com/video/uEjRI6W9wjc/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/6WsynGJaZNo/v-deo.html
shame on you and congratulations! the absolute definition of a cover in my opinion. taking a song and making it yours
I always tell people Tool are the greatest stadium rock band since Led Zeppelin.....and having seen them live 3 times in sold out stadiums (live in Australia or it would have been a lot more than 3, they didn't get out here all that often) I fucking well stand by that statement. This cover live is like tantric sex for your earballs....and all your other senses for that matter.
Welcome to enjoy some of the best covers ever made only by tool !!
This is something you should hear at least once in your life, because you're never going to forget.
Adam Jones shines in this cover. Dude is masterful on the solos
Adam Jones doesn’t play “solos”.
@@automaticwriting4220 if you say so, cuñao
Adam Jones is “solo”!
@@automaticwriting4220ummm Jambi???
I have a feeling this is the universal greeting song upon entering a wormhole and traveling to a new dimension.
My parents got pissed at me for playing tool in my room. They said it wasnt loud enough for them to hear.
Why did it take me so long as a TOOL fan to hear this?
I feel like I've finally gotten the 6th album.
something similar for me was passenger by MJK and Deftones )
Me too Bro 😅
I'm glad they made their version longer; because , nobody should ever make it shorter. MJK vocal style is perfect for this tune
Led Zeppelin made it like 30 minutes live so
@@kriglum0760 No one is talking about that, retard.
I think this track was supposed to debut on a Led Zeppelin tribute cover album. However, the production guys said to Tool "make it shorter". Then Tool refused to publish it on said album, and it got released in Salival instead. This is the story as far as I know.
i have a tremendous respect to Led Zeppelin, but this cover... they must be feel honored
+Bruno Sirigado for* I agree :P
Heart did an amazing job covering Zeppelin's Stairway to Heaven too
amen
Has any zep member commented on it?
@@tnix80 if i remember correctly this one was John Paul Jones' project, his baby, as opposed to most of the rest of Zep's music being Page's. Therefore I would only really care for Jones' and perhaps Plant's thoughts on this cover.
I remember being 17 when this came out, the box set.
This song is gold.
I owned a copy my self the cd / vhs version
I have that dvd/CD combo just chillin in my garage put away all nice
The instrumental part in the middle is mindblowing 😱
I love anyone here. Regardless of taste. We ended up here. c:
We love you too my ninja.
Right.on brother rock on
Right on
Dylan McDonald As I do you, brethren in sonic awesomeness.
Dylan McDonald amazing!! We so did dude
I can't believe you put an add in the middle of the song, you just killed my chakras
Damn, that ending could've gone on forever.
After reading a few comments, I have to point out that I'm a Led Zeppelin fan, and I think this is a lovely version of the song. Both Tool and Led Zeppelin kick ass.
i love the original song, but i feel as if this ruins it. it doesn't have the same feel as the old one. when i first heard the original, i was reading Dune (By frank Herbert). when i listened to this song whilst a book like dune, my brain put them together and it turned the song into an instant reminder of Dune. it might not make sense to you, but i have a special connection between this song and the best book ever written. it seems, to me, almost sacrilege to do this to it. i am very fond of heavy metal and classic rock, but i just cant listen to this cover. i can see how it could be so popular. it is all in the eye of the beholder. for example, 99 problems by jayz. i hated that song, but some guy named Hugo did a cover and it is one o my favorite songs now. sorry for the essay!
Joseph Dredd i've now put 'reading dune while listening to no quarter' on my do to list, thank you
electricflag :D, it's the best thing i've done in a long time.
Damn, looks like I need to buy that book :D
Damjan Keramitchievski if you have a nook or a kindle, its cheaper digitally.
A true tribute to the Greatest Band in Rock History, delivered by TOOL.
Didn't know Tool made a tribute to themselves
For sure
Nobody is allowed to cover zep! Accept tool, of course.
George Bats As much as I love tool, Zep is just the better band
Tool is the greatest Rock band in history, my friend.
Pissed this isn't on Spotify
It might on the Spotify now. Check again
@@jenniferbrezler3742 still not :(
@@owenc4188 Well that sux, man.
Only CD I still own
This is the best cover of this song I have ever heard, they take it to an entirely different level than the original
The only band to successfully improve a Led Zeppelin song.
@Silky Steve this comes damn close, though: ua-cam.com/video/Uh36o_e1Kw4/v-deo.html
Great white can do some killer Zeppelin
Crowbar did a really cool sludge metal cover of this song that I think is pretty badass
Improved an LZ song? Wtf! What an insult. I couldn't listen to this whatever you call it for more than ten seconds.
Kb Calib your smoking crack. The LZ version is Imaculate but TOOL put it on a whole new level. Best version of the song i’ve ever heard period.
i love how they kept the qualities of the original song but morphed it to their style. they didnt copy everything from the song note for note, they put their own twist to it which is awesome.
Yeah they imprinted their own signature on it
7:13
Upon hearing this for the fist time, my 3rd eye quintupled in size and I ascended to the 4th dimension.
Fuck you
@@braddittner no sir. FUCK you
Yeah, but yer pineal gland is still calcified so you'll never attain the 528 hz nirvana vibrational plane
Rick Hartman oh that’s no issue. He can just take a detour and proceed to the 17th astral plane via the 43rd dimension
Jason Holmes when there’s traffic just breakthrough
IMO, this is absolutely in TOOL’s top 3 recordings, right up there with Lateralus and The Grudge.
Is it just me or does Danny smash the drums harder than he normally does? Channeling his inner Bonham and turning it up to 13.
Tool is the only band that could get away with this!!!
This could have been on fear Inoculum… Can’t play this enough to cure my need. Unbelievable
Man I was just gonna comment the same thing I swear! WAY ahead of its time that’s 4sure
It’s in my top 3 for sure! All time that is.
I can't play this enough to satisfy something inside me.
It's more addictive than any drug
Freaking weirdo
@@davidnoriega7944 lol
@@redskincaps than you haven't tried all the drugs
"The problem with the music we were listening to didn't have the climax where we wanted the climax for our own personal masturbation." MJK
i'm just glad I can love and appreciate both versions and bands, without making pointless comparisons.
indeed !
I've listened and learned of tool in prison.along with that igniting passive element.the days have pacified along with these melodies.
It's crazy how much they changed the lyrics from the original. So much grittier and darker overall. Phrases like "Close the door, put out the light" and "They're wearing steel that's bright and true" have been replaced with *"Lock all the doors, kill the lights"* and *"Dying dreams in me and you"* . It's like a dystopian 'No Quarter', playing out in the mind of someone who's been broken both mentally and physically.
You mean like how it is now
@@Machinereplica Yes. ;-;
Tool is always going to be Tool....Zepp is one of the best bands in history, but the fusion between their sound and Tools more elaborate, intricate style is priceless....What a truly visionary band Tool truly are. Hats off.
Tool really helps me when I'm sick. I listened to pushit when I had a fever a couple years back. Now I had the stomach flu, and this poped in my mind. I feel better now. This is also a great song to get stoned to, in your room alone.
That's me right now
Careful, I've come to associate certain albums with feeling sick due to hearing them when I was sick. OK computer and Garbages first two albums make me feel weird if I hear them
Imagine if Tool did a cover of Dark Side of the Moon.
Wouldn't work
jk fn no. animals.
Echoes
jk fn - how about: Shine On you crazy Diamond? That would be epic!!
@@jerseysucks6158 i agree shine on you crazy diamond would be much more tools style, thatd be amazing to hear.
This is such a brooding rendition... The guitar conveys such a sense of hopelessness and desperation. So evocative and oh so perfect. Only tool could have pulled it off
This could be the best cover of all time. It has virtually supplanted the original in my mind, and I love the original. And my god, 7:09.
Ugh that part at 7 mins is just unreal right
This and SOADs snowblind are what all covers should be, artistic expansion and modernization of an already fantastic and timeless work
I would love to hear Tool do more covers.
originality is their specialty...so...I say no
Demon cleaner.....
@@jonseywels8163 This cover is very original though... But I agree lol
Truly the only band I would ever trust to cover music so sacred as this
the ultimate song when stoned
Absofuckinglutely. Or on shrooms.
this song drives me to another dimension when high
You ain't lying..gahdamn
24/7
I think lateralus and holy Trinity would be awesome
TOOL !!!! amazing, no matter what they do !!!
danny is probly the only one who can play this song with as much emotion as the zepplin did..beautiful cover
Feel lucky to have heard this in my lifetime. Really... just fantastic.
They brought so much POWER!!!! to this song. Great cover...
damn this is the best thing i've ever heard oh my god
Where you from girl you're cute and you're tool fan lol
Damn Dave
This might be one of the best covers of any song. I ALMOST prefer this to the original.
It would be interesting to see how advanced Zeppelin would be if Bohnam lived. Tool is now the best band of all time. PERIOD!!!!
To all the people comparing the two versions of this song. Make sure you listen to the entire thing. Tool's cover has an extensive breakdown at the end which completely re-invigorates this song. Led Zeppelin's was the original, and for that respect and acknowledgement is due. But don't let that deafen you to the masterful creation you're hearing. Technically this dwarfs the original, but that isn't worth a dime because we're comparing apples and oranges. The Tool sound is defined by complicated, screeching, melodic riffs and incredible layered drum sequences and poly-rhythms. Versus Led Zeppelin's more rhythmic style, amazing guitar solos and Robert Plants snail trail. Honestly the two bands share a lot in common, Tool has obviously been inspired by Zep to some extent, as has any rock musician in the last 40 years, whether they're aware of it or not.
"Technically this dwarfs the original"... and that is exactly why it sucks!! these guys remind me of a very adept high school band. playing 20 chords were only one is necessary to convey the emotion, the feeling. this isnt even on the same planet as the original. thanks for the laugh though!!
LimeGuy101 a very powerful and truthful statement, everyone should take time to read this.
I've always found it weird your have to compare originals and covers in a light. They are in a way different tracks. A cover can easily be better than an original, if you build upon an already amazing track you have to add something. This definitely do.
Another great example of a cover done right is Jimi Hendrix All along the watchtower. The original is amazing but it is generally accepted that the Hendrix version is superior. So is this. Open your ears.
racer111259 “ 20 chords?” This song is not played with much technicality besides maybe Danny Carey’s drumming. It’s simple overall but done in a more elaborate way.
Tool writes their own songs though. It's probably not fair to say that Led Zeppelin wrote the original.
First heard this on late night radio about 10 years ago . Wasn't really paying close attention and thought it was Zeppelin until I heard Maynard' s voice. Wow! Great cover!
Is it wrong for me to want to hear Tool cover something from Pink Floyd's Animals album?
Not at all.
not only do I think that is an AMAZING idea, but also, Pink Floyd is my favorite band and you posted this on my birthday so YES
+Tommy Griffiths they would kill on that too!!
If they did Dogs, I'd jizz in my entire dresser drawer full of pants. Pigs (Three Different Ones) would probably work better for Tool as a band though. Animals is BY FAR, my favorite Floyd album.
It's not wrong, it's so right!
Best song cover Ive ever heard! Tool is the greatest band ever, making the cover more complex than the actual song!
It's gonna sound blasphemous because this is such a classic... but I like this more than the original.
Me, too! I always somehow feel ashamed of that, but TOOL's version is so much more dynamic and complex. Plus, the ridiculously excellent production value makes it that much better!
Blasphemous is true, but completely understandable haha this version of this song is very rocking. Very rocking Indeed
This is way better than Led Zepplins original
@@kellifrumento8992 agree
Looks like we are all going to hell for blasphemy then 😂👌
Saying that the original band smokes the cover version? Not such an original statement. I think the whole purpose of doing a cover is to put your own personal fingerprint on a song that moved or inspired you in some way. Otherwise, what's the point? I like this version. That's my opinion.
Exactly!
well put, lota people in this comment section just wanna compare the two bands/songs when I think it's better to analyze it as a new interpretation. I'm thankful tool doesn't cover any songs 1:1
One of the best covers ever recorded.
It surprises me over and over again how much I love this band. I wish I could see them live again.
5:37 is when this starts to transition from Led Zeppelin cover, to Tool uniqueness.
5:37 the exact center point of the song.
Climax as Maynard puts in every song is at 7:32-7:52 best part
The only band that gives me real goosebumps
Zep rocked in the 60's and 70's. tool rocks the 90's and beyond. You have to put yourself in each era.
A few months ago, I went through all of TOOL's discography on Spotify without listening to Salival as it's not on there. I never realized that one of my favorite bands covered another one of my favorite bands! Great song choice, and of course, fantastic cover!
Maynard gave new meaning to this song with his unworldly voice... love it!!!
It is absolutely criminal that I got an ad in the middle of this video
Possibly the best recording ever.
Led Zeppelin must be proud and blown away by this homage to one of their greatest songs. Awesome rendition!!!
zepp never lets anyone do covers, but even Robert Plant when hearing this stopped and said w00w. Extremely, excessively brilliant! This is very hard for me to say, but i have to accept this as my favorite tool song ever, or at least a tie w push it live
That's a bit rich coming from the band who (apart from the Rolling Stones) owe more of their own massive success to covering/borrowing/appropriating/ripping off old blues standards than any other band ever .. as far as I know this is nonsense anyway because anyone can cover anything, they just have to pay royalties to the publishers of course. I don't know where you get your ideas, but a quick search shows up at least 60 Zeppelin songs (over half their total output) covered by various artists over the decades, with most done multiple times in many different styles .. No Quarter alone has been done about 20 times, so basically you couldn't be more wrong :/
"Ripping off" is the real stretch here. Influence and inspiration is the right term, Timmy. No blues group produce anything like the Zepp. Don't get me started with appropriation because covering a band is more towards appreciation.
Almost all the songs from Zeppelin IV onwards were original. And IV, Houses of the Holy, and Physical Graffiti are their best albums. Re-contextualizing traditional blues songs wasn't anything new. Cream, Hendrix, and many many other bands were doing the same thing. Doesn't make them any less great.
Robb Deep I totally agree with you!!!!!!
I don't know about favorite TOOL song ever, but it's dope as fuck. Wings for Marie 1&2 are better than this. Tool and Zep are my 2 fav bands ever.
Time seems to stop when you hear masterpieces like this. LOVE Tool 💗
My favorite version of this song. Tool is amazing. Absolutely amazing!
Ive seen them live in holland thanks to my great sister who knew i woud appreciate it if she bought tickets, which she did... and i can say in ONE word AMAZING its one of my most favourite memories...!!
ive listened to this song countless times..and it gets better EVERY. FUCKING. TIME.
Quite a few years ago I stood in the rain in Camden NJ while Tool played. When it was over I said to my brother that it was bullshit man... over already? He laughed and said bro, they've been playing for two and a half hours. I said I could listen two and a half more... he laughed again and agreed.
Brilliant!!! Zeppelin is my heart n' soul so this is huge for me to accept anybody other then Heart doing Zeppelin... Zep must really respect you for giving u the rights to perform No Quarter. Beautifully done!!!
Greatest cover of all time. True to the original yet true to themselves! Best ever.
After every listen of this song I let out a long sigh and say “fuck yea!!”
My grandpa was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer and died two weeks later. I couldn't visit him the last week in the hospital, because of covid restrictions. I played this song over and over and it carried me through that week.
I’m so sorry for what happened:( I also lost a family member recently from the same thing
@@metalbitch2998 Thanks and sorry for your loss, as well. I wish you and your family the best. Take care.
@@alexandermiller866 you too 🙏🏻
Shows that music is a sincere form of art. They are so talented they blow all the mainstream crap away. Thank you Tool for being original even with vintage classics.
Please keep producing quality artwork.
There was once a day, a looooong time ago. Before I had heard of Salival. I was sitting here, on the ole interweb and a thought occurred to me. Tool covering Led Zeppelin would be the most amazing marriage of progressive rock/metal to ever exist. Soon after I was drooling over the Box Set and wishing I had it. I am sure I ended up downloading the track before finally buying Salival (with the VHS btw LOL) Also, funny enough, this was also my intro to No Quarter all together. I agree with you 100%
God damnit this is so gorgeously somber and dark, I loved it since they released salival, and after years and years I don’t think I’ll ever stop loving this sweet melody 🤟🏻
🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
3:19 and my whole body had chills and tears in my eyes omg
I swear i fucking LOVE this song/cover i cant describe how it makes me feel this band will forever be one of the greatest to do it
STUNNING, BEAUTIFUL, F'N EPIC ON A WHOLE OTHER LEVEL OF EPICNESS
The definition of a cover! What a band...
Lyrics:
Lock the door, kill the light.
no one's coming home tonight.
the sun beats down and don't you know?
all our lives are growing cold, oh...
they bring news that must get through.
to build a dream for me and you, oh.
Locked in a place where no one goes.
They ask no quarter
they have no quarter.
Lock the door, kill the light
no one's coming home tonight
It's getting colder (7x)
locked in a place where no one goes.
Lock the door, kill the light
no one's coming home tonight
They bring news that must get through.
dying peace in me and you
Locked in a place where no one goes.
We have no quarter
we have no quarter
we ask no quarter
Led zeppelin version
Close the door, put out the light.
no, they won't be home tonight.
the snow falls hard and don't you know?
the winds of thor are blowing cold.
they're wearing steel that's bright and true
they carry news that must get through, oooh
They choose the path where no-one goes.
They hold no quarter.
they hold no quarter.
Walking side by side with death
the devil mocks their every step
the snow drives back the foot that's slow
the dogs of doom are howling more
they carry news that must get through
to build a dream for me and you
They choose the path where no-one goes.
They hold no quarter.
they ask no quarter.
they hold no quarter.
they ask no quarter.
The pain, the pain without quarter.
they ask no quarter.
yeah! without quarter, quarter, yeah!
they need no quarter.
the dogs of doom are howling more!
i hear the dogs of doom are howling more!
I love both versions equally for almost the same exact reasons. Just utterly amazing.
Fucking phenomenal.
Chills down my fuckin spine.
I've listened to this for years, but when youtube suggestions brought me back to it, I think I would prefer the non-robotized voice in the beginning and just hear Maynard sing in the regular haunting voice he perfected
Tool pulled off the cover to this song so well it almost sounds like it were written by tool
I love both versions! both are different. both are enjoyable.