How Rose of Versailles Made Berserk BETTER.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 жов 2024
- I decided to read what could possibly have been the biggest influence on the manga Berserk, which is never discussed. A Shoujo manga meant for young girls.
Thank you for watching! Subscribe to stay up to date on the latest videos. Cheers!
Socials 📸
/ mugenattanno
Outro Song by Five V
• Guts Theme - Berserk L...
#berserk #shoujo #kentaromiura #frenchrevoloution
![[UA] NAVI vs MOUZ | BO5 | IEM Rio 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CMBYk0cbGoA/mqdefault.jpg)
"I'm a big fan of berserk and if you're watching this you must be too" no I'm here for Rose of Versailes
preach
😂😂😂 I am a massive fan of both!
@@marleythechangling9779 same!
Having watched the Rose of Versailles anime I can definitely say Oscar definitely inspired Miura to create Griffith. As well as the Golden Age arc especially the court politics and the different wars were very much taken from Rose of Versailles.
Fact: Oscar was inspired by Bjorn Anderson, who was very popular in Japan.
The Rose(s) of Versailles is one of the best manga ever.
Sadly new fans are not ready for that conversation...
The Rose of Versailles is one of the darkest manga of its time, presented in a shiny golden wrapper, flowers and sparkles. The story development is masterful and the brutality of the narrative creeps slowly as the story progresses; culminating in a beautifully horrifying depiction of the French revolution.
Also the fact that each character have their motivations which make them develop their own schemes and all of them interwine with each other makes the story events so much intriguing and interesting
If you dig even deeper, Oscar’s design and bishonen in general draw much from Death in Venice (1971) actor Bjorn Andresen’s appearance. His fame from the film messed up his life for quite awhile - there’s a whole documentary about this out recently. You may have also seen him recently if you watched Midsommar (2019).
Oooh didn’t know this, what’s was the name of the documentary?
Riyoko ikeda's works have changed my life so much
would very much love to read more of her work
@@mugenbop I recommend oniisama e(dear brother) ! It's another one of her most brilliant works!
YES PUT SOME RESPECT ON OSCAR ❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥🌹🌹🌹
I recently read all of rose of Versailles and while I can most definitely see the inspiration to Griffith. I feel there was also a lot of inspiration into casca as well that is a bit overlooked to a lot of people, casca unintentionally has the same role of Oscar, being a woman who decides to disguise herself as a boy and soldier. She also shares similar struggles to Oscar later in the manga of falling in love with men who she can’t get married with, even having the similar wording of struggling with her longing to be a women but never able to truly be a princess like charlotte, yet also never able to fit in the role of a male soldier at times because she’s a women (her having trouble in battle when her first period comes) this is while not as explicit as oscar’s is similar in the core.
I also saw the love dynamics between more modern characters of berserk like Franese also gained heavy inspiration especially with her way of having crushes on men she can’t have. (trying to get with serpio who is brother and guts who loves casca)
Overall I really liked the series, for really pushing the boundaries of a romance story. (believe me, if I tried to draw the love triangle of this story it’s more like a web)
I’m surprised anyone can understand you. Almost everything you wrote is unintelligible.
@@lisamona6208 absolutely true! I would also add that many scenes between guts and casa are drawn from berubara. A couple fo example: when casca collapses because of her period, guts feels compassion for her because she is a woman in such a tough world, it’s directly taken from berubara where oscar collapses because of the exhausting shifts in patrolling the assembly room, and André feels compassion for her because she needs to stretch her physical ability that far. Also, in the sex scene casca shakes because she’s afraid of having sex with guts and leaving her older self behind, directly resembling Oscar fearing sex because it’s her first time and she needs to finally allow herself to be a woman and vulnerable with André ❤️ both stories are amazing, and berubara has really built a durable legacy in manga, animation and popular culture in general.
You should remember that he also took inspiration from Guin Saga and many Gekiga, which were non settled on demographics beyond breaking taboos and commercial taboos.
Shoujo and Jousei are manga demographics that are extremely underrated and crucial in the development of the most critically important shonen and seinen manga.
Berserk definitely took some ideas from Rose of Versailles and with good reason, that anime is a masterpiece!
This is very interesting. I love both series and never got to make those connections between them. And it's great to see Miura did actually acknowledged taking from it. Rose of Versailles can easily make it into a manga top 10, highly recommended.
"Under the sign of the musketeers" aka "Sous le signe des mousquetaires" was one, i watched a lot... but my GF had me lookup Rose de Versailles cuz Lady Oskar still is a badass old show of our youth... lookup up DEMETAN... lots of similarities in the dark themes of Demetan's world
I really enjoyed the video dude !
The Mangaka of rose of Versailles Riyoko Ikeda is a real genius, especially how the characters are portrayed each character has their own unique characteristics without putting a facade or making it about stupid "gender" stereotypes/roles.
I find it really interesting and really like the philosophy of rose of Versailles.
The work itself is really outstanding including the fact that its modern and wasn’t really "addressed" in that time line.
Nowadays It’s quite hard to find anime related to this type of content cause as you expected the anime industry also changed over the time but well that’s another topic.
It’s quite a shame that the shoujo genre doesn’t really have a "big" recognition compared to the shonen genre.
Anyways to keep it short if you really enjoyed berserk and rose of Versailles then I can only recommend revolutionary girl Utena to you.
Dude this anime is such a beautiful masterpiece that I cannot describe it in words.
Revolutionary girl Utena is also heavily inspired by rose of Versailles tbh the best way to describe it to you is that it’s "like" berserk however in the shoujo style.
In my opinion the antagonist in revolutionary girl Utena is even more horrific since the antagonist is so realistic and is likely to commit such crimes, which is so cruel to see that you cannot really do something about it.
I don’t wanna say to much about it cause it’s really worth to see and give it a try ^^
It's like Griffith and Utena are two sides of the same Oscar coin.
We can see that Griffith is a corrupted image of Oscar (he ready to lose all nobility, dignity and virtue for his dream) Utena is an evolution of the sad image (she doesn't have "gender" issues, her hair is long and pink, we can see her legs, she doesn't hide her femininity but still keeps noble and princely image)
Both series, Berserk and Utena, talks about power and dreams but in a different light and in a different manner (in my opinion Utena is better as work of fiction and even tops Evangelion by presenting social revolution, clear conclusion and actual quite smart messege to deliver for audience)
Wow, what a HOT TAKE
@@arlekino0792 I definitely agree with you !
I really like the similarities in both characters and how they are portrayed even though they seem to be have the same „characteristics” they rather tend to show it off differently.
They aren’t portrayed as this „look I’m just a copy paste of Oscar” but rather have Oscars presence & „appearances” it’s like Ying and Yang.
This is one of the most creative videos essays about manga/anime I've encountered. Subbed
Thanks man :)
I’ve been reading some 70’s Shojo lately, and yes, I do see it as an influenced in Berserk. This one is on my tbr list. Very nice video!
Hope you enjoy it! Very good still as I'm reading it also has historical basis so if you find learning about it in a fun way this does that too :)
@@moominkomet just go for it, berubara is such a foundational story in so many ways!
the rose of versailles is a masterpiece.
"Under the sign of the musketeers" aka "Sous le signe des mousquetaires" was one, i watched a lot... but my GF had me lookup Rose de Versailles cuz Lady Oskar still is a badass old show of our youth... lookup up DEMETAN... lots of similarities in the dark themes of Demetan's world
9:09 When he showed the scrin from the manga and Oscar shouting "To Bastille", I was like "oh no...". Having finished the anime a few days ago I still feel a peng of sorrow just by remembering that part😭😭😭
Very interesting. I'm an huge Berubara fan and it's very important to discuss how this manga influenced and continues influening today's manga.
It’s crazy reading/watching Rose of Versailles as a huge Berserk fan. You see all the different ideas, scenes, and characters that Miura directly took inspiration from in Berserk’s Golden Age arc. I was floored by just how many I was finding my first time through Rose of Versailles.
There could be endless references to Berubara (the japanese nickname for versailles no bara) in bersek. If Griffith is androgynous like Oscar in his physical appearance, Casca is the woman warrior who more directly resembles Oscar in her character. Like Oscar, casca fights in an army, and goes from an infatuation for someone who does not love her back, Griffith, to loving someone like guts who she initially oversaw but who’s kind, cares for her and loves her back. Oscar initially loves Fersen, however her love is unrequited. Then Andrè, her childhood friend and aide, companion and sort of bodyguard, manages to express her love for her, but she does only sees him as a brother figure. However towards the end of the story she gradually accepts and reciprocates his love, and spends a passionate night with him, very much like casca with Guts. Also, during the scene of the court ball she changes her battles clothes for an evening gown, where she shows her more feminine looks, in a scene where she clearly resembles Oscar dressing up as a woman for a court ball. Finally, Guts losses an eye during the eclipse trying to rescue Casca, similarly to Andrè who, in protecting her, loses an eye during a fight he gets involved into because of her.
"Under the sign of the musketeers" aka "Sous le signe des mousquetaires" was one, i watched a lot... but my GF had me lookup Rose de Versailles cuz Lady Oskar still is a badass old show of our youth... lookup up DEMETAN... lots of similarities in the dark themes of Demetan's world
You had me at "it was pretty good" and berserk. GG.
That is so cool! I have not read either books yet, but initially i was definitely more inclined to read rose of versailles because berserk seemed too gory? I'm definitely picking up rose of versailles asap now and feel more comfortable reading berserk after! Thanks for your info and knowledge!
i love how i looked up rose not berzerk so thanks for oddly being my introduction to someone actually talking about what it is besides just violent, still probs wont read it bit hey glad you enjoy it
"Le petit castor" , "little beaver" was another japanese -quebec french.
Also we got early 1990s "Uchuusen Sagittarius", aka : "Les aventuriers de l'espace" ... both were dark shows. "Remi sans famille" , "Remi without family", with his dogs n monkey was a dank kids show as well
Когда я смотрела Берсерк, мне показалось, что он чем-то похож на сёдзё. Когда я посмотрела Розу Версаля, мне показалось, что она чем-то похожа на Берсерк. Офигеть, не ожидала, что мои предположения подтвердятся!
Did you saw Rose of Versailles anime series. It made anime masters of all time. I know Berserk is another masterpiece, but believe me.
No I may one day for sure :)
The background music in rose of Versailles anime is so touching it adds a lot to the feeling and the drama
i never read berserk but i will now
"Under the sign of the musketeers" aka "Sous le signe des mousquetaires" was one, i watched a lot... but my GF had me lookup Rose de Versailles cuz Lady Oskar still is a badass old show of our youth... lookup up DEMETAN... lots of similarities in the dark themes of Demetan's world
Both work are masterful tell this day i re- read it all over again.
I pass throw this video and watch it, I press a like 🥰
A lil bit about Oscar.
Everyone LOVES Oscar: men, women, royal guard, nobles, commoners, childhood friend and even kid! Why I emphasise on kid? Because !manga spoiler! lil prince of France sad to Oscar that he loves her. After his death Oscar made a bitter joke that she could have become a queen of France if not the circumstances. After that fact I started to suspect mangaka about "mary sue" stuff. (> - >)
Nice video, also I think you accidentaly copied the description from your vagabond vid btw
I sure did haha
Just want some guidance, between shoujo & josei and shonen & seinen which demographic has the best manga's?
I mean that’s subjective up to you of what you want, if you want edgy morally grey characters try seinen and some shonen like aot and chainsaw man. If you want power Fantasy try shonen and shoujo, hardcore drama and shit try josei but at the end of the day they kinda all mix nowadays outside their demographics
@@mugenbop thanks but well. some people said shoujo and josei manga's better than shounen and seinen, so yeah..that's why im asking.
70's and 80's shoujo and some josei manga are so freaking good!!! They are nothing like you would expect for manga targeting the female readers. It's a complete different universe compared with what Shojo manga is right now. The stories were soooo deep and emotional, and at the same time contrversial and tragic. Check Riyoko Ikeda, Moto Hagio, Keiko Takemiya, Sumika Yamamoto, etc.@@Ravenizsche
Seinen is pronounced as say-nen btw
lol the ffxiv music