Dr. Manning SWEARS It's 'Shaken Baby Syndrome' | Chicago Med
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 вер 2024
- Season 1 Episode 12 "Guilty"
Dr. Halstead continues to deal with the fallout from the lawsuit brought against him by his DNR patient. A police officer tries to stop a DUI driver from being taken to surgery, leading to Maggie being arrested, and Dr. Manning misdiagnoses a mother of child abuse. Meanwhile, Dr. Charles and Reese diagnose a patient with suicidal thoughts and place him on psychological hold.
Watch full episodes Of Chicago [INSERT CORRECT] on Google Play: [INSERT LINK]
Watch full episodes Of Chicago [INSERT CORRECT] on Itunes: [INSERT LINK]
Manning always was too quick to judge people, especially parents.
For anyone who wants to know what happened, the mother was in a car accident whilst pregnant, the baby was injured at the time but thought to make a full recovery, except even rolling over in the crib could have ruptured the hematoma. The mother didn't abuse the child, manning just didn't get a full history or even check with the baby's pediatrician before calling dcfs.
Ikr
Then what happened?
@@tarua3076 I think everything got cleared up with CPS, but it was still a big mistake that understandably pissed off the mother
@Ashton Vandenberg not only was this aired years ago (it's season 1), you had to click read more after "of you want to know what happened"
Thank you
Who else hasn't watched a single full episode, and has only watched these clips?
Mee
Me lol I found it on Amazon prime yesterday I might have to give it a go
I have watched the full episodes and let me tell you, the grass isn’t greener on the other side. The clips sounds better etc
I've found generally just watching the clips is more entertaining than the full episode clips are the highlight of the episode cutting out the boring stuff
@@CanadianChipmunk I’ve been watching Chicago Fire on prime
I think Will said something about Manning that I found so right. It was something about how she always thinks she's right, that she's 'perfect', or the closest thing to it. And honestly her character is like that, it's frustrating, but realistic, sadly there are doctors and nurses like that.
If I remember correctly that's when Will's stolen gun was used to shoot a kid right ? So that comment even though correct was brushed off as Will feeling guilty for hurting a kid
@Xyz Xyz yep
Dr Manning constantly looks down on other mothers and acts as if she is mother Mary
She is the most irritating character I've ever seen on screen, and I suffered through 8 seasons of Elena Gilbert.
@@fernandaescobar3721 you've not watched every show or movie so cant judge
@@fernandaescobar3721 Don't even get started on Elena.
I know this is just a show but it’s so easy to forget drs are humans too. And they literally have people’s lives in their hands. It’s common for them to overthink situations. They want the best for their patients (and I’m not agreeing she was right btw)
@@Bdon_1874 They said the most irritating character THEY’VE EVER SEEN ON SCREEN. Doesn’t matter whether they’ve seen every movie or show or not.
The baby did a five star proformace. Bravo baby, bravo👏👏👏
Should've named the baby Oscar
That baby looked so cute when they did the head scan
Dr. Manning's holier than thou attitude is really insufferable.
She's the same in every case involving children- always so quick to judge and most of the time thinking she's better than the parents.
She want's to judge she should ask herself how much time she spends with her own kid
Yeah it's to the point were it's really hard for me to watch videos involving children that have her in
@@Avatarbob11 I hate it when she even gets involved in other doctors cases involving children and undermines them-then is oh so surprised when she's wrong and they're right.
I don't like her in general- but especially not on child cases
@@jadebolt4416 I generally don't mind her in general it's when she gets involved with a case that is to do with children weather it's her case or not that I find her hard to watch as it's pretty much always
Dr. Manning: "oh the child is injured/ill? It's obviously child abuse!"
Other Dr: "Dr Manning I turns out it wasn't child abuse"
Dr. Manning: "well it could have been"
these vids aren't real
Dr Manning is so judgmental. Shaken Baby Syndrome is often accidental from parents who truly love their children and just forget themselves while being overly stressed, it's the reason they are so happy to take their children to the hospital. As well as that, like in this case, Doctor's often jump to SBS rather than actually exploring all options because it's an easy diagnosis
I want to point out that usually it’s pretty hard for a baby to get shaken baby syndrome. They have to be like proper violently shaked for it to happen so it’s not like it just accidentally happens while playing. Usually babies get it when parents leave the baby with a family member or a carer that they think they can trust but turns out they can’t.
Shaken baby syndrome requires violent shaking, so yes it is outcome of abuse.
I think a large part of it too is a lack of education about it. I didn't know about SBS until I watched a youtube video about it (I'm not a parent though). How many parents/family members don't realise how fragile babies are and that shaking them can do irreversable damage
It’s often parents who are overtired/stressed and it’s usually just a split moment of rage. It’s not an excuse at all hurting a child is the worst of the worst, but that’s often how it happens and it’s a shame bc the consequences are irreversible
Manning gets too involved with patients but I guess that’s how her character is.
The other person agreed
The one thing I noticed was that it all the scenes the mom wasn’t holding the baby, she was NOT crying
What do u mean-
Nusrat Bibi, I think she's saying that in the scenes where the mother was not holding the baby, she was not crying. Aka, the mother cries when holding the baby and it causes her stress c:
@@lokid2122 oh okay ty for tell meh but I am sick of people doing this to there babys if there not gonna take care of it and they say they dont want the damm baby but then when it actully gets taken away they be like I want my baby back its my baby those people duscust me...
@@hi.5311 Except that this commenter's statement isn't true- we saw the mother holding the baby and it wasn't crying. The description states that Manning was wrong too.
@@Charlie-yv3ib intresting...
I get Manning has a high level or morality but there is also a very high sense of judgement and a "holier than though" tone with her that brings the sense of self righteousness and self superiority as a doctor you're not meant to judge or criticise your patients you're just meant to act out your duties. She's a doctor not a critic.
45 seconds in who’s watched one episode and now addicted
Really me i am one of the 100%
Same
Me
The full sessions and stuff are on Amazon prime video if y’all have it
Dr. Manning was wrong for assuming it’s child abuse it’s not the only way a baby can get sbs I‘m soooo irritated
@Ashton Vandenberg I mean, they're still allowed to get irritated. Also, "usually," doesn't mean always. Another commenter explained it was from complications during pregnancy. It wasn't fair of Manning to assume it was child abuse instantly. It's purposely showing the flaws of the character.
Also I feel I should note that most stories I've heard from shaken baby syndrome come from the parents themselves- usually one or the other leaves the kiddo alone with someone (a parent or babysitter) they think they can trust and that's how it ends up happening, unfortunately :/
Righttttt
@Ashton Vandenberg yes it is only a TV show but it does happen in real life too parents have been accused of abuse in the past and it transpires that there was an underlying medical problem misdiagnosis does happen I have Elhers Danlos Syndrome it's a disorder that affects connective tissue muscles and joints I have orthostatic tachycardia too as well as other complications it took years for me to be listened to I had symptoms from childhood at 16 it became chronic then at 21 it got worse I was in and out of hospital sick from work then at 27 I finally get an accurate diagnosis I'm now 30 we had social workers asking questions because of the injuries I sustained I bruise easily dislocate so you see my point
I love dr many but I do think she's wrong
I don't like doctor Manning she's always mommy shaming and to quick to judge
Maybe shes just over protective. Since she has a child herself?
@@summerl3617 yeah being overprotective is also good. But as a professional she should remain more neutral and cut everything else out first before giving a mother this much unnecessary stress and a lot of trouble. Getting to here you abuse your child and you can lose her is one of the most painful things for a mother. Especially if it's not true.
@@lIrI28282 yea I was surprised when they thought the mother was abusing the baby
@@lIrI28282 The mother was abusing the baby though.....
@@coreywilliams1454 she wasnt... the baby had a bleed in the brain because of a car accident the mum had when she was pregnant
Dr Manning is too emotional and quick to jump the gun in scenarios like this
But the other person agreed
Its really weird seeing that Dr. Manning was Melissa in pll and pll is my absolute fav show EVER!!!
Wait there same person omg i see now
She even gets engaged with the actor who played Ezra in pll in this show :D
I was shook aswell, I was like hold up I recognise that face
Omg whatttttt I never knew lol
Haha funny. My name is Melissa and my daughter is Natalie lol
Babies fall of beds alllll the time or roll and hit there heads even on the floor. This was stupid
Yes but I don't think a one time thing would have caused this. This is literally shaking a baby out of anger. It is horrible but even loving mothers sometimes snap, maybe due to lack of sleep, or the baby is crying too much, or post partum depression.
The last time I was this early Dr Reese was still here 😭💙
Okay, so who makes the baby "actor" cry before they shoot the scene?
"Cut! Okay, we need louder screaming, and her face needs to be red. Somebody pinch her harder. Take 14. And... Action!"
Sometimes it’s just a robot
@Mary Clare Mayo What they do actually is pretend to cry and that makes the baby cry.
Manning has always hated Will for getting involved with patients' personal opinions (like the anti vaxers) but she doesn't realize that what she does is even worse.
I miss Dr.Reese so much 😣
What happens to her
@@Phantom-hs1hr idk
@@Phantom-hs1hr Dr. Reese has something going on with her father in one of the episodes (around season 3 I believe? Probably wrong tho) and she leaves for a different hospital in the show because the actress left
@@xskyren_ri thats so sad
Theres nothing i love more than when a doctor or a parent or just someone make an horrible story up with why they have a illness or demage to anything, and i just love when they get proven wrong, like this poor woman (i know this isent real but it happens sometimes) but this woman got dragged away from her baby bc Dr. Manning was to quick to judge.
i never seen the episode, did she really shake her daughter?
@@TomAS-wm5mn No, before the birth the mother got into a car accident. That caused the shaken baby syndrome. The mother was told the baby would make a full recovery.
youtube: 14 comments
me: can i see
youtube: *no*
This guys is a example of somebody trying to get attention for likes :)
@@mythxv3204 Just let the poor guy do it. He ain't hurting no-one.
@@aksy6780 :/ but it is harrassment BIG HARRASSMENT lol
@@aksy6780 I'm jokinggg chill
Ik This is all acting but manning is always way to quick to judge people
Not the first time she acts this way towards a mother. This makes her really spiteful, but also proves she's good as an actress.
Everyone is very quick to criticise the actions that Dr Manning took, but what if the case was child abuse and she ignored it. Also the other doctor did agree with the diagnosis so the blame can’t be fully hers, she was doing what she thought was best. People also need to remember that yes this is a tv show but these situations do happen in real life and need to be looked out for.
It's a doctors job if they suspect abuse to report it. But, that's not what bother me. Before we even know what's wrong Manning is having a gossiping convo with the mom judging her on her age, smoking, and her baby daddy. The mother isn't her patient but Manning should have tried to be unbias in the least build a bit of report to be able to her more open to answer questions like history and other stuff about her actual patient the baby. Her conduct with the mother is t
what is getting ppl so mad. A doctor should not get tunnel vision and the fact she's so judgemental so quickly makes me wonder why she works so closely with patients. It much cause her problems a lot and in other clips I've seen it screw her because she pisses off her patients and they close up to her
@@finnsnow2495 I definitely agree that her communication skills could use some work, she is known for upsetting/angering people in the hospital. Initially I was referring to a lot of the original, unedited comments I was seeing about her just assuming it was abuse because I can understand why she reported it straight away (she may have believed the child was in danger). It would be better is she could build more of a relationship as patients would open up more and you may discover it’s not what it first looks like but as she didn’t I do understand her reporting it. That’s just what I originally meant.
In the episode it was revealed that the mom was in a car crash before the pregnancy so that's why the baby had sbs if Dr. Manning wasn't so quick to make the assumption and just asked for her history this could've been avoided. She's way too quick to judge other parents this isn't even the first time this has happened
@@jesussy2558 in this episode it was poor judgement and she definitely should have checked before reporting it but you never know one day it could save a life.
@@charlottecameron3761 okay but she needs to think about the consequences of her actions cause it can be so traumatizing. I was abused by my step-dad and cps took me from not only my dad but my mom because they thought she was abusing me too. That's traumatizing for a child to get taken away from their only support system. Her actions are careless but have severe consequences. As a professional she needs to be thorough or else she's gonna cause more harm than good. This isn't even the first time she's done this, she's so judgemental of other parents and it's problematic.
Who loves Chicago med ⬇️ I do!!
meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
I don't believe a doctor, convinced that a parent shook their infant, would say, "A mother intentionally harmed her child." That's just nonsense.
If a parent shakes their baby out of frustration, distress, whatever, that is NOT intentionally harming the child. It's a horrible thing to do, but it is very unlikely that any harm to the child was intended.
Ffs. It is a tv show. Not real.
@@hp2385 Wow, what an original comment! So insightful too! And informative--I never realized it was just TV show (not real!). I thought it was a documentary.
Why bother watching it if it's just a TV show? Because the enjoyment of watching it is letting yourself get invested in it as if it were real.
@@UA-camallowedmynametobestolen yes. And hating and loving characters is part of it. But y would u get upset about her sating she intentionally harmed her baby. She could have been right. She cant take chances.
@@hp2385 I think it's a bit of an exaggeration to suggest that I got "upset." I was annoying, displeased. I took issue with it.
But more importantly, is it OK to accuse a parent of intentionally harming their child--not just suggesting it as a possibility, but going so far as to state it as a fact--because it MIGHT be true?
And what chances would she be taking by not making the assumption that the presumed abuse was done maliciously?
@@UA-camallowedmynametobestolen i dont think it is 2 far. There will be a court case and evidence will be shown and all that. So if she didnt do it then she will get her baby back
Appreciate them treating a migraine patient. Those who know migraines now how fucking brutal they can be. Can even cause brain swelling
Chicago fire and STELLARIDE won the night yesterday!! THE LAST SCENE WAS THE BEST THING I HAVE EVER SEEN🥺🙏🥰❤️ I was bawling my eyes out in happiness and love😍💕
I get so annoyed with Dr.Manning. She always looking down at mothers and thinks she knows better, then when she gets called out and she decides she is the victim.
I mean it’s good for it to be inspected, but surely there’s a better way than dragging the mum out infront of everyone as if she is being arrested based on an assumption, when though unlikely there are many ways a baby could end up with these injuries. They know how much stress she is under after being abandoned by her family, friends, and the dad...
I swear she's always judgemental and overly emotional.
At least attempt to not judge the mom for once in your life.
If she'd shaken the baby, she'd have said that the baby rolled off something and must have been hurt that way
It didn't end up being childabuse, Dr Manning should have got fired over this
1:35 I couldn’t look at anything else but Torrey’s jawline, like how
Hello i love this show
I’ve just realised doctor Manning is doctor fell in the vampire diaries
This is why I don't like social services they sadly have too much power. When they do have power they don't usually get it right
Natalie is such a judgemental person she’s seriously the most annoying character on the show
Dr Manning is so judgemental the look she gave her when she found out she had a smoke it’s actually crazy she hasn’t been fired for just being straight up rude to all the mothers she runs into and then assumes that she shook her baby when it could have been a babysitter or anything definitely not a fan of her
Ya cause a crying baby would just get rushed back like that lol ya right
How did the baby just magically stop crying.
Who else just scrolls through the comment section after the video ends to find out what happened during the rest of the episode?
Alternate title for this clip should be Natalie judging tf outta another mother for 5 minutes straight
Also something I found funny
3:15
Stares a women down with an intense & hateful glare saying "She did this"
** Mom lovingly rocks baby & looks so sweet **
Child abuse!
🤣🤣
The least realistic part of this clip is the idea that the woman could just barge into the ER and get treatment for her baby before anyone checks her insurance info. Dr Manning's condescendance and hasty child abuse accusations were less surprising to me, sadly. Her character does have a tendency to jump to conclusions and be too judgmental 😑
Dr manning has made accusations against parents before that have turned out to be wrong. She has also locked a door band forced treatment she's not allowed to give. In real life a doctor like that would be struck off the register for being unhinged and refusing to follow policies put in place to protect parents and there children. She's a bad doctor. Don't admire this kind of doctor. Do no harm means nothing to them
This is so addicting for some reason 👁️👄👁️🤞
It seriously is 🤣
Why does this Manning Dr always go to the conclusion without even consulting the patient or the members of the family she has done this so many times....ahe is really annoying sometimes....she has no right to do this without even talking to that mother....😑
I like Dr. Manning but her savior complex adds bias to her diagnosis everytime.
I love all of your channels 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Does anyone know what happened
yh. the mother didnt hurt the baby. i cant remember exactly but i think it was. the mother had an accident while she was pregnant
the baby was born with a condition due to pre-labour issues that mimics shaken baby syndrome. Manning feels horrible about it and the mother isn't too happy either.
@@ihasheikh yep, ur absolutely right, she had a car accident before while she was pregnant, and it hurt the baby but was expected to make a full recovery
i want dr reese back..
All these people saying Manning is quick to judge but with the facts she had there was a reasonable chance of child abuse and if doctors get even a whiff of child abuse they're supposed to call up CPS immediately so they can run a full investigation into the matter.
The point is she didn't have all the facts and didn't bother to get them. She was judgemental of the mother from the start and didn't even wait to hear from the primary pediatrician. You don't accuse a bunch of parents of child abuse just because one day it can be. Getting CPS called it or having the (good) parents taken away can be traumatizing to both parent and child.
And yet so often they don't call DoCS because there's not enough evidence to report given hospital policy, and plenty of dead kids are the results
She didn't even check the babys medical history, she was extremely quick to judge medical history is one of the first things you get when you have a patient come in
i'm only 2 min in and excuse me, the mother did not have to apologise for snapping at Dr Manning. she had every right. people come to doctors for help, not to be judged and feel bad about ourselves. at least wait until you have all the facts before making assumptions about if someone is a bad parent or not.
dr.manning judges mothers so fast like sit down you aren't perfect either
Okay there’s a difference between character and actor. I’m not a big fan of Dr.Manning but the actor Torey DeVitto is an amazing.
your gonna love tvd (she plays meridith fell) s3
Love this
after watching chicago med, everytime i see melissa in PLL i'm like, dr manning step in and help
For anyone who doesn't know what Shaken Baby Syndrome - Shaken Baby Syndrome (also known as Shaken Impact Syndrome) is a form of abuse inflicted upon a child. It usually occurs when a parent or other caregiver shakes a baby out of anger or frustration, often because the baby will not stop crying.
It also has been contested as an actual diagnosis as the injuries could be something else
Why do they call it a 'syndrome' someone shaking a kid isnt a syndrome
@@thoraneh7365 It refers to the symptoms that manifest as a result of the baby being shaken, not the act of shaking itself.
Researchers are looking into possible links between early brain injury to the cerebellum and the development of schizophrenia.
SBS injures the back of the brain, too, and not just the frontal lobes.
Probably not a good idea to smack your kid's head nor face either, if there's something to the idea that physical injury to the cerebellum develops into a neurodevelopmental disorder we call schizophrenia.
Did you know autism and mood disorders are linked to the cerebellum, too
Ongoing scientific research is awesome. More funding to education and pure investigate research is needed
I like dr Manning but she is always wayyyyy to quick to judge parents, and she never gets the full story, and even though she apologizes she always does it again
Which episode is this?
Is that really the best way to deal with a woman that could have ppd?
Mr. Wilford?
*Dr manning noises intensifies*
Can Manning step off her moral high-ground for five minutes pls
I think I know Madeleine from. DCFS personally, she’s in 90% of dr mannings clips
I was really into chicago med but couldn't continue because of manning, shes way too irritating and gets into everyone's business too much
I have become addicted to these clips. This show however is not written well nor are the characters well developed. If you compare this show to House, New Amsterdam or even The Good Doctor. This show is like a soap opera.
This baby is a good actor
the mom is the gymnast who got killed in final destination
Omg!
anyone else notice the description isn't filled out instead just left copied for all the other Chicago?
How do they get a baby to keep still for a m.r.i.?normally this show is pretty realistic but adults can struggle with m.r.i.'s so how could a baby keep still? I've had one and there horrible can't imagine what it's like for a child,can anyone medical tell me how they do it?
Why
Dr Manning is too quick to judge but not because she thinks she's too perfect or always right, it's her instinct to always protect those that can't protect themselves,...I think it hurts her more when she thinks of a mother who can hurt her own child she's a damb good doctor though
irl manning would be a terrible doctor she can't separate herself.
who else knows natalie manning from pretty little liars, melissa hastings
I wish they showed the end clip after they find out what happens like if she didn't & something else was the cause id love to see Nats face after the last scene of this clip 😅 I imagine her face being like 😳 🤡 looking at the conversation at 1:20 I need to know how it ends!!!
Update: saw a comment saying what happened & all I can say is 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
still would love to see Natalie's face when she found out
123movies with the episode number and season . Hope it helps!
@@definingreality9778 ooo I didn't know 123 movies was still going 🤣 definitely going to go watch
Dr Manning, on her high Horse again.
dr,manning acts like she the perfect mother she makes me sick
She is not wrong at all. There is a impossibly low chance of SBS being caused by a car crash during pregnancy. On the other hand, child abuse is very common and should be reported as soon as possible if suspected. Everyone here seems to be an arm chair lawyer, doctor, mother,social worker etc. calm down children.
Soo did she do it or not?
@Kytic Thankss
1:04 brought to you by samsung
I don't watch this show but I watched quite a few clips and Manning has horrible bedside manner with most of her patients. Like what doctor starts off the way she did with a mother who was just all shaken up by her sick baby. She went outside to smoke that could have been a one off thing because of the stress but instead she gives the most condesending look and then lectures about second hand smoke. I know the baby is her patient but the mother is almost a second hand one when all info will come from her. How could you get accurate patient history or build report when you start off like that. And then she's like " would you like me to call the father" and she said it very snoopy like she was fishing for info and then the way she said " you don't know the father!". Like this isn't your sister Manning you can't just judge and act like a confessing jackass to these people. Even when Manning is right about people being neglectful or stuff she usually goes about it in the worst way like with the malnourished boy in one of these clips. The reason I don't watch the show is honestly because she annoys me so much idk if it's just these particular clips but they don't paint her in a good light
I would sue 🤡
what's shaken baby syndrome
What happens next someone please tell me ?
Dr Manning finds out that the mother was in a car accident while she was pregnant which caused the baby's injuries. The baby's brain injuries healed but any sort of movement like rolling in a cot could have caused the hematoma. Then Dr Manning tells Goodwin what she found out and they have to sort it out with the DYFS. The mother is not happy but I'm pretty sure the baby is ok in the end, but she might have seizures for life or something.
@@ek4730 thank you so much your the best where can I watch full episodes ?
Man,US health care is really expensive
No wonder they make such shows
I’ve only watched clips, but from so can see Dr. Manning should be let go!
I think that the baby was having a heart attack or she was having trouble breathing or the mum was hurting the baby
I don't like her she's too judgementl and wrong she see's what she wants too and ignores everything else she hasn't got her records over yet......
The actress who plays the mom, man... lady, go to acting school. 😂
Ooooooooo that baby sucking his thumbbb whaatt a cutieee😭❤️
id never leave my baby with dr. manning never sorry i cant stand her
Doctor Manning was in the right to report it, it’s a Safeguarding practice that’s required. If you suspect, you report. However, she should’ve looked into every possible cause as to why it could’ve happened.
Anyone else find the doctor so annoying sometimes
Well
But like.