That was like a reading a research paper. The arguments were coherent backed up with references and examples, and counter-examples. Finished off with a logical conclusions. Impressive Allahuma barik, may Allah increase you in knowledge and wisdom
What are you smoking? Hijab hasn't provided references for anything and has built his stance on incorrect premises. This is deviance, and any Muslim knows this. There is no nuanced view on this in our religion. The arguments presented are weak, the comparisons are non-analogous, and the ijtihad cited comes from weak 'scholars.' Does this mean I can also produce content with women and music and claim I'm disobeying Allah SWT for the greater good of the Ummah? This is nonsense.
@@m_shakeshe said it is like a research paper and quite frankly, hijab isn't going to be providing references, why can't you look them up yourself? you just ignored every single argument of maslaha then jumped to a conclusion of it being, doing even worse yourself what you accuse hijab of doing - not even demonstrating why he's wrong let alone bring evidence. The deen does not work on your feelings and is way more nuanced to fit the needs of each muslim, we've seen it from the time of the sahaba to ibn Taymiyyah and more recently the saudi shuyookh who have no problem being pragmatic with political issues involving AQEEDAH implications let alone normal stuff like Acapella and non muslim women display upon which there is already ikhtilaf. You can stay ignorant, atleast don't attack other muslims with intentions for the overall betterment of the ummah. There is room for nuance, intellect and flexibility in our deen do not turn it into irrational strict Christianity in the 14th century which eventually lead to Protestantism and schism of their religion, destroying the community because they were stuck with dogmatic beliefs.
@@AMDesignAndDevits funny how all the comments are "its wrong to me, in my opinion" yet no one refutes any of the evidence he brought up, such as the fatawah of bin baz or evidence of issues on maslaha. SubhanAllah.
@@elyonxx I think you need to pipe down. You are being emotional. Your justification is non-analogous. Are you trying to say that abiding by the teachings of Islam will lead to an irrationally strict 14th-century Christianity? This implies you view Islamic teachings as overly strict and in need of leeway, suggesting you have a problem with them. The Prophet (pbuh) himself did not resort to using women and music to attract people, even when non-believers used these methods. He could have, but this is not the will of Allah SWT. The message is clear: the Truth stands on its own. Why would we need to use prohibited means to spread it? Ask yourself, what is the aim here? To gain more Muslim followers through fringe prohibited means? Who has placed this burden on Brother Hijab? He is overburdening himself with things he is not obligated to do. His obligation is to follow the commands of Allah (SWT). You mentioned 'the sahaba to Ibn Taymiyyah and more recently the Saudi shuyookh.' I challenge you to find one person among them who would endorse a 'drama series' featuring music, uncovered girls, and intermingling. Brother Hijab is aligning with fringe ideas from individuals like 'Al Daddu,' who, as seen in two different videos, engages in clearly Sufi practices like having people spit in his hands and then wiping it on his face as a blessing. This shows you are either knowingly or unknowingly supporting deviance. Don't assume I didn't hear the whole argument. I did, and it's appalling. I love Brother Hijab more than you. Disagreeing with him doesn't make us enemies. I'm trying to help him see that his reasoning is flawed. As the hadith says: Anas (May Allah be pleased with him) reported: Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, 'Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or is oppressed.' A man enquired: 'O Messenger of Allah! I help him when he is oppressed, but how can I help him when he is an oppressor?' He (ﷺ) said, 'You can keep him from committing oppression. That will be your help to him.' [Al-Bukhari]. Change your attitude and broaden your perspective. Be scholarly and follow your deen. What will Shaykh Al Fawzan and other of the like say about this if you are saying shoyoukh of Saudi?
There is a massive difference between looking at a woman; and bringing women out for people to look at. Bro is making an argument that there are women everywhere "generalized balwa" without hijab, and we always look at them in shops, streets.. etc. So, this means we bring non-hijabis to the show. I always think: what if one of the ladies in there repented and decided to wear hijab? would you ask her to wait a bit till you finish filming? or will you reshoot the scenes and may be screen for a non hijabi to join the filming? Plus, Sarah Hussein sounds like a muslim. She is the lady doing the MI5 role in "Burning Hands". The name sounds like a muslim. She wasn't wearing hijab! Plus, if you want to make it look real, why didn't your niece (sister in the movie) take her niqab off when she entered ur apartment. This looks so weird bro. Our women don't keep their face covering with their families!!! I liked your movie by the way, although it was a bit flat and sometimes too slow and boring, but I felt bad for you having to bear the sins of people. I feel bad about myself too!
@martinroberts3977 Is using a haram menas and rationalising it using twisted arguments. That was the issue with the people of the Sabbath mentioned in surat Al-A'raf, as interpreters mention.
I pray that Mohammed Hijab sees your comment, ultimately Allah(Subhanahu wa ta'ala) is the Judge and even though many European/British people may benefit from this but from my lesser understanding it seems very risky for Mohammed Hijab & the ones involved. I dont know much but if someone sins please dont try to justify it or saying its not a sin, its like rejecting parts of islam Forgive me if I have wronged in any way. As I seek to clear my record with the Almighty I must clear my record with His creatures first.
Half of the people probably won't understand the maslaha etc etc, but most can now get justifications to play music and to show uncovered women. Argument at 12:36: "If we become pragmatic and we go into this industry and we can't tell a story about muslim people in britain removing 50% of the population, becomes an incomplete story in my opinion" So we can't tell a story by blurring out the women? We necessarily have to show them in full? So if in the future, we were to talk about the issue of prostitution, do we as muslims necessarily have to show nudity in there or inappropriately dressed women to convey the story? If the answer is no, and its that we would not do that (even if we have to talk about the issue), and blur them, why doesn't the same apply for this case. Also, why do we have to find some fatwas from 1-2 scholars to justify what we're doing? If there's one scholar allowing it, there may be 5 condemning it. So when we choose 1 over the other, isn't that just worshiping our own desires? Like, I'm just going to just pick the one who's fatwa aligns with what "I" want to do. Why can't we just try to abide by this hadith? Al-Nu’man ibn Bashir reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The lawful is clear and the unlawful is clear, and between the two of them are doubtful matters about which many people do not know. Thus, he who avoids doubtful matters clears himself in regard to his religion and his honor, and he who falls into doubtful matters will fall into the unlawful as the shepherd who pastures near a sanctuary, all but grazing therein. Verily, every king has a sanctum and the sanctum of Allah is His prohibitions. Verily, in the body is a piece of flesh which, if sound, the entire body is sound, and if corrupt, the entire body is corrupt. Truly, it is the heart.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 52, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1599
What a beautiful answer, ma sha Allah. I knew a sister many years ago, just as an example. She wanted to divorce her husband for of course nafs reasons. So she went to the Ulama'a until she found one (more than 15 Ulama'a told her "no") who said that she could divorce..
Alhamdulillah Allah is As-Samee' , Al-Baseer, Alh-Hakam,Al-'Adl, Al-Lateef, Al-Ghaffar, Al-Ghafoor. And all human will be judged accordingly by Allah and there will no longer be misinterpretation nor generalization for each and every human being is unique only to him/herself. May our good deeds exceed our bad ones by the will of Allah.
This series has benefitted my young children and lots of questions asked. Living in London and being a teacher myself I could relate to this completely and it will help them. They would ask me 3 days before; When the next episode is coming? This is 1 million times better than the content they watch. Even though they have strict guidelines to use social media.
The bad language was dubbed, they listen to it at schools and that’s how roadmen speak!! They know that it’s not right, but they will be exposed to that living in London.
@@yasararif8292just because they are exposed doesn't mean you have to be ok with it and condone things that feed on the wrong even if it's a bit. They'll be exposed to drunks and sex before marriage. By your logic you might as well sit down and have one drink with them without them getting drunk.
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said: "The hearts of the children of Adam are as one between the fingers of the Most Merciful, and He directs them as He wills." (Sahih Muslim, Book 33, Hadith 6418) Brother Hijab went from debating on Speakers Corner to acting. Very sad. May Allah guide us.
The reality is that the sunnah way of doing dawah is way more affective and lead more people to accepting islam than any tv show ever has, just look at the number of shahadah when the da’ee sticks to the sunnah. Why would anyone choose something that is not effective over that which is way more effective?
Muslims need to worry more about the preservation of Muslim life around the world and disunity that has poisoned the ummah which has been so effortlessly taken advantage of by the enemies of Islam. Muslims with their futile concerns like seeing the hair of a woman, holding the hands on the chest whilst praying or pulling the pants above the ankle has given the pathway for enemies to convince the world that Muslim life is dispensable. Disunity is the cancer that Islam suffers from everyone has their own interpretation and wants to make their version true. Qur'an and Sunnah is the only way. Please unite that is the direct order from Allah "hold on to the rope of Allah and let not be divided" we are disobeying Allah..
Here's a challenge: where is TV or entertainment stated to be wrong. And By that same logic aren't you committing a sin by Having a phone? Or laptop? Or any modern device? Go live in the caves if you are truthful.
@TheeSinnerman entertainment isn't wrong But music and looking at women is wrong, as you know. If the entertainment is free of these, then there is nothing wrong with it. As for laptops and phones, mine is free of women and music .. and if it had any, it wasn't by intention, and it is also necessary to have phones and modern devices unlike entertainment. You can't compare the 2. They are different on so many levels
@@onf3257 you absolutely can compare the 2 The only reason women would be Haram is if you sexualize them but Just them existing in TV isn't Haram especially not on Television lol
Women showing their awrah, swearing, using beatboxing to the point it sounds exactly like music etc are haram. End doesn't justify the means in Islam. If you're going to do haram, that's on you but you shouldn't justify it, ever. E.g. many of these Muslims in the comments have watched haram tv shows and movies. Are they now going to say oh yeah it's halal if I pick a fatwa from here and there. No. They know it's haram and won't justify their sins.
Totally agree with Brother Hijab. He clarified it well. Media is a great tool to do Dawah. Now my all questions are answered. May Allah bless him & grant him success in this life & Hereafter.
But doing it with women uncovering hair, etc, is definitely haram. The hadiths he mentioned in other videos don't fit in this situation, obviously. I hope other scholars with more knowledge will clarify this situation, although it's obvious that this tv series is wrong.
@@mirafu3481I didn’t see anything about the series. what else is bad about the movie apart from women’s hair? Not saying its okay just want to know the other elements
@algerino5421 because it shows haram stuff, i didn't watch it, therefore i can't speak about the story. But if you want to know more about the haram stuff: you can see hair, arms, and even the neck until the breast of a woman begins.
It’s so sad to see that when it comes to our own, we find the most minutest things to throw someone under the bus with especially with someone like brother hijab, but when it comes to the non Muslims a lot of Muslims subconsciously worship them. Support and love your fellow Muslims. We’re dehumanised in many parts of the world we have enough enemies we don’t need no more.
İf we don't police ourselves then we are doomed to be policied bu tyrants. This is not throwing someone under the bus. This method of nahyi anil munker is widely observed throughout Islamic history not only by the ulema among themselves, but by the general people's toward even the ulema. This is praised. When someone openly does something that does not comply with the Qur'an, in this example Allahu Teala ruled men to lower their gaze (as to not see women) and women to cover , and not open up or show themselves around like the kâfir, but Muhammed hijab has defied this, and is now using so called fatwa to support what is forbidden. This, leads to takfir. We can't make anyone do anything, but stating facts, that will definitely be done.
Doing haram won't take you out the folds of Islam. But justifying it, that can eventually take you out. If you're going to do haram stuff no matter what, at the very least STOP JUSTIFYING IT. Your salvation is on the line.
Sheikh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said: «وَقَدْ ذَهَبَ كَثِيرٌ مِنْ الْعُلَمَاءِ إلَى أَنَّهُ لَا يَجُوزُ لِلْمَرْأَةِ أَنْ تَنْظُرَ إلَى الْأَجَانِبِ مِنْ الرِّجَالِ بِشَهْوَةِ وَلَا بِغَيْرِ شَهْوَةٍ أَصْلًا» “Many scholars have said that it is not permissible for a woman to look at non-mahram men with desire or without desire at all.” [Majmu’ Fatawa vol 3 page 378]
Sheikh Abdul Aziz Al-Tarifi said: “There is no scholar known throughout the fifteen centuries of Islam who said that mixing in gatherings, education, and work is permissible... I have come across more than a hundred scholars and jurists throughout those centuries who have stated that it is not permissible. In fact, I have seen some of them who have discredited the justice of the one who does it, and even his guardianship of honor.” Al-Hafiz Abu Bakr Muhammad ibn Abdullah al-Amiri - who was one of the scholars of the sixth century - said in his book ( Ahkam al-Nazar) : “The scholars of the nation agreed that whoever believes in these prohibitions and the permissibility of women mixing with foreign men has committed blasphemy and deserves to be killed for his apostasy. But if he believes in its prohibition and does it and acknowledges it and is satisfied with it, then he has committed wickedness, his words are not to be listened to, and his testimony is not to be accepted . ” [The book of mixing between men and women, page 112]
From the Hanafi scholars: Al-Sarakhsi said: “The judge should present women separately and men separately, because people crowd in his council, and the mixing of women with men during a crowd is a source of temptation. This is in a dispute that occurs between women. As for the dispute that occurs between men and women, he finds no alternative but to put them before the men.” [Al-Mabsoot vol 16 page 80] Al-Hamawi Al-Hanafi said: “The preferred opinion is that a wedding is not disliked if it does not include any corruption, as stated in Al-Fath. I said: It is forbidden in our time, in addition to being disliked for matters that are not hidden from you, including the mixing of women with men.” [Ghamaz ‘Uyoon Al-Basair fi Sharh] Ibn Abidin explained the rejection of the testimony of someone who went out to watch the arrival of a prince, saying: “Because of the reprehensible things it contains, and the mixing of men and women . ” [Al-Ashbah wa Al-Naza’ir vol 2 page 114] Al-Khadami said in the sixtieth plague of the plagues of the tongue: “Permission and approval in what is a sin, such as the husband’s permission for his wife to leave his house to places other than those designated as permissible - then he counted them as seven - and said: “And in what is other than that - from visiting strangers and visiting them and the feast - he does not give her permission, and she does not go out, and if he gives permission and she goes out, they are “Disobedient” [Bariqat Mahmudiyya fi Sharh Tariqah Muhammadiyah wa Shari’ah Nabawiyah by Al-Khademi vol 4 page 10-11]
From the Maliki scholars: Qadi Iyad - may God have mercy on him - said: “He ordered us to keep a distance between the breaths of men and women, and it was his custom - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - to keep them apart so that his nation would follow his example.” [ Sharh Sahih Muslim by Al-Nawawi vol 14 page 166] . The Maliki imams, such as Ibn Farhun, Ibn Zayd al-Barnasi, and Ahmad al-Qarafi, have stated that there is no disagreement in the school of thought regarding the non-acceptance of the testimony of those who attend weddings in which men and women mix, because their presence in these places invalidates their justice . [Shu’ab al-Iman vol 7 page 411-412] Al-Nafrawi said in his explanation (Al-Fawakih Al-Dawani on the Epistle of Ibn Abi Zayd Al-Qayrawani) : “ (And no clear evil) meaning something well-known and apparent, such as the mixing of men with women” [al-Risalah with al-Nafrawi’s commentary vol 2 page 322] Abu Muhammad Al-Andalusi Al-Qahtani Al-Maliki said: Men who look at women are like wild beasts roaming around the meat. If the lions of that meat do not protect it, it will be eaten without compensation or price .
From the Shafi’i scholars: Imam Al-Bayhaqi said: This includes a man protecting his wife and daughter from mixing with men, talking to them, and being alone with them . ” Imam Al-Mawardi - may God have mercy on him - said, defining the cuckold: “He is the one who brings men together with women, it was called that because it is spread among them.” [Adab al-Dunya wa al-Din (p. 268] Abu Ishaq al-Shirazi said: “ Friday prayer is not obligatory for a woman, because Jabir narrated that the Messenger of God, may God bless him and his family and grant them peace, said: ‘Whoever believes in God and the Last Day, Friday prayer is obligatory for him, except for a woman, a traveler, a slave, or a sick person." It was narrated by Al-Daraqutni and declared weak by Al-Albani. Abu Ishaq al-Shirazi commented on the hadith to say: "And because she mixes with a man, and that is not permissible.” [Irwa’ Al-Ghaleel fi Takhreej Ahadith Minar Al-Sabil vol 3page 56] Ibn Hajar al-Haytami said after quoting al-Shirazi’s words: “Contemplate it and you will find it explicit in the prohibition of mixing; and it is so because it is a source of temptation . ” [Al-Muhadhdhab with Al-Majmu’ vol 4 page 350] Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani narrated in his explanation of Al-Bukhari’s hadith on the authority of Abdullah Ibn Abi Qatada Al-Ansari on the authority of his father, who said: The Messenger of God - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - said: “I stand up for prayer and I intend to “That I prolong it, and then I hear the crying of the child, so I shorten my prayer, for fear of causing hardship to his mother.” He quoted the words of Ibn Daqeeq al-‘Eid: “This hadith is general in its meaning for women, except that the jurists specified certain conditions for it, including that she should not use perfume, and perfume includes anything similar in meaning, because the reason for prohibiting it is that it arouses desire, such as good clothing.” And the jewelry that appears, and the luxurious adornment, and also mixing with men." [Fath Al-Bari by Ibn Hajar vol 2 page 349] Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar said in his explanation of Sahih Al-Bukhari in (Chapter on men carrying the funeral procession and not women) : “...and there has been reported something that is more explicit than this in prohibiting them, but it is not according to the conditions of the author, and perhaps he referred to it, which is what Abu Ya’la narrated from the hadith of Anas, who said: “We went out with the Messenger of God - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - in a funeral, and he saw women , so he said: ‘Will you carry him? ’ They said: ‘No. ’ He said: ‘Will you bury him? ’” They said, “ No.” He said, “Then go back, sinners, but not rewarded . ” Al-Nawawi reported in (Sharh al-Muhadhdhab) that there is no disagreement on this issue among the scholars, and the reason for it is what was mentioned above, and because the funeral must be accompanied by men, so if women carried it, that would be a pretext for them to mix with men, which would lead to temptation [Fath Al-Bari vol 3page 182] Al-Bajrimy said: “People gathering after the afternoon prayer to supplicate, as the people of Arafah do. Imam Ahmad said: There is nothing wrong with it. Imam Malik disliked it... and Sheikh Al-Tawkhi said that it is forbidden because it involves mixing of women with men, as is seen now.” [Al-Bajuri on Al-Khatib vol 2 page 226]
From the Hanbali scholars: Sheikh Al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah - may God have mercy on him - said: “It was the Sunnah of the Prophet - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - and the Sunnah of his successors to distinguish between men and women... because the mixing of one of the two types with the other is a cause of temptation. So when men mix with women, it is like the mixing of fire and wood . ” Imam Ibn al-Qayyim - may God have mercy on him - said: “The one in authority must prevent men from mixing with women in the markets, public places, and places where men gather... He must prevent women from going out adorned and beautified, and prevent them from wearing clothes that would make them appear naked, such as loose and thin clothes, and prevent them from talking to men in the streets, and prevent men from doing that. If the guardian sees fit to spoil the woman’s clothes by using ink or something similar when she beautifies herself and goes out, some jurists have permitted this and were correct. This is one of the least financial punishments for them. He has the right to detain a woman if she goes out of her house frequently, especially if she goes out adorned. Rather, women’s admission of this is helping them in sin and disobedience, and God will ask the guardian of the matter about that. The Commander of the Faithful, Omar ibn al-Khattab - may God be pleased with him - forbade women from walking in the path of men and mixing with them on the road. The ruler must follow his example in that. There is no doubt that allowing women to mix with men is the root of all calamity and evil, and it is one of the greatest causes of the general punishments, just as it is one of the causes of the corruption of public and private affairs. The mixing of men and women is a cause of the spread of indecencies and adultery, and it is one of the causes of general death and continuous plagues. One of the greatest causes of general death is the spread of adultery, due to women being allowed to mix with each other. [Al-Istiqaama vol 1 page360] Ibn al-Jawzi said: “As for what the storytellers have introduced of gathering women and men, it is one of the innovations in which strange things happen, such as women mixing with men, and women raising their voices in screaming and wailing, and other things . ” [Uncovering the Problematic Hadith of the Two Sahihs vol 1 page 776] Ibn Rajab said: “The only thing that is prescribed is for women to be separate from men as a whole, because there is a fear that their mixing with men will lead to corruption . ” [Fath al-Bari in Explanation of al-Jami’ al-Sahih al-Bukhari vol 2 page 134]
This is one of the most interesting Series I have watch as a non Muslim. Its interesting to see the world thought someone who is Muslim. It can be Haram as most Muslims say but It was education for me
The question is can one deliver the message without ambiguity or using ijtihad opinions? Can this not be done with less evil?? The reason here is that opening the doors for masla7a reasons can lead to transgression of the boundaries of Allah. Political opinions are greater in masla7a because the potential mafsada is greater so I don’t think that’s comparable.
I know of many families, that watch all sorts of movies with their childern. Disney movies which incorporate elements of moral, sexual ambiguity, Godlessness and ect. For older kids, superhero movies that feature costumes and themes of sexualized nature. In contrast, this show offers a more realistic portrayal, addressing relevant and meaningful issues currently faced in the real world, and provides a straightforward and wholesome viewing experience for all ages.
I know of people who do not watch those sinful things you have mentioned, and they do not watch what is less than that in badness, rather they watch lectures and durus.
I haven't watched the series but it is always encouraging to see muslims broadening their scope and trying new things, Islam is to be shared and entertainment is one of the largest AND most accessible industries, any modest muslim can engage in creative endeavors for a relatively low price, and stories communicate messages so effectively, I wish more and more productions like this are made.
Yep amazing what the weapons of mass destruction can do ... mind programing ..downloading bullocks into your heads . Save the children and show out Disney bbc film industry music industry ..this man is an agent of sorts. He is the wolf in sheep clothing..
Brother Mohamed Hijab , however iam actually not watching this series as it may consider a something that's considered haram but I get your point here that as you're in the UK it's lesser damage to do this or that in the series and by giving examples you mentioned it's quiet abit clearer point so if that is your intention then may Allah reward you for this Also I haven't watch the series but I get the general idea of difficulty in living in western society as a Muslim..
Almost every major Ulema has spoken out about Gaza in their Khutbas and speeches. You actually don't care if they speak out or not about Gaza. You care if they speak against the rulers.
السلام عليكم ورحمةالله وبركاته I understand where Brother Hijab is coming from. But I think it's different when you are the one recording or making the series. There is an individual who is using the UA-cam platform to promote and spread the message of Islam. Okay, you may say that he should make his website and divert his audience that way, but with the tools and traffic that UA-cam has, his website will never get to that stage. He has no option but to use that platform, and then when he has the following he desires or requires to make his own website, he should. I think there is a subtle difference between doing something yourself and setting its standards vs. having no other option but to use what is at your disposal. I remember once discussing respecting the Qur'an. I know this is a very indo-pak thing, but my brother and I were discussing this, and I highlighted what my teacher said, "Respect is an act from the heart; if someone sits on a seat, does that mean he is disrespecting the Qur'an? If that is the case, that means the one who is walking is disrespecting the Qur'an'." My brother then raised a valid and interesting point. He said, "There is a difference between both incidents/situations. The one who is sitting on the seat has sat utilising his option and freedom to sit there. On the other hand, the one who is walking can't do anything to lower his buttocks than the one seated. " Lastly, the criteria's set by Islam are there to further stop and prevent all types of sin/مفاسد/ذنوب. Maintaining a strong belief in the traditional understandings of Islam will prevent you from crossing limits and, furthermore, desensitisation. I mean, if you steal once you will likely steal again, if you know what I mean.🤷 اللهم اهدنا، واهد بنا واجعلنا سببا لمن اهتدى.
It was a good series but i wouldnt say its Allowed and please dont promote that your allowed in Islam to do such acts... Islam is spread through Sunnah and media isnt Sunnah
Please comment on the recent behaviour of the apparent Muslim, Androo Tate. Is someone advising this person? Is he being taught about Islam? He urgently needs to learn to stop running his mouth and stop putting fellow muslims, sisters, in harms way.
I washed my hands from following andrew tate, he has cognitive dissonance… one time he says he supports islam and Muslims and then some time he is saying weird stuff like what he said three days ago
By this logic we should all embrace bidah, the Shia and Sufis scholars have much more knowledge than a layman don't they? Take your knowledge from trustable Sunni ulema not celebrity Dawah guys This is clearly bidah and haram
My ears are burning from the arguments presented by the brother. Shocking that someone who is seen by some as a person of knowledge (Islamic knowledge) is speaking in this manner. Can only make dua for his guidance & my advice to Sapience is to have him stick to worldly subjects or maybe areas of his specialisation such as world history etc, because having him teach Islaam is going to adversely impact your credibility especially in the eyes of serious students of Islaam
@@AhmedRaza-lh4oj I don’t know all of them, but I have listened to brother Hamza Tzortsis and he at least stays within his area of expertise I believe. May Allaah Azza Wa Jall guide them and us
I've been following Hijab for many years at it's very disappointing to see him looking this uncomfortable, battling his fitrah for a tv series...the sin is not worth it. You do an excellent job in the dawah field, stick to it brother!
My brother Mohammed Hijab, I have followed you for a long time and Wallahi I want good for you. Here is an analogy and my honest interpretation on your comments about showing uncovered women on youtube, just because they're going to be there anyways whether you include them in your series or not. You live on a remote island, there is no food or water whatsoever except for within one bar/ pub that exists on the island. Within this bar they serve alcohol, as well as other non alcoholic drinks and food. Essentially what you are saying is because this is the only place where you can find something to eat or drink, it is also permissible for you to go in there and drink alcohol as you please. Where is the sense in this my brother? Of course, you would enter the bar to find food and water for yourself but this is not an excuse to commit haraam. You have always been extremely analytical and reasonable and idk how you aren't able to see this. Just because there are women all over youtube, why does that permit you to hold hands with the kuffs and follow them in their transgressions by including them in YOUR OWN videos? For what purpose are you doing this? We don't need to stoop to these filthy lows for the sake of Dawah, because Dawah is something sacred and it is upon us to uphold the rights of the Prophet SAW by following him in his methodology of giving Dawah. At the same time, it is only upon us to convey the message and guidance of the heart is by the will of Allah only. Tell me my brother, if we have to sit here and have countless discussions to even decide whether this series is permissible or haraam, then what kind of dawah is this? Why tread a blurred line when there is no need? I love you for the sake of Allah and I pray that you are upon correct guidance.
Ask yourself this, did the prophet ASW go to such extremes? Did he risk his own akhira by doing such acts? Allah says that he is nothing more than a guide and so are we. There is no need to go to such lengths as Allah is the one who guides the hearts. Accept your mistake and be humble
In my opinion he is 99% CORRECT, this show is advantageous in that it reflects a good picture about muslims for the non-muslim viewers. However, it has NO BENEFIT for a MUSLIM viewer bcz its objective is not targeted towards muslim audience. So i WOULD NOT RECOMMEND MUSLIMS TO WATCH it but encourage non muslims to do so!
Masha Allah the authenticity. You strike a balance between respect for others and even those that criticise you and being true to yourself and Allah. May Allah continue to guide you and open the doors of his mercy to you. May he protect you and your family from harm and evil. Ameen
Vage reasoning for showing women without hijab and looking at them while Quran clearly order for man to lower gaze and women to cover, its period. You do your best doesn't matter who did what in past what not
Why are there people degrading the fatawa brother hijab has used from various scholars? They are talking about it like these scholars are just random people commenting on videos declaring their fatwa… These scholars aint like this, they aint you or me
Not everybody is a scholar, He could be from a deviant sect. Like the one MH mentioned. He is a Sufi who rejects clear attributes of Allah in the Quran.
@kaz4845 why are you getting all pumped up about? He just said he would love to see two knowledgeable people talk on that topic, and btw if you have any questions about Muhammad ali Go and ask on his channel
@@kaz4845 Mohamed Ali is doing dawah to all people in the street(men,woman)and if a woman came to him to ask about the Qur'an he wouldn't say no to her because this is free mixing because she is a kaffera so it's more important that she comes to islam and for the sake of argument if he did not talk to woman this would completely affect his dawah, and when he uploads video with woman taking to him, he completely bluers her and every woman waking in the background of the video as well. How on earth you're comparing that with Mohamed Hijab making a series and uploading it to hundreds of thousands of people around the world with uncovered (mutaberjat)woman innit without a legitimate reason?!!
@@YoussefAssemZahran2005 they are both talking directly to non mahram women with their awra exposed.. The action is exactly the same.. Your giving me reasons that are different. Is the act haram by itself? Or only haram based on the reason?
12:54 - Not sure this makes sense, as the contention is showing the faces, body, hair etc of women visually. The Quran is written text. Can the two be compared as such?
@user-op8fg3ny3j Wouldn't that necessitate cross dressing? Also, I don't have any real knowledge regarding these rulings/this topic. I'm only pointing out a particular comparison he made which doesn't make sense to me
@@OmarAliYT. there are lots of transgender actors you can hire and according to the scholars they are still considered men so it won't be classed as free mixing or zina if you look at them
It makes sense. We're not comparing the media form here. We're comparing the story telling technique. Because the Qur'an tells stories, Hijab is trying to tell a story as well. The Qur'an tells story how it is, thats the point. Even the Qur'an mentions how a woman seduced Prophet Yusuf AS, and even stated what she said to seduce him. Qur'an does not shy away from that. If you have shahwa, then it is upon you to look away. If you see a beautiful woman out there with hijab etc covering her awrah yet you feel shahwa just from looking at her eyes, then is it upon the woman to walk away from you? no, you are the one that needs to walk away. The most effective media for telling stories these days is in Video form. A lot of people don't read books anymore, they enjoy watching videos more. How else are you gonna tell a story in visual form yet completely remove important actors / parts of the story, it just doesn't make any sense.
No matter who makes fatwa , Allah says , if you disagree go back to Quran and sunnah !! … He did not say follow fatwa of Ibn Baz or Ibn Uthymeen RahimahumAllah … The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The lawful is clear and the unlawful is clear, and between the two of them are doubtful matters about which many people do not know. Thus, he who avoids doubtful matters clears himself in regard to his religion and his honor, and he who falls into doubtful matters will fall into the unlawful as the shepherd who pastures near a sanctuary, all but grazing therein. Verily, every king has a sanctum and the sanctum of Allah is His prohibitions. Verily, in the body is a piece of flesh which, if sound, the entire body is sound, and if corrupt, the entire body is corrupt. Truly, it is the heart.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 52, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1599
Honestly, as someone living in the west, this seems like a PAINFULLY obvious point, to me. Are there any people that watch his series, that would otherwise not watch something that would be clearly in conflict with Islam on a deep level? We NEED to be involved in these kinds of arts and entertainment; the alternative is just that we will end up consuming the arts and entertainment of the non-Muslims that are many degrees of magnitude worse. Worse in terms of the message and what is being shows itself too. And that is presuming that all of these things are haram, in this context, in the first place! As Hijab alludes to, if people took these things they are criticizing his series for and applied them consistently, they would have to poke their eyes, ears, nose, etc. You would be paralysed by every little thing. You would not be able to go on the internet because of the vast degree of haram that are there and you will inevitably stumble across. You would not be able to go outside because of all the haram that is unavoidable. You would not be able to work because of all the haram that cannot be avoided. You could not exist at all! It's exactly as the prophet SAW told us that: “Verily, the religion is easy and no one burdens himself in religion but that it overwhelms him. Follow the right course, seek closeness to Allah, give glad tidings, and seek help for worship in the morning and evening and a part of the night.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 39 May Allah reward Hijab, and make this the start of a revolution and revival of Islamic thought and media at all levels.
A simple counter logic is, why take risk in a critical matter like this?? and was creating this TV series necessary?? what if you didn't make it and continued your dawah?? and what if you invested this much effort in your dawah videos in some way? There are immense problems with this series effects of which could have been easily avoided.
Clearly, you didn't understand anything, or you already made up your mind before listening to this. Simple question to engage your mind. Do you understand the concept of maslaha?
The way I understood it, there is a huge missing gap in the mainstream media space. The majority of young muslims are watching TV Shows and Movies which include extremely haram elements e.g. romance, nude/inappropriately clothed women, western morals etc. There is a need to replace the medie diet of these young Muslims with alternatives that are engaging and promote Islamic morals. This content will empower them as Muslims whilst also promoting Islam to the wider non-muslim society. This is the benefits vs harm analysis that Mohamed Hijab's team have done. You can disagree but at least understand how they came to their conclusion.
In an age where entertainment is a widely accepted and influential medium for conveying information, it is essential for Muslims to utilize this tool to spread their message effectively. By engaging with popular culture and media, we can share our values, teachings, and perspectives with a broader audience. This approach not only allows us to reach more people but also helps in fostering understanding and respect for our beliefs in diverse communities.
@@riyaansheikh7470 Rasulullah Sallallahu Alaihi ve's-Sallam, the Prophet who gave this Ummah the message of Allah including how to live until Qiyama , was a living walking example... Have you forgotten ? Emri bil maruf, nehyi anil munker was one of the amal he performed most, not one narration can show Him 'acting', even though there was acting in His time. İn the letter sent to Hercules, there is a clear line between Islam and Kufr. That line never fades, who ever crosses, crosses alone.
"In an age where interest based banking is widespread, it is upon muslims to use this tool to make as much money as possible and serve the Ummah." Does this apply? NO. Looking at womens awrah is completely forbidden. Whatever he is quoting is when you happen to see a woman. This is not the case in a TV series. You are actively searching for it and the woman is being presented to you. The ends dont justify the means.
When it came to criticizing a scholar like Al-Albani, you spoke as if you were a scholar yourself, making accusations with this Ali Dawah by rudeness and arrogance. But now, you claim you are not a scholar when you realize there is no escape or refuge for you from the issue of music. I used to be proud of you that came from the same ancient city in Egypt, my city Alexandria, but now I feel ashamed of you and your actions.
At 18 mins The Maslaha is based on the fact there are dharurat, such as transport, accommodation, food security and I forgot one more. Car insurance isn't an arbitrary issue it actually hinges itself on the fact that in the sharia a private mode of transport is a birth right of a Muslim. This is also why some who follow abu hanifah and even Yusuf Qardhawi said its ok to take an interest-bearing mortgage with the caveat it cant be a buy-to-let, and it must be owner-occupied.
The mortgage issue is completely twisting what Abu Hanifa said. They meant if the person has no home. The vast majority of people in the developed west rent for their entire lives.
@@ks-pk7of that’s wrong but I understand your view point. The case is made that if owning a home is a birth right in sharia can you then make an exception under dire circumstances. For instance there are no alternatives as you are too poor to pay cash, you can’t live anywhere else etc. the concept of renting a home even within the uk is seen as a precarious housing arrangement. That’s because the home I’m which you rent can be sold or you can be evicted, the sharia wants to protect you from that. The issue is mainly we now live in a modern nation state capitalism where prices of houses are inflated as they are bought with leveraged debt.
@@Mayor_Imad I want to answer that question but I feel I would do it an injustice so I will ask you to ask someone qualified. Maybe even a cursory google search may give you a heads or tails if it.
Brother muhamed hijab is not a person of Islamic knowledge and he is definitely not fit to give fatwa people should fear allah and look at who they are taking knowledge He is well spoken and as a person i like him so I am not against my brother in anyway
For all those who are pushing the unity agenda and asking to let this slide, There is no tolerance for haram in Islam. Even if Sheikh ibn Taymiyyah (God forbid) or any other was to do such a thing, the response would be the same. There is no unity in disobedience to Allah.
The main poin we should talk about why aren't arab ulama are not speaking about the really genocide happening in our watch I'm not hearing any one saying about their silence
You shouldn't post things like that on Sapience. People come here to gain certainty, not doubt, from the ideas that Mohammed talks about. I wouldn't think badly of Mohammed because of his series, because he's just one actor. But his excuses are worse than anything. I am very disappointed to hear such ideas on this channel.
There is no justification for his movie. Free mixing is Haraam; there is no justification for it. Hijab might say the movie needed for Dawah; Islam is not in need of that Dawah. It seems he’s using Islam in this case to make money; if the movie was without free mixing then one can give it a pass, but there is free-mixing throughout
General Advise In Islam, we take the correct means to achieve a good outcome and objective I can't see a "Dharoorah" a "Necessity" here to go against clear Islamic teachings on allowing faces of non-mahram to be seen by every muslim through these episodes This work done by a person doing dawah will confuse the layman (Muslim) that all the content of this work and the elements in it are correct and according to deen, and it may encourage others to copy The more we strive to do things according to deen even if we don't achieve 100% of the outcome we want, the more opportunities of tawfeeq and barakah we will receive in Shaa Allah I ask Allaah the Almighty to grant us all the knowledge, the guidance and the ability to do good in line with the means that He made permissable
Should’ve just said something like I was giving the reality of our area so it included women as well. You had hajabi and non Muslim women in it as well. Everyday we see this in the UK and Western worlds all over
Bin Baz's fatwa was not based on maslaha. Seeking help from non-muslims is found in the text, Prophet alejhisalam took help of ibn Abdijj to enter Makkah. Uthaymen's fatwa for voting is based on lesser of two evils, and early scholars such as Izz Abdussalam have stated this principle of usool fiqh years before ibn Uthaymen. Lastly, if you believe maslaha to be allowed, it needs to be factually demonstrated that the series is bringing more good, than harm.
So he takes from Shanquiti who is a student of Qaradawi who had some very controversial fatwas. He also went off topic on making movies by making excuses. He starting to turn into Yasir Qadhi. And lying saying scholars are silent in Arabia about Gaza when they are making dua for them. Only intelligent people can see through what he is saying.
@@noticing33 and who isn't? A lot of sheep believe in news that Saudi supports Zionist. Most of you probably listen to DH. Did you see him appeasing to the far-right?
Just because you dislike certain scholar doesn't mean their fatwa, opinion etc. have no merit or qualifications. I'm talking about Qardawi that have many of his scholarly work being benefited by many Muslim and ulama. If they (including Qardawi) have stirr controversial in your perspective, that doesn't mean their scholarly work and authority automatically disqualified
May Allah Guide us and him, never Humiliate us and him and Protect us and him from self amazement. Alhamdulillah the truth is clear as the falsehood is clear. Only a people who never wanted guidance will now follow him. Any parents reading this… keep your children well clear of him. Allahu AlMustaan
Forget everything, guys seriously in the west how do you live? i went to turkey as a holiday this year, and just so you know, According to the Turkish government, 99 percent of the population is Muslim, which, according to the government, includes Alevis, i was just so shsocked how do the muslims live, in the shopping malls, everyone was almost naked, i was so so shocked, the underground metro and trains were literly full everyone was literly stuck to everyone in specific times of the day, and indeed it was mixed, i cannot imagine living there for months how could you live somewhere worse than that? the sitiuation has gone so bad... it was a nightmere... everyoner should get way more carefull than they were...
@TheSyporg Muslims will either be represented or represent themselves in the media. It's quite simple, really. Think how many minds have been subconsciously shaped through movies and series.
Do you have any teenage aged children? I work with a ton of Muslim youth and we are deluding ourselves if we think they are not watching mainstream movies and TV shows. No matter how much we try to control it, they will be exposed to mainstream media and the poison of it. On the other hand, if our youth have access to content like our brothers TV series, they’ll enjoy it just as they enjoy mainstream media, while also getting some powerful lessons out of it. I’ve talked to several youth already who were inspired and shaken by some of the scenes in the Burning Hands series. If you do not watch shows or waste your time on these things. Alhamdulillah that’s the best way to be. But the fact is, the majority of our people are distracted by mainstream media. We can either try and restrict our children from it completely. Which hardly works. Or, we can make an effort to control the content and provide them with better alternatives. On a final note. We can argue that the Sahaba used the media of the time to spread good. What was the media of the their time? Poetry. The enemies used poetry to spread lies and corruption. The Sahaba, such as Hassan ibn Tabbit (RA) were encouraged by the Prophet SA to respond with their own good poetry. Allah knows best what the right answer is. May Allah show us the way
i just have one thing to say the ones who criticise hijab and think they knoew more than him with not good qualification are the same people who would ask scholars why are they silent about gaza and say why dont you protest aginst your ruler of saudi arabia these people whoo tend to know everything go and see what hadith authentic says that do not protest against muslim rulers even if they are corrupt ,these guys will follow one part and rejct others they ask why scholars silent about genocide i want to ask what have you guys done by shouting ,most of them atleast in here in my country chant protest and then go to buy product from zionist nbrands atleast if you have real concern go and first boycott these brands and many scholars have done that go see they are abiding by the sunnah ,if you are capable of fighting then go and do jihad by hand but if you cannot do it with your actions
Muhammad hijab has definitely worked hard to make this movie according to islamic norms, we all are humans if there is something unislamic then he should be forgiven and he should have made more movies like that
No joke some dude was telling me about how nuts it is that this guys has made a series ect.. he was like wth heck women ect wll that.. anyways after long convo he mentions "u seen the knew game of thrones" 😂😂😂😂😂🤣💀💀💀. I dont say all in the comments watch neftlix shows or american shows comedy or whatsoever but there's a big number of ppl tht watch tv showd and movies with all the adult scene done today is wild. N ppl speaking out for this. Damn. If you dont watch anything at all. You have a book shelf or tend to your garden or enjoy ur life without tv and shows u already are 1000% living life great. Doesnt take away from those who do but its wild how ppl js are so angry n stuff. Man jus go for a walka
Bro you have no proof from the Quran and sunnah to justify what you did , very poor analogy , just because UA-cam has haram doesn’t mean you can incorporate haram elements , your series is not a life and death situation , you took one shiekh fatwa and did a qias that is invalid . You can not take something that you can not control and therefore you yourself create the haram that you cannot control , hijab you can leave the country if you can’t deal with the fitnah around you , in the Quran Allah says that the angles will ask , wasn’t Allah land specious for you to migrate ??? Hijab I feel sorry for the route your taking , may Allah guide you
Yes, the level of hypocracy & sophistry. The Ayatollah won't ever sit down for a talk with an uncovered woman no matter if she is a Muslim or not, so this is just a fake excuse. Also, Hijab & Dawah recently said that Islam allows women to drive, go to universities, vote and have their own bank accounts - to us Christians this is pure feminism!
Remember brother that just yesterday you made takfir on Humza Yousaf not giving him an excuse of maslaha or even a thought but you are stretching this very concept when it comes to your series. There are many points you mention I would like to discuss with you, if you have some way to reach you we can discuss them on whatsapp.
Hijab audience are those who love media… he will bring those love media to Islam and to the mosque, for those who are already going to the mosque u dont have to watch if your not comfortable. Let’s support Bro Hijab in getting brother and sister from the media to the mosque and those who are in the mosque will help to get those sister and brother to solat again. It is realistic way to get people who love entertainment to love Islam.
Right and wrongs are clear.
If you are wrong, you must accept it.
Even the children know that it's wrong.
We have now reached the era of ridiculousness, in which womens obligatory haya is compared to car insurance... No way is this justifiable!
Yes, This should be cancelled.
@@jahseedelves4190
Why cancelled,discussing the issues are more civilized.
That’s the same problem he has on the *God Logic* podcasts.
What kind of reasoning is this?!! No way it is halal to show women not wearing decent clothes.Islam is innocent from these words
Your camel agrees.
That was like a reading a research paper. The arguments were coherent backed up with references and examples, and counter-examples.
Finished off with a logical conclusions.
Impressive Allahuma barik, may Allah increase you in knowledge and wisdom
What are you smoking? Hijab hasn't provided references for anything and has built his stance on incorrect premises. This is deviance, and any Muslim knows this. There is no nuanced view on this in our religion. The arguments presented are weak, the comparisons are non-analogous, and the ijtihad cited comes from weak 'scholars.' Does this mean I can also produce content with women and music and claim I'm disobeying Allah SWT for the greater good of the Ummah? This is nonsense.
@@m_shakeshe said it is like a research paper and quite frankly, hijab isn't going to be providing references, why can't you look them up yourself? you just ignored every single argument of maslaha then jumped to a conclusion of it being, doing even worse yourself what you accuse hijab of doing - not even demonstrating why he's wrong let alone bring evidence. The deen does not work on your feelings and is way more nuanced to fit the needs of each muslim, we've seen it from the time of the sahaba to ibn Taymiyyah and more recently the saudi shuyookh who have no problem being pragmatic with political issues involving AQEEDAH implications let alone normal stuff like Acapella and non muslim women display upon which there is already ikhtilaf. You can stay ignorant, atleast don't attack other muslims with intentions for the overall betterment of the ummah. There is room for nuance, intellect and flexibility in our deen do not turn it into irrational strict Christianity in the 14th century which eventually lead to Protestantism and schism of their religion, destroying the community because they were stuck with dogmatic beliefs.
@@m_shakes It is insane to me that people are justifying doing this.
@@AMDesignAndDevits funny how all the comments are "its wrong to me, in my opinion" yet no one refutes any of the evidence he brought up, such as the fatawah of bin baz or evidence of issues on maslaha. SubhanAllah.
@@elyonxx I think you need to pipe down. You are being emotional. Your justification is non-analogous. Are you trying to say that abiding by the teachings of Islam will lead to an irrationally strict 14th-century Christianity? This implies you view Islamic teachings as overly strict and in need of leeway, suggesting you have a problem with them.
The Prophet (pbuh) himself did not resort to using women and music to attract people, even when non-believers used these methods. He could have, but this is not the will of Allah SWT. The message is clear: the Truth stands on its own. Why would we need to use prohibited means to spread it?
Ask yourself, what is the aim here? To gain more Muslim followers through fringe prohibited means? Who has placed this burden on Brother Hijab? He is overburdening himself with things he is not obligated to do. His obligation is to follow the commands of Allah (SWT).
You mentioned 'the sahaba to Ibn Taymiyyah and more recently the Saudi shuyookh.' I challenge you to find one person among them who would endorse a 'drama series' featuring music, uncovered girls, and intermingling. Brother Hijab is aligning with fringe ideas from individuals like 'Al Daddu,' who, as seen in two different videos, engages in clearly Sufi practices like having people spit in his hands and then wiping it on his face as a blessing. This shows you are either knowingly or unknowingly supporting deviance.
Don't assume I didn't hear the whole argument. I did, and it's appalling.
I love Brother Hijab more than you. Disagreeing with him doesn't make us enemies. I'm trying to help him see that his reasoning is flawed. As the hadith says:
Anas (May Allah be pleased with him) reported:
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, 'Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or is oppressed.' A man enquired: 'O Messenger of Allah! I help him when he is oppressed, but how can I help him when he is an oppressor?' He (ﷺ) said, 'You can keep him from committing oppression. That will be your help to him.'
[Al-Bukhari].
Change your attitude and broaden your perspective. Be scholarly and follow your deen. What will Shaykh Al Fawzan and other of the like say about this if you are saying shoyoukh of Saudi?
There is a massive difference between looking at a woman; and bringing women out for people to look at.
Bro is making an argument that there are women everywhere "generalized balwa" without hijab, and we always look at them in shops, streets.. etc. So, this means we bring non-hijabis to the show.
I always think: what if one of the ladies in there repented and decided to wear hijab? would you ask her to wait a bit till you finish filming? or will you reshoot the scenes and may be screen for a non hijabi to join the filming?
Plus, Sarah Hussein sounds like a muslim. She is the lady doing the MI5 role in "Burning Hands". The name sounds like a muslim. She wasn't wearing hijab!
Plus, if you want to make it look real, why didn't your niece (sister in the movie) take her niqab off when she entered ur apartment. This looks so weird bro. Our women don't keep their face covering with their families!!!
I liked your movie by the way, although it was a bit flat and sometimes too slow and boring, but I felt bad for you having to bear the sins of people. I feel bad about myself too!
I don't get the big deal? but I still don't get the show?
@martinroberts3977 Is using a haram menas and rationalising it using twisted arguments. That was the issue with the people of the Sabbath mentioned in surat Al-A'raf, as interpreters mention.
I pray that Mohammed Hijab sees your comment, ultimately Allah(Subhanahu wa ta'ala) is the Judge and even though many European/British people may benefit from this but from my lesser understanding it seems very risky for Mohammed Hijab & the ones involved.
I dont know much but if someone sins please dont try to justify it or saying its not a sin, its like rejecting parts of islam
Forgive me if I have wronged in any way. As I seek to clear my record with the Almighty I must clear my record with His creatures first.
Soooo much music too
Would you say the same of dawah videos where non muslim woman are featured? Are those people not doing the same?
Half of the people probably won't understand the maslaha etc etc, but most can now get justifications to play music and to show uncovered women.
Argument at 12:36: "If we become pragmatic and we go into this industry and we can't tell a story about muslim people in britain removing 50% of the population, becomes an incomplete story in my opinion"
So we can't tell a story by blurring out the women? We necessarily have to show them in full?
So if in the future, we were to talk about the issue of prostitution, do we as muslims necessarily have to show nudity in there or inappropriately dressed women to convey the story?
If the answer is no, and its that we would not do that (even if we have to talk about the issue), and blur them, why doesn't the same apply for this case.
Also, why do we have to find some fatwas from 1-2 scholars to justify what we're doing? If there's one scholar allowing it, there may be 5 condemning it.
So when we choose 1 over the other, isn't that just worshiping our own desires? Like, I'm just going to just pick the one who's fatwa aligns with what "I" want to do.
Why can't we just try to abide by this hadith?
Al-Nu’man ibn Bashir reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The lawful is clear and the unlawful is clear, and between the two of them are doubtful matters about which many people do not know. Thus, he who avoids doubtful matters clears himself in regard to his religion and his honor, and he who falls into doubtful matters will fall into the unlawful as the shepherd who pastures near a sanctuary, all but grazing therein. Verily, every king has a sanctum and the sanctum of Allah is His prohibitions. Verily, in the body is a piece of flesh which, if sound, the entire body is sound, and if corrupt, the entire body is corrupt. Truly, it is the heart.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 52, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1599
Agree with this point for sure
Exactly! This is wrong. Period.
What a beautiful answer, ma sha Allah. I knew a sister many years ago, just as an example. She wanted to divorce her husband for of course nafs reasons. So she went to the Ulama'a until she found one (more than 15 Ulama'a told her "no") who said that she could divorce..
@@MrSaimoooo Very relevant example.
Alhamdulillah Allah is As-Samee' , Al-Baseer, Alh-Hakam,Al-'Adl, Al-Lateef, Al-Ghaffar, Al-Ghafoor. And all human will be judged accordingly by Allah and there will no longer be misinterpretation nor generalization for each and every human being is unique only to him/herself. May our good deeds exceed our bad ones by the will of Allah.
This series has benefitted my young children and lots of questions asked. Living in London and being a teacher myself I could relate to this completely and it will help them.
They would ask me 3 days before; When the next episode is coming?
This is 1 million times better than the content they watch. Even though they have strict guidelines to use social media.
You are fine with them watching something that has inappropriate language?
The bad language was dubbed, they listen to it at schools and that’s how roadmen speak!!
They know that it’s not right, but they will be exposed to that living in London.
@@yasararif8292 dubbed? will be what? i didnt get your comment sorry.
@@yasararif8292just because they are exposed doesn't mean you have to be ok with it and condone things that feed on the wrong even if it's a bit. They'll be exposed to drunks and sex before marriage. By your logic you might as well sit down and have one drink with them without them getting drunk.
Series literally didn’t teach anything except ignorant UK people hating their neighbour. Zero dawah
The end does not justify the means
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said:
"The hearts of the children of Adam are as one between the fingers of the Most Merciful, and He directs them as He wills."
(Sahih Muslim, Book 33, Hadith 6418)
Brother Hijab went from debating on Speakers Corner to acting. Very sad. May Allah guide us.
The reality is that the sunnah way of doing dawah is way more affective and lead more people to accepting islam than any tv show ever has, just look at the number of shahadah when the da’ee sticks to the sunnah. Why would anyone choose something that is not effective over that which is way more effective?
Exactly, the prophet ASW did not go to such extremes nor instructed us to risk our own akhira like this
👏👏👏👏👏👏
Dawah should be done according to the sunnah. You aren’t wiser than Allah swt and His Messenger saw
Muslims need to worry more about the preservation of Muslim life around the world and disunity that has poisoned the ummah which has been so effortlessly taken advantage of by the enemies of Islam. Muslims with their futile concerns like seeing the hair of a woman, holding the hands on the chest whilst praying or pulling the pants above the ankle has given the pathway for enemies to convince the world that Muslim life is dispensable. Disunity is the cancer that Islam suffers from everyone has their own interpretation and wants to make their version true. Qur'an and Sunnah is the only way. Please unite that is the direct order from Allah "hold on to the rope of Allah and let not be divided" we are disobeying Allah..
Bro was asked a simple question, made a a brilliant research paper exam as an answer
@@jona7200 sounds brilliant if you didn't study
@@hassim7867 exactly
Sounds brilliant if you are stupid. Sounds like someone beating around the bushes if you not stupid.
Wisdom comes with age. Well done Hijab.
But if you make it halal that doesn't seem to have an end as everything can be used as a مصلحة argument ..
?
Here's a challenge: where is TV or entertainment stated to be wrong. And By that same logic aren't you committing a sin by Having a phone? Or laptop? Or any modern device? Go live in the caves if you are truthful.
@TheeSinnerman
entertainment isn't wrong
But music and looking at women is wrong, as you know.
If the entertainment is free of these, then there is nothing wrong with it.
As for laptops and phones, mine is free of women and music .. and if it had any, it wasn't by intention, and it is also necessary to have phones and modern devices unlike entertainment.
You can't compare the 2. They are different on so many levels
@@onf3257 you absolutely can compare the 2
The only reason women would be Haram is if you sexualize them but Just them existing in TV isn't Haram especially not on Television lol
@@onf3257 Exactly, if we take the maslaha argument of him, we will be just like Christianty in their today liberalism
Women showing their awrah, swearing, using beatboxing to the point it sounds exactly like music etc are haram. End doesn't justify the means in Islam. If you're going to do haram, that's on you but you shouldn't justify it, ever. E.g. many of these Muslims in the comments have watched haram tv shows and movies. Are they now going to say oh yeah it's halal if I pick a fatwa from here and there. No. They know it's haram and won't justify their sins.
Something that sounds like music is haram? who told you that? give me the source
Totally agree with Brother Hijab. He clarified it well. Media is a great tool to do Dawah. Now my all questions are answered. May Allah bless him & grant him success in this life & Hereafter.
But doing it with women uncovering hair, etc, is definitely haram. The hadiths he mentioned in other videos don't fit in this situation, obviously. I hope other scholars with more knowledge will clarify this situation, although it's obvious that this tv series is wrong.
@@mirafu3481I didn’t see anything about the series. what else is bad about the movie apart from women’s hair? Not saying its okay just want to know the other elements
@algerino5421 because it shows haram stuff, i didn't watch it, therefore i can't speak about the story. But if you want to know more about the haram stuff: you can see hair, arms, and even the neck until the breast of a woman begins.
@@mirafu3481 Ah okay jazakallah khairan thank you for the response brother
@algerino5421 no problem, brother 👍
It’s so sad to see that when it comes to our own, we find the most minutest things to throw someone under the bus with especially with someone like brother hijab, but when it comes to the non Muslims a lot of Muslims subconsciously worship them.
Support and love your fellow Muslims. We’re dehumanised in many parts of the world we have enough enemies we don’t need no more.
İf we don't police ourselves then we are doomed to be policied bu tyrants. This is not throwing someone under the bus. This method of nahyi anil munker is widely observed throughout Islamic history not only by the ulema among themselves, but by the general people's toward even the ulema. This is praised.
When someone openly does something that does not comply with the Qur'an, in this example Allahu Teala ruled men to lower their gaze (as to not see women) and women to cover , and not open up or show themselves around like the kâfir, but Muhammed hijab has defied this, and is now using so called fatwa to support what is forbidden. This, leads to takfir.
We can't make anyone do anything, but stating facts, that will definitely be done.
Doing haram won't take you out the folds of Islam. But justifying it, that can eventually take you out. If you're going to do haram stuff no matter what, at the very least STOP JUSTIFYING IT. Your salvation is on the line.
Sheikh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah said:
«وَقَدْ ذَهَبَ كَثِيرٌ مِنْ الْعُلَمَاءِ إلَى أَنَّهُ لَا يَجُوزُ لِلْمَرْأَةِ أَنْ تَنْظُرَ إلَى الْأَجَانِبِ مِنْ الرِّجَالِ بِشَهْوَةِ وَلَا بِغَيْرِ شَهْوَةٍ أَصْلًا»
“Many scholars have said that it is not permissible for a woman to look at non-mahram men with desire or without desire at all.”
[Majmu’ Fatawa vol 3 page 378]
Sheikh Abdul Aziz Al-Tarifi said: “There is no scholar known throughout the fifteen centuries of Islam who said that mixing in gatherings, education, and work is permissible... I have come across more than a hundred scholars and jurists throughout those centuries who have stated that it is not permissible. In fact, I have seen some of them who have discredited the justice of the one who does it, and even his guardianship of honor.”
Al-Hafiz Abu Bakr Muhammad ibn Abdullah al-Amiri - who was one of the scholars of the sixth century - said in his book ( Ahkam al-Nazar) : “The scholars of the nation agreed that whoever believes in these prohibitions and the permissibility of women mixing with foreign men has committed blasphemy and deserves to be killed for his apostasy. But if he believes in its prohibition and does it and acknowledges it and is satisfied with it, then he has committed wickedness, his words are not to be listened to, and his testimony is not to be accepted . ”
[The book of mixing between men and women, page 112]
From the Hanafi scholars:
Al-Sarakhsi said: “The judge should present women separately and men separately, because people crowd in his council, and the mixing of women with men during a crowd is a source of temptation. This is in a dispute that occurs between women.
As for the dispute that occurs between men and women, he finds no alternative but to put them before the men.”
[Al-Mabsoot vol 16 page 80]
Al-Hamawi Al-Hanafi said: “The preferred opinion is that a wedding is not disliked if it does not include any corruption, as stated in Al-Fath. I said: It is forbidden in our time, in addition to being disliked for matters that are not hidden from you, including the mixing of women with men.”
[Ghamaz ‘Uyoon Al-Basair fi Sharh]
Ibn Abidin explained the rejection of the testimony of someone who went out to watch the arrival of a prince, saying: “Because of the reprehensible things it contains, and the mixing of men and women . ”
[Al-Ashbah wa Al-Naza’ir vol 2 page 114]
Al-Khadami said in the sixtieth plague of the plagues of the tongue: “Permission and approval in what is a sin, such as the husband’s permission for his wife to leave his house to places other than those designated as permissible - then he counted them as seven - and said: “And in what is other than that - from visiting strangers and visiting them and the feast - he does not give her permission, and she does not go out, and if he gives permission and she goes out, they are “Disobedient”
[Bariqat Mahmudiyya fi Sharh Tariqah Muhammadiyah wa Shari’ah Nabawiyah by Al-Khademi vol 4 page 10-11]
From the Maliki scholars:
Qadi Iyad - may God have mercy on him - said: “He ordered us to keep a distance between the breaths of men and women, and it was his custom - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - to keep them apart so that his nation would follow his example.”
[ Sharh Sahih Muslim by Al-Nawawi vol 14 page 166] .
The Maliki imams, such as Ibn Farhun, Ibn Zayd al-Barnasi, and Ahmad al-Qarafi, have stated that there is no disagreement in the school of thought regarding the non-acceptance of the testimony of those who attend weddings in which men and women mix, because their presence in these places invalidates their justice .
[Shu’ab al-Iman vol 7 page 411-412]
Al-Nafrawi said in his explanation (Al-Fawakih Al-Dawani on the Epistle of Ibn Abi Zayd Al-Qayrawani) : “ (And no clear evil) meaning something well-known and apparent, such as the mixing of men with women”
[al-Risalah with al-Nafrawi’s commentary vol 2 page 322]
Abu Muhammad Al-Andalusi Al-Qahtani Al-Maliki said:
Men who look at women are like wild beasts roaming around the meat.
If the lions of that meat do not protect it, it will be eaten without compensation or price .
From the Shafi’i scholars:
Imam Al-Bayhaqi said:
This includes a man protecting his wife and daughter from mixing with men, talking to them, and being alone with them . ”
Imam Al-Mawardi - may God have mercy on him - said, defining the cuckold: “He is the one who brings men together with women, it was called that because it is spread among them.”
[Adab al-Dunya wa al-Din (p. 268]
Abu Ishaq al-Shirazi said: “ Friday prayer is not obligatory for a woman, because Jabir narrated that the Messenger of God, may God bless him and his family and grant them peace, said: ‘Whoever believes in God and the Last Day, Friday prayer is obligatory for him, except for a woman, a traveler, a slave, or a sick person." It was narrated by Al-Daraqutni and declared weak by Al-Albani.
Abu Ishaq al-Shirazi commented on the hadith to say: "And because she mixes with a man, and that is not permissible.”
[Irwa’ Al-Ghaleel fi Takhreej Ahadith Minar Al-Sabil vol 3page 56]
Ibn Hajar al-Haytami said after quoting al-Shirazi’s words: “Contemplate it and you will find it explicit in the prohibition of mixing; and it is so because it is a source of temptation . ”
[Al-Muhadhdhab with Al-Majmu’ vol 4 page 350]
Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani narrated in his explanation of Al-Bukhari’s hadith on the authority of Abdullah Ibn Abi Qatada Al-Ansari on the authority of his father, who said: The Messenger of God - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - said: “I stand up for prayer and I intend to “That I prolong it, and then I hear the crying of the child, so I shorten my prayer, for fear of causing hardship to his mother.” He quoted the words of Ibn Daqeeq al-‘Eid: “This hadith is general in its meaning for women, except that the jurists specified certain conditions for it, including that she should not use perfume, and perfume includes anything similar in meaning, because the reason for prohibiting it is that it arouses desire, such as good clothing.” And the jewelry that appears, and the luxurious adornment, and also mixing with men."
[Fath Al-Bari by Ibn Hajar vol 2 page 349]
Al-Hafiz Ibn Hajar said in his explanation of Sahih Al-Bukhari in (Chapter on men carrying the funeral procession and not women) : “...and there has been reported something that is more explicit than this in prohibiting them, but it is not according to the conditions of the author, and perhaps he referred to it, which is what Abu Ya’la narrated from the hadith of Anas, who said: “We went out with the Messenger of God - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - in a funeral, and he saw women , so he said: ‘Will you carry him? ’ They said: ‘No. ’ He said: ‘Will you bury him? ’” They said, “ No.” He said, “Then go back, sinners, but not rewarded . ” Al-Nawawi reported in (Sharh al-Muhadhdhab) that there is no disagreement on this issue among the scholars, and the reason for it is what was mentioned above, and because the funeral must be accompanied by men, so if women carried it, that would be a pretext for them to mix with men, which would lead to temptation
[Fath Al-Bari vol 3page 182]
Al-Bajrimy said: “People gathering after the afternoon prayer to supplicate, as the people of Arafah do. Imam Ahmad said: There is nothing wrong with it. Imam Malik disliked it... and Sheikh Al-Tawkhi said that it is forbidden because it involves mixing of women with men, as is seen now.”
[Al-Bajuri on Al-Khatib vol 2 page 226]
From the Hanbali scholars:
Sheikh Al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah - may God have mercy on him - said: “It was the Sunnah of the Prophet - may God bless him and his family and grant them peace - and the Sunnah of his successors to distinguish between men and women... because the mixing of one of the two types with the other is a cause of temptation. So when men mix with women, it is like the mixing of fire and wood . ”
Imam Ibn al-Qayyim - may God have mercy on him - said: “The one in authority must prevent men from mixing with women in the markets, public places, and places where men gather...
He must prevent women from going out adorned and beautified, and prevent them from wearing clothes that would make them appear naked, such as loose and thin clothes, and prevent them from talking to men in the streets, and prevent men from doing that.
If the guardian sees fit to spoil the woman’s clothes by using ink or something similar when she beautifies herself and goes out, some jurists have permitted this and were correct. This is one of the least financial punishments for them.
He has the right to detain a woman if she goes out of her house frequently, especially if she goes out adorned. Rather, women’s admission of this is helping them in sin and disobedience, and God will ask the guardian of the matter about that.
The Commander of the Faithful, Omar ibn al-Khattab - may God be pleased with him - forbade women from walking in the path of men and mixing with them on the road. The ruler must follow his example in that.
There is no doubt that allowing women to mix with men is the root of all calamity and evil, and it is one of the greatest causes of the general punishments, just as it is one of the causes of the corruption of public and private affairs.
The mixing of men and women is a cause of the spread of indecencies and adultery, and it is one of the causes of general death and continuous plagues.
One of the greatest causes of general death is the spread of adultery, due to women being allowed to mix with each other.
[Al-Istiqaama vol 1 page360]
Ibn al-Jawzi said: “As for what the storytellers have introduced of gathering women and men, it is one of the innovations in which strange things happen, such as women mixing with men, and women raising their voices in screaming and wailing, and other things . ”
[Uncovering the Problematic Hadith of the Two Sahihs vol 1 page 776]
Ibn Rajab said: “The only thing that is prescribed is for women to be separate from men as a whole, because there is a fear that their mixing with men will lead to corruption . ”
[Fath al-Bari in Explanation of al-Jami’ al-Sahih al-Bukhari vol 2 page 134]
This is one of the most interesting Series I have watch as a non Muslim. Its interesting to see the world thought someone who is Muslim.
It can be Haram as most Muslims say but It was education for me
CONGRATS HABIBI HIJAB.....INSHALLAH EVEN IF ONLY ONE HUMAN BEING IS DRAWN TO ISLAM FROM YOUR EFFORTS MAY YOU BE FULLY REWARDED......
Dont take from Mohammed Hijab he is entertainer, you are in a position of dawah how can justify your dawah Mohammed hijab whats next Hollywood.....
😂😂😂 pl keep mouth shut
@@mizwan2 you are not mentally sane
@@shadowstorm5261 yes how is asylum 😁
He is a commentator not a scholar his opinion is wholly justified as a layman!
And don't take from you. You provide no proof or evidence just your opinion. He's providing scholarly opinion and evidences from the sunnah
The question is can one deliver the message without ambiguity or using ijtihad opinions?
Can this not be done with less evil??
The reason here is that opening the doors for masla7a reasons can lead to transgression of the boundaries of Allah.
Political opinions are greater in masla7a because the potential mafsada is greater so I don’t think that’s comparable.
Regardless of whether he is right or not, that was a world class rationalization
I know of many families, that watch all sorts of movies with their childern. Disney movies which incorporate elements of moral, sexual ambiguity, Godlessness and ect. For older kids, superhero movies that feature costumes and themes of sexualized nature. In contrast, this show offers a more realistic portrayal, addressing relevant and meaningful issues currently faced in the real world, and provides a straightforward and wholesome viewing experience for all ages.
You've gone from one haraam to another. Just because Br Hijabs video does not have people in hero outfits does not make it Islamically acceptable.
Assalamu Alaikum, you must really seriously consider to delete this comment dear sister, no need to expose this to everyone.
No sins have been exposed dw
I know of people who do not watch those sinful things you have mentioned, and they do not watch what is less than that in badness, rather they watch lectures and durus.
I haven't watched the series but it is always encouraging to see muslims broadening their scope and trying new things, Islam is to be shared and entertainment is one of the largest AND most accessible industries, any modest muslim can engage in creative endeavors for a relatively low price, and stories communicate messages so effectively, I wish more and more productions like this are made.
Series is very good! Especially ep03
Its wonderful. The timing wit what is happening in the UK. Perfect timing
The largest medium we can use is Interest based banking. We can all get rich and then donate it to Gaza. Works?
Yep amazing what the weapons of mass destruction can do ... mind programing ..downloading bullocks into your heads . Save the children and show out Disney bbc film industry music industry ..this man is an agent of sorts. He is the wolf in sheep clothing..
Brother Mohamed Hijab , however iam actually not watching this series as it may consider a something that's considered haram but I get your point here that as you're in the UK it's lesser damage to do this or that in the series and by giving examples you mentioned it's quiet abit clearer point so if that is your intention then may Allah reward you for this
Also I haven't watch the series but I get the general idea of difficulty in living in western society as a Muslim..
I mean the guy argued it brilliantly tbh
facts
Cause he is good sophist
@mcdonaldsgaming3974 Oratory and eloquent speech is not sophism
@@aminqurtubi He didn't at all, just some talk around the bush.
To the one who has no knowledge but likes to hear speech misquoting texts using Arabic terminology you think he makes a good argument
the scholars in the Arab world who are silent about Gaza Genocide are NOT EXCUSED.
💀💀💀
Almost every major Ulema has spoken out about Gaza in their Khutbas and speeches.
You actually don't care if they speak out or not about Gaza. You care if they speak against the rulers.
@@ToHimWeWillBeReturned let me guess, the khutbah went like this; "we are powerless to act, all we have is dua".
@@ToHimWeWillBeReturnedKhutbahs written by their pay masters, with no direct mention of Palestinian or Gaza.
السلام عليكم ورحمةالله وبركاته
I understand where Brother Hijab is coming from.
But I think it's different when you are the one recording or making the series. There is an individual who is using the UA-cam platform to promote and spread the message of Islam. Okay, you may say that he should make his website and divert his audience that way, but with the tools and traffic that UA-cam has, his website will never get to that stage. He has no option but to use that platform, and then when he has the following he desires or requires to make his own website, he should.
I think there is a subtle difference between doing something yourself and setting its standards vs. having no other option but to use what is at your disposal.
I remember once discussing respecting the Qur'an. I know this is a very indo-pak thing, but my brother and I were discussing this, and I highlighted what my teacher said, "Respect is an act from the heart; if someone sits on a seat, does that mean he is disrespecting the Qur'an? If that is the case, that means the one who is walking is disrespecting the Qur'an'."
My brother then raised a valid and interesting point. He said, "There is a difference between both incidents/situations. The one who is sitting on the seat has sat utilising his option and freedom to sit there. On the other hand, the one who is walking can't do anything to lower his buttocks than the one seated. "
Lastly, the criteria's set by Islam are there to further stop and prevent all types of sin/مفاسد/ذنوب. Maintaining a strong belief in the traditional understandings of Islam will prevent you from crossing limits and, furthermore, desensitisation.
I mean, if you steal once you will likely steal again, if you know what I mean.🤷
اللهم اهدنا، واهد بنا واجعلنا سببا لمن اهتدى.
You watched til the end?
Makes much sense
@@user-op8fg3ny3j
Yes, brother.
Actually u can bypass all the ads by paying for youtube premium.....no more ads!
It was a good series but i wouldnt say its Allowed and please dont promote that your allowed in Islam to do such acts... Islam is spread through Sunnah and media isnt Sunnah
Please comment on the recent behaviour of the apparent Muslim, Androo Tate. Is someone advising this person? Is he being taught about Islam? He urgently needs to learn to stop running his mouth and stop putting fellow muslims, sisters, in harms way.
Andrew Tate will be my dog in jahannam
I washed my hands from following andrew tate, he has cognitive dissonance… one time he says he supports islam and Muslims and then some time he is saying weird stuff like what he said three days ago
@@AkramSaeed-qr7tdwhat did he say 3 days ago?
@@muaz5873 he was speaking good of tommy robinson which is an islamophobe
@@muaz5873 he was speaking good about tommy robinson which is an islam.oph.obe
Funny how people with infinitely less knowledge than him are passing categorical judgements in the comments.
@@SupermanOG the commons
Since when in Islam laymen cannot share islamic reminders ?
Take your knowledge from the ulemaa
By this logic we should all embrace bidah, the Shia and Sufis scholars have much more knowledge than a layman don't they?
Take your knowledge from trustable Sunni ulema not celebrity Dawah guys
This is clearly bidah and haram
@@Abdullah_0083Ah anime fan 😂.
My ears are burning from the arguments presented by the brother.
Shocking that someone who is seen by some as a person of knowledge (Islamic knowledge) is speaking in this manner.
Can only make dua for his guidance & my advice to Sapience is to have him stick to worldly subjects or maybe areas of his specialisation such as world history etc, because having him teach Islaam is going to adversely impact your credibility especially in the eyes of serious students of Islaam
They all are like this at sapience.
Yeah it's so bad and wrong
@@AhmedRaza-lh4oj I don’t know all of them, but I have listened to brother Hamza Tzortsis and he at least stays within his area of expertise I believe. May Allaah Azza Wa Jall guide them and us
@@Shehryar486
Yeah but go speak to them directly. You'll see
I've been following Hijab for many years at it's very disappointing to see him looking this uncomfortable, battling his fitrah for a tv series...the sin is not worth it. You do an excellent job in the dawah field, stick to it brother!
Doing acting with women and music is not acceptable at all at least for dawah men
My brother Mohammed Hijab, I have followed you for a long time and Wallahi I want good for you. Here is an analogy and my honest interpretation on your comments about showing uncovered women on youtube, just because they're going to be there anyways whether you include them in your series or not.
You live on a remote island, there is no food or water whatsoever except for within one bar/ pub that exists on the island. Within this bar they serve alcohol, as well as other non alcoholic drinks and food. Essentially what you are saying is because this is the only place where you can find something to eat or drink, it is also permissible for you to go in there and drink alcohol as you please. Where is the sense in this my brother? Of course, you would enter the bar to find food and water for yourself but this is not an excuse to commit haraam. You have always been extremely analytical and reasonable and idk how you aren't able to see this. Just because there are women all over youtube, why does that permit you to hold hands with the kuffs and follow them in their transgressions by including them in YOUR OWN videos? For what purpose are you doing this?
We don't need to stoop to these filthy lows for the sake of Dawah, because Dawah is something sacred and it is upon us to uphold the rights of the Prophet SAW by following him in his methodology of giving Dawah. At the same time, it is only upon us to convey the message and guidance of the heart is by the will of Allah only. Tell me my brother, if we have to sit here and have countless discussions to even decide whether this series is permissible or haraam, then what kind of dawah is this? Why tread a blurred line when there is no need? I love you for the sake of Allah and I pray that you are upon correct guidance.
what if the actor playing the women is a non Muslim man? so there's no gender mixing or cross dressing
@@user-op8fg3ny3jthen it is okay there is nothing haram then
@@user-op8fg3ny3j yeah but he'd be imitating women by acting like one and then again that's so unattractive and no man would play such a role lol
Money 💰 >> reason
M Hijab's Aqeeda is doubtful.
Really liked the series. The rationale was super clear! May Allah bless all your efforts. Ameen❤
Ask yourself this, did the prophet ASW go to such extremes? Did he risk his own akhira by doing such acts? Allah says that he is nothing more than a guide and so are we. There is no need to go to such lengths as Allah is the one who guides the hearts. Accept your mistake and be humble
In my opinion he is 99% CORRECT, this show is advantageous in that it reflects a good picture about muslims for the non-muslim viewers. However, it has NO BENEFIT for a MUSLIM viewer bcz its objective is not targeted towards muslim audience. So i WOULD NOT RECOMMEND MUSLIMS TO WATCH it but encourage non muslims to do so!
كانَ النَّاسُ يَسْأَلُونَ رَسولَ اللهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عليه وَسَلَّمَ عَنِ الخَيْرِ، وَكُنْتُ أَسْأَلُهُ عَنِ الشَّرِّ مَخَافَةَ أَنْ يُدْرِكَنِي، فَقُلتُ: يا رَسولَ اللهِ، إنَّا كُنَّا في جَاهِلِيَّةٍ وَشَرٍّ، فَجَاءَنَا اللَّهُ بهذا الخَيْرِ، فَهلْ بَعْدَ هذا الخَيْرِ شَرٌّ؟ قالَ: نَعَمْ، فَقُلتُ: هلْ بَعْدَ ذلكَ الشَّرِّ مِن خَيْرٍ؟ قالَ: نَعَمْ، وَفِيهِ دَخَنٌ، قُلتُ: وَما دَخَنُهُ؟ قالَ: قَوْمٌ يَسْتَنُّونَ بغيرِ سُنَّتِي، وَيَهْدُونَ بغيرِ هَدْيِي، تَعْرِفُ منهمْ وَتُنْكِرُ، فَقُلتُ: هلْ بَعْدَ ذلكَ الخَيْرِ مِن شَرٍّ؟ قالَ: نَعَمْ، دُعَاةٌ علَى أَبْوَابِ جَهَنَّمَ مَن أَجَابَهُمْ إلَيْهَا قَذَفُوهُ فِيهَا، فَقُلتُ: يا رَسولَ اللهِ، صِفْهُمْ لَنَا، قالَ: نَعَمْ، قَوْمٌ مِن جِلْدَتِنَا، وَيَتَكَلَّمُونَ بأَلْسِنَتِنَا، قُلتُ: يا رَسولَ اللهِ، فَما تَرَى إنْ أَدْرَكَنِي ؟ قالَ: تَلْزَمُ جَمَاعَةَ المُسْلِمِينَ وإمَامَهُمْ، فَقُلتُ: فإنْ لَمْ تَكُنْ لهمْ جَمَاعَةٌ وَلَا إمَامٌ؟ قالَ: فَاعْتَزِلْ تِلكَ الفِرَقَ كُلَّهَا، ولو أَنْ تَعَضَّ علَى أَصْلِ شَجَرَةٍ حتَّى يُدْرِكَكَ المَوْتُ وَأَنْتَ علَى ذلكَ.
الراوي : حذيفة بن اليمان | المحدث : مسلم | المصدر : صحيح مسلم | الصفحة أو الرقم : 1847 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : [صحيح]
Masha Allah the authenticity. You strike a balance between respect for others and even those that criticise you and being true to yourself and Allah. May Allah continue to guide you and open the doors of his mercy to you. May he protect you and your family from harm and evil. Ameen
He can state what’s halal’s and haraam with everyone else’s content but his own! 🤦🏽♀️
Similar to what Madkhalis do!
Bro Hijab - is a legend
mashaAllah
Really? He’s sidetracking and singing like a canary here. Simple question and he started talking about elections and Saddam. 😅
@@ayyazkhan5245 I don't know why y'all cheering for him.
Watch out You're egergarating.
Falling in a deep pit of twisting the deen.
I wish there were more discussions like this
Jazakallhahu khayra bother Hijab and sapience institute
Vage reasoning for showing women without hijab and looking at them while Quran clearly order for man to lower gaze and women to cover, its period. You do your best doesn't matter who did what in past what not
Why are there people degrading the fatawa brother hijab has used from various scholars? They are talking about it like these scholars are just random people commenting on videos declaring their fatwa… These scholars aint like this, they aint you or me
Not everybody is a scholar, He could be from a deviant sect. Like the one MH mentioned. He is a Sufi who rejects clear attributes of Allah in the Quran.
I would love to see you talk on that topic with Muhammad ali from the muslim lantern
He will never do that and we all know why
@@purposeoflife4829 Muhammed Ali talks to kuffar women all the time doing dawah.
Does that count as free mixing?
@kaz4845 why are you getting all pumped up about? He just said he would love to see two knowledgeable people talk on that topic, and btw if you have any questions about Muhammad ali Go and ask on his channel
@@kaz4845 Mohamed Ali is doing dawah to all people in the street(men,woman)and if a woman came to him to ask about the Qur'an he wouldn't say no to her because this is free mixing because she is a kaffera so it's more important that she comes to islam and for the sake of argument if he did not talk to woman this would completely affect his dawah, and when he uploads video with woman taking to him, he completely bluers her and every woman waking in the background of the video as well.
How on earth you're comparing that with Mohamed Hijab making a series and uploading it to hundreds of thousands of people around the world with uncovered (mutaberjat)woman innit without a legitimate reason?!!
@@YoussefAssemZahran2005 they are both talking directly to non mahram women with their awra exposed.. The action is exactly the same..
Your giving me reasons that are different. Is the act haram by itself? Or only haram based on the reason?
Muhammed Hijab is a legend.
Masha-Allah may Allah reward him and preserve him
Aameen Aameen
12:54 - Not sure this makes sense, as the contention is showing the faces, body, hair etc of women visually. The Quran is written text. Can the two be compared as such?
what if the actor playing the women is a non Muslim man? so there's no gender mixing or cross dressing
@user-op8fg3ny3j Wouldn't that necessitate cross dressing? Also, I don't have any real knowledge regarding these rulings/this topic. I'm only pointing out a particular comparison he made which doesn't make sense to me
@@OmarAliYT. there are lots of transgender actors you can hire and according to the scholars they are still considered men so it won't be classed as free mixing or zina if you look at them
He should not used Qur'an for defending his haram content
It makes sense. We're not comparing the media form here. We're comparing the story telling technique. Because the Qur'an tells stories, Hijab is trying to tell a story as well. The Qur'an tells story how it is, thats the point. Even the Qur'an mentions how a woman seduced Prophet Yusuf AS, and even stated what she said to seduce him. Qur'an does not shy away from that. If you have shahwa, then it is upon you to look away. If you see a beautiful woman out there with hijab etc covering her awrah yet you feel shahwa just from looking at her eyes, then is it upon the woman to walk away from you? no, you are the one that needs to walk away.
The most effective media for telling stories these days is in Video form. A lot of people don't read books anymore, they enjoy watching videos more. How else are you gonna tell a story in visual form yet completely remove important actors / parts of the story, it just doesn't make any sense.
No matter who makes fatwa , Allah says , if you disagree go back to Quran and sunnah !! … He did not say follow fatwa of Ibn Baz or Ibn Uthymeen RahimahumAllah …
The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The lawful is clear and the unlawful is clear, and between the two of them are doubtful matters about which many people do not know. Thus, he who avoids doubtful matters clears himself in regard to his religion and his honor, and he who falls into doubtful matters will fall into the unlawful as the shepherd who pastures near a sanctuary, all but grazing therein. Verily, every king has a sanctum and the sanctum of Allah is His prohibitions. Verily, in the body is a piece of flesh which, if sound, the entire body is sound, and if corrupt, the entire body is corrupt. Truly, it is the heart.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 52, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1599
Honestly, as someone living in the west, this seems like a PAINFULLY obvious point, to me.
Are there any people that watch his series, that would otherwise not watch something that would be clearly in conflict with Islam on a deep level? We NEED to be involved in these kinds of arts and entertainment; the alternative is just that we will end up consuming the arts and entertainment of the non-Muslims that are many degrees of magnitude worse. Worse in terms of the message and what is being shows itself too.
And that is presuming that all of these things are haram, in this context, in the first place! As Hijab alludes to, if people took these things they are criticizing his series for and applied them consistently, they would have to poke their eyes, ears, nose, etc. You would be paralysed by every little thing. You would not be able to go on the internet because of the vast degree of haram that are there and you will inevitably stumble across. You would not be able to go outside because of all the haram that is unavoidable. You would not be able to work because of all the haram that cannot be avoided. You could not exist at all! It's exactly as the prophet SAW told us that:
“Verily, the religion is easy and no one burdens himself in religion but that it overwhelms him. Follow the right course, seek closeness to Allah, give glad tidings, and seek help for worship in the morning and evening and a part of the night.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 39
May Allah reward Hijab, and make this the start of a revolution and revival of Islamic thought and media at all levels.
A simple counter logic is, why take risk in a critical matter like this?? and was creating this TV series necessary?? what if you didn't make it and continued your dawah?? and what if you invested this much effort in your dawah videos in some way? There are immense problems with this series effects of which could have been easily avoided.
Clearly, you didn't understand anything, or you already made up your mind before listening to this.
Simple question to engage your mind.
Do you understand the concept of maslaha?
The way I understood it, there is a huge missing gap in the mainstream media space. The majority of young muslims are watching TV Shows and Movies which include extremely haram elements e.g. romance, nude/inappropriately clothed women, western morals etc.
There is a need to replace the medie diet of these young Muslims with alternatives that are engaging and promote Islamic morals. This content will empower them as Muslims whilst also promoting Islam to the wider non-muslim society.
This is the benefits vs harm analysis that Mohamed Hijab's team have done. You can disagree but at least understand how they came to their conclusion.
All about ££££££'s the br probably got offered big money £150k or more and had to justify doing it...regardless of risk
@@sufyan2297 slandering your brother with no evidence.
@@myname4946 "probably" just a guess, it won't be peanuts for this type of a production...simple logic no slander here
In an age where entertainment is a widely accepted and influential medium for conveying information, it is essential for Muslims to utilize this tool to spread their message effectively. By engaging with popular culture and media, we can share our values, teachings, and perspectives with a broader audience. This approach not only allows us to reach more people but also helps in fostering understanding and respect for our beliefs in diverse communities.
IF ENTERTAINMENT BECOMES HARAM THEN WE DONT WANT THAT ENTERTAINMENT
Don't need to do haram to do this.
@@insan107 ok so how else can it be do u tell me
@@riyaansheikh7470 Rasulullah Sallallahu Alaihi ve's-Sallam, the Prophet who gave this Ummah the message of Allah including how to live until Qiyama , was a living walking example... Have you forgotten ?
Emri bil maruf, nehyi anil munker was one of the amal he performed most, not one narration can show Him 'acting', even though there was acting in His time. İn the letter sent to Hercules, there is a clear line between Islam and Kufr.
That line never fades, who ever crosses, crosses alone.
"In an age where interest based banking is widespread, it is upon muslims to use this tool to make as much money as possible and serve the Ummah."
Does this apply? NO.
Looking at womens awrah is completely forbidden. Whatever he is quoting is when you happen to see a woman. This is not the case in a TV series. You are actively searching for it and the woman is being presented to you.
The ends dont justify the means.
whats the justification to only having 3 episodes?
When it came to criticizing a scholar like Al-Albani, you spoke as if you were a scholar yourself, making accusations with this Ali Dawah by rudeness and arrogance.
But now, you claim you are not a scholar when you realize there is no escape or refuge for you from the issue of music.
I used to be proud of you that came from the same ancient city in Egypt, my city Alexandria, but now I feel ashamed of you and your actions.
At 18 mins The Maslaha is based on the fact there are dharurat, such as transport, accommodation, food security and I forgot one more. Car insurance isn't an arbitrary issue it actually hinges itself on the fact that in the sharia a private mode of transport is a birth right of a Muslim. This is also why some who follow abu hanifah and even Yusuf Qardhawi said its ok to take an interest-bearing mortgage with the caveat it cant be a buy-to-let, and it must be owner-occupied.
The mortgage issue is completely twisting what Abu Hanifa said. They meant if the person has no home. The vast majority of people in the developed west rent for their entire lives.
Why is car insurance Haram? I didn't understand that part
@@ks-pk7of that’s wrong but I understand your view point. The case is made that if owning a home is a birth right in sharia can you then make an exception under dire circumstances. For instance there are no alternatives as you are too poor to pay cash, you can’t live anywhere else etc. the concept of renting a home even within the uk is seen as a precarious housing arrangement. That’s because the home I’m which you rent can be sold or you can be evicted, the sharia wants to protect you from that. The issue is mainly we now live in a modern nation state capitalism where prices of houses are inflated as they are bought with leveraged debt.
@@Mayor_Imad I want to answer that question but I feel I would do it an injustice so I will ask you to ask someone qualified. Maybe even a cursory google search may give you a heads or tails if it.
Need more videos like this where conversation on shariah are spoken about but also easier for the layman to relate to.
Had no Arabic terms been used without the faith which somenmay have in him, no-one would ever accept this response from him.
Brother muhamed hijab is not a person of Islamic knowledge and he is definitely not fit to give fatwa people should fear allah and look at who they are taking knowledge
He is well spoken and as a person i like him so I am not against my brother in anyway
Bro really cooked in this clip.
for real
Ong
For all those who are pushing the unity agenda and asking to let this slide,
There is no tolerance for haram in Islam.
Even if Sheikh ibn Taymiyyah (God forbid) or any other was to do such a thing, the response would be the same.
There is no unity in disobedience to Allah.
"Why are you coming on UA-cam to comment on This...."
Don’t listen
Missed opportunity for a blur on Hijab at 15:25 lol
Jokes aside, thanks for the interesting discussion.
The main poin we should talk about why aren't arab ulama are not speaking about the really genocide happening in our watch I'm not hearing any one saying about their silence
You shouldn't post things like that on Sapience. People come here to gain certainty, not doubt, from the ideas that Mohammed talks about. I wouldn't think badly of Mohammed because of his series, because he's just one actor. But his excuses are worse than anything. I am very disappointed to hear such ideas on this channel.
We need to support our brother M. HIJAB, he aims to spread islam for his entire life
One thing cannot justify other,Its alarming how ppl twisting and tweaking fatwas.
There is no justification for his movie. Free mixing is Haraam; there is no justification for it. Hijab might say the movie needed for Dawah; Islam is not in need of that Dawah. It seems he’s using Islam in this case to make money; if the movie was without free mixing then one can give it a pass, but there is free-mixing throughout
Dont u go out. And when u do i bet u encounter women everyday
General Advise
In Islam, we take the correct means to achieve a good outcome and objective
I can't see a "Dharoorah" a "Necessity" here to go against clear Islamic teachings on allowing faces of non-mahram to be seen by every muslim through these episodes
This work done by a person doing dawah will confuse the layman (Muslim) that all the content of this work and the elements in it are correct and according to deen, and it may encourage others to copy
The more we strive to do things according to deen even if we don't achieve 100% of the outcome we want, the more opportunities of tawfeeq and barakah we will receive in Shaa Allah
I ask Allaah the Almighty to grant us all the knowledge, the guidance and the ability to do good in line with the means that He made permissable
One aalim's fatwa is not the consensus of all the ulema.
@@salimr4718 it is for hardcore fans
Every issue doesn't require consensus ot ijma
He never said that it is
Should’ve just said something like I was giving the reality of our area so it included women as well. You had hajabi and non Muslim women in it as well. Everyday we see this in the UK and Western worlds all over
Bin Baz's fatwa was not based on maslaha. Seeking help from non-muslims is found in the text, Prophet alejhisalam took help of ibn Abdijj to enter Makkah.
Uthaymen's fatwa for voting is based on lesser of two evils, and early scholars such as Izz Abdussalam have stated this principle of usool fiqh years before ibn Uthaymen.
Lastly, if you believe maslaha to be allowed, it needs to be factually demonstrated that the series is bringing more good, than harm.
Non muslims in the comments are proof of that
So is ertugrul
So he takes from Shanquiti who is a student of Qaradawi who had some very controversial fatwas. He also went off topic on making movies by making excuses. He starting to turn into Yasir Qadhi. And lying saying scholars are silent in Arabia about Gaza when they are making dua for them. Only intelligent people can see through what he is saying.
dua is for Allah not for the people, you can speak out against zionism and make dua why do u people think they are mutually exclusive
Difference between making dua for them and urging the nation against the zionazis and america as much as possible
@@noticing33 and who isn't? A lot of sheep believe in news that Saudi supports Zionist. Most of you probably listen to DH. Did you see him appeasing to the far-right?
Just because you dislike certain scholar doesn't mean their fatwa, opinion etc. have no merit or qualifications. I'm talking about Qardawi that have many of his scholarly work being benefited by many Muslim and ulama. If they (including Qardawi) have stirr controversial in your perspective, that doesn't mean their scholarly work and authority automatically disqualified
@@Zzzk155 if it goes to the extent of kufr yeah it becomes no use for me. Maybe old-age made him more senile which can happen.
May Allah Guide us and him, never Humiliate us and him and Protect us and him from self amazement. Alhamdulillah the truth is clear as the falsehood is clear. Only a people who never wanted guidance will now follow him. Any parents reading this… keep your children well clear of him. Allahu AlMustaan
We should not take fringe opinions
May Allah bless if he is correct or condem him ...
Don't mistake knowledge for information. Y'all tripping
Greetings from Los Angeles,CA usa…i love your series dude, we need more
WHO CAREZ IF PEOPLE LISTEN TO MUSIC , etc….
that is not categorically haram - and no its not even by consensus
He just reflected the question and he saying if you point the finger at me we need to point the finger at every one else
Still haram...still haram!!
Forget everything, guys seriously in the west how do you live? i went to turkey as a holiday this year, and just so you know, According to the Turkish government, 99 percent of the population is Muslim, which, according to the government, includes Alevis, i was just so shsocked how do the muslims live, in the shopping malls, everyone was almost naked, i was so so shocked, the underground metro and trains were literly full everyone was literly stuck to everyone in specific times of the day, and indeed it was mixed, i cannot imagine living there for months how could you live somewhere worse than that? the sitiuation has gone so bad... it was a nightmere... everyoner should get way more carefull than they were...
Just wondering what the purpose of the series is
Far right(Tommy Robinson ) /uk gov treatment of Muslims.
Entertainment? Go read books to increase your deen and support Muslim content creators when ur on YT trying to be entertained.
@TheSyporg Muslims will either be represented or represent themselves in the media.
It's quite simple, really. Think how many minds have been subconsciously shaped through movies and series.
Do you have any teenage aged children? I work with a ton of Muslim youth and we are deluding ourselves if we think they are not watching mainstream movies and TV shows. No matter how much we try to control it, they will be exposed to mainstream media and the poison of it.
On the other hand, if our youth have access to content like our brothers TV series, they’ll enjoy it just as they enjoy mainstream media, while also getting some powerful lessons out of it. I’ve talked to several youth already who were inspired and shaken by some of the scenes in the Burning Hands series.
If you do not watch shows or waste your time on these things. Alhamdulillah that’s the best way to be. But the fact is, the majority of our people are distracted by mainstream media. We can either try and restrict our children from it completely. Which hardly works. Or, we can make an effort to control the content and provide them with better alternatives.
On a final note. We can argue that the Sahaba used the media of the time to spread good. What was the media of the their time? Poetry. The enemies used poetry to spread lies and corruption. The Sahaba, such as Hassan ibn Tabbit (RA) were encouraged by the Prophet SA to respond with their own good poetry.
Allah knows best what the right answer is. May Allah show us the way
? Knowledge with entertainment or do you like reading a book
well mu'amalat is something in our hands whereas politics is not necessarily
Can you please share what the opinion of Sheikh Abdullah al ujairy?
0:55 first of all others do it….terrible argument. Comparison of nasheed also irrelevant.
i just have one thing to say the ones who criticise hijab and think they knoew more than him with not good qualification are the same people who would ask scholars why are they silent about gaza and say why dont you protest aginst your ruler of saudi arabia these people whoo tend to know everything go and see what hadith authentic says that do not protest against muslim rulers even if they are corrupt ,these guys will follow one part and rejct others they ask why scholars silent about genocide i want to ask what have you guys done by shouting ,most of them atleast in here in my country chant protest and then go to buy product from zionist nbrands atleast if you have real concern go and first boycott these brands and many scholars have done that go see they are abiding by the sunnah ,if you are capable of fighting then go and do jihad by hand but if you cannot do it with your actions
Muhammad hijab has definitely worked hard to make this movie according to islamic norms, we all are humans if there is something unislamic then he should be forgiven and he should have made more movies like that
So why are people reading Qur'an on phones? The first three generations didn't have mobile phones. Therefore, phone is haram 😑
What??
You don't have to justify yourself Hijab.
Er yes he does.
No joke some dude was telling me about how nuts it is that this guys has made a series ect.. he was like wth heck women ect wll that.. anyways after long convo he mentions "u seen the knew game of thrones" 😂😂😂😂😂🤣💀💀💀. I dont say all in the comments watch neftlix shows or american shows comedy or whatsoever but there's a big number of ppl tht watch tv showd and movies with all the adult scene done today is wild. N ppl speaking out for this. Damn. If you dont watch anything at all. You have a book shelf or tend to your garden or enjoy ur life without tv and shows u already are 1000% living life great. Doesnt take away from those who do but its wild how ppl js are so angry n stuff. Man jus go for a walka
A little logic is a dangerous thing. Almost every argument made my Hijab was fallacious.
Bro you have no proof from the Quran and sunnah to justify what you did , very poor analogy , just because UA-cam has haram doesn’t mean you can incorporate haram elements , your series is not a life and death situation , you took one shiekh fatwa and did a qias that is invalid .
You can not take something that you can not control and therefore you yourself create the haram that you cannot control , hijab you can leave the country if you can’t deal with the fitnah around you , in the Quran Allah says that the angles will ask , wasn’t Allah land specious for you to migrate ???
Hijab I feel sorry for the route your taking , may Allah guide you
Wrong analogies. Political or situational matters are different to going out your way to create a movie for financial gains
Yes, the level of hypocracy & sophistry. The Ayatollah won't ever sit down for a talk with an uncovered woman no matter if she is a Muslim or not, so this is just a fake excuse. Also, Hijab & Dawah recently said that Islam allows women to drive, go to universities, vote and have their own bank accounts - to us Christians this is pure feminism!
Remember brother that just yesterday you made takfir on Humza Yousaf not giving him an excuse of maslaha or even a thought but you are stretching this very concept when it comes to your series. There are many points you mention I would like to discuss with you, if you have some way to reach you we can discuss them on whatsapp.
What video was that? About HY?
Muslims will try make halal three thing music zina wearing of silk
He is not smart he trying to sound smart pay attention he is not saying nothing of substance talking in a circles
Unfortunately.
Hijab audience are those who love media… he will bring those love media to Islam and to the mosque, for those who are already going to the mosque u dont have to watch if your not comfortable. Let’s support Bro Hijab in getting brother and sister from the media to the mosque and those who are in the mosque will help to get those sister and brother to solat again. It is realistic way to get people who love entertainment to love Islam.