I enjoyed watching this so much! I am taking a class on American Lit and we are studying Emily Dickinson. This a wonderful concise analyses. Thank you for sharing.
It's very sincere and deep interpretation of this poem! You are spreading a good idea of self worth - the most essential thing we need to keep in mind in this crazy world. Thank you, dear !
Thank you for your sweet interpretation of this poem. We need enthusiastic "teachers" to help us "get" the poem. I could not fathom Shakespeare....wish I had someone in my life that was a nerd of the bard. All the secrets and meanings of his props and prose..... Just all the little nuances of the stirred up caldron....that brew would just make more sense...and maybe get someone interested to investigate....but I guess that is a lot of work! I am up there in age...but have been "craving" poetry....better late then never....I will see what else your channel offers. What is the book you wrote? Thanks...
@@mzmz8354 I've heard both, I think the original is advertise but saying banish makes the meaning more clear in modern English since how the language is interpreted has changed some since her time
When reading this poem I imagine a very playful and cheeky spirit emerging from a cloud of purple smoke to test my progress on the path toward ego death and illumination.
As a fellow lesbian who is also Neurodivergent I identify with this poem a lot. It makes me wonder what Emily was thinking about when she was writing about how no one could know who she really was. Was she living such a rich inner life that she didn't need anyone else? Was she referring to the women she had secretly dated and had fallen in love with? Or perhaps did she have that innate feeling of just knowing she wasn't like everyone else but, she didn't have words to explain it? I don't know but, I feel that she was reaching out for another person who was living in secret almost begging to find someone else that feels like no one special. Is she being sarcastic when she talks about how dreary it is to be a person full of clout, blowing their hole but not really saying anything of substance?
im somebody for others, but to me im nobody. i feel dark around me like im always lonely in my mind but my body is there being crowded like i am someone i have identity out there
Thank you alot for that great explanation for that great poem, but please, could you add written explanation to your videos just to help english literature students from different cultures and different languages speakers, just like me🤣
I’m Nobody! Who are you? Are you - Nobody - too? Then there’s a pair of us! Don't tell! they'd advertise - you know! How dreary - to be - Somebody! How public - like a Frog - To tell one’s name - the livelong June - To an admiring Bog!
I am so tired of being told-- "Nobody cares!" that I finally said in 2020, "You're right! I'm nobody! and I care!" So I ran for President of the United States of America under the name "Nobody" as well as running for Sheriff of Hamilton County, Ohio, USA under my legal name Brian Schuh. I lost
Great question thank you for asking it. I think that those lines represent fogs when they're making noise in the swaps and others watching them. Meaning she's making fun of the people who talk a lot, "making meanigless noise", are the center of attention and others, a swamp, admiring them. Maybe it's the equivalent of modern day Kardashians hhh they're in the spot light but it doesn't mean that it's a good thing or they're doing good with it. She's making fun of them and those watching/admiring them saying who could possibily want that.
Thank you very much for your interpretation of "I'm nobody". Maybe you'll like my setting of this poem, which I recorded together with my singing partner Laura in my little home studio. You can find the recording at this link: ua-cam.com/video/ZCq4Tb-7wjk/v-deo.html You can find a live performance of this song by Laura and me at this link: ua-cam.com/video/G-8DjozOnRg/v-deo.html
I do not mean to be contentious, but I must ask: if you wanted people to love frogs, would you DISSECT one for them? Or would you, instead, expose them to a beautiful living one. Poetry and logic...sigh...are not friends. It's like magic---if you explain how it's done, the wonder disappears. It's like humor---if you explain the joke, it isn't funny. You lost me with "presumably because the addressee..." I applaud your love of poetry, but...no, please don't think that killing and dissecting it serves it. It doesn't. You could, if you threw out the book of logic, talk about this poem in a wonderful way, and I hope you find your way to treating poetry with the kind of respect it deserves for the very nature of how poetry functions....
'Thank you' from a Nobody to another Nobody. Keep sharing more like this.
I enjoyed watching this so much! I am taking a class on American Lit and we are studying Emily Dickinson. This a wonderful concise analyses. Thank you for sharing.
I love how eloquent you are! I understand the poem now. Thank you for explaining the poem.❤️
This video is so lovely and interesting to watch, thank you!
It's very sincere and deep interpretation of this poem! You are spreading a good idea of self worth - the most essential thing we need to keep in mind in this crazy world. Thank you, dear !
that mean a lot to me, thank you
Thank you for your sweet interpretation of this poem. We need enthusiastic "teachers" to help us "get" the poem. I could not fathom Shakespeare....wish I had someone in my life that was a nerd of the bard. All the secrets and meanings of his props and prose..... Just all the little nuances of the stirred up caldron....that brew would just make more sense...and maybe get someone interested to investigate....but I guess that is a lot of work! I am up there in age...but have been "craving" poetry....better late then never....I will see what else your channel offers. What is the book you wrote? Thanks...
I’m obsessed with your passion! 😍
thank you!
Love your book collection.
Beautifully explained.
One of my favourites.
I am nobody are you nobody too? Then there is a pair of us, don't tell or they will advertise you know?
Is it "they'd banish us"or is it "they'd advertise us"?
@@mzmz8354 I've heard both, I think the original is advertise but saying banish makes the meaning more clear in modern English since how the language is interpreted has changed some since her time
I like how you analyze the poem of one of Emily Dickinson great poems and i like how you explain it.
Thank you so much for explaining
When reading this poem I imagine a very playful and cheeky spirit emerging from a cloud of purple smoke to test my progress on the path toward ego death and illumination.
2:15 to hear poem again
Beautiful explanation with a beautiful person 🙂
Love your interpretation of the poem😎
thank you!
This is greatt
The back story is amazing ! Good job girl
thank you!
As a fellow lesbian who is also Neurodivergent I identify with this poem a lot. It makes me wonder what Emily was thinking about when she was writing about how no one could know who she really was. Was she living such a rich inner life that she didn't need anyone else? Was she referring to the women she had secretly dated and had fallen in love with? Or perhaps did she have that innate feeling of just knowing she wasn't like everyone else but, she didn't have words to explain it? I don't know but, I feel that she was reaching out for another person who was living in secret almost begging to find someone else that feels like no one special. Is she being sarcastic when she talks about how dreary it is to be a person full of clout, blowing their hole but not really saying anything of substance?
Love this. Thanks so much
Thanks
Nice interpretation! Love it!
im somebody for others, but to me im nobody. i feel dark around me like im always lonely in my mind but my body is there being crowded like i am someone i have identity out there
i wanna read it
thanks!
My fav.
Rania 😊🥰 i know you you know my grampa❤
I can't understand your speech bit i love your enthusiam. Saludos desde Montevideo.
Nice job -
Thanks for sharing
I understand it very nicely ❤️❤️
Please!! Analysis the forbidden fruit by Emily Dickinson 🙏
So hard to grab it
Thank you alot for that great explanation for that great poem, but please, could you add written explanation to your videos just to help english literature students from different cultures and different languages speakers, just like me🤣
Only after death do we get some partial Melody that we were trying to hear, but nothing is lost when the end result is the same.....
Very interesting
Thoughtful
Thanks I need ir for My homework :D
i'm only here for answers thank you
thank u so much !!!
Very helpful thanks
happy to hear it
I’m Nobody! Who are you?
Are you - Nobody - too?
Then there’s a pair of us!
Don't tell! they'd advertise - you know!
How dreary - to be - Somebody!
How public - like a Frog -
To tell one’s name - the livelong June -
To an admiring Bog!
I am so tired of being told-- "Nobody cares!" that I finally said in 2020, "You're right! I'm nobody! and I care!" So I ran for President of the United States of America under the name "Nobody" as well as running for Sheriff of Hamilton County, Ohio, USA under my legal name Brian Schuh. I lost
Hey, Rania. I am also Rania. I am Rania Rattile Himi from Bangladesh. 🌸🌸🇧🇩🇧🇩
How did she eat - she never came out of her room? Good question- she didn't
What is the outro music?
I have tow questions I will be happy if you answered them.
what does it mean “like a frog” and “to an admiring bog.
Great video ♥️👍🏼
Great question thank you for asking it.
I think that those lines represent fogs when they're making noise in the swaps and others watching them. Meaning she's making fun of the people who talk a lot, "making meanigless noise", are the center of attention and others, a swamp, admiring them. Maybe it's the equivalent of modern day Kardashians hhh they're in the spot light but it doesn't mean that it's a good thing or they're doing good with it. She's making fun of them and those watching/admiring them saying who could possibily want that.
@@RaniaAttafi wao soo very well explained. I had the same q.thanq so much
Thanks from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
No she tunisia i knew her be cause im attafi to
Thank you very much for your interpretation of "I'm nobody". Maybe you'll like my setting of this poem, which I recorded together with my singing partner Laura in my little home studio. You can find the recording at this link: ua-cam.com/video/ZCq4Tb-7wjk/v-deo.html
You can find a live performance of this song by Laura and me at this link: ua-cam.com/video/G-8DjozOnRg/v-deo.html
Funny - some say 800 - some say 1700 and some say 1800 poems - which one is correct? WE - - - - HOPE - - - to know the TRUTH - - - - some - - DAY
I do not mean to be contentious, but I must ask: if you wanted people to love frogs, would you DISSECT one for them? Or would you, instead, expose them to a beautiful living one. Poetry and logic...sigh...are not friends. It's like magic---if you explain how it's done, the wonder disappears. It's like humor---if you explain the joke, it isn't funny. You lost me with "presumably because the addressee..." I applaud your love of poetry, but...no, please don't think that killing and dissecting it serves it. It doesn't. You could, if you threw out the book of logic, talk about this poem in a wonderful way, and I hope you find your way to treating poetry with the kind of respect it deserves for the very nature of how poetry functions....
Did I miss the analysis? I don’t believe there was any..
Why does Emily call herself a nobody in her poem?
love this please do more poems with exp[anation !
Please kathrina min poem analysis , bon courage
i'll keep it in mind :*
Are you married!! 👰, 😂 😂.. Love from Indian occupied kashmir.. ♥ ♥
I am not a body. Are you a soul as a well. How dreary
I think she had a eating disorder - very common today in 2023 -
Not really an analysis. Lots of talk but few insights.
Beautifully explained.
Thanks