They are going to do every single chapter from every single book. One chapter every week (on another channel) Will take several years to complete all the books. That 198 chapters. Meaning it will take almost 4 years. Although on this channel looks like they are putting a few episodes combined into one longer episode on this channel.
1:28:00 I have a theory about the green mist coming from Harry's vault. I believe it was the remnants of a Finite Incantatem spell. In book two, Snape uses this spell during the dueling club and it's described as "A haze of greenish smoke was hovering over the scene." Maybe when the door is opened with Harry's key, the spell triggers, wiping out defensive spells on the vault, and leaving a green mist or haze.
Guys, molly asking for the platform number is just a teachable moment for the kids. Just like when you count stuff at the store with your kids, to work on their numbers. She is asking to see if they know the platform number.
Exactly, it's like several people trying to decide where to eat and everyone has a different taste. They all know the obvious choice when someone just rhetorically says, "There's only one place we're going to find all those choices, The Food Court," which is the local place where everyone goes to satisfy multiple appetites. I never thought it odd when Mrs Weasley says, "Platform 9 and three quarters this way" and also "There's only one place we're going to find all of this, Diagon Alley." It's rhetorical conversation.
@@Caffeinated_Firefly She has like half a million kids, she would notice a lost looking boy who looks exactly like a tiny James Potter, her brothers were order members and would have known him. Even if Dumbledore didn't put her up to it, the timing is interesting considering she also knows she has to hide the platform from the muggles. It's possible someone from the school told her to be on the lookout for him, maybe even Hagrid or McGonagall.
Regarding Hagrid "disappearing" i also thought of a potential port key? That's a method of travel that doesn't seem to require magic being used by the traveler
Hagrid is an AWESOME wizard! He NEVER verbalizes any spell. Always non-verbal! Many witches and wizards have trouble with that, Even TM (Volty) verbalizes most of his spells.But knowing that he can, his duel with Dumbledore in the MoM, nether DD nor TR verbelizes their spell. But back to Hagrid.... AWESOME!!!
Voldemort actually usually doesn't. You can see it's practically always nonverbal during his duel with Dumbledore. The one exception is particular uses of the Killing Curse.
2:48:17 my theory about why Ron's robes were worse than the twins' is that, since his height is always emphasized, there probably wasn't as much choice.
Replying from the UK HUMBUG: A hard, boiled sweet, usually striped. MOLESKIN: a type of tight woven cotton fabric. (Like brushed cotton but heaver and tighter.) Very soft, like tye velveteen pelt of a mole. Usually worn by country folk, as it's unlikely to snag as might a looser weaved cloth. WHELK: Marge's eating of a whelk is an odd one. Unlike escargot they're not fine dining, and you'd be more likely to find them in a working class Cokney pub, or lower class seaside resort. They're usually eaten covered in salt and vinegar, and like snails are rubbery. Also like snails they need something strong to make then palatable. Excellent work gents!
2:00:50 This really hit close to home. I finished reading this series not long before the passing of my mother, so rereading this series really helps to remind me of a fond part of my life and calms me down so much whenever I start to get emotional
Love this new addition to the channel. Them talking about McGonagall passive aggressively sending the letters made me laugh, imagine her with hundreds of quills in the great hall all bewitched to write the same thing with that wry smile on her face lolol
McGalleon. And if you understand THAT, then you already listened to 70 episodes of insanely deep podcasting about the series a few chapters at a time. And yet, you are here, sounds like my kind of people
Just having started with episode 4, I realized: Beside a million other what ifs, there's this really interesting one I've never considered before: What if Petunia hadn't been jealous but supportive of Lily and later married a wizard? Would've made a big difference for Harry's early years and also might've changed things between Lily and Snape.
Less of a "what if" but I always wished Hermione had also had a sister who was just a muggle but rather than being jealous, she was super supportive. Because in many ways Hermione mirrors Lily while also being her opposite in other ways and a supportive sister would have been in line both with the mirror and the opposite. Kinda feels like it would have been a nice touch. Doesn't affect the story at all but it's there
What if Hagrid was granted the position of keeper of keys so that he might have the ability to track down said monster? This would be essentially hiring Hagrid to clear his name.
I remember a fanfiction in which someone mentioned the unfairness of the trace rule and the person said "Well, the spirit of the law is that a minor shouldn't be doing magic without adult Wizarding supervision, in case they have an accident and someone needs to fix a failed spell" ... and honestly it makes sense. It's still kind of unfair, but... it does make sense. Besides, if you force the Trace onto every minor, Wizarding kids wouldn't be able to be homeschooled Also, about the ice cream, it could be just a little white lie Hagrid said to surprise Harry with the ice cream! I absolutely can picure Hagrid being like "hehehe I'm gonna secretly buy this kid all the treats"
I like formal names in the intro. It fits the status of the books as British national treasures, the aesthetic of the set, and maybe quaint the British tv (BBC?) thematic throwback. However you want to look at it, it all feels right.
GB is the asmongold of countries. Everyone knows its disgusting and has a horrific history far worse than any other country on earth. But because they are totally unrepentant about their atrocities, and even take pride in them, nobody cancels them... Even jk is a bigot. National treasure you say???
Yes, Hermione has that Ravenclaw v Gryffindor discussion with the Sorting Hat. She mentiones that in OotP when everybody is so astonished she bewitched the Galleons. Some Ravenclaw says "how cone you're not in Ravenclaw", and she drops a line like "the Hat considered that for a while". I know because I just read that very chapter to my son last week.
i'm reminded of Paige from Charmed. her parents died in a car crash but she survived the same crash by automatically teleporting out of the car without even realizing she could do it.
To be fair Dedalus Diggle recognized Harry one day while he was shopping with Petunia, and he was at The Leaky Cauldron that day, even shook his hand twice if I recall.
Hagrid in Griffendoor: MacGonnagal tells Hagrid in HBP that he can represent Griffendoor while she takes the headmaster position in the last few chapters. Surely she would not let a Hufflepuff do this!
It makes perfect sense to me that Peter sleeps all the time. Hes suffering from serious depression, he betrayed his friends and it didnt even pay off, he then lost all protection and human to human interaction seemingly forever and on top of that he is too cowardly to kill himself. He is just sleeping due to depression
My head cannon is that Hagrid used a portkey to get to the shack on the rock. At this time Albus is still in good standing with Fudge. I'm sure he could be convinced to allow (if he would even notice because security was lax at the Ministry at that time) one to go get Harry Potter for school.
Harry actually asked Hagrid how he got there, and he says that he flew. How he flew or what on is never said, however I highly doubt that his coat, as many pockets as it has, could hide either a broomstick or Sirius’ Motorcycle.
@austinrestovic the only thing that makes sense to me is a Thestral. We are told that brooms can't hold his weight, and the motorbike wouldn't have been able to disappear
Loved the content! I’m going to listen to all of these 😂 - British people say squashy! It’s so funny when Americans are like “very Harry potter” when in fact it’s just very British 😂- Keep your hair on is a British expression, means calm down
Chapter 5- Narcissa looking at wands always bugged me. So I’ve head cannoned that since certain woods/cores are better for certain traits/magics, Narcissa was consulting w Ollivander so he could have wands lined up to try when Draco came in (spoiled brat yk) lol
The fact that Narcissa got Draco his wand meant that Draco's wand doesn't need to meet the wizard to lend loyalty. Which makes perfect sense as to how Harry was able to get that wand's loyalty by just grabbing it from Draco's hand. That wand will sway to anyone.
In defense of Neville: I have always thought he had some brain damage dating from the attack on his parents. Assuming they were attacked at home, perhaps one of the Death Eaters did something to him, or a well-meaning relative blurred his memory afterwards to protect him from the knowledge and overdid it.
I don’t think so, because Neville is for sure more talented than given credit for. In Herbology, he excels at it, so no comment, Potions, Snape is just the worst, so he isn’t great at (like every other Gryffindor), and the rest of the classes that require wands, he has an excuse because he used his Fathers wand, (the wand chooses the wizard) so he is physically limited with what he can do
It's because neville is using his father's wand. This would make sense that he is poor at wand work until he joined the DA. Its just a idea or the teachers aren't being patient with him
the platform number is easily explainable as her testing Ginny in that moment... to see if Ginny remembers because she's a child still learning about the world. the easiest answer is usually correct
Yes… but screaming it, out loud, with a group of red headed children pushing trolleys, already sticking out like a sore thumb, screaming a platform that doesn’t exist. I do believe that the international statute of secrecy would have a problem with all of that combined😅
I remember seeing a tumblr post (I think) of a head canon that Molly probably loudly announced all of this because she’s perceptive and motherly and could tell Harry was uncertain. So she makes a whole display of how it works and then ‘notices’ Harry and offers to help, providing all the options he’d need to get across safely. I liked that notion a lot!
Since you decided to talk at length about the Chamber of Secrets and Myrtle's murder, I'm surprised you didn't mention the fact that Aragog could never have been the monster attacking people, because all of the victims were always unmarked, and acromantulas are GIANT SPIDERS with GIANT FANGS that would OBVIOUSLY leave HUGE marks.
As to the question about "how did everyone know that was Harry Potter?" Well, he looks exactly like James, doesn't he? And we are led to believe that James was quite well known in the wizarding world. He was a Pure-Blood, for starters and all the pure-blood families know each other and are in fact related in some distant way.
Did you miss the point of the podcast? Sure they made references to future events but the focus of this episode is the single chapter they're reviewing
@austinrestovic Did you miss the point of the podcast? Sure they made references to future events but the focus of this episode is the single chapter they're reviewing
Mundungus is the one that made a sound like a car back firing. I think it depends on the wizard. I think Fred & George were excellent (they said they got their licence with distinction) they'd enjoy sneaking up on folks!!!
I think Bill or Charlie might have been the first to take Scabbers to Hogwarts, going off the timeline. It's been 10 years since Scabbers first became a house pet of the Weasleys (12 years based on conversations between characters in Prisoner of Azkaban but that's not for another 2 years, so 12 - 2 equals 10), which back then would be one year before the start of the player's first year in Hogwarts Mystery (I'll treat HM as if it took place in an alternate timeline because there was no mention of Cursed Vaults in the original timeline), but that would have still been 5 years before Percy becomes a Hogwarts student. This would be Molly's 17th year going to King's Cross (I think 10th with her kids), so Ron is about 10 years younger than Bill. So Ron would have been 1 year old, Fred and George would have been 3, Percy would have been 5, Charlie would have been 10, and Bill would have been 12 when they first took in Scabbers.
Draco's wand is so perfect for the character who he had the potential to become (conflicted, outside suited for dark magic, core from one of the purest creatures) but I can imagine it going kind of like when I was buying glasses as a kid. While I was getting my eye exam, my mom was looking at frames, picked out a few that I would try, and one of them would usually fit, but I was still free to look at others. So maybe Narcissa would pick out a few that would fit someone of Draco's nature and social standing, at least to have a starting point
Did you miss the point? It would mean his wand has no allegiance to him. The wand is supposed to choose the wizard. Their mom isn't supposed to do it for them 😂
Not sure if there is a difference between the books and audio books but, it does mention that the Dursley's do get out of the car and go into the station with him. I just listened to this chapter in-between that episode and this supercut.
Ben, I loved your observations of how Fred and George take after their dad. Both don't mind bending the rules. Both enjoy inventing things and finding out how stuff works and improving upon it.
Chips in the U.K. are not what we call Chips, but rather Fries, so the Chips bags, would be grease covered paper bags from a fast food shop. They would otherwise say Crisps.
Hermione DEFINITELY chose her house. She says it in the 5th book when she was talking about the charmed coins and was asked why she wasn't in Revenclaw. She says that the hat considered it but put her in Griffyndor. She left out that she asked for it. Like Harry always does when he reveals that the hat considered putting him in Slytherin.
Although Kings Cross doesn't have a car park in front of the station there is a car park that is linked to the station. The car park is located on Canal Reach and has 231 public car parking bays. There are 6 bays with electric charging points on level 2 next to the lifts, of which one is a disabled bay.
I love love LOVED the walking challenge this summer! I figured I’d get most of my distance done at a music festival in July. In my head it was a done deal, it was set in STONE that GotJ was going to be the boost I needed to finish the race. But, come to find out… I do a LOT more walking in my daily life than I ever realized and I ended up finishing (I want to say) about a month before the festival. I’ve been using a step counter ever since and it’s honestly done wonders to my confidence. Thank you.
I wish they do these more then just Sundays. It's going to take years to finish all the books. I would like 2 a week. But I'm going to still listen too
That will truely make my 40th Birthday a magical Birthday. Hopefully, I will have time for episode 3, chapter 5 and beyond while enjoying my own Birthday gifts and time with family, plus a meal out in the evening. Can't believe I have less than a week of my 30s left. This is possibly, one of my favourite chapters in Sorcerers Stone or philosophers Stone book 1. I love the lead up in chapter 3 to when the magic truely gets started in this chapter. I thought the episodes focussed on 3 chapters per episode though, not just one, given that chapters 1 to 3 were last weekend's episode.🎉
The neat thing about the illustration,I found, is that the frog doesn’t just fit with the chocolate frog, butthead fact that Neville has lost his frog/toad so much in the chapter.
21:11 - I can imagine Hagrid just sticking his head to the window and friendly asking to speak to Harry and hand him the letter while Petunia is getting traumatised from his sudden appearance.
As a Swede I can confirm we are big Harry Potter fans! And Frozen is also very popular. They actually do decent job representing Scandinavia and I think especially the inclusion of the Sami people in Frozen 2 is really nice.
I would love to see a What If of everyone going into their "rightful" houses, or the houses they were almost put in, like Hermione and Mgonagal in Ravenclaw, Neville in Hufflepuff and Harry in Slytherin, etc.
I'm re-enjoying the episodes in the supercuts, and I love the discussion of Hermione as a hat stall because now I'm just imaging Hermione out witting the hat and I'm laughing
I definitely think putting 2-3 chapters together would be for the best. I love this podcast series but I’m so far ahead I’m starting to forget what I read
I wonder if Narcissa went to Ollivander's to reserve a time slot (so to speak) for Draco. Because it would he unfitting for a Malfoy to have to wait their turn.
Just listened to the chapter 4 section and when Lily and petunias childhood was brought up,it got me thinking. If a Squib and a muggle had a child, would it be muggleborn or halfblood?
That's such an interesting question. I suppose they could be either or both. Maybe they are something else entirely. Half muggle half squib. Such a good thought! 😊
Couple of 9 and 3/4 ideas. maybe the platform number does change, just not every year, certainly not in the time that Harry is there; maybe it happens in response to muggles discovering the platform or just so they don't get suspicious. If the platform number truly does not change then Petunia should have known the number from when Lilly went. So maybe Vernon isn't so much "there isn't no platform 9 and 3/4" but more "You are the magical one, you figure out how to get to it"
Cannot wait to watch this whole series I will probs end up listening multiple times I’ve already watched all the videos and the compilation episodes on here
A thought this podcast provoked: what would have happened if Hagrid had successfully turned Dudley into a pig? Would he have undone it before they left for Diagon Alley or would he have just left Dudley like that and Dumbledore might've come to fix it before Dudley started school? Hagrid also did that (in the books) because Vernon made him angry. Dudley didn't do anything. He was just standing there and suddenly would've been a pig. Seems mean and out of character for Hagrid to do that to an 11 yr old that did nothing to him.
Just because I thought it was great that Ben learned a scientific fact about the earth while researching Harry Potter facts here is a very short explanation for those who also didn't know that the earth has a bigger diameter at the equator than from pole to pole. It's because the earth rotates around an axis vertical to the equator and the centrifugal force makes the earth a little bit more "flat" at the poles.
At 1:39:40, J was talking about the unicorn horns not being more expensive than they should be in comparison to the hairs, and it got me thinking that maybe they’re so cheap, relatively, because maybe unicorns shed their horns like deer and rams and many other antlered animals 🤷♀️ therefore not being as expensive as you’d think seeing as you could probably just find one on the forest floor one day
Love listening to you guys!! Your explanation on candy bars was funny because I had the same realization when I went to England and got a mix of mini bars. It blew my mind because their Milky Way was just a soft toffee covered in chocolate and their mars bars are like our Milky Way ones. Always love the thought process we go through on thinking most things in HP are magical, but most are just something British that sounds foreign to us.
I love it when you mentioned the name of the wind because I hadn't heard about it until one of your videos a few years ago and I read it and loved it. Hopefully there's an audience for a similar podcast regarding the name of the wind? I know it sucks the story isn't finished and all.. but yeah I'd love to hear/see more Kingkiller Chronicles in the channel too. (Yes, I've watched the ones already made in here, and really enjoyed them :P ) Much love guys! Weather's horrible. Hope you're well, -Vini
Just looked up peppermint humbugs and learned something new as well. According to Wikipedia, humbugs are a British/Irish kind of sweets, usually flavored with peppermint. I'm not a fan of peppermint, though, to say the least. Maybe, that's why I never noticed any peppermint humbugs during my stays in London. Anyway, on the subject of learning new things: thank you for the in-depth analysis of the HP books and pointing out so many minute details I've overlooked so far!
One thing to point out about the Dursley’s leaving Harry at Kings Cross is that petunia knew about the platform from Lily and having dropped her off there when they were kids. So likely it was just the messing with Harry and seeing you do that you can get there if you really tried, but she didn’t care if he did or not.
In chapter 4 when Hagrid asked the Dursleys if they could make him some tea or if they had something stronger like alcohol. To me that was him trying to give them a chance to be hospitable and show him, their guest, even if he just came unannounced some hospitality. But he must have known that they wouldn’t do that so he then wanted to show not just Harry but also the Dursleys that he’s hospitable and that he’s capable of entertaining his guests even when it’s unexpected.
🙋♀️🍁🇨🇦🍁 Hey guys I'm in my 50's and I grew up with "humbugs" and yes they are the "pillow" cut candy's also known as square, that are red & white stripped... & peppermint flavoured. I'm not sure if it's because I have a strong mixed British heritage or if it was just a common penny candy back in the 70's and so on... I also grew up with barely candy as well which has become a rare thing to find now outside of British import shops Anyway humbugs taste somewhat like a sweeter & milder candy cane if that helps you any... Barely candy has a distinct flavour that's hard to describe... it's basically a very mild sweet taste... I know that isn't really helpful but if you ever try one yourself you'll understand 🤭 ... I just came across this series early this morning and I'm debating on binging as many episodes as possible before I fall asleep... 🤭 we'll see
"Dumbledore defeated Grindewald in 1945, and discovered 12 uses for dragon blood. He loves chamber music and tenpin bowling." I can almost picture this being read by an announcer as Dumbledore walks by, waving, at the Miss America pageant. That is exactly what those introductions are like. They describe a few important accomlishments and then end with a couple of superfluous details.
I always thought Scabbers should have been Charlie's old pet--he has graduated school and gone to work with *dragons*, feels like you might not want to take your rat lol. Also! I always thought maybe Molly gives the kids extra food in case they need to share :)
I don't know whether you have covered this or not but it would be cool to see what you think would have happened if Harry had killed Bellatrix in Order of The Phoenix
My sister overheard: "What!? A fall from a tower- killed the Longbottom's? It's a scandal!" She knows next-to-nothing about Harry Potter, but she goes "Dumbledore has something to say about that." She proceeded to leave to hang out with her friends.
Hi! There are lots of things I’ve been thinking listening to you… First, about all the Dumbledore and Hagrid thing with the wand, If Dumbledore autorized Hagrid to use magic to find Harry or if he fixed his wand, obviously the Ministery doesn’t know, and maybe Dumbledore would get in big problems. I think when JK was writing the Philosopher Stone she hadn’t think throughout the muggles thing, because in this book there are lots of good wizards talking about how awful muggles are… McGonagall at the beginning, Hagrid with “the biggest muggles”, Ron saying they have a muggle uncle but they don’t talk about him… and then she added the part about how only evil wizzards discriminate. It’s true, in the spanish translation Trevor was a tortoise at the beginning and then they changed it! I read it in spanish (I’m from Chile) and I always though that was a translation mistake. Thanks for doing this!!!
Loving this! Also question: When they're robe shopping how do they get their color coded robe and accessories? They haven't been sorted yet! So is there like a student store at Hogwarts??!?!!? LOL. They make it such an important point to get your robes fitted but then like.....???? Also Agrippa is a real person as well!!!
The color-coded robes is mostly a movie thing. Never really brought up in the books. And even so, perhaps First Years are just SOL; must wait til year two.
My theory would be that their robes and uniform could be charmed to match the colour scheme of the house they get sorted? Wouldn't seem that farfetched imo, they already have stuff like "self-repairing" spells integrated, what's some colour/pattern change?
2;52:00 chocolate frog cards are the Wikipedia pages of famous wizards and thus some nerd in their basement keeps tabs on their goings and update the cards manually. 😂
My theory about Mad Eyes eye is akin to Daredevils ability where he can "see" sound and the eye paints a full picture of everything as sound or magik possibly bounces off the surrounding area and translates it into percieved site. So Moody could see perfectly in the dark as well as the light, reveal traps and secrets and even see invisibility
The green smoke from Harry's vault could've been an enchanted item that went up in smoke if the proper password or procedure wasn't done before entering.
I think that a lot in this book was not thought through to 7 books. But on the pet thing. Percy got an owl. Owls eat mice and rats. Giving him to Ron was saving his pet.
2:06:52 I think you guys might be forgetting that Petunia knows about Platform 9 3/4 - iirc we see her and her family saying Goodbye to Lily in Snape's memories. Petunia knows that the platform's there. She won't do anything to assist Harry in finding it, but she's not completely abandoning him; she's doing the barest of barest minimums. Not sure if the author wrote the part with this in mind, though.
Thestrals make a lot more sense, but I always like imagining Hagrid using his umbrella like Mary Poppins just floating down to the cabin on the rock
LOL I love that so much more than I probably should 🤣
This is my new head cannon!!
I never even considered thestrals
Omg so funny. Plus then in goblet of fire Madam mawmzine arrives in a carriage pulled by winged horses.
If this means that they’re going to do every single chapter until the end of the books, I can consider my life complete
They are indeed!
This truly is the greatest Carlin Bros timeline we get to experience in real time. I’ve already relistened to each episode a couple times!
At the rate it’s being released though we’re looking at what a decade or two?
@@princton23 2 episodes every weekend?
They are going to do every single chapter from every single book. One chapter every week (on another channel) Will take several years to complete all the books. That 198 chapters. Meaning it will take almost 4 years. Although on this channel looks like they are putting a few episodes combined into one longer episode on this channel.
1:28:00 I have a theory about the green mist coming from Harry's vault. I believe it was the remnants of a Finite Incantatem spell. In book two, Snape uses this spell during the dueling club and it's described as "A haze of greenish smoke was hovering over the scene." Maybe when the door is opened with Harry's key, the spell triggers, wiping out defensive spells on the vault, and leaving a green mist or haze.
OOOH THIS IS GOOD I LIKE YOUR THEORY !!
Headcanon accepted!
Guys, molly asking for the platform number is just a teachable moment for the kids. Just like when you count stuff at the store with your kids, to work on their numbers. She is asking to see if they know the platform number.
Also making sure Harry overhears.
Exactly, it's like several people trying to decide where to eat and everyone has a different taste. They all know the obvious choice when someone just rhetorically says, "There's only one place we're going to find all those choices, The Food Court," which is the local place where everyone goes to satisfy multiple appetites. I never thought it odd when Mrs Weasley says, "Platform 9 and three quarters this way" and also "There's only one place we're going to find all of this, Diagon Alley." It's rhetorical conversation.
My personal headcanon is that she just noticed Harry looking lost and said that to make sure he'd know he could go over and ask for help
That's always how I read it too.
@@Caffeinated_Firefly She has like half a million kids, she would notice a lost looking boy who looks exactly like a tiny James Potter, her brothers were order members and would have known him. Even if Dumbledore didn't put her up to it, the timing is interesting considering she also knows she has to hide the platform from the muggles. It's possible someone from the school told her to be on the lookout for him, maybe even Hagrid or McGonagall.
“Keep your hair on” is a British expression meaning “calm down, stop making a fuss”.. we say it all the time! 😊
I think it comes from the times people wore wigs
Regarding Hagrid "disappearing" i also thought of a potential port key? That's a method of travel that doesn't seem to require magic being used by the traveler
Awesome!
I'm screaming it's flu powder through the phone. When you guys are talking about the dirt on ron's nose 😂😂😂
Hagrid is an AWESOME wizard! He NEVER verbalizes any spell. Always non-verbal! Many witches and wizards have trouble with that, Even TM (Volty) verbalizes most of his spells.But knowing that he can, his duel with Dumbledore in the MoM, nether DD nor TR verbelizes their spell. But back to Hagrid.... AWESOME!!!
True. But he also had to. He was not allowed to do magic so he practiced...in silence. 😢
Voldemort actually usually doesn't. You can see it's practically always nonverbal during his duel with Dumbledore. The one exception is particular uses of the Killing Curse.
And when he does use the verbal component it usually backfires.
LOL yeah if he just never verbalized his spells maybe they wouldn't backfire 🤣 (I'm kidding) @@jeremytung1632
@@lukeroberson2115I question if the unforgivable 3 can be NVBL as you have to "mean it" perfectly bellatrix
2:48:17 my theory about why Ron's robes were worse than the twins' is that, since his height is always emphasized, there probably wasn't as much choice.
Replying from the UK
HUMBUG: A hard, boiled sweet, usually striped.
MOLESKIN: a type of tight woven cotton fabric. (Like brushed cotton but heaver and tighter.) Very soft, like tye velveteen pelt of a mole. Usually worn by country folk, as it's unlikely to snag as might a looser weaved cloth.
WHELK: Marge's eating of a whelk is an odd one. Unlike escargot they're not fine dining, and you'd be more likely to find them in a working class Cokney pub, or lower class seaside resort. They're usually eaten covered in salt and vinegar, and like snails are rubbery. Also like snails they need something strong to make then palatable.
Excellent work gents!
2:00:50 This really hit close to home. I finished reading this series not long before the passing of my mother, so rereading this series really helps to remind me of a fond part of my life and calms me down so much whenever I start to get emotional
Love this new addition to the channel. Them talking about McGonagall passive aggressively sending the letters made me laugh, imagine her with hundreds of quills in the great hall all bewitched to write the same thing with that wry smile on her face lolol
McGalleon. And if you understand THAT, then you already listened to 70 episodes of insanely deep podcasting about the series a few chapters at a time. And yet, you are here, sounds like my kind of people
😂😂😂😂
Just having started with episode 4, I realized: Beside a million other what ifs, there's this really interesting one I've never considered before: What if Petunia hadn't been jealous but supportive of Lily and later married a wizard? Would've made a big difference for Harry's early years and also might've changed things between Lily and Snape.
What if: Petunia was also a witch
Less of a "what if" but I always wished Hermione had also had a sister who was just a muggle but rather than being jealous, she was super supportive. Because in many ways Hermione mirrors Lily while also being her opposite in other ways and a supportive sister would have been in line both with the mirror and the opposite. Kinda feels like it would have been a nice touch. Doesn't affect the story at all but it's there
@@ScareCrow90I believe JK at one point had drafted a sister for Hermione but scrapped the idea.
What if Hagrid was granted the position of keeper of keys so that he might have the ability to track down said monster? This would be essentially hiring Hagrid to clear his name.
I remember a fanfiction in which someone mentioned the unfairness of the trace rule and the person said "Well, the spirit of the law is that a minor shouldn't be doing magic without adult Wizarding supervision, in case they have an accident and someone needs to fix a failed spell"
... and honestly it makes sense. It's still kind of unfair, but... it does make sense. Besides, if you force the Trace onto every minor, Wizarding kids wouldn't be able to be homeschooled
Also, about the ice cream, it could be just a little white lie Hagrid said to surprise Harry with the ice cream! I absolutely can picure Hagrid being like "hehehe I'm gonna secretly buy this kid all the treats"
I like formal names in the intro. It fits the status of the books as British national treasures, the aesthetic of the set, and maybe quaint the British tv (BBC?) thematic throwback. However you want to look at it, it all feels right.
GB is the asmongold of countries. Everyone knows its disgusting and has a horrific history far worse than any other country on earth. But because they are totally unrepentant about their atrocities, and even take pride in them, nobody cancels them...
Even jk is a bigot.
National treasure you say???
Yes, Hermione has that Ravenclaw v Gryffindor discussion with the Sorting Hat. She mentiones that in OotP when everybody is so astonished she bewitched the Galleons. Some Ravenclaw says "how cone you're not in Ravenclaw", and she drops a line like "the Hat considered that for a while". I know because I just read that very chapter to my son last week.
i'm reminded of Paige from Charmed. her parents died in a car crash but she survived the same crash by automatically teleporting out of the car without even realizing she could do it.
To be fair Dedalus Diggle recognized Harry one day while he was shopping with Petunia, and he was at The Leaky Cauldron that day, even shook his hand twice if I recall.
Hagrid in Griffendoor: MacGonnagal tells Hagrid in HBP that he can represent Griffendoor while she takes the headmaster position in the last few chapters. Surely she would not let a Hufflepuff do this!
I think she remains the head of gryffindor house, she asks Slughorn to represent Slytherin as the current head of house (Snape) had flown the coop.
It makes perfect sense to me that Peter sleeps all the time. Hes suffering from serious depression, he betrayed his friends and it didnt even pay off, he then lost all protection and human to human interaction seemingly forever and on top of that he is too cowardly to kill himself. He is just sleeping due to depression
My head cannon is that Hagrid used a portkey to get to the shack on the rock. At this time Albus is still in good standing with Fudge. I'm sure he could be convinced to allow (if he would even notice because security was lax at the Ministry at that time) one to go get Harry Potter for school.
Harry actually asked Hagrid how he got there, and he says that he flew. How he flew or what on is never said, however I highly doubt that his coat, as many pockets as it has, could hide either a broomstick or Sirius’ Motorcycle.
@austinrestovic the only thing that makes sense to me is a Thestral. We are told that brooms can't hold his weight, and the motorbike wouldn't have been able to disappear
Loved the content! I’m going to listen to all of these 😂 - British people say squashy! It’s so funny when Americans are like “very Harry potter” when in fact it’s just very British 😂- Keep your hair on is a British expression, means calm down
Chapter 5- Narcissa looking at wands always bugged me. So I’ve head cannoned that since certain woods/cores are better for certain traits/magics, Narcissa was consulting w Ollivander so he could have wands lined up to try when Draco came in (spoiled brat yk) lol
The fact that Narcissa got Draco his wand meant that Draco's wand doesn't need to meet the wizard to lend loyalty.
Which makes perfect sense as to how Harry was able to get that wand's loyalty by just grabbing it from Draco's hand.
That wand will sway to anyone.
This is something that's definitely becoming my favourite thing
Cats are magical even in the Muggle world!
In defense of Neville: I have always thought he had some brain damage dating from the attack on his parents. Assuming they were attacked at home, perhaps one of the Death Eaters did something to him, or a well-meaning relative blurred his memory afterwards to protect him from the knowledge and overdid it.
I don’t think so, because Neville is for sure more talented than given credit for. In Herbology, he excels at it, so no comment, Potions, Snape is just the worst, so he isn’t great at (like every other Gryffindor), and the rest of the classes that require wands, he has an excuse because he used his Fathers wand, (the wand chooses the wizard) so he is physically limited with what he can do
It's because neville is using his father's wand. This would make sense that he is poor at wand work until he joined the DA. Its just a idea or the teachers aren't being patient with him
the platform number is easily explainable as her testing Ginny in that moment... to see if Ginny remembers because she's a child still learning about the world. the easiest answer is usually correct
Yes… but screaming it, out loud, with a group of red headed children pushing trolleys, already sticking out like a sore thumb, screaming a platform that doesn’t exist. I do believe that the international statute of secrecy would have a problem with all of that combined😅
I remember seeing a tumblr post (I think) of a head canon that Molly probably loudly announced all of this because she’s perceptive and motherly and could tell Harry was uncertain. So she makes a whole display of how it works and then ‘notices’ Harry and offers to help, providing all the options he’d need to get across safely. I liked that notion a lot!
Since you decided to talk at length about the Chamber of Secrets and Myrtle's murder, I'm surprised you didn't mention the fact that Aragog could never have been the monster attacking people, because all of the victims were always unmarked, and acromantulas are GIANT SPIDERS with GIANT FANGS that would OBVIOUSLY leave HUGE marks.
As to the question about "how did everyone know that was Harry Potter?" Well, he looks exactly like James, doesn't he? And we are led to believe that James was quite well known in the wizarding world. He was a Pure-Blood, for starters and all the pure-blood families know each other and are in fact related in some distant way.
Did you miss the point of the podcast? Sure they made references to future events but the focus of this episode is the single chapter they're reviewing
@austinrestovic Did you miss the point of the podcast? Sure they made references to future events but the focus of this episode is the single chapter they're reviewing
Having watched all the episodes separately it’s a real dilemma to decide whether or not to watch this now
How is it a dilemma? It's pretty obvious that you should watch the original and leave a like then watch this version and also leave a like.
@@needsanameedit4982I see what you did there 😂
Always assumed Hagrid used a portkey when he vanished- we know Dumbledore is more than capable of making them.
Mundungus is the one that made a sound like a car back firing. I think it depends on the wizard. I think Fred & George were excellent (they said they got their licence with distinction) they'd enjoy sneaking up on folks!!!
Your podcast is incredible guys! One of your best ideas ever! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I think Bill or Charlie might have been the first to take Scabbers to Hogwarts, going off the timeline. It's been 10 years since Scabbers first became a house pet of the Weasleys (12 years based on conversations between characters in Prisoner of Azkaban but that's not for another 2 years, so 12 - 2 equals 10), which back then would be one year before the start of the player's first year in Hogwarts Mystery (I'll treat HM as if it took place in an alternate timeline because there was no mention of Cursed Vaults in the original timeline), but that would have still been 5 years before Percy becomes a Hogwarts student. This would be Molly's 17th year going to King's Cross (I think 10th with her kids), so Ron is about 10 years younger than Bill. So Ron would have been 1 year old, Fred and George would have been 3, Percy would have been 5, Charlie would have been 10, and Bill would have been 12 when they first took in Scabbers.
Draco's wand is so perfect for the character who he had the potential to become (conflicted, outside suited for dark magic, core from one of the purest creatures) but I can imagine it going kind of like when I was buying glasses as a kid. While I was getting my eye exam, my mom was looking at frames, picked out a few that I would try, and one of them would usually fit, but I was still free to look at others. So maybe Narcissa would pick out a few that would fit someone of Draco's nature and social standing, at least to have a starting point
Did you miss the point? It would mean his wand has no allegiance to him. The wand is supposed to choose the wizard. Their mom isn't supposed to do it for them 😂
Not sure if there is a difference between the books and audio books but, it does mention that the Dursley's do get out of the car and go into the station with him. I just listened to this chapter in-between that episode and this supercut.
Ben, I loved your observations of how Fred and George take after their dad. Both don't mind bending the rules. Both enjoy inventing things and finding out how stuff works and improving upon it.
Chips in the U.K. are not what we call Chips, but rather Fries, so the Chips bags, would be grease covered paper bags from a fast food shop. They would otherwise say Crisps.
My copy says they have packets of crisps
New headcanon: the people who made the Nimbus 2000 were in fact founded in 9 BC, and they started with flying carpets.
Hermione DEFINITELY chose her house. She says it in the 5th book when she was talking about the charmed coins and was asked why she wasn't in Revenclaw. She says that the hat considered it but put her in Griffyndor. She left out that she asked for it. Like Harry always does when he reveals that the hat considered putting him in Slytherin.
How do you know that if she left it out? 😂
In book 1, she flat out says she wants to be in Gryffindor when they're on the train.
Although Kings Cross doesn't have a car park in front of the station there is a car park that is linked to the station. The car park is located on Canal Reach and has 231 public car parking bays. There are 6 bays with electric charging points on level 2 next to the lifts, of which one is a disabled bay.
I find it hilarious that snaps notes from his time as a student are a better teacher than himself as a teacher
Chapter 5: didn’t Hagrid in book 7 during the seven potters chapter say ‘thestrals and brooms can’t hold me weight you see?’
I love love LOVED the walking challenge this summer! I figured I’d get most of my distance done at a music festival in July. In my head it was a done deal, it was set in STONE that GotJ was going to be the boost I needed to finish the race. But, come to find out… I do a LOT more walking in my daily life than I ever realized and I ended up finishing (I want to say) about a month before the festival. I’ve been using a step counter ever since and it’s honestly done wonders to my confidence. Thank you.
I wish they do these more then just Sundays. It's going to take years to finish all the books. I would like 2 a week. But I'm going to still listen too
Yes nearly 4
198 chapters
How wonderful that we get something consistently for the next long while.
That will truely make my 40th Birthday a magical Birthday. Hopefully, I will have time for episode 3, chapter 5 and beyond while enjoying my own Birthday gifts and time with family, plus a meal out in the evening. Can't believe I have less than a week of my 30s left. This is possibly, one of my favourite chapters in Sorcerers Stone or philosophers Stone book 1. I love the lead up in chapter 3 to when the magic truely gets started in this chapter. I thought the episodes focussed on 3 chapters per episode though, not just one, given that chapters 1 to 3 were last weekend's episode.🎉
The neat thing about the illustration,I found, is that the frog doesn’t just fit with the chocolate frog, butthead fact that Neville has lost his frog/toad so much in the chapter.
I am Swedish. So it is funny that one of the best YTchanels´s podcast is #1 in Sweden .
According to Google, peppermint humbugs are a real-world hard candy with a toffee center
I thought the dirt on the nose was a reference to them being poor. Also, later on, Ginny has a pygmy puff.
21:11 - I can imagine Hagrid just sticking his head to the window and friendly asking to speak to Harry and hand him the letter while Petunia is getting traumatised from his sudden appearance.
As a Swede I can confirm we are big Harry Potter fans! And Frozen is also very popular. They actually do decent job representing Scandinavia and I think especially the inclusion of the Sami people in Frozen 2 is really nice.
I would love to see a What If of everyone going into their "rightful" houses, or the houses they were almost put in, like Hermione and Mgonagal in Ravenclaw, Neville in Hufflepuff and Harry in Slytherin, etc.
They did a series on what if Harry was in Slytherin but the others would be cool as well
I'm re-enjoying the episodes in the supercuts, and I love the discussion of Hermione as a hat stall because now I'm just imaging Hermione out witting the hat and I'm laughing
"You 'might' trip on a stalagmite" is how my science teacher made it stick. Of course he gave the "other ones hold 'tight' to the ceiling"
Hagrid flew using the Mary Poppins Method: Umbrella
I definitely think putting 2-3 chapters together would be for the best. I love this podcast series but I’m so far ahead I’m starting to forget what I read
Talking about chocolate frogs, whe have a classic candy here in Chile called "sapito" literally "little frog"... it's actually really good xD
I'm so happy. I had to work today and you guys will get me through 😊
I love the intro, it feels like a book club meeting 🤗
I wonder if Narcissa went to Ollivander's to reserve a time slot (so to speak) for Draco. Because it would he unfitting for a Malfoy to have to wait their turn.
6 chapters down, 13 to go in this book. After that, hold on to your wands and brooms because we have a long way to go.
I think the weather thing is just in case the owl comes back delayed or like battered looking. That way there's an explanation for it
“We are officially… in…the wizarding world.” Benjamin C.
Start of chapter 5 and Ben is channeling his inner Macho Man! 💪🏽👌🏽😂
Just listened to the chapter 4 section and when Lily and petunias childhood was brought up,it got me thinking. If a Squib and a muggle had a child, would it be muggleborn or halfblood?
That's such an interesting question. I suppose they could be either or both. Maybe they are something else entirely. Half muggle half squib. Such a good thought! 😊
@@hleebeg the obvious name option is “Squiggle” 😂
@@Synthesyn342 oooooh!! I love that!
Couple of 9 and 3/4 ideas.
maybe the platform number does change, just not every year, certainly not in the time that Harry is there; maybe it happens in response to muggles discovering the platform or just so they don't get suspicious.
If the platform number truly does not change then Petunia should have known the number from when Lilly went. So maybe Vernon isn't so much "there isn't no platform 9 and 3/4" but more "You are the magical one, you figure out how to get to it"
Cannot wait to watch this whole series I will probs end up listening multiple times I’ve already watched all the videos and the compilation episodes on here
A thought this podcast provoked: what would have happened if Hagrid had successfully turned Dudley into a pig?
Would he have undone it before they left for Diagon Alley or would he have just left Dudley like that and Dumbledore might've come to fix it before Dudley started school?
Hagrid also did that (in the books) because Vernon made him angry. Dudley didn't do anything. He was just standing there and suddenly would've been a pig. Seems mean and out of character for Hagrid to do that to an 11 yr old that did nothing to him.
Since kilometers deep under London doesn't make much sense, I always read it as kilometers wide. So, really big.
Blunt force trauma to the head while going 80 mph is going to kill a wizard
Just because I thought it was great that Ben learned a scientific fact about the earth while researching Harry Potter facts here is a very short explanation for those who also didn't know that the earth has a bigger diameter at the equator than from pole to pole. It's because the earth rotates around an axis vertical to the equator and the centrifugal force makes the earth a little bit more "flat" at the poles.
Resident brit here.
King's Cross Station does have a car park, several infact. There just not open air
At 1:39:40, J was talking about the unicorn horns not being more expensive than they should be in comparison to the hairs, and it got me thinking that maybe they’re so cheap, relatively, because maybe unicorns shed their horns like deer and rams and many other antlered animals 🤷♀️ therefore not being as expensive as you’d think seeing as you could probably just find one on the forest floor one day
Love listening to you guys!! Your explanation on candy bars was funny because I had the same realization when I went to England and got a mix of mini bars. It blew my mind because their Milky Way was just a soft toffee covered in chocolate and their mars bars are like our Milky Way ones. Always love the thought process we go through on thinking most things in HP are magical, but most are just something British that sounds foreign to us.
I love it when you mentioned the name of the wind because I hadn't heard about it until one of your videos a few years ago and I read it and loved it. Hopefully there's an audience for a similar podcast regarding the name of the wind?
I know it sucks the story isn't finished and all.. but yeah I'd love to hear/see more Kingkiller Chronicles in the channel too. (Yes, I've watched the ones already made in here, and really enjoyed them :P )
Much love guys!
Weather's horrible. Hope you're well,
-Vini
Just looked up peppermint humbugs and learned something new as well. According to Wikipedia, humbugs are a British/Irish kind of sweets, usually flavored with peppermint. I'm not a fan of peppermint, though, to say the least. Maybe, that's why I never noticed any peppermint humbugs during my stays in London. Anyway, on the subject of learning new things: thank you for the in-depth analysis of the HP books and pointing out so many minute details I've overlooked so far!
I believe hagrid was speaking metaphorically about harry having his name down since the day he was born
You guys really need to do a quiz that is multiple choice; Wizarding world, or just British.
They didn't snap Newt's wand when he was expelled when a beast attacked. When he was covering for Leta LeStrange.
One thing to point out about the Dursley’s leaving Harry at Kings Cross is that petunia knew about the platform from Lily and having dropped her off there when they were kids. So likely it was just the messing with Harry and seeing you do that you can get there if you really tried, but she didn’t care if he did or not.
I just got back to the bit where malfoy barges into the compartment and Peter Pettigrew does the one good thing in his life and bites Crabbe.
In chapter 4 when Hagrid asked the Dursleys if they could make him some tea or if they had something stronger like alcohol. To me that was him trying to give them a chance to be hospitable and show him, their guest, even if he just came unannounced some hospitality. But he must have known that they wouldn’t do that so he then wanted to show not just Harry but also the Dursleys that he’s hospitable and that he’s capable of entertaining his guests even when it’s unexpected.
🙋♀️🍁🇨🇦🍁 Hey guys I'm in my 50's and I grew up with "humbugs" and yes they are the "pillow" cut candy's also known as square, that are red & white stripped... & peppermint flavoured. I'm not sure if it's because I have a strong mixed British heritage or if it was just a common penny candy back in the 70's and so on... I also grew up with barely candy as well which has become a rare thing to find now outside of British import shops
Anyway humbugs taste somewhat like a sweeter & milder candy cane if that helps you any...
Barely candy has a distinct flavour that's hard to describe... it's basically a very mild sweet taste... I know that isn't really helpful but if you ever try one yourself you'll understand 🤭 ...
I just came across this series early this morning and I'm debating on binging as many episodes as possible before I fall asleep... 🤭 we'll see
"Dumbledore defeated Grindewald in 1945, and discovered 12 uses for dragon blood. He loves chamber music and tenpin bowling."
I can almost picture this being read by an announcer as Dumbledore walks by, waving, at the Miss America pageant.
That is exactly what those introductions are like. They describe a few important accomlishments and then end with a couple of superfluous details.
"Keep your hair on" is British slang used to tell a person to not become too excited or upset, John.
George (ChosenNightwolf)
I always thought Scabbers should have been Charlie's old pet--he has graduated school and gone to work with *dragons*, feels like you might not want to take your rat lol.
Also! I always thought maybe Molly gives the kids extra food in case they need to share :)
How can you consider Mars bars a muggle-sounding name? "Mars is bright tonight."
J named his sons after Nick and Nate Diaz?! 🤜🏽💪🏽😂
I don't know whether you have covered this or not but it would be cool to see what you think would have happened if Harry had killed Bellatrix in Order of The Phoenix
For starters, no Cursed Child.
So I already love your idea.
My sister overheard: "What!? A fall from a tower- killed the Longbottom's? It's a scandal!"
She knows next-to-nothing about Harry Potter, but she goes "Dumbledore has something to say about that." She proceeded to leave to hang out with her friends.
Hi!
There are lots of things I’ve been thinking listening to you…
First, about all the Dumbledore and Hagrid thing with the wand, If Dumbledore autorized Hagrid to use magic to find Harry or if he fixed his wand, obviously the Ministery doesn’t know, and maybe Dumbledore would get in big problems.
I think when JK was writing the Philosopher Stone she hadn’t think throughout the muggles thing, because in this book there are lots of good wizards talking about how awful muggles are… McGonagall at the beginning, Hagrid with “the biggest muggles”, Ron saying they have a muggle uncle but they don’t talk about him… and then she added the part about how only evil wizzards discriminate.
It’s true, in the spanish translation Trevor was a tortoise at the beginning and then they changed it! I read it in spanish (I’m from Chile) and I always though that was a translation mistake.
Thanks for doing this!!!
I really love the Christian elusions.
Loving this!
Also question: When they're robe shopping how do they get their color coded robe and accessories? They haven't been sorted yet! So is there like a student store at Hogwarts??!?!!? LOL. They make it such an important point to get your robes fitted but then like.....????
Also Agrippa is a real person as well!!!
The color-coded robes is mostly a movie thing. Never really brought up in the books.
And even so, perhaps First Years are just SOL; must wait til year two.
My theory would be that their robes and uniform could be charmed to match the colour scheme of the house they get sorted? Wouldn't seem that farfetched imo, they already have stuff like "self-repairing" spells integrated, what's some colour/pattern change?
2;52:00 chocolate frog cards are the Wikipedia pages of famous wizards and thus some nerd in their basement keeps tabs on their goings and update the cards manually. 😂
My theory about Mad Eyes eye is akin to Daredevils ability where he can "see" sound and the eye paints a full picture of everything as sound or magik possibly bounces off the surrounding area and translates it into percieved site. So Moody could see perfectly in the dark as well as the light, reveal traps and secrets and even see invisibility
The green smoke from Harry's vault could've been an enchanted item that went up in smoke if the proper password or procedure wasn't done before entering.
I think that a lot in this book was not thought through to 7 books. But on the pet thing. Percy got an owl. Owls eat mice and rats. Giving him to Ron was saving his pet.
2:06:52 I think you guys might be forgetting that Petunia knows about Platform 9 3/4 - iirc we see her and her family saying Goodbye to Lily in Snape's memories. Petunia knows that the platform's there. She won't do anything to assist Harry in finding it, but she's not completely abandoning him; she's doing the barest of barest minimums. Not sure if the author wrote the part with this in mind, though.
I always thought Hagrid probably used a port key, which is why he was keeping an eye on the time and knew he had to leave Harry quickly.