▶ Comparison of Batman Forever 4K (4K DI) HDR10 vs Regular Version

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 95

  • @9114SouthCentralAv
    @9114SouthCentralAv 4 роки тому +31

    Whether you like the film or not, it’s hard to argue against its Oscar nomination for Best Cinematography. Stephen Goldblatt did a really good job.

  • @Kevinb1821
    @Kevinb1821 5 років тому +35

    Not many people like this movie but I love it. Probably because I was 7 when it came out.

    • @villagedipper
      @villagedipper 4 роки тому +1

      Kevinb1821 Dang right that’s what can make a movie special. Just watched forever tonight still love it.

    • @lander77477
      @lander77477 4 роки тому

      I was 12, and yeah, regardless of how objectively good a movie is, when you see it at a young age, you forever have a nostalgia for that movie

    • @CyborgSodaCollects
      @CyborgSodaCollects 2 роки тому

      We need the Schumacher cut.

    • @Jerry4050
      @Jerry4050 Рік тому

      Not as bad as Batman and Robin which I almost walked out. Even if the fourth movie was campy it was very disrespectful of just being the 1966 Batman which the older Burton films try to stay away from.

  • @marcbelo7301
    @marcbelo7301 4 роки тому +13

    This Batman will always have a special place with me.

  • @paul-blovesmovies
    @paul-blovesmovies 5 років тому +18

    I love these comparisons. 4K is such an expensive market, even the price of the TVs are ridiculous, I haven't gotten into it. But these videos have me convinced I'm missing out. Batman Forever is my favourite Batman movie and this just looks gorgeous. I'm a little mad at some of the colour changes, as Batman Forever relies on its beautiful bright colours, the Nicole shot early on is an awful change. But most of this comparison makes me need this so bad. Thanks for uploading this vid, awesome job as always, super helpful. 👍👍

  • @OCDSuomi
    @OCDSuomi 5 років тому +34

    The WB logo color change is interesting!

    • @Mymoonization
      @Mymoonization  5 років тому +7

      Indeed !

    • @jswatch9270
      @jswatch9270 5 років тому +2

      @@Mymoonization probably trying to make the background a little dark

    • @Mymoonization
      @Mymoonization  5 років тому +4

      I assure you that no !!

    • @jswatch9270
      @jswatch9270 5 років тому

      @@Mymoonization but I like it though can u review this version of the movie

    • @Mymoonization
      @Mymoonization  5 років тому

      What exactly do you want to know ??

  • @MattHrman-Cutis
    @MattHrman-Cutis 5 років тому +11

    I like both editions they're good in their own way

  • @marcbelo6088
    @marcbelo6088 3 роки тому +5

    many people will say "I think this movie is bad", but not me, I love this movie because I grew up with it.

  • @BatmanKnightfan
    @BatmanKnightfan 3 роки тому +11

    Nicole Kidman looks gorgeous in 4K Blu-ray 🥰😍😘😍❤️
    #releasetheschumachercut

    • @Jerry4050
      @Jerry4050 Рік тому

      Sucks now in the AMC theatre preview she has a bad face lift or her eyebrows arch in a way that she look weird as fuck

  • @Jerry4050
    @Jerry4050 Рік тому +1

    I saw the HBO Max version and its basically the 4K transfer since I noticed the neon light scene looks darker and I remember it being brighter in theatres in 1995. The colors look way tone down of how I remembered.

  • @Nindroidgamer110
    @Nindroidgamer110 3 роки тому +1

    I wonder what lead to the colour grading choices of the 4K remaster

  • @ivanisization
    @ivanisization 4 роки тому +2

    Best 4k clean up movies ive seen

  • @TemptingNoise
    @TemptingNoise Рік тому +2

    I do genuinely love the new colour grade but give people the choice of both.

  • @alexabraham8163
    @alexabraham8163 5 років тому +6

    Nice beat

  • @kevinmai3998
    @kevinmai3998 3 роки тому +2

    It’s like watching a brand new movie.

  • @UltraKryptonian
    @UltraKryptonian 3 роки тому +2

    BluRay looks good to me!

  • @evanzaremba4722
    @evanzaremba4722 Рік тому

    I loved Batman Forever as much as I love all of the Burton/Schumacher Batman movies.

  • @nope5657
    @nope5657 2 роки тому +1

    WB fucked up these transfers so badly. While technically they are superior in that the 4K has more definition and sharpness and even better color balance, they just slap a goddamn blue filter over EVERY. DAMN. FILM. It's not AS bad here as it is for Batman 89 and Returns, but it's what kept me from upgrading from the standard blu-rays.

  • @danielwalters2045
    @danielwalters2045 4 роки тому +1

    Why did they change the bloody Warner Bros logo from Dark Blue to Grey ?

  • @albertoray5888
    @albertoray5888 4 роки тому +3

    Wow superb work in 4k

    • @nope5657
      @nope5657 2 роки тому +1

      Nah. They just made it bluer.

  • @icecoldbluesonic
    @icecoldbluesonic 2 роки тому +1

    The blue tint looks kinda weird, I like the blu-ray more

  • @TheThrill007
    @TheThrill007 2 роки тому +1

    Oh my God, how did they manage to screw up the color correction on every film in this franchise??? The whole series looks so... blue!

  • @Wassonop
    @Wassonop 5 років тому +3

    Love your videos! Your videos help me decide if the 4K upgrade is worth it. Thank you for making these videos for us. Any chance on making the Toy Story trilogy in 4K comparison? I am curious as to how different those movies look. Thanks for all that you do on this channel!

    • @Mymoonization
      @Mymoonization  5 років тому +1

      Yes in this weekend Wasson.
      So stay tuned 👍 !

  • @adammartin9298
    @adammartin9298 5 років тому +3

    Brilliant upgrade

  • @doshi066
    @doshi066 5 років тому +3

    This was my first Batman film iv ever saw so it has a special place in my heart .. definitely wanna get the other films too...not sure about Batman and Robin through

  • @Slashingthrough
    @Slashingthrough 5 років тому +7

    It became a bit too dark in the 4k version imo

    • @Jerry4050
      @Jerry4050 Рік тому

      @M W I remember it from the theatres being way more colorful in 1995 which how I remember it. The HBO Max version uses the same dark colors. I felt like I was watching the older Tim Burton films unless they are trying to achieve that?

    • @Mike-t5r9q
      @Mike-t5r9q Рік тому

      ​@Jerry4050 that works out better in my opinion the movie now fits in more with the Tim Burton movies it makes Forever more edgy then ever before

  • @filipposcordo9501
    @filipposcordo9501 5 років тому +1

    Thank you very much for the answer about the remastered Superman in 4K! However I still don't understand why we need HDR or Dolby Vision instead of making the DVD to its final version without these two... I mean, can't they just set the colors, contrast and all the other things like if there was HDR or Dolby Vision?

    • @film-maniac
      @film-maniac 5 років тому +1

      They absolutely could. Heck, I can get an image similar to HDR on 1080p. Just by tweaking tv settings. Using VIVID (which I usually don't use) and playing with the various color settings. Want that red/orange unnatural push you get with HDR? (I dont, but...) Then play with the magenta, yellow, & red settings. And easy to darken the image yourself too.

    • @filipposcordo9501
      @filipposcordo9501 5 років тому

      @@film-maniac So HDR is useless? Hahahaha

    • @film-maniac
      @film-maniac 5 років тому

      @@filipposcordo9501 It's a fine gimmick as long as you don't care about creator intent & prefer your movies altered.

    • @Clay3613
      @Clay3613 5 років тому +1

      @@filipposcordo9501 Don't listen to that dude.

  • @XYZ-pm3ju
    @XYZ-pm3ju Рік тому

    Note to self: more often than not, remasters dick around with tonemapping.

  • @luxeroyal7286
    @luxeroyal7286 5 років тому +11

    They went overboard with the blue filter

  • @villagedipper
    @villagedipper 4 роки тому +1

    I’d get the 4Ks of 89-97 if I didn’t already have the dvd 4 pack. Keep the 90s gritty.

    • @Mike-t5r9q
      @Mike-t5r9q Рік тому

      Why not have both editions

    • @villagedipper
      @villagedipper Рік тому

      @@Mike-t5r9q I did finally upgrade to the 4K 4 pack when it went on sale last year. It’s a glorious upgrade from dvd.

  • @systemmonitor5295
    @systemmonitor5295 10 місяців тому

    The grading is horrific on some scenes.

  • @jens9473
    @jens9473 5 років тому

    Why does the WB logo look gray in the 4K version?

    • @film-maniac
      @film-maniac 5 років тому +1

      Because the HDR gimmick is an alteration of how a film is intended to look.

    • @jens9473
      @jens9473 5 років тому

      @@film-maniac ok so the blueish hue in the original is unintended?

    • @film-maniac
      @film-maniac 5 років тому

      @@jens9473 wasnt referring to that

    • @jens9473
      @jens9473 5 років тому

      @@film-maniac ok, what are you referring to? i thought the 4K alteration was supposed to give more color, not less? please correct me if I'm wrong I'm interested to know :)

    • @film-maniac
      @film-maniac 5 років тому

      @@jens9473 Less a matter of more color than it is altered color. I can't recall the movie but I saw one that had a scene with green mist. But with HDR, the mist was a smurf-like blue. I just saw Batman 89 in a theatrical presentation 2 months ago so it's fairly fresh in my mind. I can say that the HDR version is NOT how the film looks. I mentioned the one-eyed Batman already. The opening shot of Gotham City with HDR darkens the buildings but the small city lights are bright & prominent, like Xmas lights. That's not how it looked theatrically. The correct intended look is without HDR. Others will disagree but unlike 3D which adds depth but doesn't otherwise alter the image, I consider HDR a gimmick because without it, there's barely a difference between 1080p and 4k on most displays. HDR provides a difference, even if it's not accurate. As one director told me a couple years back after his already-colorful film hit HDR disc: "They made my movie look like a $%#& cartoon!" Others can disagree but I'll stick with how a movie was intended to look, unless the filmmakers themselves amend it. We've had HDR, then HDR-10, and now I've heard of an HDR Plus! (Not sure if that's the correct term.) How many HDRs do you need? LOL!

  • @chadking1938
    @chadking1938 5 років тому +3

    Could at least put on some soundtrack on.

    • @Mymoonization
      @Mymoonization  5 років тому +4

      For reasons of copyright I can’t unfortunately !

  • @8imuspaul1291
    @8imuspaul1291 5 років тому +1

    Nice comparison video.

  • @ne2740
    @ne2740 5 років тому +1

    Da entsteht ein ganz anderer Film

  • @film-maniac
    @film-maniac 5 років тому +3

    Too many artificial alterations in color (HDR is such a gimmick) and the usual darkened image, but at least that hides one of the nipples. So maybe some can call that an upgrade.

    • @Clay3613
      @Clay3613 5 років тому +4

      You know nothing about how HDR works do you?

  • @oldnewpixel
    @oldnewpixel 3 роки тому +1

    Haw can you "improve" an Oscar nominated cinematography for its 4K release? Make it blue. Make every bloody remaster out there blue

    • @majesticpublicenemy3201
      @majesticpublicenemy3201 3 роки тому +3

      Uh no, they made the film look the way it (and many other older films) looked back when it came out. The blu ray didn’t do it justice. Blue problem? Lol, other 90’s films like Batman Returns and The Matrix (and many more) had a bloody blue tint when they came out. But now some people, particularly those claiming HDR is nothing but a gimmick (smh) are claiming that “suddenly” these films are being given a blue tint for no good reason when in reality they look far closer to how the filmmakers intended.

  • @Jimmy091707
    @Jimmy091707 2 роки тому

    I bet many people watch this because of nicole kidman

  • @ktoogood11
    @ktoogood11 4 роки тому +3

    That tint is terrible I prefer the bluray

    • @majesticpublicenemy3201
      @majesticpublicenemy3201 3 роки тому

      Good for you, boomer xoomer. I’ll keep enjoying the 4K release that makes the movie look sharper and, yes, better than ever.

    • @ktoogood11
      @ktoogood11 3 роки тому

      @@majesticpublicenemy3201 🤡

  • @LOVE-lu7vc
    @LOVE-lu7vc 5 років тому +1

    😜🦇😻

  • @AztecMC1
    @AztecMC1 4 роки тому +1

    Except 4k hdr is always gray and dull... nice try.

    • @majesticpublicenemy3201
      @majesticpublicenemy3201 3 роки тому

      Except that isn’t the case. What is *usually* the case though, is older films just come out looking the way they did when they first came out - and actually sharper than ever. But nice try you and all the other anti-HDR critics …

  • @ktoogood11
    @ktoogood11 4 роки тому +1

    Seriously whats so special about that 🤷‍♂️😂

    • @crystalballer431
      @crystalballer431 4 роки тому

      Did you watch this on a 4k screen?

    • @ktoogood11
      @ktoogood11 4 роки тому

      @@crystalballer431 yes

    • @crystalballer431
      @crystalballer431 4 роки тому +1

      @@ktoogood11 I'm not sure what the issue is then

    • @ktoogood11
      @ktoogood11 4 роки тому

      @@crystalballer431 the issue i don't like the tint on the 4k i prefer the bluray it looks more natural

    • @crystalballer431
      @crystalballer431 4 роки тому +1

      @@ktoogood11 the tint doesn't bother me because it looks so cleaned up now. I think 1:32 is the best example of this.

  • @willkomnath2560
    @willkomnath2560 3 роки тому

    Slightly sharper and a blue tint does not mean better.

    • @majesticpublicenemy3201
      @majesticpublicenemy3201 3 роки тому

      It does when that’s how the film originally looked liked. Yes, like a bunch of other 90’s films that are “suddenly” blue in 4K, Batman Forever is now looking more like it should. But of course, you can’t tell that to certain snobs

  • @paul-blovesmovies
    @paul-blovesmovies 5 років тому

    I love these comparisons. 4K is such an expensive market, even the price of the TVs are ridiculous, I haven't gotten into it. But these videos have me convinced I'm missing out. Batman Forever is my favourite Batman movie and this just looks gorgeous. I'm a little mad at some of the colour changes, as Batman Forever relies on its beautiful bright colours, the Nicole shot early on is an awful change. But most of this comparison makes me need this so bad. Thanks for uploading this vid, awesome job as always, super helpful. 👍👍