MINECRAFT CHRISTIAN FAILS AT ATTACKING ATHEISM

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
  • #minecraft #christian #christianity #atheist #atheism #god #religion
    On a daily basis I have discussions with christians about what they believe and of course about the lack of evidence for what they believe.
    In those discussions, one central theme keeps returning over and over and over again: they don't understand what atheism is. They really don't.
    Sometimes, it LOOKS like christian apologists understand that atheism only is not believing the claim that a god exists. And then one minute later they make a totally silly remark that clearly shows that they don't understand what atheism is.
    Today, I found a youtube channel of a christian who talks about his beliefs and about atheism while building stuff in Minecraft. He made a video called “3 difficult questions for atheists”. This guy has 157.000 subscribers right now. So you christians must think that he is one of the best in addressing these matters. Let's listen to him and let's hope we finally find a christian apologist who understands what atheism is...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 247

  • @Bob-of-Zoid
    @Bob-of-Zoid Рік тому +11

    "I would rather have questions that can't be answered, than answers that can't be questioned" -Richard Feynman

  • @harryjr1133
    @harryjr1133 Рік тому +12

    I'm an atheist and I have pets. If anyone Christian or atheist hurt my pets. Their life wouldn't be worth spit to me.

  • @klebbe1
    @klebbe1 Рік тому +14

    Well, it's easy to make statements like "atheists can't explain this" when you fully ignore your burden of evidence for the baseless assertion that "God did it".

  • @marcies3789
    @marcies3789 Рік тому +26

    I like how his making a church in Minecraft is really just building a fortress with giant walls

    • @Revanbzn
      @Revanbzn Рік тому +6

      And he is building it all in cobblestone. Like a degenerate.

    • @aubreyleonae4108
      @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому +4

      And just as authentic as a real church.

    • @mr.commonsense
      @mr.commonsense Рік тому +2

      Bro, that was life in the middle ages summed up

    • @mr.commonsense
      @mr.commonsense Рік тому +2

      ​@@Revanbznhe collected the taxes from the poor, uses the cheapest material and pockets the rest

    • @dwaneanderson8039
      @dwaneanderson8039 Рік тому +6

      @@mr.commonsense But it's also a perfect metaphor for Christianity today. They're trying to protect their echo chamber from the outside world.

  • @tommyvictorbuch6960
    @tommyvictorbuch6960 Рік тому +58

    "Science doesn't know everything, religion doesn't know anything."
    - Aron Ra -

  • @mitvelkez
    @mitvelkez Рік тому +16

    The most important question I need to answer today is; what shall I have for dinner.

    • @AnnoyingNewsletters
      @AnnoyingNewsletters Рік тому +2

      *_Carpe cena_* ‼️
      [ _Seize the dinner_ ]

    • @OlivierGabin
      @OlivierGabin Рік тому +2

      Penne rigate al pesto for me. I'm pastafarian by the way...

    • @AnnoyingNewsletters
      @AnnoyingNewsletters Рік тому +1

      Small world. I opted for rigatoni. 🙂

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому

      You could have some good Borscht like I has last night.

    • @OlivierGabin
      @OlivierGabin Рік тому

      @@Dock284 I'm short of pampushka to go with it. Next week maybe...

  • @Dock284
    @Dock284 Рік тому +8

    I've been watching this guy for a while now and so I'm glad someone is finally reacting to one of his video's.

  • @dwaneanderson8039
    @dwaneanderson8039 Рік тому +5

    I value human life more than other species because I am a human and I value my own life. And as a social species, humans will naturally value other members of their own species over other species.
    BTW, in response to "God loves animals," he demands lots of animal sacrifices.

    • @pineapplepenumbra
      @pineapplepenumbra Рік тому +3

      If there's a religious person and a dog drowning, the chances are that I'm going to try to save the dog first.
      After all, isn't the religious person supposed to believe that they're going to Heaven when they die? So what have they got to be afraid of? The poor dog has no such belief.
      Also, if they're a muslim, then the qur'an says that allah plans ALL births and deaths, so if they die, why should they, or any of their muslim friends or family worry or whine?

  • @heiyuall
    @heiyuall Рік тому +4

    “God’s voice smells like burnt toast.”

  • @Toobielove
    @Toobielove Рік тому +22

    "Is a smart person's life worth more than a dumb person's?" My own personal opinion is yes! For example, if that minecraft guy and a current top physics scientist are drowning and I can only save 1 of them, I'd choose the scientist. Period! 😂😂😂

    • @aubreyleonae4108
      @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому +9

      If the physicist weren't there I'd go try to find one.

    • @markcostello5120
      @markcostello5120 Рік тому +3

      @@aubreyleonae4108 What to throw in the water?

    • @mr.commonsense
      @mr.commonsense Рік тому +2

      ​@@markcostello5120Lots and Lots of Lithium (it's the first column of the periodic table and the first metal with a free ion, that means it's pretty cheap and dangerous to throw in the water)

    • @aubreyleonae4108
      @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому +1

      @@markcostello5120 probably never find that physicist, but ill keep lookin'. At any rate what other guy ?

    • @aubreyleonae4108
      @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому +2

      @@markcostello5120 i don't know anything about a drowning. I wasn't there, no one saw me do it. You can't prove a thing.

  • @Bob-of-Zoid
    @Bob-of-Zoid Рік тому +3

    You are mocking religion!!!!
    And I love it!!!😜😂🤪🤣 The "You can go reproduce yourself" is so elegant compared to how I would have said it! You are a man of diplomacy and have the gift of oratory.

    • @pineapplepenumbra
      @pineapplepenumbra Рік тому

      We can, and should, mock religion, but what's funny is that so many religious people say, "god will not be mocked" while following books that massively insult any god that _might_ (unlikely though it seems) exist.

  • @meridianheights6255
    @meridianheights6255 Рік тому +6

    I love the narration. I can't stand the Minecraft visuals, though. His arguments are utter bollocks and Minecraft is boring and makes me dizzy. I love this channel content.

  • @tremas3329
    @tremas3329 Рік тому +5

    I value humans more than other animals(some humans less than some animals, if im honest) because Im human. I identify more closely to most other humans than most other animals because i can relate, empathize and understand them more. Pretty damn simple, and i didnt even have to refer to (what he thinks) athiesm is.

  • @jenna2431
    @jenna2431 Рік тому +3

    If I were a fly, I'd prioritize the flies. If I were a dog, I'm prioritize the dogs. Since I'm human I prioritize humans. At least some of them. And clearly NOT because they're all intelligent.

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +1

      Yeah and but if I had to chose chances are I'd save my dog over some random dude I've never met.

    • @FoxInnaHat
      @FoxInnaHat Рік тому +1

      @@Dock284 Exactly. If you dont account for any nuances, then you're proposing an objective moral value. which since they do NOT account for nuances then they arent wrong every time and therefor cannot be objective

  • @jimetal28
    @jimetal28 Рік тому +1

    You're dealing with people who can "read" the bible, look around at the world, and still believe what they do.
    What makes you think they would listen to anything being said by someone who isn't holding a bible.

  • @pollypockets508
    @pollypockets508 Рік тому +3

    The body count argument is so annoying. First off, it's generalizing an entire group of people. We are all exactly the same as Stalin. Forget about the good atheists like A. Phillip Randolph. No, we all have to be exactly like Stalin.

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +2

      It's like thinking that everyone with a mustache is like stalin or the german guy.

    • @NEXUSKNIGHT2
      @NEXUSKNIGHT2 Рік тому

      ​​@@sound.of.scienceWhich is strange considering that Adolf was a Christian when He started the Holocaust BUT He would not be a "True Christian" in their eyes

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +2

      Like calling black people inferior because most majority black countries are poorer than mostly white European nations.
      Makes no sense and is very silly and also VERY insulting.

  • @tomsenior7405
    @tomsenior7405 Рік тому +2

    Lovely. Christians just love to be persecuted, don't they. The whole "War on Christmas" nonsense is hilarious. My immediate neighbours consist of: A devout Catholic family, A Hindu family, A Muslim Couple, A gay couple, An Atheist, A lapsed Catholic and a widowed Christian. Starting 1 December, each window is filled with Christmas decorations. (I do not put up mine until Christmas Eve). The only empty window belongs to the Christian lady. It would appear that Christians are the only ones who are at War with the most wonderful time of the year.

  • @Szadek23
    @Szadek23 Рік тому +3

    I remember stumbling over this video. Stopped watching when he said something like "atheist are pro-choice because they don't value human life" and stopped there. There's so much wrong with that, I don't even know where to start. This person isn't worth listening to.
    Oh and for his question, human life isn't intrinsically worth more and that of other animals.We only feels that way because we are humans. If aliens came to earth, they would likely valaue themselves more than us, too (assuming they think somewhat simiilar to us).

    • @grahvis
      @grahvis Рік тому +1

      Valuing others members of your social group more than outsiders is a natural part of evolution. A lion values other members of their pride more than they do a human.

  • @grapeshot
    @grapeshot Рік тому +8

    My favorite one is if we come from monkeys why is there still monkeys🤦🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️

    • @debrabathurst7276
      @debrabathurst7276 Рік тому

      You’ve got to be joking… still trotting out this limp reasoning.

    • @Szadek23
      @Szadek23 Рік тому +1

      Which is like asking "If you came from your grandparents, why do you still got cousins?". A nonsense question from top to bottom.

    • @bunnykiller
      @bunnykiller Рік тому +2

      I had a guy tell me that and I asked him if his parents are still alive, he said yes, and then I mentioned he came from his parents why are they still alive....

    • @aubreyleonae4108
      @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому

      If fundies come from idiots , why are there still idiots ?

  • @Arlondev
    @Arlondev Рік тому

    I actually deboonked this guy in his comment section, idk if my comment is still up, I don't really care about continuing the conversation because it wasn't really going anywhere, but I'm glad someone with a little more experience is taking this guy on

  • @rrpostalagain
    @rrpostalagain Рік тому +3

    Well a fly’s life is obviously more important… to the fly. My goodness this is weak stuff.

    • @MrCanis4
      @MrCanis4 Рік тому

      And he kills them by the hundreds every day when he drives his car.

  • @justincredible.
    @justincredible. Рік тому +6

    He doesn't even know they're straw man arguments. He thinks he is making really good points, like all of them.

  • @topcat2069
    @topcat2069 Рік тому

    "Ignorant arrogance seems to be a major attribute of "plebeian" (low) christianity" with little or no understanding of science or truth".

  • @Bob-of-Zoid
    @Bob-of-Zoid Рік тому

    "Their arguments fail" says the guy who is failing more and more with every argument! Oh the projection!

  • @MgtowRubicon
    @MgtowRubicon Рік тому +1

    "We get our morality from our natural evolution as a social species.
    Wherein, our survival depends on our interactions with other people.
    Society applies very strong selective pressures, natural selection pressures, on us to develop natural empathy for family, friends, and fellows.
    This is where our morality comes from;
    you don't want to piss off all of your other peers by being mean to everybody around you because society will visit that back on you.
    People who are defects in how poorly they treat other people, they tend to be ostracized from the gene pool by imprisonment, banishment, or killed."
    -- Aron Ra

    • @FoxInnaHat
      @FoxInnaHat Рік тому +1

      "but.... but...... Humans am special!!!! that why we smart"
      ~ Someone, probably a Theist

  • @TReyeHD
    @TReyeHD Рік тому +1

    He probably made up all these arguments after not being able to answer a counter question from an Atheist last month.
    Their Bible also says "Live and let live" but they ignore that part. Cherry picking at its finest, mentlegen.

  • @jrpence
    @jrpence Рік тому +3

    Arguments based on nothing while literally building castles in the sky.

  • @NeilDegrasseTysonWithAKatana
    @NeilDegrasseTysonWithAKatana Рік тому +3

    Why does the title sounds like the result of a stroke ?

  • @bunnykiller
    @bunnykiller Рік тому +4

    Questions Theists cant answer... does gawd have hair, does gawd have body odor, what color are gawds eyes, does gawd have an accent, what does gawd look like, how old is gawd, does gawd age, why is gawd a cold blooded killer, if gawd knows everything do people really have a choice?

    • @FoxInnaHat
      @FoxInnaHat Рік тому +1

      well i mean they can answer it rather easily, they'll just tell you to take their answers on faith lol

    • @pineapplepenumbra
      @pineapplepenumbra Рік тому

      @@FoxInnaHat Hello again.

    • @pineapplepenumbra
      @pineapplepenumbra Рік тому

      There are some questions I ask that the religious NEVER answer.
      Such as:
      What makes you religious people so ARROGANT that you are all are so convinced that you couldn't be fooled by a multi-millennia old Uber-Angel?
      And:
      Care to play a game? It's called Rate Your God.
      The rules are simple, you rate your god from 1 - 10, with 1 being, _"I'm a mature, secure, relaxed, logical, intelligent, compassionate, loving god. I don't care if people know about me and I certainly don't care about being worshipped, rather, I want people to be nice and supportive to each other and other animals."_
      7 being, "You MUST worship me! If you don't, as I'm a petty, narcissistic being I will deny you when you die, and either kill you permanently, while rewarding those who did worship me with everlasting life in Paradise, or exile you to a place of extreme unpleasantness."
      and 10 being, *Worship me you scum! You DESERVE ETERNAL TORTURE! If you don't worship me I will burn you, I WILL BURN YOU FOREVER!!!"*

    • @Dylan-it5vi
      @Dylan-it5vi Рік тому

      No, no, no, no, no one knows, probably as old as time and space, probably not, do you mean nature? It doesn’t necessarily, if people aren’t aware of their unconscious and don’t chose their genes and environment do they really have a choice? Yes somewhat they can

  • @aubreyleonae4108
    @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому

    This is what happens when you drop acid backwards . . .

  • @Szadek23
    @Szadek23 Рік тому +3

    Can't tell if minecraftheist are worse than cartheist or not.

    • @davidcarney1533
      @davidcarney1533 Рік тому +1

      Cartheist is worse. They can directly interact with other human beings if they're not paying attention

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +1

      at least they are playing a fun game and not just sitting in their care (or worse driving in it)

    • @genitacles1725
      @genitacles1725 Рік тому

      I'd say better than a driving cartheist. Only in that it isn't endangering the lives of others.

  • @fatehound2607
    @fatehound2607 Рік тому +1

    Interesting to see a perspective of someone that despite us having different views, I sorta agree that their arguments are very weak now that I further analyze it. Good video, always enjoy watching atheist views it's good to be researching all people's point of view.

  • @Angel-Kitten
    @Angel-Kitten Рік тому +1

    Oh yes, the biblical god appreciates animals in the form of bloody sacrifices and the pleasant aroma of burnt flesh. In the exodus, he gave the people very detailed instructions about how to properly offer sacrifices to him.

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому +1

      What you don’t like the smell of bbq, you a vegan or something?
      You know they ate it right? Try again

    • @juanausensi499
      @juanausensi499 Рік тому +1

      @@eggheadusa Why should a being that doesn't need to eat, find any human food aroma pleasant?
      And they didn't ate the sacrifices, they burned them completely. But it's a shame they didn't do that. The story of the crucifixion would be much more interesting that way.

    • @Dylan-it5vi
      @Dylan-it5vi Рік тому

      Old Testament

    • @Angel-Kitten
      @Angel-Kitten Рік тому +1

      @@Dylan-it5vi is a holy book of Christians.

  • @andystokes8702
    @andystokes8702 Рік тому +1

    I can explain a lot of things from a naturalistic perspective. I do not need a belief in God to explain most of the natural phenomena I witness every day but I have to agree, I see absolutely no explanation either from an atheistic point of view or from a Cristian perspective to account for why Piers Morgan has a TV career. It defies all logic regardless of how you look at it.

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому

      Yes but that’s based on a simpletons world view, like if you boil your poop and the other guy doesn’t, does it really make you intelligent?

  • @Nexus-jg7ev
    @Nexus-jg7ev Рік тому

    This was some insufferable religious bogus... Btw, what's wrong with claiming that there are no gods?

  • @AntitheistHuman
    @AntitheistHuman Рік тому +1

    They say "questions for atheist" here and there and back and forth, as if they have anything to say about it anyways... religion does not answer anything, it's an obstacle in answering questions and discovering knowledge, as for example "proof your god exists" what a thrill that no theists can answer that without acknowledging it's magic it's wishful thinking it's "their feelings" and these is all translated to they can't prove it and they actually have no reasons to believe it other than their feelings, theism falls apart on itself.

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому

      You’re simply uncultured, theirs a reason every great civilization has a centralized religion. Even if it’s not real mythology is the most important thing in humanity.
      It’s fine to be a blind follower and believe what school or churches say but don’t dehumanize the other side.
      After all you npcs are equally as lame to individuals who can’t think for themselves.

  • @aubreyleonae4108
    @aubreyleonae4108 Рік тому +1

    I used to wonder why these chuckle headed, magician devotees never learned anything. Then I realized they've never left the room they're in which consists only of their own tiny group of tiny minded projectionists. "Dude, say what you will about union projectionists of days gone by, at least they had an ethos." Kodak would be so proud of this crew.

  • @TopLob
    @TopLob Рік тому +1

    Here's a question atheists can't answer: "Who are the atheist's Jesus?"
    (This is sarcasm, btw.)

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +1

      Insert Troll Face Here

  • @AbstractStew
    @AbstractStew Рік тому

    His first question is why is an animal's life worth more than an animal's life? 6:22
    That makes no sense.

  • @MrCanis4
    @MrCanis4 Рік тому +2

    This dude has questions for Atheists.
    Na, I don't understand your answer.
    I'll make up my own answers then.
    And as expected, totally nonsensical and dishonest answers.

  • @pollypockets508
    @pollypockets508 Рік тому +1

    Omelets aren't baked. Lol

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому

      I think they are, that is done in an oven, not in a frying pan... Just do a google image search for "baked omelet"...

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому

      Actually they usually are surprisingly enough.

  • @coeal2680
    @coeal2680 Рік тому +1

    Not just bad at arguing against atheism, also bad at Minecraft xD

  • @stevewebber707
    @stevewebber707 Рік тому

    Why is it that most of these questions for atheists, don't end up doing much aside from showing how bad the theist's answers are?
    Putting aside questions of who needs to answer some questions, I will not choose simplistic, and faulty answers to soothe my feelings.
    If theists are happy with such resolutions, that is their choice, but I feel sorry for them living with such a flawed understanding.

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому

      What flawed understanding?
      You’ve never seen passed the visible light spectrum
      What evidence do you have they are wrong and you right?
      You both are free to choose both wrong too.

    • @stevewebber707
      @stevewebber707 Рік тому

      @@eggheadusa The evidence is that they present horribly flawed arguments instead of evidence. If they present any arguments
      I am not going to outline every flawed argument I have ever heard from a theist. If you want to present one I can tell you why I think it flawed.
      Oh and have you heard of infrared goggles? Or other technological aids to perceive other frequencies of light? If you intend on speaking on the incomplete understanding we have of reality, it's weird to speak of electromagnetic frequencies that are rather well understood.

  • @randomperson5579
    @randomperson5579 Рік тому

    I love when people are just like "if you don't believe god why aren't you doing extremely heinous things everyday, how can you have morals" idk bro maybe the thought of "if i do a bad thing, i'll feel bad, or i'll be punished for it" works really well. if i'm gonna be thrown into prison for stealing money, that's a pretty good reason to not do it. then you get people who say stuff like "oh but without the law you'd commit crimes cause nothing is stopping you". Any sort of reward system works as a pseudo-government itself, christianity is a reward system, you do good, you're rewarded, you do bad you get sent to eternal damnation, Sounds a lot like how laws work in our world. what makes the christian bible the right one, why isn't islam right, why isn't mormonism right, every religion says they're the right one, but all say mostly the same thing, just believe what you want but don't belittle and harass others (which if they read the bible i'm pretty sure this is something that's mentioned multiple times, don't be a jerk).

    • @britaom3299
      @britaom3299 Рік тому +2

      Earlier today on another YT vid, some Christian was saying that "only the BIBLE can be a source of morality", and anyone who doesn't have the bible cannot have morality!
      Unbelievably arrogant and condescending... but I just had to ask him this:
      Do you think it is moral to FORCE a ra pe victim to MARRY her rapist?
      He said "no", obviously unaware that Deuteronomy 22:28-29 explicitly states that THIS is the penalty for r_ping a virgin.
      So where is HE getting the idea that this is morally wrong? Because it is not from his bible!

  • @theblackswan2373
    @theblackswan2373 Рік тому

    Spot on.

  • @johnchambers9836
    @johnchambers9836 Рік тому

    I'm an atheist
    I don't think human life I automatically more important than other animal life.
    Humans protecting other humans is an evolutionary trait to maintain the species. A wolf would rather kill a human thsn another wolf
    No war, no genocide, no murder was done in the name of atheism

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому

      Just shows how uneducated you are and biased blinded.
      Look into what the Soviet Union did to Christians, communist countries killed plenty of civilians because religion and plenty of petty murders too.
      The problem with humanity is tribal bias, you are the problem not your group or the other group. I blame individuals ignorance

  • @Inferno-hn3zx
    @Inferno-hn3zx Рік тому

    Religion is such a waste of time in life!

  • @justincredible.
    @justincredible. Рік тому

    There is animal sacrifice in his book.

  • @bradypustridactylus488
    @bradypustridactylus488 Рік тому

    According to this, divine command theory and objective morality muddled with Cartesian dualism are the definitive answer to the purely subjective question of why we treat human life differently from animal life. It is a boiler plate answer to a difficult question that occupies the minds of ethicists who work in drug testing, agriculture, entertainment, the military, and zoological gardens. Even though he claims a lot, he actually gives us no guidelines at all for these ethical dilemmas. He just blathers. His Christianity has no answers that work in the real world.

  • @Kinessmata-Akkadian
    @Kinessmata-Akkadian Рік тому

    Uh... We gamers and Minecrafters don't own this Kingdom craft guy. XD Rip him apart all you want.

  • @Dylan-it5vi
    @Dylan-it5vi Рік тому

    To your end point no his God doesn’t promote stoning people. That’s the false god people worshipped during the Old Testament Pharisees. then Jesus came and said “let he who without sin cast the first stone” - he’s a Christian so believe that

  • @camwyn256
    @camwyn256 Рік тому +12

    It depends on which human and which animal.
    I'm going to try to save my dog over Jordan Peterson any day

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +5

      I was thinking the same about my neighbor's hamster and any top brass of the third reich...

    • @rallyfeind
      @rallyfeind Рік тому +1

      The idea that you find it acceptable to have a list of any version of people that you would rather die than a random animals is not a win for your supposed humanity and morality. Animals kill as a response to needing food and to defense of self group like family. When you, a conscious and thinking human, engage in murder value and human life on an exchange rate then you lost the argument by participating at all. There is not a morality in having reasons beyond that of an animal for acting like one. If you need to use your mind to dream up an answer like these but you can't think to say "death is not a sacrifice of value" and stop having the talk then you are just the same in a different flavor. You are the loyal opposition to Christianity when you confine yourself to their moral frameworks. Bet I won't see a surge of Islamic and other religions being picked on the same at all. Food for thought while you fantasized about death and judging people like Christians.

    • @FoxInnaHat
      @FoxInnaHat Рік тому +2

      @@rallyfeind Ok cool story, but there is ALWAYS nuances to EVERY problem. Stop pretending to stand on some moral high horse. If you sit here and claim moral objectivity then its clear you have spent very little time thinking on those morals at all.

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      @@sound.of.science God is good and the devil is evil

    • @camwyn256
      @camwyn256 Рік тому +2

      @@Nathan-pj2yl except in with Job

  • @lash163
    @lash163 Рік тому +1

    Atheism properly understood is the belief God and gods don't exist.
    God belief has alot of implications in stuff like Metaphysics and Ethics, if you reject God belief, it's perfectly reasonable for a theist to ask how you account for things God belief traditionally did.
    Especially since that framing of this video is that people leave Christianity because it can't account for certain things

    • @ateriana5116
      @ateriana5116 Рік тому +3

      Atheism is to not believe that a god exists. It can include the believe that there is no god, but it's not the same.
      "God belief has alot of implications in stuff like Metaphysics and Ethics, if you reject God belief, it's perfectly reasonable for a theist to ask how you account for things God belief traditionally did." -lash
      Why are you asserting that those things have anything to do with god? God did it or the bible said so are not answers, but it's generally the only things that theists have.

    • @lash163
      @lash163 Рік тому

      ​@@ateriana5116 Yeah it seems that Sound of Science forgets Positive atheism is a thing in order to dunk on this Christian. In any case, even if you want to hold to that weaker version of atheism, it still rejects a God belief and all it entails.
      And God has a lot to do with Ethics and Metaphysics, God is literally posited as the foundation for all those things. If you don't understand that then what are you rejecting when you reject theism? It's perfectly reasonable for a theist to wonder how an atheist can account for this

    • @edisoncarter3841
      @edisoncarter3841 Рік тому +6

      So you couldn't be bothered to understand what atheism is.
      Do you believe in unicorns? If no, are you an aunicornist?
      Explain how metaphysics and ethics apply to your lack of unicorn belief.
      It might be easier if thiests give evidence of any gods before making assumptions about said gods.
      The Christian pantheon appears to have millions of gods to fit their specific sect since they can't agree on many specific attributes like a Build-a-god workshop.

    • @burke615
      @burke615 Рік тому +8

      ​@@lash163 An atheist could literally just answer, "I don't know," and be at once both more correct and more intellectually honest than a theist who posits an unproved entity as being that "foundation." If your "foundation" can't even be shown to exist, then your entire worldview is baseless. Start with proving that any god exists, rather than wondering why people who see no evidence for a given notional entity don't believe in it.
      You also prove the video's point by attempting to insert your own definition of atheism in your very first sentence, and then claiming that that is the "proper" understanding. It's weird how so many people who use the label reject that definition, if that's the proper definition. It's also weird because your reply shows that you know that what you defined is actually just a subset of atheism, "positive atheism" or "strong atheism." You seem to miss the point that if questions are being asked of "atheists" they should be related to all atheists, not just atheists who happen to collect stamps or whatever other subcategory you choose to misdefine as being "atheism properly understood." Either that or you were being intentionally dishonest with your "atheism properly understood" nonsense.

    • @silphiumforever
      @silphiumforever Рік тому

      Atheists don't have to "account" for anything, full stop. Metaphysics are conceptual tools. Humans are a tool-using species. Must all tools be physical objects? Why? And there are DOZENS of moral and ethical systems which do not rely on the supernatural. This line of thinking teeters on presup level "atheists must have something which does exactly what we say god does and in the exact same way and for the exact same reasons (except it isn't our god and we had better be able to prove whatever it is that isn't our god that does these things actually exists) or the cosmos will spiral into instant chaos." Nonsense. All that's left to say is: "if it wasn't for our god, then we couldn't even be having this conversation to begin with so that proves god right there." Pure childishness.

  • @Nathan-pj2yl
    @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

    God is good and the devil is evil

    • @Arlondev
      @Arlondev Рік тому +1

      God is a despot and neither of them exist

    • @Paolo8772
      @Paolo8772 Рік тому +2

      That's cute. Are you in your 1st year of preschool or the 2nd?

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому +2

      @@Paolo8772 no jackass he has autism

    • @eggheadusa
      @eggheadusa Рік тому

      @@Nathan-pj2yl I don’t care if you’re trolling or not, it’s hilarious.

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      @@eggheadusa okay

  • @tommyvictorbuch6960
    @tommyvictorbuch6960 Рік тому +19

    You can't be a Christian (or Islamic) apologist, and also be honest. One rules out the other.

    • @o-hogameplay185
      @o-hogameplay185 Рік тому +3

      you can't be religious and be honest at the same time

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +1

      @@o-hogameplay185 you can you are just ignorant in that case

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      @@o-hogameplay185 what do you mean by that please explain please

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      @@o-hogameplay185 please

    • @o-hogameplay185
      @o-hogameplay185 Рік тому +2

      @@Dock284 no. there isn't a single religion that can provide any proof of their claims. this means that despite what the evidence shows, you are dishonestly believeing in nonsense

  • @darrylelam256
    @darrylelam256 Рік тому

    Theist: Here are questions that atheist can't or have a hard time answering.
    Me: I can answer them easily. In fact I can even point out that your answers are not very good.
    Value is subjective, even if a god existed and placed a value on humans it would be that god's subjective value that we would have. Without a god to dictate what he values onto us its us who determine what is important to us, what has worth to us. We often see other humans as more valuable than other animals because we are human. This idea that god values humans is just pure BS as the vast majority of humans are going to go to a helll of some kind or be destroyed by the god that is claimed to value us. But the only humans that these various gods are going to value in the end are the few that are going to kiss their a$$ and be allowed into these claimed heavens.
    For example in christianity it doesn't matter how good you are. You could dedicate your life to helping others, you could care cancer, you could end world hunger, god is still going to claim that you are a sinner. That you are guilty of some crime and that you need to be punished with an unending torture unless you beg him to forgive you for failing to be prefect. We are all born sinners according to christian mythology, according to this sick religion none of us have even a chance of living up to god's ridiculous standards. He wants to punish every last one of us, unless we kiss his a$$ hard enough.

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      What the fuck is a theist please explain

    • @darrylelam256
      @darrylelam256 Рік тому

      @Nathan-pj2yl Theist: a person who believes in a god or gods.
      Really if you don't know something that basic you might want to refrain from commenting.

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому

      @@darrylelam256 theist is a bad word

    • @darrylelam256
      @darrylelam256 Рік тому +1

      @@Nathan-pj2yl Ok unless you start saying things that are even remotely intelligent I'm done with you.

    • @Nathan-pj2yl
      @Nathan-pj2yl Рік тому +1

      @@darrylelam256 okay

  • @bboybreaks6487
    @bboybreaks6487 11 місяців тому

    Why do you talk like that? People must look at you weird when you're ordering food or a pint down your local boozer 😂

  • @youtubeforkidz1394
    @youtubeforkidz1394 Рік тому

    The bible does account for brushing your teeth and also as a catholic you dont only adhere to the bible but also church teaching. As Catholics we are called to take care of our bodies so brushing your teeth would fall under that.

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +6

      Oh boy... No, the bible does not account for brushing your teeth. There is only people like you who try to bend the text of the bible into your own advantage.
      The bible also tells you to destroy a city that has turned to idol worship. What cities have you destroyed lately?

  • @gloeiende1
    @gloeiende1 Рік тому

    Thus?? An atheïst does not believe in the existenz of God(s)??? Can you explain that again????
    😆😆🤣😂

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +1

      OK, do you believe in the existence of pixies?

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +2

      I'm utterly confused as to what you are trying to ask here.

    • @gloeiende1
      @gloeiende1 Рік тому

      @@Dock284 Hé George!! What's you name??...*
      Well, there is no real question.
      Just making fun of people you have to explain the being of an atheïst over and over and over 1.000.000x....... again while it must be ferry clear now... (and still don't understand, but likely don't care.... *and already know the answer).

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +2

      Ferry clear? All aboard!

    • @gloeiende1
      @gloeiende1 Рік тому

      @@sound.of.science I think this guy and all the christian know all too well what “atheïsm” is.
      To them it means “to be undecided”, freefalling, no rope to hang on, not to know what they need to know, uncertainty if u wish.
      And that scares the living hell out of them.
      They lack the (cap)ability to analyze and/or research and understand the world and to find new grounds to stand on…..

  • @DissociatedWomenIncorporated
    @DissociatedWomenIncorporated Рік тому +1

    As an agnostic I get to laugh at both of you for thinking you’re the rational ones 😄

    • @PhrontDoor
      @PhrontDoor Рік тому +3

      As an agnostic, you have to accept that you are almost definitely an atheist.
      If you either assert that agnosticism means that you cannot KNOW if a god exist or that you cannot KNOW what a god is... then you cannot believe in a god.
      Agnostic isn't a mid-point on belief, it is merely a midpoint on KNOWLEDGE. And knowledge is a subset of belief.

    • @thefuzzman
      @thefuzzman Рік тому +1

      Agnosticism says nothing about a belief in god/gods. It describes knowledge of a god/gods. Two entirely separate answers to two separate questions. From my experience, when a person claims agnosticism, they're really an atheist that just doesn't want to be associated with "atheism", usually due to negative connotations. A person can be either agnostic theist (believes in God, but doesn't know for sure one exists) or agnostic atheist (doesn't believe and doesn't know). So where do you fit?

    • @DissociatedWomenIncorporated
      @DissociatedWomenIncorporated Рік тому

      @@PhrontDoor my knowledge matches my belief, my disbelief in a god or gods _and my disbelief_ in a lack of god or gods is equal. Both are absurd/incredible claims, both require extraordinary evidence. Don’t try to imperially assimilate me into your collective. My belief is that we are too primitive to even begin to try and answer questions about the existence or lack of existence of god(s) or of what is incorrectly labelled “the supernatural”.

    • @DissociatedWomenIncorporated
      @DissociatedWomenIncorporated Рік тому

      @@thefuzzman I reject theism and atheism equally, they’re both dumb.

    • @Dock284
      @Dock284 Рік тому +2

      Why exactly? I assume you think a god exists but you don't claim to know what this god is like. We claim that we don't see any evidence for god and thus don't believe in one. How is that irrational?

  • @BillGarrett
    @BillGarrett Рік тому

    "You've gone to Belief Buffet and put atheism on your plate, along with a bunch of other things from other sources, while I ordered the Combo Meal from Christian Chicken. Did your atheism come with a drink? Does it include vegetables? Dessert?"

    • @frozentspark2105
      @frozentspark2105 Рік тому

      It doesn't need to. Atheist's did not make the claim or promises. That's on religion to provide it

    • @BillGarrett
      @BillGarrett Рік тому

      @@frozentspark2105 that's exactly my point. Atheism is one component of a larger whole - one type of food on the plate, and one you can mix and match with many others

    • @frozentspark2105
      @frozentspark2105 Рік тому

      @@BillGarrett you don't know what you're talking about. You're all over the place

  • @youtubeforkidz1394
    @youtubeforkidz1394 Рік тому

    Im not going to answer the whole video because i have things to do but i will answer one part. Talking about how God killed so many humans because they simply didnt obey him. But he had valid reasons for it. In the case of the flood and when the israelites went and killed entire cities, it was because the people in those places were practicing horrible things and worshipping ancient deities by sacrificing children to them. That is why those places God commanded complete annihalation.

    • @sound.of.science
      @sound.of.science  Рік тому +4

      So your god murdered a million babies and children because some of their parents worshipped another god? And you call that a 'valid reason'. That is totally disgusting.

    • @juanausensi499
      @juanausensi499 Рік тому

      That's not a valid reason AT ALL. Even if they were horrible people who killed their own children (but obviously not all of them), i don't see the improvement made by killing everybody, INCLUDING ALL THE CHILDREN.