Do you buy Keir Starmer's claim that this is the end of 'noisy politics'? | LBC debate
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 сер 2024
- Matthew Wright reacts to the fallout from yesterday's general election, where Keir Starmer was announced Prime Minister following a Labour landslide.
In a speech outside Number 10, Keir Starmer vowed that this is the end of an era for 'noisy performance politics'. Matthew Wright asks listeners, Do you buy his statement?
0:00 Matthew Wright recounts yesterday's events
5:00 'Boring can be a pretty attractive thing right now', says editor Tim Ross
9:28 Caller Harry and Matthew Wright debate over immigration
13:08 The Labour Party is 'doomed to fail', says caller David
16:46 Keir Starmer's politics are 'uncharismatic', says caller Nick
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#matthewwright #keirstarmer #labour #labourlandslide #primeminister #news #ukpolitics #generalelection #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
I'll take a serious, dull, competent PM, over a charismatic, self serving, cheating liar
Think we have a dull cheating liar.
Ask Old Mr Corbyn MP
Let's hope Starmer doesn't turn out to be a serious, dull, competent, self serving cheating liar. I wish him well, but I can never forget that above anything else, he's a politician.
Serious politics rather than populism any day. Service, not sound bites.
@@VincentLeSabre
So you want DePfiffel 2.0?
How did that work out for those that died while he partied?
For the state security risk MI5 said he posed while he partied with putler oligarchs and flunkies after the Skripal poisoning where our citizens were killed on British soil, even putting the son of a KGB agent in our horse of lords.
How did that work out for the people of Afghanistan that helped the British army and were left to fend for themselves.
How did that work out for the millions of people who now have costs of living equivalent to 13 grand a year worse off than 14 years ago?
😂😂😂
Give your head a wobble!
So what have we had. Theresa May, nasty. Boris charismatic, incompetent. Truss no charisma, incompetent. Sunak no charisma, couldn't even bring an umberella to a rain storm. I'll take Starmer over all of them.
Look where Boris’s charisma got us.
Exactly
I don't understand how people think Johnson is charismatic.
I'm so bored of this whole Charisma debate
Who cares about charisma as long as our lives improve
What by voting a globalist into number 10?
Labour is despised by 80% as 4 in 5 refused to vote 4 Starmer. 80% of electorate are very scared of Labour & if remoaner corbynites fail to deport millions of criminals like Abdul Lawangeen, then voters will boot out Labour in huge numbers in approx 2028.
They won't
Downhill from here
They won’t
I don’t want charisma, just like I don’t want lies, gaslighting and corruption.
You will get it with starver
@@jimmymcdonald426 There is literally no evidence for that assertion.
My opinion ok have a nice day @@jonathanboam5409
Well that is exactly what you have now got! LIES , Gaslighting , corruption and much more!
lies starmer used to win the leadership. gaslighting over gaza. corruption from purging the left from labour and hijacking SNP motion day by threatening speaker of the house at the behest of his handlers, the israel lobby and ex tory donors.
I thought his speech was wonderful
@@VincentLeSabre "weak lack of testosterone delivery" - Jesus Christ this wins for worst comment of the day... Personally I thought Starmer's speech was fantastic - finally someone who is willing to try and bridge the divide, rather than make it bigger. This is what we need, not someone gloating that the other side lost, but someone who is willing to say to the people who didn't vote for him "you may not believe in me, but I will work until you do".
I was emotional during his speech.
Who wants testosterone and charisma. Give me someone who is serious about the enormity of the task in front of him. This, he acknowledged. He has proven that he has guts and stamina, proven by the changes he has wrought in Labour. He has taken them, in five year from nothing to winning the election. He will move forward slowly but surely.
@@VincentLeSabre The country is tired and just left an abusive relationship. He literally said that his priority is home building along with other things and as pointed out at 2:04 stocks in building companies have gone up because of it.
"didnt tell us what he plans to do", you didnt listen lol.
@@VincentLeSabre If you want Testosterone delivery, get on HRT. This is politics, not the locker room of the gym.
I prefer intelligence and hard work over dubious facts and “charisma” any day.
So do I
You assume because he hasn't any character that he will work hard for the people! wow!
@@James-872 no. I don’t assume that. They already appear to be cracking on even if you don't agree with what they are doing.
And look where "charismatic politics" got us
i agree this charmatic politics really started with Blair.
Look where an overwhelming majority got us, oh look another one....
So charisma Is Johnson, Farage and Trump is it. That's a no from me
Agreed - I’ll take my chances with boring and analytical thanks.
You voted a WEF puppet into power, a man who will continue shutting down farms, like the Tories did.
And gobby Gove
blair is the one most want the new new labour to emulate. are you saying you dont want a blair type again too?
@@Glasgow_kiss Where did I say that then? Oh yeh I didn't
I'd rather have boring politics than what we had before
Unfortunately Farage is going to try and bring back what we had before
FFS he’s only been PM 5 minutes give him a chance 🙄😜
I will take boring politicians who stay out of the headlines for nonsense if it means we have better lives. Charisma is overrated.
Something tells me that's not what we're going to get
Just give him chance for God's sake 5 mins in already being criticised
Totally agree!
I had forgotten how the Press goes after Labour governments! It’s been a while. He was made PM yesterday lunch, why hasn’t he solved everything yet?
The man is a globalist, just like the Tories. More farms being paid to closed, nothing is going to change.
@@VincentLeSabre they published a manifesto, I read it, it was definitely a manifesto. The press hammers the Labour party, and they will do as long as they are in power. Just watch the next week in the news cycle, when Starmer has had literally no time to get anything rolling, and see what the press has to say. As to the vagaries of the FPTP system, it’s strange how no-one gave a toss until the right-wing vote was split in the same way the left-wing vote has been for decades. I’m for PR, are you?
@@VincentLeSabre "They actually don't usually", even the press themselves openly admit they do lol. The reason why labour appear weak is because if a labour candidate sneezes, its heavily criticised and is front page news for days, meanwhile you literally had tory members performing heavy corruption and the press acted shocked when it got called out for not challenging that. Look at the bacon sandwich for proof lol.
Please bring back boring politics, the toxicity of the last 14 years has been unbearable!
Sounds like folks want a charismatic con man and not an actual politician in charge…….
Because those people don't really care about the country as long as they're alright.
Politicians don't need to be 'charismatic', they need to be *competent and trustworthy* when it comes to doing their job. Boring is just fine if it brings stability. Politics isn't supposed to be a soap-opera.
two things starmer lack as well. look at how poorly he does in polls. look at the lies he said to get the leadership and to get elected.
Keir won't have illegal parties, won't use his position for personal gain or have affairs. I also believe he will do his best for EVERYONE in the country and not just those who are rich. THAT is what is important here.
Boris treated the rules with the contempt they deserved. Imagine if this country had just got on with things? Rather than locking down?
We’d be in a lot better shape than we are now!
Thanks, that was funny.
@@gpw203 When did he have an illegal party? When has he used his position for personal gain? When has he had an affair?
@@peterholden3672 Imagine how much less pressure the NHS would be under now if that had happened? Government wouldn’t have had to have spent nearly as much as it did on keeping business afloat. It would have been better for the country in the long term.
@@gpw203what are you on about Keir is pretty clean at this point
I need a break from all the lies, corruption, deceit and gaslight from a club of gangsters.
Ummm, I hate to tell you this but..... nothing's changed!
@@Wang_Monkey It's only the third day of his premiership. Bit too early to call, isn't it?
We're all hoping politics isnt in the news much now because we'll be coasting along instead of creating culture wars
Amen to that
The left created culture wars and look how it's panning out in the US. They have a senile president and a VP that was picked to tick back xes. Neither will beat Donald j Trump.
Can you imagine having politics where the primary aim of our government is not to annoy people?
Hardly a ringing endorsement for Labour. 33% of the vote on a low turnout 😂
@@markgt894 it is ridiculous system, that a party can get 66% of the seats on 33% of the vote with a 60% turnout
That can work if we had single transfer vote, as they may be 1st for 33% but also second for 40%
That's the first step to more representative politics in the UK
So so tired of populism. Give me mundane sensible moderate politics any day of the week. Incrimental change and longterm thinking is what a country needs to improve.
That 2nd caller is the problem with this country he doesn't know anything about politics but fan boys so much over farage that he thinks he'd just solve everything so how.
That's how a lot of people vote unfortunately, you should vote for the party policies you agree with, not the individual.
Nigel Farage took over a brokerage firm in 2011, he drove it to insolvency within 3 years and wound up with tens of thousands of unpaid tax debt. The idea he could run a country is beyond a joke.
"I'm quite scared of Reform voters", is what he said. How does that sound like a farage fan boy?
Why are people complaining already its been 1 day so far
Have you ever been to the UK.
It's all the English ever do; moan and snipe from sidelines without ever offering any positive contribution.
Noisy politics... The thing is. Politics that WORKS is invisible. You never see it. Like the cogs in machinery. Nobody opens up an engine that works to pick it apart and find the faults.
Now contrast that to the US politics where they dont even have the ambition to govern and no longer have the ability to run an election without controversy anymore. Its easy to look at the american chaos. Where politics are all over social media and think "Politicians are all the same" and apply the same kind of extremism and hate to politicians over in the UK or Canada. -Even Australia.
"Country first, Party second" huge differentiator between him and the Tories if he can stand by it.
People are so dumb, they actually believe politicians.
@@leehighland5435 that's because we haven't had a politician who we can trust for so long...
@@EtharealBTB
Starmer said westminster or devos, he said devos, he is a globalist, he doesn't work for the UK.
@@leehighland5435 Inb4 you trust Farage.
“Why hasn’t labour fixed all the problems of the last 14 years already? Whaaaah!”
FFS 🤦🏽 🤷🏽♂️
No-one is saying that, pay more attention
As long as we have a government that actually get on with their job with a half decent moral compass the country should improve from where we have been recently.
You're deluded, the UK voted a globalist in. Net zero means the shutting down of all the farms. It's already happening in europe. Starmer will carry on with that agenda.
I agree with the first caller that we need to take immigration off of the cards but it's not by embracing the right wing it's by making it a non-issue. Process aslyum claims then there will be no hotel use, have a process centre in france and there will be no boats. Increase training in the Uk, and up wages to reduce the need for migration. And in general improve people's lives and then there is no need for a scapegoat. That is how that rhetoric ends.
Have a process centre in France and there will be no boats? Well my friend, people who travel to another country to improve their lives are not deterred by processing centres. People will travel to better their lives if the processing centre is on the moon or in Afghanistan. It doesn’t make a difference. What deters such people is a clear immigration or non-immigration policy. If the policy is we don’t accept asylum seekers, asylum seekers will not come. If the policy is we don’t accept immigrants to work or study. Then immigrants wouldn’t come to work or study. But the truth is: successive governments realise sectors of the economy need immigrants so they shout about stopping immigration whilst in practice, those governments increase immigration.
100%, this immigration 'issue' has been created by the Tories, they used people as pawns for their political scapegoating. They wanted the hotels, they wanted the boats, they wanted the headlines. Process claims efficiently, deport those who don't have a valid claim, integrate those that do and like you say improve our homegrown training, standard of living, wages etc. and people won't pay attention to immigrants.
@@Osiriswear He means have a processing centre in France where people can claim asylum to enter the UK, if they are granted then there is no need to use the boats or pay gangs to cross the channel. Something like 70% of the people crossing on the boats get their asylum applications approved (eventually) we are just taking too long with the claims.
@@Osiriswear you don't know what a processing centre is, it processes aslyum seeker claims meaning zero boats. Before 2018 we had zero boats, why do they think that was.
sadly starmer the populist is going down the right wing route of shouting SMASH THE GANGS. instead of the quicker and cheaper and more competent route of re-establishing safe and legal routes. that puts the gangs out of business even faster. cant operate with no customers.
Doesn’t matter if a PM is charismatic or not. It is not Big Brother.
We should focus on competence, not on charisma…
I think Starmer will try and keep politics calmer, but he can only do so much. He has a lot more control over actual government, as opposed to the theatre that is politics.
Especially now that attention seeker Farage made it in
Don’t need to be charismatic just level headed calm in a crisis and hard working.
Hey Sunak !!! Don't forget to pay Piers Morgan his £1,000 winnings before you run away to America. 🤣🤣🤣
And to pay back the £2.5 Billion you gave Dad-in-Law for our North Sea Oil contracts.
It is not the end of noisy politics we'll have Farage and his cohorts with Trumpian show standing spewing nonsense for the next five years. Sir Starmer should easily be able to contain the Tories in the short term but he will need to be Machiavellian with Farage. Interesting times ahead
The way to defeat Farage is to deliver decent government that makes people better off, healthier, and happier. Then we don't need to worry about Nigel.
Farridge won’t have the opportunity in the House, being in a small party. He may get an occasional question but that’s it. And as soon as the thrill of being there wears off, he will be off, leave it to his minions and be out and about slobbering over the press and other media.
@@Lynnefromlyn yes, he'll be away to sponge off the Trump gang as soon as he can
I just want truth and action.
Broken Promises are just fancy lies.
Competence is what people want. And decency.
If anything in Norwich we've seen the Brexit Exodus of European workers They were some of our best customers! and there's nothing to replace them
Every speech recently by Starmer has been fantastic
Make politics boring again!
Leadership is not all about charisma but competence. Sir Kier Starmer looks more principled, I am sure he will bring change.
Charisma is just words and empty gestures. Promising the world and delivering nothing
No. I am shouting no more Austerity.
We had loads of Austerity under Atlee. It was the only way to deal with the mess we were in.
The war time generation were more realistic than we are , and tougher than we are.
@@johnrussell3961- yes it was tough after the war. However Atlee's 1945 government introduced seismic changes - the NHS, welfare state & housebuilding. A nation fit for heroes. It was desperately needed & the Tories continued with some of it afterwards.
Enough. No more austerity.
Is it too much to ask?
We can't endure any more austerity. The poorest & most vulnerable should no longer be punished for the failures of neo liberalism.
@@Coops5361 . Atlee continued voter Austerity so the labour Goverment had enough tax to pay back war debt, fund the NHS and create the welfare state.
Money doesn’t grow on trees.
That idea was invented by the Tories in the ‘50’s.
How's that going to work with net zero, they are shutting farms down because of it, starmer is a globalist, so no change of course there. Food prices are going to keep increasing. You will see suffering beyond anything, but don't worry, the Tories will be blamed.
It won’t be a Tory austerity which steals from the poor to give to the rich. It will a needed austerity to get the country back on its feet after the corruption and incompetence of the last 14 years. And even during this austerity we will still see improvements, whereas with the tories all that saved money went ..where? Not into the infrastructure Not into the pay packets of public sector workers!
I'd like a debate about how much the media was responsible for the promotion of "charismatic" insubstantive narcissistic individuals. The failure to call out Johnson & co's lies was criminal. Now they indulge Farage.
The media - and not just the right wing media - are totally complicit in getting the reprehensible Farridge into Parliament and his loathsome party lots of publicity. Recently Farridge was given monumental amounts of airtime and newspaper column inches - not so the Lib Dem’s and the Greens.
A return to the idea that the Prime Minister is merely the first among equals in their cabinet and a public servant, not a president or king, is long overdue.
It will be interesting to see how this juxtaposes with the upcoming Tory leadership contest, which I predict will be as toxic as ever.
Finally I feel like we’ll have a government that won’t take us for granted
Wishful thinking.
Starmer must now get the last five PM and cabinets locked up for there crimes
A marvellous idea.
I mean, what's Starmer ever done for us? He's been in power for over 1400 minutes and my life hasn't improved!
😂😂
Your sneering cynicism is unwelcome. Give the man a chance. ❤
Let's see what they do.
I buy the fact the man's been in office a day and needs to be given time to sort the mess. Any supposition and baseless assumptions and discussion is a waste of time. We got better things to do with our time
No. But he's barely been in 5 mins. we'll see
What exactly does charisma do for anyone?
its got Trump way too far
Its a primary attribute if you are a Bard and influences the level and number of spells you can memorise.
@@kevinsmarts9953😂😂
Most people only pay attention to politics when things are going badly. I want a PM who I don't feel the need to pay attention to.
What drugs is this man David on ???
Politics should be boring
My takeaway from this election is the general apathy of the people, the number of interviews I've watched where people said they didn't vote because it doesn't make a difference to their lives. Hence the rise of Reform and the number of single issue MP's we see in this parliament. Unless Labour change this, extremism will become the norm
If the lights of Nigel Farage is what we have install for the country if labour doesn’t change things for the better then I will want out of this country
Not charismatic? Absolute deal-breaker. I guess the country will have to stay broken. 🤷
Easiest way to counter "Populists" is call them Nazis and interview them Jeremy Paxman style focusing on how weird they are.
Best way to defeat populism is to make people feel happier, healthier and better off. Then they have no reason to vote for the fruitcakes.
Quite Churchillion. Reasurance of gravitas. Not another Tory clown.
Before coming to politics , every politician is an ordinary member of the public. When you listen to the caller like David, you understand why the standard of politicians is going down.
So you are going to trust a man who has accepted £76 000 worth of personal gifts from donors! That sounds like putting service to Kier Starmer first, party second snd country last!!!!!
As long as they are declared (that's how you know about them) that is perfectly legal and as long as they don't influence policy they are morally acceptable.
@@kevinsmarts9953 yeh, right. So Starmer (a consummate liar) isn't going to be influenced by these 'gifts' 🤣😂🤣
@@JohnTreacy-ix3wr You do know that you just lost the government that not only lied in every breath but actually send an MP to lie to the late Queen's face?
Is that consummate enough for you or can you only see in Daily Mail-a-scope?
@@JohnTreacy-ix3wryou don’t seem to be very well informed. Whinge whinge whinge. At least the adults are in charge now.
@@JohnTreacy-ix3wrand you don’t know much about it either.
We gave a charismatic, populist windbag the power and look what happened? I’ll take dull and sensitive over that any day.
I Hope the media doesnt demand and encourage división, antagonism and controversy in order to sell news
Politics should be about boring compentsy not big personality incompentsy
I don’t care about dull or boring as long as he gets the piggies snouts out of the trough, takes action on the fraud and dodgy stuff then they govern in a way that is right for the country and the people.
The influence of the press is diminishing rapidly!
I'd caution your caller on adopting the Australian scheme. Last year we had around half a million immigrants who we didn't have infrastructure or even housing for. As for importing teachers and builders, train your own instead of taking them from poorer countries which also need teachers and builders.
That’s colonialism talking when they only want certain immigrants.
"I think we should bring in an Austrailian style immigration system"
The UK did bring in an Austrailian style immegration system, over a decade ago. 🤦♂
I would rather have someone done uncharismatic if it means our lives will improve and I’m willing to give Starmer a chance.
🤣😂 - you'd think UK brought migrant workers out of the kindness of their heart, fix up
It’s an ironic paradox of leadership, the boring pragmatic leader avoids problems before they happen and it may appear they aren’t doing anything at all.
A great leader is never a showman and never self serving
Politics should be animated and noisy! Engagement in the political discourse should be encouraged. Starmer will stoke up passivity.
Last caller was spot on. Labour under Starmer is center right, not left wing
We shall see.
Nobody wants charisma. All most people want is an honest, hard working man (or woman) of the people who is intelligent and is decent and has integrity. I'm SO glad that Starmer is a sensible man.
Remember when he promised the people of Liverpool he would never give the Sun an interview..... well he lied like so many other times and guess what this will be what he is remembered for most.... complete dishonesty to destroy Labour
Who cares about charismatic, if he can get the country back on track, he can be as dull as he wants.
I know its only been a day, but I'm happy with the direction so far.
I guess we'll see, but I'd rather be hopeful of a chance than expecting turmoil again.
Sir Keir has a huge job ahead. However, it’s refreshing that he’s putting the country first, rather than prioritising personal gain. He’s ruthless and selfless in equal measure. Three cheers for Keir!
Actions speak louder than words..... We'll see.
No globalist puts their country first, country comes last, the WEF first, try and wake up.
@@VincentLeSabre What return did you get from Tories? How much Health Insurance will you pay if Reform scrapped the NHS?
Brilliant video
David Cameron = Zero charisma
Liz Truss = Zero charisma
Rishi Sunak = Zero charisma
But they were also incompetent.
Starmer will devolve all power now,to the Local authorities,he'll point to them once you start complaining he'll say it's down to them not Central Gov,the Honeymoon will last about 6 months👎🤣🤣
The dream of every conservative is the end of politics. There's no neoliberalism--it's economics. There's no racism, no sexism, no homophobia--it's all the way it should be. You just keep your head down, focus on your work, and let the big boys take care of you.
The ministers he has appointed show to me he wants people who know not clowns act like theybdo but don't aka Tories
This is the most undemocratic “mandate” on earth!
And Mathew do you really think this is going to be much quieter, boring politics? Reform with a credible presence and the independent left also with a credible presence all coming for blood- Stùrmer needs to make his presence known and decide does he slide further right and introduce fascism or move left and introduce humanity!
What are noisy politics?…..why don’t we have musical politics with frills on….pink frills
The shouty, jokey, clowny nonsense we have seen for fourteen years - particularly since Johnson came to power.
If you don’t understand what is meant by noisy politics you really have no reason to be commenting here.
Hardly a ringing endorsement for Labour. Only 33% of the vote on a low turnout! 😂
Can’t you count? And who cares abut your uninformed opinion? We’ve now got a decent government instead of the corrupt and incompetent ones we’ve had over the past 14 years. As for reform…I don’t think the fascists will stick around too long.
How does charisma help improve the suffering citizens?
eugenicists are the issue. the immigrants were the smokescreen.
It's a result driven business. People need to feel like things are improving. Wages, housing, transparency in Westminster. Until things start getting visibly better I think people will still be sceptical
An honourable man
Only because he is about to be on the wrong end of it
Is it the end of the UK committing war crimes?
No war crimes committed.
So tired of these soulless career politicians.
Becomeing a politician should be similar to jury duty, with the most accomplished and intelligent people in our society, from all backgrounds and disciplines, being called upon to 'represent' the people.
Instead...we are stuck with a bunch of money hungry, power obsessed, career politicians from Eton 😢
You must be happy now we have the most 'working class' front bench in the parliamentary history. No more 'money hungry, power obsessed career politicians from Eton' running the country.
Anyone can officially join a party and put their name forward for an election, or even run as an Independent if they don't agree with any of the main parties. Its like voting - you can't complain about the government if you don't try to change it.
I wouldn't want to be 'called up to 'represent' the people' any more than I want to be called up for jury duty. It's not a responsibility I'd like, and I know very few people who would like it.
Keir Starmer as Steer Calmer? I hope so, but I'll believe it when I see it; 14 years of suffering under a criminal government is enough to make a hardened cynic out of Buddha. (I'm not Buddha, but I used to be pretty laid back until that gang of Libertarian pirates got in)
2008: No drama Obama.
2024: No drama Starmer.
David not speaking for himself at all can only hear propaganda
if both of you speak at the same time, we don't understand.
It's a pretty dumb phrase and reinforces notions that he prefers to do things 'on the quiet'. Hopefully the media are not going to facilitate this..
Depends who his gentler politics apply to. Will he carry on being mysterious?
That David bloke from Norwich was hard to listen to.
Inherited the same problems the tories had, any answers?
Wright wont let anyone get a word in just listen to him 👎👎