full of knowledge, you are true pakistani sir, you are the reflection Sir Syed Ahmed Khan because you have the aim to make yours nation path right. Allah bless you.
Sir jab tak aap jese heere humare darmiyan zinda hain tab tak ilm o danish k charagh ye sone se kahi zada qeemati ilm ki roshni phelate rahen ge. Mujh Kam ilm k paas wo alfaaz ni hain jin se mein aap ki tareef bayan kr sakoon. Jazakallah Sir❤❤❤
Aftab Iqbal, such discussions needed to be discussed a long ago. History of India has been distorted amply by British, Marxist and Muslim historian for their own interest. Keep on posting such programmes of discussion.
Aftab Sahib, you deserve lot of compliments for organizing this great SHOW !!! We need more people like you to bring peace on this planet. Thank you. Iqbal USA
Very informative video. Aftab sir i am a big fan of you. I am watching your show. I want to meet you once in my life in your any show. You are a true man. I had been watched all your shows. From Azka Murtaza.
Beautiful show Aftab Bhai .. may Allah bless you and give you strength to keep on educating us on our history and rectifying us on the misconception we have been taught in schools about mughals and all the muslim rulers .. lastly please invite Sir Hassan Nisar in your show . Thanks
Sir I am One Of Your Fans I just want to request you to introduce a segment or even only a single segment on student-teacher,Parent-teacher And Child-PARENT Relationship that can have Useful effect on parents and teachers.And also some advice For the students to develop Moral Capabilities in them. And I must also congratulate You for this beautiful and informative platform CONGRARTULATIONS....
Thanks a lot Aftab Iqbal Sab for this worthless and very useful efforts/dialogue/information you providing us. Zamaana hogaya tha Tarrekh ka track bhool giya tha, distract hogaya tha tareekh sy, Aap ny phir say wo shooq lotaai hay. Mera Nam SAEED UR RAHMAN hay may Mardan ka rehnay wala ho. App kay sarry guests, aur participants ko appreciate karta ho. w Alaikum As'salam
One of the best Pakistani youtube channels out there. please continue these disscussions. Been dying to hear Dr. Mubarik Ali's perspective on these matters.
Sir it's great to hear from Dr Mubarak sir a small correction regarding this show Aligarh school had become aligarh Muslim University where Irfan Habib sir is a professor Emritus. So there is no more a Aligarh school
Really liked this discussion - Jingoism should we kept aside on both sides and rulers should be judged based on situation of his subjects and not based on his religion
Please discuss with Dr Mubarak Ali about pre Muslim Hindu Rulers of the subcontinent. Please also shed some light on the contribution of Indian subcontinent in modern day civilisation. One more topic that pakistani viewers deserve to listen to is the evolution of languages in subcontinent, specially Urdu, Hindi and Punjabi and their relation to each other.
Must continue Sir G. It is lit of knowledge off course. My question is this what is genetically missing in our selves that we hardly resist and gave tough time to our opponents in war? Is it the inherited dividing class system or what other aspects?
Very good program. But it is better to start in a sequence and discuss it in time frame or eras of different ruling family. History should be described in in an order either ascending or descending. In this way a common man will be able to understand other you will complicate his previous little knowledge
Bht zbrdst bat yh k hm ny apny heroes hi ghalat bna ly hn hme pta e ni k ik hero bnany ka miyar kia hy bs qabiz ajany waly ko hero maan lty hn.. Hmra mutala hi bht kam hy bs jo chiz fascinate krti hy usko adopt kr lete hn
Sir ap ka sho yorpe me sub se zada pasnd kia jata hai ham sub dost ap ka har sho mil beth ke dekhty hain.reely very nice sho mera pehla cumint hai ap ke sho me ap se aik requst hai ke aik sho un logun pe bi zaror karein jo ajent ki baton me ke apna ghar chor kar yorp me a ke kampo me bathy hain na kam milta hai na wapis ja sekty hai keyon ke lakho rupay lega ke ay hain ghar kesy jain samjh nahi ati ap hi koch mshwra dain ke kia karna chahye ham sub ko.plzzzz
Dear Aftab sb! I respect you a lot due to your knowledge. Sir! Being a loyal Pakistani, I feel quite upset on bad law & order situation in Pakistan. I request you kindly to talk about the law and order situation of other countries of our region based on true statistics so that we may get true picture and also discuss a solution for Pakistan to get rid of this embarrassing situation. Thanks
A very great episode again on the subject of history. Sir i have this question in mind about Hazrat Sikandar Zhulqarnain, the king who is mentioned in the Quran, why is he called by the name Sikandar?
Thank you, Kays, we are glad you are enjoying our content. We hope you will subscribe to our channel and share it with your friends. Thanks also for the feedback, we will take it into consideration.
Sir, if U specific few minuts in each prog. to describe the alexander's life from start to end, it will be helpfull for us to understand history related to that era.
I have one more request if you can discuss with Dr Mubarak Ali about the the claims of a alot of muslim clans and races in Indian subcontinent to have Arab origin. Why this claim is so significant to disassociate themselves from Indian subcontinent.
Both are incredible, is it possible for an ordinary pakistani to meet Aftab iqbal at his house?though most of the celebrity can meet him at his home comfortably and with privilge.
I’m literally keen of getting this sort of knowledge but i used to feel helpless to get it but your talk about our history is a great blessing❤️ Keep making more videos on history! I wanna know who we are, who am i?
Sir, its surely too late after the dialogue was uploaded. However, if it reaches you, can you please throw some light on raja ranjeet singh? In a sense that through history, when the outsiders have invaded sub=continent, was he a real local leader who stood as Punjabi ruler in Punjab?
This is probably the Supreme benefit of having internet. Sitting in Kolkata, I am listening to this amazing analysis.
Me too bro
full of knowledge, you are true pakistani sir, you are the reflection Sir Syed Ahmed Khan because you have the aim to make yours nation path right. Allah bless you.
Sir jab tak aap jese heere humare darmiyan zinda hain tab tak ilm o danish k charagh ye sone se kahi zada qeemati ilm ki roshni phelate rahen ge. Mujh Kam ilm k paas wo alfaaz ni hain jin se mein aap ki tareef bayan kr sakoon.
Jazakallah Sir❤❤❤
fascinating discussion... not just history... but on the history of varying histories...
Dr. Mubarak is really a great historian
Aftab Iqbal, such discussions needed to be discussed a long ago. History of India has been distorted amply by British, Marxist and Muslim historian for their own interest. Keep on posting such programmes of discussion.
Aftab Sahib, you deserve lot of compliments for organizing this great SHOW !!! We need more people like you to bring peace on this planet.
Thank you.
Iqbal USA
Chawal ka insan chutia
yes, the dialogue should continue
شکریہ آفتاب صاحب الله آپ کو سلامت رکهے...
Log Matlab de ameen
Interesting comments.
AADAAB ARZ HAY WE appreciate your way of discussion regards PRADEEP SOGANI from jaipur Rajasthan India
خبردار میں آج تک ڈاکٹر صاحب کی باتوں کو بطور حوالہ کے سنا تھا آج آپ سے سامنے آمنے گفتگو نے بہت مزہ دیا ..
Eye opener.
Thanks a lot.
سر آفتاب اللہ پاک آپکو صدا سلامت رکھے اور ایسے ہی ہماری صلاح کرنے اور ہیمیں معلومات دینے کی مزید توفیق دے
آمین ۔۔۔
You and your shows always best
bohat a6a Aftab Sb Allah PAk ap ko or Izat ata farmay....... Ameen.......
Very informative video.
Aftab sir i am a big fan of you.
I am watching your show.
I want to meet you once in my life in your any show.
You are a true man.
I had been watched all your shows.
From Azka Murtaza.
Beautiful show Aftab Bhai .. may Allah bless you and give you strength to keep on educating us on our history and rectifying us on the misconception we have been taught in schools about mughals and all the muslim rulers .. lastly please invite Sir Hassan Nisar in your show . Thanks
Thanks Aftab sir for giving us this beautiful video clip and awaring us about historygreat work👍
Sir I am One Of Your Fans
I just want to request you to introduce a segment or even only a single segment on student-teacher,Parent-teacher And Child-PARENT Relationship that can have Useful effect on parents and teachers.And also some advice For the students to develop Moral Capabilities in them.
And I must also congratulate You for this beautiful and informative platform
CONGRARTULATIONS....
Itne great Historian se milwane ka bohot shukria Aftab sab
what a knowledgeable short clip,
Thank you Aftab Sir,
Dilawar Ghumman I agree with you
Thank you, Dilawar and Shakeeb, we are glad you are enjoying our content. We hope you will subscribe to our channel and share it with your friends.
just thank you sir....
I dont know Dr. Mubarrak Ali very well but plz request them to come again and again...plz
Thanks a lot Aftab Iqbal Sab for this worthless and very useful efforts/dialogue/information you providing us.
Zamaana hogaya tha Tarrekh ka track bhool giya tha, distract hogaya tha tareekh sy, Aap ny phir say wo shooq lotaai hay.
Mera Nam SAEED UR RAHMAN hay may Mardan ka rehnay wala ho.
App kay sarry guests, aur participants ko appreciate karta ho.
w Alaikum As'salam
One of the best Pakistani youtube channels out there. please continue these disscussions. Been dying to hear Dr. Mubarik Ali's perspective on these matters.
Thank you Dr Mubarak Ali sahab app ne jo history is qoum ko bataye hai uski tarif ke qaabil hai...
loving this series sir..thank u so much from Qatar...Tipu Sultan k baare me agahi ata karenge to kafi concepts clear hojaenge...muntazir
Sir it's great to hear from Dr Mubarak sir a small correction regarding this show Aligarh school had become aligarh Muslim University where Irfan Habib sir is a professor Emritus. So there is no more a Aligarh school
Really liked this discussion - Jingoism should we kept aside on both sides and rulers should be judged based on situation of his subjects and not based on his religion
very nice ...duration thora bharayen aur dr sahib sey agar isiee topic pr aur khuch baat hu tu bara acha hai
i love Dr sab so nice of you Aftab sab thankssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
very nice n very informative .thank u very much aftab sahab.
Please discuss with Dr Mubarak Ali about pre Muslim Hindu Rulers of the subcontinent. Please also shed some light on the contribution of Indian subcontinent in modern day civilisation.
One more topic that pakistani viewers deserve to listen to is the evolution of languages in subcontinent, specially Urdu, Hindi and Punjabi and their relation to each other.
treasure of knowledge aftab sahab such great job with dr mubarak ali
Must continue Sir G. It is lit of knowledge off course. My question is this what is genetically missing in our selves that we hardly resist and gave tough time to our opponents in war? Is it the inherited dividing class system or what other aspects?
Who told you read real history rajput resited almost 600 years than Maratha,jat,sikh,ahom.
Great My Teacher Sir Aftab Iqbal Sahb
A very well informed programme keep up the hard work and keep discussing
Very good program. But it is better to start in a sequence and discuss it in time frame or eras of different ruling family. History should be described in in an order either ascending or descending. In this way a common man will be able to understand other you will complicate his previous little knowledge
very well composed program, full of knowledge just in 15 minutes Super. Please invite other scholars too. Thanks
100% true as per the history we are taught here in India. Seems like I am revising my History text books of 11th class- Mideval India.
Bht zbrdst bat yh k hm ny apny heroes hi ghalat bna ly hn hme pta e ni k ik hero bnany ka miyar kia hy bs qabiz ajany waly ko hero maan lty hn.. Hmra mutala hi bht kam hy bs jo chiz fascinate krti hy usko adopt kr lete hn
Dr. Mubarak is right in his analysis. It all depends on the perspective of people or the ruler.
Sir ap ka sho yorpe me sub se zada pasnd kia jata hai ham sub dost ap ka har sho mil beth ke dekhty hain.reely very nice sho mera pehla cumint hai ap ke sho me ap se aik requst hai ke aik sho un logun pe bi zaror karein jo ajent ki baton me ke apna ghar chor kar yorp me a ke kampo me bathy hain na kam milta hai na wapis ja sekty hai keyon ke lakho rupay lega ke ay hain ghar kesy jain samjh nahi ati ap hi koch mshwra dain ke kia karna chahye ham sub ko.plzzzz
Aftab Iqbal sb kindly suggest the history books too for viewers.
Liked your unbiased description of history
It is sad to see we glorify foreign invaders like Alexander and not local heroes like Raja Porus who died defending our mother land
loved to see dr. mubarik ali
awesome hopefully we will get more of Dr mobarak Ali :)
Praise the historian for putting the right view to us.
wonderful sir ..
Very interesting
superb
I think the narrative should be current to give a direction to the Nation.
fantastic job keep it up
Dear Aftab sb! I respect you a lot due to your knowledge. Sir! Being a loyal Pakistani, I feel quite upset on bad law & order situation in Pakistan. I request you kindly to talk about the law and order situation of other countries of our region based on true statistics so that we may get true picture and also discuss a solution for Pakistan to get rid of this embarrassing situation. Thanks
thanks sir
Sir u prove what u always said that acting matter not actor ..every new chracter u bring in khabardar is more funny & interesting .love u Sir
Thank you Aftab Sir,
A very great episode again on the subject of history. Sir i have this question in mind about Hazrat Sikandar Zhulqarnain, the king who is mentioned in the Quran, why is he called by the name Sikandar?
Kindly bring a video everyday thx
sir thnx fr awaring us about history...plzz tell us about changez khan and halaku history with ahmad shah abdali being a critic plzz
Thank you, Kays, we are glad you are enjoying our content. We hope you will subscribe to our channel and share it with your friends. Thanks also for the feedback, we will take it into consideration.
Thanks to video upload
very good Aftab sahb
Sir, if U specific few minuts in each prog. to describe the alexander's life from start to end, it will be helpfull for us to understand history related to that era.
+Arif Ali we have dedicated a few episodes to Alexander already. Did you watch those?
Sir, I watched just one episode.
ap history ko bohat khoob andaz se bayaan krte hen tamam pehlu agar aam awaam ke samne ain gay to mochi behnsa jaise log fitna nae kr pain gay
aftab Sahab Zara Roshni Uswa e hasna or Khulafa e Rashdeen ke Adwaar per b de jiye taa k hum sab Apne mazbat se mazeed agah ho saken.. thank u
اسلام و عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
MASHAALLAH very nice
thanks sir for educate
very nice information
sir khabardar main butt sahb Nazar nahi aatay Kia wajah hai
Mr Aftab iqbal you are doing Good
THANK YOU SIR YOU HAVE DONE A GREAT JOB.
bahut aahla
Sir am a fan of your channel
Very nice show
I have one more request if you can discuss with Dr Mubarak Ali about the the claims of a alot of muslim clans and races in Indian subcontinent to have Arab origin. Why this claim is so significant to disassociate themselves from Indian subcontinent.
Sir you are doing a great job
thnx sir
Special request Plz do episode on chengis khan
Nice work
Thank you Nusrat for your support. Please share with your friends and subscribe to our channel!
GupShup With Aftab Iqbal Welcome, any time
GupShup With Aftab Iqbal iLike you Aftab bhi
❤️ from INDIA
How to meet you sir??.. Amazing show..
Both are incredible, is it possible for an ordinary pakistani to meet Aftab iqbal at his house?though most of the celebrity can meet him at his home comfortably and with privilge.
Sir please suggest books for reference of your discussion.
Sir g sultana rizya per be
Superb 👍
Ottoman history episode should be included bc its a great islamic empire which influenced west and east
NICE Discussion...
Salam, excellent initiative.
I’m literally keen of getting this sort of knowledge but i used to feel helpless to get it but your talk about our history is a great blessing❤️
Keep making more videos on history!
I wanna know who we are, who am i?
I love you sir
very nice sir g
Plz carry on sir g...
Sir what do you say about saladin
sir plzz make second clip,,
Good
Sir, its surely too late after the dialogue was uploaded. However, if it reaches you, can you please throw some light on raja ranjeet singh? In a sense that through history, when the outsiders have invaded sub=continent, was he a real local leader who stood as Punjabi ruler in Punjab?
Nice Sir Aftab
good sir ge
Well done from Hong Kong
Dear sir where do you think King Aurang Zaib is because he was the one who ruled over complete India After Ashoka
Well done ✅👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻