love this young sheikh lectures and answers to common question . may Allah protect him and give him more knowledge of the deen in the Qura and sunnah way
-What is bidah -What are the rulings pertaining to bid’ah -Difference between Masaail ijtihadiyyah and clear-cut bidah -Difference between mubtadi and a person of bidah -Taking from as-habiya bid’ah
Allahu Akbar.!! May Allah guide us to the truth this is the problem we are facing here in Ghana. in our masjid those.refused to take sheikh Rabee"s disparagement are call misguided and innovators .i will be very happy you could visit our masjid in Ghana
Taraweeh was done by the prophet him self. The term bidah Umar used has nothing to do with the real meaning of bidah used by Schullers later on. The prophet says من أحدث في أمرنا ماليس منه فهو رد.او كما قال صلى الله عليه وسلم.
didn't imam ash-shafi'i explain the bidah hasanah? in the same vein as omar (ra)? that if it is rooted in islaam then it is a good bidah... i.e. the 20 rakah of tarawih vs the sunnah of 8...
Yes, imam Syafi'i explain bid'ah Hasanah is a SUNNAH which is we do now (before we don't). Not an innovation which is new in our religion. 20 rakaat in which Umar Radhiyallahu Anhu did is a Sunnah, why? Because Rasulullah is not limit the rakaat for tarawih, Rasulullah shalallahu alaihi wassalam said sholat 2 by 2 rakaat, he didn't mention for how many. But Rasulullah give an example with 8 rakaat. So 20 rakaat is new number. That is bid'ah hasanah which is imam Syafi'i mean. But some people misinterpreted, they can create a new sholat and they think it's bid'ah hasanah. Nooo it's not what imam Syafi'i mean.
@@hotaryuzaki Imam Suyuti is not the prophet, he can make mistakes and if he said that there is bid'ah hasanah he is wrong and we ask Allah to forgive him for his mistake. Bid'ah hasanah is saying the prophet was ignorant, that he hid knowledge we are in need of.
@@ia1399 when you don’t have knowledge don’t dare to challenge scholars that’s not your job and i’m not gonna argue with you about that or anything but just please take my advice as your little brother and don’t challenge or say a scholar made a mistake without full knowledge i’m not saying they never make mistakes i’m just saying we can’t challenge them because that sets a wrong precedent and our kids will be disrespectful so leave it for the scholars you just follow one of the 4 madhabs
@@maherelzaher As mentioned in the videos, even this one, people who were followers of innovated beliefs and methodologies that reached the level of kufr.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t I looked up salafi publications And it seemed just everyone was refuting them for their deviant claims 🤣. Even other Salafi groups That’s not my Aqeedah You still haven’t presented any proof for your claim
@@maherelzaher The video I mentioned is not by salafipublications- it’s a refutation against them akhi. The proof is that it is well known in the musnad of imam Ahmed that many names in there are people who had innovations with them.
love this young sheikh lectures and answers to common question .
may Allah protect him and give him more knowledge of the deen in the Qura and sunnah way
Ameen
May Allah guide us all.
Ameen
May Allah bless you brother.
That's that jet fuel Shaikh الله اكبر
-What is bidah
-What are the rulings pertaining to bid’ah
-Difference between Masaail ijtihadiyyah and clear-cut bidah
-Difference between mubtadi and a person of bidah
-Taking from as-habiya bid’ah
5th Madhhab Bidah is we’re people donthingvthat are not in the sunnah and it is sinful for doing bidah
God bless you
Rebounds really shaykh 🤺🐝🐝🐝
Allahu Akbar.!! May Allah guide us to the truth this is the problem we are facing here in Ghana. in our masjid those.refused to take sheikh Rabee"s disparagement are call misguided and innovators .i will be very happy you could visit our masjid in Ghana
Listen to the first 15 minutes, was this intentional?
Who is Shareef and Abu Jameel?
So What is Taraweh? Umar R said its Bidda Hasana?!
Bidah in the linguistic sense and not in the literal sense as the prophet himself prayed taraweeh.
Taraweeh was done by the prophet him self. The term bidah Umar used has nothing to do with the real meaning of bidah used by Schullers later on. The prophet says من أحدث في أمرنا ماليس منه فهو رد.او كما قال صلى الله عليه وسلم.
didn't imam ash-shafi'i explain the bidah hasanah? in the same vein as omar (ra)? that if it is rooted in islaam then it is a good bidah... i.e. the 20 rakah of tarawih vs the sunnah of 8...
ua-cam.com/video/Api4807goM0/v-deo.html
How can it be a bidah if its already rooted in Islam?
Yes, imam Syafi'i explain bid'ah Hasanah is a SUNNAH which is we do now (before we don't).
Not an innovation which is new in our religion.
20 rakaat in which Umar Radhiyallahu Anhu did is a Sunnah, why?
Because Rasulullah is not limit the rakaat for tarawih, Rasulullah shalallahu alaihi wassalam said sholat 2 by 2 rakaat, he didn't mention for how many.
But Rasulullah give an example with 8 rakaat.
So 20 rakaat is new number.
That is bid'ah hasanah which is imam Syafi'i mean.
But some people misinterpreted, they can create a new sholat and they think it's bid'ah hasanah.
Nooo it's not what imam Syafi'i mean.
@@hotaryuzaki Imam Suyuti is not the prophet, he can make mistakes and if he said that there is bid'ah hasanah he is wrong and we ask Allah to forgive him for his mistake. Bid'ah hasanah is saying the prophet was ignorant, that he hid knowledge we are in need of.
@@ia1399 when you don’t have knowledge don’t dare to challenge scholars that’s not your job and i’m not gonna argue with you about that or anything but just please take my advice as your little brother and don’t challenge or say a scholar made a mistake without full knowledge i’m not saying they never make mistakes i’m just saying we can’t challenge them because that sets a wrong precedent and our kids will be disrespectful so leave it for the scholars you just follow one of the 4 madhabs
You said Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal learned from innovators?
He reported hadiths from innovators yes. Go to the video 'stop the fitnah salafipublications' for more info.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4tso who are some of the innovators he learned from?
@@maherelzaher As mentioned in the videos, even this one, people who were followers of innovated beliefs and methodologies that reached the level of kufr.
@@user-ze9tj9yj4t I looked up salafi publications
And it seemed just everyone was refuting them for their deviant claims 🤣. Even other Salafi groups
That’s not my Aqeedah
You still haven’t presented any proof for your claim
@@maherelzaher The video I mentioned is not by salafipublications- it’s a refutation against them akhi. The proof is that it is well known in the musnad of imam Ahmed that many names in there are people who had innovations with them.