What's point in them getting support in keyrela? Stalin is one of the most corrupted politicians in TN. Oru mairum arinjooda ennittu sappotta adikkaan nadakunnu. Kurishu theevravadhi naari.
Been born in tamilnadu, have always thought our state is poor and underdeveloped. But now as a public sector employee, going around the nation, i could feel how blessed we are. Most people are poor and don't understand why they are poor. No one has a right and no one cares to question it.
@@rohitramesh8502 how many times have you been a finance minister to judge if he is good and the other once is bad? whats your criteria for being genius? when manmohan singh was priminister 2 times, how many people called him hitler? you people use some common sense or you are just follower of anti india parties?BJP own election not like on these people had votes and been leaders
@@Shreenapp Not only english subject matter also. Can Annamalai, a State President of a National party and a former IPS officer answer such powerful questions?
I clicked thinking that I will listen 5 mins...I ended up listing to the whole interview. What a thought provoking conversation. Everytime I am awe of this man. Hope he becomes PM of the country and improves the lives of not just TN but all. God bless him and his family.
remember they are all corrupt from head to toe and they are commission,collection,corruption govt,only this fellow talks as if they are do gooders, actually what is happening in tamilnadu for all the ills now facing because of these corrupt people and most of the ministers of present government indulged in corruption and amassed wealth in untold proportion.guys who don't have resources to feed their families now owning schools and medical colleges thousand and thousands of land parcels allover tamilnadu.what is ridiculous is the fact that for just 67 crores Jayalalithaa was sent to prison and these fellows who swallowed thousands of crores of public money throwing away to gullible poorest people mere two hundred rupees to procures their votes and swindle more and more,judges of the courts were district secretaries of this party and looking other wayround to help these goons escape,such is the situation here.
@@alonzo_go Hello, he did mention a 3rd criteria, which is "proven track record" and you are not highlighting to malign TN FM purposely fake id pappan dog!!
This is the first ever interview where Mr. Thapar is at the least interrupting mode. Isn't it? How brilliant and rational Mr PTR is in his articulation!
PTR is full of well articulated noise than real substance. The anglo-saxon Karan Thapar is his best listener. Look at what happened to Lehman Bros where PTR was Head of Trading. We had a gambler for a Finance Minister in Tamil Nadu. In a way it is good he is not Tamil Nadu's FM anymore. Thief Stalin woke up to the reality and moved him out of Finance.
We salute Mr Thiagarajan Minister of finance Tamil Nadu . I am from Kerala. I also speak and write Hindi. I fully agree with the 2 language policy of regional language and English as common language as suggested by him . He is a real thinker. He should be a national leader.
@@MeMe-sy5xp On a recent trip, the officer at the immigration desk kept on asking me questions in hindi but I politely told him that my hindi is very weak and I kept on replying in English - I think he has got the job by recommendation and cannot speak English at all.
*"Since every school in India teaches English, why can't it be our link language? Why do Tamils have to learn English for communication with the world and Hindi for communications within India? Do we need a big door for the big dog and a small door for the small dog? I say, let the small dog use the big door too!"* - MR.Annadurai Our Late CM of Tamil Nadu
Well said! This is hard to understand for some poeple. Many of my north Indian friends always ask why you don't speak Hindi? It's our national language. hehe. Trust me, it's really hard to explain.
I am listening to this interview for the 10th time. All the times I felt that this interview ended abruptly and it should have continued for another 30 minutes or more. It contained valid and intelligent questions and suitable and enlightening answers. Conversation between two geniuses and quite interesting to watch
P Thiagarajan has argued in a logical, clear and convincing way that makes it difficult to disagree with his point of view. Tamil Nadu is lucky to have such a clear headed finance minister.
Somebody being eloquent makes them good at "being eloquent." Track record and work speaks. By that way, all standup comedians would have become great leaders. Work should speak first, and then the person.
I believe that the Tamil Nadu State Finance Minister has clearly exhibited the civilised and humane attitude of the South Indian population. Great!!!!👍👍👍👍
South has no need to prove anything to persian immigrants who are the norths of india... Education+patriotism makes all the difference. See our finance ministers track record.... If possible understand and adopt....
@@sushmachandak3316 hae sushma i dono where u r frm.. but if u are from tamilnadu..please check ur name too.. thanks..and by the by I'm not accusing u.. it's everyones basic right to choose religion, name, food etc..Thanks.. God bless
Hats off to PTR. Each and every word uttered by him comes from his mind. I read a comment which says that PTR is a ray of hope in these difficult times. I endorse this statement.
A good interview, no political remarks, blame-game or deriding of individuals or parties. A real sincere discussion of current realities and concerns of our country's future. And PTR has proved himself to be an optimistic patriot who is interested in finding solutions for the myriad problems the country is facing.
@@manchikantimurty7375 no. Partly true. Former tn cm and dmk president, mr. M. Karunanidhi was the man who identified him and give IT wing president in 2006 to 2011 dmk government. He insisted ptr 2 come to politics. Now ptr asked for different department after winning 2021 TN MLA elections. But stalin changed his department and gave him Finance and Human Resources Department. Stalin only changed his posting. Thats all. Only karunanaidhi introduced him into dmk n politics.
Very well done Honb'l minister, you proved yourself. After a long time, sensible and appreciable answers made Karan spellbound. You correctly said many IAS think or others think that all of them are 10-headed Ravana's and 20-handed to keep hands in 20 committees. experienced officials agree with me that they are good organizers but poor knowledge but boast that they know everything in fact they do not know anything but steal facts and knowledge from one officer's specialist and pass it on to another committee as if they know it but in fact, all of their ideas are borrowed. They work with authorities but with no real knowledge in anything. Putting them in many and various committees only makes them feel proud and they can not do justice to any one committee. so hereafter one officer should have one portfolio only so that they can think make ideas rather than symbolically chairing and taking a salary. we should change at least now after 75 years of independence to become independent of IAS. They were appointed because there was no specialist and now many experts are available so the IAS should be phased out slowly as they are part of political corruption and not doing their constitutional duties in spite of the constitutional post they occupy. Most of them are greedy for money and power. They should leave specialist departments only to be administrative. All heads of the department post to be given to concerned department specialists who are working in their department for many years. If anybody is not fit to be head of the department they should resign and go home.
Don't be fooled. Come pay a visit to TN government schools and you still see the nonsense. PTR is just a drama king, most of what he says is just lies. TN has the highest debt after Punjab and it's traveling towards financial ruin. People vote on freebies and money (yeah pathetic, this culture was started by dear PTR s party. Corrupt to the core)
எங்களுக்கு இந்தியா நாட்டின் இன்றைய நிலை பற்றி நல்ல புரிதலை கொடுத்துள்ளீர்கள் மதிப்பிற்குரிய PTR Sir. இன்றும் என்றும் துணிவுடன் உங்கள் கருத்துக்கள், அறிவுரைகளை கொடுங்க சார்.. வாழ்க தமிழ்! வளர்க தமிழ்நாடு!!💕💞💞
when we were born and raised in TN, we were always unhappy and critical of DMK/ ADMK`s etc.. but after growing up and visiting many other states we feel our state is much better in many aspects like infra developments, schools, public transport, services, healthcare etc.
You are right. The local elitist view of tamil population is carefully nurtured and fine tuned perception by media controlled by brahmins.their views are supported by orthodox upper caste people. Not everyone of them,but still they are very vocal, and they extended this view through social media.their educational background helps them. If one has an unbiased view as a commoner i will give the dravidian parties 60-70% marks,despite the stigma of corruption that is deliberately painted on them.
Wow Dr. PTR huge Respect, we are in awe of you, India 🇮🇳 is in dire need of such leaders,...it would be great to have him as the Finance minister of India 😍👍🏼🇮🇳.. Thank you Mr. Karan Thapar for your fearless n forthright journalism 🙏🏼
@@bhargajavarao8614 lol Modi? just Gothra famous guy is rewarded for his hatred against the Minorities ,when it comes performance the man a real Chaiwala sells pakoda well
Never seen Karan Thapar listening to somebody without interrupting for such a long time. Seems Thapar enjoys the never seen, heard ideologies from a politician from South in such a smooth flowing English.
As u said this is very true... Mr. Karan has never listened anyones words .. He intrudes inbetween ... We cant see a discussion like this in next 10yrs atleast ...
Listening to Mr. PTR, I am wishing I should be living in Tamilnadu...his vision and facts are so clear for states as well as the country...people like him should get into national politics and represent India 👍👍
@@radhikakumar2331 Yes. Definitely people of north will not understand PTR's vision and politics and they don't allow him to play any role in national level.
Sir, Our people favour tainted, not gentlemen. Majority of hindu people still believe that deliverances to this nation come by the hands of modi and bjp rss. The very sad thing are, a section of slavery minded tamil people (gujarati's shoes lickers) mingled with bjp rss, seeking all possibilities to uproot Tamil Nadu Government (we are citizens of this state).
@@radhikakumar2331 for more comedy you should see modi runing away from Karan’s interview few years back. You can also have fun along with Rs2 you got from BJP
How coherently he linked the sense of self-respect, to rationalism and political self-determination!!! Only a truly well read and wise person can speak with such intellectual clarity. Thank you TN for electing such a great leader. Hope to see him steer the country from the center in the future.
ஐயா தங்களின் அறிவிற்கும் ஆற்றலுக்கும் தெளிவிற்கும் தங்களின் தைரியத்திற்கும் மனம் நிறைந்த வாழ்த்துகள். உங்கள் உடல் நலத்திலும் அக்கறை கொள்ளுங்கள். இந்தியாவிற்கே சொத்து நீங்கள்.
Certainly one of the best interviews in recent times, and quite timely too. PTR was forthright, to the point, and immensely sensible - frankly, something quite uncommon in these times of empty rhetoric, false narratives, jingoism and worse. We are lucky that some parts of the country has not descended into insanity. And yes, would like to thank Mr Thapar for bringing in the oft forgotten part of India into the picture.
Man you are wonderful, upright,articulate,illustrious and on top an honest journalist. People should be forth coming to subscribe your great show. I'm a Pakistani and an arid listener. May God bless you.
Respected Mr.P T R, We are proud to have you as as our finance minister... None before you had given a clear and spectacular replies to many questionnaires. Your encountered reply over their question fired is applaudable.. 🙏
I think this interview is worth translating into all the Languages of this Union and spread across... As Thamizhian We are very of you Mr.Thiagarajan... As Karan Thapar has told at the end of the interview, take care and Long live...!!
In the larger interest of the nation the IT wing of DMK should translate this interview in all languages and also release the video with sub titles in local languages to ensure the Dravidian model of governing should reach all over India. Great salute to PTR Sir
Wow, I usually don’t like to hear 30 mins or more videos, but this one even after finishing I felt like I couldn’t get enough, feel like listening to more. Thanks Mr Thiagrajan for taking up this career, it makes such a big difference to the people of nation
Foolish DMK is dividing people artificially based on the disproven Aryan Invasion Theory. Dravida separatist movement was created and supported by the British, to keep India divided. No other Dravida people or party in the South support the divisive policies of DMK. These divisive traitors should not be elected by the people.
Wish I could convey to him how well he puts his thoughts across in not only this but all his interviews. Such a refreshing change to hear a statesman and not a politician
This is THE JOURNAISM THAT WE NEED. ONE OF THE MOST CREDIBLE JOURNALIST N THE MOST RESPECTABLE FINANCE MINISTER. INDIA NEEDS SUCH EDUCATED SENSIBLE PEOPLE AT THE HELM. AWAKEN INDIA JAI HIND
But unfortunately for our NATION....we now have forced as condendemd sin by having SHEER MAD TRAYANT that too a FRAUD, FANATIC Above all an NATION'S. HISTORICAL record who is a BEARER of Fictiouse DEGREE....n....in turned virtually a ILLITERARATE guggler!!!🙏💐🍀🛐🤗
@@drstanlypinto251 The miracle of india will be short lived if the cow belt remain perpetually tantalised by the rabble rouser.Ram, cow and mandir can belt up the Hindi belt, rest of india ll opt for a better alternative.
The most astonishing part of this interaction was about how the so-called "Hindi-belt" states like UP, Bihar, MP etc. have lost their own languages and dialects just because many of those were a subset of Hindi...It is nice to see Mr. Thiagarajan being sensitive about those lost languages as well while rightly defending their stand on why they oppose imposition of a "Three-language policy" or Hindi imposition on Tamils...It puts a mirror on the Hindi speaking states that this is how we can make language diversity a matter of pride for the nation...
This is the reason behind, why we tamils opposed the hindi to dominate our day to day life under compulsion. Learning any language is subject to the choice of the peoples. You can't force us to follow your dictate.
@@indianfrontline we do have people in the "North" who understand this emotion...we understand that nobody is there in TN (except for probably a rare group of people which are omnipresent) who hate Hindi or anything...the hatred is against the imposition of Hindi rather than Hindi itself...it is already evident through our conversation that if thoughts are similar or if people really want to communicate with each other, then language is not that big a problem...but my friend, I really believe that this issue is not among the common people, it is the politicians who haven't been able to achieve anything for their people, and yet they want the common people to have an opinion about something that such politicians crave for...At the same time, the common man also feels proud to have an opinion about something they feel seems to be related to "National Interest" and since they don't have any distinct opinion about it, they tend to take the stance as their own leaders...
@@abhisheknigam2918 Thanks for your understanding that tamil people dont oppose hindi as a language many people here study hindi. Opposition is on imposition only.
To listen to PTR is so refreshing; so enlightening. His mastery over language, facts and figures and marshalling of points, and the articulate and down to earth manner in which he conveys them with out being rhetorical is amazing. He is a rare intellectual politician or should I say a thorough bread financial professional that our country needs. He calls a spade a spade. He will go places India needs to tap his experience and expertise. I salute him for what he is doing for the country.
Brother remember he is a tamilian. We are the people who taught everything to this world. We are all one in this world don't discriminate the people of this world, by forcing oneself on another, the black are the first humans on this world, Remember that always.
First of all as a tamilian we thank to our honourable CM M K Stalin to select Mr PTR as a finance minister of T Nadu then only we came to know that how talented he is. In my point of view english fluency is not talented but the points he delivers in his own style is appreciable and also answering questions in any matter rapid and valuable reply is superb PTR sir please keep it up and go ahead in your own way
When GST council was formed where was Mr PTR voice ? He has come from wealthy family background & I do agree Qualified but spent his most of life in USA, Now He is spending his retirement life with minister portfolio ….
A very interesting interview. Mr Thiagarajan has explained all issues clearly and fearlessly. He has avoided direct attack on PM but has indicated his incompetence and dictatorial style succinctly. Human nature finds way to normalise conditions and capacity to bring down powerful, dictatorial regimes with Hitler and Indira Gandhi's examples. The interview focussed more on issues confronting the citizens rather than a political slugfest.
An intelligent leader with clear ideas and views,very optimistic.Really India Today is a miracle and wish it will live forever. Karanji thanks for arranging this one.
IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO ELSE...JUST NOT YOU...THESE GOLDEN WORDS SHOULD BE REMEMBERED BY ALL IN 2024. It was a Pleasure & an Honour to listen to someone as enriched as Mr.P Thiaga Rajan.
It was one of the best interviews I watched. PTR's clarity of thought, his sense of history, and the understanding of the current economic and social issues are commendable. His faith in the capacity of Indians to bring positive change is grounded in reality. Congratulations to both PTR and Karan
தமிழ்நாட்டின் கல்விதரம் அறிவு ஆற்றல் நாட்டின் பொருதாரவளர்ச்சி திட்டமிடுதல் ஆகியவற்றில் எப்படி சிறந்து விளங்குகிறது என்பதற்கும் தமிழ்நாட்டுமக்கள் சிந்தனை எப்படி இருக்கும் என்பதற்கும் தமிழநாடு நிதி அமைச்சர் திரு. PTR.தியாகராஜன் அவர்கள் ஒரு நல்ல உதாரணம்
What a fabulous, hope-filled discussion based on facts and a love for country, it’s history as well as its future! Thank you Mr Thapar for bringing fearless journalism since many many years 🙏👏🏼 Thank you Mr PTR for your insights, clarity of thoughts and rational responses. This was a balm to anxious nerves, for hearts that beat for the motherland even while being far away 💕
Very well done Honb'l minister, you proved yourself. After a long time, sensible and appreciable answers made Karan spellbound. You correctly said many IAS think or others think that all of them are 10-headed Ravana's and 20-handed to keep hands in 20 committees. experienced officials agree with me that they are good organizers but poor knowledge but boast that they know everything in fact they do not know anything but steal facts and knowledge from one officer's specialist and pass it on to another committee as if they know it but in fact, all of their ideas are borrowed. They work with authorities but with no real knowledge in anything. Putting them in many and various committees only makes them feel proud and they can not do justice to any one committee. so hereafter one officer should have one portfolio only so that they can think make ideas rather than symbolically chairing and taking a salary. we should change at least now after 75 years of independence to become independent of IAS. They were appointed because there was no specialist and now many experts are available so the IAS should be phased out slowly as they are part of political corruption and not doing their constitutional duties in spite of the constitutional post they occupy. Most of them are greedy for money and power. They should leave specialist departments only to be administrative. All heads of the department post to be given to concerned department specialists who are working in their department for many years. If anybody is not fit to be head of the department they should resign and go home.
One of the best interview I watched in my lifetime. Karan Thappar brings out the best answer from the great PTR. Thank you PTR for representing us (Tamil People) with Pride and speaking truth without hesitation. Hope our wisdom win soon.💐♥️
i belong to madurai TN. I am very proud to have elected mr ptr from our constituency for the betterment of TN and rest of the country. I thank mr.karan to bring out such a valuable personality like PTR. i see lot of difference in his views and thoughts. very insightful and thought provoking speech.
பி டி ஆர் பழனிவேல் தியாகராஜன் அவர்களின் பேச்சை கரண் தாபூர் அவர்களே வியந்து கேட்டுக் கொண்டிருக்கிறார்கள் என்பதுதான் இந்த காணொளியின் ஹைலைட்😀❤️👌👍 congratulations to finance minister of Tamilnadu
I have to go back and get the the one that has been been delivered delivered by the end end the week week so we we will be be able able you tomorrow tomorrow to to you and and will see if if any questions please let me know me know me know me know what to to you you know you you will have a great great great evening thank love love love love thank thank love thank one love thank
@@apurbamandal413 make in india is work nightmare... don't only focus employment... one foreign company start the production india, of course we got employment but don't forget they unofficial used out natural resources... one-day they will leave but that time india lost most of natural resources...MADE IN INDIA is good for nation because india company use Indian resources and market to other countries with brand of india...
Sir,I salute your determination,conviction and "panditya".Ppl like you are our hope. I am a retired person and I will do my best to support your wonderful programme. Your programme on Akasi Chin and India's dubious(almost false)claim over that barren land is etched in my memory. I can't express how much I love your programme.Let your programme continue till this undeclared emergency ends and India becomes free again
குடும்ப கட்சி கொள்ளைதான் அடிக்கும். ஓருவர் அறிஞர் மாதிரி பேசினாலும் கட்சி சனநாயக தன்மை அற்ற கட்சி என்பதனால், ஒருகுடும்ப தேவையைப் பூர்த்தி செய்ய சட்டங்கள், திட்டங்கள் வளைக்கப்படும் என்பதனால் எல்லாம் வீணே! அதிகார குடும்பத்தின் நெருக்கம் காரணமாக அதிகம் பேசுகிறார் இவர். உண்மை நமக்கு தெரியாதா?
Excellent interview. Karan ji . compliments to you for inviting sensible, educated and enlightened politicians at a time when more and more politicians are trying to take us to archaic times in the name of vishwaguru.. Keep it up. Karan sir..
Wow …the South seems to impress more and more … so nice to listen to such an educated political voice … after listening continuously to the nonsense of the cow belt …
Arre when will be considered as true indians. North south fight is so boring. We are also equal yaar. Its only our ignorance that is causing these probs thats all.
In spite of his profound understanding in finance, history and politics, the moment he was appointed as Finance minister he constituted a committee consisting of great minds such as Raghuram rajan, Arvind Subramaniam, etc., which proves the seriousness with which he has taken the job of steering the finances of tamilnadu.
Wonderful ideas of Mr. Thiaga Rajan for self respect and so on. About language problems he is pointing to two language formula that is English and their own language is correct. I respect his ideas.
Yes very true. With due respect all North Indian brothers. See the obvious and let my north Indian Hindi brothers please let us co-exist with all the differences. Uniformity is not the answer. Saffronisation and Hindification is not the answer.
This two language policy has been implemented by ANNA ( Founder of the DMK). Tamilnadu still following this policy regardless of party. Mr. P.T.R is one of follower of great leader.
@@mastkalandar3200 she and ptr both from madurai, tamilnadu. Ptr studied in NIT Trichy, 160 km from Madurai. He later went to America, worked in Lehmann brothers till 2008 collapse, then worked in Standard Chartered Bank in Singapore, MBA in Sloan School of Management, Degree in Buffalo University in New York. He is also an Investment Banker, with economics phd. 1st Time MLA and Former IT Wing President of DMK Party (3rd largest party in Parliament). Now he is TN Minister for Finance, Human Resources, Pensions, Accounts and Administration of TN Government. Dmk has set up a new party office in delhi, Near Parliament. Stalin CM and PTR may come to national politics any time. Nirmala studied in some random RSS BJP school in Trichy. Today is Nirmalas Birthday, 20th August 2022. After that I dont know kuch about her. Sorry.
Virtually it was a brainy session between the two sharpest and witty minds. The man responding to queries interrogations posing questions was also enjoying quizzing with the one and only inquisitive anchor of substance Magically we have at last found someone naming palanivel thigarajan a gentleman sincere dedicated honest highly educated politician and finance minister now of tamil nadu in the midst of buffoons.
I am becoming fan of this guy day by day. Thanks for putting states conditions and views openly. India cannot be india with one language, one governing party and one religion. Regionalism is the key thread to hold everything together. Thanks Karam Thapar too, you have been a treat always.
Well said. People like Mr Thiagrajan should be part of Central govt. Eventually the rational, cultured and down to earth south indian wisdom will save india
I wish but unlikely. Modi does not like to listen any contrarian voice, even from his own party. (Example, Gadkari was shunted out of the BJP's central committee.) He want's to control everything. But as PTR said, all this is cyclical -- it is going to crash one day. Hopefully, then we will have a more inclusive center.
@@krishnapillai2595 bulldozer baba yogi also removed. Yeddyurappa selected. Karnataka CM Basavaraj Bommai removed despite bommai meeting n talking to Bjp top management
@Karan: a humble request. Could you please arrange to have this interview with PTR into all the possible regional languages and allow it to flow across the country! I do watch most of your shows and I would say this is one of its best and have never seen the person sitting across you have answered all your questions soo good! This definitely has all the content to be propagated through out the country to understand the real Dravidian politics and it’s ideologies!!! This certainly would be the best of the best of your all interviews that I have seen through. Thanks for bringing PTR to your program and unravel his political discourse!!!!
Sensible conversation, his speech showcase that he put heart and soul for India and specially for tamilnadu and other states growth too... Amazing PTR !!!
I am from Tamilnadu Tirunelveli this finance minister is the worst one we have seen in our state...he can't even become a office boy without his family background....! His grandfather and father both ministers in DMK government earlier- PTR claims of working in leading financial institution should be invistgated because it can be Sonia Gandhi's fake claims of studying in Oxford....! My state debt have increased by 2 lakh crore after this bugger became FM of TN...
@@shivakrishna1167 karan thapar is here in india to raise just concerns fear and problems. never ever he has praised any one who is at the right. This finance minister is called most educated and knowledgeable, why tf will he give an example of hitler as if center is killing people if you are not BJP. I hate these educated illiterates. He talks like TN is not a developed country and other states are lagging behind because they speak hindi. Same examples from past 6 months in every interview. talks about 4 doctors every 1k people and in covid TN had the 2nd highest death in the country after maharastra. Wire never sees those problems
I am hearing Karan's interview after quite sometime. The way he handled this interview is really excellent. PTR rocked as always, articulated the views of us (South India) very clearly. There are fundamental differences which people miss to understand, he rightly pointed out the existence as miracle. The landscape is united because of the invasion of some external forces, but South Indians particularly Tamilians are not lesser when it comes to patriotism. We oppose things only based on the facts, pain points and not based on any preconceived notions. He ended the interview with an optimistic note but the modi and shah are 10 times more danger than indra, I mean from the point of view of democracy, social justice, right to speak and expressing the views, diversity etc. We are one nation but not one (the same), every body are unique in their ownways and let's respect each other. Hope the magic will continue for ever, long live India.
South Indians don't like to be told by someone sitting in Delhi, what to wear, what to eat, what language to be learnt and what religion to be followed.
Exactly my views -"South Indians particularly Tamilians are not lesser when it comes to patriotism.", Mr Mugunthan Lakshminarayanan. And, the Golden words to remember in 2024 like after Indira's emergency is "IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO ELSE...JUST NOT YOU", merey Hindi bhai log. Please save the miracle and let it shine in the world for ever! Jai Hind!!
@Indiaisbest I am not regularly following the discussions happening in Wire. Watched it because of PTR's interview.. what sort of evidence do you need on his response..? For me everything he spoke is based on facts..
You have occupied the power on the basis of the sacrifices of leaders who got independence If you have got any remorse now you should have set right them when you were in powerat the "CENTRE" for nearly 144 years in nda and upa1upa2 Your party is Nd has been anti national and anti constitution You allowed education go to the concurrent list to state list A bunch of contradictions not supported by any other state in this country High style english may mis lead a section of foolish tamilians but not always To morrow tamil nadu is devided as many states What will be your position Because ta.il nadu was not a separate state ever Do you mean to say that the more developed gujarat hS o self respect Or The other southern states who were in the Madras president y have no self respect ? This indirect anti national forces will see their end soon
Being from south and currently in north, I know hw unprivileged are north indan people on basic facilities,social upliftment, socila equality ,education ,free thinking...loved the way PTR's visionary outlook towards a future India..
Foolish DMK is dividing people artificially based on the disproven Aryan Invasion Theory. Dravida separatist movement was created and supported by the British, to keep India divided. No other Dravida people or party in the South support the divisive policies of DMK. These divisive traitors should not be elected by the people.
😂🤣PTR is a moron. DMK is the most regresive, dynastic corrupt parties in the world. PTR is one such dynasty who was licking the shoes of british and was against Indian independence
I’ve always been a free thinker & visionary, now I know it’s my Tamil ancestry, I will visit one-day, my great grandparents left Tamil Nadu 170 yrs ago as indentured slaves.
Appa pl remember our culture and and civilization we the ancient people of this world. But we are very humble and help everyone, that ia the reason what we are today.
*TN finance minister is just awasome*
*Loads of appreciation and respect from Kolkata*
Am proud to elected Mr.PTR
Legend ptr
There is huge support for Stalin and Thiagarajan in Kerala...
What's point in them getting support in keyrela? Stalin is one of the most corrupted politicians in TN. Oru mairum arinjooda ennittu sappotta adikkaan nadakunnu. Kurishu theevravadhi naari.
All gas. If you want to ruin Kerala further, invite these guys over for one day
Church right?
@@craigslist1323 kerala is already being ruined by its fiscal knowledge disabled government.
What about mullaperiyar
Seriously I am a North Indian but I wish one day this man should lead us & make us proud 🙏
Its where the "but" comes is where we start the geographic divide.
We have better things to do
More.
Wishing the same a 1000 times
😀AGREE
Been born in tamilnadu, have always thought our state is poor and underdeveloped. But now as a public sector employee, going around the nation, i could feel how blessed we are. Most people are poor and don't understand why they are poor. No one has a right and no one cares to question it.
@shriprasad jagadeesan ur shiiity idiot go n see northern states 😂
@shriprasad jagadeesan 😂😂sangi it's the second most richest and highest GDP contributor in the country
@@abi7749 👌
@@abi7749 grow up
Bcoz corruption free govt never was there
This TN finance minister is so well spoken.
Compare him with an arrogant lady , who knows little about economics& is a zero in politics
@@sivaramanmudaliar9728 u itself told she is 0. Then y compare genius with 0.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
@@rohitramesh8502 how many times have you been a finance minister to judge if he is good and the other once is bad? whats your criteria for being genius? when manmohan singh was priminister 2 times, how many people called him hitler? you people use some common sense or you are just follower of anti india parties?BJP own election not like on these people had votes and been leaders
@@rohitramesh8502 loving your comment
As a Tamilian, I am proud to have a talented finance minister like you!
Absolutely
Bro plz thinks about up Bihar also..🤐🤐😀
@@yhariom5169yup yha.gamechanger
is speaking in English a talent .. ??
@@Shreenapp Not only english subject matter also. Can Annamalai, a State President of a National party and a former IPS officer answer such powerful questions?
Am a keralite. I love tamilians. They have a strong sense of brotherhood. And they are very sensible too.
❤️
🙏❤️👍
Love from TN chayta ... ❤️
🙏
Adipoli cheyta
I clicked thinking that I will listen 5 mins...I ended up listing to the whole interview. What a thought provoking conversation. Everytime I am awe of this man. Hope he becomes PM of the country and improves the lives of not just TN but all. God bless him and his family.
Before your thought PM, I wish let him be the Finance minister of india for long period irrespective of which political party helming the delhi fort.
Such a treat to our ears. Hope this country learns to respect intellect and not goons shouting at the top of their voice.
😀AGREE
It is we who view that shit all the day and discuss that disgusting
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
My bloody foot
PTR always shouts at everyone against him.. at the top of the voice..
He is real learned person, whom we need as real leader.
Yes hee is our minister 👌
yes Indeed
😀AGREEE
Sure. He will do his best like he did with his previous jobs.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
Wise, balanced, logical and articulate. I find this minister thousand times more impressive than many bureaucrats and army officers.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
He Trains Officers in OTA
He is also a product of army school.
@@s.arivudainambi1627
Kj
@@apurbamandal413 p
I’m relocating to Tamil Nadu just to vote for this guy! Could he lead a national resistance in a few years ? 🙏🏼🙌🏼
Thanks maga,bega chesthundi👍👍
remember they are all corrupt from head to toe and they are commission,collection,corruption govt,only this fellow talks as if they are do gooders, actually what is happening in tamilnadu for all the ills now facing because of these corrupt people and most of the ministers of present government indulged in corruption and amassed wealth in untold proportion.guys who don't have resources to feed their families now owning schools and medical colleges thousand and thousands of land parcels allover tamilnadu.what is ridiculous is the fact that for just 67 crores Jayalalithaa was sent to prison and these fellows who swallowed thousands of crores of public money throwing away to gullible poorest people mere two hundred rupees to procures their votes and swindle more and more,judges of the courts were district secretaries of this party and looking other wayround to help these goons escape,such is the situation here.
@@alonzo_go Lol nice name 👌🤣
True
@@alonzo_go Hello, he did mention a 3rd criteria, which is "proven track record" and you are not highlighting to malign TN FM purposely fake id pappan dog!!
I am from UP and respect Mr Palanivel thoughts and his approach.
"India is a miracle".....sensible answers by Mr.PTR.....
Potentially cannot be , if we move the same way!!
Brilliant interview, PTR is a joy to listen. No jingoism, difference is education and world view in my opinion. In short no frog in the well
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
This is the first ever interview where Mr. Thapar is at the least interrupting mode. Isn't it?
How brilliant and rational Mr PTR is in his articulation!
You judgement is perfect 🎉
PTR is full of well articulated noise than real substance. The anglo-saxon Karan Thapar is his best listener. Look at what happened to Lehman Bros where PTR was Head of Trading. We had a gambler for a Finance Minister in Tamil Nadu. In a way it is good he is not Tamil Nadu's FM anymore. Thief Stalin woke up to the reality and moved him out of Finance.
Gentlemen like Mr.Thiaga Rajan are a ray of hope in the difficult times our country is going through right now.
I honestly like his interview and explanations, His english excellent were as our own Central Minister can't speak a basic English! Strange na.
We salute Mr Thiagarajan Minister of finance Tamil Nadu . I am from Kerala. I also speak and write Hindi. I fully agree with the 2 language policy of regional language and English as common language as suggested by him . He is a real thinker. He should be a national leader.
@@ianpadiyar7314 qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq
@@MeMe-sy5xp On a recent trip, the officer at the immigration desk kept on asking me questions in hindi but I politely told him that my hindi is very weak and I kept on replying in English - I think he has got the job by recommendation and cannot speak English at all.
His focus on self-respect and basic intellectual freedom is very fundamental to the concept of India
India needs leaders like this Gentleman!
He is logical, Calm and articulate.
More Power to him! God Bless
😆😆😆
Super weldone tamilnadu fm
*"Since every school in India teaches English, why can't it be our link language? Why do Tamils have to learn English for communication with the world and Hindi for communications within India? Do we need a big door for the big dog and a small door for the small dog? I say, let the small dog use the big door too!"*
- MR.Annadurai
Our Late CM of Tamil Nadu
Annadurai the great
Well said! This is hard to understand for some poeple. Many of my north Indian friends always ask why you don't speak Hindi? It's our national language. hehe. Trust me, it's really hard to explain.
Its not a dog its cat 😊
@@manojkumarravimohan3500 athuvum thiruttu poonai
Yeah.. I too heard from my father about this speech.. not dog but cat..
Simply superb and we had leaders with forevision...
I am listening to this interview for the 10th time. All the times I felt that this interview ended abruptly and it should have continued for another 30 minutes or more. It contained valid and intelligent questions and suitable and enlightening answers. Conversation between two geniuses and quite interesting to watch
P Thiagarajan has argued in a logical, clear and convincing way that makes it difficult to disagree with his point of view. Tamil Nadu is lucky to have such a clear headed finance minister.
Somebody being eloquent makes them good at "being eloquent." Track record and work speaks. By that way, all standup comedians would have become great leaders. Work should speak first, and then the person.
@@nandanshetty3184 shall I give you our TN track record ?
@@Mahboob1993 ipadi yellam kelvi keta answer ku enga povaru, irunga whatsapp la reply vandhadhum varuvaru
LOL
@@Mahboob1993 Tamil Nadu is one of the foremost states of India. Tamil Nadu is not talking here, the new finance minister is.
I want him as India’s Finance Minister. Period.
I'm glad that I got him as FM my state. Tamilnadu is in safe hands 👐 Always in an awe of Mr.PTR 😍🇮🇳
Spellbound Clarity and intentions of this man towards his state and our country. 👍🏼 We need his leadership more and more, its a need of an hour.
I believe that the Tamil Nadu State Finance Minister has clearly exhibited the civilised and humane attitude of the South Indian population. Great!!!!👍👍👍👍
Converts will support anyone who is anti Hindu 😂😂
South has no need to prove anything to persian immigrants who are the norths of india... Education+patriotism makes all the difference. See our finance ministers track record.... If possible understand and adopt....
Susan, please come back to original,if nothing else atleast get a name in your own language. Conversion is ok, but why convert your name also 😂
@@sushmachandak3316 hae sushma i dono where u r frm.. but if u are from tamilnadu..please check ur name too.. thanks..and by the by I'm not accusing u.. it's everyones basic right to choose religion, name, food etc..Thanks.. God bless
No need to change anybody's name. Name doesn't matter. What matters is thinking. We in TN too had lot of names influenced by other languages.
Hats off to PTR. Each and every word uttered by him comes from his mind. I read a comment which says that PTR is a ray of hope in these difficult times. I endorse this statement.
A good interview, no political remarks, blame-game or deriding of individuals or parties. A real sincere discussion of current realities and concerns of our country's future. And PTR has proved himself to be an optimistic patriot who is interested in finding solutions for the myriad problems the country is facing.
The host & guest did exceptionally well.
STALIN was wise enough to select such person as finance minister
What you mean there was nothing political in this interview? Every idea or thought in this interview still viable political thought in Tamilnadu.
@@manchikantimurty7375 no. Partly true.
Former tn cm and dmk president, mr. M. Karunanidhi was the man who identified him and give IT wing president in 2006 to 2011 dmk government. He insisted ptr 2 come to politics.
Now ptr asked for different department after winning 2021 TN MLA elections.
But stalin changed his department and gave him Finance and Human Resources Department.
Stalin only changed his posting. Thats all. Only karunanaidhi introduced him into dmk n politics.
A very intelligent and wise politician
Salutes and immense respect to you, Mr PTR, for your sane, forthright, though-provoking and brilliant views as expressed here through this programme.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
Very well done Honb'l minister, you proved yourself. After a long time, sensible and appreciable answers made Karan spellbound. You correctly said many IAS think or others think that all of them are 10-headed Ravana's and 20-handed to keep hands in 20 committees. experienced officials agree with me that they are good organizers but poor knowledge but boast that they know everything in fact they do not know anything but steal facts and knowledge from one officer's specialist and pass it on to another committee as if they know it but in fact, all of their ideas are borrowed. They work with authorities but with no real knowledge in anything. Putting them in many and various committees only makes them feel proud and they can not do justice to any one committee. so hereafter one officer should have one portfolio only so that they can think make ideas rather than symbolically chairing and taking a salary. we should change at least now after 75 years of independence to become independent of IAS. They were appointed because there was no specialist and now many experts are available so the IAS should be phased out slowly as they are part of political corruption and not doing their constitutional duties in spite of the constitutional post they occupy. Most of them are greedy for money and power. They should leave specialist departments only to be administrative. All heads of the department post to be given to concerned department specialists who are working in their department for many years. If anybody is not fit to be head of the department they should resign and go home.
This is why Tamil nadu is progressing well, bcos of progressive thinking and not indulging in religious and indo-pak nonsensical debates
You don't know how he & his party makes fun of ppl from North India...
Yes. Dynamic progress in corruption left right and center. PTR is the exception;
Don't be fooled. Come pay a visit to TN government schools and you still see the nonsense.
PTR is just a drama king, most of what he says is just lies. TN has the highest debt after Punjab and it's traveling towards financial ruin.
People vote on freebies and money (yeah pathetic, this culture was started by dear PTR s party. Corrupt to the core)
@@69rkannan thevidiya paya 😂😂 vadakkans ku poi oombi vitu...unga amma la kooti kudu
@@69rkannan BJP IT cell spreading hatred
A clear picture of "India Today-A Miracle" through the eyes of a Tamilian - Dr.PTR..Great Sir !!
Few lines talks everthing
எங்களுக்கு இந்தியா நாட்டின் இன்றைய நிலை பற்றி நல்ல புரிதலை கொடுத்துள்ளீர்கள் மதிப்பிற்குரிய PTR Sir. இன்றும் என்றும் துணிவுடன் உங்கள் கருத்துக்கள், அறிவுரைகளை கொடுங்க சார்.. வாழ்க தமிழ்! வளர்க தமிழ்நாடு!!💕💞💞
when we were born and raised in TN, we were always unhappy and critical of DMK/ ADMK`s etc.. but after growing up and visiting many other states we feel our state is much better in many aspects like infra developments, schools, public transport, services, healthcare etc.
100% true... i was shocked to see even gujarat ....
You are right. The local elitist view of tamil population is carefully nurtured and fine tuned perception by media controlled by brahmins.their views are supported by orthodox upper caste people. Not everyone of them,but still they are very vocal, and they extended this view through social media.their educational background helps them.
If one has an unbiased view as a commoner i will give the dravidian parties 60-70% marks,despite the stigma of corruption that is deliberately painted on them.
Yes, vasanth when you go to other states sure you will feel what tamilnadu culture and climate is. We are far better when compared to North.
Soo true
Indeed. 100%
We need this type of leader in our central leadership to ensure the real development of our country. A big salute to a visionary leader.
India will diminish!!
Mr. Thiagarajan, starting from Self-respect, moves on to Social Justice, and so clearly explains the Dravidian culture...Nice.
PTR is a gem, His contribution to Tamil Nadu state's is invaluable. Tamil Nadu should protect him .
ok,, better give cm post to this ....will cm family accept
@@padmanabhangovindaswamy4893 wil you stop discrimination based on ur manu
Thiagarajan is one of the few politicians who instills hope that we can all have in a future India.. wishing him all the best..
Mr PTR !! Discussion what India 🇮🇳 needs at this juncture!! Kudos to Mr Karan bringing this valuable information and discussion!!
Tamil nadu is the only state is assertive ol state government rights
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
Wow Dr. PTR huge Respect, we are in awe of you, India 🇮🇳 is in dire need of such leaders,...it would be great to have him as the Finance minister of India 😍👍🏼🇮🇳.. Thank you Mr. Karan Thapar for your fearless n forthright journalism 🙏🏼
Well supported Beulah!!!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
India has great Talent. Modi 71 the autocrat has killed this talent through self praise
No body can match the aura of Modiji yes ptr should be national financial advisor right man in wrong party
@@bhargajavarao8614 lol Modi? just Gothra famous guy is rewarded for his hatred against the Minorities ,when it comes performance the man a real Chaiwala sells pakoda well
@@bhargajavarao8614 no one can match his free jhumlas, given 24x7
Never seen Karan Thapar listening to somebody without interrupting for such a long time. Seems Thapar enjoys the never seen, heard ideologies from a politician from South in such a smooth flowing English.
I too was perplexed
He listen when he is paid. Earlier he was a prime time tv anchor. Now small time youtube anchor.
@@prnathan633 That literally is proof that he stood up for his values. Journalists who are sell outs are usually the ones that make big money.
As u said this is very true... Mr. Karan has never listened anyones words .. He intrudes inbetween ... We cant see a discussion like this in next 10yrs atleast ...
Listening to Mr. PTR, I am wishing I should be living in Tamilnadu...his vision and facts are so clear for states as well as the country...people like him should get into national politics and represent India 👍👍
Haha.. Semma comedy.
@@radhikakumar2331 Yes. Definitely people of north will not understand PTR's vision and politics and they don't allow him to play any role in national level.
@@radhikakumar2331 Yes the comedian camera addict modii ruling this country is the big comedy
Sir,
Our people favour tainted, not gentlemen.
Majority of hindu people still believe that deliverances to this nation come by the hands of modi and bjp rss.
The very sad thing are, a section of slavery minded tamil people (gujarati's shoes lickers) mingled with bjp rss, seeking all possibilities to uproot Tamil Nadu Government (we are citizens of this state).
@@radhikakumar2331 for more comedy you should see modi runing away from Karan’s interview few years back. You can also have fun along with Rs2 you got from BJP
As a person from TN and ardent fan of PTR, Reading the comments here is so heart warming.
True!👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
What a relief that this platform hasn't been hijacked by devotees 🙏
Same feeling 👍
@@nishantbanthia8765 because they can't understand what he is telling here that may be the reason
@@MrPupoov 😂💯
How coherently he linked the sense of self-respect, to rationalism and political self-determination!!! Only a truly well read and wise person can speak with such intellectual clarity. Thank you TN for electing such a great leader. Hope to see him steer the country from the center in the future.
We can surely expect great strides & progress in TN in the foreseeable future by this gentleman Mr. Thiagarajan.
This is the aspiration of majority of Indians. Hope this come to pass in 2024.
UP, MP, can never match TN even in a decade
Am from Tamilnadu. India need him as FM for her service and it’s our honor to send him to service.
Thank you sir. All credits goes to TN chief minister Shri. MK. Stalin.
ஐயா தங்களின் அறிவிற்கும் ஆற்றலுக்கும் தெளிவிற்கும் தங்களின் தைரியத்திற்கும் மனம் நிறைந்த வாழ்த்துகள். உங்கள் உடல் நலத்திலும் அக்கறை கொள்ளுங்கள். இந்தியாவிற்கே சொத்து நீங்கள்.
I want this man to be the finance minister of India... Only people like him to recover India from the financial mess they have made currently
thanks u on behalf of TN. better if this leads as PM of India
I recommend Dr.PTR to be our next PM
First I want him as the CM of Tamilnadu.. let him clean here and go to PMs seat..
@@pradeepvijayan6264 🤣🤣🤣
@@rathinaveldeivasigamani6199 😝😝😝
Certainly one of the best interviews in recent times, and quite timely too. PTR was forthright, to the point, and immensely sensible - frankly, something quite uncommon in these times of empty rhetoric, false narratives, jingoism and worse. We are lucky that some parts of the country has not descended into insanity.
And yes, would like to thank Mr Thapar for bringing in the oft forgotten part of India into the picture.
Man you are wonderful, upright,articulate,illustrious and on top an honest journalist.
People should be forth coming to subscribe your great show. I'm a Pakistani and an arid listener. May God bless you.
Respected Mr.P T R, We are proud to have you as as our finance minister...
None before you had given a clear and spectacular replies to many questionnaires.
Your encountered reply over their question fired is applaudable.. 🙏
I think this interview is worth translating into all the Languages of this Union and spread across... As Thamizhian We are very of you Mr.Thiagarajan... As Karan Thapar has told at the end of the interview, take care and Long live...!!
Good suggestion
In the larger interest of the nation the IT wing of DMK should translate this interview in all languages and also release the video with sub titles in local languages to ensure the Dravidian model of governing should reach all over India. Great salute to PTR Sir
Absolutely correct.
Exactly..He is precious to us,not just as a Tamilian I say it as an Indian...
Specifically.UP
After hearing this interview, I am getting some hope for our country. we are having learned/educated/informed person in politics.
Wow, I usually don’t like to hear 30 mins or more videos, but this one even after finishing I felt like I couldn’t get enough, feel like listening to more. Thanks Mr Thiagrajan for taking up this career, it makes such a big difference to the people of nation
Foolish DMK is dividing people artificially based on the disproven Aryan Invasion Theory. Dravida separatist movement was created and supported by the British, to keep India divided. No other Dravida people or party in the South support the divisive policies of DMK. These divisive traitors should not be elected by the people.
@@vasukinagabhushan lol, the world knows who is dividing india, only people who don’t believe are the ones benefiting from it
LIKEWISE
wow .. 😂😂 seems ur a agent for George Soros agent.... pks will get good hike from Soros...by showing this nonsense I mean interview
@@prajivkumar2741 what is it that you are trying to say
Democracy and freedom of speech must go on. Thanks
One of the most candid interviews by Karan with almost no interruptions. The clarity exemplified by PTR is phenomenal. Thank you both of you.
Yes, This Was One Such Interview,
Where Karan Has Not Interuppted
With His Tricky Sub Questions,
On The Contrary, He Was Enjoying It.
@@navaneethakrishnanramakris3796 I felt the same!
Wish I could convey to him how well he puts his thoughts across in not only this but all his interviews. Such a refreshing change to hear a statesman and not a politician
This man is rightly a minister…well versed, knowledgeable, bold, caring…provides hope continued success of our country
This is THE JOURNAISM THAT WE NEED.
ONE OF THE MOST CREDIBLE JOURNALIST N THE MOST RESPECTABLE FINANCE MINISTER.
INDIA NEEDS SUCH EDUCATED SENSIBLE PEOPLE AT THE HELM.
AWAKEN INDIA JAI HIND
One of the brilliant minds in the Indian political landscape. How I wish he were our PM.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
But unfortunately for our NATION....we now have forced as condendemd sin by having SHEER MAD TRAYANT that too a FRAUD, FANATIC Above all an NATION'S. HISTORICAL record who is a BEARER of Fictiouse DEGREE....n....in turned virtually a ILLITERARATE guggler!!!🙏💐🍀🛐🤗
@@apurbamandal413 stop it
@@drstanlypinto251 The miracle of india will be short lived if the cow belt remain perpetually tantalised by the rabble rouser.Ram, cow and mandir can belt up the Hindi belt, rest of india ll opt for a better alternative.
The most astonishing part of this interaction was about how the so-called "Hindi-belt" states like UP, Bihar, MP etc. have lost their own languages and dialects just because many of those were a subset of Hindi...It is nice to see Mr. Thiagarajan being sensitive about those lost languages as well while rightly defending their stand on why they oppose imposition of a "Three-language policy" or Hindi imposition on Tamils...It puts a mirror on the Hindi speaking states that this is how we can make language diversity a matter of pride for the nation...
Misery needs company. India is a miracle, but now it is in misery. It needs support from people like us to bounce back n kick out bjp rss from india
This is the reason behind, why we tamils opposed the hindi to dominate our day to day life under compulsion. Learning any language is subject to the choice of the peoples. You can't force us to follow your dictate.
@@indianfrontline we do have people in the "North" who understand this emotion...we understand that nobody is there in TN (except for probably a rare group of people which are omnipresent) who hate Hindi or anything...the hatred is against the imposition of Hindi rather than Hindi itself...it is already evident through our conversation that if thoughts are similar or if people really want to communicate with each other, then language is not that big a problem...but my friend, I really believe that this issue is not among the common people, it is the politicians who haven't been able to achieve anything for their people, and yet they want the common people to have an opinion about something that such politicians crave for...At the same time, the common man also feels proud to have an opinion about something they feel seems to be related to "National Interest" and since they don't have any distinct opinion about it, they tend to take the stance as their own leaders...
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
@@abhisheknigam2918 Thanks for your understanding that tamil people dont oppose hindi as a language many people here study hindi. Opposition is on imposition only.
Exactly. Beautifully spoken. India is a miracle and may it remain like that!
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
To listen to PTR is so refreshing; so enlightening. His mastery over language, facts and figures and marshalling of points, and the articulate and down to earth manner in which he conveys them with out being rhetorical is amazing. He is a rare intellectual politician or should I say a thorough bread financial professional that our country needs. He calls a spade a spade. He will go places
India needs to tap his experience and expertise. I salute him for what he is doing for the country.
No, india Don't need him, only an suganthira Thani Nadu needs him.
Brother remember he is a tamilian. We are the people who taught everything to this world. We are all one in this world don't discriminate the people of this world, by forcing oneself on another, the black are the first humans on this world, Remember that always.
@@safetyfirst2413 if someone raises qn about the government people like you to comment like this, first understand what is his opinion
Why the word NOTION should be used when a commonly used word IDEA is available?
I echo that, he Inspire millions.
Myyyyy god !!
He should be the prime minister candidate. Finally we have a suitable mind. Thank you TN.
Oh my god.modi
First of all as a tamilian we thank to our honourable CM M K Stalin to select Mr PTR as a finance minister of T Nadu then only we came to know that how talented he is. In my point of view english fluency is not talented but the points he delivers in his own style is appreciable and also answering questions in any matter rapid and valuable reply is superb
PTR sir please keep it up and go ahead in your own way
Especially answering to each & every question of Mr.Thapar without thinking,thanks to PTR
A true leader keeps good and capable persons around him.
Mr Karan is naturally Is anti BJP man & He generally select to Interview those who speak agnst Modi,
When GST council was formed where was Mr PTR voice ? He has come from wealthy family background & I do agree Qualified but spent his most of life in USA, Now He is spending his retirement life with minister portfolio ….
Mr Karan had also called Mr. Modi for an interview and the interview was short closed within a short period.
A very interesting interview. Mr Thiagarajan has explained all issues clearly and fearlessly. He has avoided direct attack on PM but has indicated his incompetence and dictatorial style succinctly. Human nature finds way to normalise conditions and capacity to bring down powerful, dictatorial regimes with Hitler and Indira Gandhi's examples. The interview focussed more on issues confronting the citizens rather than a political slugfest.
This applies to the Dravidian ideology too.
தன்மானம், அதுவே தமிழனின் தனி அடையாளம். PTR ஒரு பிடர் கொண்ட தமிழ் சிங்கம். கர்ஜனை சும்மா அதிருதல்லவா?👏👏👌👌
An intelligent leader with clear ideas and views,very optimistic.Really India Today is a miracle and wish it will live forever. Karanji thanks for arranging this one.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
This is the power of good education we see in this interview. Proud to have this type of person in politics . Well spoken sir.
Well said. This is the power of education.
Our country is gone 40 years back in development since last 8 years.
Not 40 it's 400 years atleast
@@ani4759 Yes, In terms of social values.
As a Tamilian we are proud to be like this kind of politition after 75 years of independence. Keep it up PTR.
IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO ELSE...JUST NOT YOU...THESE GOLDEN WORDS SHOULD BE REMEMBERED BY ALL IN 2024. It was a Pleasure & an Honour to listen to someone as enriched as Mr.P Thiaga Rajan.
No offense but any chance dropping your caste based surname? Surely it don't look progressive. Again, no offense.
First get a name in your own language
@@sushmachandak3316 i ❤️ that reply...
@@starwar2901 English men also have a surname...what do you think these surnames are? U can trace their history with that family name
@Indiaisbest are you a BJP bot.
The clarity in thought process is notable. I am seeing a rare interview in which Karan Thapar is all ears and almost with no interruptions.
Always a treat listening to PTR. Undoubtedly, PTR is the most qualified politician/statesman in India today. Thanks, Karan!
One of the Best interviews I have ever seen in my four decades of following Indian politics and economics.
It was one of the best interviews I watched. PTR's clarity of thought, his sense of history, and the understanding of the current economic and social issues are commendable. His faith in the capacity of Indians to bring positive change is grounded in reality. Congratulations to both PTR and Karan
Any interview by PTR deserves an instant like. Hats off Sir!
My country needs more Thyagarajans... ...loved the talk. Thank you Karan Thapar
தமிழ்நாட்டின் கல்விதரம் அறிவு ஆற்றல் நாட்டின் பொருதாரவளர்ச்சி திட்டமிடுதல் ஆகியவற்றில் எப்படி சிறந்து விளங்குகிறது என்பதற்கும் தமிழ்நாட்டுமக்கள் சிந்தனை எப்படி இருக்கும் என்பதற்கும் தமிழநாடு நிதி அமைச்சர் திரு. PTR.தியாகராஜன் அவர்கள் ஒரு நல்ல உதாரணம்
Mr.Karan Thapar is one of the best journalist and very bold and fearless
I'm a fan of Nohakhwan Shadman Raza
I'm a fan of Nohakhwan Shadman Raza and I'm from Chennai, Tamilnadu
Ptr
What an interview! PTR's views on the language policy was very sensible.
What a fabulous, hope-filled discussion based on facts and a love for country, it’s history as well as its future! Thank you Mr Thapar for bringing fearless journalism since many many years 🙏👏🏼 Thank you Mr PTR for your insights, clarity of thoughts and rational responses. This was a balm to anxious nerves, for hearts that beat for the motherland even while being far away 💕
Very well done Honb'l minister, you proved yourself. After a long time, sensible and appreciable answers made Karan spellbound. You correctly said many IAS think or others think that all of them are 10-headed Ravana's and 20-handed to keep hands in 20 committees. experienced officials agree with me that they are good organizers but poor knowledge but boast that they know everything in fact they do not know anything but steal facts and knowledge from one officer's specialist and pass it on to another committee as if they know it but in fact, all of their ideas are borrowed. They work with authorities but with no real knowledge in anything. Putting them in many and various committees only makes them feel proud and they can not do justice to any one committee. so hereafter one officer should have one portfolio only so that they can think make ideas rather than symbolically chairing and taking a salary. we should change at least now after 75 years of independence to become independent of IAS. They were appointed because there was no specialist and now many experts are available so the IAS should be phased out slowly as they are part of political corruption and not doing their constitutional duties in spite of the constitutional post they occupy. Most of them are greedy for money and power. They should leave specialist departments only to be administrative. All heads of the department post to be given to concerned department specialists who are working in their department for many years. If anybody is not fit to be head of the department they should resign and go home.
@@tajmedical4946 Very true.👌
One of the best interview I watched in my lifetime. Karan Thappar brings out the best answer from the great PTR.
Thank you PTR for representing us (Tamil People) with Pride and speaking truth without hesitation.
Hope our wisdom win soon.💐♥️
i belong to madurai TN. I am very proud to have elected mr ptr from our constituency for the betterment of TN and rest of the country. I thank mr.karan to bring out such a valuable personality like PTR. i see lot of difference in his views and thoughts. very insightful and thought provoking speech.
👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
பி டி ஆர் பழனிவேல் தியாகராஜன் அவர்களின் பேச்சை கரண் தாபூர் அவர்களே வியந்து கேட்டுக் கொண்டிருக்கிறார்கள் என்பதுதான் இந்த காணொளியின் ஹைலைட்😀❤️👌👍 congratulations to finance minister of Tamilnadu
Anna you very very correct
Self Respect,Education,
Analysing and questioning is a key of human development.
Hope we all work to achieve this..
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
Thiagarajan is intelligent We need such like persons to make India’s Miracle to be worthwhile for every Indian
@@tarvinderbuxi7147 Exactly 👍🏼🙏🏼🇮🇳
I have to go back and get the the one that has been been delivered delivered by the end end the week week so we we will be be able able you tomorrow tomorrow to to you and and will see if if any questions please let me know me know me know me know what to to you you know you you will have a great great great evening thank love love love love thank thank love thank one love thank
@@apurbamandal413 make in india is work nightmare... don't only focus employment... one foreign company start the production india, of course we got employment but don't forget they unofficial used out natural resources... one-day they will leave but that time india lost most of natural resources...MADE IN INDIA is good for nation because india company use Indian resources and market to other countries with brand of india...
Impossible to believe that politicians like these still exist in our country..
Wish we had many more.. Across the states.. Across the party lines..
Dr. PTR hit the nail on the head and verbalises all my fears but strikes an optimistic note. A great assessment of India @ 75
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'
Sir,I salute your determination,conviction and "panditya".Ppl like you are our hope.
I am a retired person and I will do my best to support your wonderful programme.
Your programme on Akasi Chin and India's dubious(almost false)claim over that barren land is etched in my memory.
I can't express how much I love your programme.Let your programme continue till this undeclared emergency ends and India becomes free again
தமிழனாக பெருமிதம் கொள்கிறேன்
தமிழ்நாட்டிற்கு கிடைத்த திறமையான நிதியமைச்சர் PTR
குடும்ப கட்சி கொள்ளைதான் அடிக்கும். ஓருவர் அறிஞர் மாதிரி பேசினாலும் கட்சி சனநாயக தன்மை அற்ற கட்சி என்பதனால், ஒருகுடும்ப தேவையைப் பூர்த்தி செய்ய சட்டங்கள், திட்டங்கள் வளைக்கப்படும் என்பதனால் எல்லாம் வீணே! அதிகார குடும்பத்தின் நெருக்கம் காரணமாக அதிகம் பேசுகிறார் இவர். உண்மை நமக்கு தெரியாதா?
Excellent interview.
Karan ji . compliments to you for inviting sensible, educated and enlightened politicians at a time when more and more politicians are trying to take us to archaic times in the name of vishwaguru..
Keep it up. Karan sir..
Wow …the South seems to impress more and more … so nice to listen to such an educated political voice … after listening continuously to the nonsense of the cow belt …
Arre when will be considered as true indians. North south fight is so boring. We are also equal yaar.
Its only our ignorance that is causing these probs thats all.
In spite of his profound understanding in finance, history and politics, the moment he was appointed as Finance minister he constituted a committee consisting of great minds such as Raghuram rajan, Arvind Subramaniam, etc., which proves the seriousness with which he has taken the job of steering the finances of tamilnadu.
Wonderful ideas of Mr. Thiaga Rajan for self respect and so on. About language problems he is pointing to two language formula that is English and their own language is correct.
I respect his ideas.
I Am Manipuri ,we Have Our Own Script ,First Manipuri ,Second English .
Yes very true. With due respect all North Indian brothers. See the obvious and let my north Indian Hindi brothers please let us co-exist with all the differences. Uniformity is not the answer. Saffronisation and Hindification is not the answer.
This two language policy has been implemented by ANNA ( Founder of the DMK). Tamilnadu still following this policy regardless of party. Mr. P.T.R is one of follower of great leader.
The present FM of india isnt too fluent in Hindi and a lot less knowledgeable about her portfolio.
@@mastkalandar3200 she and ptr both from madurai, tamilnadu.
Ptr studied in NIT Trichy, 160 km from Madurai. He later went to America, worked in Lehmann brothers till 2008 collapse, then worked in Standard Chartered Bank in Singapore, MBA in Sloan School of Management, Degree in Buffalo University in New York. He is also an Investment Banker, with economics phd.
1st Time MLA and Former IT Wing President of DMK Party (3rd largest party in Parliament).
Now he is TN Minister for Finance, Human Resources, Pensions, Accounts and Administration of TN Government.
Dmk has set up a new party office in delhi,
Near Parliament.
Stalin CM and PTR may come to national politics any time.
Nirmala studied in some random RSS BJP school in Trichy.
Today is Nirmalas Birthday, 20th August 2022.
After that I dont know kuch about her. Sorry.
Excellent piece of interview by PTR. Very cleverly put across his opinions for welfare of the state and the country.
Virtually it was a brainy session between the two sharpest and witty minds. The man responding to queries interrogations posing questions was also enjoying quizzing with the one and only inquisitive anchor of substance Magically we have at last found someone naming palanivel thigarajan a gentleman sincere dedicated honest highly educated politician and finance minister now of tamil nadu in the midst of buffoons.
🇮🇳পুরো দেশ জুড়ে দুটো Campaign চালাতে হবে।
◽1) 'Make India full Democracy'
◽2) 'All Human Rights for all the People of India'...
I am becoming fan of this guy day by day. Thanks for putting states conditions and views openly. India cannot be india with one language, one governing party and one religion. Regionalism is the key thread to hold everything together.
Thanks Karam Thapar too, you have been a treat always.
Yes, u r absolutely right. 👍
Well said. People like Mr Thiagrajan should be part of Central govt. Eventually the rational, cultured and down to earth south indian wisdom will save india
I wish but unlikely. Modi does not like to listen any contrarian voice, even from his own party. (Example, Gadkari was shunted out of the BJP's central committee.) He want's to control everything. But as PTR said, all this is cyclical -- it is going to crash one day. Hopefully, then we will have a more inclusive center.
@@krishnapillai2595 bulldozer baba yogi also removed. Yeddyurappa selected.
Karnataka CM Basavaraj Bommai removed despite bommai meeting n talking to Bjp top management
@@krishnapillai2595 Modi is just a mouthpiece. The RSS makes all the decisions.
@@krishnapillai2595 I fervently hope you're proven right asap.
@@rohitramesh8502 yeddi selected because of karnataka elections next year.
@Karan: a humble request. Could you please arrange to have this interview with PTR into all the possible regional languages and allow it to flow across the country! I do watch most of your shows and I would say this is one of its best and have never seen the person sitting across you have answered all your questions soo good! This definitely has all the content to be propagated through out the country to understand the real Dravidian politics and it’s ideologies!!! This certainly would be the best of the best of your all interviews that I have seen through. Thanks for bringing PTR to your program and unravel his political discourse!!!!
Sensible conversation, his speech showcase that he put heart and soul for India and specially for tamilnadu and other states growth too... Amazing PTR !!!
I am from Tamilnadu Tirunelveli this finance minister is the worst one we have seen in our state...he can't even become a office boy without his family background....! His grandfather and father both ministers in DMK government earlier- PTR claims of working in leading financial institution should be invistgated because it can be Sonia Gandhi's fake claims of studying in Oxford....! My state debt have increased by 2 lakh crore after this bugger became FM of TN...
@@shivakrishna1167 karan thapar is here in india to raise just concerns fear and problems. never ever he has praised any one who is at the right. This finance minister is called most educated and knowledgeable, why tf will he give an example of hitler as if center is killing people if you are not BJP. I hate these educated illiterates. He talks like TN is not a developed country and other states are lagging behind because they speak hindi. Same examples from past 6 months in every interview. talks about 4 doctors every 1k people and in covid TN had the 2nd highest death in the country after maharastra. Wire never sees those problems
@@shivakrishna1167 fool like you will not understand anything. I am not DMk supporter but His opinions are valid.
@@shivakrishna1167 And you conveniently ignored the mess created by your partner ADMK ruling :)
@@shivakrishna1167 don't blabber
I am hearing Karan's interview after quite sometime. The way he handled this interview is really excellent.
PTR rocked as always, articulated the views of us (South India) very clearly. There are fundamental differences which people miss to understand, he rightly pointed out the existence as miracle. The landscape is united because of the invasion of some external forces, but
South Indians particularly Tamilians are not lesser when it comes to patriotism.
We oppose things only based on the facts, pain points and not based on any preconceived notions.
He ended the interview with an optimistic note but the modi and shah are 10 times more danger than indra, I mean from the point of view of democracy, social justice, right to speak and expressing the views, diversity etc.
We are one nation but not one (the same), every body are unique in their ownways and let's respect each other.
Hope the magic will continue for ever, long live India.
South Indians don't like to be told by someone sitting in Delhi, what to wear, what to eat, what language to be learnt and what religion to be followed.
Very aptly put.
Exactly my views -"South Indians particularly Tamilians are not lesser when it comes to patriotism.", Mr Mugunthan Lakshminarayanan. And, the Golden words to remember in 2024 like after Indira's emergency is "IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO ELSE...JUST NOT YOU", merey Hindi bhai log. Please save the miracle and let it shine in the world for ever! Jai Hind!!
@Indiaisbest I am not regularly following the discussions happening in Wire. Watched it because of PTR's interview.. what sort of evidence do you need on his response..? For me everything he spoke is based on facts..
You have occupied the power on the basis of the sacrifices of leaders who got independence
If you have got any remorse now you should have set right them when you were in powerat the "CENTRE" for nearly 144 years in nda and upa1upa2
Your party is Nd has been anti national and anti constitution
You allowed education go to the concurrent list to state list
A bunch of contradictions not supported by any other state in this country
High style english may mis lead a section of foolish tamilians but not always
To morrow tamil nadu is devided as many states
What will be your position
Because ta.il nadu was not a separate state ever
Do you mean to say that the more developed gujarat hS o self respect
Or
The other southern states who were in the Madras president y have no self respect ?
This indirect anti national forces will see their end soon
Being from south and currently in north, I know hw unprivileged are north indan people on basic facilities,social upliftment, socila equality ,education ,free thinking...loved the way PTR's visionary outlook towards a future India..
Foolish DMK is dividing people artificially based on the disproven Aryan Invasion Theory. Dravida separatist movement was created and supported by the British, to keep India divided. No other Dravida people or party in the South support the divisive policies of DMK. These divisive traitors should not be elected by the people.
😂🤣PTR is a moron. DMK is the most regresive, dynastic corrupt parties in the world. PTR is one such dynasty who was licking the shoes of british and was against Indian independence
Exactly
I’ve always been a free thinker & visionary, now I know it’s my Tamil ancestry, I will visit one-day, my great grandparents left Tamil Nadu 170 yrs ago as indentured slaves.
Appa pl remember our culture and
and civilization we the ancient people of this world. But we are very humble and help everyone, that ia the reason what we are today.
Thanks!
i am a proud dravidian muslim and i am proud of PTR!!