Why Indonesia is MOVING its Capital City

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 жов 2024
  • #shorts
    This clip is about Indonesia moving its capital city from Jakarta to a completely new city in a completely different part of the country..
    Full video: • Countries That CREATE ...
    Images licensed from istock.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 90

  • @GEOfocusChannel
    @GEOfocusChannel  Рік тому +8

    I hope you like the clip! Check out the full video here: Full video: ua-cam.com/video/VksxnUfhsps/v-deo.html

  • @tmblighty917
    @tmblighty917 Рік тому +60

    I wonder how soon they will move out there since 20cm each year sounds like a pretty serious threat. At such a rate, it's one netter in just 5 years

    • @rizaradri316
      @rizaradri316 Рік тому +15

      Yet people are still stubborn by saying moving the capital is not necessary

    • @tmblighty917
      @tmblighty917 Рік тому

      @@rizaradri316 and why do you think they say that what seems unreasonable to me. But it must make some sense to them, right? What is your opinion on why they say they they don't need to move

    • @rizaradri316
      @rizaradri316 Рік тому +5

      @@tmblighty917 Because most people say the money spent on the new capital should be used on something else. Like increasing subsidies (Indonesians love subsidies), increasing salaries for workers, helping the poor, etc.

    • @rizaradri316
      @rizaradri316 Рік тому +6

      @@tmblighty917 They never cared that overcrowding and sinking rate are major issues. To them, prosperity are much more important than moving the capital

    • @rizaradri316
      @rizaradri316 Рік тому +4

      @@tmblighty917 Heck. I even saw a protest sign that says "kami tidak makan infrastruktur" in English that means "We don't 'eat' infrastructure" or in other words they don't need infrastructure as long as their bellies are full.

  • @AR-bh3mn
    @AR-bh3mn Рік тому +14

    The burden of Java Island is too heavy.....
    Jakarta is no longer fit to be the capital.......
    Untuk Kemajuan Indonesia! ✊

    • @anonimtanpanama3012
      @anonimtanpanama3012 Місяць тому

      The south of java coastline is rising anyway while the north is sinking.

  • @rizaradri316
    @rizaradri316 Рік тому +42

    Yet most people here in Indonesia still argues that moving the capital is not necessary. First the pollution part. They argued the government has been intensifying the usage of EV, so there would be less pollution. Secondly the economics. Most people still saying "why waste all the money on the new capital. Wouldn't it makes a lot more sense if the government spend it on helping the poor, increasing subsidies, etc". Thirdly, politics. There's been a lot of claims that if the government moved the capital, it will hampers democracy.

    • @ankokunokayoubi
      @ankokunokayoubi Рік тому +14

      Moving is a good idea but a lot of things needs to be considered and it should not be rushed upon.

    • @SetuwoKecik
      @SetuwoKecik Рік тому +11

      The funny part is that the ones who complains are mostly comes from Java island.

    • @hevnervals
      @hevnervals Рік тому +5

      ​@@SetuwoKecik That's why federal systems need a neutral spot for their administration.

    • @MrEmitremmus
      @MrEmitremmus Рік тому

      Democracy is a joke. It's a bunch of under-informed over stimulated fools voting based on emotions.

    • @icebro7584
      @icebro7584 Рік тому

      @@ankokunokayoubi rushed? When is the deadline?

  • @grammarwuot5427
    @grammarwuot5427 Рік тому +29

    Went to Jakarta for a few days on a trip and my impression of the traffic was
    "How tf can people live like this???"

    • @ankokunokayoubi
      @ankokunokayoubi Рік тому +3

      I would rather live poorer in serene village than having more money in city like Jakarta but daily life quality sucks.

    • @someone-pi8zu
      @someone-pi8zu Рік тому

      we were used to it

    • @coy290
      @coy290 Рік тому

      Banyak motor hingga kemacetan begitu panjang 🤣🤣🤣🤣untungnya aku tinggal di desa di daerah kediri jawa timur 🤣🤣✌

    • @muhammadfayiz3243
      @muhammadfayiz3243 Рік тому

      the traffic of station in Jakarta, more crazy

    • @senjahari8941
      @senjahari8941 11 місяців тому

      ​@@ankokunokayoubiyakin? Kalo hidup di desa semakmur sedamai yg kamu pikirkan.. Kenapa banyak orang2 desa banyak merantau ke Jakarta?

  • @Merry19938
    @Merry19938 10 місяців тому +3

    Saya akan ke Indonesia bulan Januari, adakah teman Indonesia yang bisa merekomendasikan beberapa tempat wisata?

    • @diditsuhendra238
      @diditsuhendra238 9 місяців тому

      Saya bisa menemanimu berjln jalan diindonesia

    • @Merry19938
      @Merry19938 9 місяців тому

      @@diditsuhendra238 Terima kasih, apakah Indonesia menyenangkan?

  • @ankokunokayoubi
    @ankokunokayoubi Місяць тому +1

    The most criticism of this new capital city is that the planning, development and execution being rushed and something could go wrong by those.
    Another one is environment & social issues

  • @DOLSKICOOL
    @DOLSKICOOL 3 місяці тому +2

    Salam Dari Indonesia 🇮🇩

  • @ChapatiMan
    @ChapatiMan Рік тому +19

    I know, Jakarta is sinking so let’s build a new city on swampy Borneo

    • @SetuwoKecik
      @SetuwoKecik Рік тому +1

      Idk man, it's like you have better options that's strategically located right at the center of the country.

    • @arismursidi
      @arismursidi Рік тому +8

      it's not swampy at all, it's kinda hilly instead..

    • @muhammadfayiz3243
      @muhammadfayiz3243 Рік тому +1

      For the location which will be the new capital is not swampy, it's already in the right position, center of the forest

  • @Raheem_1412-
    @Raheem_1412- Рік тому +3

    Good luck Indonesia

  • @siraitbugisshulthonusnish919
    @siraitbugisshulthonusnish919 Рік тому +1

    Horeeee we have a new Capital City yeeeessssssss 💪💪💪💪

  • @jmwvirgil
    @jmwvirgil Рік тому +3

    Well, that's lovely for the people who can afford to move, I guess.

  • @arismursidi
    @arismursidi Рік тому +3

    Jakarta problem (pollution, sinking, flooding, traffic jam, etc.) is not the main reason relocating the capital to Borneo, it's more because of developement reason..

  • @diaquitaquita8984
    @diaquitaquita8984 2 місяці тому +1

    🇮🇩

  • @fadiy24110
    @fadiy24110 Рік тому +6

    I'am from Indonesia
    Indonesia will move its first lady to Kalimantan, which will be called Nusantara

  • @friskjidjidoglu7415
    @friskjidjidoglu7415 Рік тому +1

    They seem like problems of the Indonesian government could could alleviate with the concerted efforts But choose not to

  • @anonimtanpanama3012
    @anonimtanpanama3012 Місяць тому +1

    Why move thousands of kilometer away?, just move tenth of kilometers southward, there are still plenty empty spaces with elevation hundreds of meters above sea level. Millions of jakarta resident will stay in jakarta. And the business will still be there since 4 centuries.

  • @Ethan63755
    @Ethan63755 Рік тому

    Kalimantan is my place I saw the structure in gor

  • @syabilalbilal4069
    @syabilalbilal4069 3 місяці тому +1

    Jakarta slowly but surely sinking.isnt stopping me from living there, i mean who wouldnt want to live in a real life atlantis

  • @endangmaharani5366
    @endangmaharani5366 Рік тому +4

    Why the government move from Jakarta to kalimantan:
    1. Bcoz jakarta traffic jam to much
    2. Bcoz floating around Jakarta every year
    3. Bcoz to much QADRUUN in jakarta
    4. Bcoz kalimantan bigger than java
    5. Bcoz kalimantan in the center of Indonesia

    • @SetuwoKecik
      @SetuwoKecik Рік тому +3

      "Qadruun"
      Everyone lives in 2022 while Endang still in 2014.

    • @someone-pi8zu
      @someone-pi8zu Рік тому

      ​@@SetuwoKecik wdym whos endang?

    • @Mosquito_Hunter8
      @Mosquito_Hunter8 Рік тому

      Bro is living in 2016 lmao

  • @GiteswarPradhan
    @GiteswarPradhan 27 днів тому

    Indonesia capital - Nusantara (on the island of Borneo)

  • @asepu.5800
    @asepu.5800 Рік тому +1

    This update finna be lit 🔥🔥🔥

  • @sudiyono.priakekarberotot
    @sudiyono.priakekarberotot 10 місяців тому

    jakarta problem (population, sinking, flooding, traffic jam, etc) is not the main reason relocating the capital to kalimantan, it's more because of development reason

  • @yaroslavpanych2067
    @yaroslavpanych2067 Рік тому +1

    OK, once they move to new location, Jakarta will be abandoned by most of inhabitants due to move to new capital, as result Jakarta will be healed of current problems, but the same shit will happen on new location. I suggest to think again!

    • @AyedYoutube
      @AyedYoutube Рік тому

      Nobody is abandoning jakarta. Not as long as Indonesia exist as a country.

    • @SetuwoKecik
      @SetuwoKecik Рік тому

      But at least Jakarta's burden will got lessened and the problem in the new capital won't be that severe, assuming it's a well-planned city since it was made from scratch.
      Better than nothing, you know?

    • @aisukururimu7515
      @aisukururimu7515 Рік тому +3

      What makes you so sure the people residing in Jakarta will automatically move to the new capital? The Jakartans don't live in Jakarta simply because it's the capital, they live there because it's an economic hub, you can move your capital, but moving an economic hub is simply ridiculous, so I doubt Jakarta will be abandoned by most of it's inhabitants

  • @samk522
    @samk522 Рік тому +4

    So the government and its workers will move out of the sinking city and the people left in Jakarta will... just die, I guess.

    • @yaroslavpanych2067
      @yaroslavpanych2067 Рік тому +2

      Nope, majority of people will move along with capital, so extraction of ground water will be significantly reduced, and so sinking will stop. Current solution is the most idiotic most expensive solution!

    • @hevnervals
      @hevnervals Рік тому +1

      Not a politicians job to move people. People move themselves

  • @sayaorangkaya221
    @sayaorangkaya221 Рік тому

    jakarta sedang dibenahi smua oleh pj heru dan pusat smua sungai swdamg dinormalisasi dan sedang dibangun gean seawall juga

  • @Cindiyy-z9y
    @Cindiyy-z9y 2 місяці тому

    New name of new capital city "IKN NUSANTARA"

  • @kas789
    @kas789 Рік тому +6

    We had this discussion million times, they move their capital because its sinking and bc of the flooding

    • @GEOfocusChannel
      @GEOfocusChannel  Рік тому +16

      The video’s not for you, then.

    • @someone-pi8zu
      @someone-pi8zu Рік тому

      ​@@GEOfocusChannel 💀

    • @muhammadfayiz3243
      @muhammadfayiz3243 Рік тому

      flooding happen every year in Jakarta, more answer is bcs Jakarta already overpopulation, and too many people gather & making money in here so uneven with the other city

  • @mr.libluckiestinfinitebene2589

    That picture not about sinking, it's normal flood

  • @Chanchanlala
    @Chanchanlala Рік тому +1

    fastest sinking city in the world, you can tell very obvious with bare eyes

  • @SuperTonyony
    @SuperTonyony Рік тому +1

    How about becoming a REAL democracy first? Then they can worry about building a new capital. 🙄

  • @raybg-ew4ux
    @raybg-ew4ux 2 місяці тому +1

    Ada maksud tersembunyi

    • @Scrat4357
      @Scrat4357 Місяць тому

      Iya, kalo daerah lain gk dibangun gk ush ngoceh ya 🤭

  • @someone-pi8zu
    @someone-pi8zu Рік тому +1

    as an Indonesian who lives in Jakarta, i agreed that Jakarta is sinking quickly. i might move out to the new capital city of Indonesia (Kalimantan) someday

  • @pepepepito623
    @pepepepito623 Рік тому +2

    Allah will help.

  • @someone-pi8zu
    @someone-pi8zu Рік тому

    i think Jakarta will be sinked soon or abandoned soon

  • @TyrantLibreals
    @TyrantLibreals Рік тому +1

    Hypocracy! Indonesian Government 🇮🇩 is currently invading West Papua New Guinea 🇵🇬 for resources & economy

    • @nurul-ps5tg
      @nurul-ps5tg Рік тому +1

      Jangan asal memfitnah lu yah dapat berita dari mana indonesia meninvasi papua barat makanya janggan mudah terprovokasi media dan cuman ditelan mentah mentah

    • @Scrat4357
      @Scrat4357 Місяць тому

      Man are you stupid or dont know about Indonesia history?
      The west part of the island of New Guinea was part of Dutch east indies therefore they are belong to the Indonesia

  • @sayaorangkaya221
    @sayaorangkaya221 Рік тому

    yang miskin miskin itu pendatang dari kampung pada bikin bangunan yang dibiarkan pemerintah pusat diera suharto sampai sby