Dialogue with History Episode 14: Pakistan: On the Writing of Our History: GupShup with Aftab Iqbal

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @abrmuni569
    @abrmuni569 7 років тому +4

    One notable example of people's history of Punjab is _Babar Baani_ of Baba Guru Nanak. Guru Nanak wrote a number of passages about the _Mughal_ invasion of India. He describes the brutalities he eye witnessed first hand. Babar did not even spare houses of worships _Masjid and Mandir_ alike. These writings are now a part of _Granth Sahib_.
    Too bad, a Muslim Punjabi did not bother to read such writings of their past.

  • @TalootWattoo
    @TalootWattoo 7 років тому

    This is the best video so far, this man should on tv, he talks better than every anchor that appear on tv everyday.

  • @ypervaiz
    @ypervaiz 7 років тому

    Dr Mubarak Ali a living legend. Bravo Aftab sb. Thank you very much.

  • @irfanahmadjaleel1961
    @irfanahmadjaleel1961 7 років тому +1

    Very Informative. Thanks Aftab Sb. Your Guest is a Treasure indeed.

  • @mohammadnaeemarain2076
    @mohammadnaeemarain2076 7 років тому

    Geo my Sweet brother Allah pak apko Hasidon k Hasad or Dushmano k shar se hamesha mehfoz rakhe aameen

  • @wasimsahilsahil
    @wasimsahilsahil 7 років тому

    Aftab bhaiALLAH pak apko sehat tandrusti deALLAH pak apko apki family ko hmesha khush rkhay buri nazar se bachayeMy pray Always with you....

  • @muhammadziaullah3638
    @muhammadziaullah3638 7 років тому

    Dialogue with history is a great initiative to dissect history...please also talk about history of Khulafa i Rashadeen and Muslim supermacy in Europe

  • @asmaather9051
    @asmaather9051 7 років тому +2

    Very interesting discussion btw now the word Wazir e Aazm makes more sense as Mubarak Sb rightly said we use the word Aazam mostly for the killers and oppressors 😜

  • @ScientificInsan
    @ScientificInsan 7 років тому

    Buhat awla Buhat awla.... Jitni tareef ki jae kam hai Aftab saab..

  • @uetiancivilian05
    @uetiancivilian05 7 років тому

    Very good to see Dr Mubarak Ali on the show.. It will be good to invite some personalities who has the courage to tell us the real history; the history of creation of Pakistan and after creation of Pakistan; and can analyse different govts of Pakistan. An important thing i want to mention is " please suggest one book in every program" so that people can develop the reading habit because our schools never courage students to read books.
    Thank you for such a good show and all the segments are really good.

    • @AftabIqbalOfficial
      @AftabIqbalOfficial  7 років тому

      +Muhammad Habib thank you for the comments and feedback. We appreciate your support!

  • @UsmanW86
    @UsmanW86 7 років тому +1

    I really appreciate your efforts n have a lot of respect for you.. keep it up sir.. May Allah Almighty give you more strength.. to be honest I watch your programs for learning not only for entertainment.. I don't think that I have ever missed your programs..
    Wsalam
    Usman

  • @Rzi6878
    @Rzi6878 7 років тому +4

    keep it up aftab iqbal...
    ALLAH bless you ever n ever...

    • @AftabIqbalOfficial
      @AftabIqbalOfficial  7 років тому +1

      Thank you, Rizwan for your support. Please share with your friends and subscribe to our channel!

    • @ashfaqfarooqi7088
      @ashfaqfarooqi7088 7 років тому

      monument of gum naam soldier not enough for us? wo jo tareek rahoon mea maray gaey.

  • @eternalindian6714
    @eternalindian6714 6 років тому

    Excellent discussion.Feel myself enriched.It is true that we should not forget the history and journey of common mass throughout the civilization.But i would like to add as long as Pakistan does not emerge as a secular,progressive and tolerant nation-the distortion of history will continue.History is written by winners but it should not loss it's sheer objectivity.

  • @ahsanrauf6144
    @ahsanrauf6144 7 років тому

    Dr Mubarak Ali shb bohat bara kaam kr rhy hn

  • @Pakistani14747
    @Pakistani14747 7 років тому

    keep it up the good work.
    my inspiration Aftab Iqbal sahib

  • @sjsajju8852
    @sjsajju8852 7 років тому +1

    Mind opening show.Great

  • @rameeahmed2877
    @rameeahmed2877 7 років тому +1

    bohat khub aftab sab
    ..

  • @shahnazshabbir7418
    @shahnazshabbir7418 7 років тому

    Thats really great i realllyyy appreciate ur struggle to aware the ppl about their history. this is also a kind of "khidmat.e.khalq" Graet sir i wish ppl like u will b a clear guidline for us. At least v r getting true info frm somone in media!!!

  • @autodesk9994
    @autodesk9994 7 років тому

    Bravo, Superb. Thanks Aftab sb for ur efforts to enlighten us

  • @virasat69
    @virasat69 7 років тому

    Excellent episode thanks for making us aware of History

  • @abrar380
    @abrar380 7 років тому +1

    Love to see your videos i wish you upload a new one everyday

  • @sheryarking
    @sheryarking 7 років тому +1

    I love this show. 😍😍

  • @rajawasimandahar4163
    @rajawasimandahar4163 7 років тому +1

    great Aftab sahb

  • @numanarshad6584
    @numanarshad6584 7 років тому +1

    Very great show sir but I have a request that please also share those events of history of Pakistan that have contaminated by the state

  • @bobbybhalli7560
    @bobbybhalli7560 7 років тому

    Lajawab show

  • @adnanmirza9643
    @adnanmirza9643 7 років тому +1

    Nice video, and message

  • @ehsan960
    @ehsan960 6 років тому

    Very nice Aftab sab

  • @israrisrar390
    @israrisrar390 7 років тому

    grate aftab sir

  • @VillageTV
    @VillageTV 7 років тому

    nice show!

  • @AA-cz8kw
    @AA-cz8kw 7 років тому

    Respect for u aftab sb

    • @AftabIqbalOfficial
      @AftabIqbalOfficial  7 років тому

      Thank you, Atif, we are glad you are enjoying our content. We hope you will subscribe to our channel and share it with your friends.

  • @amitabhavajrapani2898
    @amitabhavajrapani2898 7 років тому

    great discussion
    now start teaching real history to pakistanis before the arrival of bin qasim in 8th century without untruths and fabrication

  • @abdulrehmanbuttbutt9366
    @abdulrehmanbuttbutt9366 6 років тому

    These Shows Are really informative. This shows Aftab Iqbal's sincerity but this will not prove much fruitful until we Bring Mass awareness among people and Set Good scientific and really educative books for students.. think about it

  • @hasnatshah2425
    @hasnatshah2425 3 роки тому

    Good topic

  • @Prince70065
    @Prince70065 7 років тому

    pls do episode on chengis khan and its conquest

  • @zohaibkhalid3022
    @zohaibkhalid3022 7 років тому

    doctor sab too good knowledge

    • @AftabIqbalOfficial
      @AftabIqbalOfficial  7 років тому

      Thank you, Zohaib for your support. Please share with your friends and subscribe to our channel!

  • @navidaj2195
    @navidaj2195 7 років тому

    great
    sir episode ka time thora sa brha da,

  • @tayyabroyal5431
    @tayyabroyal5431 7 років тому

    سر میں ایک سچا پاکستانی ہوں اور پنجابی ہوں اس لئے میں پنجابیوں اور سکھ پنجابی انکی تاریخ پوچھنا چاہتا ہوں کہ ہمارے پنجابی اس وقت کہاں تهے اور پنجابی مسلمانوں نے کب سے بولنا شروع کی اسکے علاوہ بریصغیر میں پنجابی کتنی بری قوم تهی مہربانی ہوگی مجهے پنجابی سے بہت پیار ہے اور آپ ہی اسکے بارے میں مجهے بتا سکتے ہیں کسی نے بهی مجهے نہیں بتایا ایک بار پھر سے آپ سے التجاح ہے کہ پنجابی کی تاریخ کا لازمی پروگرام کریں گے آپکا بہت شکریہ

  • @princesaqi9545
    @princesaqi9545 7 років тому

    nice

  • @BestCollectionOffical
    @BestCollectionOffical 6 років тому

    best sir keep it

  • @sheripk49
    @sheripk49 7 років тому +1

    sir cyrus k bary me b kuch btayen its a request plzzz😝😝😛

  • @ahmeddaood7858
    @ahmeddaood7858 7 років тому

    good

  • @Prince70065
    @Prince70065 7 років тому

    special request plzzz do episode on chenghis khan

  • @hassansardar5377
    @hassansardar5377 7 років тому

    I like this sHoW

  • @kungrani381
    @kungrani381 7 років тому

    Sir I want to know about the book, islamisation of Jinnah! What do you think about it?

  • @sjsajju8852
    @sjsajju8852 7 років тому +1

    RESPECT SIR
    IF POSSIBLE CAN YOU PLEASE NARRATE UN RESOLUTION WHAT POSSIBLY COULD HAVE BEEN DONE.AND AS A PAKISTANI AND INDIANA'S HOW WE SHOULD DEAL WITH IT.

    • @projecttitans
      @projecttitans 7 років тому +1

      I agree with him whats done is done... both Pak and India should move on now and try to improve relations and have mutual trust for the sake of the common people. I dream of a adya when India Pak will have open borders where we could move freely.

  • @muhammadasjad6900
    @muhammadasjad6900 7 років тому

    Alslam u elaikum sir,
    Aap ney Qaid e Azam aur Allama iqbal ki photo kiu nahin lagai

  • @islam4all-KL
    @islam4all-KL 7 років тому +1

    aftab sahb
    again wordless appriciation ...
    but sir one thing which i feel ever during watching your whole programs you always talk about Politics, Current affairs and many other topics,, but You never discuss The problems of the youth of Pakistan ... I think You should Do a separate Programe for it and give suggesion to GovT of pakistan for Removing youth problems and government should set a forum for resolving youth affairs
    thanks

    • @AftabIqbalOfficial
      @AftabIqbalOfficial  7 років тому

      Thank you, Mohsin, we are glad you are enjoying our content. We hope you will subscribe to our channel and share it with your friends. Thank you also for your feedback.

  • @bobbybhalli7560
    @bobbybhalli7560 7 років тому

    Yar ye kOn log dislikes kaR Rahe hain...?

  • @trshuk
    @trshuk 7 років тому

    why dont you Mention Sahir Ludhianvi he was local or Munshi Prem Chand

  • @liaquathayat809
    @liaquathayat809 7 років тому

    AoA Aftab Sahib SAP aksar tang per tang mehman ki tarf rakhtsy chain Jo a cha nahin lagta Thanks

  • @alibutt248
    @alibutt248 7 років тому

    aftab sahb turi c mehman ki recpect he kar liya...tang ko control mein rakeyin...hope so next time mehman ki recpect ka khyal karyin gayin....

  • @faisalmehboob3137
    @faisalmehboob3137 7 років тому

    Sir g app jo be berty log he un ko ley plz 👀💤💤💤

  • @umarfarooq6874
    @umarfarooq6874 7 років тому +9

    Sir g jab bethte hen to beshak tang pe tang rakhen pr bas guest ya host ki trf paon na kiya kren

  • @TalootWattoo
    @TalootWattoo 7 років тому

    nawaz sharif kay badnami ki roohani waja bhi bata dain, hum chahtay hain kay faisla aanay se pehlay ap humain wo waja bata dain. Faisla aa gaya to har anchor is case par itni batain karay ga kay ye roohani waja un main kahin gum na hojay...

  • @MrBshree
    @MrBshree 7 років тому

    ur leg is covering mahatma gandhi s face from camera angle....better dont use him if u cant respect him

  • @zohairazzak1226
    @zohairazzak1226 7 років тому

    Go nawaz go go ganjy go