Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
diskusinya kurang sehat, anda hanya bisa bermain dalam area pemikiran anda sendiri dan tidak berusaha berpikiran terbuka dengan menggunakan pendekatan sudut pandang lawan diskusi 😢
WHY HAVE PE0PLE DECIDED THOSE TAWEEZ WITH QURAN VERSES ARE NOT SHIRK ❓ As we know asking the dead for help is SHIRK, If l was to claim asking the dead for help is not SHIRK because this dead person is going to ask ALLAH to help us, will the PEOPLE agree with this ❓ The answer is no, which is correct ✔ WHY DO WE USE A DIFFERENT RULE F0R THE TAWEEZ, BECAUSE THE POINT WAS USING TAWEEZ FOR HELP IS SHIRK ❓
*It is a logical absurdity to get all your morals from a being whose existence you cannot prove, I am not talking about God, I believe God exists, I am saying that there is no evidence in any Islamic scripture that Allah is God.* I don't mean to be rude in this beautiful month of Ramadan, and trust me I have as much respect and love for Allah as Allah in my religion, however I will contest the Islamic moral view with logic and facts, because I believe it is my duty to oppose any ideology that leads to unnecessary suffering of innocents. With all due respect to Allah swt. Allah swt made many claims in the Holy Qur'an about the material world that PROVES that Allah swt is NOT OMNISCIENT, BY EXTENSION NOT OMNIPOTENT AND NOT THE CREATOR. What are these claims? Allah has a throne where the Sun goes to rest after a whole days running around the Earth (Qur'an 36:38 and Sahih Al Bukhari 3199). Stars fall down when they die (81:2) quran.com/81 Stars are missiles to be thrown at rebellious devils and they are also ornamentary lamps to decorate the night sky (67:5) quran.com/67/5 The sky is a *solid canopy/ceiling with no holes in it* (Qur'an 2:22 and Qur'an 21:32) These are a few claims among many others like it, that are proven to be demonstrably false through science, decades ago, to put it mildly. It is opposite to the well established truth. Which proves Allah swt is not God. If he was, he wouldn't make such mistakes in such an important book to mankind. God is supposed to be omniscient and omnipotent, the author of the Holy Qur'an, who is allegedly God, is not, proven through these claims. Now if you really have evidence that Allah is God, then give a logical rebuttal, but if you fail in doing so, then that is not what you truly believe. It is just a political excuse for you. Therefore it is a logical absurdity to get all your morals from Allah. This is why liberalism (definition of which may vary but I have my own) and secular humanism is the only logical and rational basis for morality.
Masha’ALLAH welcome home and all thanks to ALLAH(SWT), may Almighty always keep you under his protection, make you a light of guidance for others and reward you with all the best here and in the world after, Ameen
I humbly beseech The One Almighty God, The Most Merciful, The Most Just, The Most High, The All Knowing, to protect, raise and honour, all the oppressed peoples of the world and those who fight for them, and humiliate and crush the oppressors and those who stand with them, on this temporary Earth and in the eternal Hereafter.
We all agree idol worship will remain shirk, even if we where to put Quran verses on an idol We all agree reading Bismillah or reciting QURAN verses before eating pork will not make it halal Why are we making TAWEEZ halal, by claiming it is a QURANIC AMULET ( TAWEEZ ) ❓
Masha'allah tabarakallah 🤲brother Muhammad May.Allah's Reward you Immensely And protect you and keep you safe and make you Greatest scholar the Muslim ummah Ameen 💜♥️
From Italy! I am originally from Italy too but we live in Switzerland with my parents, please make dua that they accept Islam too like I did AlhamduliLlah 💗 May The Creator guide this person to the right path! Like always, thank you for your effort, may you be rewarded by Allah subhanahu wa taala in this life and in the next. 🇨🇭❤️🇵🇸
I feel bad for this guy. He's one of those guys going through life all alone without any role models. So he has too much time on his hands to be lost in his thoughts. May Allah (swt) guide him.
May Allah guide him indeed. But no, I don't feel sorry for him. We all live in similar environment... it is not a cause for sympathy... first world problems my akhi.🤷🏻♂️
@@lucian8256Understandable since this is a Muslim channel, you will see comments like that. If you go in a christian channel you will see same type of comments when someone doesnt agree with them. Life g.
@lord.jesus.christ.follower, you left Islam and now believe that God has a son that he crucified for the all of Christians sins??? Sorry, but you are not a knowledgeable person whatsoever and so lost
@@lord.jesus.christ.follower Hello. I'm a muslim who recently started reading the bible just to become more knowledgable about other religions. You said that Jesus Christ is the son of god who came to rescue us from hell. Okay, if the SON of god is so merciful that he wants to rescue his servants from hell, how come is the father (god) himself MUCH LESS merciful than the son? I'm referring to this verse in the bible: Genesis 3 Verses 14-16: So the Lord God said to the serpent, “Because you have done this, “Cursed are you above all livestock and all wild animals! You will crawl on your belly and you will eat dust all the days of your life. 15And I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will crush your head, and you will strike his heel.” 16To the woman he said, “I will make your pains in childbearing very severe; with painful labor you will give birth to children. Your desire will be for your husband, and he will rule over you.” Talk about a merciful god... I would never want to worship a god that punishes me without giving me a second chance. Also, your "All-powerful" god needed rest after creating the Heavens and the Earth, take a look at this verse. Genesis 2 Verses 1-3: Thus the heavens and the earth were completed in all their vast array. 2By the seventh day God had finished the work he had been doing; so on the seventh day he rested from all his work. 3Then God blessed the seventh day and made it holy, because on it he rested from all the work of creating that he had done. And this is literally in the first 3 pages of the bible. Imagine how many errors i can find if I read the whole bible! Return back to Islam brother. Leave this religion where you associate partners with Allah swt. I pray to Allah swt that he guides both you and I and all the brothers and sisters reading this comment.
@NaseerZaid-ou2ou someone named gabriel something, he making excuses for his inability to look smart while simultaneously trying to paint Ali as the one who misunderstood and have not answered his questions. In reality though he lacks basic understanding of speech of what Ali mentioned and how his argument amounts to insanity on his part and yet refuses to see it as he is too full of himself.
Congrats brother< I'm asking Allah to give you the knowledge, patience and guid you closer to Himself and Heaven. Finally i would like to share this verse from Qur'an: Surah Al-Furqan vs 70 As for those who repent, believe, and do good deeds, they are the ones whose evil deeds Allah will change into good deeds. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful. إِلَّا مَن تَابَ وَءَامَنَ وَعَمِلَ عَمَلًۭا صَـٰلِحًۭا فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ يُبَدِّلُ ٱللَّهُ سَيِّـَٔاتِهِمْ حَسَنَـٰتٍۢ ۗ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ غَفُورًۭا رَّحِيمًۭا
(وَلَقَدۡ صَرَّفۡنَا فِی هَـٰذَا ٱلۡقُرۡءَانِ لِلنَّاسِ مِن كُلِّ مَثَلࣲۚ وَكَانَ ٱلۡإِنسَـٰنُ أَكۡثَرَ شَیۡءࣲ جَدَلࣰا) [Surat Al-Kahf 18:54] We have surely set forth in this Quran every ˹kind of˺ examples for people, but human being is more argumentative than anything
Your Lord is He Who drives the ship for you through the sea, in order that you may seek of His Bounty. Truly! He is Ever Most Merciful towards you. (66) And when harm touches you upon the sea, those that you call upon besides Him vanish from you except Him (Allah Alone). But when He brings you safely to land, you turn away (from Him). And man is ever ungrateful (67) Al-Isra 17;66-67
[2:257] Allah is the guardian of those who believe. He brings them out of the darkness into the light; and (as to) those who disbelieve, their guardians are Shaitans who take them out of the light into the darkness; they are the inmates of the fire, in it they shall abide.
Aslm Brother. As a biologist myself, I hadn't actually thought of how the concept of evolution is essentially put into the minds of people as indoctrination until you pointed it out. Which is also interesting considering Darwin himself didn't consider the theory as anything against the existence of a Creator, yet everyone citing his theory (incorrectly) believes it is
That's because Darwin's theory is a propaganda tool to expand secularism. It starts with botany, then education, psychology, physiology and then the rest of the schools in philosophy. If you notice, every education system in the world teaches about Darwin theory as facts. Although it's not the truth. We are still fighting the proliferation of the theory because it's not facts. I think it's the same as how today LGBTQ studies are being spread.
@@nighteyes9512 yeah isn't from monkey, but we are from homo erectus, monkey and human are have common ancestors I am muslim believing in evolution doesn't make you disbelieve, even proto evolution was founded by muslim (al jahiz)
@@lilyrosesoul0077 In this very video, The host quotes Allah teaching Adam AS the names of things. If we know we are all the children of Adam AS, how do caveman that no language fit in all of this?? Evolution is nothing but an explanation that completely removes anything beyond the physical natural realm. Science and the human mind is limited.
@@levi_satoru2943 yeah man and i did not panic because it is mubah or haram i panicked because i scratched my head and Brother Muhammed said at the same time „for example scratching your head“ my face went like this 😳
When I first found his vid, I was like wow he's so harsh?.. But after I binge-watch lots of his vid and came across one statement that he put out, he said, debate need to be firm and he's debating, not giving soft talks. And I believe thats bcos ppl who seek him wanted to find faults so I believe he's answering them after a careful look of how the guest would approach. And he's got lots of knowledge, subhanAllah
We have to make him more famous..this brother deserves more recognition..simple worlds he knows how to explain the same message with different people that is a gift from Allah..as a revert he has helped me 100%
@@faheemahmed5786 It's not "what happens to god, it's what is the implication of NOT blessing people with Islam. Does it mean that god CHOOSES who will be blessed to be muslim and who will not?
بارك الله فيك اخ محمد... على الرغم من ان في كل مرة يتصل بك شخص ليتحدث عن موضوع مختلف اجدك تتعامل معه بهدوء و ثقة بالنفس عالية و تمطره بالحجج و البراهين التي لا ينكرها الا جاحد ..جعل كل اعمالك في ميزان حسناتك و حسنات والديك الكريمين
@@lucian8256Ali was one of the most respectful people I’ve had the chance to talk to, despite me and him disagreeing on basically anything, and me not being able to get some of my points across as well as I would’ve liked to, I really appreciate the space he gives us to explain our pov.
@@rasmus4236I think what he refers to was that he is often a bit quick to judge on certain aspects, almost defensively interrupting a point. While i have noticed that myself I really think he was extremely respectful despite knowing he’d disagree with me on essentially everything beforehand.
@gabrielescaramuzzo was that you on the video? Big respect to clap back on those who say Ali is disrespectful. On ur point about evolution I'd add that belief in God is NOT justified by evolution and since its innate, its very problematic for atheists to justify. Anyway, most of us Muslims appreciate ur manners and pray that you find the truth out of love and care for your well being as a brother in humanity ❤️
I don't understand these comments. I mean, may Allah accept your intentions but at least give the hadith behind it. Saying "May Allah reward you." Doesn't mean anything because there is already reported rewards for saying this. You don't have to make an extra dua for them to be rewarded. And the rewards are huge. Copy this 👇 and paste no problem. But at least explain the rewards so that people would actually do it knowingly, and you would cause them to learn a hadith while at it. "Whoever glorifies Allah (by saying Subhan-Allah) after every Salat (prayer) 33 times, and praises Allah (by saying Alhamdu-lillah) 33 times, and exalts Allah (by saying Allahu Akbar)33 times, those are ninety-nine in all, and says to complete a hundred: La ilaha ill-Allahu, wahdahu la sharika lahu, lahul-mulku wa lahulhamdu, wa Huwa 'ala kulli shai'in Qadir (There is nothing which deserves to be worshipped except Allah Alone Who has no partner; to Him belongs the kingdom, to Him praise is due, and He has power over everything), his sins will be forgiven, even if they are as abundant as the foam of the sea." [Reported by Muslim].
Brother Muhammad Ali why have these kind of titles for these videos if you’re doing Da’wah? Please don’t have such titles as ‘backfires’ etc because these people will watch your videos too again and we don’t want to sound as belittling them. And Allah Knows Best.
A kind heartly advice and so good manner at the end of this video. You are so blessed with sabr in this kind of conversation. I would have struggle to stay calm. Alhamduliilah amin
@@gabrielescaramuzzo I'm not the most knowledgeable I'm actually still learning myself but I'm willing to have a friendly discussion and help you find some resources for your research. also I'm a native Arabic speaker too so that might help ig :3
I must say to all the reverts, it must've been hard leaving everything youve been taught all your life and seek the truth, mashallah brothers and sisters may Allah continue to guide us ❤
It wasn't so much difficult as it was infuriating - and then scary, IMO. Infuriating because when I first opened the Quran and read it, I became angry because it relayed very clearly and directly some harsh truths about Jesus (as) and Christianity - and how Christians have been fooled and mislead by the church and the clergy (I was Christian at the time). Then as I continued to read more, continued to reference, and continued to verify the Quranic information and POV - it became awakening, mind-opening, awe-inspiring, and then scary - scary that it could actually be the truth. In the end it became very easy to accept though - all it took was for me to sincerely reach out to ask God: "God, if you truly exist - please show me a Sign - and whatever Truth that you show me, that is the Way that I will follow. Your Will - not mine". The Sign came shortly afterwards and I immediately became firm towards Islam. I took Shahada shortly after. IMO, this is what most other Christians fail to do: To search out and follow Truth - no matter where it leads. They are afraid to leave what they've been force-fed most of their lives......
@@gabrielescaramuzzoi know you don’t believe in Islam, but please don’t take this as a provocation. If a Muslim says „may Allah guide you to the right path“, it’s actually the biggest compliment you/someone can receive. You seem like an intelligent and good hearted human, I hope Allah guides you to the right path. Thank you for joining the discussion with the Muslim lantern, very kind of you to genuinely be interested and polite.
@@gabrielescaramuzzoI have a question for you,has your position changed since the vid is there anything you wanted to say in the vid but couldn’t id love to hear your full perspective
@@Special-Creature Oh I know It’s a compliment, and I appreciate it. What i was referring to is the comment about me thinking that islam is the same as every other religion, which is obviously not true.
*Following in the year 1396 AH, Rabita organized a book writing competition on Islamic Seerat-Un-Nabi. Many writers from different countries participated in this global competition with interest. Out of 171 manuscripts, the book 'Ar-Raheeq Al-Makhtum' won the first prize.*
Make dua for our brother Muhammed Ali for his great work and please support his channel and be a part of reward from Allah in sha Allah in this blessed month of Ramadan🤲🏼
Just like Babies, grow in water within the mother's stomach and once born if they immediately return to water (pool) they are comfortable but if they don't interact with water as they grow old, water becomes hard to get used to, and they develop phobias related to swimming and drowning. Likewise, babies are born with an innate knowledge of God but as they grow in an Atheist society they are far removed from God and the belief diminishes.
I see brother M.A Videos, I clicked Play and the Like 👍 button at the same time (bcoz I know things are about to go down) I sit back and enjoy the cooking 🧑🍳
Poor guy was too nervous to ask coherent questions. Atheists often cant defend their thought process because they’re so afraid of being proven wrong. May Allah guide this one
I really love how brother muhammad Ali doesn't beat around the bush ,just answers him directly, brief ,precise and concise ,❤the point the atheist, really sees this makes sense
I am crying while typing this message i request people to just give me some news or anything to comfort me about gaza will there be cease fire will they get food will they live a normal life again .. my heart is crying as no muslim country i mean none of the muslim country is doing anything for them except for barking like a scared dog thats it ... May Allah save gaza and Palestinians
Brother, Nothing can happen without the will of Allah, Remember everyone who was killed there are in paradise and the patient ones will be rewarded with paradise Inshallah, We must cry for ourselves because we are being tested as well, I make duaa for them everyday, but you must remember that Allah have more mercy than all of us ❤
@@nogag8219 What has history got to do with how they can help themselves now? You are deluded and stuck in the past to help the people in the present. I don't care who claims the land, btw, unlike Zionists. Givee the Palestinians the same rights as Israelis and take the whole land as one Israel, I know you won't don't want that, as you only care for genocide.
I have actually never watched a single mohamed hijab video, as i have found him to be a brainless, cloutseeking individual from a few debates that i have watched that he took part in. I distinctly remember Muhammed Ali making that argument on one of his videos on The Muslim Lantern channel, where he was responding to questions of people on the streets. I think the video is along the lines of “very clever atheist gets proven wrong” but i might be completely wrong about the wording. Either way that would not matter, despite the origin of the argument i still don’t find it convincing, if it wasn’t Ali who brought it up, then my fault was to ask him. As far as the mumbling goes, i was nervous due to this being my first time speaking in front of a large audience, and the fact that i was picked first in the livestream, and that caught me off guard and couldn’t mentally prepare as well.
@@gabrielescaramuzzo dude chill 😎. It was just my opinion, I must have misjudged. BTW, I myself mumbled many times, no issue there. Also, Mohd. Hijab is not that bad, he is also doing wonderful job spreading truth. May Allah preserve him. Anyways, philosophy is for brainless people, read into Islamic sources and do proper research, then come to conclusion. The trick is to ask the relevant questions and accept the truth when its presented. That's what we called sincerity. Food for thought!
@@gabrielescaramuzzo 😂. Its all good. I would recommend you to read into Islamic sources bro, do proper research. Leave philosophy, it does not befit a healthy mind. May Allah make it easy for you to accept the truth.
Icl Gabriel seems like a good guy overall. A little nervous and underprepared but I think he had some genuine interest in learning about Islam without any bad intentions.
Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah!
Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY
www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
شيخ محمد علي ارجو تفعيل خاصية الترجمة الى العربية جزاك الله خيرا
diskusinya kurang sehat, anda hanya bisa bermain dalam area pemikiran anda sendiri dan tidak berusaha berpikiran terbuka dengan menggunakan pendekatan sudut pandang lawan diskusi 😢
InshaAllah
WHY HAVE PE0PLE DECIDED THOSE TAWEEZ WITH QURAN VERSES ARE NOT SHIRK ❓
As we know asking the dead for help is SHIRK, If l was to claim asking the dead for help is not SHIRK because this dead person is going to ask ALLAH to help us, will the PEOPLE agree with this ❓ The answer is no, which is correct ✔
WHY DO WE USE A DIFFERENT RULE F0R THE TAWEEZ, BECAUSE THE POINT WAS USING TAWEEZ FOR HELP IS SHIRK ❓
*It is a logical absurdity to get all your morals from a being whose existence you cannot prove, I am not talking about God, I believe God exists, I am saying that there is no evidence in any Islamic scripture that Allah is God.*
I don't mean to be rude in this beautiful month of Ramadan, and trust me I have as much respect and love for Allah as Allah in my religion, however I will contest the Islamic moral view with logic and facts, because I believe it is my duty to oppose any ideology that leads to unnecessary suffering of innocents. With all due respect to Allah swt.
Allah swt made many claims in the Holy Qur'an about the material world that PROVES that Allah swt is NOT OMNISCIENT, BY EXTENSION NOT OMNIPOTENT AND NOT THE CREATOR. What are these claims?
Allah has a throne where the Sun goes to rest after a whole days running around the Earth (Qur'an 36:38 and Sahih Al Bukhari 3199).
Stars fall down when they die (81:2) quran.com/81
Stars are missiles to be thrown at rebellious devils and they are also ornamentary lamps to decorate the night sky (67:5) quran.com/67/5
The sky is a *solid canopy/ceiling with no holes in it* (Qur'an 2:22 and Qur'an 21:32)
These are a few claims among many others like it, that are proven to be demonstrably false through science, decades ago, to put it mildly. It is opposite to the well established truth.
Which proves Allah swt is not God. If he was, he wouldn't make such mistakes in such an important book to mankind. God is supposed to be omniscient and omnipotent, the author of the Holy Qur'an, who is allegedly God, is not, proven through these claims.
Now if you really have evidence that Allah is God, then give a logical rebuttal, but if you fail in doing so, then that is not what you truly believe. It is just a political excuse for you. Therefore it is a logical absurdity to get all your morals from Allah.
This is why liberalism (definition of which may vary but I have my own) and secular humanism is the only logical and rational basis for morality.
Im a revert from Italy, Alhamdulillah , 5 years!!!!!
M.sh sis
MashaAllah
Masha’ALLAH welcome home and all thanks to ALLAH(SWT), may Almighty always keep you under his protection, make you a light of guidance for others and reward you with all the best here and in the world after, Ameen
Mashallah ❤
MashaAllah tabarakAllah
Make dua for our brothers and sisters in Palestine 🤲
I humbly beseech The One Almighty God, The Most Merciful, The Most Just, The Most High, The All Knowing, to protect, raise and honour, all the oppressed peoples of the world and those who fight for them, and humiliate and crush the oppressors and those who stand with them, on this temporary Earth and in the eternal Hereafter.
hope they can be free and happy like us. hope they achieve peace and win. and no more fighting.
We all agree idol worship will remain shirk, even if we where to put Quran verses on an idol
We all agree reading Bismillah or reciting QURAN verses before eating pork will not make it halal
Why are we making TAWEEZ halal, by claiming it is a QURANIC AMULET ( TAWEEZ ) ❓
@thetruthwithproof8802
What are you talking about?
Masha'allah tabarakallah 🤲brother Muhammad May.Allah's Reward you Immensely And protect you and keep you safe and make you Greatest scholar the Muslim ummah Ameen 💜♥️
From Italy! I am originally from Italy too but we live in Switzerland with my parents, please make dua that they accept Islam too like I did AlhamduliLlah 💗
May The Creator guide this person to the right path!
Like always, thank you for your effort, may you be rewarded by Allah subhanahu wa taala in this life and in the next. 🇨🇭❤️🇵🇸
insha'ALLAH may ALLAH guide ur parents to islam and may ALLAH bless u too....
MashAllah, I'm a Swiss Muslim also, there is a lot of faith amongst the mountains of the Alps, alhamdulillah
Ameen.
Jazak Allahu Khayran BarakAllahu Feekum Alhamdulillahi rabbi al'alameen
@@abuzacharia01Ameen
Inshaallah sister.. May Allah guide your parents ❤
I feel bad for this guy. He's one of those guys going through life all alone without any role models. So he has too much time on his hands to be lost in his thoughts. May Allah (swt) guide him.
Ameen
May Allah guide him indeed. But no, I don't feel sorry for him. We all live in similar environment... it is not a cause for sympathy... first world problems my akhi.🤷🏻♂️
Ameen 🤲 😊
that's an incredible assumption you made there
@@lucian8256Understandable since this is a Muslim channel, you will see comments like that. If you go in a christian channel you will see same type of comments when someone doesnt agree with them. Life g.
I have watched hundreds of Muslim Lanterns videos. Every time I admire more Mohammad’s knowledge and sharp thinking.
@@lord.jesus.christ.followerWhy adam is not the son of god?
@lord.jesus.christ.follower, you left Islam and now believe that God has a son that he crucified for the all of Christians sins??? Sorry, but you are not a knowledgeable person whatsoever and so lost
@@lord.jesus.christ.follower Hello. I'm a muslim who recently started reading the bible just to become more knowledgable about other religions.
You said that Jesus Christ is the son of god who came to rescue us from hell. Okay, if the SON of god is so merciful that he wants to rescue his servants from hell, how come is the father (god) himself MUCH LESS merciful than the son?
I'm referring to this verse in the bible:
Genesis 3 Verses 14-16:
So the Lord God said to the serpent, “Because you have done this, “Cursed are you above all livestock and all wild animals! You will crawl on your belly and you will eat dust all the days of your life. 15And I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will crush your head, and you will strike his heel.” 16To the woman he said, “I will make your pains in childbearing very severe; with painful labor you will give birth to children. Your desire will be for your husband, and he will rule over you.”
Talk about a merciful god...
I would never want to worship a god that punishes me without giving me a second chance.
Also, your "All-powerful" god needed rest after creating the Heavens and the Earth, take a look at this verse.
Genesis 2 Verses 1-3:
Thus the heavens and the earth were completed in all their vast array. 2By the seventh day God had finished the work he had been doing; so on the seventh day he rested from all his work. 3Then God blessed the seventh day and made it holy, because on it he rested from all the work of creating that he had done.
And this is literally in the first 3 pages of the bible. Imagine how many errors i can find if I read the whole bible!
Return back to Islam brother. Leave this religion where you associate partners with Allah swt. I pray to Allah swt that he guides both you and I and all the brothers and sisters reading this comment.
@@lord.jesus.christ.followeroh you are ex muslim???? Then let me ask you a question!!! How many rakaah in wudu while you are performing al Fatiha???
@@lord.jesus.christ.follower Former Muslim? How many Hajj do you do in Zakat?
This guy is humble and respectful. May Allah guide him to the right path.
Nah, he aint respectful, it was only on livestream, we can see him bashing Ali here on comments
He's naive
Surely those who disbelieve, it being alike to them whether you warn them, or do not warn them, will not believe.
@@abdullaa7281 where is he in the comments?
@NaseerZaid-ou2ou someone named gabriel something, he making excuses for his inability to look smart while simultaneously trying to paint Ali as the one who misunderstood and have not answered his questions. In reality though he lacks basic understanding of speech of what Ali mentioned and how his argument amounts to insanity on his part and yet refuses to see it as he is too full of himself.
I‘m a revert from Germany!❤
Congrats brother< I'm asking Allah to give you the knowledge, patience and guid you closer to Himself and Heaven. Finally i would like to share this verse from Qur'an:
Surah Al-Furqan vs 70
As for those who repent, believe, and do good deeds, they are the ones whose evil deeds Allah will change into good deeds. For Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
إِلَّا مَن تَابَ وَءَامَنَ وَعَمِلَ عَمَلًۭا صَـٰلِحًۭا فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ يُبَدِّلُ ٱللَّهُ سَيِّـَٔاتِهِمْ حَسَنَـٰتٍۢ ۗ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ غَفُورًۭا رَّحِيمًۭا
MashaAllah
BarakaAllah
Mat Allah make things easy for you
Alhumdulillah
Islam is spreading everywhere with incredible rate, welcome to Islam brother 😊
He created man from a sperm-drop; then at once, he is a clear adversary. Al Kitab 16:4
This absolutely blows my mind...
@borsalinokizaru9862 Exactly ! Very dangerous mindset. Reaks of arrogance and disobedience.
(وَلَقَدۡ صَرَّفۡنَا فِی هَـٰذَا ٱلۡقُرۡءَانِ لِلنَّاسِ مِن كُلِّ مَثَلࣲۚ وَكَانَ ٱلۡإِنسَـٰنُ أَكۡثَرَ شَیۡءࣲ جَدَلࣰا)
[Surat Al-Kahf 18:54]
We have surely set forth in this Quran every ˹kind of˺ examples for people, but human being is more argumentative than anything
Allah does not even know where sperm is generated from. It is a fake allah
Your Lord is He Who drives the ship for you through the sea, in order that you may seek of His Bounty. Truly! He is Ever Most Merciful towards you. (66) And when harm touches you upon the sea, those that you call upon besides Him vanish from you except Him (Allah Alone). But when He brings you safely to land, you turn away (from Him). And man is ever ungrateful (67) Al-Isra 17;66-67
[2:257] Allah is the guardian of those who believe. He brings them out of the darkness into the light; and (as to) those who disbelieve, their guardians are Shaitans who take them out of the light into the darkness; they are the inmates of the fire, in it they shall abide.
Aslm Brother. As a biologist myself, I hadn't actually thought of how the concept of evolution is essentially put into the minds of people as indoctrination until you pointed it out. Which is also interesting considering Darwin himself didn't consider the theory as anything against the existence of a Creator, yet everyone citing his theory (incorrectly) believes it is
That's because Darwin's theory is a propaganda tool to expand secularism. It starts with botany, then education, psychology, physiology and then the rest of the schools in philosophy. If you notice, every education system in the world teaches about Darwin theory as facts. Although it's not the truth. We are still fighting the proliferation of the theory because it's not facts.
I think it's the same as how today LGBTQ studies are being spread.
Evolution is process. The Creator created this process. As a muslim there is no conflict in believing that evolution came from God.
@@lilyrosesoul0077 but the thing is that evolution isn't true. humans did not evolve from monkeys
@@nighteyes9512 yeah isn't from monkey, but we are from homo erectus, monkey and human are have common ancestors
I am muslim believing in evolution doesn't make you disbelieve, even proto evolution was founded by muslim (al jahiz)
@@lilyrosesoul0077 In this very video, The host quotes Allah teaching Adam AS the names of things. If we know we are all the children of Adam AS, how do caveman that no language fit in all of this??
Evolution is nothing but an explanation that completely removes anything beyond the physical natural realm. Science and the human mind is limited.
Guy wasn't ready for this discussion 😂 May Allah guide this brother.
admittedly i wasn’t expecting to be going first in the livestream lol so i wasn’t mentally ready for the discussion
You can't disprove 1+1=2 if you were given an eternity to prepare 😉 good luck man@@gabrielescaramuzzo
@@ayyubjackson hahahah of course man! It always depends on who’s defending the 1+1 side ;)
@@gabrielescaramuzzoYou were a respectful individual brother, don’t be too harsh on yourself and May Allah guide you to the Truth.
@@gabrielescaramuzzofratello apprezzo la tua curiosità che Allah ti guidi
As Brother Muhammed said scratching your head, I simultaneously scratched my head. 🤣🤣 I panicked for little bit.
lmao..by mubah he just meant normal things that is neither virtuous nor sinister..i can see you already got a troll comment😂😂
@@levi_satoru2943 yeah man and i did not panic because it is mubah or haram i panicked because i scratched my head and Brother Muhammed said at the same time „for example scratching your head“ my face went like this 😳
Stop these non sense
@@staingun20 ohh😆
😂
Watching from a fellow Muslim from Norway 🇳🇴
Alhamdulillah
All praise belong to Allah.
Emaddd! I still remember you from the good old days, an OG goat, great to see you here brotha ❤️
@@EmadGGs W emad
When I first found his vid, I was like wow he's so harsh?.. But after I binge-watch lots of his vid and came across one statement that he put out, he said, debate need to be firm and he's debating, not giving soft talks. And I believe thats bcos ppl who seek him wanted to find faults so I believe he's answering them after a careful look of how the guest would approach. And he's got lots of knowledge, subhanAllah
exact same journey with me!
And then ? He is respectful person and he is giving good dawah
You r such an amazing person brother mashaAllah...May Allah bless u ❤️❤️ love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️
We have to make him more famous..this brother deserves more recognition..simple worlds he knows how to explain the same message with different people that is a gift from Allah..as a revert he has helped me 100%
support dawah by become members
Pray for brother Muhammad Ali. May Allah bless him every day more and more.
Ameen ❤
Amin
Alhumulillah for being a Muslim. Can’t thank Allah SWT enough for this blessing.
If that's true, then it also implies that Allah is involved NOT blessing some people with Islam. How do you reconcille that?
@@iiddrrii6051 What would happen to God if He didn't bless some of His creations? 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@faheemahmed5786 It's not "what happens to god, it's what is the implication of NOT blessing people with Islam.
Does it mean that god CHOOSES who will be blessed to be muslim and who will not?
@@iiddrrii6051 What if God did such things? 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@faheemahmed5786 Then is salvation arbitrary?
A really nice conversation, wish every conversation were like this
JazakAllahu khair brother
Admiration and love from Ethiopia love ur contents ..always learning ❤
የሚገርም ልህ ነው በአላህ አላህ ይጠብቀው
@@openmindethiopia6653Ameen😊
Love your videos from Somalia 🇸🇴
بارك الله فيك اخ محمد... على الرغم من ان في كل مرة يتصل بك شخص ليتحدث عن موضوع مختلف اجدك تتعامل معه بهدوء و ثقة بالنفس عالية و تمطره بالحجج و البراهين التي لا ينكرها الا جاحد ..جعل كل اعمالك في ميزان حسناتك و حسنات والديك الكريمين
He is respectful may Allah guide him
Ameen
Cant say the same about Ali
@@lucian8256Ali was one of the most respectful people I’ve had the chance to talk to, despite me and him disagreeing on basically anything, and me not being able to get some of my points across as well as I would’ve liked to, I really appreciate the space he gives us to explain our pov.
@@rasmus4236I think what he refers to was that he is often a bit quick to judge on certain aspects, almost defensively interrupting a point. While i have noticed that myself I really think he was extremely respectful despite knowing he’d disagree with me on essentially everything beforehand.
@gabrielescaramuzzo was that you on the video? Big respect to clap back on those who say Ali is disrespectful. On ur point about evolution I'd add that belief in God is NOT justified by evolution and since its innate, its very problematic for atheists to justify. Anyway, most of us Muslims appreciate ur manners and pray that you find the truth out of love and care for your well being as a brother in humanity ❤️
If you read this;
Say "SubhanAllah" 33x
Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x
Say "Allahu akbar" 34x
May Allah reward you.
I don't understand these comments. I mean, may Allah accept your intentions but at least give the hadith behind it. Saying "May Allah reward you." Doesn't mean anything because there is already reported rewards for saying this. You don't have to make an extra dua for them to be rewarded. And the rewards are huge. Copy this 👇 and paste no problem. But at least explain the rewards so that people would actually do it knowingly, and you would cause them to learn a hadith while at it.
"Whoever glorifies Allah
(by saying Subhan-Allah) after every Salat (prayer) 33 times,
and praises Allah (by saying Alhamdu-lillah) 33 times,
and exalts Allah (by saying Allahu Akbar)33 times,
those are ninety-nine in all, and says to complete a hundred: La ilaha ill-Allahu, wahdahu la sharika lahu, lahul-mulku wa lahulhamdu, wa Huwa 'ala kulli shai'in Qadir (There is nothing which deserves to be worshipped except Allah Alone Who has no partner; to Him belongs the kingdom, to Him praise is due, and He has power over everything),
his sins will be forgiven, even if they are as abundant as the foam of the sea." [Reported by Muslim].
beautifully put and concluded. pray that this brother will soon be blessed with islam. ramadhan karim brother n sisters
Brother Muhammad Ali why have these kind of titles for these videos if you’re doing Da’wah? Please don’t have such titles as ‘backfires’ etc because these people will watch your videos too again and we don’t want to sound as belittling them. And Allah Knows Best.
I hope he sees your comment
Agreed 💯
I'm pretty sure he got consent
He is telling the true incident which happened during the talk which gives the viewers what they will be watching rather than sugarcoating.
For sour
A kind heartly advice and so good manner at the end of this video. You are so blessed with sabr in this kind of conversation. I would have struggle to stay calm. Alhamduliilah amin
Allahumma Barik Fik brother.... May Allah reward u for this.... really love ur videos...
Ameen
بارك الله أخي محمد وجزاك الله خيرا❤
M.A never missed me of learning Islam deeper. He is really knowledgeable than his age.
Me: UA-cam is okay yet. Let me go offline.
Muhammad Ali: Uploads a video.
Me: yay! Last one. Clicks!!! ❤
جزاك الله خيرا وبارك الله فيك
Thank you for handling his concerns genuinely. I can see that he is curious but unsure about where to begin
May Allah guide you brother Gabriele and let you see the clarity of Islam.
تقبل الله صيامكم
I hope he see's the discussion for what it is and then does the proper research. May ALLAH SWT guide him . Ameen Ameen Ameen
I feel he asks questions. But it feels like he doesn't want to listen to the answers
I cant skipped ur post my brother❤❤❤❤
May Almighty Allah reward Muhammad Ali and bless him. This brother is so knowledgeable
Gabrielle seems very polite and sincere. May Allah guide him.
thank you so much :)
@@gabrielescaramuzzo ♥️♥️♥️
@@gabrielescaramuzzoYoooo it’s Gabriel. Do you need anything additional to know more about Islam?
@@uta9944 hahahah i still have countless questions that i was no able to ask Ali due to time reasons, If you would like i’d love to ask you :)
@@gabrielescaramuzzo I'm not the most knowledgeable I'm actually still learning myself but I'm willing to have a friendly discussion and help you find some resources for your research. also I'm a native Arabic speaker too so that might help ig :3
May Allah guide us all to the straight path Ameen
Ameen
امين يارب
Masha Allah, Brother Mohammad Ali is so knowledgeable for his age. May Allah help him spread the message of Islam more and more
Always looking forward to your video Akhi, I learn every time Alhumdullilah
Thanks
I must say to all the reverts, it must've been hard leaving everything youve been taught all your life and seek the truth, mashallah brothers and sisters may Allah continue to guide us ❤
It wasn't so much difficult as it was infuriating - and then scary, IMO. Infuriating because when I first opened the Quran and read it, I became angry because it relayed very clearly and directly some harsh truths about Jesus (as) and Christianity - and how Christians have been fooled and mislead by the church and the clergy (I was Christian at the time). Then as I continued to read more, continued to reference, and continued to verify the Quranic information and POV - it became awakening, mind-opening, awe-inspiring, and then scary - scary that it could actually be the truth. In the end it became very easy to accept though - all it took was for me to sincerely reach out to ask God:
"God, if you truly exist - please show me a Sign - and whatever Truth that you show me, that is the Way that I will follow. Your Will - not mine".
The Sign came shortly afterwards and I immediately became firm towards Islam. I took Shahada shortly after. IMO, this is what most other Christians fail to do: To search out and follow Truth - no matter where it leads. They are afraid to leave what they've been force-fed most of their lives......
Mashallah one of my favorite videos
Alhamdulillah. May Allah guide all these lost people.
جزاك الله خيراً يا محمد
This comment is for support the channel thank you Mohammad Ali
see a video, click it. life is simple
😊
Alhamdulillah
Same
Same here ✋ 😊
Alhamdulillah 🎉
Beautiful. Simply beautiful. Let him go to the basis of his beliefs😀 and realize that he is brainwashed.
بارك الله فيكم
May Allah bless you brother Mohammed and your team.
Excellent video mashaAllah
Excellent Dawah mashaAllah tabarakAllah
I felt second hand embarrassment when he didn't even know the basics of evolution 😂 baraka allaho fik brother ali for these discussions
MashaAllah! brother Mohamed Ali, I ask Allah to protect you!
Hmmm I love the atheist it's always so interesting seeing them thinking that Islam is the same as other religions 😂
I dont understand, what about islam did i generalize on?
@@gabrielescaramuzzowas that you in the video
@@gabrielescaramuzzoi know you don’t believe in Islam, but please don’t take this as a provocation. If a Muslim says „may Allah guide you to the right path“, it’s actually the biggest compliment you/someone can receive.
You seem like an intelligent and good hearted human, I hope Allah guides you to the right path. Thank you for joining the discussion with the Muslim lantern, very kind of you to genuinely be interested and polite.
@@gabrielescaramuzzoI have a question for you,has your position changed since the vid is there anything you wanted to say in the vid but couldn’t id love to hear your full perspective
@@Special-Creature Oh I know It’s a compliment, and I appreciate it. What i was referring to is the comment about me thinking that islam is the same as every other religion, which is obviously not true.
Waiting for your new video everyday !!!! everytime I watch your videos the more i understand about my own religion Allahumdullillah !!
Supporting
I read Sealed Nectar. Very good❤
*Following in the year 1396 AH, Rabita organized a book writing competition on Islamic Seerat-Un-Nabi. Many writers from different countries participated in this global competition with interest. Out of 171 manuscripts, the book 'Ar-Raheeq Al-Makhtum' won the first prize.*
جزاك الله خيرا
Make dua for our brother Muhammed Ali for his great work and please support his channel and be a part of reward from Allah in sha Allah in this blessed month of Ramadan🤲🏼
MashAllah sister very good idea.
Alhamdulillah...awesome video as always from my brother Muhammad Ali. May Allah SWT guide this young man to the right path.
He seems really confused, may Allah guide him
Jazakom Allah khair
جزاك اللهُ خيرًا بارك الله فيك أحبك في الله أخي يهديكم الله و يصلح بالكم تقبل الله منا ومنكم بأمان الله آمين يارب العالمين
Highlight of the day
Just like Babies, grow in water within the mother's stomach and once born if they immediately return to water (pool) they are comfortable but if they don't interact with water as they grow old, water becomes hard to get used to, and they develop phobias related to swimming and drowning. Likewise, babies are born with an innate knowledge of God but as they grow in an Atheist society they are far removed from God and the belief diminishes.
ua-cam.com/users/shortsmqMnsIUJmVY?si=UjdISBSoHWDKygV7
بارك الله فيك ✨
I’ll take first.
Also JazakumAllahu khair for the video
May ALLAH SWT increase your knowledge even more and mine as well, I am learning a lot from you Akhi
Alhamdulillah! I ❤ Islam and may Allah guide more people to Islam.
Great nd informative
I see brother M.A Videos, I clicked Play and the Like 👍 button at the same time (bcoz I know things are about to go down)
I sit back and enjoy the cooking 🧑🍳
MashaAllah brother very good video
I am amazed at your patience n knowledge brother MA. May Allah bless you n protect you always.
I love this channel. May Allah reward him. ameen
May Allah guide this person to truth😊.
May Allah reward you
He mistook Bro Muhammad Ali with Bro Zishan.
Exactly, the terms mentioned are mostly used by Zeeshan, Hijab and Ali Dawah etc
Nice discussion
Poor guy was too nervous to ask coherent questions. Atheists often cant defend their thought process because they’re so afraid of being proven wrong.
May Allah guide this one
Masha’Allah
Honest guy mashallah
May Allah guide him.
MaShaAllah
Allahumma Barik brother❤
Jazakanlah heiran bro Ali
JazakAllahu khair
Dude seems just like me, has that full of curiosity mentality but kinda lazy to read books 😅
lmfao cant deny that for sure
He looks like a nice guy . First time i see an athiest who doesn't curse and hate Muslims !!!
@@Hassenfeki I know this is out of the blue, but I hope you got your employment issues resolved ❤️
@@vibz8346 how do u know that ?!
Gazak Allah khair
I really love how brother muhammad Ali doesn't beat around the bush ,just answers him directly, brief ,precise and concise ,❤the point the atheist, really sees this makes sense
I am crying while typing this message i request people to just give me some news or anything to comfort me about gaza will there be cease fire will they get food will they live a normal life again .. my heart is crying as no muslim country i mean none of the muslim country is doing anything for them except for barking like a scared dog thats it ...
May Allah save gaza and Palestinians
Brother, Nothing can happen without the will of Allah, Remember everyone who was killed there are in paradise and the patient ones will be rewarded with paradise Inshallah, We must cry for ourselves because we are being tested as well, I make duaa for them everyday, but you must remember that Allah have more mercy than all of us ❤
Well Palestinians don't want to help themselves.
@@nogag8219 You seem to know how they can help themselves more than they do. Will you declare yourself as the Prophet next?
@@TalEdds you don't know much history, do you?
@@nogag8219 What has history got to do with how they can help themselves now? You are deluded and stuck in the past to help the people in the present.
I don't care who claims the land, btw, unlike Zionists. Givee the Palestinians the same rights as Israelis and take the whole land as one Israel, I know you won't don't want that, as you only care for genocide.
It’s the “aha” for me after every word ahaha
Another video alhamdulilah!
Masha Allah!❤
He was not prepared. He already made up his mind and watching too much Mohd Hijab video, made him mumbling while asking question.
yes his informations about causations and necessary being are from the brother mohammed hijab 😊
I have actually never watched a single mohamed hijab video, as i have found him to be a brainless, cloutseeking individual from a few debates that i have watched that he took part in.
I distinctly remember Muhammed Ali making that argument on one of his videos on The Muslim Lantern channel, where he was responding to questions of people on the streets.
I think the video is along the lines of “very clever atheist gets proven wrong” but i might be completely wrong about the wording.
Either way that would not matter, despite the origin of the argument i still don’t find it convincing, if it wasn’t Ali who brought it up, then my fault was to ask him.
As far as the mumbling goes, i was nervous due to this being my first time speaking in front of a large audience, and the fact that i was picked first in the livestream, and that caught me off guard and couldn’t mentally prepare as well.
@@gabrielescaramuzzo dude chill 😎. It was just my opinion, I must have misjudged. BTW, I myself mumbled many times, no issue there.
Also, Mohd. Hijab is not that bad, he is also doing wonderful job spreading truth. May Allah preserve him.
Anyways, philosophy is for brainless people, read into Islamic sources and do proper research, then come to conclusion. The trick is to ask the relevant questions and accept the truth when its presented. That's what we called sincerity. Food for thought!
@@TheSadidaddy I didnt mean to come across as rude btw, just wanted to clarify a few things hahah
@@gabrielescaramuzzo 😂. Its all good.
I would recommend you to read into Islamic sources bro, do proper research. Leave philosophy, it does not befit a healthy mind.
May Allah make it easy for you to accept the truth.
May Allah increase your wisdom and patience brother.
Icl Gabriel seems like a good guy overall. A little nervous and underprepared but I think he had some genuine interest in learning about Islam without any bad intentions.