Gossamer Gear The One Tent Review | Is it the Best Solo Trekking Pole Tent Value?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @wolfeadventures
    @wolfeadventures 2 роки тому +5

    It actually requires 50"/125cm poles.I really like this tent. At 6'2" the end tie outs are super helpful in increasing head/foot room. I find some sticks or branch and use them. I agree with the zipper-could have been on the other side and I wish it was a rainbow style to allow access to the entire vestibule-like Zpacks Duplex. I don't think that would have increased weight too much. You can also use small sections of shock cord on the bathtub tie out points to attach them to the corner fly stakes-this pulls the tub out which is helpful.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      That's correct--the height is lower than the poles because of the dip in the ridgeline between the trekking poles. Thanks, Wolfe!

    • @Xerute
      @Xerute Рік тому

      I am 6'2" with a NEMO Tensor 3" pad would I fit, also will it even fit a 25" NEMO rectangular pad?

    • @wolfeadventures
      @wolfeadventures Рік тому

      @@Xerute probably pushing limits but if the foot and head ends are pulled up and away as I described yes you could fit.

    • @Xerute
      @Xerute Рік тому +1

      @@wolfeadventures I currently have a NEMO dragonfly 2P and looking to cut weight and maybe be able to get into a smaller floor plan

    • @wolfeadventures
      @wolfeadventures Рік тому

      @@Xerute it’s a big change to go to a 1p from 2p. You will have little to no room inside the mesh for your gear. You will have to store it in the vestibule which is fine. Just takes getting used to.

  • @punkrocker1984
    @punkrocker1984 Рік тому

    Thank you for your comprehensive review. You helped me chose to buy this tent when I was unsure and struggling to find a good and unbiased overview of it online. Good job providing all the information needed for a well informed decision.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  Рік тому

      Thank you, Punk Rocker! I hope you like the tent as much as I have. Let me know how it works out for you!

  • @Everydaybackpacker
    @Everydaybackpacker 2 роки тому +2

    Great review! May have to think about this when I get my next tent. My buddy jay uses sticks to guy out the lines on the head and toes instead of trekking poles.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Solid plan! I hope to do something like that this year because the added headroom makes a biggg difference. Thanks, GM!

  • @catherinelauda6948
    @catherinelauda6948 14 днів тому

    Perfect review. Thanks

  • @wowwaterfalls
    @wowwaterfalls 2 роки тому +1

    Great content. These reviews are actually very helpful. Thanks for sharing. Big like 👍

  • @rolfdenver
    @rolfdenver 2 роки тому

    Great review and info as always … and I too own the BTT Gear Co. hoodie which performed beautifully for me on a long-distance backpack this summer.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you, Rolf! Hope you are doing well! Sorry for the delayed reply--can't wait to catch up soon!

  • @anthonyng8800
    @anthonyng8800 2 роки тому

    Good overview thanks. Slept in the silnylon version last night in Temps as low as 33F and windy. Honestly cannot see condensation developing here since the entire entrance side is mesh. Furthermore, the fly entrance beak cannot be setup any lower than 10 inches off the ground which means I got cold wind blown at me all night. If anyone has a hack, lmk. I tried to hang my puffy against the mesh door to block the wind, but need some clips. Agree about the low quality stakes (I replaced, supplemented with seatosummit larger ones for the 6 guy outs, using the originals for the 4 bathtub corners). Also don't Ike the door ties, they're not easy to work with. Looking forward to the xmid pro magnetic latch, large interior and hopefully better overall usability.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      That all makes great sense to me, Anthony! I am really curious about the balance between ventilation and condensation. I tend to sleep pretty warm, so I am hoping that helps compensate for the issues you point out here. I also agree with you about the door stays. Let me know how the Xmid turns out--I've been curious about it for a long time now!

  • @Top.Mallorca
    @Top.Mallorca 2 роки тому +1

    Good trent review! Warm greetings from Palma de Mallorca Spain! Like 👍

  • @BravestoneHikes
    @BravestoneHikes 2 роки тому +1

    Great gear review. I really like a trek pole tent. Looks like a great option and price point.

  • @Travelty
    @Travelty 2 роки тому +1

    Fantastic rocky view.

  • @MinuteontheMountain
    @MinuteontheMountain 2 роки тому +1

    Great review, my friend.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Thank you, MotM! Hope you are out enjoying the warmer weather this weekend!

  • @bjclark4936
    @bjclark4936 2 роки тому

    Agree about the door and stakes. I also don’t like the way the doors are connected to the front guyline. Either door should be able to be closed without the other being closed. But that door placement keeps me looking at other tents to replace my One.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Great thoughts, BJ! I think it’s a great but imperfect tent. How long have you had yours?

    • @bjclark4936
      @bjclark4936 2 роки тому

      I’ve had the One for about 3 years so it’s the slightly longer version which is good because the new version is too short for me. I also have replaced the guyline with slightly bigger cord as the 1.8 mm cord they use started to slip in the linelocs. But it is pretty spacious and sets up easily. This version also has 2 tieout points front and back along the seams for more stability on windy nights. I find using them really solidifies the tent regardless of wind so I use 4 shepherd hook stakes to tighten up the tent. It’s a good tent for the money

  • @MegaMastiffman
    @MegaMastiffman 2 роки тому

    Great review man thanks

  • @daveforbes6751
    @daveforbes6751 2 роки тому

    Awesome review Snackbox 👏. As you know I have the dcf version of this tent, which to my knowledge is the exact same except for material. By far the best under 1lb trekking pole tent out there. It is my go to tent. Ridiculously easy to set up and so far bomb proof after using it all year. It has survived wind, rain, and snow. I would replace the stakes and use at least 2 bigger ones of the 6 for the two trekking pole fly tie outs the other 4 for the base of the tent don’t matter as much. I usually replace the tent stakes. My only gripe at this point would be they use very little material for stake loops and are very small. I constantly worry about ripping them off 🤷‍♂️ Outside of that no real complaints. Condensation is always an issue with single wall tents. I had very little problems with condensation outside of camping right next to a steam. I was mostly in the west and Midwest where it not as humid. When I was out east it was early spring. The zipper on the fly is awesome. The packability is also ridiculously small 👍

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you, Dave! It's great to hear that I wasn't totally off on my initial evaluation, I love the idea of using two different types of stakes for the pole tie outs. That's really sharp. I am hoping the condensation is minimal on the CT this year. Where are you headed this summer? Any cool trips planned?!

  • @DaveOffGrid
    @DaveOffGrid 2 роки тому

    Diggin those water bottle stickers!! 😆 I have a question Snackbox! On the back wall it appears like it's up very high. You mentioned it's for better ventilation but is it a tighter mesh? How would that hold up in the rain?

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      I think it's gonna do pretty well overall. The wind would have to blow pretty hard to get under the fly, but I am a little more concerned about how this one will do in heavy wind. It's almost a literal sail, so we will see how it does this year on the CT!

  • @DoseofDirt
    @DoseofDirt 2 роки тому

    Hey man! Excellent overview of this tent! Seriously love the attention to detail. I've been looking at ultralight 1P tents options (I have a Lanshan 1 Pro and really like it, but I just can't help but want another one...or two... 🤣). My one hesitation on this one is the tapered foot end. I love my 23+ inch wide pads and haven't found a tapered one that I love, which means none of my favorite pads would fit in this tent. What pad are you using in it?
    Otherwise, I think this is honestly the most feature rich ultralight tent and it is an awesome price. Seriously tons of bells and whistles on this thing!

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      This tent has me really optimistic, though I was a little surprised at a few things. I use a Sea-to-Summit UL Insulated pad, so it tapers enough at the end to fit (I hope). Have you checked out the Six Moon Designs tents? They have a few that I think are at least this good but also tend to be about 33% less expensive. Thanks again, DoD!

    • @DoseofDirt
      @DoseofDirt 2 роки тому

      @@OutsideComfortZone Yes! I've been considering getting a lunar solo, but what attracts me to the GG is how light it is while still being affordable. But maybe I'll just get both. 😂

  • @חניאינגבר
    @חניאינגבר 2 роки тому

    Hi there, thanks for the great review! I'm going to take that one on my upcoming PCT, wondering how it performs in rainy and/or windy waether. Any thoughts?

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      That's a great tent for that trip. I think it will do well in rain and wind so long as you do your best to position the narrow side toward the wind, preferably feet facing the wind. You will likely have the most challenging parts early in the hike where staking it in can be tough, so I'd practice using rocks to tie out corners. Someone also recommended using bigger stakes for the two trekking pole guy lines, but these changes should be cheap and have a BIG payoff. Can't wait to hear more about your PCT hike!

  • @CDL_Gaming
    @CDL_Gaming Рік тому

    I would think that maybe the placement of the zipper has more to do with structural integrety than saving weight. if you have a zipper on that larger side and open the door you look to be losing like 60-70% of a wall. With a tent held up by trekking poles and guy line tension having more tension on a larger surface means more stability. Or at least it does in my mind.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  Рік тому

      I think this all sounds right to me. The tent is pretty stable in tough weather, as well, for what it’s worth.

  • @TravelHungryForLife
    @TravelHungryForLife 2 роки тому +1

    Wonderful share and channel here well done
    All the best see you again be healthy and safe CHEERS 👍

  • @tangenttrails
    @tangenttrails 2 роки тому

    Great review!
    Thanks.✌️

  • @noname-hs5hv
    @noname-hs5hv Рік тому

    I use the groundhog stakes from MSR with this tent. I agree that the stakes it comes with are incredibly cheap and annoying. Never had an issue with the groundhogs.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  Рік тому

      Those MSR stakes are really some of the absolute best out there. couldn't agree more!

  • @adventureawaits5003
    @adventureawaits5003 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for sharing 👍

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Thank you, Adventure Awaits! Looking forward to catching up on your latest videos!

  • @patricksilcox6878
    @patricksilcox6878 2 роки тому

    Love it! What's your favorite tent stake?

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      I like a basic shepherd's hook, but not the ultralite titanium ones. It has to be able to be hit it with a rock without being bent and pulled out easily when it's time to pack up. Thanks, Patrick! We gotta go camping again soon sometime!

  • @CastawayHikes
    @CastawayHikes 2 роки тому

    I am really interested in The One but I am not comfortable gambling on 10d silnylon. I would feel a lot better if they used sil coated polyester and heavier denier fabric like SMD does

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +1

      I can totally understand that, El Arr. I think the Deschutes with the Serenity bug net would be a nice option for you in that case. It would offer you a very comparable tent setup with only a couple extra ounces. Keep me posted on which route you choose!

    • @CastawayHikes
      @CastawayHikes 2 роки тому +1

      @@OutsideComfortZone I am pretty strongly considering getting crazy and selling a kidney for the Duplex 🤣

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому +2

      @@CastawayHikes haha! I can appreciate that but there are too many stellar tents for half the price and just a few more ounces that I’d buy a SMD tent and use the extra cash for a plane ticket to Yosemite, haha

  • @luckyjanetravel
    @luckyjanetravel 2 роки тому +1

    nice review look good tent

  • @USAThrill
    @USAThrill 2 роки тому +1

    This is cool!

  • @drsjr9275
    @drsjr9275 11 місяців тому

    I would like to know if you did a follow up on this tent after the CT? Thinking of getting one but I really want to know how it worked? Thank you!!!!

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  8 місяців тому

      Hey there, and sorry for the delayed reply. I did use it on the CT and think it's a pretty good tent overall. I do find the condensation to be a bit frustrating, but overall it's a good tent. I took it on the JMT this year, too, and it was decent there, as well. The tent itself is really stable, which I think makes up for the condensation issues I experienced. Did you end up picking one up?

  • @QuyenHoangVlog
    @QuyenHoangVlog 2 роки тому +1

    đi chơi ở ngọn núi đẹp quá phải dựng lều ở ,chúc bạn vui vẻ

  • @bikerob1231
    @bikerob1231 2 роки тому

    So what stakes are you going to use for replacements for this tent?

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Hey Bike Rob! I picked up four ultralight shepherd hooks for the corners and two MSR groundhog stakes for the two side tie downs. It seems to be the best balance between sturdy staking and light pegs.

  • @HawkeyeOnaMission
    @HawkeyeOnaMission 2 роки тому

    CT again?

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Yep, something about it has me hooked. How about you? Any cool trips coming up?

    • @HawkeyeOnaMission
      @HawkeyeOnaMission 2 роки тому +1

      Yup. Started last year, had to stop at Camp Hale to take care of some family issues, will pick back up in July. Live about 20 minutes from Waterton.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      @@HawkeyeOnaMission that’s stellar news. Hope to cross paths with you sometime this year!

  • @megaosfan
    @megaosfan 2 роки тому

    No need to throw shade. You are better than that!! The lottery has long been over with. Just sign up for an appointment online and go shop. It’s that simple.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      Oh my friend. I did have an appointment. They still would not sell me a hoody.

    • @megaosfan
      @megaosfan 2 роки тому +1

      @@OutsideComfortZone doesn’t sound right. Considering they allow you to get a size or color that isn’t in store (sold out) you can have it sent to the house (just have to pay for shipping). So what’s the story? Been there 3 times this past year and NEVER an issue.

    • @OutsideComfortZone
      @OutsideComfortZone  2 роки тому

      @@megaosfan it was really maddening. There’s a video about the entire ordeal from around November. My wife and I realllllyyy wanted to buy hoodies for wedding photos to support the local business, and they said we didn’t get the “right appointment.” We were both really bummed because we did everything right but they changed the policy after our appointment was made but before the appointment itself. When we got there, they had the item behind the counter and refused to let me buy the item because my appointment wasn’t the one I needed for that item. I gave up on them and decided the Etsy hand makers were more up my alley. I wish the folks in Leadville the best, but I also heard from dozens of folks about their bad experiences there when I posted my video.

  • @villagewallybachay2
    @villagewallybachay2 2 роки тому +1

    You are nice video very nice once very good

  • @zladatv
    @zladatv 2 роки тому

    *👍супер и привет от тренера по футболу!!!!!-!!!!!-!!!!!-!!!-*