there is a geological formation up the Escalante river in Utah, long ago engulfed by the rising water of Lake Powell as it was filling in the early 1960's. It was beautifully depicted in Eliot Porter's photographic work, The Place No One Knew, which documented many sites that were soon to be engulfed. It is called Cathedral in the Desert. I discovered Debussy's piano La Cathedrale engloutie at just about the same time '63 ... forever linking the beauty of the location and the music played so well here.
There can be no life without water; it is an absolute. For me, there can be no classical piano music without Helene Grimaud. Here she brings her unequaled talent to this program like water to a parched and thirsty land. Thank you, Helene.
I first heard this piece of music when I was about 8 years old... and it haunted me and still does some thirty something years later... so moving, so beautiful... and she has played it here so enchantingly, it made the hairs stand up on my neck and my eyes water... just perfect...
Fresh interpretation on a great piece, her playing is as always impeccable. And she gives something to the piece. Which is more than you can say for most pianists who seem to think dinamic markings and phrases should be played like it sounds on a computer notation software. Honestly this is my favorite interpretation of this piece.
Beautiful interpretation. Very soft even in the middle, but Grimaud makes this work well. I love her tone and phrasing. Her 2 against 3 at 2:38 is wonderfully done, and it's hard to get that just right.
I agree, but honestly I don’t think this 2 against 3 is even close to challenging for her (and I would say for any professional pianist )😅 Still, I love her interpretation, which is the major difficulty here
My dogmatic thought . This is music of requiem for the late crew of the battleship that deep bottom of the sea lie . The thought of genius Debussy is incalculable to me . I'm just impressed by listening to this masterpiece on incomparable performance . From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun . Which are you watching this from ？
How interesting! I like the orchestra version of this music. I always imagine it as battleship Yamato at the bottom of the ocean. Then modern exploration submarines attach large balloons to Yamato. The Balloons fill with air and the ship lifts from the bottom of the ocean. As the music becomes louder, Yamato rises faster and faster, until its prow breaches the surface of the sea. The ship explodes out of the ocean, and water sprays everywhere because of the impact. Other ships all around look at the great old battleship float again. The golden chrysanthemum at the front, still shining in the sun.
@@mariorossi9655 Marvelous ！ You are great ！ Thank-you ， thank-you so much to your wonderful and respectable reply ！ Japan is cherry blossoms in full bloom . But all banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom having gorgeous Bento ， delicious foods ， treats and drinks is self - restraint by Coronavirus infection problem . In Tokyo , the going out of night , bar ,snack , night club , karaoke shop , department store , Saturday and Sunday are self - restraint. It's is a very pity that we just watch cherry blossoms in full bloom . Someday please please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom having gorgeous Bento ， delicious foods . Tokyo is full of surprises ， mystery and pensive feeling . Take care of yourself Good luck ！ See you again .
@@garypotter1985 Thankyou A corner of cicadas and autumn frail lifes insects buzzing and Quiet without traffic noises and streets beggers and various dusts of Tokyo 🍱🐮🎑🍢🌸🎋🌊🍙👺🎏🎎🍓🍜🥋🍘🍄🗡️🍒🗻🥢💮🥟🎍🍾🍚🐝🏯🍥🎆⛩️🐈🎇🎌🇯🇵 TheseEmoji絵文字are things unique to Japan 🎇is Japanese graceful and graceful and unimaginable and beautiful fireworks 🐈is famous Royal Hachikou忠犬ハチ公 🍥is Narutoナルト a friend of Raamen拉麺ラーメン
The path to perfection is long and hard ! As a reward-lllumination!!! Comes down in a simple formulation Nothing super flous, like a briliant PROSTATE'
Le chemin versla Pefecition est long et difficile! En r'ecompense-lllumination!!! Se re'sume en une formulation!!! Simple. Rien de superflu, comme dans le Brilliant PROSTATE'
Самые прекрасные мгновения всегда полны грусти, чувствуеш, что они мимолётны, хочется их удержать, а это невозможно... Беру Ваше ☀️ в ладошки и умываюсь
É difícil expressar em palavras a magia dessa musica nas mãos angelicais dessa pianista! O universo de Debussy é exotico.É uma harmonia que vem de encontro com os sons da natureza.É o que sinto!
Beautifully played. The sound is not very good but she understands the music and makes it hers which is what it's all about. I don't see what's "aggressive" about her playing at all as someone commented below.
My soul is sinking ! Where is the destination ？ Heaven or hell ？ I am immersed in pleasure while listening to her exquisite performance . From Tokyo in Japan where deeply loves Debussy . Which national are you watching this video ？
@@Rita-di2ny Sorry the very late reply ！ Thank-you very much to your reply ！ Now Tokyo is the hustle and bustle with Coronavirus infection ！ All schools are rest for a month . Be careful with Coronavirus infection. Avoid unnecessary and urgent outing and crowds , and wash your hands frequently . There is a shortage of masks around Japan . Just talking is infected within 2 meters . Take care of yourself Good luck ! Someday please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom .
@@victorjuansotomayorvargas4196 Sorry the very late reply ！ Thank-you very much to your reply ！ Tokyo is the hustle and bustle with Coronavirus infection ！ Be careful with Coronavirus infection ！ Avoid unnecessary and urgent outing and crowds , and wash your hands frequently . There is a shortage of masks around the world containing Japan . Just talking is infected within 2 meters . Take care of yourself Good luck ! Someday please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom .
@@shin-i-chikozima мне чеснок помогает, надгрызть зубчик и по бровям, вокруг глаз, ноздрей и по губам, и так несколько раз, С молитвой о здравии разумеется. Периодичность маска-процедуры подскажет ваше самочувствие. Рецепт пришол на ум от Бога, когда вспомнил, что читал, про эпидемии чумы с халерой средних веков, там правда маски-колпаки покруче были. Да и при кашле, просто держать зубчик чеснока, во рту, изредка его прикусывая, особенно когда кашель спать недаёт. СпасиБоБожий антибиотик мне надёжно помогает.
This song transcends the range of human evaluation . Her performance is incomparable and exquisite . 🍎 From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan in winter . Which national are you watching this video ？
I can't believe that there is fools on this earth who disagrees with this wonderful performance . These fools are same as the stone or the mud in which they do not have the feelings as the man and the function .
Last night I've played concert. Small, corona chamber atmosphere. I played Haydn, Clementi and Debbusy. After concert I took off my concert suit and went home. Quiet and peacefully. At home I couldn't sleep so, In some quatter of night I turned on my player and first in the row was Ravel piano concerto played by the Helene. My God, I felt in love in every single note that she played. Maybe I fall in love.....
And considering the piece here is about the Sunken Cathedral, which from time to time rises above the water at low tide (it's an actual legend in France), I find the intro quite befitting here.
Sus comentarios machistas no interesan a nadie. Si se tratase de un hombre, también comentaría su aspecto físico? Ya está bien de juzgar a las mujeres en relación a su físico!! No es amabilidad, es puro machismo por el cual confunden capacidad con atracción sexual y reducen a las mujeres al mero objeto de su deseo. Hay que empezar a pensar con el cerebro en vez de con la entrepierna, por muy educada que usted crea que la tiene!!😠
Hmm... so now Im curious for the music in the beginning. I came here for debussy but now Im left wanting more of that introduction. Anyone know where can I find more of it?
Yeah mate, at first I was like "this aint no sunken cathedral... what is this...? Its... its.... woah. Idk what it is but i want MOAR" :P Its just so quiet and peaceful but kinda sad too
Madame Grimaud, je vous écoute depuis longtemps. S'il vous plaît essaiyé de ne plus faire cette respiration car sur les cd on les entend beaucoup. Mais vous ête ma pianiste préférée. J'èspère que je pourrai vous entendre à Toulouse bientôt. Merci pour tout le bien que vous m'apportez.
Si l'on entend la respiration dans les enregistrements, c'est plutôt une question de placement et de choix des micros. L'interprète doit-il s'effacer au profit de la musique "pure"? Je pense plutôt que ce l'on appelle "silence" n'existe pas, notre cerveau filtre en permanence les sons "parasites"
@@elultimosonador3958 Thank-you Which is your country ？ Take care of yourself Good luck ！ Be on the alert for Coronavirus infection ！ I am drinking my favorite Budwiser
En fait c'est un projet expérimental d'où sa manière particulière de jouer qui combine musique et nature.Tout ça est une question de goût.Maintenant pour dire qu'elle ne maîtrise pas bien Debussy's faut être plutôt gonflé :D. Elle sait jouer la pièce de manière académique mais elle a décidé dans ce projet de faire autrement c'est malin.Elle se plante très rarement,tout ce qu'elle fait est voulu et calculé dans ses moindres détails. Il faudrait peut - être lui dire après un de ces concerts :" Dis Hélène,je pense que ton attaque là est un peu trop agressive,tu devrais y aller plus doucement"....Ah ah.Vous voulez pas lui offrir un métronome non plus?pfff :D.
,,То, что Бог нам однажды отмерил, друзья, увеличить нельзя и уменьшить нельзя Постараемся с толком истратить наличность, на чужое не за'рясь, в займы не прося" ( OmarHaiam Октуально для ступ еней 1048-1131г.) А избранным всегда! Иначе Самосовершенства
Problème de tempo dans la 1ere page, les blanches sont nettement trop rapides, ca tue tout l'effet, et la montée n'est pas belle du tout. Les nuances beaucoup trop fortes. Bref, très moyen, écoutez plutôt Rubinstein, Arrau ou Cortot...
Honnêtement pas sa meilleure performance. Elle transmettre hâte et malaise, tout le contraire de ce qui est demandé dans cette pièce (Debussy dit "profondément calme"). L'effet des cloches n'est pas bien exécuté. Les doubles croches sonnent encombrées et pas nettes (3:29) Il suffit d'écouter Michelangeli, par exemple, pour comprendre la différence dans ce passage crucial. Bien sûr c'est une pianiste d'élite, mais je suis un peu déçu de cette interprétation.
Elle est généralement merveilleuse, mais pas ici... ce n'est pas grave. Personne n'est parfait, elle est pardonnée. Comparez avec Benedetti Michelangeli (par exemple) vous comprendrez.
КРЕСТЬЯ'НИН И ЛИСИ'ЦА Лиса' 🦊 крестья'нину одна'жды говори'ла: ,,Скажи' кум ми'лый мой Чем лоша'дь от тебя' так дру'жбу заслужи'ла. Что, ви'жу я, она всегда' с тобо'й? В дово'льстве де'ржишь ты её и в хо'ле; В доро'ге ль - с нею ты, и часто с нею в по'ле; А ведь из всех звере'й едва' ль она не все'х глупе'й,, - ,,Эх, ку'мушка, не в ра'зуме тут си'ла! - Крестья'нин отвеча'л - Всё это суета'. Цель у меня совсе'м не та: Мне ну'жно, чтобы' она меня' вози'ла. Да что'бы слу"шалась кнута',, И.А. Крыло'в
Uh, je n'aime pas du tout ! Son interpretation a completement ratée la dynamique de la pièce et par conséquent le climax qui arrive quelque part vers la deuxième minute a disparu. I don't like it at all. Her interpretation has completely missed the dynamics and so as a consequence the climax that arrives somewhere around the second minute has disappeared.
I agree. And the phrasing is disjointed, the tone erratic. Debussy's extraordinary piece simply falls apart. This is a great disappointment. To hear how Debussy's piece can be played I would suggest the performances by Reine Gianoli or Yvonne Léfébure, which were uploaded to UA-cam in 2012, but have been heard far too infrequently. Or Dominic Piers Smith's 2007 performance at the Yamaha competition. All get it wonderfully right. Edward Kilenyi's 1950 recording is remarkable. And of course there are always the absolutely astonishing performances by Cortot. Or the superb performances by Gieseking, Arrau, Nelson Freire, Michelangeli, Richter, Pletnev, Zimerman. The Debussy piece has some truly magnificent interpretations. It is very sad that this is not one of them.
Всё, что здесь нравится мне, ума не хватит перечесть, пока что... А вот декорация оставляет желание её улучшить... И вот портрет Ваш как то промелькнул Уж очень слабый Будто совсем дитя старалась Но тем не менее ПОХОЖ
What agressivity ... Quelle agressivité ... Cette interprétation venant d'Hélène grimace devrait être plus douce normalement 😕 This interprétation coming from Hélène Grimaud should be softer normally 😕
What's your favourite recording of Hélène Grimaud?
Brahms- piano concerto no 1
Janacek In the Mists - from the album Water.
Every key she touches is magic. She is a living mousai (muse). As far as I am concerned, this question is unanswerable.
Rachmaninov - Piano Concerto 2
J.S. Bach/Busoni Chaconne, I think she made it come alive.
there is a geological formation up the Escalante river in Utah, long ago engulfed by the rising water of Lake Powell as it was filling in the early 1960's. It was beautifully depicted in Eliot Porter's photographic work, The Place No One Knew, which documented many sites that were soon to be engulfed. It is called Cathedral in the Desert. I discovered Debussy's piano La Cathedrale engloutie at just about the same time '63 ... forever linking the beauty of the location and the music played so well here.
There can be no life without water; it is an absolute. For me, there can be no classical piano music without Helene Grimaud. Here she brings her unequaled talent to this program like water to a parched and thirsty land. Thank you, Helene.
Glad that she played Debussy at last. I remember she said in an interview that Debussy's music is 'too beautiful' to her.
Do you remember which interview was that?
Actually the word she used is 'too pretty'
www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/classicalmusic/3585562/The-pianist-whos-leader-of-the-pack.html
Thats's a beautiful interview. Thanks!
I first heard this piece of music when I was about 8 years old... and it haunted me and still does some thirty something years later... so moving, so beautiful... and she has played it here so enchantingly, it made the hairs stand up on my neck and my eyes water... just perfect...
Fresh interpretation on a great piece, her playing is as always impeccable. And she gives something to the piece. Which is more than you can say for most pianists who seem to think dinamic markings and phrases should be played like it sounds on a computer notation software. Honestly this is my favorite interpretation of this piece.
This piece is achingly beautiful. What a transcendental performance!!
Beautiful interpretation. Very soft even in the middle, but Grimaud makes this work well. I love her tone and phrasing. Her 2 against 3 at 2:38 is wonderfully done, and it's hard to get that just right.
I agree, but honestly I don’t think this 2 against 3 is even close to challenging for her (and I would say for any professional pianist )😅
Still, I love her interpretation, which is the major difficulty here
A great pianist, very expressive, emotional and superb technical skills.
such a cool piece! I chose this piece to do for my college junior recital wish me luck
Hi Grace, I believe in luck, and I believe that w/ luck, and w/ your dedicated practice, you will achieve the performance of your dreams. 🍀
Oh my godness what a fantastic pianoplayer Helen G, is. This is outstanding in every way, as the music from that era as well.👍
Such presence in the moment and deeply felt performance.
Wonderful 🥰 And Helene Grimaud is a such a beautiful woman 🧚♀
superbe interprétation qui nous transcende totalement
Hélène Grimaud est SUBLIME. c'est un ange
Tres expressive. J'adore ce interprétation.
Interprete fascinante, le respect de l'instrument, cette esprit par rapport à l'œuvre..,
Parabéns HELENE!!!MARAVILHOSA APRESENTAÇÃO!!!ABRAÇO DE CORAÇÃO!!!
Mademoiselle Grimaud, ne nous en voulez pas, mais l'interprétation réalisée par ABM reste de loin la meilleure encore aujourd'hui
Wonderful pianist!!!
A feast for the soul and for the eyes......
There is something extraordinary in her splendid performance .
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
My dogmatic thought .
This is music of requiem for the late crew of the battleship that deep bottom of the sea lie .
The thought of genius Debussy is incalculable to me .
I'm just impressed by listening to this masterpiece on incomparable performance .
From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun .
Which are you watching this from ？
How interesting! I like the orchestra version of this music. I always imagine it as battleship Yamato at the bottom of the ocean. Then modern exploration submarines attach large balloons to Yamato. The Balloons fill with air and the ship lifts from the bottom of the ocean. As the music becomes louder, Yamato rises faster and faster, until its prow breaches the surface of the sea. The ship explodes out of the ocean, and water sprays everywhere because of the impact. Other ships all around look at the great old battleship float again. The golden chrysanthemum at the front, still shining in the sun.
@@mariorossi9655
Marvelous ！
You are great ！
Thank-you ， thank-you so much to your wonderful and respectable reply ！
Japan is cherry blossoms in full bloom .
But all banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom having gorgeous Bento ， delicious foods ， treats and drinks is self - restraint by Coronavirus infection problem .
In Tokyo , the going out of night , bar ,snack , night club , karaoke shop , department store , Saturday and Sunday are self - restraint.
It's is a very pity that we just watch cherry blossoms in full bloom .
Someday please please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom having gorgeous Bento ， delicious foods .
Tokyo is full of surprises ， mystery and pensive feeling .
Take care of yourself
Good luck ！
See you again .
Watching this from the uk….. land of the rising rain fall 😂
@@garypotter1985
Thankyou
A corner of cicadas and autumn frail lifes insects buzzing and Quiet without traffic noises and streets beggers and various dusts of Tokyo
🍱🐮🎑🍢🌸🎋🌊🍙👺🎏🎎🍓🍜🥋🍘🍄🗡️🍒🗻🥢💮🥟🎍🍾🍚🐝🏯🍥🎆⛩️🐈🎇🎌🇯🇵
TheseEmoji絵文字are things unique to Japan
🎇is Japanese graceful and graceful and unimaginable and beautiful fireworks
🐈is famous Royal Hachikou忠犬ハチ公
🍥is Narutoナルト a friend of Raamen拉麺ラーメン
The path to perfection is long and hard ! As a reward-lllumination!!! Comes down in a simple formulation Nothing super flous, like a briliant PROSTATE'
Le chemin versla Pefecition est long et difficile! En r'ecompense-lllumination!!! Se re'sume en une formulation!!! Simple. Rien de superflu, comme dans le Brilliant PROSTATE'
Love the reinterpretation. That low C though is bigger without the added octave!
I love her ღ
Grandiose, fascinating to listen and to watch! A great artist interpreting great art! :) :) :)
Самые прекрасные мгновения всегда полны грусти, чувствуеш, что они мимолётны, хочется их удержать, а это невозможно...
Беру Ваше ☀️ в ладошки и умываюсь
Не удерживай-то, что нельзя удержать
ОДНАКО ФОТО ВЫРУЧАЕТ ТУТ !
Se que es una gran artista, pero no se puede negar que su belleza física viaja paralelamente a su talento.
Nasceu para isso. Extrema sensibilidade!
É difícil expressar em palavras a magia dessa musica nas mãos angelicais dessa pianista! O universo de Debussy é exotico.É uma harmonia que vem de encontro com os sons da natureza.É o que sinto!
Grand piece.
Beautifully played. The sound is not very good but she understands the music and makes it hers which is what it's all about. I don't see what's "aggressive" about her playing at all as someone commented below.
it's definitely aggressive. not necessarily a bad thing. i admit i dont yet know what the best way to interpret this is
Hélène one most pretty pure woman at the piano.
My soul is sinking !
Where is the destination ？
Heaven or hell ？
I am immersed in pleasure while listening to her exquisite performance .
From Tokyo in Japan where deeply loves Debussy .
Which national are you watching this video ？
france!
Bolivia
@@Rita-di2ny
Sorry the very late reply ！
Thank-you very much to your reply ！
Now Tokyo is the hustle and bustle with Coronavirus infection ！
All schools are rest for a month .
Be careful with Coronavirus infection.
Avoid unnecessary and urgent outing and crowds , and wash your hands frequently . There is a shortage of masks around Japan .
Just talking is infected within 2 meters .
Take care of yourself
Good luck !
Someday please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom .
@@victorjuansotomayorvargas4196
Sorry the very late reply ！
Thank-you very much to your reply ！
Tokyo is the hustle and bustle with Coronavirus infection ！
Be careful with Coronavirus infection ！
Avoid unnecessary and urgent outing and crowds , and wash your hands frequently .
There is a shortage of masks around the world containing Japan .
Just talking is infected within 2
meters .
Take care of yourself
Good luck !
Someday please come to Tokyo of the luscious and transient spring where all Japanese people are making merry and floating under the cherry blossoms in full bloom .
@@shin-i-chikozima мне чеснок помогает, надгрызть зубчик и по бровям, вокруг глаз, ноздрей и по губам, и так несколько раз, С молитвой о здравии разумеется. Периодичность маска-процедуры подскажет ваше самочувствие. Рецепт пришол на ум от Бога, когда вспомнил, что читал, про эпидемии чумы с халерой средних веков, там правда маски-колпаки покруче были. Да и при кашле, просто держать зубчик чеснока, во рту, изредка его прикусывая, особенно когда кашель спать недаёт.
СпасиБоБожий антибиотик мне надёжно помогает.
This song transcends the range of human evaluation .
Her performance is incomparable and exquisite . 🍎
From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan in winter .
Which national are you watching this video ？
I can't believe that there is fools on this earth who disagrees with this wonderful performance .
These fools are same as the stone or the mud in which they do not have the feelings as the man and the function .
.....beautiful......
The piece starts at 01:22
Well played. In terms of technique perfect.
She's rushing trough many bars. Miss that heavy feeling of a sunken cathedral.
However, great performance.
❤j aime beaucoup❤
Last night I've played concert. Small, corona chamber atmosphere. I played Haydn, Clementi and Debbusy. After concert I took off my concert suit and went home. Quiet and peacefully. At home I couldn't sleep so, In some quatter of night I turned on my player and first in the row was Ravel piano concerto played by the Helene. My God, I felt in love in every single note that she played. Maybe I fall in love.....
Essa performance me dá algo no coração que mistura euforia com calmaria.
There are many beautiful female pianists in the world, but Hélène almost makes me forget Debussy.
Jeff Dawson She’s one of those women who gets prettier with age, isn’t she? A very gifted lady.
Спасибо большое что посвятили в суть произведения
What is 0:00 until 1:15 ? I don't understand.
I think this is taken from 'Water' fifteen pieces of impressionist piano with intervals which she calls 'Transitions'. This is one of those.
And considering the piece here is about the Sunken Cathedral, which from time to time rises above the water at low tide (it's an actual legend in France), I find the intro quite befitting here.
Maravilhoso!!
Hermosa pianista y hermosa interpretación saludos desde Chile ok.
Sus comentarios machistas no interesan a nadie. Si se tratase de un hombre, también comentaría su aspecto físico? Ya está bien de juzgar a las mujeres en relación a su físico!! No es amabilidad, es puro machismo por el cual confunden capacidad con atracción sexual y reducen a las mujeres al mero objeto de su deseo. Hay que empezar a pensar con el cerebro en vez de con la entrepierna, por muy educada que usted crea que la tiene!!😠
Hmm... so now Im curious for the music in the beginning. I came here for debussy but now Im left wanting more of that introduction. Anyone know where can I find more of it?
Oh wait. I just saw the description. Never mind
Erian Ajuria, ikr? Same!
That music in the beginning is just absolutely gorgeous!
Yeah mate, at first I was like "this aint no sunken cathedral... what is this...? Its... its.... woah.
Idk what it is but i want MOAR" :P
Its just so quiet and peaceful but kinda sad too
А вы разве не всё знаете?
que lindo >:3
oscarrrrrrrrrrrrrr
Madame Grimaud, je vous écoute depuis longtemps. S'il vous plaît essaiyé de ne plus faire cette respiration car sur les cd on les entend beaucoup. Mais vous ête ma pianiste préférée. J'èspère que je pourrai vous entendre à Toulouse bientôt. Merci pour tout le bien que vous m'apportez.
Si l'on entend la respiration dans les enregistrements, c'est plutôt une question de placement et de choix des micros. L'interprète doit-il s'effacer au profit de la musique "pure"? Je pense plutôt que ce l'on appelle "silence" n'existe pas, notre cerveau filtre en permanence les sons "parasites"
Ich würde Helene gerne live hören. Ciao, dall'Italia del sud
Hélène Grimaud est une artiste colossale.
Grandissima bravissima solista pianista dei tempi moderni
Helene seems like an extremely spiritual person.
Just by looking at Helen's face, we know what she is playing. What kind of magic is this?
The hindsight kind
I like that. That's funny. :) good one mate@@adrianwright8685
THAT WAS MOVING AND BEAUTIFUL!MIKE MCDONALD
Je t'aime my lady Grimaud Helene
Декорации возопиют к совершенствованию!
К иллюзионистам и
спецам по художжественному
дизайн моделированию👁️🤔💞
Beautiful looking hands!
Helene =incredible
It purifies a distractions full of soul s
Whats in the intro? its nice too
She has an album called Water. It’s from that
very beautiful
Yes, and the camera cannot focus on the object of the video.
Iguana
When l am listening to this music ， I shall be the strange feeling draw in the lake.From where are you watching this video ？
im 2 yers in the future. the pandemic has happened. so has a gigantic us election. im in my cellar pouring wine
@@elultimosonador3958
Thank-you
Which is your country ？
Take care of yourself
Good luck ！
Be on the alert for Coronavirus infection ！
I am drinking my favorite Budwiser
EXECELLENT SHINING 🌟 ASTERISK
Qulque chose de Mystique dans cette interprétation .
How many keys can she reach?
03:19
It’s not supposed to be C octave…
En fait c'est un projet expérimental d'où sa manière particulière de jouer qui combine musique et nature.Tout ça est une question de goût.Maintenant pour dire qu'elle ne maîtrise pas bien Debussy's faut être plutôt gonflé :D. Elle sait jouer la pièce de manière académique mais elle a décidé dans ce projet de faire autrement c'est malin.Elle se plante très rarement,tout ce qu'elle fait est voulu et calculé dans ses moindres détails. Il faudrait peut - être lui dire après un de ces concerts :" Dis Hélène,je pense que ton attaque là est un peu trop agressive,tu devrais y aller plus doucement"....Ah ah.Vous voulez pas lui offrir un métronome non plus?pfff :D.
Now I have learned what they mean, (your listening pleasure)
Я шёл по лесу поднималс и спускался
Шёл не спеша
Ходил мой взгляд по ягодным местам
Мечтал приятно мило
Дайте человеку Цель, ради которой стоит жить и он сможет выжить в любой ситуации. Гёте
,,То, что Бог нам однажды отмерил, друзья, увеличить нельзя и уменьшить нельзя
Постараемся с толком истратить наличность, на чужое не за'рясь, в займы не прося" ( OmarHaiam
Октуально для ступ еней 1048-1131г.) А избранным всегда! Иначе Самосовершенства
日本では「沈める寺」となっているが「沈める城」なのか？廃寺が海中に没していくのかと思っていたが、古代の遺跡の城、波打ち際にある古城、が海中に没していこうとしているところかな？
@@奈良の鹿さん-y1z ありがとう❗初めて知りました。貴女の助けを借りて、このかなり生きずらい世の中を、泳いでいきます。
先日、大きな公園の帰り、草ぼうぼうの脇道に入ったら、カラスがラップコーティングのままの新品のおにぎりをつついていました。
わたしは、ラップをきれいに取り去って、元の場所に置きました。
5メートルほど離れて、見ていました。おにぎりの中には鮭の大きな切り身が入っていました。
カラスはすぐ戻ってきて、3回に分けて食べていました。
カラスよ❗カラス。
お前とわたしは、奇跡的にこの世に生を受けたもの。
お前の手助けになるなら、わたしは、喜んで役に立とう。
共に生あるかぎり、生き抜こうではないか❗
カラスよ❗カラス。
黒い翼をはばだかせ、生をまっとうすることを祈る。
さようなら‼️
Problème de tempo dans la 1ere page, les blanches sont nettement trop rapides, ca tue tout l'effet, et la montée n'est pas belle du tout. Les nuances beaucoup trop fortes. Bref, très moyen, écoutez plutôt Rubinstein, Arrau ou Cortot...
Ou Benedetti Michelangeli !!!
Ah oui, et d'accord sur le commentaire. La montée est trop forte, ce n'est pas l'idée. Premier enregistrement d'elle qui ne me convainc pas, je crois.
ГОЛОСОВЫ'Е ПРА'КТИКИ И ЗВУКОТЕРАПИ'Я С УМЕ'НИЕМ РАЗСЛА'БИТЬСЯ
Honnêtement pas sa meilleure performance. Elle transmettre hâte et malaise, tout le contraire de ce qui est demandé dans cette pièce (Debussy dit "profondément calme").
L'effet des cloches n'est pas bien exécuté. Les doubles croches sonnent encombrées et pas nettes (3:29)
Il suffit d'écouter Michelangeli, par exemple, pour comprendre la différence dans ce passage crucial.
Bien sûr c'est une pianiste d'élite, mais je suis un peu déçu de cette interprétation.
,,Человек лиш тогда побеждает, когда в глубине души признал себя побеждённым...?...
(От мудрецов)
Elle est généralement merveilleuse, mais pas ici... ce n'est pas grave. Personne n'est parfait, elle est pardonnée. Comparez avec Benedetti Michelangeli (par exemple) vous comprendrez.
В сей ☮️ едва ли снова попадём
Старых друзей и днём с огнём мы не найдем
Лови момент
Ведь он не повторится
Как мы и сами не повторимся в нём
ОмарХайям
Se avesse suonato così un uomo non avrebbe avuto la carriera stellare della Grimaud! Oggi bisogna nascere donna, signori meditate!
la prise de son n'aide pas , mais elle n'est pas dans son meilleur element avec Debussy, a mon humble avis ...
КРЕСТЬЯ'НИН И ЛИСИ'ЦА
Лиса' 🦊 крестья'нину одна'жды говори'ла: ,,Скажи'
кум ми'лый мой Чем лоша'дь от тебя' так дру'жбу
заслужи'ла. Что, ви'жу я, она всегда' с тобо'й? В дово'льстве де'ржишь ты её и в хо'ле; В доро'ге ль - с
нею ты, и часто с нею в по'ле; А ведь из всех звере'й едва' ль она не все'х глупе'й,, - ,,Эх, ку'мушка, не в ра'зуме тут си'ла! - Крестья'нин отвеча'л - Всё это суета'.
Цель у меня совсе'м не та:
Мне ну'жно, чтобы' она меня' вози'ла. Да что'бы слу"шалась кнута',,
И.А. Крыло'в
Большые пути начинаются с малых шагов, как топает малыш в большую жизнь
Источник Китайских мудрецов (Импровизация)
А'нгел мой Будь со мной Ты впереди' я за тобо'ю в след ко Све'ту
Играй моймилый музыкант
Незаурядный твой талант...
Покойдушевный с тишиной Вам в помощь калыбель истины
Benchmark performance
Possibly the worst performance I ever heard of this piece.
Я в начале подумала что у меня трип...
joj,tak toto nemalo chybu
Too much rubato, and too fast some places. Apart from that, very nice touch.
3:0
Uh, je n'aime pas du tout ! Son interpretation a completement ratée la dynamique de la pièce et par conséquent le climax qui arrive quelque part vers la deuxième minute a disparu.
I don't like it at all. Her interpretation has completely missed the dynamics and so as a consequence the climax that arrives somewhere around the second minute has disappeared.
I agree. And the phrasing is disjointed, the tone erratic. Debussy's extraordinary piece simply falls apart. This is a great disappointment. To hear how Debussy's piece can be played I would suggest the performances by Reine Gianoli or Yvonne Léfébure, which were uploaded to UA-cam in 2012, but have been heard far too infrequently. Or Dominic Piers Smith's 2007 performance at the Yamaha competition. All get it wonderfully right. Edward Kilenyi's 1950 recording is remarkable. And of course there are always the absolutely astonishing performances by Cortot. Or the superb performances by Gieseking, Arrau, Nelson Freire, Michelangeli, Richter, Pletnev, Zimerman. The Debussy piece has some truly magnificent interpretations. It is very sad that this is not one of them.
c'est l'intro qui te perturbe ?
Ultrabrutalni L'interprétation d'Hélène n'était pas comme vous vouliez?
Я непонимай
Mozart #23
Всё, что здесь нравится мне, ума не хватит перечесть, пока что...
А вот декорация оставляет желание её улучшить...
И вот портрет Ваш как то промелькнул
Уж очень слабый Будто совсем дитя старалась Но тем не менее ПОХОЖ
なんだ？これは？！
No! Too objective .and harsh. Where is the poetry?
Larkenfield Rofl yeah ok
What agressivity ...
Quelle agressivité ... Cette interprétation venant d'Hélène grimace devrait être plus douce normalement 😕
This interprétation coming from Hélène Grimaud should be softer normally 😕
j'aime pas ! c'est une pianiste qui n'est pas faite pour jouer ce style se morceau
,,На вкус и цвет, товарищей нет.,, ,,О вкусах не спорят,,....
спасибо за помощь
What's all that rubbish at the beginning?