One Doesn't Survive: Milwaukee's New M12 Gen 4 M18 Drivers
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лис 2024
- Lifetime updated tool rankings: torquetestchan... Since I've been asked several time, the knife is a japanese Mcusta: amzn.to/3dG6R17 Today we try out the all new Milwaukee FUEL M12 3453 impact driver, Gen 4 M18 2953 impact driver and see how they compare to everyone's favorite the 2853-20.
Not everything goes according to plan, but hey - that's life. We show you either way.
~Links may include affiliate links, which we earn some % from sales on~
Torque, who started TTC, is working in product development for Astro Tools who doesnt make impact drivers at the moment. TTC is not the only testing out there, always consider multiple sources when looking at a tool!
I think it's about time that we switch to 5/16 collets and bits, but I guess it's not as big an issue when you're actually using them to drive screws
I think 5/16" hex should have been used from the start 5/16" bits already exist, such as hand impact drivers. But you're right what we're doing here leans towards the stupid side vs how they are most often used. That said, most of the other drivers didn't mind the abuse
I'd love to see this and 5/16 to 1/4 extension adapters. Lately, I rather like using relatively short 1/4" hex extensions with the cheap to replace 1" long tips.
This is a thing:
(1) M18 FUEL™ 7/16" Hex Utility HTIW w/ ONE-KEY™ (Tool Only)(2865-20)
They know how to make other size hex collets. And how to charge a lot for anything that fits in them.
Any more power than necessary is wasted.
@@WilReid I have been looking into this very item. You can get a 7/16 hex drill drill adapter. The already have 7/16 auger bits and hole saws.
Negative 16 subs on this video so far, we don't make the tools guys, just test 'em! :P We obviously would have preferred it survive through testing so we could have clean data on this one. We purchased a replacement, and we along with others will be trying to find out if its possible to break it again and how. Doing various tasks. We'll post a link here for that. If it's a fluke, that's worth knowing as much as anything else.
Torque who started this channel is working for Astro Tools who dont make anything like an impact driver, though it's still worth knowing when watching videos like these. Always look to several sources!
Just noise, wouldn't worry about it too much
Minus subs 🤣 why are you watching this channel if you don't want the facts
A shame people would unsubscribe because their favorite tool sucked or broke. Your channel has been the best at really finding out what is a good product and what is not. Keep it up, and hope we see Torque again, but everyone is great.
Even the most objective possible testing isn't acceptable if Milwaukee loses. You're expected to lie and feel good about it. Come on!
@@Lee-lb9qh take your TDS elsewhere
I knew it, I knew I shouldn't buy the new M18 until your video came out. I follow a ton of other channels and no disrespect to them but I wasn't about to buy one without seeing what you found. This channel rocks!
Most other channels are just hypemen for companies lol. The M12 looks better than my Gen2 M12 by a significant margin though, I enjoy it.
You waited for what?…Inclusive. No fault of there own.
@@steffendetrick9403 ?
@@AlexDenton0451 Looks better or performs better?
@@euphoricmonk Performance wise, I actually cover up might light on my M12 due to it being easy to hook my index finger on.
If you can get this one, get it, if you have a M12 already, be happy with it.
What's going to happen is they're going to make these drivers too powerful and the supporting hardware wont handle it.i think its time they focus on durability and not outright power.
You can turn down power though
If you're referring to adapters then the answer is pretty black and white where at that point you buy a proper impact that doesn't require an adapter.
BLASPHEMOUS WORDS BRÖTHR, MOAR BEANS FOR THE BEANS GOD
Seems the collets cant take the torque either.
Obviously one industry is going to try to keep up with the other it's not anything to lose sleep over
I think that we are reaching a point where technology in motor and impact drive have exceeded the capability of the metals that we are using. It's hard to blame the bit, that's a ton of power on a 1/4" piece of metal.
I agree.
Deploy adamantium bits
Maybe the 7/16 drive the utility companies use will be the answer, I doubt it but I love tools the more the merrier.
We have long exceeded that point imo, even a DCF 887, a 10yo construction, destroys 1/4" adapters. Imo there should be a new, larger tool standard introduced, or just used really, I believe we already have 3/8" hex bits, but not commonly used.
@@TorqueTestChannel Do you have links to all the charts for everything you have tested? It would be really nice to be able to quickly reference the actual numbers of this stuff.
I was more excited about the lighting on the nose than improvements in power/speed. I think that when Milwaukee asked the trades guys what they wanted to see in a new impact lighting was the most requested. I know that's what I would have asked for. The older gen stuff already had plenty of power given the 1/4 hex drive. I work in plenty of dark places and the extra light would be helpful
@@Lee-lb9qh Milwaukee calls it innovation tough lol
@@Lee-lb9qh you're right, however I've used both the 887 and the m12 gen 2 and I like the form factor of the m12 better. It's a personal preference and it's even nicer now that I can have the best of both worlds
@@Lee-lb9qh not only that but Dewalt is smaller in size.
Same here, but after watching this I'm sticking with my gen 3 and flashlight. The lights alone aren't worth spending the cash if you own a last gen mode, IMHO.
Thanks for making this video I was considering getting the M12 fuel because I love my cordless ratchet and thought I could share batteries but looks like I’ll need to get an M18 and use same charger for the 12 battery with the ratchet.
I think what I'm learning is that the M12 offerings are becoming more and more capable. The M18 platform has always had the capability. But, now the light-weight and compactness of the M12 doesn't come with as much of a power loss. You might go through batteries a lot faster with them, but you're not really lacking power anymore.
Seeing the prior gen M12 would be interesting!
I have the m12. And let me tell you. It’s my favorite impact. Very light weight and powerful. Just feels good
Even this model #?
It would be nice to see a comparison between the new m12 vs the previous model
I just bought the new and have an old and was thinking the same thing. I’m gonna do a video on the two soon. Insane difference. There is pros and cons for both.
@@unclejacksyoutube6496 waiting on that review
Do it
Im a carpenter and work in a commercial building atm. I have the m12 and love it, so do my coworkers. The main selling point is how light it is. At the end of the day all we are doing is putting small screws in steel framing and drywall screws lol. Get the appropriate tool for the right job.
I'm a M12 guy. I like the small compactness of it and it fits well in my tool bag. Disappointed in the M12 here!
Bought a M12 impact driver 3/8 drill combo years back. Instantly hooked. With the bitty batteries, my young kids could help out by driving deck screws into the fence and whatnot. At the point now where I think I will have to get into a M18 impact wrench for auto work.
Yup get a mid or high torque for auto work and driving lag bolts. M12 for the rest!
Having such a high torque impact driver seems pointless to me. The fact that it breaks the bits so easily kind of verifies that feeling. I have an M12 Fuel Impact driver (gen 3) that I use for screws and bolts/nuts that I can use with 1/4 drive (generally up to 13mm tops), and an M12 Fuel 3/8” drive impact for bigger stuff. The 1/4 hex driver is good for small stuff that probably needs less then 30ft*lbs, and I use the 3/8” drive for bigger stuff. No bits to break, it’s more compact in actual usage since it doesn’t need the long bit to work. Yes, it’s another tool to buy, but $120 for a tool that you use every day is nothing for a professional.
I love it when you break a tool! Manufacturers beware, this tool is going to get tested AND most users of your tools will know everything. Better make them good! Thanks for another great video.
I have the gen 3 m12. Its awesome with 1/4 drive sockets. I use it for top engine stuff. I also have the 3/8 stubby m12 impact, and I usually go for the driver for most lighter stuff. Its also awesome for just general stuff around the house. If you want I can lend you the gen 3 m12.
I think they made the m12 gen 2 and 3 so good it's gonna be hard to top it . Like other commenters said they should probably focus more on durability , usability and versatility rather than just sheer power at this point .
But then again power claims make tools fly off the shelves so that's what the marketing department is gonna push.
This channel is the reason why i havent try to get the Gen 4, awaiting Torques Channel test and input...in conclusion i will hold off for now and use my gen3's
I got the m12 and m18 drill/driver and I honestly use the m12 impact and the m18 drill for electrical rough in. It's cool having both
Saturday relaxed, almost buying the ultimate tech from Milwaukee, until I stopped to watch your video, by far, the best choice are the 2018 models MILWAUKEE 2853-20 M18 FUEL & MILWAUKEE 2804-20 M18 FUEL. Both tools are in eBay 89.99 each from many sellers. Thanks bro, I love your channel!
Since you tried out the latest m12 impact driver, is there anyway you can test out the other two m12 impact drivers that Milwaukee has to offer?
I love my M12 fuel gen 3 drill and impact driver combo kit. It took everything I threw at it. I used that impact driver on 8 inch medium lags in one sitting and used up 2 bars of battery left on an xc3.0 and the anvils only got as warm as a stack of fresh copies from a photocopier at the end. Same thing with driving 100 3 inch coarse thread wood screws with the heads recessed in one sitting.
I just got the 3453 M12 for under dash work on passenger cars and it’s working very well for that job. Not a screwdriver, I know but this is versatile enough to get the job done.
This is interesting, I haven't experienced many issues with my m18 tools honestly, I've still got my gen 3.0 impact driver going strong and yes it still tries to drop bits but I've known this lol.
My go to driver is actually my m12 surge hydraulic impact, I've simply fallen in love with it's portability to power ratio.
I would love to see some tests on the hydraulic impacts!
This m12 doesn't hesitate when putting in #10 3.5" wood screws, it might be a smidge slower than the m18 but it really is quiet and when you're only putting in 3-5 screws? Who cares.
Is the answer none of them survive?
I’m a big Milwaukee fan, I’ve also had my m12 impact break driving in a sheet rock screw, and my m18 broke when I tried to break free my crank bolt.
I was pretty sure it wasn’t going to be stout enough, but for the tool to break simply from trying to loosen a bolt, well, I thought that was the tools job.
I have an M12 2551-20 impact driver. I also have Bosch and a Porter Cable impact drivers. Like my recent project where I needed to drive just short of a thousand 3-1/2" #12 deck screws (Torx bits used), the M12 was the one I reached for. Granted, I'm 80 years old, but its light weight, smooth operation with plenty of torque to drive the screws with a handy hook for my pocket so it was where I was when I needed it, was a winning combination. I've zero need for more torque in an impact driver. The ability to twist off adaptors is not a feature. I have the M12 3/8" drive stubby for that, and the 2767-20 (my only M18 tool though the 3/8" drive Mid Torque is at the top of my list) for when I need to remove really stuck stuff.
Some times it's not all about HP but functionality M12 is a fraction of the weight compared to the M18 so running deck screws all day I would definitely consider the M12
This! Milwaukee been done perfected the impact driver with the m18 Surge. I haven’t seen a person use a regular impact driver since that came out.
M12 surge is far superior m18 surge, same power and sound, half the size.
Sound like a "right tool for the right job" situation to me. When I bought my m12 Hydraulic Impact, I choose that one over the standard Gen 3 because it was lighter, quieter, and smaller, even though the marketing admitted it made less peak inch pounds over the standard Gen 3 impact. My reasoning was, I was going to use this tool to install coax cable on house eves every day using cable clips with 1 inch screws, the tool was going to be used over my head almost always in uncomfortable spaces and positions and I wanted comfort over power.
Trust me when you get draw the short stick and get nothing but old post wire homes and you gotta replace over 1000 feet of cable with a heavy drill, you're going to want to run to your van to cry for a little when you cant steady arm to get that last screw clip in.
I have the M18 and LOVE it. It's the most powerful Stubby drill you can get plus tri-led and very lightweight. Very hard to find just walking in a store and won't be on display either. Easy to find on-line. All the guys at work are jealous!!
I think you have to use the XC battery to get the numbers the manufacturer states, that got noticed on VCG construction, the no power issue will be the solder has melted on one of the joints, i used to get this on the original sawzall all the time, im not overly happy with the milwaukee tools currently, and seeing the new ones are not improved alot if at all on the old is even more of a reason to wait a bit longer for the new shiny tool. Having a better light isnt enough to upgrade.
Also, I have a modifiend Ridgid 3.0ah octane battery. Swapped the cells out to make it a 4.2ah pack, and increased the continuous amperage from 35A to 45A. Planning on swapping the cells on one of my m12 batteries soon.
I just don't think its wise to run 1/2" adapters on an impact driver and use larger sockets. Regardless if it can or not. I've ruined 1 impact driver doing that and partially ruined a chuck on another one making bits not stay in well. One reason why they sell impact nut drivers only up to about 5/8 or so.
was gonna say this same thing and I was thinking maybe the new design cant handle that big of socket or spin it with enough torque and speed to show the real results.
This is why I bought a 1/2" m18. Was worried about my 3/8" m12 that almost always was used with an adapter surviving.
My impact of choice is always M12 size, weight, and performance. Then new Gen is worth it imo it feels faster and more powerful. However we are reaching the point where the tool will break themselves unless they use better materials
That m12 one is 99 bucks with a battery and charger at Home Depot I just picked one up. Excited
When Milwaukee tells ya it's too new to warranty tell them you don't have the box to return it. I had the jobsite speaker quit working within a month and they told me the same thing. I told them I didn't have the box because I didn't expect a Milwaukee tool to die that quickly.
The DCF850 is short as hell, and doesn't break minutes in. ...Hard to say what the best impact you should buy is.
850 with a power stack is hard to beat when it comes to compactness and lightness
The hilti SID 2-A is the nicest impact driver I have used, not the most powerful but that's what I love about it. It offers far more control with better trigger sensitivity and a more consistent trigger. If I want more power I grab an impact wrench. edit: Also it doesn't snap socket adapters nearly as much as my 2853-20.
Have you tried the newer brushless sid2-a12 ? Amazing.
@@vojnikjna30 SID 2A-12 is definitely a nice upgrade from the SID 2-A. SID -2 Extremely slow but smooth. Have both including the SID 4 and SID 6 Any Hilti product is phenomenal period!!
I’ve been HUGELY Disappointed with Home Depot’s return/ exchange/ warranty process on a Milwaukee tool also. #(2880)
WITH receipt. And UNDER the 90 days specified on said receipt.
They told me, “Milwaukee doesn’t let us ‘exchange’ them.. so I have to refund your money, and you just have to buy it again.”
🤯 Hmm.. wonder how many of those sales figures of theirs come from instances like this? 🤔
Sort of a workaround into fudging the numbers if you ask me.
If Mil won't allow HD to exchange, why are you blaming HD for the inconvenience?
I've been having the same issues with milwaukee tools and batteries failing on me, but seems to be the newer tools having problems.
Basically got my m12 driver for free. Home Depot is running a m12 high speed ratchet and hex driver plus two batteries and charger for $250… that’s cheaper than the ratchet and battery combo alone.
The company that makes those adapters must love you all
I wonder if the impact bricked itself after getting jammed up? I have no idea how it would know that but it seems suspicious how it died. Maybe after detecting so many trigger pulls with no movement it shut itself down. That's not too crazy to believe given the new drills have kickback protection. Or maybe some component just blew up. Given the way impacts work maybe they have no jam up motor protection given that they shouldn't ever jam up and it fried itself.
Im sure they dont self destruct on purpose.
@@djsi38t not so much self destruct but disable itself. Sound crazy? Think again. Some Makita batteries count the number of times it couldn't be charged due to a battery fault and after so many shut itself down.
It's an electronics failure. All these brushless have mini motherboards (I prefer sticking with brushed), it probably overheated given the symptoms show.
I'm glad I bought the gen-3(2853-20). And if I was buying the M12, it would be the Surge. Quieter, smoother, and still enough to drive screws.
Nice to see a glimpse of the warranty process and that you can get a refund for it. Nothing sucks more than trying to warranty something and just get silence, or worse get your review censored for being "too negative."
*cough* Amazon *cough* *cough*
Gen 3 M12 user here. I only use the HO 2.5Ah/30w & 5.0Ah/60w. I feel a very clear difference between my 2.5Ah and 5.0Ah batteries. I also have a m12 3/8" impact wrench and of course notice a very clear difference between the two batteries when applied. I have 100% power on the 2.5Ah batteries until I lose a quarter of battery charge. While the 5.0Ah batteries seem to give 100% power until I lose half of the battery charge. I'd love to see some tests on these new batteries, specifically the 5.0Ah/60w.
I have the brand new gen 3 M12 stuff. I just bought it a few days ago with the hammer drill and impact driver combo. Smart or foolish, the first thing I did was take the impact driver out of the box, put in the half charged CP2.0 battery an adapter and 17mm socket and took a lug bolt out that had just been torque to 110nm. It didn’t even hammer that long to do it, 5 seconds maybe. I know that’s not the wisest or most scientific thing to do but it did it, twice! After that I charged everything and put it away, I won’t be doing that again but it was cool to see it do it.
@@ShainAndrews Of course I won’t only use it fully charged, I never said nor meant to imply that. I’m no engineer but I understand enough about LiPo batteries to know not to do that. The point I was making was I wanted to see what it could do straight outta the box on a barely half charged compact 2AH battery. But maxing out a brand new tool with a brand new battery at 50%SOC which is probably closer to 30%SOC is not the wisest decision. Use the tool for its intended purpose and let everything wear in a little before pushing it to do things it’s not designed for is the better choice.
@@2down4up Thanks for your comment man. I'm considering that exact set, especially now that the prices have come down a little with the 4th gen coming out.
Amazing. All that hype from Milwaukee for this?
Now, I'm really curious how the Flex does with 3.5 and 6.0 stacked batteries.
Great testing, as usual!
Team Red is Dead. Flex already said it, they are what’s next.
Yeah I am disappointed in this new shit that dosnt even compete with the old. Damn RED get it together!
@@athannaelanderson3806Milwaukee is far from dead.
I kinda figured that about the m18 honestly. The specs are too similar to the previous generation. The m12 was a surprise that it did so poorly, but again, it’s really out of its league on that particular chart. Mine does great on cabinet hardware, but that’s more of its intended purpose lol.
The M12 is overkill for most impact driver jobs. I use the 7.2v Makita impact driver for pretty much everything. Its funny, in my shop i got pretty almost all the goodies from the XGT lineup and quite a few other powertools but the only tool my visitors are talking about afterwards is the 7.2v impact driver.
Bosch 12v are way better for cabinet work. They have power but it’s so refined and a joy to work with. No I don’t work for them and actually my big 18v tools are all Milwaukee. Snap-On makes crap pliers/wire strippers but still charge $8k for one. Usually to get a perfect tool set, you find the best variation from the right company. Lineman = Klein. Plumbing = Knipex. All the rest pliers = Channellock. 18v = Milwaukee. But 12v = Bosch by far. I have big hands but that horrible m12 fat azz handle is a deal breaker. Their 12v’s aren’t that small and get into actual tight spaces.
@@pflaffik Snap-in’s outdated Ni-Cad 7.2v is still the best/smallest driver for car interior work. The newest Bosch 12v is close but it has a very fat head. M12 tools are still pretty ridiculously big and fat in all the wrong areas. Their not for close quarters work, their just for people who want slightly smaller tools I guess?! The Surge is literally the same size in m12 and m18 flavors. M18 all the way!
Milwaukee are notorious for overpowering products to beat competition.
My mate had a Milwaukee impact driver that constantly broke bits.
Even my expensive Wera bits. They only last a day
I sell Milwaukee daily and process tons of warranties for milwaukee.
Milwaukee has sent me other peoples tools that were sent in for repair (as in, I've received multiple warranty shipments of tools that have been fixed and they belong to other companies and other people not even in my state).
Milwaukee has lost a couple of my customer tools.
Milwaukee even sent me a D Ring impact that was still completely in pieces because they said it wasn't covered and customer didn't want to pay $150. It was literally the whole tool disassembled in a box they sent me back.
I've had them deny warranty on a 2 speed grease gun with invoice and proof of purchase 3 weeks prior
I sent off a chainsaw and got a brand new one box and all 5 days later. I got a 2767-20 that I never claimed. I got a multi-tool that I never claimed. As much as I love Milwaukee, they have issues
Can you guys do a drill video? I sometimes need to cut holes with a big spade bit or punch through aluminum and steel. RPM matters a lot, and I am dubious about many claims
You can use impacts for spade bits, the torque of a big drill is outright dangerous when working in tight spaces in weird positions. Impacts will not work nearly as fast as a huge drill but they get the job done without the employees going on sickleave with wrist injury. I got the XGT hammer drill, awesome power in high gear, but thats for big concrete bits, wouldnt use it for spades unless its in easy spots and then with the side handle attached.
ProjectFarm has done at least one drill video. I personally really like his tests and they often line up with the findings here.
solidified my thoughts… i’ll be happy to keep my gen3 m12 and picking up gen3 m18’s on sale! good vid!
Did I miss a re-test on the Gen 4 M18? Very curious whether that was just bad luck or whether we have another case of a new design that's got some serious problems.
Went to Summit Racing in Ohio and they have the greatest Milwaukee display I have ever seen.
If it's the M12 that dies, I'm gonna need someone to torture test the M12 drill, the actually compelling part of that duo.
7:09 wow I was considering selling my Milwaukee gen3.5 impact driver and get a gen4 that just confirmed my decision, I’ll stick with the gen3.5!
Glad I saw this
My gen 3 impact driver is still going strong
any chance you can check out the makita 12v ratchet WR100DZ and the 12v brushless 3/8 impact gun DTW180Z i use both on a daily basis and find them to be great vs milwaukees stubby 12v gun and high speed ratchet but would love to see the rankings !! much love from australia
Yes please want to see makita 12v ratchet
This is an appreciation comment for Wendy from Home Depot 😳😍🥰
It really all depends on what you need as well. I work on aircrafts, M18s are a big no for them. Way to over powered, woukd strip every screw and end up drilling through a panel. The M12s even at times can be to much. But i have the 3453-20 M12 Gen 3 Impact. Most of the guy's at the hanger all use it. Absolutely great tool.
This new little M12 seems like a nice contender to DeWalts newish DCF840. Would like to see how that little buddy does
I think most 20V tools would beat the M12. We need to add like 2-3 12V tools at once to see where it really lands.
@@TorqueTestChannel well I do say this in regards of the more slim, but long profile of it and the 840. I bought my 840 to replace my 5 year old 815 and is my go to for small underhood components and especially under the dash
@@TorqueTestChannel see if Man Caber Tools will lend you his DeWalt and Hilti 12v drivers.
Wow! You killed it. Didn't expect that. Yet again another company releasing something that is not ready. To new to replace, that's proof of premature releasing products. Glad I've held off. Going to wait for sure now.
If only there was a brand that had: Less frequent releases, more testing, more engineered for the user and no sensational marketing? That would be great. They could chose a name like for example Makita, i think i would buy that.
@@pflaffik tbh I miss my Makita DTD171 the only impact driver I miss do to its function selections. Under powered slightly I found.
@@ToolTimeToday The problem with impact drivers is rather that theyre overpowered. Try the 7.2v Makita, it will be your favorite impact driver.
If only you realized this isn't normal. How many people are using a 1/4" tool on bolts that large? Oh wait, nobody outside of TTC!
Wow two videos in 2 days! Nice!
The new M12 hammer drill when I was using it with a nylon wire cupped brush after 3-5 minutes shut off and flashed 4 lights indicating that it over heated. Somewhat disappointed considering I have a 12v Bosch that does not shut off on a lockout.
I’m guessing these safety features are for adding more power and presetting the safety temp limit cutoff low enough so warranty claims diminish quite a bit.
Glad to see what dealing with returns would be like.
I use the impact drivers while working on cars. The 2853 can handle about 95% of the fasteners on a normal passenger car - not sure if that's "abuse" or just normal use!
You must not be in the rust belt haha impact driver wouldn’t get me very far on automotive fasteners lol only very small ones
Ahh the Yellow Makita i still love that thing, although it was a pain in the ass to get it to Europe
I think you should test out the new Metabo HPT Bolt wh36dc. I have a Japanese import of it. It's a newer 36v, not the original triple hammer.
Thanks for posting this information. The little M12 Surge driver looked interesting but the seriously exaggerated performance claims are a deal breaker. Another thing Milwaukee does is exaggerate the Watt-hour ratings of the M12 battery packs. For power ratings of battery pasks to make sense the manufacturer must use the nominal cell voltage but Milwaukee uses the peak voltage of the M12 pack instead. For the M18 packs they correctly use the nominal cell voltage.
I use an m12 surge impact at work because it still getser done and it’s nice on my ears, do you have a video with the m12 vs m18 surge at max battery? And maybe also do a decibel test and show both torque and decibel information on the same graph
Max battery as in the biggest battery you can put on each respective tool
This is what I've always wondered about those Pipeline event samples they send those attendants home with. Even if they are the same, how many of those guys would show one of these tools sh*@tting the bed like this? I'm sure some would, but the one guy whose driver eats it, after being flown out and attending that stuff for multiple day. I dunno if it always makes the cut...
Just want to point out that Jim Davis of Philly Fixed and Brian Hofmeister of WorkshopAddict have repeatedly done highly critical reviews of stuff they've been provided.
I prefer slower impacting tools, they undo just as tight bolts and dont constantly wear out and break driver bits and adapters. no they dont put small screws in as quick but that's a trade off im willing to accept. That said i wont judge a tool based on one failure, there's always a few duds in mass produced tools, we'll see if it become a common occurrence though.
Looking forward to the follow up on this one and if the failure can be duplicated. Yikes, new Milwaukee not so reliable, possible....
I've noticed the new m12 drill set retails for cheaper than the gen 3 which is interesting
I have Apex,snap on and proto bit adapters and have not broken or twisted one yet.Although I dont quite use them as hard as you do,I think personally an apex or snap on adapter would be a good idea.Apex EX-370-B-4.It is only 3/8 drive though,not sure if they have 1/2 inch drive.They are extremely rugged though and have a very thick shaft.Once you need 1/2 drive it really makes sense to use an impact wrench anyway.
There's almost never a reason to upgrade a tool unless they change something drastically. The impacts just didnt change much/enough.
They changed a lot, for the worse.
Interesting stuff! Thanks for showing the pitfalls as well!
Dang. I really wish you had the chance to go through Milwaukee's service repair. I've heard really awful things about it. Not a good look that this broke the first day.
Any Milwaukee rep will exchange them on site
Or that it was "too new" to service. What kind of logic is that? Shouldn't they want to find out how a brand new model/tool failed so quickly?!
in my exp, it's just a little slow sometimes.
I've had to use their warranty service a couple times before and IME as long as it's in warranty they just send you a new replacement at 0 cost.
Batteries that are out of warranty absolutely will not be replaced though, found out the hard way those go from date of manufacture not date of sale.
I know it's not really what you do, but I would love to see a tear down comparison between the Gen 3 and Gen 4. Whatever they changed for the Gen 4, it breaks down easily and often when used on larger fasteners. Which is weird since the new Hercules impact driver seems to be the same impact as the Gen 4, but it doesn't have any of the same issues.
Great test to find the weak link, but personally I use a small 1/2 impact for large screws.
Great video bro, That was disappointing that it broke. so far it seams the upgrades aren't worth it. but we will see what they have is tool sales this fall
Really we don't know from this video if that driver is "worth it". At most these are meant for lag bolts. The faster impacts per minute I can see really coming in handy for a big job like building a deck. Still doesn't seem like a humongous upgrade though
Thanks this video just saved me some money on buying that new m12 impact driver.
Can you do a test on a bushnell lithium ion flashlight?
I guess we will have to wait for a Gen 4.1 or 4.5. So much for quality control
Am I the only one that would be interested in the M12 driver if it were a 1/4" square drive and not hex? It would be great for a lot of top end disassembly. Nice and small and compact. When you put the adapter on it that adds nearly 3" in length.
I think you'll be interested in Milwaukee electric ratchet. it's got a square drive
Milwaukee M12 2552-20
If you guys are interested in testing a 2553 and a 2462 (old brushed M12 driver), what would the turnaround time be like?
They are not interested.People want to see new stuff to make an informed purchase.
Another thing to keep in mind, M12's are p weak to battery degredation too. This isnt an excuse for it, it's really bad how many of my batteries have just crapped out on M12.
The M12 is worth it , you can get a 21 kit for $99 which is cheaper than the tool bars.
I'd take this more serious if the correct battery was used on each tool. 🤷🏻♂️
Awesome content outside of that.
Well then, that settles that. I’ll be going back and grabbing one of the last 3 on clearance at the depot tomorrow
You guys are the GODSEND for us techs choosing tools for professional use instead of being forced to spend 300% more on the proven mainstream pro truck tools.
Maybe you should also do some new research on the new IR line (always a good balance of power and reliability) but how bout that new line at Lowes FLEX that boasts an unbelievable lifetime warranty on batteries and tools.... How is that possible in shop conditions?? even if the tools have somewhat usable power they would be one of the most reliable buys for techs. Id like to see that in action
With the power these things are making, i'm suprised that someone hasn't started trying to push 5/16 or 3/8 hex chuck model.
Problem is 99 percent of bits are 1/4 inch.
My M12 3/8 gun started making a weird noise, I took it apart and one of the planet gears had a broken tooth on the gear. They didn't have one in stock so they gave me a whole new gun.
This is why everyone needs to make their top of the line impact drivers with hybrid collets like the Bosch Freaks. These tools have exceeded the capabilities of 1/4 inch adapters for years now, so I wish someone would use that solution on a tool where it actually matters.
Also, if Harbor Freight actually makes their Hercules line a viable option in the coming years the way their newest impact wrenches seem to be, Milwaukee won't be able to get away with such incredibly poor warranty support anymore.
I got both the Freak 3 and the Gen 3 Milwaukee and the best feature about the Bosch is it will never break any adapters.
For Philips and torx head screws the Milwaukee is a bit faster though
I own some m18 Milwaukee tools and I personally think they aren't made with the same quality as say Makita tools or some of the newer Dewalt tools coming out. Plus on average Milwaukee charge quite a bit more here in England compared to the other two brands for body only tools.
The Milwaukee batteries are about the same as what Dewalt charges and quite a bit cheaper than Makita batteries.
Examples of Milwaukee quality issue here in the UK include:
Drill chucks being poorly centred from factory, so spin slightly off causing you to more than likely break smaller drill bits.
The collet issues on the impact driver.
The ribbon cables in the impact wrenches wearing through or worse getting pinches from poor assemble from factory.
Trigger issues from general grim or moisture from the environments thst they were designed to work in because they don't use any rubber seals to prevent the ingress of dirt, which other brands do..
Battery wabble that honestly really p*ssed me off when I first start buying their tools, which wear the contacts down on the tools your use them on.
The m12 battery clips breaking so you have to hold the battery in if you want to use the tool.
Lol seriously I don't know why I switches brands now.
I will be interested to see what Dewalts new 1/2 is like, and some of their other tools which will be coming out soon from what I hear.
The only time I want to hear the word "NO" when I have a warranty claim is when customer service says "No Problem we will get taken care of !"
Home depot only said no because they didnt have one to replace it with.Otherwise it would have been an instant replacement.
I'd like to see a test with the battery-powered Metabo 1/2" drive.
Thanks
Home Depot must really be going downhill. I saw more employees than customers at the last 2 I went to with many of the common items sold out. Despite spending 30min looking at appliances, not a single person came over to help. Even Lowe's is better these days, and Ace is always closer with pricepoints getting more similar every day.
Oh no, HD is going down hill everywhere! Or maybe that’s your HD and an isolated incident.
People don't have to go to stores... just go online and buy anything you want... that's why you don't see people in stores not just Home Depot
That’s strange as my Home Depot never seems to have any employees around. I’ve seen customers (including myself) moving the large ladder around to get items from up high. I stopped going there and now go to Menard’s (which always has many employees walking around to assist).
HD was never my favorite. Always Unorganized. Lowes is always a step ahead, more organized and better customer service
Same with my hd
That’s disappointing - seems like marketing and volume sales is what they care about.
I use the M12 1/4 Milwaukee daily @ work as a Mazda technician. One of my favorite tools. Mostly use it for basic stuff but I’ve tested it removing wheels torqued to 150 ft/lb. Crazy for a tiny gun of its size. Super impressive, I love it!