Ham Radio, GMRS, MURS, FRS, and LMR Radio Comparison - LMR, Ham, GMRS, MURS, & FRS Explained
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- In this video I explain the differences between ham radios, GMRS radios, FRS radios MURS radios and LMR type radios - I also explain what an FCC Business License (LMR or PLMR license is).
Correction: 15:04 I said that ham radio operators cannot use an LMR (Part 90) radio to transmit on ham frequencies, but that was incorrect.
► For a step-by-step guide to purchasing your GMRS license go here:
www.notarubicon.com/how-to-ge...
► Like my shirt? Get yours here! --- a.co/9wwUzxA
►Want to help support my channel? ►►JOIN and become a member for as low as $1.99/mo (cancel any time) - Click here for more info: / @thenotarubicon
►► Or just click the $Thanks button at the bottom of the video
►► Did your comment get DELETED? Read this page to find out why: www.notarubicon.com/what-does...
►►►►► My video & audio equipment list: a.co/6Tk9kOr
NOTICE - The above links (and most other links on my channel) are affiliate links - if you use one of my affiliate links to make a purchase I may receive credit/payment/money/something of value in return.
Music by Stern Beats - You can find him here:
/ @sternbeats9057
#GMRS - Авто та транспорт
left out the CBs
Are you sure? I'm pretty sure I addressed CBs in the video. You should watch the video again, but try to pay attention this time.
@@TheNotaRubicon 🤣 The replies, so close to my heart. Love them!
@@TheNotaRubicon "Some People"
That didn’t take long.
Pinned!!!!!
We had a MURS outbreak when I was in the Army. It took out the whole company for a few weeks. If you're going to be around MURS, wear Crocks in the showers.
It may have been caused by a spurious transmission....
Are you talking about MERS - Middle East respiratory syndrome?😅😅😅😅
...and be sure you don't drop the soap!
@@jimborambo958 Seems like Crocs in the shower wouldn't help your lungs. Maybe MRSA? 🤣
LMRO
That ending 🤣🤣🤣 thanks Randy!
Thanks, for breaking this all down, Sensei 😁
BTW, You said *No Matter What", and the FCC, cut you off! 😱😂
Love that you used a UV-5R for the ham!!
it is the best ham radio!
Are there radios that operate on the bacon spectrum?
Love your shirt. Truth is also uncomfortable sometimes; unlike comforting lies
don't break down the fairy tale. I put both my legs in the same pant leg and got stuck, so I just identify as a mermaid as I lay on the ground.
@@volvo09 😂😂 Love it!
Thanks for that comprehensive overview!
Quick "sad ham" note - there is no restriction against using commercial (Part 90) radios on amateur frequencies, as you suggested, because there is no type acceptance or certification required under Part 97. You can use a radio that was designed for another service, even if you need to modify it to do so. The general stipulation under Part 97 is "No amateur operator shall willfully or maliciously interfere with or cause interference to any radio communication or signal. " The amateur radio service is intended for tinkering and experimenting, people even build their own radios.
2:14 Best part in the entire video. Sad hams commenting in 3, 2, 1...
"Some People" "Experts Online" This is why I love this channel. :)
I didn't know much about LMR, I specifically enjoyed that part of the video. Thanks so much!
The ending was awesome 😂
I bought my maintenance guys MURS radios on our 4-acre campground and it worked fairly well except when they would use the radio with the antenna down. I added a 1/4~ antenna to the office radio with RG-58 coax going up into the attic, this also allowed me to chat with the office when next door at Walmart or Murphy's gas when I was running errands. We used DCS codes so we did not have to listen to local Fast Food traffic in the background that was blocks away and not clearly heard consistently anyway.
I came to learn about radios, I stayed for the hilarous deadpan personality.
There may be a million other videos but none of them are as snarky as you. You're the best.
As a total admitted and unremorseful radio 'pirate' on All bands, I love your videos and especially your humor. You are both extremely informative and entertaining.
Love how you saved the most important information for the end. Great work sir, truley enjoy your content.
This is one of the best videos comparing the different radio services I have seen. I'm glad you hit the updated rules relating to data on GMRS. It's a shame they made you cut out that important part at the end. Glad I saw it the first time.
Videos are awesome. You're introducing a large group of individuals to the airwaves. I saw your live chat with HRCC. I fully support you getting your ham license as a fundraiser and would even donate myself. I think you could document The experience via UA-cam and make some very entertaining content on the matter.
Thank you so much for making this video! I can't wait for the one in which you test out the GPS functionality of the new Btech GMRS Pro.
🤣 sir I just love your videos. They are great. Great explanations on the topics. And great humor and attitude. Keep on keeping on!
I like your jeep videos but awhile back I saw the videos on the boafeng and since then I’m hooked on it so thanks for that dude now I gotta teach my wife thanks for your videos they are helpful in case you were wondering
Best UA-cam video closing I have seen in a long time!
Long time listener, first time commenter. Loved the talent on loan reference.
I still remember when I illegally pushed transmit button on uv5r for 1 sec then was lookin out the window the rest of the day waiting for FCC to show up.
Ok, the ending of that one made me laugh out loud! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼😂🤣😂
Great video. Very entertaining and informative. I got the info I needed.
Slight correction, Randy. You certainly *can* legally use an LMR gear on ham frequencies, and hams have been doing so since Xenu was a toddler. Hams can pretty much use anything they want within the ham bands, including home-built transmitters, so long as it transmits cleanly. And while you mentioned power levels for the other services, what may intrigue some is the 1500 Watt maximum power permissible on amateur gear. Not that I would recommend running your Boo-fwang into legal limit amp :)
I found your final point to be quite riveting!
Shout-out to all the Ham Ph.D.s!!!
(...I'm so sad....)
Great video. Although I am not looking at LMR, its good to know the who, what, where when and why.
This was VERY helpful. Thank you and keep up the great work.
Dude!!! You crack me up!! LOL! I appreciate your humor... I'd love to have coffee with you a talk $#!t for a while... Keep up the awesome work!
Educational, interesting and hilarious! Excellent, and thanks!
Good vid Randy. Keep'em coming.
Your video is the best because you have the coolest microphone. Everyone knows the coolest looking microphone makes the best videos. I mean if I don't like the mic or the boom I'll just find another video.
That closer was wonderful. Thank you sir.
I love how you always abruptly end the Video Randy Its just oh there is More And Bam Nothing 😂 @NotaRubicon Productions
Conciseness mode employed. Bravo!
This is such a great channel.😊
Thanks for the video! Keep up the good work!
After spending so many hours over the past month researching 2way radio comms in the US, I have come to the conclusion that the FCC has no interest in enforcement and only sees licensing as a revenue stream.
There is an entire segment of the industry dedicated to "10 meter" radios that do not operate on 10 meters. Yes, these "10 meter" radios with clicky 40 position dials and 100 watt output somewhere between 10 & 12 meters.....and no one cares. I think it's hilarious, actually.
Oh.....the FCC doesn't have to worry about HAM band enforcement, they have the sad hams to handle it.
Thanks for the videos, they are very informative and way more entertaining than I had hoped for. Again, thank you.
FANTASTIC VIDEO!!! HAM GMRS COOPERATION!!! IM COURTESY SUBSCRIBING TO JOSH. THANK YOU, NOTARUBICON, YOU HAVE CREATED AN AWESOME UA-cam CHANEL.
Dude love your T shirt!
That ending... 💀
Simply brilliant.
I really feel you're the most informative that I've seen and I'm about to purchase my first gmrs radio what would you recommend
I love your radio videos!
Very interesting info here. Especially the LMR stuff!
But these sudden endings... are killing me! 😠
That was really good suggestion there at the end. Everyone should keep that advice in mind at all times for their own safety and the health of others around them - however I'm getting reports that some other viewers couldn't see the video all the way to the end. Hmmmm.... It would be unfortunate if they missed being able to see all the dancing zebras.
This is the video I wanted you to make.
As an amateur radio expert for over 284 years, it's my duty to inform you that you overlooked the most important distinction between all of those. They are all spelled differently.
What a cliffhanger! "...no matter what..." What? No matter what what? Still a great vid. Thanks!
I find the similarities and differences between Canada and the US's radio systems quite fascinating. CB and Ham are basically identical, while Canada's "GMRS" is essentially the same as the US FRS. Our VHF LMR system is kind of interesting, though, as it's almost like an amalgamation of MURS and the US LMR. There are the proprietary "business frequencies" that cost a lot to get and are specifically assigned, but there are also numerous "open" frequencies/channels that are for public use. There is a $42 annual fee to transmit on the LMR VHF radios, but this is widely ignored and not at all enforced by Industry Canada (despite the dire warnings of sad hams everywhere) and then there are also the "Resource Road Channels" for use by anyone on active logging and resource roads in BC for safety reasons. I really wish Canada would harmonize our GMRS rules with the US, because it's a fantastic radio service, like new age CB radio.
Again, loved the Rush reference! Talent on loan from… Xenu?
great video great info.. thanks
I think MURS is a good option for community groups because the frequencies are less common which provides a bit of security, but also means in emergencies you're not going to have a lot of random people using all the FRS channels at once. The ability to remove antennas will also obviously help you get a dB increase. I find MURS to have more clarity of the voice than FRS when I tested them side by side.
The main thing to be careful of is that with so many radios that can listen to murs, if most people are using the other services and one group is using MURS, then the murs group is going to be much easier to identify and locate because they're the only one using it, having an opposite affect than intended. It depends on several things so ultimately it may not be an issue, but it's something to consider. Same thing with a lot of the digital radios that send a bunch of information about themselves and the user and the location and stuff; people who know what they're doing and have a little bit of simple gear can end up getting much more information about the users than just the spoken conversation. Sometimes security through obscurity is cool and sometimes hiding in plain sight and running in the middle of the pack is the answer. Having all the options and capabilities and knowing what works best for whatever task is I guess the big goal, but it's a lot of effort and money and time to amass all the crap and aquire all the knowledge and set up a plan and a network etc... I feel overwhelmed just thinking about it.
@@vitogriffin8902 I think most nefarious folks don't know or care about radio so much in the US. I could be wrong, maybe the wolves are getting their ham licenses and GROL+R licenses just so they can go after people.
@@troy3456789 I agree, most don't, but if there comes a time where simple family or group communication security becomes a real issue then there will be an element of compromised or changed people for various reasons. Nobody thinks they're the bad guy and desperate times call for desperate measures.
@@vitogriffin8902 Not all emergencies mean end of the world, now we are in a rolling battle kind of thing. Much more likely to be a natural disaster, which we have plenty of every year.
Yeah fellas for those situations I wouldn't even use analog radio at all without using YAGIs and constant movement
"now of course the most important thing to remember when using any type of radio, is that, no matter what, wherever y..." video ends. Brilliant ending, much applause.
I'm a Happy Ham! However, a GMRS Operator too. So, I'M EXTREMELY HAPPY!
Thanks Randy! Could you do a video (I recall you recommending some refurbished/surplus HTs in the past) on getting the LMR license? I run a tiny business so I qualify in that area. -Lee in Minneapolis
THANK YOU for answering son linguering question
I think he spent way too much time on ham radio and I did notice a few subliminal messages about getting a license. Great video & thanks. N2NUT
The best part: The Big Red Wave! 👌
I originally only ended up with GMRS because buying a business frequency was so complicated and expensive, and I was told they would only give me one if I built a tower for the main base station.
I'm pretty happy with GMRS now, though. It checks all the boxes I need.
Probably you could just commercially licence a couple handhelds. That's what I did but I am in Canada. It was pretty simple. IIRC I just had to list the IC certified equipment I was using, the emmisions type, station type (base/mobile/handheld), where my station is (my home) and that it was to be used for short range truck to truck comms. Think it was $80 per year. You could request a frequency but I just let them assign one
I love it when businesses use FRS. I can sit in my car and mess with them.
Them: Hey Jake where are you? We need some help unloading the truck.
Me: Jake is out back smoking a fat blunt, So stop being lazy and unload the truck yourself."
Them: WHO IS THIS?
Always appreciative of your material. Bit snarky, but considering how some hams can act? I get it.
Also not only can a nine year old do the tech exam? That SAME nine year old can has and DID do the Extra exam. So. Y'know. Not Rocket Scuence (though full disclosure. the extra exam does scare me.)
You had me at business porpoises.
There may be a million videos but no one has the Don't give a fk attitude like you do. Nice explanation of everything.
When you get a talent loan from Xenu.....what kinda payments are you making monthly?
I have been a Ham for at least 120 years and i am here to tell you by my brilliant expertise, that is NOT a UV-5R but in fact a BFF8-HP! i can tell that by my pure jean yus not by the sticker at the bottom of the radio.
... but yes, undisputed best ham radio ever. #fenggang #grabFengGoInnawoods
new to radios herer. what type of antenna is needed for home to use for murs radios
I am commenting, not because I have anything worthy to say, because I want to see this video and channel rise in the rankings just to piss off more "some peoples".
Finally got a tech. license, and they're right, now I know more than God. Since everything you said is wrong, I don't need to break it down.
Can I go to the top?
This video is good, but I'd like to know that is the technical difference. As far as I understand all is radio are they kind of the same?
Radios! Love me some Radios
I have a special question... can you spell out the differences between the UV9G and the GMRS-9R? Seems they are much the same. Except the GMRS-9R comes in colors.
How long does the LMR Business License last,ie does it have a expiration date similar to the GMRS license? Is there a maximum number of user allowed by the FCC Overlords?
900mHZ does not have longs but it does have the throughs. And I think you can do whatever you want encryption-wise and you don't need a license.
If Zenuw would allow I would give you 2 thumbs up.
I’m interested in a video review of that BTech GMRS Pro unit!
I’m a Kenwood guy, but I’m really intrigued by this BTech!
Maybe you should watch this video: ua-cam.com/video/Mkk5hY3hM2k/v-deo.html
I'm surprised some agency, nobody ever asked for, doesn't have regulations on breathing.
Code 43-A-473: Breather must purchase a breathing license ($50) before breathing. Breather must not exceed 10 breaths per minute. Deep breaths or excessive breaths are a class B license, for which a 50 question test must be taken and a fee of 100 non refundable dollars must be paid. Deep heavy breathing for a duration longer than 30 minutes will require an in person interview with the Federal Agency of Gases.
Federal Agency of Gases, I see what you did there. 😄 I was studying for my HAM license and trying to think of one for FCC, the only one appropriate for sharing I came up with was Father Clown Car.
That ending has my OCD aflame. "No matter what" what?! 🤣😂
yea, seemed a little circumcised didn't it. Pretty funny.
nice shirt 👍👍
Love the end of the video lol
LMAO 😂 At the ending!! Funny shit!
this guy is nuts. .my kind of guy.
business or commercial porpoises
Are there FRS radios that can send and receive digital data (as mentioned at 11:16 in video)?
Motorola makes some IIRC.
I would like to thank for the
Where's the rest of the video? It seems like it abruptly ended - without an ending?
Thank you for the very informative video
It's nice knowing what radio to buy when you have unlimited amounts of money like I do I elected to go with your number one choice for the best ham radio ever manufactured in the history of man kind
I spent $22.50 of blood sweat and tears and purchased the uv5r with the rubber duck antenna and 48 hours later took my ham test passed it set the radio off hit the repeater talk to people around the world
48 hours and $22.50 later I have conquered the ham radio
All right that was simple back to the cocaine and hookers
Apologies if I missed something, but in a recent video about what you keep in your Jeep, you mentioned your mobile GMRS radio is encrypted? What am I missing?
You should watch that video again.
So if you encrypt ham transmission for a purpose other than preventing others from knowing what you're talking about its ok?
I wonder if you could have a show on Zello? How to tie your repeater to Zello.
...No matter what.........." Always have your Roger Beep Turned on! 😆
...whenever||| Love it. ; )
Do Lot Lizards use FRS or Business Band FM CB these days? Asking for a interstate milkman friend.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
I know you prefaced the video with things you were discussing and those omitted, I was wondering what your thoughts are on this. What if the citizens of 'Merika rose up, joined together and created a communication system free of FCC or the ITU. It could be called citizens band. Catchy huh? Possibly an idea for a future vid?
If citizens rose up and took over the government, there would just be a different set of people making the rules and taking your money. People only want to take over to be a ruler!!
Another advantage of being able to remove the antenna is that you can try transmitting without the antenna attached to see if it will destroy the radio. But, who would do that?
Who would do that? Of course, our favorite UA-cam radio guy.... ua-cam.com/video/SdMLCDPc04Y/v-deo.html
Would the FCC take you to court if you encrypted GMRS transmissions using Navajo code talkers?
I love when the cows down the street from my house greet me with a rounding chorus of MURS when I pass them
does fcc care about any think ,cause if they why don't they some think a bout channel 6 since you brought up cb radios , I'm a ham operator as well .I have not heard of fcc doing anything to anyone . in my 50 years of radioing thank you very much
"Back in the day" law enforcement used to monitor CB channel 9 for emergency comms. Do they monitor any of the GMRS channels now?
99.99998% do not.
How's the btech pro ? Inquiring mind need to know more
I guess you'll have to watch my video on the BTech GMRS pro to find out.
@@TheNotaRubicon seen it. Still inquiring
This might have been mentioned before, but with the argument "Which is better, HAM, or GMRS", I'd like to make this point.
Though it's true, that HAM will reach others hundreds or thousands of miles away, I suggest that will be of little value in a SHTF situation. All HAM contacts can do, is inform you of what shit is hitting THEIR fan, at a great distance from you! Wouldn't it be more valuable to know what is going on in the immediate area where you are, and having contact with some that might actually come to your aid, or give you local information? Yes, HAM can communicate at short distances too, but I suspect there might be less of them, and equipment is generally more expensive. But I get it....whatever you're into is fine with me.
The FRS antenna removal test noise you made was pretty disturbing 7:11