The Mizos and Nagas : Are they untouchables? The History and Facts.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 353

  • @valentvarte36
    @valentvarte36 6 місяців тому +180

    Im mizo and atheist, Hindu never give us education, hindu always discriminate us. But, christiam missionary give us education and never discriminate us. ❤ From Mizoram.

    • @valentvarte36
      @valentvarte36 6 місяців тому +34

      @@abhei1226 go and learn before you are barking here. Little knowledge is dangerous.

    • @Bujbjjhfhhyfyvhvv
      @Bujbjjhfhhyfyvhvv 6 місяців тому +25

      True! Cowbelt belt can never understand
      Mizoram is considered as happiest state in India.

    • @opppp142
      @opppp142 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@abhei1226 they lived there not because of discrimination but because of conflict..

    • @UreTriggered
      @UreTriggered 6 місяців тому

      Hindu themselves for fighting for independence.

    • @LoLo-gf3hu
      @LoLo-gf3hu 6 місяців тому +5

      ​@abhei1226 you saw one video made by andbhaks and now consider to know so much about our state affairs.......
      Lets me tell you honestly, you have no idea at all about our history culture tradition or value

  • @NagaHeadhunter-br1cb
    @NagaHeadhunter-br1cb 6 місяців тому +81

    I'm from Nagaland and we Naga 100% Christian ❤❤

    • @pariwanglen2860
      @pariwanglen2860 6 місяців тому +2

      No there are non-Christians (Hindu, animist) among Naga such as Zeme and Rongmei

    • @udmember8593
      @udmember8593 6 місяців тому +1

      But tribals are not christian. Tribal worship nature not jeshu. Yeshu

    • @Alliswill943
      @Alliswill943 6 місяців тому +4

      ​@@pariwanglen2860 bro we are proud to be Christian and proud to be naga

    • @pariwanglen2860
      @pariwanglen2860 6 місяців тому +1

      @@Alliswill943 You might be Christian... But large section of the Zeme Nagas and Rongmei Nagas still follow animism or Hinduism...

    • @Alliswill943
      @Alliswill943 6 місяців тому

      @@pariwanglen2860 r u naga or

  • @dhritimanbardalai3021
    @dhritimanbardalai3021 6 місяців тому +51

    We Assamese too greatful towards Christian missionaries like Nathan Brown। Because of their contribution to our language। Even though our ancestors did not converted into noble Christianity, Christianity contributed us a lot 😊 by the way as a teacher he should study before going to teach something।

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +5

      Yes. Thanks for the comment. Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @dhritimanbardalai3021
      @dhritimanbardalai3021 6 місяців тому +3

      @@TheTopicalTalks welcome। I'm going to watch your videos sure।

    • @Assamesenomad
      @Assamesenomad 6 місяців тому

      ​@@dhritimanbardalai3021ghenta kela... Toi Christian hoi tur nijor identity nai soboke nkobi ami assamiya hindu hoi Amar nijoiso ase

  • @asobaquinket-he2zv
    @asobaquinket-he2zv 6 місяців тому +38

    Being a tribal doesn't mean untouchable like dalit because tribals are everywhere in all the 7 continents and everybody is advance,educated,dicipline and literate

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +3

      You are right. And I have attempted to tell the same thing.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @rahulparewa6535
      @rahulparewa6535 Місяць тому

      Do u knw when will dalit word came?
      Or we are not untouchables
      Ancient tym k migration Arya log tha aaya or yha cheeze changes krne lge
      Har koi apne aap ko supreme rkhna chahta tha or aaj v yhi h

  • @talenthunt102
    @talenthunt102 6 місяців тому +26

    Never ever use the word 'untouchable' on Nagas.
    We're head hunters.

  • @liangshiu8880
    @liangshiu8880 6 місяців тому +34

    We nagas and mzos don' t practice untouchaables like hindus.

    • @Tengchong57
      @Tengchong57 6 місяців тому +4

      Even we Garo too ❤️‍🩹

    • @beigokumar8539
      @beigokumar8539 6 місяців тому

      U right

    • @CHROMINIUMMaring
      @CHROMINIUMMaring 6 місяців тому +1

      Even our khasi ancestors from Meghalaya never practise Hinduism before Christian came to our state
      We have our own khasi religion
      But those RSS leader told that meghalaya is a Hindu state since ancient time.
      I was like what 😳

    • @kjmnb-x9d
      @kjmnb-x9d 3 місяці тому

      There's nothing called untouchable even in arunachal

    • @Rajwarsonu
      @Rajwarsonu 3 місяці тому

      This shows how weak your beliefs are, just a group of people discriminating against you and you can change your religion or hate it ?
      Go To anywhere in this world, one thing is eternally true
      They will discriminate against you by
      Rich and poor
      Race
      Nationality
      Skin colour
      Believes
      Gender

  • @rapprao4555
    @rapprao4555 6 місяців тому +23

    I am Naga and my forefathers does not even know their is a hindu civilization or mainland India people exist our only encounter was Ahom after that bristish and atleast to other part of Indian

    • @Ningombamfam
      @Ningombamfam 6 місяців тому

      And meitei too right??

    • @SlimJim3082
      @SlimJim3082 6 місяців тому +2

      ​@@NingombamfamMeiteis were only known to the Nagas in present-day Manipur. To the rest of the Naga tribes, meiteis were unknown.

    • @malemmangang6691
      @malemmangang6691 6 місяців тому

      ​@@SlimJim3082 joker 😂 jungli monkies😂

  • @NataZetsu
    @NataZetsu 6 місяців тому +10

    If we're untouchables to them then they're also untouchables to us!

  • @kvikughaachumi927
    @kvikughaachumi927 6 місяців тому +16

    If we're untouchables than Our people should always be ready to breakaway from union of India And join China',or become independent...the entire North East India...

    • @rkdmarak5580
      @rkdmarak5580 6 місяців тому +4

      I am not always happy with the new ideology of India because they are sometimes discriminate against north east

    • @TripuraTipperah
      @TripuraTipperah 6 місяців тому +1

      Do you think that's possible ?
      Tripura is now a colony of refugees.. sad but true & the central govt. Ignores it
      Unlike Tripura all other Northeast state have some freedom and enjoying the Federation power from Union of India
      Make use this opportunity to make your state more prosperous and strong

  • @Yampanaga
    @Yampanaga 6 місяців тому +4

    No one can change our Christianity
    Love u from nagaland

  • @WallimChwnglim-ni6ts
    @WallimChwnglim-ni6ts 6 місяців тому +15

    Untouchable was invented by the aryans , the foreigners. Whether adivasis, dalits, nagas, mizo Or any other tribals, they are indigenous inhabitants of this land. Especially among the mongoloid, there is no untouchable. If we are untouchable, they too are untouchable for us.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +2

      Khan Sir might have spoken out of ignorance. I hope he learns the truth.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @mizdremz7363
    @mizdremz7363 3 місяці тому +4

    Mizo and Naga are looking similar than other states of Northeast India..the majority of Christianity and their culture was very closely..in my college there are many students of Nagas and Mizos but can't identified them from their looks and all of them are Christians

  • @Tibalismisprimitive
    @Tibalismisprimitive 6 місяців тому +23

    There is no Casteism in North East
    We dont even know what is untouchable or touchable
    This is the very reason why Hindu belt states besides being economically more advanced than North East their mentality is still backward . Please treat your own Hindu people with equality despite economic inequality only then u will be like North East India.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +4

      One of the most evil practices in the Hindu religion is the caste system. They must do away with this.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @chicktale
    @chicktale 6 місяців тому +36

    If northeast ppl are untouchables then people of Thailand, Burma,china, Cambodia,laos, Philippines etc are also untouchables😂.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +8

      Yes. The mongoloid race is devoid of any such evil discriminations.

    • @dickyuuu45788
      @dickyuuu45788 6 місяців тому +6

      ​@@TheTopicalTalks not quite true. In manipur the meities who are majority hindu considered themselves superior and considered the tribals of manipur as untouchables. The tribal still to these days are marked by derogatory remarks as "Hao". Don't know about other NE state like assam Or tripura but in manipur untouchables were mostly practiced by the meitei hindu.

    • @b.t.f6280
      @b.t.f6280 6 місяців тому +13

      ​@@dickyuuu45788And today they meiteis are demanding for tribal status...the irony 😂

    • @dickyuuu45788
      @dickyuuu45788 6 місяців тому +3

      @@b.t.f6280 yes the hypocrisy is truly astounding. Many people from mainland have this misconception that caste system doesn't prevail in NE, majority of meetei still consider themselves as superior and tribal as inferior being which is why in manipur we have all this complex issues. The caste system has totally divided the people of manipur which can never be solved.

    • @chicktale
      @chicktale 6 місяців тому +5

      @@dickyuuu45788 Meiteis were also a tribe that adapted Hinduism long long ago,otherwise they have their first religion called sanamahism.Anyways Meiteis always consider themselves above tribes in northeast India and other people in mainland India also.They have very weird pride.

  • @Atu201
    @Atu201 6 місяців тому +4

    I'm christian love from TRIPURA ❤✝️🙏

  • @YoungStar11567
    @YoungStar11567 6 місяців тому +8

    East or West Christian is the best because there is no untouchability, dowry, sati etc .....
    From Wancho hunter land Arunachal Pradesh

    • @lungchey8840
      @lungchey8840 3 місяці тому +1

      Do not proud of your religion You people already forgot your forefathers practices your cultures nd identity

    • @Introvertdairy
      @Introvertdairy 2 місяці тому

      Converted 😂

  • @venachhangte7642
    @venachhangte7642 6 місяців тому +5

    It’s thankful that you have clarified the misconception that Bihari Khan Sir had given. I had also watched that video of Khan Sir and it made me furious. Back then these two warring tribes were never untouchable. We have our own great history,culture and customs. Untouchability prevails only within Hinduism; so, back then we weren’t hindu nor Indian. We lived peacefully within our own territories under our wise Chiefs. Later only we were included under the British territory and we fought two world wars for them and after independence we fought multiple wars for India. I am a Mizo, I am an Indian and I am not an untouchable

  • @YatoKonyak-t1h
    @YatoKonyak-t1h 6 місяців тому +13

    U mentioned about misconception about the other video, yes, Naga never either India nor Myanmar but remained freed Naga.. Foreign Christian missionary came and converted to christianity.. It's good u cleared the doubt amongst different section of the society.. Naga never untouchability never subdue by outside world.. 🍎

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes Dear, it's my attempt to clear the thing and bring forth the truth.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @rkdmarak5580
      @rkdmarak5580 6 місяців тому +3

      Let's make A Country Nagaleem we meghalaya willing to support

  • @livefastdieyoung8703
    @livefastdieyoung8703 6 місяців тому +6

    Discrimination,abuse and insults against the Nagas and Mizos starts from Assam..... Assam is even worst than the mainland India for the Mizos and the Nagas .....

    • @necrosodomy7023
      @necrosodomy7023 6 місяців тому +1

      General Assamese people are no less than the mainland Indians they all look alike I know and have seen these people have such kind of attitude towards tribal people they think they are above or superior in terms of race, culture, education than the tribal communities.

  • @hriata5384
    @hriata5384 6 місяців тому +7

    In the pre colonial era..... Lands inhabited by MIZO(ALL ZOS) wrre today Mizoram, kachin and chin parts of sagain state of burma that stress all the way to bay of bengal...
    Zampui hills of tripura and kukil inhabited area of maniour along with chitaging hill track of Bangladesh.....
    Even today these places are still inhabited by MIZO(ZOs).....
    But devide and conqure rule was unsed by british.... And again deveide by partition....till. Dated....
    So i think of someone want to talk about history of Mizoram from its precolonial era i think its right to mention this fact as well....

  • @kethkoth-wb6sw
    @kethkoth-wb6sw 6 місяців тому +6

    Someday everyone will know the truth.......😮😮
    'Let's truth prevail '
    God bless everyone 🙏🙏

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for the comment.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @nokainketerakum7267
    @nokainketerakum7267 6 місяців тому +6

    Untouchable still exists in some parts of UP and Bihar.... (Where does khan sir lives?).... We Naga never knew untouchables.. 😂😂😂😂😂 Only God knows.

  • @KenizenloJThong
    @KenizenloJThong 6 місяців тому +2

    Sir, this content is very informative and thank you for uploading a very good research on both the Mizos and Nagas.. It is said by the Britishers Scholars that the tribal people of Nagaland practiced the purest form of Democracy in the olden days.......

  • @christin1001ify
    @christin1001ify Місяць тому

    Such a Clear and informative video. Well done 👍

  • @einstein5455
    @einstein5455 6 місяців тому +10

    Nagas were Christian before mizos

    • @jamesboth3785
      @jamesboth3785 2 місяці тому

      Just the Aos. The konyaks converted to Christianity only in the middle of 20th century. 😂😂 while the whole Mizos were already Christian by the early 20th century

  • @tympzzz
    @tympzzz 6 місяців тому +2

    Long live mizos and Naga's.❤

  • @JEY2002
    @JEY2002 6 місяців тому +2

    Thank you brother 🙏

  • @zilumorizip
    @zilumorizip 2 місяці тому +2

    Jesus never taught us untouchables thank you, Lord.

  • @Devaram_doley
    @Devaram_doley 6 місяців тому

    You have rightly explained with authentic reference .Here what you have explained ,have been being explained by me to our tribes belong to the Mongolian and are living in the North Eastern States since '90

  • @Obitoclips_
    @Obitoclips_ 6 місяців тому +2

    Christians log jaha bi reheta hai waha Education bi atcha hota hai aur Clean bi hota hai State.... 💓

  • @Numarkayi
    @Numarkayi 3 місяці тому

    Thankyou so much for this informative videos ❤❤❤.

  • @AvsegnoGrisiewky
    @AvsegnoGrisiewky 6 місяців тому +5

    In Mizo and Naga the only distinction is Rich/Poor and Beautiful/Ugly

    • @iNstiNct-wx2vo
      @iNstiNct-wx2vo 6 місяців тому

      Wat u trying say broda?

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      😀You are right.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @lavender1986
      @lavender1986 6 місяців тому

      😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂chicken defending kfc

  • @NyajutTaiam
    @NyajutTaiam 6 місяців тому +10

    Khan sir mentioned untouchable not to show any disrespect but to show the mentality of Central people towards the tribal people then. Tibals or Adivasi were always looked down by others.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes. But there was a slight mistake in his presentation and I have attempted to rectify that. No hard feelings. Respect for him. Please do share the video and subscribe to the channel.

    • @user-xw7zq8jlc
      @user-xw7zq8jlc 6 місяців тому +2

      By your write up I am absolutely sure that You know nothing about the Tribal welfare committee 1952 of the Government of India there are four categories of Tribes they are:
      (1) Tribal communities : adhering to traditional patterns of life who lived in a specific area for 1000 of years and are the indigenous people of that land.
      (2) Semi-tribal communities (although these communities have settled down in rural areas by engaging in agriculture and other allied activities, but by living amongst the Hindus, who follow a jati-varna system, the tribal communities have also considered themselves as a form of castes by engrossing themselves into the concepts of purity and pollution, that are keys to the jati-varna system);
      (3) acculturated tribal communities (these communities have migrated to urban and semi-urban communities in order to work in formal organisations)
      (4) assimilated tribes (these groups have assimilated into the wider world and have now de-tribalised themselves)
      In the light of these categories the tribes of North East broadly falls under the first category we have nothing to do with your Brahminical Culture of Varna System in fact we are the native to our concern state. Rest of ya'll are the outsiders and we considered you as the 2nd class citizens.

    • @mLBB-x-HoK22savg
      @mLBB-x-HoK22savg 6 місяців тому

      Go watch the full then defend ur racist slave minded mainland Indians

  • @JasmithaMarak
    @JasmithaMarak 19 днів тому

    First christian in northeast India me Ramke W Momin or second Tangkan Sangma North Garo hills se Hai 👍👍 God bless you brother

  • @Zaelyn6190
    @Zaelyn6190 6 місяців тому +3

    You've oppened so many peoples closed minds

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for acknowledging Dear. Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @kamletraveller162
    @kamletraveller162 4 місяці тому

    Non-tribals were untouchable for us. We never knew about non-tribals amd we were proud tribal and real son of the soil.

  • @Bujbjjhfhhyfyvhvv
    @Bujbjjhfhhyfyvhvv 6 місяців тому +21

    When did nagas and mizos become untouchables? 😂
    Majority untouchables are in Bihar while 'khan sir' himself being bihari😂
    Nagas and Mizos are brave warriors who fought for themselses not like
    biharis were labours of britishera, mughals(turks), Scynthians for last 25 centuries😂.
    *25 century of slavery history of Biharis😂*

    • @hppyking2211
      @hppyking2211 6 місяців тому

      Brother😂

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +2

      Yes Khan Sir is from Bihar. But the Islam religion also doesn't practice the varna system. He might have spoken this out of ignorance. Let's hope he learns and rectifies.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @yalektatak7388
    @yalektatak7388 6 місяців тому +2

    Yes 100% right hai👍💐💐💐💐

  • @Tengchong57
    @Tengchong57 6 місяців тому +2

    Im Garo meghalaya 100/ Christian ❤❤

  • @APnijir28
    @APnijir28 Місяць тому

    Exactly what you said.. 💯.. correct...they should condemn him .

  • @chingkongowam1775
    @chingkongowam1775 6 місяців тому +1

    Right said 👍

  • @spatarzx1007
    @spatarzx1007 24 дні тому +1

    The British left but they enslaved those people through Christianity.😢

  • @assamhealthcare3672
    @assamhealthcare3672 4 місяці тому

    Very nice Explain Thanks

  • @AkitoZhimo-sz1zb
    @AkitoZhimo-sz1zb 6 місяців тому +2

    very sorry to inform you some of ur statements are not correct too . though you are trying to validate your points in support

  • @beyongmak14
    @beyongmak14 6 місяців тому

    Thank you sir for sharing ur knowledge,,

  • @bogum26
    @bogum26 4 місяці тому

    Point to be noted 💯 right 👍▶️ achi

  • @thecrunchlator2500
    @thecrunchlator2500 6 місяців тому

    Support NE creators ..unite people

  • @hmartrolls1630
    @hmartrolls1630 6 місяців тому

    His statement is true for north india and many other parts of india but not for north-east, infact even the british empire doesn't even allowed the missionaries to spread Christianity among the tribals.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes. But even in north India and other parts the tribals can't a part of the varna system. Tribals are indigenous. The religions they practice today have been adopted.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @anyaipansanganyaipansag5376
    @anyaipansanganyaipansag5376 6 місяців тому +1

    Aap indirectly, hum tribals ko behka rahe hai. We Northeast people respect all religions and tradition. Im Christian, but respect Hindu also.

  • @saiasaibung2303
    @saiasaibung2303 6 місяців тому

    We are Touchable But as We all Know "UNITY IN STRENGTH",Policy is what we follow as a Believer.

  • @rajapegu4713
    @rajapegu4713 6 місяців тому +1

    Hi sir I am your new subscriber 😊😊😊

  • @SumanBasumatary-m3e
    @SumanBasumatary-m3e 2 місяці тому

    Ilove your massage

  • @RickyAhongsangbam-uj5rt
    @RickyAhongsangbam-uj5rt 6 місяців тому +6

    There were only 3 states in north east- Assam, and the princely states of Manipur and Tripura. Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and Nagaland were part of the larger territory of Assam. Eventually, they got separated to form their own distinct states.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +1

      You are absolutely right. ✔Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @Tarozhou
      @Tarozhou 6 місяців тому

      Arunachal Pradesh wasn't even part of India,the region was under Tibetan control till British came, you're saying if Arunachali have anything to do with Assamese it was only mereged into Assam by British

    • @lalruatkimachhakchhuak4761
      @lalruatkimachhakchhuak4761 6 місяців тому +3

      if we were to go by that all of Assam was under Bengal Governor or administration of British India

    • @Takuachi12
      @Takuachi12 6 місяців тому +2

      ​@@TheTopicalTalks The tribals of Arunachal, mizoram or Nagaland were never under the rule of ahoms or any other kingdoms. Despite of many attempts to capture the land of tribals by Ahoms, they failed to do so. Instead, Our Arunachalee tribes used to raid on some plain areas of Assam to gain resources which later forced ahoms to make an agreement with tribals in which they will send us resources such as food or any other usable things for keeping peace in the region. Britishers just draw their boundaries and put these States into Assam.

    • @Takuachi12
      @Takuachi12 6 місяців тому

      ​@@Tarozhou That's true that our Arunachal wasn't part of India and doesn't have any relation with India historically but also we weren't under the control of any outside kingdoms. Just some parts of tawang was under Tibetan Kingdom but the rest 95% part of tribals areas were always free from outside dominance. We used to engaged in inter-tribe wars to expand one's own territory. There have been some very gruesome wars happened between my (Nyishi tribe) and Apatani tribe which have been told by my grandparents.

  • @Meghasu
    @Meghasu 6 місяців тому +2

    Good video sir 👍

  • @KhutulAcchumi
    @KhutulAcchumi 6 місяців тому +1

    That Khan always says what he want ,, brother we are with you and always will ,, and please visit Hornbill fes

  • @rkdmarak5580
    @rkdmarak5580 6 місяців тому +1

    Yes we all north east people are untouchables 😢😢😂😂

  • @Beautytips469nisha
    @Beautytips469nisha 2 місяці тому

    Right 👍👍👍👍 sir

  • @rajapegu4713
    @rajapegu4713 6 місяців тому +1

    Assam k schedule tribal k vdo chayiye ❤❤❤

  • @vati216
    @vati216 6 місяців тому

    Tribe is a social group, it has no relation with caste system.
    Infact every human race had their humble beginnings from a tribal society and as their population grew, upgraded to kingdoms & empires.
    I dont blame khan sir but in Indian society, tribe & caste is often intertwined though they are completely different subjects.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes. This is because of the ignorance. Let people know the reality.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @isaacpameih4863
    @isaacpameih4863 6 місяців тому

    M (Rongmei) Naga from Manipur.

  • @zeangangmei3862
    @zeangangmei3862 6 місяців тому

    Salute hai Sirji...wana know abt more of Rani Gaidinliu n hapou Jadonang..pls sir..

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks. I shall surely bring a video on them some day.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @Abukiogi
    @Abukiogi 6 місяців тому +3

    Khan Bhai, your State Bihar lowest literacy rate in India

  • @tonipaleng
    @tonipaleng 6 місяців тому +1

    Pls, tag this this video to khan sir.

  • @SlimJim3082
    @SlimJim3082 6 місяців тому

    The term "untouchable" is an indian invention. To the rest of the NE, there was no such thing as untouchable people. Sure, the various tribes were warring against each other and even had economic trades but the people didn't view others as inferior.

  • @manjitrupbikram
    @manjitrupbikram 6 місяців тому

    Please add Khasis, Garos, Bodos, Tripuris, Arunachalis, Ahoms, Manipuris etc. to the list.

  • @rajapegu7131
    @rajapegu7131 6 місяців тому +1

    ❤️❤️❤️

  • @sanjitdvrma4951
    @sanjitdvrma4951 Місяць тому

    👍♥️

  • @gojingpame
    @gojingpame 6 місяців тому +2

    Sir Channel name changed.. ❤❤❤

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes for something better. Do You like it?😀

  • @983165419
    @983165419 6 місяців тому +1

    I am a tribal boy from jharkhand can I marry a naga or mizo girl?

    • @cilbirthmomin1435
      @cilbirthmomin1435 6 місяців тому

      It depends on your personality not by nationality,

    • @Son0fTheSoil
      @Son0fTheSoil Місяць тому

      Especially your financial status(very important)

  • @apollotikher6085
    @apollotikher6085 6 місяців тому +1

    Hearing untouchable word for the first time for naga n mizo........m confused

  • @jungleboy.123
    @jungleboy.123 6 місяців тому +7

    Without knowledge how can he talk about NE

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Dear, everybody can't know everything. I hope he learns it better. He is a good teacher though.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @nikofficial4741
    @nikofficial4741 6 місяців тому

    Sir aapka last topic best tha hum saab ek ho kar festival celebration karna hai

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +1

      Yes. Nahi to humara identity khatm ho jaega. Please do share the video and subscribe to the channel.

  • @c.mangyangchang9994
    @c.mangyangchang9994 6 місяців тому

    brother u got a very very important topic...but u too should research b4 speaking about others. I don't know anything about my mizo brothers but I feel u need to learn about naga history.
    Thank u

  • @mayad718
    @mayad718 6 місяців тому +1

    Nice

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @roslynzatecr4843
    @roslynzatecr4843 3 місяці тому

    I'm mizo and I'll be glad if no-one touch me😂

  • @ShadyMellow-zh8gs
    @ShadyMellow-zh8gs 6 місяців тому +1

    🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @maiholiaw4927
    @maiholiaw4927 6 місяців тому

    I doubt that, as a Khasi tribal and along with my kin the Jaintias, we were not considered untouchables for a simple reason, Hinduism was not the religion of ours. It was only in 1500AD with the emergence of the Khasi &Jaintia Kingdom which conquered some fringes of the Hindu dominated plain areas of Assam and Bangladesh (more prominently the Jaintia Kingdom) that we were exposed to Hinduism. While Hindu influence is present in the Jaintia Niam tre religion, it is almost absent in the Khasi Niam Tynrai. So the Idea of the Varna system is absent. On top of that, the Plains people were only exposed to tribal kings and warriors or traders who traded in the markets (Haats) the ideas of the Khasi &Jaintia tribals being untouchables, was absent. By the time there were sizable non -tribal Hindu population in Shillong, when it became the capital of undivided Assam, much of the local population were already Christians. So frankly speaking, this concept of NE tribals being untouchables is a fairly recent idea propounded by some vested interest.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes you are right. Such concepts of castes and untouchability are from the Hindu religion.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @pingothetiger8900
    @pingothetiger8900 6 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for clarifying

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for the comment. Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @Ren_Kichu777
    @Ren_Kichu777 6 місяців тому

    Im glad my people were republicans from our forefathers and still is more democratic then many .. thank you ... ❣️

  • @amitbaba2308
    @amitbaba2308 6 місяців тому +3

    Sir, adivasi matalab tribal people hota ha untouchability nehi.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Sir, please focus @1:26 min of the video.

  • @thisnthat7760
    @thisnthat7760 6 місяців тому +1

    You are wrong about one thing about the Nagas, we are not animists or pagan,we don't follow that religion, we believe in monotheism . That is one creator God in heaven who is father of all and one big bad evil in the land of the death that is destructive,our customs and traditions are similar to ancient Judaism having all sorts of rites and rituals, that is why when the missionaries came and preached the gospel , everyone figured out that it is where they belonged,and also our society never kept slaves , head hunting is purely as 'trophies ', inter tribal warfare is solely for land grabbing, despite that every naga tribe is independent of each other and the society runs on democracy,The nagas are one of the few societies in history that practiced democracy,.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thank you for the input. I have spoken as per my research. May be there's more to get. But trust me in many sources the Nagas too are referred to as animists.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @BimanJoyReang-p1q
    @BimanJoyReang-p1q 2 місяці тому

    Iam from tripura

  • @Hrangchalpa
    @Hrangchalpa 6 місяців тому

    Kya hai uski channel

  • @laljoyneihsiel7459
    @laljoyneihsiel7459 6 місяців тому

    The only untouchable is Mizo is spirit.

  • @TokhBjm
    @TokhBjm 6 місяців тому +2

    Who is mr,khan we don't know that person and we would never want to know this kind of people he is nothing but just to create hatred among indian brothers and sisters.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for the comment. Mr Khan is a good teacher but I think it's his ignorance. Do share this video to let the world know the truth.
      I have already made a video on the Chakma- Hajongs. Please watch it.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.

  • @ty-ny2se
    @ty-ny2se 6 місяців тому +1

    👍

  • @johnylalrina1451
    @johnylalrina1451 5 місяців тому +1

    It is just stupid to describe some specific ethnic communities as Mongol race these days. You make it seems like we have some kind of geonology connection with the Mongols which we do not. If you want to know more about Mizo as one ethnic group, go read Chin ethnic group from Burma too. Our community is divided into India, Bangladesh, Myanmar and states too. We have a state in two different countries. Chin-Mizo-Kuki is one of the largest tribal group in this region, bigger than Naga and Meitei combine. Thats why we cannot be intimidated by an group. Assam police were finding out the hard way by loosing around ten policemen. We are also fighting Burmese army in Chin State as we speak. This is who we are. I am Mizo.

  • @TillingTado
    @TillingTado 6 місяців тому +2

    👍👍👍👍

  • @sahil5rana
    @sahil5rana 6 місяців тому

    No tribals are not consider part of caste hierarchy many adivasi like meena even helped rajputs (after that rajput even gave land and had matrimonial relationship with them)

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes. Tribals are never a part of such discriminations. Please do share the video and subscribe to the channel.

    • @user-xw7zq8jlc
      @user-xw7zq8jlc 6 місяців тому

      By your write up I am absolutely sure that You know nothing about the Tribal welfare committee 1952 of the Government of India there are four categories of Tribes they are:
      (1) Tribal communities : adhering to traditional patterns of life who lived in a specific area for 1000 of years and are the indigenous people of that land.
      (2) Semi-tribal communities (although these communities have settled down in rural areas by engaging in agriculture and other allied activities, but by living amongst the Hindus, who follow a jati-varna system, the tribal communities have also considered themselves as a form of castes by engrossing themselves into the concepts of purity and pollution, that are keys to the jati-varna system);
      (3) acculturated tribal communities (these communities have migrated to urban and semi-urban communities in order to work in formal organisations)
      (4) assimilated tribes (these groups have assimilated into the wider world and have now de-tribalised themselves)
      In the light of these categories the tribes of North East broadly falls under the first category we have nothing to do with your Brahminical Culture of Varna System in fact we are the native to our concern state. Rest of ya'll are the outsiders and we considered you as the 2nd class citizens.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      @@user-xw7zq8jlc Thank you fur your input. I am much obliged. The ocean of knowledge is very vast and it's never enough to have learnt. But your input has given me a lot of idea.🙏
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @Lohriibaba
    @Lohriibaba 6 місяців тому +2

    Sir the male picture you used to represent both Naga and mizo are interchanged, the male picture on the mizo side is a Naga and on the Naga side the male picture is a mizo, more over mizos are never known as head hunter, where as Nagas practice head hunting untill late 50s in some Naga community. Not intending to hurt anyone but any content with correct representation attracts more viewers and positive openion about the content creator. Thanks

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for the comment. Actually, those pictures are just representational and depictional in nature. It's very tough to get such photos for the Northeast people. I tried my best to present them well. In addition I have also tendered a disclaimer in the beginning of the video.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @Rzkhumi
      @Rzkhumi 6 місяців тому +1

      Mizos were also head hunters

  • @Pegu-ou9gy
    @Pegu-ou9gy 6 місяців тому

    Khan sir northeast k baare mein ache se pata nhi hai sir ji

  • @akitoshohe855
    @akitoshohe855 6 місяців тому

    This practice "untouchable" Is clearly seen and practiced by the main land land people,which is prevalent even today in some rural or backward areas, in fact it's divided into four sects such as Brahmans, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and Sudras, the sudras are rhe lower caste and are considered as untouchables even today, thats why shame on you to call Nagas as untouchables, you have to study the history of the Nagas and you will know

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Yes. The practice of casteism and untouchability is a part of Hindu Culture. I have attempted to clarify it. Hope people get it.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @moodswings634
    @moodswings634 6 місяців тому +2

    But mizoram people don't use Nagas attire so kindly collect more info 👍

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +2

      Yes. That's why I have mentioned a disclaimer in the beginning of the video. Please acknowledge.

    • @moodswings634
      @moodswings634 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@TheTopicalTalks but if you are talking about others culture then you too should be clear about it I'm not here for correction I just love the way you have stood up but people are watching and some are unknown to this states and our culture so that's my point of view 👍

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +1

      @@moodswings634 thanks

    • @WallimChwnglim-ni6ts
      @WallimChwnglim-ni6ts 6 місяців тому +1

      Culture acquires, adopts, change Or fades with the passage of time

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      @@WallimChwnglim-ni6ts Yes. You are true. But we must cling to the base as much as we can. Unique identity, unique culture and customs are the beauty of this earth. If we can adorn it in our own way I think we do justice to it.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @philipjamatia2866
    @philipjamatia2866 6 місяців тому +1

    Bangali maderchuk iam from tripuri

  • @ahuvizhimo2786
    @ahuvizhimo2786 6 місяців тому +1

    'The Naga system of democracy was a form of purest democracy which is very difficult to conceive as existing even for a single day, and yet that it does exist here,is an undeniable fact.'
    - JOHN BUTLER (then DC of Naga hills,1869)

  • @ryanphom3443
    @ryanphom3443 6 місяців тому +4

    Naga n mizo are lost tribes of Israel...so many years past more than 2500 BC Israel lost tribes was found in India North East..that y Israel still claim mizo n Naga are there people..

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Thanks fore the information. I am yet to come across such a piece of information. I will surely do a thorough research on this. But as of now since the other tribal groups of NE also have resemblance with them (Naga and Mizo) I am not sure about it. May be there's another reason for their claim.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

    • @abcb1683
      @abcb1683 6 місяців тому

      Nonsense claim.
      Nagas and mizos are sinitic tribes that originated in China and captured land of austroasiatics in NE brother. what Israel nonsense are you talking about?
      Do a dna ancestry test, you wont even find 1% israel😂

    • @Eot-ys7ut
      @Eot-ys7ut Місяць тому

      Claim for free fighters in gaza

  • @adarau1989
    @adarau1989 6 місяців тому +4

    Your video is knowledgeable, but I think you need to learn more about Nagas and our freedom fighters, in Nagaland we call all the fighters as freedom fighters and not like you mentioned as terrorist.

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Dear, I have no right to term them terrorist. I have just tried to put forward the instinctive thought of the people.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @thaitokbi1705
    @thaitokbi1705 6 місяців тому +2

    Khan sir sach hi bola he

    • @sujit.btry1
      @sujit.btry1 6 місяців тому

      Nhi

    • @YatoKonyak-t1h
      @YatoKonyak-t1h 6 місяців тому +1

      Kia saach bola.. Tum jiselok es duniya mein nafrat phela nese kush phaida nei.. 🤪🤪

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому

      Haan,unhone sach kaha par adhura hain. Darasl Tribals kabhi Achhoot Nahi hain.
      Please do like and share the video. Please do subscribe to the channel. Do wait for my next video on Inner Line Permit and its history.
      Yours
      The Topical Talks.

  • @Only4game
    @Only4game 6 місяців тому

    The topic of untouchability does not arise with respect to the Indian history and culture. The Naga & Mizo culture was completely Foreign to the general Indian populace eho had no idea if these two entities even existed except for some few Indians from Assam. The topic itself doesnt make any sense at all😐

  • @rik9773
    @rik9773 6 місяців тому

    British Assam tak nhi Arunachal bhi poch Gaya tah..

    • @TheTopicalTalks
      @TheTopicalTalks  6 місяців тому +1

      Yes. But at that time Arunachal had not been created. It was considered as a part of Assam. Please do share the video and subscribe to the channel.