Don't worry man, after the peaceful reunification with Mainland China in near future, Taiwan will be a dual language province of China, Mandarin, Cantonese, Fujian dialect and English.
I agree mostly with the foreigner English teacher in Taiwan that Taiwan will not become a bilingual nation by 2030. Taiwan will never become a bilingual nation because most people in Taiwan can't speak English well and most people don't speak English in Taiwan and Taiwan is an island, and Taiwan is not a nation in the united nations and we live in the Republic of China, not Taiwan nation. So they're always lying to you that Taiwan will become a bilingual nation so who are the idiots? Outgoing kids are 外向的小孩非厚臉皮的小孩。
Once upon a time that a British man spoke 45 pounds in British English to a Chinese person Alee. Alee replied to him so I don't know English which means that Alee can't speak and understand British English especially Scottish English. Then the British spoke American English to Alee and Alee replied in American English which means that most people speak and understand American English, not English.I agree mostly with the foreigner English teacher in Taiwan that Taiwan will not become a bilingual nation by 2030. Taiwan will never become a bilingual nation because most people in Taiwan can't speak English well and most people don't speak English in Taiwan and Taiwan is an island, and Taiwan is not a nation in the united nation and we live in the Republic of China, not Taiwan nation. So they're always lying to you that Taiwan will become a bilingual nation so who are the idiots? Outgoing kids are 外向的小孩非厚臉皮的小孩。
Well said! Allan points out the problem of English teaching in Taiwan. I do miss my college English, she always gave us a two hours listening session for a special topic. Then next week, we had to write a script of 10 minutes conversation on that topic. Then played it with your partner in class. I think that is a good way to train English speaking. In my college, the freshmen had to organize an English drama and play on stage at end of the second semester. So pity that is only one year course. If we could do that for more years, that would improve our ability of speaking English. Thanks for the tip for improving English speaking.
you're absolutely spot on, I got a lot of thoughts and takes on this issue. But still got some work to be done, so unfortunately I do not have to much time to express my thoughts.
都有固有文化啊 應該也不是不能平行 只是比較難 台灣也還有台語 原住民語 說實在你能讓人懂話就很可以了 Speaking is very fast Cover subtitles then try to understand what you said can boost English abilities
Hi Allan, I wonder if the subtitle of your video can be adjustable. I enjoyed listening to your English very much and try to practice listening skill. If we can turn off subtitles and turn it on when needed, that would be great. Just my personal preference, please don't feel stressed.
Taiwan is not really bilingual but when it comes to tourism, I guess they have one of the best communicable English level in terms of non-Anglophone world Disclaimer: I speak fluent Mandarin, but that was based on my observation during my trip.
Can't agree with more. It's like you are going to Taipei, but your GPS is HsingChu. Never get chance to go wherever you want. And in school, wanting kids to speak English, but teachers never speak, only in class. So...... who knows.
I always recommend my students watch English shows with English subtitles and if they play videogames to play in English. Practical everyday exposure with the things a student is actually interested in is important when learning a new language.
@@LonerAsceticWell, that's not a big deal for native speakers. All you need to do is speak what you want to convey. They can understand your intentions from some keywords in your sentences.
One thing English as a second language learners should realise is that English is a 'close enough' language. There's no such things as 'perfect' English. Local languages, syntax, expressions and dialects get mixed in with English everywhere it is spoken. So long as an English learner gets the basic idea across to a native speaker the deal will get done - no need for perfect grammar, pronunciation, syntax or even the exact word or phrase. Unlike some languages where anything less than perfection will get blown off by native speakers (ie. French).
You are right. Too shy to speak out in English is a big obstacle to sharpen the English ability. I once met you in Taichung MRT. You and your friend sat right beside me in the car. I was so excited. "Is he Allen? the sound. the tattoo on his hand. Yes, it is Allen. Should I say hello to him? I really want to say I like your videos. What if he replies to me and I can't understand? Although I know he can speak Mandarin. " when I kept hesitating ,you just got off in 南屯站. it is my regert.QQ
agree with you - it is usually lack of confidence when their English listening and comprehension is actually really good. I have a few colleagues who are often apprehensive when I chat with them in English, but I think building up a good rapport and relationship with your co-workers or friends will help that confidence, by making yourself approachable.
I 100% agree with your opinion in speaking English of Taiwan education. My English was terriable for 48 years, but I try to find the way to sepak good English. Now I speak English to my 10 years old daughtor ervery day, I try to train her English for 2 years as a native speaker.
This is a dangerous topic in Taiwan. As you mentioned, people in Taiwan are more concerned about face-saving. Back to the topic, I totally agree with your point of view. I think we need some motivation to learn other language, such as for working, or traveling…and so on. I have ever tried to teach my nephew English, but she said there’s no benefit to learn English because most of her classmates/friends are only speak mandarin. Therefore, I believe motivation is also a key point for learning a new language.
I will say, one of the reason Taiwanese start to pratice English and mind their pronounciation is to distinguish. Distinguish from what? From those under-developing Asians, not specific for any country, just, all. It happens when the stereotype "bad English is similar to be uncivilzed" But, something have to be declared, there are clearly a bunch of people want to distinguish themselves from the Mainland Chinese, since some of them arrogantly think that their Chinglish pronounciation doesn't matters at all. In conclusion, thanks for your introduction and demonstation of ELSA, it will definitely help the requirement mentioned above.
I am from India where English is not the native language but still widely spoken. I can say that Allan has correctly pointed the reasons why Taiwan cannot be a bilingual country in the near future. To the Taiwanese friends reading this comment - be confident of your English and its okay to make mistakes. The point is to understand the other person and also be understood. No one is going to give you bad scores when you speak in English.
Great video, great topic. Please let us know if you find a good app to learn Chinese? I don't quite agree that Taiwanese people are shy to start a conversation. It happened so many times that people just come up to me and start a conversation, very often to get a chance to practice their English. That's also part of Taiwanese hospitality and kindness. I agree however, that the route is long to make Taiwan a bilingual country. I mean, English bilingual, because it already has mandarin, Taiwanese, hakka and so many others.
You not entitled to judge our Asian English ability. Whst s bummer thst tou dont soeak any Chinese gor kiving in Taiwan fir mire than onr decade. Shsme on you and uou are here to judge us
In my opinion, Taiwan does not need to become a bilingual country with English as the second official language. Here are the reasons: First, the widespread education in Chinese has already made it the common language, and there are almost no native English-speaking communities within the country. Second, it is impossible in today's society, unlike in colonial times, to introduce a large population of officials and workers from a colonial mother country to popularize the language. Moreover, Chinese has a very strong uniqueness, and the aggressive promotion of English would stifle Chinese character culture. The areas in Taiwan where English is heavily used are popular tourist spots and foreign companies, but these areas represent only a small portion of the entire population of Taiwan. Most importantly, the status of English as an official language is not related to the international perspective of citizens or the national competitiveness.
If you want to improve the English education, you can't just provide classes. You need to creat an English environment such as English channels, speaking in English in schools.
Allan is like that stereotypical Asian FOB who just stayed with the local Asian community after immigrating to the US and never extensively conversed in English. Over time, he learned bits and pieces of English but never became fluent because English is difficult.😅 (Sorry for poking fun at you. 🤣) Honestly, it's just not that easy for a native English speaker to speak Mandarin fluently due to the tonal characteristics of Mandarin. The minute changes in tone are hard to detect for some. We should show grace to each other, especially if someone is actively trying.💙
I believe that one day our country will become bilingual or multilingual. Currently, we are unable to achieve this because many older people do not speak foreign languages.😄 Making Taiwan a bilingual country would be particularly beneficial for society and the region, and it would bring significant changes to the nation as well. It's just a matter of time. 我相信，我們國家總有一天可以成為雙語或是多語國家， 之所以目前無法成為雙語國家是因為連高齡層問題不會外國語言的關係， 讓台灣成為雙語國家對社會及地域特別有幫助~ 對國家也會有很大的改變~只是時間上的問題而已~😁
We have been teaching English at public schools for the past 3 years here in Taiwan. We can tell you exactly how and when that confidence is lost. But what we have to say might be a bit controversial for your comment section. Should anyone want to get the insights of two public school English teachers, they know where to find us. Also The Elsa app was one of my go-to recommendations when we lived and taught in Vietnam. The app was developed by a Vietnamese And was one of the few apps that could really work with the tones associated with Vietnamese. I'm happy to see that it is still in use and has expanded quite extensively! ~JB
與AI練習，提升你的英文口說能力，增強自信！我強烈推薦ELSA Speak： bit.ly/elsa-lifeintaiwan-yt
Don't worry man, after the peaceful reunification with Mainland China in near future, Taiwan will be a dual language province of China, Mandarin, Cantonese, Fujian dialect and English.
I agree mostly with the foreigner English teacher in Taiwan that Taiwan will not become a bilingual nation by 2030. Taiwan will never become a bilingual nation because most people in Taiwan can't speak English well and most people don't speak English in Taiwan and Taiwan is an island, and Taiwan is not a nation in the united nations and we live in the Republic of China, not Taiwan nation. So they're always lying to you that Taiwan will become a bilingual nation so who are the idiots?
Outgoing kids are 外向的小孩非厚臉皮的小孩。
Once upon a time that a British man spoke 45 pounds in British English to a Chinese person Alee. Alee replied to him so I don't know English which means that Alee can't speak and understand British English especially Scottish English. Then the British spoke American English to Alee and Alee replied in American English which means that most people speak and understand American English, not English.I agree mostly with the foreigner English teacher in Taiwan that Taiwan will not become a bilingual nation by 2030. Taiwan will never become a bilingual nation because most people in Taiwan can't speak English well and most people don't speak English in Taiwan and Taiwan is an island, and Taiwan is not a nation in the united nation and we live in the Republic of China, not Taiwan nation. So they're always lying to you that Taiwan will become a bilingual nation so who are the idiots?
Outgoing kids are 外向的小孩非厚臉皮的小孩。
我是一個對學習語言有強烈興趣的人，我一開始看你的頻道是因為我真的很想學英式英文，很感謝你將字幕整理的很好，同時有中英文，並且用正常速度講話，而非刻意放慢。我從你的頻道，不只學習語言，也學習到更多角度和觀點看事情。👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
不用理會酸民的酸言酸雨，說什麼中文沒學好⋯。雖然不免有心態或眼界狹隘的人，但多數台灣人的包容性很強的。😊
台灣政府老是只用傳統的舊方法空中英語教室and let's talk in English 來只讀不說英語，所以至今執政了八年多還無法建立了雙語國家的。因此，美國要向賴清德總統的教育部及國發會推薦各級學校及各機關用AI 學英語。
最近看到蠻多網紅推薦Elsa，感覺蠻厲害。謝謝Allan分享的優惠
Well said! Allan points out the problem of English teaching in Taiwan. I do miss my college English, she always gave us a two hours listening session for a special topic. Then next week, we had to write a script of 10 minutes conversation on that topic. Then played it with your partner in class. I think that is a good way to train English speaking. In my college, the freshmen had to organize an English drama and play on stage at end of the second semester. So pity that is only one year course. If we could do that for more years, that would improve our ability of speaking English.
Thanks for the tip for improving English speaking.
Wow, you speak so fast, that I couldn't catch you until I listened twice, but, still, I think this is one way of practicing & training, thank you.
身為一個英文接近自學的純正台灣人，學校的英文課對我最大的幫助大概就是單字量，
剩下的語感跟聽力幾乎都是靠整天看UA-cam養出來的，現在英文程度大概在CEFR-B2左右
但其實高中時期超討厭英文課 哈哈哈哈哈
Yes, ELSA is a very powerful tool for improving their English pronunciation.
you're absolutely spot on, I got a lot of thoughts and takes on this issue. But still got some work to be done, so unfortunately I do not have to much time to express my thoughts.
都有固有文化啊 應該也不是不能平行 只是比較難 台灣也還有台語 原住民語 說實在你能讓人懂話就很可以了
Speaking is very fast
Cover subtitles then try to understand what you said can boost English abilities
比起自信和文化的因素 ,我覺得是臺灣不像香港和新加坡等華人國家那麼國際化 ,也就是屬於金融中心 物流樞紐 ,以至於國人得以接觸到更多有別於旅遊上的語言溝通 像是上學,工作和日常生活上的 而這幾種層面上的英語口語溝通往往才是國人們累積和提升英文能力的主要推力 因為這些層面佔據每個人在一天當中絕大部分的時間 ,而遠大於服務員或路人在遇到外國遊客的情境的時間。
亦即如果台灣能夠成為像香港和新加坡那樣層級的國家 那自然而然就能變成雙語國家了 ,特意去從教育層面的思維來加以改變似乎僅是治標而不治本 ,其實應該要改變的不僅是教育層面 ,而是臺灣整體在國際上的競爭力
臺灣一直都是雙語國家，相信有九成以上的臺灣人，會說兩種以上的語言。
可以理解，Allen 提到的雙語國家應該是指加上「英語」
有兩個疑問請教 Allen,
1.現況大部分的臺灣人會說 母語(臺語、客語、原民語、新住民原生國語言...) + 現行的國語 ，請問這樣可以稱為 bilingual 嗎？
2.未來若臺灣成功推展英語，成為雙官方語言，將會有多數臺灣人會使用三種語言，在英語怎麼形容？
謝謝
Hi Allan,
I wonder if the subtitle of your video can be adjustable. I enjoyed listening to your English very much and try to practice listening skill.
If we can turn off subtitles and turn it on when needed, that would be great.
Just my personal preference, please don't feel stressed.
The Chinese translation in around 41 seconds is the opposite of what you said in English!
Taiwan is not really bilingual but when it comes to tourism, I guess they have one of the best communicable English level in terms of non-Anglophone world
Disclaimer: I speak fluent Mandarin, but that was based on my observation during my trip.
影片內容這麼好，為什麼要用農場標題???
其實年輕一代英文已經比上一代好多了。但相反的又有人會怕小孩洋涇濱或太洋了，中文也不好英文也不好。
台灣其實就早是雙語國家了，其實大多台灣人都能流利的說中文和台語喔~~~
Can't agree with more. It's like you are going to Taipei, but your GPS is HsingChu. Never get chance to go wherever you want. And in school, wanting kids to speak English, but teachers never speak, only in class. So...... who knows.
沒錯，一定不可能雙語的。全台才多少外國人士，我在台南市場賣米粉，講台語啦，台灣價值，你出社會後，英文在台灣是有什麼用？你工資會多多少？老闆一毛都不會給你加的啦
看看現在新聞台文字工作的水準,"【聚焦真相】防治胃癌無聲殺手 幽門桿菌是元凶",影片2分32秒處,姓氏傻傻分不清.
自己中文能力要紮穩腳根,現今有注音輸入選字可能錯誤,偶爾有同音別字尚可諒解,而當今根本連文字工作者都錯字連篇,前幾天還有"刺身"弄成"赤身"的新聞標題出現.
先回頭重新紮根吧!!
詐騙在台灣太猖獗，是一個重要因素人之間的心防致使冷漠
I'm curious: When you say TaiWHAAAAN, does ELSA correct your pronunciation of Taiwan?
Pretty good
只有英文嗎？
為什麼臺灣人要配合那些不願說國語的外國人，去學英文。
我這輩子是不會出國了，也沒體力出國，但那些說住了幾十年的外國人卻不會說國語。
臺灣人去外國，卻要說當地的語言，當地人也不想說國語，
反而臺灣人在自己的地方，卻要配合外人。
很好。你看起來是不需要
當然，以你的觀點來看，對於任何外語的學習是出自於尊重當地文化。但我覺得不要被自身的觀點給限制了。論通用性，英文在全球仍具有易學，且資訊更新最快的優勢。二來是以台灣必須打入全球的供應鏈，開拓更廣泛的市場，英文是其中的必備條件。
國際化的社會本來就是互相配合，如今中國也已經沒有多少旅客來臺，反觀其它各國來臺旅客有所上升，加上臺灣的經濟也有國際化的趨勢，除非你想要臺灣鎖國並且成為一個外資都看不上的落後地方，否則配合世界趨勢學習英文才是我們身為國際公民的生存之道
沒錯，我個人是對來台工作卻簡單中文溝通都不行的外國人很反感
但是為了接觸更多我至少得會基本英文溝通，看人的需求吧!
PS.來台旅遊的不在討厭範圍內
Taiwan is dual language dude!!! It is Taiwanese and Mandarin 😋
台湾若想和我们中国对抗，长远来看，双语(中文，英文/台语，英文)是很重要的，毕竟台湾体量小，和日本一样完全加入西方世界才是上策。
林北國台語攏欸通
台灣早就是雙語、三語了
洗勒靠杯三小
很兇歐
日本也沒有成為雙語國家啊！
韓國也沒有成為雙語國家啊！
德國也沒有成為雙語國家啊！
那請問在英國本土會讓英語以外的語言成為英國的雙語國家嗎？
為什麼非得遷就外國人？
只是更有競爭力，多學其他語言有什麼不好
ㄜ.......你提的國家好像都是不需要雙語的大國，我們是小島國，確實是需要與世界交流的，不需要自我鎖國，我倒希望台灣的雙語不會走向 " 新加坡式 " 或 " 印度式 " 英文，因為我知道台灣人比他們強😁😁
語言一定是學越多越好，但英文沒有必要變成官方語言。
@@tceechia 我覺得英文不一定非得是官方語言，但中文的官方語言地位肯定是應該拿掉的，以我經驗來看這個語言真的浪費人們太多時間又根本只有臺灣 中國 馬來西亞 新加坡在講，其中馬來西亞 新加坡根本可以直接用英文溝通，學習中文的投資報酬率真的已經太低了
我認同像你說的語言越多越好，我覺得就可以在臺灣優先推廣像是英文 西班牙文 法文這種國際上真的最多人最多國家在使用的語言
我們的祖先向來也是被迫遷就外國人啊，包含你我現在在用的中文也是外國語言啊，那既然現在中文沒有競爭力又不實用又花我們更多學習時間，那為何不直接英語 西班牙語 法語化？
而且日韓都有大量的古典/流行文化輸出，多少還能吸引西方人去學日語 韓語，而德國即便沒有成為雙語國家，英文能力還是碾壓臺灣，德語本身雖然輸英文 西班牙文 法文，但也不是那麼小眾，這就是為什麼人家還是可以把德語當主要語言啊
不然你去看看荷蘭 比利時 盧森堡 印度，不也都老實的學英文講英文嗎？
學英語不是為了遷就英國人，是因為美國人，要不是美國人說英文，怎麼會有那麽多人學你一個江河日下的國家的語言。英國人確實懶於學第二語言，但英國人請擺好你的位置，其他國家不是為你而學，是為了和美國交流。
不只是為了美國，世界上還有許多英語系國家，實際上絕大多數非英語國家的第一外語也都是英文，而像如今人口世界第一並且正在崛起的印度更是人人都說英文
我覺得現在已經不是去區分到底是為了英國還是美國去學英文的時候了，重點是學習並加強各種腔調的英文（比如印度腔）會對臺灣的競爭力產生極大的幫助
大多是英國殖民地，所以都是和英國有関
我們是雙語國家啊，國語、台語,還有台灣國語😂😂😂
台灣早有多語言（地方語），何來不是雙語國家？
這樣的標題，不會有很多流量，但你說的是的事實！與其一天到晚吹台灣多好，不如說實話，我喜歡！❤❤❤
對，和平統一後會更好。
對啊，都快同大陸統一啦，有鬼所謂咩
Go with you 🎉🎉🎉
@@DiuLayGoHi 台灣人唔係中國人，亦唔應該「被統一」
我現在人在多倫多學習英文要將近一年的時間，從不知道如何開口到知道怎麼跟其他外國人溝通，這已經是蠻大的進展了。我認為最大的突破點還是像影片當中講的，害怕犯錯與被嘲笑。我在學校遇到各式各樣的國際生，彼此都不會去嘲笑彼此的口音，但只有自己人會嘲笑（台灣人笑台灣人的發音與口音）其實我不明白好笑的地方在哪（？就是不懂不會才要學習，而自己人嘲笑自己人的心態到底是為何？
在國外學習英文，老師從來都不會笑話我們，不斷地鼓勵我們。所以我們勇於的犯錯跟學習，真的只有在錯誤中學習，才能進展得更快！
我自己是英文流利使用者，以前在英國旅遊還被歐洲人誤以為當地人，回到台灣後，發現近年越來越多英文母語人士或非母語人士的外籍人定居台灣。我遇過主動跟我說中文的歐語系人士（我猜應該是東歐來的）講得很流利，使有口音也不妨礙理解，我也用中文跟他對談，作為他願意融入我的社會的尊重。同時也看過在速食店點餐不會一句中文，板著臉用英文點餐，得到不會英文的店員用中文笑著回應，我不會主動幫忙，如果我幫忙了，這個人永遠不覺得有需要學習基本中文。如果他要在這裡久住，可不是好事。
沒錯，不應那讓那這些仗勢者白人特權白人至上的死老外認為亞洲人都應該要迎合他們說英文，憑什麼
之前遇到外國人來旅遊用英文問我事情，我也聽不太懂他的口音，請他講慢一點我才好理解。但他還是堅持要用他的語速，我就直接走掉了😂
Nice🤣🤣🤣
可能對方也聽不懂你的發音，要跟對方一樣的腔調才行。（誤）😂😂😂
I always recommend my students watch English shows with English subtitles and if they play videogames to play in English. Practical everyday exposure with the things a student is actually interested in is important when learning a new language.
沒有用，臺灣的英文只出現在考試卷中，考完全部忘光，因為只是在意文法的對與錯，並無落實英語生活化，考試很棒，但一遇到要說要聽時卻不知從何下手完全鬥不起來，外國人其實並不在意文法對錯的糾結，只要詞能達意即可，就像中文我們常常說一個人很漂亮或很帥，但外國人或外籍勞工就會講成漂亮那麼多，很帥那麼多但我們還是聽的懂，這就是詞能達意，只要在台灣待久一點自然就會自我導正，一點也聽不出來是外國人
不是阿~每個語速講那麼快~而且英文還有連音~等於跳過某些音~很難寫出來寫出完整句子~還有文法弄錯外國人會聽不懂
@@LonerAsceticWell, that's not a big deal for native speakers. All you need to do is speak what you want to convey. They can understand your intentions from some keywords in your sentences.
@@LonerAscetic不是太嚴重的文法錯誤都是可以接受的，by加拿大友人
@@LonerAscetic 哥，這不是不學英文的重點阿...
@@LonerAscetic練習是要找對方法，不能奢求英文程度還沒那麼好立刻就去聽語速快的英文啊，我爸爸快70歲了，還在努力的繼續練習英文聽力。
臺灣絕對有機會成為雙語國家，或許一百年後；
或許把那一批愛喥咕的官員全部換成新住民後；
我們有些人愛笑東南亞國家，其實他們早贏了；
希望能有幸看到臺灣整體環境進步，謝謝分享！👍🥰🙏
真想不透，那些阻止我們同時擁有多種語言的政客在想什麼；
還有那些假冒臺灣人的粉紅老要我們放棄英語，學中文就好；
難道把文言文學好就能增加國際地位？還是被再教育更容易？
我也希望台灣能成為雙語國家。但悲觀的是，我們目前從教育環境到一般社會環境，英文的使用率還是偏低。很難更進一步提升國人的英文水準。我們不應該只是單純的背誦單字和文法，最重要的是溝通。語言就是要拿來說的，能夠在日常生活中得到應用才能學得更快，更準確。
@@s6_kr9134 你完全明白我在說什麼！👍
@@s6_kr9134 我認為理想上 在久遠的未來 如果能直接成為英語/西班牙語國家還是最有優勢
比起花更多的時間去學中文，長大後發現除了臺灣 中國 馬來西亞 新加坡四國以外都沒人用中文，還不如直接學最多人用的英文或西班牙文（也可以都學），這樣可以一次性解決非常多的問題（比如“整天被中國人說是同文同種” “臺灣藝文創作走不出華語圈” “外國人來臺灣旅遊和生活但語言不通” 等問題）
台湾不已经是台语和国语的双语国家了吗😅
Allan講的很正確，亞洲人因為文化和教育常常害羞，怕犯錯，注重面子，就導致學習語言的困難。（我雖然這麼說但我也不例外哈哈哈哈）我也來試試看Elsa AI。謝謝推薦
別把"台灣人"的英語習性硬扣在"亞洲人"的頭上好嗎?
確實發音不準確會導致溝通困難，也會影響聽力能力。Elsa這個工具感覺不錯
One thing English as a second language learners should realise is that English is a 'close enough' language. There's no such things as 'perfect' English. Local languages, syntax, expressions and dialects get mixed in with English everywhere it is spoken. So long as an English learner gets the basic idea across to a native speaker the deal will get done - no need for perfect grammar, pronunciation, syntax or even the exact word or phrase. Unlike some languages where anything less than perfection will get blown off by native speakers (ie. French).
Good point 👍🏼
試想一個台灣人住在英國16年卻只會很簡單的英文單字，不知有何感想。
Allan這樣說真的激發了我學習英文的動力哈哈哈。好想提升自己的能力來幫助國家發展。我已經購買了Elsa premium，覺得頁面設計很棒，AI對話也很聰明，推薦大家也試試看
一直很喜歡看Allan在台灣的生活影片，也很喜歡跟外國朋友交流，但總是因為害羞不敢開口。我英文的聽讀寫還可以，但一到口說就卡住，腦子裡有很多想說的話卻說不出口。影片裡推薦的elsa AI感覺很厲害，我會試試看，希望能改善我的口說。謝謝頻道提供的優惠！
要在不同國家生活、觀光、旅遊，就該用當地的語言。在自己國家，不要刻意貶低自己的語言，硬要說不是自己的母語，然後說得零零落落表現得很糟糕害羞沒自信，這樣的意義為何？對於一些在路上看到外國人就要用外文嘗試溝通的人，真的很無聊，有些外國人來台為了學中文或要體驗台灣文化，當地人就應該展現出自信的一面，勇敢說中文，真聽不懂再用英文表示溝通也不遲。至於雙語國家就算了吧，毫無邏輯可言的政策。
太中肯了 學生沒機會說英文🤷♀️🤷♀️🤷♀️🤷♀️
如果雙語教育目的是想全民集體侍候歐美白人, 那也太低賤.
來台灣長居的外國人他應該學好"我們一般溝通的話".
事實上也很多外國人樂於說國語.
他們或許是教師, 業務代表, 文化人士.
我們想想, 我會和社區鄰居聊天下大勢嗎?
很少. 大家各懷鬼胎. 各滑手機視線不接.
那麼, 我們有那樣多英文程度和老外聊天?
連英文系畢業的都很艱難. 你懂英語會話, 但你未必能體會外國人的價值觀.
有一個管理員說: 我就算會講英語, 我也不和老外聊天. 他有事, 他應該用我懂的語言和我對話.
我只和菲律賓移工講話, 但是因為他剛來台灣, 他不擅於中文溝通.
剛來台灣的, 我們要幫他.
但沒必要全瘋狂雙語教育吧?
大家都要去五星級國際大飯店當櫃台員嗎? 那薪水很高嗎?
跟AI練英文口說好厲害哦。之前有看過別人分享用ChatGPT練，但我試了覺得好困難，因為看不到字幕有時不知道他在說什麼。Elsa AI會自己設計情境，而且它講的話也有字幕，最主要是結束後還有各種口說技巧的回饋。覺得很值錢
You are right. Too shy to speak out in English is a big obstacle to sharpen the English ability.
I once met you in Taichung MRT. You and your friend sat right beside me in the car.
I was so excited.
"Is he Allen? the sound. the tattoo on his hand. Yes, it is Allen. Should I say hello to him? I really want to say I like your videos. What if he replies to me and I can't understand? Although I know he can speak Mandarin. "
when I kept hesitating ,you just got off in 南屯站.
it is my regert.QQ
agree with you - it is usually lack of confidence when their English listening and comprehension is actually really good. I have a few colleagues who are often apprehensive when I chat with them in English, but I think building up a good rapport and relationship with your co-workers or friends will help that confidence, by making yourself approachable.
台灣要推雙語國家...........，
不是為了讓大部份人具備英語口說能力，
是為了騙外籍移民來台灣定居，
解決台灣的勞動力不足問題，
政府根本就不想增進全民的雙語能力，
只是因為目前英語是主流的國際語言，
只好推雙語國家騙外國人在台灣生活講英語就好了，
而且，
一般人學好英語口說與培養太好的英語能力，根本一點用都沒有!
在台灣要賺錢的捷徑是當半導體產業的工人或工程師，
大部份人，只要看得懂理工與工業用的英文文件，
然後可以跟外國廠商用英語比手畫腳溝通就好，
根本用不到太流利的英語口說能力。
艾倫在臺灣多年覺得自己會講三種語言😊嗎？除了英語另外的國語、台語、客家語都會說嗎？😊
這個中文標題是有爭議的, 也不太討喜, 只是為了吸睛.
本人英語流利(有出國學習英語), ELSA Speak我用3年了(對發音和口調是有幫助的, 費用上親民).
台灣本來就是雙語或多語國家了...請觀眾不要自貶, 對英語有興趣的是可以使用影片推薦的APP.
Allan的影片總是充滿正能量！提出的問題也很有見地。我本來就用了elsa快一年了，真的很好用，我的發音改善了很多，自信也提升了不少，現在跟外國人溝通不像以前那麼緊張了
英語是國際語言，台灣做為東亞的民主國家自然要掌握，起碼出國能交流。
確實不會變成雙語國家，就跟有人持有雙重國籍也不一定會完全同化成另一國人，這是一樣的概念
sorry, we are already bilingual. WE speak mandarin and Taiwanese (min-nam).
國中那種超級重視文法的英文考試，逼退了很多人學習英文的熱情
U R WRONG！
Taiwan has become a multilingual country.
English is power. Power leads to FIRE.
生活用不到的工具給再多也沒用
其實想讓英文變好，還有一個方法是跟英文不是母語，但比你好一些的同學對話。
雙方都會犯錯，而且是一個期待犯錯的學習情境，就沒什麼丟臉的問題。
等到進步了，就換個更優秀的同學練習。
不過這種環境，比較不容易在義務教育出現，所以可能要花點錢去補習班，或大學時找外文系的同學進行。
I 100% agree with your opinion in speaking English of Taiwan education.
My English was terriable for 48 years, but I try to find the way to sepak good English.
Now I speak English to my 10 years old daughtor ervery day, I try to train her English for 2 years as a native speaker.
台灣其實是多語言國家就是了
我有朋友說，他在家裡三聲道切換，國客閩
你媽媽是個雙語國家
沒錯
This is a dangerous topic in Taiwan. As you mentioned, people in Taiwan are more concerned about face-saving.
Back to the topic, I totally agree with your point of view. I think we need some motivation to learn other language, such as for working, or traveling…and so on. I have ever tried to teach my nephew English, but she said there’s no benefit to learn English because most of her classmates/friends are only speak mandarin. Therefore, I believe motivation is also a key point for learning a new language.
I will say, one of the reason Taiwanese start to pratice English and mind their pronounciation is to distinguish. Distinguish from what? From those under-developing Asians, not specific for any country, just, all. It happens when the stereotype "bad English is similar to be uncivilzed" But, something have to be declared, there are clearly a bunch of people want to distinguish themselves from the Mainland Chinese, since some of them arrogantly think that their Chinglish pronounciation doesn't matters at all.
In conclusion, thanks for your introduction and demonstation of ELSA, it will definitely help the requirement mentioned above.
有雙語阿，中文跟臺語
好久沒看到allan這型態的主題影片,唯一不一樣的是一張舊木桌不見了😁,台灣全角落有人居住的地方要達到全雙語,當然不可能很快達到,老一輩的人有的甚至國語都不會講,只講他們方言,更不用去想學老外語言?只期望下一代,這一代的小孩即時在學校的英文課,加重其課業,用強迫的方式教他們去學,雖說短期間有效用,但長期間卻....真正問題在你週遭的「環境」在哪裡以及目地為何? 其實只是學另一種語言功夫而且是全球使用廣泛的語言,大家以為學英文目地可能是要出國到講英文的國家旅遊或出差,不可能所有台灣人都能去,也不可能天天出國(那是要花錢的),然後回來一段時間,三年或十年沒出國,英文又全忘了(長時間不講某種語言是會忘了如何說),那麼問題在「環境」,我們現在住的地方如果早上見到老外或隔壁的隔壁有老外居住,此時說「英文」的機率變高,全台見老外機率及密度越來越高,此時不學英文會被淘汰,雙語環境就形成了,功力比去學校強迫學的還強,那就是用自然的心態去學語言,那樣的效果才棒👍,還有學另一個語言不一定要完全跟當地口音標凖,八成能聽懂就夠了,比如1:一個老外跟我對談中文時,用標準的台式口音對談。另一個2:老外用尚能勉強能聽懂的中文口音,你們覺得我會喜歡哪個? 答案是2,因「老外會說中文耶!!!」的驚嚇度比標準式的還高,哈哈!😁
How about learning Spanish?
剛好相反，跟外國人說話，有很多時候我發現他們想跟我講中文，但我想跟他們講英文
大家聊起來的就是: 我看到老外，覺得講中文很怪....所以忍不住就講英文😂
分析得很有道理！學任何語言缺乏自信都是很難講出口的，先跟AI練習是不錯的選擇。感謝推薦elsa app，我正好需要這樣的App來練習
雙語政策就是打水漂，漂亮的國王的新衣。再500年也無法成功！有必要有機會把英語說好的人，自然會想辦法把它學好。何必花大把的錢把不需要的人一起拖下去呢？
I am from India where English is not the native language but still widely spoken. I can say that Allan has correctly pointed the reasons why Taiwan cannot be a bilingual country in the near future. To the Taiwanese friends reading this comment - be confident of your English and its okay to make mistakes. The point is to understand the other person and also be understood. No one is going to give you bad scores when you speak in English.
外籍人員來台很難用英語溝通，這問題是誰該被檢討？正確應是外國人必須自我檢討！我們多數人不出國謀生，而且在此使用國語已可以毫無障礙的彼此溝通良好，所以英語在此不是必須的生活工具，外來人士無道理來批評國人的英語水平。外國人若想在本地獲得便利生活和增強自信，首先需檢視自己有沒有具備基本的中文能力。
Can you talk about Taiwan’s tax system? Sales tax, income tax, medicare tax, social security tax, property tax, etc. I am interested to know. Thanks.
成為中英雙語國家到底有多重要？全世界不鳥英文的國家多如牛毛。其實英文爛才能迫使這些英美或外籍來台人士學習中文。我學會法文就是因為法國人英文太差而且多數人不屑以英文跟旅法者溝通（包含高知識分子）。先前看過這頻道的其它影片，我真的覺得這頻道主人應該調整一下英文自我中心的心態。學英文在臺灣一直都很重要，所以他也覺得自己很重要，我只想反問：你的光環是誰給你的？你是不是該對這島嶼上的人民及其文化精神內涵予以尊重？
Great video, great topic. Please let us know if you find a good app to learn Chinese?
I don't quite agree that Taiwanese people are shy to start a conversation. It happened so many times that people just come up to me and start a conversation, very often to get a chance to practice their English. That's also part of Taiwanese hospitality and kindness.
I agree however, that the route is long to make Taiwan a bilingual country. I mean, English bilingual, because it already has mandarin, Taiwanese, hakka and so many others.
English is a tool for people to communicate….English is not the-must-offered-service Taiwanese required to serve for any English speaking countries
看到豐樂雕塑公園耶~
以前常帶小孩去玩
不過....我跟台灣人打電話、面對面交談都會有點不敢了~
現在打電話點餐定位已經好一些了
但面對面點餐、結帳尤其不熟的店也還是會卡卡的
看來要讓英文變好的路還很長
You are right!We lack of confidence to speak English.
You not entitled to judge our Asian English ability. Whst s bummer thst tou dont soeak any Chinese gor kiving in Taiwan fir mire than onr decade. Shsme on you and uou are here to judge us
這麼多網紅影片
我喜歡看你的
除了內容有意思
你還有中英為對照
我可以學些生活英文
這是一個很重要的流量密碼
你千萬要把握好你和其他網紅的差 異
希望Allan 哥 不要講中文，因為我喜歡聽Allan哥講英文，再看Allan哥的中英文字幕學英文 ，哈哈哈哈
In my opinion, Taiwan does not need to become a bilingual country with English as the second official language. Here are the reasons: First, the widespread education in Chinese has already made it the common language, and there are almost no native English-speaking communities within the country. Second, it is impossible in today's society, unlike in colonial times, to introduce a large population of officials and workers from a colonial mother country to popularize the language. Moreover, Chinese has a very strong uniqueness, and the aggressive promotion of English would stifle Chinese character culture. The areas in Taiwan where English is heavily used are popular tourist spots and foreign companies, but these areas represent only a small portion of the entire population of Taiwan. Most importantly, the status of English as an official language is not related to the international perspective of citizens or the national competitiveness.
我的確怕被笑，怕尷尬，所以總是開不出口。現在科技發達，跟AI練習也是很好的解決辦法
其實就是沒在用就忘光而已，英文、美語要成為台灣第二語言，可能要等到台灣一半的人口是使用英文才有可能，不然國語、台語還是主流
If you want to improve the English education, you can't just provide classes. You need to creat an English environment such as English channels, speaking in English in schools.
Do you speak English?
No, I don't. Sorry.
真的完全就是我會講的
日本人的市民 也不太會英語啊 但她們的觀光發展也不因此受限…
Allan is like that stereotypical Asian FOB who just stayed with the local Asian community after immigrating to the US and never extensively conversed in English.
Over time, he learned bits and pieces of English but never became fluent because English is difficult.😅
(Sorry for poking fun at you. 🤣)
Honestly, it's just not that easy for a native English speaker to speak Mandarin fluently due to the tonal characteristics of Mandarin.
The minute changes in tone are hard to detect for some.
We should show grace to each other, especially if someone is actively trying.💙
Tone is my problem… I just can’t do it
I purchased ELSA already!
Thank you, English Uncle.
I believe that one day our country will become bilingual or multilingual. Currently, we are unable to achieve this because many older people do not speak foreign languages.😄
Making Taiwan a bilingual country would be particularly beneficial for society and the region, and it would bring significant changes to the nation as well. It's just a matter of time.
我相信，我們國家總有一天可以成為雙語或是多語國家，
之所以目前無法成為雙語國家是因為連高齡層問題不會外國語言的關係，
讓台灣成為雙語國家對社會及地域特別有幫助~
對國家也會有很大的改變~只是時間上的問題而已~😁
多學習一門語言當然是好事
不過台灣不會成為雙語國家
也不需要成為雙語國家
我覺得台灣是否成為雙語國家不那麼重要，重要的是每個人都能提升自己的外語能力，這樣對個人和國家發展都有幫助。Allan推薦的Elsa AI也不錯，用科技來提升英文能力，我也打算試試看。
Allan, sorry your request for a day off is denied. You’ll just have to make more videos for us to see. 😉
現在可能比較需要學越南語或印度語了
印度的印地語也只有一部份印度人會講，實際上當兩個不認識的或是不同地區的印度人見面時也都是說英語，因為印度語言多樣性太高，只有英文才是唯一共通語言，所以其實我的結論是臺灣還是要以英文為主
台灣講水準不是水平
We have been teaching English at public schools for the past 3 years here in Taiwan. We can tell you exactly how and when that confidence is lost.
But what we have to say might be a bit controversial for your comment section. Should anyone want to get the insights of two public school English teachers, they know where to find us.
Also The Elsa app was one of my go-to recommendations when we lived and taught in Vietnam. The app was developed by a Vietnamese And was one of the few apps that could really work with the tones associated with Vietnamese. I'm happy to see that it is still in use and has expanded quite extensively! ~JB
Maybe an interview on my channel would be a good place to start!
@@lifeintaiwan We should be able to make that happen. 😉 ~JB
我用了ELSA兩年 有幫助我發音 常讓其他移民朋友以為我在美國出生！在美國有很多移民不同的口音，但我覺得口音所然有幫助 但是重要是能溝通很重要‼️我在這裡認識很多印度工程師英文很好，也認識英文很爛的美國人！