Where Does The Money Go?: Ammar H Khan, Miftah Ismail Talk Taxes, NFC Award, Debt | Pakistan Economy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 чер 2024
- What's Pakistan's biggest problem? For Miftah Ismail, former finance minister, it's excessive spending. Watch Ammar H Khan interview Miftah Ismail about Awam Pakistan's economic plans, the country's spending, and revenue generation. The former minister insists that revising the NFC award is need of the hour.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dawn News English is your window into the latest news, insight, and features from South Asia and beyond.
Official Facebook: / dawndotcom
Official Twitter: / dawn_com
Website: www.dawn.com
Official Instagram: / dawnnewsenglish
#pakistan #miftahismail #pakistaneconomy #economy #financenews #business #businessnews #finance #economiccrisis #debt
#news #latestnews #dawnnewsenglish #dawnnews
Total revenue. 18000 bn pkr
To provinces : 7500
Interest Amt. : 9700
Balance. : 800
With this 800 bn pkr Pakistan has to keep its body and soul together for entire year!
Please u don't worry what pakistan has to keep or not..
@@SulemanAbbas-jp3im this year the interest payment is 9700 bn pkr. You know next year what going to be that figure?
11000 bn pkr!
Sure u would not like to listen to us.
@@sanjithkmemon8525 dear this is not new for this mafia laden estate
@@sanjithkmemon8525yes they don’t want to face this harsh bitter reality 😅 what can u expect from this banana republic corrupt nation 😂 duaoo pay chalney walli kaum kaa yahee harsh hotaa hain
They were not the part of corrupt government??
Nothing in Pakistan will change.pak military has to sell all fauji foundation companies and get out of DHA and leave the market to competition then only pak will change No one will have monopoly
Your strategy is based on assumption that election commission will be unbiased and fair elections will be conducted. This is not the case, you have to get approval from establishment before you get elected. No matter how much cable person you bring.
Miftah is an intellectually dishonest lad. He had done and will also do Nothing but just talking the talks.
Just imagine his political Role Model were (and i think is ) Nawaz and Shahbaz Sharifs.
Under the Sharifs era he did each and every heinous crime, bad political maneuvers to fail Imran Khan govt at the cost of destruction of Pakistan's economy and even never regretted for his deeds.
And ironically now the pain for Pakistan is rattling in his stomach
And that baggage is enough for him to carry the rest of the life.
Its rightly said A man is remembered by his company.
Politics should be the business of straight right honest people and unfortunately he isn't that kind of person
I think this establishment’s another backup plan if Nawaz/Zardari/Asim failed then they put them as a front man.
pakistanis be like : Humen dushman ke bachhon ko padhaana tha. Iss liye hum apne bachhon ko nahi padhate. LOL.
Generals have to go back to barracks and stop interfering in election communion judiciary and Beauracracy
Again this party is launched at the behest of our conspiring establishment.
He talking all Abt big dreams of education health etc . Biggest question with future finance minister is abt maths , i.e. where will the money come from ?? With GDP is 350 billion tax collections r according to that , even there PPL who have Clawed Pakistan for their benifit never will give taxes . So u just tell how will u increase the revenue .
Expenditure is most easy as u will increase the revneue Fojis will instantly increase the defence budget too citing rise in indian budget and marking it as most important sector
Misgovernance is not that big of a problem in reality ,
It's madness for Pakistan to try to match Indian military spending when almost half of entire Pakistan population are living in poverty. India is currently spending over 83 billion dollars a year in their military and this budget is expected to double over the next 10 years to 160 billion dollars a year as India's GDP doubles to 7 trillion dollars in the next ten years. If Pakistan tries to match that, then the majority of Pakistanis will live in poverty
Please stop the God Damn music in the Background...
you're right, music is haraam. Any Muslim who listens to music will go to Jahannam. That's why I stopped listening
@@sachinnair91Pajitroll
I agree with Miftah on the fact of the matter
Papistan …… made for elites 😂😂
A sincere request to Dawn New English to please invite Economist Dr Kaiser Bengali on the show. His insights on these questions will be valuable.
Remove music please it's very annoying
All the best. sir. Nothing attempted, nothing gained.
Good news is that Putin sir offered Gun doom to Sharif ji in recent meeting to meet urgent needs
Can u please remove the music in the videos. It’s not really relevant for a podcast.
I agree and the music is haraam
No suffering economy has advanced by heavily taxing its middle class
Funny. The first question should be what does the “establishment “ as you guys call euphemistically think about this? That’s pretty much is the crux of the issue. Circumventing that central question is understandable but not going to solve the Pakistans issue.
Please remove music from the background it's very annoying
@Ammar H khan (host) you are a well reelected and renowned economist why did you point out the private education scheme that Miftah mentioned. It would have takken 15 seconds for you fugure it out. They wanted Pakistan to be in trap and you were quite ?
Rule of fair law and intervention in judiciary is the main problem
We need reforms in judiciary , defence , agencies and rest goes afterwards
Remove the background music wtf is that for?
Dr. Miftah Ismail, you are really talking sense and you can bring about a change with your political aspirations. My biggest regret with you is that being a capable person, why did you join PML(N), the bunch of corrupt, incapable buffoons!
one idea to invite fdi could be by framing a law to assure fdi investors that their profits or certain percent of it would be ring fenced and repatriable or allow it to be deposited in overseas banks. if you really want then you can always guarantee potential investors. you have to show that you mean business and next govt or military will not change this soon after.
Imran khan is vision of Pakistan honest politician for Pakistan
How about forming a group of intellectuals, popular and not popular, but able and credible, to create awareness among people to influence government policies and decisions!
Except Punjab , most of the examinations are compromised
What’s the guarantee that parents will spend the voucher on their child’s education and not just spend themselves?
It is somewhat same as sehatcard, and sehatcard was exploited by private hospitals! Also, leaving public sector hospitals in their current state, where doctors complete their training and are future consultants, is a bad investment in the future!
The idea should be to improve basic structure and not outsourcing to private sector.
Also, if you keep ignoring the standard and conditions of doctors in training, they will continue to leave Pakistan.
Discourse needs to be changed enough of political parties and politicians should be about people and issues
Guess Dr Hoodbhoy should be consulted
I will be your first voter from lhr ❤❤❤
Yahan hakumat ko 5 saal pooray hi nahi karnay detay
Thugs mafia
To iski party pakistani fauj ke boot nahi chategi? Kaali vigo, Enforced Disappearance. OK, Bye.
My first impression for Mr. Mufta Ismail to Indian actor Mr. Ahead Warsi resemblance .
Honestly I'm investing my time and money in crypto now because this new price is a clear sign for new investors to come in
Ye banda Pakistan me baithkar accent maar raha hai.. Kaun se audience hain bhai udhar.. Irony
This is a tribal society. Khans will vote for Khan in KPK.Ranas will vote😊 R
Invest in Bitcoin before retiring by diversifying across assets, allocating a small portion of your portfolio, staying updated on market trends, and considering long-term holding to balance risk and growth...
I recently sold half my tech stock holdings due to all-time highs, leaving me with $400k. Should I invest in ETFs now or wait for a market correction considering potential inflation?
9:25 5000 rupees per child per month?
Where you will get that much money?
That's the money that the government spends on educating a child through the public system already.
bekaar hi Pakistani inferiority complex mein pade rehte hain - India mein jitne unicorn nahin hain pakistan mein utne past, present aur future prime ministers hain - what a vibrant democracy
If education is privatized people with money i.e. those in government will do following, and this includs Miftah (he is industrialist).
1: Create a chain of profite schools
2: Get them regulated by government
3: Charge 5000 per kid to government
4: Provide sub par quality of education and hire cheepest teachers possible
5: regulators will not touch you because you are sitting in government
6: Spend 2500/kid on providing education and rest is your profit which is 50%
Profit per year = no of the childrens that got enrolled × 50% × 5000/kid
7: force government to increase the price per kid otherwise threaten them with closing schools.
This is a huge trap in which Maftah wants Pakistan to get in. The education mechanism he is talking about will create people with power and money more rich. Government will take money in the form kf tax from poor and will pay it to rich as 5000/kid.
its not gonna work like the way you said
there would be good competition that would allow parents to take there kids to other school which they find better
voucher system is most perfect easy to work with
also provincial government can held NTS like computerize tests to check kids progress and by investing in NTS to use AI technology to check these tests
@@yetoha-fv7qs Initially there will be competition but soon competing schools will sit together and will create a monopoly and will blackmail government, to increase the cost per child.
Private school only exists to create more and more profit, they dont care about quality of education, national service etc.
Regarding NTS, you have boards to check the progress of kids, you can make them efficient.
He is economist ND Pakistan have few economist in PhD
True >50 will fail even Asistant Prof..
On education, I would say we have to look around the private educational system of our country. Even a private school at the corners of our streets are way better than the public schools at the centers of our cities. why so? The thing that I personally went through is the factor of responsibility. When a parent spends his\her money on children from their pocket, they want returns on their money. And those returns are ensured by a constant fear in the minds of school administrations of losing the income if they fail to ensure the expectations of parents. Here the parents as well as teachers own the responsibility of the education of children. Whereas in the case of public schools, parents consider government, that a third party, responsible for the education of their children, and teachers, having no fear whatsoever of losing the income as the government employ them on permanent basis as well as the absence of any supervision, make them tardy eventuating in the disruption of education. The suggestion hidden in this experience is that the government should provide parents with money required for the education of their children instead of institutions which after their establishment disappear from the administration of our state.
So bloody funny.. How can you set right your Agriculture sector when you haven't done its first necessitating step and apparently do not have the will to pursue it either. Land Reforms..
As long no solution about generals power hunger , generals fauji corporation as long no political party will be able to govern . Control this generals militia then think about politics & isdues
Without Imran khan nothing going to change
Pakistan army robeing Pakistan
what you want to show to the world by speaking english. it won"t change anything
👏🏼
Show's host is so dull and expressionless.
Changing our thinking doesn’t mean anything, what we need is empowered local government that raise their own taxes and spend local money locally , provinces need to send money down stream. Local bodies election should be normalised and getting rid of overpaid bureaucrats who do nothing but waste state resources for their own enjoyment., Abolish this AC, DC Bullshit
Either Miftah is missinformed or he is on some agenda.
Strongly disagree with education policy.
1: You are planing on having a regulating authority that will regulate private schools and our childrens can goto those private school. How do you make sure that regulator will be un corruptable. Rather use your energy, time money on making the existing system more efficient.
2: By privatizing education you will create a monster. It will be matter of time before private schools will create a monopoly and will threaten government on increasing the cost of education or they will close schools. Private equity will capture schools and will run it as a for profit business. Government will be constantly blackmailed and this will be irreversible process. Real world example is American private health care system, hospitals charge private citizens ridiculous amount of money for basic needs.
you're spot on! Many millions of poor Americans without health insurance are terrified of getting sick because they don't want to get huge $500,000 medical bill for 1-2 month hospital stay, not joking!
Couldn't the government just nationalise private schools if they try to hold them hostage in this hypothetical scenario?
@@waleedabbas4996 nationalization will be highly unlikely, because people in government will be the ones who will be getting benefit from this system.
Real time example is sugar cartel , these are the people who are sitting in government and they gives subside to their own industries, each political party has people who benefits from it, and there is a silent consensus among them not to touch sugar mafia. There is no way sugar industry will be nationalized.
@@AbdulHannan-uv6ym Sugar is a non-essential good, you can just tax/remove subsidies but I get your larger point. The incentive structures in this case are extremely susceptible.
Side note, I also don't think public education can realistically improve in the short to medium term.
@@waleedabbas4996 agree it will difficult task but still doable.
Khaam khyal electable traficing service agency?
Another failed fouj project.
shame on both. Being a Pakistani and trying to support the lower or New Ppls in politics, Giving you idea in English instead of a clear and concise Language which is urdu.
I think you should do like khutba alala abad like allama iqbal that deliver khutba in english instead of urdu. We are Pakistan and we have our language if you are ashamed of following it then you are all just drama
He hilmself a big drama
Miftah just bulshit. When you are in government your every stance is totally different. You Miftah gave freehand to banks to loot 100 bn rupees from business men when you set rate of USD 248 for LCs and market rate was 228. Shame on you
Another bunch of liers
Lot of bullshit .
fv
People are only with imran khan
(مشکوات کتاب العلم)
علما، آسمان کے نیچے بد ترین مخلوق ہونگے۔ (رسول صعلم کا فرمان)
PAKISTAN KA ASLI DUSHMAN.... QURAN 👍
Visa lagao aur jan churao
Wow the two most boring people on earth
boring? watch the video properly with open mind, some very important topics was discussed and Miftah is clearly a very smart handsome man
fv