Audi A4 Avant vs Volkswagen Passat Estate vs Skoda Superb Estate | Head2Head
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 чер 2024
- Practical estates make a great alternative to high-riding SUVs if you need to carry a family and bundles of luggage. I pit the latest Audi A4 Avant against the smart VW Passat Estate and the spacious Skoda Superb Estate to see which deserves a place on your shortlist.
Subscribe to carwow on youtube -
ua-cam.com/users/Carwow?sub_c...
Awkward haggling is a thing of the past with carwow. Choose your perfect car with our configurator tool and let the country’s best dealers compete over you. Compare the five best offers by price, location and dealer ratings and choose the one that’s right for you - no hassle, no haggling, just a great deal.
Visit our site to save money on your new car - www.carwow.co.uk/ - Авто та транспорт
The Skoda is so big. My children in the back are in a different time zone!
How does this comment only have 3 likes?
I like the Passat
I traded my Superb saloon for an Octavia Estate mainly because we couldn't hand the kids bottles of water and snacks from the front seat on long drives!
@@ronnienes xddd
NZ police just changed to superbs and I think size had alot to do with it considering the issues they had with the latest (and last) commodores.
Spec the Skoda with xenon headlights, 17 inch wheels and black color and it will look like it's twice the price :)
MyRealName And led lights..
No, I mean xenon and 17 inch. You can get xenon headlights and LED daylights (the small ones). 19 inch means more noise and less comfort.
before ou order your Superb in black take a look at Dragon Skin: www.skodacommunity.de/media/20161113_133117-1.42122/full
19 inch are way too big. Tho u prob want those if u have a small penis. Haha.
No but seriously 19s will seriously sacrifice comfort
MyRealName And driving it will still be less comfortable and more noisy.
Interior: Audi. Exterior: Passat. Value: Skoda
Franciscoman22 Agreed
Franciscoman22 How can Skoda have a better value if the engine and all the parts are made and manufactured by Volkswagen. Also to 90% the same as VW. The Irony 😂
Abdullah Chaudhry that's why it has value! It's the cheapest and offers more than sufficient attributes leading to great value for money compared to the other two. As you said it also shares components, and is one the most practical/spacious contenders. Win - win!
Sir Sparco Aaaaah. you meant It that way. That makes totally sense! I had interpretated it the wrong way!
Abdullah Chaudhry No worries man😅
I like these 3 Volkswagens :))
😂
😅😅😊😊
Mat thank you for your brilliant reviews, they are both positive, informative 🙂
The servicing costs on the SKODA are excellent with my local Service Centre.
One of my friends had to replace one of the short, moulded rubber engine hoses in his Audi A4 and was quoted £115.00 from the Audi garage....
When he took the same part to the SKODA garage they quoted under £50.00 for the same part,... using the same OEM Part Code.
I love Audi's,... but for me, badge snobbery doesn't support such a high profit margin.
That passat is damn beautiful
Skoda in White or Black, LED headlights, black pack and 19 inch wheels... it looks better than the other 2 as long as it's not the poverty spec version like the one in the video
Jurgen DX, and the Audi A4 and Passat look like $200K cars as well in their best fitting specs. I mean:
res.cloudinary.com/carsguide/image/upload/f_auto,fl_lossy,q_auto,t_cg_hero_large/v1/editorial/volkswagen-passat-206-tsi-r-line-2017-%284%29.jpg
Jurgen DX still has that Skoda badge tho..
I have driven the Laurin-Klement spec (The highest one here in Slovakia) and I was surprised how well it looked. Although I was pretty disappointed with road and wind noise. Lots of older and cheaper vehicles have better soundproofing than this top-of-the-line Superb has.
@@kalpeshshelat Yeah the passat looks not really good especially on the I want to die or sleep it's the same here shape and interior. It's probably the worst of the three inside design wise...But it's ok for older people.
The picture you posted...looks like a 1.6 tdi with rims, no thanks!
@@Jack13853 These cars are for grown ups, go watch Honda Civic videos
TL:DR -
The Passat is almost identical to the Skoda and costs about 4 gran more, If you got the money go for the Audi, it's definitely worth it, if not, the Skoda does a hell of a job for it's price.
I dont have money so i bought used Audi
@@MrStefano218 I dont have the money so I brought a oldish newish passat
Matan Frenkel I don't think they're even that comparable. The A4 is significantly smaller than the other two
Looking for a big boot, I would consider the A6 only against the Superb, the A4 is not in the same league.
They should have compared the A6 estate with those two others.
I just bought the Superb L+K combi diesel 4x4, DSG, 190hp and it's ABSOLUE best value for money. Great review, keep it up. ;)
For the value, Skoda all the way, the space in that thing is absolutely incredible. One of the reasons for me to keep driving skoda. Plus, the infotainment system keeps getting better in and doesnt lack anything for me personally anymore.
I drived the skoda superb 2016 with black color 19 inch rims look is just epic best value for money interior look good and its high quality I was amazed by car just epic...
what a good review!!
keep doing it!
thanks Mat
I seriously think the Superb is the best looking here. (or the least dull in this case😂)
Alain Noël Molengraaf Dude, That horrible paint job and those halogen headlamps is absolute shit. How can you prefer it?
Magicman Youre right the red doesnt suit the car but in another colour it is much nicer
its actually really spicy
hence the name of it :)
IMO the best are: Skoda from the front, Audi from the back, and VW from the inside...
I think we would need an update on this. :)
Skoda wins even tough: Mat didn't know a digital driver's display and lever folding rear seats were available, the car looks awesome with a better paint LED lights and bigger wheels, and the Superb was super low spec being compared to two already more expensive cars that had even more kit added separately. Bravo Skoda!
There are no lcd dashboards and led headlights in Superba.
Both of those options are available in Germany for the Superb
I went from an E-class to the Superb. No regrets! Ridiculously good value. I felt silly not to.
I went from an A6 saloon to a Superb Sportline hatchback. No regrets either. The Audi was lovely but the Superb really isn't that far behind at all anymore. It's also had fewer problems.
I've wanted a Skoda for a while now. I drive an old Passat and I've been thinking of an upgrade. This video pretty much sealed the deal for a Skoda.
The most eye appealing to me is definately the skoda. It's beautiful in its simplicity. People complain that the new volvo's s90 makers focused on front and interior and didnt care about the rear (which in my opinion is beautiful). But Audi fanboys dont mind that everysingle new audi looks exactly the same on the outside? It like they have spent all their money on the interior and just to make it not insanely expensive they put a dull and very common audi body.
you're not gonna be seeing the outside of the car when you're driving it, which is what you'll be doing most of the time because you know.. you bought the car to drive it
I like the Passat
I have the Audi, but really, the Superb is really a great car.
Because thats the car he wants. The Skoda is a car he needs...
Tak1 I've recently replaced my 2014 Skoda Octavia with a new Audi A4 and can easily say there's not much the Audi is doing better than the Skoda... Skodas are great cars, comfy, spacious and great value for money. But driving an Audi is much different and I'm not talking about badge snobbery... you can feel you're driving a premium vehicle because of the design, the quality of materials, the sound insulation... it's not always all about how much money you can save. If you need a roomy, honest family car then Skoda is the best on the market. But you're looking for something a bit more special, Audi is fantastic. I have the virtual cockpit and it's just amazing. The whole car looks very modern and hi-tech, I have supple Nappa leather, real aluminium everywhere and in general quality is great.
I have a Skoda, but really, the Audi is really a great car... :)
It looks great on paper. But when you drive it you Will be reminded of the Price difference. I mean i own an audi a6. And when i drove the superb it felt cheap, noisy and awkward to drive. I would defo go for the audi a4
I like the Passat
Woohoo! Even happier I just got my Skoda Superb estate!
I'm thinking of buying one how have you got along with yours so far?
@@1905tommy HI, Eric. Got it serviced a couple of weeks ago. No problems. I am really pleased with it. Loads of room (the envy of my climbing buddies in that respect) and even better when the back seats are down. I'm thinking of adding a piece of padded ply to level up the back a little for car camping. The diesel engine is nippy enough for me (I'm 67 but have always been a fan of utility vs speed). I have the green version which has an economy display histogram (optional of course to have it on) that encourages you to be a frugal driver and change up to avoid hammering your fuel. I treat it as a challenge and keep an eye on it. The car hasn't given me an ounce of worry, apart from scraping my plastic bumper on the kerbs outside my house - the car is quite low slung and the kerbs unusually high. I am quite used to the fuel-saving cut out when stopped at lights, and restarting automatically as soon as I depress the clutch. I would not hesitate to recommend this car.
@@TerryMcGearyScotland thankyou really appreciate your in depth review very helpful 🙂
Nice! Hope you happy with the car :D
miljan zbork Still delighted with it , thanks Milan. I even featured it in a ‘boot cam’ clip yesterday when I was piling my hiking gear inside its cavernous boot.
A lot of the features you praised the audi for can be specced on the passat and superb too. (electric tailgate for example). Also, why not get the LED front lights for the superb? It would look so much better! :D
ThinkCleverAndSmart Superb also have LED headlights in higher eq packs
the audi has it stock.. like the only thing the audi had specced that i noticed, was the electronic seats(but not even the S-line ones) and the virtual cockpit..
336 Bhp Skoda Superbs beating you at the traffic light
Thanks for the video, great as always. One inquiry, if possible, for future videos, I always see your videos but I don´t take reference about the fuel economy in mpg, could you say also in l/100. Thanks anyway.
Comparing the Superb in its lowest specs... Too bad
my dad got his VW Passat s 2.0 TDI bluemotion estate just before Christmas, 15,000 miles later he still likes it! 👍👍👍
Claas 650 it is a passat it is a vw man any thing vw is op i know the feeling because i to own a vw
There's a noodle hanging off Matt's nose at 1:00 :D Did anyone else notice?
tadaaaaa
Laughed way too much at this. Back to first grade. ( :D XD )
i was a bit surprised too :D .. dont mind me im just wobbeling here
?
Jan Kubec Didn’t see it
Here in Iceland a Superb with a few extras (similar to standard passat) is only a little bit cheaper, however the A4 is much more expensive than the Passat, IMO a superb with a few extras is the best bang for the buck, but I would prefer a loaded Passat over a basic A4
You need to consider what all comes as standard with A4.
@@radekmraz1432 the A4 doesn’t come with much more as standard than the others
Go for the bigger wheels on the Superb and it looks the best imo
but does it have a satnav that takes you straight to Poland?
care to elaborate?
@@stacia6678 XD, those 3 cars are from VAG group, Volvo is not !!
Jeremy Clarkson would be Proud...
@@user-hv3xv4xs6j probably WW2
Underrrated
I remember my dad owned the 2008 or 9 superb salon and even there the leg room in the back is ridiculously big i was a kid so i could literraly strech my legs during long trips
These were the best types of reviews, need more like this again!
Excellent analysis. Love the video 🙏🏻💪🏻🙌🏻👏🏻
8:56 that's not matt
You sure?? Think it's just the lighting.
how do you know that the guy's name isn't mat?
Looks like a sad Ricky Gervais
Looks like Bronn from Game of Thrones
no shit
I like it, reviewing cars that aren't almost the exact same price but help decide how much you should spend.
great review! just what I was looking for.
if you go for the skoda in the Sportline or Laurin & Klement8 specification its looks just as posh!!
agree and the price is competitive
i have fully loaded new Passat and i work for Audi so i drove Audi A4 alot, i also tried Superb and frankly speaking u feel why Audi cost more, materials, and how they are put together, comfort of suspension and sounds from it while driving on worse roads, i just hate those suspension sounds when Passat or Superb has bigger wheels (18"->..)
Fax
Passat for me, Superb is good as well.
angus20715 w-w-what about Audi?
@@emmahamilton6413 I like the Passat
i bought the 2016 passat 4 matic with 190 ps getting it next week can’t wait
First class review, really enjoyed it.
I think the passat looks absolutely amazing. Nothing exciting, nothing boring. Its perfect.
I just bought a 2014 estate VW Passat executive tdi bmt 2.0litre diesel this week top spec, full leather, heated seats, sat nav, parking sensors etc.... One of the best cars i have ever owned!
are you still happy with the car?@@MedievalRichard
@@FjornFjall he sold it😅
The Superb with the large alloys and the sportline option definitely will look posher
VW best all rounder I think
I love my Passat sportscombi
Great review... for me i just want a Skoda Superb Scout 🔝🔝🔝
Bit of a weird development, in the previous generation the superb would have been hands down the most premium feeling of the bunch and still is a very nice place to be for traveling today.
I don’t know why people still call Skoda the budget brand? I know it had the reputation but today, the Kodiaq is way better and feels far more premium than the Tiguan. The Superb and Passat are so identical in terms of quality. What’s so budget about what’s basically the same thing with a different badge?
Loving the wagons! Passat for me.
Should've included the SEAT Leon ST as well. I honestly think the two less premium brands of the V.A.G (SKODA and SEAT) offer a better all round package and dare I say it, better styling.
Something Sumting leon st is not in the same class, its a rival for the golf or an a3
@@kevintjeuh8888 yeah but also superb is not a4 and passat (B) chassis, it’s A6 chassis
0:48 _"VW has done an alright job to make sure this big-ol' box doesn't look totally mind-numbingly dull"_
Wait, I don't get it. Come again...?
1:54 _"VW has done an alright job to make sure this big-ol' box doesn't look totally mind-numbingly dull"_
OK, now I get it. Thank you! :D
Did you sit in Laurin & Klement version of Skoda Superb? Is quite nice inside
I bought my 2016 Superb on the strength of this review and interestingly many of the features Matt focused on in the Passat are also present on the superb, like the bag hooks in the boot. the parcel shelf works the same way too and in the MMI you can set it to either open or stay closed when the hatch is lifted.
Other thigs I like - the ability to change headlights from LH to RH mode when driving in Europe. The umbrellas in the door cards. It's compatible with Android Auto and Apple Car play anyway so the 'premium' entertainment system of the A4 is less of a draw. The 2x rear heated seats were a big bonus for the kids and the 18" wheels make it look much more premium.
I have to ask - shouldn't the Audi be represented by A6 Avant in this comparison, in regards to the boot size?
Driving a Passat with the dials as a screen, I must say, with the the map on, I really love it. It's not too bright at night either, and in the sun, you don't have to worry about not being able to see the screen information. The only annoying thing is that with polarised sunglasses, you have more difficulties reading the screen, but that's the only complaint.
Can you do an updated one one of these cars
Hey Matt can we get a comparison video between new BMW 3 series, Mercedes C class 2019, Audi A4 and the VW Passat?
Your comparing a base model Skoda Superb with the others ....bring in the L&K and it's a whole new game !
#TeamSuperb. Cough 280bhp version
Brother
280 for the top engine.. What a joke ;p dont waste your money and get an audi where the top engine gets you more than 500 bhp ;)
@@AhmedThaking where tf a normal a4 has 500 hp
@@stfu7079 he is obviously talking about the RS4
If the first comment said the 280bhp version which is the VRS
The 500bhp I'd obviously going to be the RS4.
Ahmed Tha King how can you even compare a Audi rs4 with a Skoda superb. There is a 60000£ difference! It’s like comparing a Ferrari to a Dacia. Such an irrelevant comment.
That was really cool looking forward to more videos like this
When you said buying cars on PCP I was slightly confused
Can you compare the A4 to the Superb. I thought the A6 and Superb share the same chassis. And I have to disagree with you on looks. I think the Superb looks far better than the Passat.
PS I have a Superb. I took it for the luxury (SE L Executive). I can carry the in-laws, their lapdog, two very large dogs, a dog push chair for the lap dog. We have a tonne of room, it's very comfy for long journeys to the sea side.
Curiously, I've never noticed any road or wind noise with my 2.0 DSG Superb (it's a 2018, which is the same mark)
Superb cannot ever be better than the Passat, I mean it is a nice car too, but come on, it will never ever be better than the VW, it just will not be, there needs to be some hieararchy between the models inside the VAG.
@@dusanmihajlovic4732 I think you misunderstand. I was talking about the market. Audi have the A6 and the A4, skoda the Octavia and the Superb, VW have the Passat. So what I am saying is that large exec car market is the A6 and Superb. The large family car is A4, Octavia and Passat. If you compare the interior size of the Superb and Passat, for the cost you'd be a mug to go for the Passat, it's almost the same, the gizmos maybe not the very latest, but it's all the same mechanical parts.
To me comparing the Octavia and Passat is a fairer comparison especially if you want to make a brand hierarchy.
As a point where do you think Seat sits?
Octavia goes with Golf. Superb goes with Passat. Phaeton has been turned down so cannot find a comparisment to it. It should have been an A8. Now you got Arteon which goes with A5 according to many but in newest model you have a Shooting Brake Arteon. Should I compare it with A4 variant?Just not. Should I compare it with A6 variant, maybe, maybe not. With Superb? No mate. What I want to say is that inside the groupation there is no rivalires between the car makers, and everyone knows their position. There could never be that an engine suplier can be worse that the one who gets their engine or to have a car that is a higher class model than what his engine or parts supplier has. What about Touareg and Kodiaq with 2.0? What about Tiguan and Karoq? What about R models? Also on the other side, cannot compare for example VW's R models with Audi's RS models... What the truth is that every car has its own costumers and it is planned to be like that. Superb is a nice car again, and I wish you many many more miles with it, cheers!
what is wrong with engine choices in the uk? There are a lot more petrol engines than diesel engines available for the Passat here in Germany.
Felix O. - VEOTech Yea it is a bit ironic considering that VW are spending most on petrol engines these days.
I reckon we'll see a petrol version in the UK sooner or later.
Felix O. - VEOTech They would get more choices if they would drive on the other side of the road.
We have more petrol (2 or 3) than diesel (only 1) Passat models in Australia as well. And we are right hand drive like the UK.
@@murraysampson2501 but you're upside down! so it balances out
Love your channel! Can you please do a test of 4WD systems. BMW vs Audi vs Volvo vs Mercedes.
Great review!
I Really Love The VW Passat. And I love its design the most!
Hey VW bring skoda to the USA!
I wish you would tell us the actual capacity of the boots in Litres instead of just abstract comparisons between the models. It would be useful to know to the parcel shelf and without.
The dripping snot at 6:02 is epic! :D
6:03 got some snot hanging out of your nose mate :)
Just saving it for later.
thelahcen1 hahaha well spotted!
"tada!"
Finally comparsion of Skoda!!
There is a petrol version of the Passat. The GTE. Admittedly it's a hybrid but if you do a lot of short journeys and the occasional long one it could make more sense than a diesel.
I just bought a 2014 estate VW Passat executive tdi bmt 2.0litre diesel this week top spec, full leather, heated seats, sat nav, parking sensors etc.... One of the best cars i have ever owned!
Idk man. Toyota Camry hybrid is pretty good
The Skoda seems to be the best choice,it's a mix of the other two but cheaper.
I think that skoda superb in better gear is from outside nicer that vw Passat. Let's google skoda superb in laurin and klement or in sportline with 206 kw engine.
Nero CZ, let’s google the VW Passat in Arctic white, with the R-line package as well!
res.cloudinary.com/carsguide/image/upload/f_auto,fl_lossy,q_auto,t_cg_hero_large/v1/editorial/volkswagen-passat-206-tsi-r-line-2017-%284%29.jpg
@@kalpeshshelataaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand it looks boring
@@EqualsDeath and skoda looks waaaay more boring...it doesn t look like a sport car , it looks like a grandpa car. Passat is way more premium and faster. Skoda looks so basic...
12345 6789 Passat been looking basic and the same for 20 years. I should know, I own one.
@@kalpeshshelat I've got the 2019 arctic white ,18 inch wheels ,panoramic roof, tinted windows and alcantara sport seats,led headlights love it
That check engine light at 3:42 hahah
The B5 generation Passat wagons have flip-forward rear seat cushions which let the seat backs fold all the way down for a flat load floor. Has this very desirable feature carried into the current generation?
Superb interior looks like Passat B7 interior quite a bit
That's because they share the same platform, interior (including the engines).
I'd have the Passat. It looks mature. I prefer an estate car to look a bit boring
Really nice vid!
Had a Superb as a courtesy car recently and was really impressed - only thing that let it down for me was it was so noisy.
Picked a shit spec Superb, i sell them and you need to go for SEL+. Comes standard with Full leather, xenon headlights, led drl's, nav, electric tail gate (like in the Audi) oh and handles in the boot to pop the seats down like the other 2 list goes on. Like i say a shite spec
JT Williams got to make the Audi look good
I think they were really pushing the value for money card with this spec Superb.
JT Williams 7
the audi had nothing in it aswell... all the cars were pretty much stock
They can still pull the value for money card if they raise the value up a bit further with a decent spec.
With a couple of small kids, the additional space of the Passat or Superb is more important than the prestige/luxury of the Audi. But if you have the money and don't need the space, the Audi will put a smile on your face if you see it waiting in the parking lot. The other two are very good at taking you from A to B, but lack the fun factor.
You mean snob factor?
If possible, in your future reviews can you please indicate if soft touch materials are used on the doors where my hands are likely to rest rather than just focusing on materials used on the dash where as a consumer my hands are least likely to interact with regularly,thanks
LOVE the check engine light is "lit" on the Audi!
How oblivious are people nowadays? That's because the ignition is on but the engine is off.
very good comparison, three really good cars, three good options, but i pay more for the a4 due to sofististication, design, and quality. But TFSI better than TDI
The Passat is not diesel only. You can get it with a 1.4 and 2.0 liter TSI petrol engine.
Depends on the market, really.
In europe, the avant starts at 34k Euro and it's the basic model with fwd and a sloppy engine. For 36k you can get the Skoda superb combi laurin&klement, with very premium interior, AND the 2.0 tsi engine, 4x4, dsg transmission and 280 hp! It goes from 0 to 60 in 5 and a bit seconds. That's just a ridiculously amazing value for a premium car that's very capable and very practical. And Skoda seems to also be a very reliable brand.
good concept for a comparison
Should you not be comparing the A6 Avant instead of the A4?
Yea no, that car is ridiculous expensive compared to the two other
I agree. The chassis size is completely wrong for a comparison
Am I the only one who likes the look of the superb over the passat?
yes, u are the only one
Nope your not the only one
You got reversable booth floor in skoda too and trunk door that opens from the button..
I'd go for an old X type estate with the 4 wheel drive cheap reliable and great badge
Tbh i don't like to have a Head2Head between a premium brand and 2 uhhh how do i put it? Standard brand? Anyways, it makes the test feel unfair because of that, even if the Skoda won.
Surely the Skoda Octavia and Golf estate are more suited rivals to the A4 space wise?
Ruben Jennings that is correct
eeexactly
but not price wise.
No No. The C class estate and 3 series touring are more suited.
Mr Smith I mean within the VW AG
for the Audi price you can equip skoda with xenon, 18 inch rims, leather seats with ventilation, 9 inch infotainment system and 2 liter TSI engine which will have 220hp compared to audi's 1.4 tsi with only 150 hp.
We need more estates in the states!
*Superb is Superb*
And audi is audi and vw is vw..
Skoda is the cheapest car from vag group...
I think the Passat looks the best
I have one with the R line package and I think it's stunning.
Flaviu Daniel Audi looks far more better,then comes Passat and then the Skoda
audi for the looks passat and skoda for the practicality and insignia sports tourer if u want both :P
Yes in this trim the Passat is a more clean cut and slightly more modern than the AUDI, which certainly does not fair well in red - and the AUDI will benefit visually from having larger wheels - The Passat somehow does not really need it.
All Audi cars look the same from front. Even BMW has more front variety than Audi, even with the same exclusive grill. If you remove the Audi badge, you just get a worse looking, slightly premium feeling, less practical car over a Passat. Skoda looks and feels cheap tbh. Not like a VW should. Passat is the only buyable car here. Better alternatives to Audi by BMW and MB. Cheaper alternatives to Skoda by Dacia, Suzuki, Peugeot, Hyundai.
Hey Carwow and Matt, can you do this again for 2020?
Just get the Skoda Superb 280 estate. 0-60 in 5.3 secs, and 260km/h top speed. Perfect.