Hate to rain on your parade, but they’re trained to cognitively remember how to trace a series of lines that’s disciplined through training, still impressive but they’re not really painting
@mr.petersen7150 So they are like humans is what you are saying. Trained to remember things and write it down. Cool. If they aren't painting, who is? Is there an invisible person guiding them?
Aside from the speculations of possible unfair treatment of the elephants involved in training, I’m just fascinated that elephants possess the cognitive ability to paint actual pictures like this
Sadly i witnessed first hand some of the treatment the Elephants get, they routinely have humans riding on them all day, and the trainer has a sharp tool that he used to stick in the Elephants ears, which were bleeding and seeping. Same with bears and Tigers. The bears were completely shaved and forced to do tricks for a cheering crowd, it was heart wrenching and pitiful watching this almost deformed looking bear parading around just skin and bones. Something that has stayed with me through the years. This was back in 2001, hopefully animal welfare have stepped in since then.
When elephants are left to paint freely, they just make abstract splotches and lines of color. I think this one was taught to make the specific pattern for a reward.
@@Big_BlackHawk Ah yes the fake friends I was out partying with last night 😂 Just think for a moment use that tiny pea sized brain of yours. How would an elephant be able to understand complex shaping to paint itself at such detail? We DO in fact have paintings made by much more intelligent animals, in particular Gorillas, and even though they are highly intelligent they have nowhere close to an understanding of structure and shapes. They have a good idea about coloring and using colors to paint something you can discern but nothing that comes as close to what this video depicts, again, those where Gorillas. Much more intelligent. Don’t you find it odd there just so happens to be a human right behind the elephant?
@@Big_BlackHawk also how the fuck would an algorithm know the difference between a staged video and a legit one?! Do you even know what an algorithm is? 🤣🤣
Oh baby! They treat these elephants SUPER well. Really. This elephant has painted this same picture thousands of times. That's how much fun the elephant is having while it paints the same picture! Cute right?
@@luky4487 They might have tortured it but that was a very poor choice of words. I’m a horse rider, and my horse is great. I didn’t torture him, I spent years training.
If I didn’t see it with my own eyes, I wouldn’t have believed it. She paints in true perspective and even uses shadowing, sees in color, even paints her breaking off a tree branch and eating it and is only six years old!! Signs her name to the painting and NO MISTAKES!That’s f-en incredible! When I was six, I could only paint stick figures. Sell the paintings for a million dollars and use the money to protect her environment. I have to show this video to my friends.
I really hope they "trained" her fairly and properly and respectfully because look at how precious💙Elephants are naturally sweet and uber smart so there's no need for violent "methods of discipline"
Animals and birds are not only source of human beings entertainment.They are not source of food for human beings.They have their own life. so Please give them good treat, love, care and respect 🙏
I love the way the eyes look like they widen when she puts the brush to paper lol the concentraition and just pure presciousness 😢❤ and she knows when she needs more paint 😅❤
She isn't doing the painting. Elephants are very intelligent but painting isn't one of the things they are good at. Her trunk is being controlled by the mahout hiding beside her front legs. These elephants naturally would be naughty trying to play with each other. The reason they don't move is because they are pressing a nail in the flap of their ears, causing pain and reminding them of punishment.
@@shakeserfistssmith1364 Oh! I'm sorry, don't mean to. I've been studying from the best. Mostly self- education and a lot of research. I also follow many Animal Activist groups all over the world. I'll give you a video that will show you an elephant painting Telenoche - Memorias de un Elefante - Capítulo II and give you a video on how they train them young breaking the spirit of an elephant You may be better off not watching this one because it will make you cry. "Very disturbing footage". I can tell you that they are torn away from their mothers and begin their torturous training at the age of two. The first one starts in Spanish but hang in there they speak English when they are painting. You will have to copy and past in search . You Tube doesn't allow links leading to animal cruelty.
@@keepwildinthewild just shows my naivety,I myself am self taught. I come from a small town and was not exposed to much of the world. Then came the internet, at 40! Lol. It was worth it.
@@shakeserfistssmith1364 You aren't naive. If I hadn't studied them, I would have thought they were painting. I know a lot about elephants, and this is not natural to them. What is natural to them at this age would be breaking away to play with each other. But that nail being pressed into their ears they don't dare to leave their posts.
Elephant are the most Intelligent Animal on this earth, they have emotions too I am very impressed that this little champion SUDA made a very heart touching drawing and by painting he just saw us his love to all Human Beings.. I am sure that those elephants are very happy and not under any harrassment. Live long SUDA and all other Friends.. 🌹💐🙏😇 Lots of Love and Respect from INDIA 🇮🇳💐🌹
They do. How else does she know how to paint? She didn’t just come out of her mother knowing how to paint. She knows if she doesn’t paint, she will be hurt. I wonder how much abuse she went through to learn. Fucking people. I know damn well this poor baby is abused.
Once when I was a little boy my papa took me to watch a parade on the road. At that time an elephant walked through front of us. He was chained. When he saw me he smiled at me and when he rose his trunk to wave at me his master struck his trunk. He was harmed just because he wanted to say hi to me😭😭😭. By the way I wasn't grown enough to figure out if the elephant was he or her😬. Whatever, that memory hurts me a lot☹️
@Winter Rous T They could, if the people that were training them were not Indians. I'm not racist or anything but all of us know that Indians are generally rude and violent. For example I once called the tech support team from Pubg Mobile and an indian answered and kept swearing me like "Motherfucker" "Cock Sucker" and more. I repeat, I'M NOT RACIST
Omg. He drew it in 3D. And see how steady and accurate his brush was as he retraced the lines! Unbelievable! Incredible! Super artistic and intelligent!
14yrs ago and I'm just seeing this. I'm pissed...this elephant's uniqueness should have a documentary film for the world to see. Let me go do some research. She's unbelievably talented.
I agree. I see a lot of negative comments on this video, and honestly, I dont know how she was treated. From what i see in this video however, she certainly seems to be genuinely happy to paint. She is literally dancing in between brush strokes. That does not seem like a sign of an abused animal to me. I could be wrong though.
@@burntroses176 why do people assume this. Hurting the elephants wouldnt teach them how to paint, it would teach them to be scared of people. Did the elephant look scared? She was literally dancing in between brush strokes.
This elephant paints better than me But the fact that their forcing the elephant to do this and they probably did somethibg cruel to it.. i mean like.. elephants are almost endangered species?!. They shouldnt be doing that!
I doubt that that they abused them. They are so gentle and good with the elephants. It is ok for them to do that to they are very smart and are usually very good at being taught. If abuse was contained then people would have shut it down already.
Also just because they are vulnerable does not mean they get abused all the time. These people seem to love and care for the elephants. The elephants seem to love them back and seem to love painting.
She is not painting. The mahout hiding beside her front legs takes control of her trunk and maneuvering it around the canvas. Elephants wouldn't even pick up a brush voluntarily for the tip of her trunk has very sensitive nerve endings that it is painful to hold anything for very long there. People need to know that Thailand cruelly uses elephants for profit. The one horrible things that is done here is these youngsters are the result of being torn from their mothers in the wild and put through extreme cruel and inhumane training till they lose their spirits and begin the rest of their lives obeying their human owners. This is not natural behavior for them. They would be running a muck playing with each other and being mischievous. Where they have a nail being pressed into the sensitive part of the ears, they dare not to stray.
Tbh, they don't look in a bad shape to me. You know, every year, tons of children are abused by their parents, that doesn't mean all parents abuse their children. Same goes for zoos and nature reserves, some mistreat their animals, some don't. Elephants are actually really smart creatures and I think I've hear of studies proving they can feel pleasure doing things like painting. Plus, looking at the communication means they had in African countries 10 years ago (when this video was posted), I don't think those elephants caretakers knew about their capacity to learn how to paint before seeing them into action. Rather than being tortured to learn, it seems more likely to me that they simply imitated humans after seeing them paint because they found it entertaining. We only saw 15 minutes of them without context, so we can't tell for sure how things are for them behind the curtains.
Mowd Cridhe Bunny Well, not really. I can understand how maybe an elephant would enjoy picking up a paintbrush and slapping some paint onto a canvas but there is absolutely no way that this elephant was painting that picture of its own volition. As smart as they are, elephants don’t have the brainpower necessary to conjure up abstract representations of real world things like that. There is only one explanation: she was forcibly trained to do that. Remember that elephants aren’t like dogs; they won’t simply do whatever you say in favor of food. Instead, elephants must be “broken,” typically through corporal punishment or being confined into very small cages until they bend to the will of their master. If you see an elephant doing literally any kind of trick, gimmick, or unnatural interaction with humans, 99% of the time they’re doing it because they have no other choice.
I've seen it first hand, the person standing next to the elephant tugs on the elephants ear manipulating it into a trained action from the trunk. Sorry to ruin it for u but you will never see an elephant painting without the handler stood next to it usually on the far side from the audience.
The elephants aren't painting. The mahout is maneuvering her trunk around the canvas. This is a tourist trap. They use elephants for profit and it's not a pleasant life for them.
those comments are full of idiots who jump into conclusions without knowing their shit. Elephants are creative and emotional animals by their nature. But you never know. Humans can be evil
@@dieselgeezer18Yes they are creative sweet beings. Elephants are playful when they are happy but that's not the case here. They are painting when they are told to do so. They are being forced.
Like elephants used in the elephant trekking industry, young elephants used for painting must be broken and experience the pain of the phajaan process. Over this time baby elephants are starved, shackled, and beaten, until their spirit is completely broken and will submit to the will of their captors. www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-an-elephant-paint-is-cruel-not-cute/
I know......pleaseeeeee pray with all my heart that abuse was NOT involved in this. I'm an animal activist and have read, heard, and witnessed some of the horrific treatment elephants endure for our entertainment. Its absolutely heartbreaking!!!!!!
Von wegen gequält werden die Natürlich ist es nicht lebt ihr in eurer Traumwelt bloß die Augen verschließen ihr sollte Mal hinter die Kulissen sehen unmenschen
The elephants are not painting? The mahouts conveniently hiding on the other side of them guiding their trunks around the canvas. This is a long painful procedure for them. Their trunks have many nerve endings which hurts them to grip things in this case, a paint brush. These juveniles normally be playing together, but if they try to stray, they get pieced on the back of the ear, with a nail, one of the most sensitiveness parts of their bodies.
K. Lo No it not .... it’s fucking sad and cruel. You don’t think he just picked up a paint brush and started painting do you. no of course not he was most likely beaten into it
I feel so sad about seeing that TORTURE STICK (bullhook) under the painting stand. Elephant sees it all the time so (s)he knows that it’s goint to be used if the master is unhappy with the elephant’s work. This cruelty must be stopped.
@@grenda5 They undergo a process that includes being ripped apart from their mother shortly after birth, being whipped, being submersed and darkness and water for days on end, being starved, and being tortured to ensure that there Quote spirit is broken. This is not fake, hundreds of account have been reported of this. Elephants are wild, so they naturally won't do this. Please do not support this industry. For more information, look up on national geographic's article on wildlife tourism.
@@theenjeneer2493 This actually isn't a zoo. The animals here are From the entertainment and wildlife tourism industry. Nothing like a zoo. They undergo a process that includes being ripped apart from their mother shortly after birth, being whipped, being submersed and darkness and water for days on end, being starved, and being tortured to ensure that there Quote spirit is broken. This is not fake, hundreds of account have been reported of this. Elephants are wild, so they naturally won't do this. Please do not support this terrible industry. For more information, look up on national geographic's article on wildlife tourism.
The Enjeneer They are NOT set free, after being in captivity they would not survive. The ones that are healed are usually in their own environment not in a zoo. That way they can be set free again.
That's incredible. They must be the smartest animals. I don't even know how that is possible. I hope he is treated good tho. If you treat elephants bad you're scum. Imagine having a painting of an elephant painted by an elephant
there definitely is. it’s such a sad truth and no one ever talks about it. the torture and exploitation of endangered animals for tourism is just disgusting.
A lot of torture was involved When they were two, They were stolen from their families and had to go through the 'crush;' this video will explain better than I can upsetting footage. ua-cam.com/video/ibTJmYLLNOA/v-deo.html
@@enricoputrawijaya4591 The elephant is not painting. Maybe a line or two, but the mahout is guiding her trunk and inflicting pain to her ear, and maybe parts of her body to keep her focused and stay put. These elephants are miserable and depressed. This is no life for an elephant, standing there all day in the hot sun 7 days a week, then shackled all night. She should be roaming the jungle with her family. Not stolen from her family in which she was stolen by these people. ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html
I noticed that the first two elephants were drawing essentially the same picture. Interesting! That makes me think this is trained behavior, rather than spontaneously created art. It is remarkable, regardless.
If you saw what they do to make these elephants to just stand their, it would break your heart and probably infuriate you. They are not doing the painting. The mahout, hiding beside front legs where you cant see him, is guiding her trunk around. This is nothing but a tourist trap and cruelty to animals.
For all those commenting on how amazing this is, you have absolutely no idea what disgusting treatment they receive behind the scenes. All you have to do is search up the "Phajaan".
Thank you Oracle. As I watch the trick, I see how precise the elephant uses its trunk. It is controlled by the trainer!!!! I used to watch captive wild animals with fascination with their tricks until I realize how animal cruelty plays into the picture. Dolphins, killer whales etc. I did Google phajaan. I encourage the viewers to do so themselves. I also would like to hear from the trainers' point of view regarding the practice. And the elephant/human culture in Asia from experts. And the debate from both sides.
@@fabgirard1429 I agree with you. But with caution. Let's hear all sides of the debate. Think hunting licenses in developed countries.Trophy hunting in Africa. Commercial harvesting of krill in the southern oceans.
This is not natural to the animals, just imagine if you're being forced to crawl all the time, which is not natural to us human. We seen this as entertainment without realizing the process these animal had gone through.... So sad....😫
ö ô ok calm down. They were just asking because there is actually no proof of the elephant enjoying this. This comment is just trying to raise awareness whether it is true or not, because this happens. Also you don’t have to get so mad over a question-
Я в восторге,первый раз вижу чтобы слон рисовал,и так чётко и красиво,какой молодец,наверно много трудов пришлось приложить,чтоб научить,смотрела,немогла оторвать глаз,это великолепно,умничка,учителя хорошие.
@@bhimsenluchooman4046 please read all the posts on here. There is a long one by some one who explains it all eloquently. Good that you lome elephants.
Some are actually trained, not hit or anything. And if the elephant was hit or anything, the people could get arrested for animal cruelty. So yeah. But that's just my opinion.
Thats what im saying. An elephant learning to paint in 2 months could only happen if the elephant is actually interested in painting. The happy dance tells me she is somewhat of a "prodigy" elephant, who truly loves painting. Im no elephant expert; but something tells me you could not get these result, in only 2 months, just by torturing an elephant into painting. Because If they could, unfortunately, more places would be doing it.
Thank God someone else commented on this. So did I...I caught it immediately and stopped the vid, had to reason for a minute...we kill these animals for just their tusks? We're insane as a species...clueless.
All of these elephants were trained using TORTURE. Be aware of that! It's called Phajaan, Crush training, Torture training; it's done by BRUTALITY, 24/7, for as long as it takes for the people to crush the elephant's spirit and Will. It KILLS up to HALF of all captive Asian elephant calves, and is part of why Asian elephants are becoming extinct, including in captivity. Wake Up! Learn!
@@ashrafsalemi4064 Captive Asian elephants are forced by Torture training to work and obey man. It's not beautiful, they were FORCED to do this by TORTURE. Learn about Phajaan, also called Crush training, also called Torture training, which kills up to half of all captive Asian elephant calves. Every working elephant on the Earth, including those who are forced to paint, were forced through it, and they are abused with sharp steel hooks, knives, and other vile tools of abuse, and chained when they aren't working, shackled as slaves. It's Not beautiful. Please learn.
they were probably "stimulated", especially since its more than one elephant doing it. or they don't need much training and its something they are naturally prone to learn fast and easy to motivate, doubt it though >
You can see the sadness in their eyes... Guys, elephants don't have a natural inclination to paint. From our perspective this is a fascinating video, but in truth they are tortured by their trainers in preparation for their paintings and while during. The handler here is most likely employing a hidden nail in their hand and piercing the elephant's ear and tugging it to dictate where to direct the brushstrokes. If its only entertainment you're here for, then know that this isn't an elephant that can paint, it's a human that can use an elephant to paint-like controlling a video game character. And perhaps by itself that would be impressive, were there no animal abuse involved.
@@montyrayza7220 : Could U learn such like artistic painting after regular beating for a month , No and Never---- even Picasso was not to be able to paint like our Suda, dear. Bravo!
problem is that its always the same picture, meaning that someone has most likely taught the elephant through re-enforcement and that may be far from a pretty sight. You know its from the heart, when the elephant writes, "HELP ME, I am in Chinese re-education program!"
for those wondering, the elephant is guided on what to paint by the trainer nudging their ear in the direction thye need to move the brush. they were taught how to paint each image and every elephant can only do one.
@@davidjones-vx9ju of course not, as they don't have trunks...... but Iif they had trunks, they might be capable of doing similar feats with proper training...
Absolutely amazing. I'm applauding this lovely talented elephant. Please I hope they are well taken care of and no ill treatment or torture is meted out to those elephants.
No. They are very depressed and miserable. These people bought them from a training camp where they are inhumanely trained to perform for tourists. The paintings are done by the elephants. The mahouts are doing most of the work and are constantly inflicting pain with a nail they have between his fingers. These babies were stolen from their families and I can assure you that the mother has ongoing sadness. Elephants share the same emotions as us. These guys work 7 days a week until closing and are shackled up all night. This video explains it all. It's mostly Spanish but hang on. You'll get it. ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html
we don't know but normally, painting elephants cannot be pressured or else they won't like to paint... if this elephant is an expert of painting, it may only be because he was set free to paint something... those who are pressured to paint are normally not competent at all and will be less productive... yet this elephant seems pretty fine but as I said, these are my theories, we cannot be a hundred pourcent sure
Suda painted with such careful deliberate strokes. She has that same right brain focus that a human has! I know, I am also an artist. She got deep into it and really enjoyed herself. This was so fun to watch! I am left with sheer amazement at the intelligence and emotion she demonstrated! ❤
I saw an elephant paint in Thailand. The trainer guided him the whole time, literally steerimg the head while the elephant kept his trunk stiff. On this video, you don't quite see what the care taker is doing, but he seems to be always standing right next to the elephant when she paints something. My guess some kind of steering is going on there as well. Maybe the elephants are okay with it, but it's certainly a tourist show and I would only buy / support such a picture if I knew for sure that it was drawn without human "blueprint" and that the paint (and whatever training took place) wasn't harmful.
I think each elephant is trained in a specific pattern so when they paint they only make that pattern for a reward. When untrained elephants are left to paint by themselves, they tend to make abstract little flecks, splotches, and lines instead of trees and such.
Regardless of training or how intelligent elephants are, there's little evidence that they have any innate cognition for abstract images and relationships. In other words I doubt the elephant would even regard any relationship between it's own kind and the two dimensional image it drew on paper. But I'd be interested in reading studies on the subject.
Same, like I’m not against animals being trained as long as the animal is happy, healthy, and the training isn’t abusive or in any way detrimental to the animal, and that the animal has lots of free time to just chill
This video is 14 years old and I'm only just learning an elephant can paint an elephant better than I can paint an elephant.... how is this even possible?????
@mommyissue I dunno .... sounds to me like that elephant is living a better life than u are 🫢 can u plz explain to me how the hell u torture an elephant into having a talent or a skill as such ..... just how😂😂
This is not a blessed animal.... this is an animal that has been severely abused by a human. Please look up Elephant Crushing...and have a tissue handy as well.
@@DaNNy_DodgeSpain ellos se terminan creyendo que son inteligentes, ellos ven solo lo que hacen, el producto final, lo que se ve en el video, no ven todo el recorrido, entonces sí, se engañan, se mienten, se creen sus mentiras de que sus logros son verdaderos y naturales... se creen que son los mejores por lograrlo... esto es como el ladron que consigue 1 millon de euros a punta de pistola.... será lo que quieras, pero inteligente, como que no.
The elephant is not painting. The guy who never moves from her other side is forcing her trunk on the canvas. I've seen how they do this and how they are trained. Not pretty. This would make you cry.
So, when you see an elephant in a large forest attentively listening to Beethoven and moving in time, I guess you assume it was tortured to do that too?
It's amazing what you can make an animal or a little child to do. Isn't it fun to watch bears running around in the circus like their clowns. They really look like they're having fun & plus we get to enjoy watching them. Animals & children are here to please us & they really do.
YOU CAN HEAR THE ELEPHANTS CRY. THE GUY BEHIND HOLDS THE ELEPHANTS EAR AND BETWEEN THEIR FINGERS IS A NAIL THAT THEY PIERCE INTO THE EAR IF THEY DO NOT DO IT RIGHT. (sorry for caps its copy-paste)
I love elephants. Just imagine an animal, smart, strong and gentle… that’s the elephant. The elephant combines all positive qualities, all positive characteristics an animal can have! Huge respect to our big friends, I don’t know why people in India, Thailand, South Africa, Bangladesh or Indonesia treat them so badly. Just from their size I would feel quite intimidated so I would never dare to behave disrespectful to an elephant let alone mess with an elephant
Suda, you are very great. Now I understood that Elephants do everything perfectly if trained well. But such training should not be painful to the elephants. If they are really tortured to learn this art, it is more painful to the viewers than being excited.
I don't know about these particular elephants, so I wouldn't presume to say how they were treated. But, yes, in conditioning, the "bell" system is well known. Initially a creature is beate or otherwise made to suffer, all the while the bell rings (or it rings at the beginning, I am not sure). After a while, only the bell is rung, and the creature behaves as if it had been beaten, so complies. It's a system that goes back as far, or even further than, the arabian knights etc.. I don't know if it would workl in a painting situation, though, and besides, something like thos could be done more successfully with a rewards system.I'm not surer the elephant is aware it is actually drawing itsalf, either, since it (a 2 dimensional line drawing) requires a primate's mental configuration. But who knows?
This is a wonderful video. Suda should always be protected and treated well. Suda has ushered in a new era for the elephants. Heartiest congratulations to Suda for learning how to draw, paint and write her name in English at a tender age of four. With proper coaching Suda might be able to draw and write more. I wish Suda a happy and a long life and good luck. Thanks.
"proper coaching"???? Get real, beat & torture them to achieve this! The mahout is controlling the Ele's trunk by pressing a nail into it's ear where u can't see it. Also, there are faint pre-drawn lines on canvass. They are just filling them with paint like a coloring book, forced to do it by mahout.
I’m glad I came to the comments and wasn’t the only one who knew about this elephant. The keepers abused them to teach them how to paint, they would beat them if they didn’t do the correct thing, and eventually the elephant learned how to navigate certain things in order to not get beat. He knew if he drew a line in this way, and not this way, he would be okay.. such a smart fucking animal and its so sad to see that these creatures, that clearly have some sort of thinking process, abused for profit.. money is the root too all evil, and we’re seeing that more and more in everyday things and life..
These elephants are tortured slaves of humans www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-an-elephant-paint-is-cruel-not-cute/ Like elephants used in the elephant trekking industry, young elephants used for painting must be broken and experience the pain of the phajaan process. Over this time baby elephants are starved, shackled, and beaten, until their spirit is completely broken and will submit to the will of their captors.
I wont leap to conclusions of abuse, but clearly painting hearts and her own name isnt natural. An outline of an elephant I can possibly accept, but the additions make it quite clear it's taught to simply copy something. Still very impressive, but most likely not natural.
I pity the elephant... he was trained but he didnt have his wild life to njoy in his way.. however suda u r an amazing painter.... i was focusing only on your eye.. u are very involved in that painting.. lovely
Resolve that may be true in some cases and I agree that many have been through torture, I do not know if these ones have been tortured, but these ones did the paintings by memory, elephants can remember a lot
Resolve I do see the trainer, but I don’t understand the body language of the elephant. I know u could be correct, but I cannot tell so I am unable to know. 🤷🏻♀️ I’m in no means saying ur wrong, I’m just saying that I can’t tell and that’s it, sorry. Goodnight.
Did anyone ask, how he was taught to do this? Hope no tortures involved.
It is, that's not normal
I would imagine that the elephant is painting by following lines on the paper that can't be seen at a distance.
Yeah
Might be conditioning
@@cybersoil100 Good observation. You might be right.
I hope and pray that this gorgeous elephant was treated with love and respect
Sorry, but you are a dreamer!
I am sure that These elephants are not trained by love and respect because elephants are not to draw or paint
It sadly was
not
Probably not
Nope... they pinch the Elephants ears, to control which way they move the brush...😔 xxx
it was elephants who drew all those cave drawings not humans. makes sense now
Bro that was my first thought no joke. Also what a knee slapper
😂😂
They torture them...
ua-cam.com/video/iQsg-ECcEUk/v-deo.html
@@matejblaha4659...
LoL 😂 underated comment
They draw better than me. I never knew Elephants could paint. This is truly astonishing. Such beautiful creatures.
Hate to rain on your parade, but they’re trained to cognitively remember how to trace a series of lines that’s disciplined through training, still impressive but they’re not really painting
@mr.petersen7150 aside from the allleef abuse concerning this situaton, I'd argue that's exactly the same thing artist's do
@mr.petersen7150 So they are like humans is what you are saying. Trained to remember things and write it down. Cool. If they aren't painting, who is? Is there an invisible person guiding them?
@@chill21100 You are clueless.
@@LarsTragel-zh7ei How are they clueless? That's exactly what it is! Even if it's not an original painting, the elephant still painted it.😂
Aside from the speculations of possible unfair treatment of the elephants involved in training, I’m just fascinated that elephants possess the cognitive ability to paint actual pictures like this
Do a little research. The elephants don't have the ability. They just hold the brush. Every stroke is controlled by the trainer standing next to them.
@@2bb-2 Yeah, I was amazed at first as well, and then the bubble burst. Better to know the truth.
speculations? the elephant was tortured to do this.It's is as true as your stupidity.
Sadly i witnessed first hand some of the treatment the Elephants get, they routinely have humans riding on them all day, and the trainer has a sharp tool that he used to stick in the Elephants ears, which were bleeding and seeping.
Same with bears and Tigers. The bears were completely shaved and forced to do tricks for a cheering crowd, it was heart wrenching and pitiful watching this almost deformed looking bear parading around just skin and bones. Something that has stayed with me through the years.
This was back in 2001, hopefully animal welfare have stepped in since then.
well they dont. They have been trained to do the strokes in this way. They don't know what they are drawing at all.
She even goes over some lines multiple times to make them thicker, this is incredible.
Too good to be true and it most definetively is. Somethibg fishy is going on
When elephants are left to paint freely, they just make abstract splotches and lines of color. I think this one was taught to make the specific pattern for a reward.
@@Big_BlackHawk Touch grass? I’m not the one dumb enough to fall for such an obviously fake video
@@Big_BlackHawk Ah yes the fake friends I was out partying with last night 😂
Just think for a moment use that tiny pea sized brain of yours. How would an elephant be able to understand complex shaping to paint itself at such detail? We DO in fact have paintings made by much more intelligent animals, in particular Gorillas, and even though they are highly intelligent they have nowhere close to an understanding of structure and shapes. They have a good idea about coloring and using colors to paint something you can discern but nothing that comes as close to what this video depicts, again, those where Gorillas. Much more intelligent.
Don’t you find it odd there just so happens to be a human right behind the elephant?
@@Big_BlackHawk also how the fuck would an algorithm know the difference between a staged video and a legit one?! Do you even know what an algorithm is? 🤣🤣
I hope they treat these sweet babies well. So talented she is
They are not. They are severly amused till mentally broken. Have jou a link to that article
@@luky4487 exactly
Oh baby! They treat these elephants SUPER well. Really. This elephant has painted this same picture thousands of times. That's how much fun the elephant is having while it paints the same picture! Cute right?
@@luky4487 They might have tortured it but that was a very poor choice of words. I’m a horse rider, and my horse is great. I didn’t torture him, I spent years training.
@@luky4487 training is a thing
If I didn’t see it with my own eyes, I wouldn’t have believed it. She paints in true perspective and even uses shadowing, sees in color, even paints her breaking off a tree branch and eating it and is only six years old!! Signs her name to the painting and NO MISTAKES!That’s f-en incredible! When I was six, I could only paint stick figures. Sell the paintings for a million dollars and use the money to protect her environment. I have to show this video to my friends.
After seeing the comments, I'm not sure whether to like or dislike
Better ignore 🤷♀😄
I dislike it :/
@@pastspinel4849 me too actually, because this is not good to animals
@@quit6174 ye I know, that's why I dislike it
be honest with yourself, but remember animals are suffering to make laugh a bunch of idiots in the public
I really hope they "trained" her fairly and properly and respectfully because look at how precious💙Elephants are naturally sweet and uber smart so there's no need for violent "methods of discipline"
IKR
I am sad for all the elephants treated badly:(((
@@flaviodesanctis1671 umm thats if their mad and treated bad we are talking about the good ok so stop with the bad
@@flaviodesanctis1671 i know they treated her bad if u see her body tho
@@caken5505 for those elephants, Suda might be treated like that before or now.
Animals and birds are not only source of human beings entertainment.They are not source of food for human beings.They have their own life. so Please give them good treat, love, care and respect 🙏
Yo since when aren't birds animals
Are you caring animals and birds
I‘ve looked for this comment
@@margi1411 Yes i ve a cute puppy rescued from somewhere. Unfortunately he is unable to walk cause his back legs have been broken
are birds like a whole other life form
I love the way the eyes look like they widen when she puts the brush to paper lol the concentraition and just pure presciousness 😢❤ and she knows when she needs more paint 😅❤
She isn't doing the painting. Elephants are very intelligent but painting isn't one of the things they are good at.
Her trunk is being controlled by the mahout hiding beside her front legs. These elephants naturally would be naughty trying to play with each other. The reason they don't move is because they are pressing a nail in the flap of their ears, causing pain and reminding them of punishment.
How do you know this.? You gonna bust my bubble aren't you?
@@keepwildinthewild
@@shakeserfistssmith1364 Oh! I'm sorry, don't mean to. I've been studying from the best. Mostly self- education and a lot of research. I also follow many Animal Activist groups all over the world.
I'll give you a video that will show you an elephant painting
Telenoche - Memorias de un Elefante - Capítulo II
and give you a video on how they train them young
breaking the spirit of an elephant
You may be better off not watching this one because it will make you cry.
"Very disturbing footage". I can tell you that they are torn away from their mothers and begin their torturous training at the age of two.
The first one starts in Spanish but hang in there they speak English when they are painting. You will have to copy and past in search . You Tube doesn't allow links leading to animal cruelty.
@@keepwildinthewild just shows my naivety,I myself am self taught. I come from a small town and was not exposed to much of the world. Then came the internet, at 40! Lol. It was worth it.
@@shakeserfistssmith1364 You aren't naive. If I hadn't studied them, I would have thought they were painting. I know a lot about elephants, and this is not natural to them.
What is natural to them at this age would be breaking away to play with each other. But that nail being pressed into their ears they don't dare to leave their posts.
He was just 4years old aww God bless you child 🐘 I cried watching this.😘 wish I could hug you tight and say that you're such a sweet baby.
How do you hug an elephant lol
I was touched at first, it even made me cry but I wish they weren’t abused in order to draw this. It’s seen they are well trained :((((
How would we know if they're abused or not?
@@miss_bhello7925 ua-cam.com/video/iQsg-ECcEUk/v-deo.html
Are you black?
I am speech less after looking this vedio..plz love these wonderful animals...
A great suggestion from UA-cam after a long time 😅
Ang galing ng nagturo jan
@@marisalicayu7961 hi can u speak english..
Wow! Never thougt this, never saw this!
Suda, bravoooo!
Hm, I hope Suda is well and do it with a free will.
A creative elephant. Why not?
by the power of GOD almighty...excelente👏👏
Elephant are the most Intelligent Animal on this earth, they have emotions too
I am very impressed that this little champion SUDA made a very heart touching drawing and by painting he just saw us his love to all Human Beings..
I am sure that those elephants are very happy and not under any harrassment.
Live long SUDA and all other Friends.. 🌹💐🙏😇
Lots of Love and Respect from INDIA 🇮🇳💐🌹
Preet Bhatt that’s kind of you 😊
@@redstripezoom8856
From My ❤️ Thank You Very Much..
" वसुधैव कुटुंकम् " 🙏💐🌹😄
The most intelligent animal on Earth are the cetaceans (Dolphins and similar) after the human.
😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰😀😀😀😀😃😃😃😃😃
@@ogalo1653 Yes 🐬 are very cute as well and has higher IQ
💐🌹🙏😄
I hope that People don't abuse this Amazing creature 🙁
Elise Amann i hope that too! Hope this elephant wasn’t abused to learn how to draw just to make humans enjoy :(
I hope so.
I'm vegan and animals just deserve to be free.
They do. How else does she know how to paint? She didn’t just come out of her mother knowing how to paint. She knows if she doesn’t paint, she will be hurt. I wonder how much abuse she went through to learn. Fucking people. I know damn well this poor baby is abused.
Because I can: You do realize that animals can be trained without any abuse?
@@underthestarsoverthemoon4259 proof please?
The steadiness and perfect strokes of it is amazing, elephants have always been my favorite animal ;)
They are abused it isn’t cute
There are alot elephants in my country. But I don't like when people torture them...
Once when I was a little boy my papa took me to watch a parade on the road. At that time an elephant walked through front of us. He was chained. When he saw me he smiled at me and when he rose his trunk to wave at me his master struck his trunk. He was harmed just because he wanted to say hi to me😭😭😭.
By the way I wasn't grown enough to figure out if the elephant was he or her😬. Whatever, that memory hurts me a lot☹️
@@hiperku5085 what the. Elephant acully smiled at you!! He/she must have been a loving 🐘
@Winter Rous T They could, if the people that were training them were not Indians. I'm not racist or anything but all of us know that Indians are generally rude and violent. For example I once called the tech support team from Pubg Mobile and an indian answered and kept swearing me like "Motherfucker" "Cock Sucker" and more. I repeat, I'M NOT RACIST
Omg. He drew it in 3D. And see how steady and accurate his brush was as he retraced the lines! Unbelievable! Incredible! Super artistic and intelligent!
Its actually really sad.
She is a girl. Suda is a girl name.
She** Sudha is a female name
@@samomanawatpronouns is not needed
@@SAN-bi2vm In most East and Southeast Asian languages, yes. But in English, I’m not sure.
14yrs ago and I'm just seeing this. I'm pissed...this elephant's uniqueness should have a documentary film for the world to see. Let me go do some research. She's unbelievably talented.
Very true this is something very unique
@leavewildinwild
Not hard to find. Suda the painting elephant
I agree. I see a lot of negative comments on this video, and honestly, I dont know how she was treated. From what i see in this video however, she certainly seems to be genuinely happy to paint. She is literally dancing in between brush strokes. That does not seem like a sign of an abused animal to me. I could be wrong though.
Did you research!? What did you find!?
How can anyone hurt these precious and intelligent animals. I wanted to hug the elephant lol.
Mr.Gabriel Garza *lot’s of love (Another’s meaning for lol.)
Lol
Me too!!! 😍
ikr they just hurt the elephants to do things right, I really want the world to change
@@burntroses176 why do people assume this. Hurting the elephants wouldnt teach them how to paint, it would teach them to be scared of people. Did the elephant look scared? She was literally dancing in between brush strokes.
Lol we just got a tutorial on how to draw an elephant by an elephant 😂🤣🤯
😂😂😂😂
xD
XD
WTF do you say. That elephant is drawing nicely and you are making fun of him
Sooraj S please tell me you’re trolling 😂
I pray these wonderful elephants are treated well with respect given proper care.
ua-cam.com/video/3uh9W2Es7Ng/v-deo.html
🤔🤔
Stfu
Keep dreaming
It will never happen in this world
They aren’t they are severely abused for this!
Hi.
This is an amazing masterpiece! Suda is the Picasso of the jungle ❤
Thats cause she was beat and tortured until it was forced to repeat a single picture. Not art. Just pain.
มึงอย่ามามั่วรู้ดี@@gorbshal2598
@@gorbshal2598honestly i would usualy never agree to animal abuse comments but you might be right
Picasso was a terrible painter, majority of the time.
This elephant paints better than me
But the fact that their forcing the elephant to do this and they probably did somethibg cruel to it.. i mean like.. elephants are almost endangered species?!. They shouldnt be doing that!
@@viofrostline9289 ;-; im gonna be a. Vet how on earth am i gonna do that?! Can you tell the future? I have 6 pets and i have never shouted at them.
Yes, but is beautyful elephant and her draw
Stand master:Suda
Stand name:the brush
I doubt that that they abused them. They are so gentle and good with the elephants. It is ok for them to do that to they are very smart and are usually very good at being taught. If abuse was contained then people would have shut it down already.
Also just because they are vulnerable does not mean they get abused all the time. These people seem to love and care for the elephants. The elephants seem to love them back and seem to love painting.
I can't take it, this really melts my heart. Pls don't hurt her/him.
oh they hurt them alright
:(
She isn't hurt. Look at her body language. Not every elphant farms are the same.
Its looking innocent but none of us know that the pain, it is going through
they not it
infire mannn Watch the phajaan videos, that will change your mind!!!!!
@@Mu5096rdgh ffs im saying the elephant isnt an object
You don't know too then
Well many ppl in the comments know
It's amazing they can paint, but how lovely is it to draw a member of their species picking flowers? Loving and peaceful creatures.
She is not painting. The mahout hiding beside her front legs takes control of her trunk and maneuvering it around the canvas. Elephants wouldn't even pick up a brush voluntarily for the tip of her trunk has very sensitive nerve endings that it is painful to hold anything for very long there. People need to know that Thailand cruelly uses elephants for profit.
The one horrible things that is done here is these youngsters are the result of being torn from their mothers in the wild and put through extreme cruel and inhumane training till they lose their spirits and begin the rest of their lives obeying their human owners.
This is not natural behavior for them. They would be running a muck playing with each other and being mischievous. Where they have a nail being pressed into the sensitive part of the ears, they dare not to stray.
You are not too bright. Training with PAIN!!!??
Omg... This makes a tears on my eyes.. How cute.. He done this with perfection 😘😘😘😘😘😘
Because he was abused to do so
Je m'appelle Abderrahim et fermer votre gueule
There's so many beautiful beings on this planet, wich we call "animals"
Agreee!!
We Human How do you know he was abused?
after 10 years this pops in my recommendation in quarantine
this ain't right how they train them to paint
Yeah just draw it in front of them until they learn
Elephants in 5098 be like:(shoots AK47)
@Vivi Cruz m.ua-cam.com/video/ITlo2ZBJOWU/v-deo.html
Tbh, they don't look in a bad shape to me.
You know, every year, tons of children are abused by their parents, that doesn't mean all parents abuse their children.
Same goes for zoos and nature reserves, some mistreat their animals, some don't.
Elephants are actually really smart creatures and I think I've hear of studies proving they can feel pleasure doing things like painting.
Plus, looking at the communication means they had in African countries 10 years ago (when this video was posted), I don't think those elephants caretakers knew about their capacity to learn how to paint before seeing them into action.
Rather than being tortured to learn, it seems more likely to me that they simply imitated humans after seeing them paint because they found it entertaining.
We only saw 15 minutes of them without context, so we can't tell for sure how things are for them behind the curtains.
Mowd Cridhe Bunny Well, not really. I can understand how maybe an elephant would enjoy picking up a paintbrush and slapping some paint onto a canvas but there is absolutely no way that this elephant was painting that picture of its own volition. As smart as they are, elephants don’t have the brainpower necessary to conjure up abstract representations of real world things like that. There is only one explanation: she was forcibly trained to do that. Remember that elephants aren’t like dogs; they won’t simply do whatever you say in favor of food. Instead, elephants must be “broken,” typically through corporal punishment or being confined into very small cages until they bend to the will of their master. If you see an elephant doing literally any kind of trick, gimmick, or unnatural interaction with humans, 99% of the time they’re doing it because they have no other choice.
Beautiful
I still can’t believe the baby elephant drew this beautiful painting. It’s so amazing without even making mistake. So beautiful
The Camouflage Girl they got bite until they are able to draw a good painting
@Expert French Toast and cheese is yummy!! English may not be Antoines first language, so please behave yourself, geez learn som compassion.
@Expert French Toast and cheese is yummy!! ua-cam.com/video/iQsg-ECcEUk/v-deo.html now look who is wrong
I've seen it first hand, the person standing next to the elephant tugs on the elephants ear manipulating it into a trained action from the trunk. Sorry to ruin it for u but you will never see an elephant painting without the handler stood next to it usually on the far side from the audience.
Yep :3
What a sueprise ! A very nice painter . A grand salute to the elephant baby and to the woner .🙏🙏🙏
The elephants aren't painting. The mahout is maneuvering her trunk around the canvas. This is a tourist trap. They use elephants for profit and it's not a pleasant life for them.
Is this video in everyone's recommendation?
Yea
Musa Khan yep 👍
It is because of the UA-cam algorithm 😂
Yes wtfff
Yesss
The comments brought me down :(
Hope these elephants are being treated okay
those comments are full of idiots who jump into conclusions without knowing their shit. Elephants are creative and emotional animals by their nature.
But you never know. Humans can be evil
@@dieselgeezer18Yes they are creative sweet beings. Elephants are playful when they are happy but that's not the case here. They are painting when they are told to do so. They are being forced.
Like elephants used in the elephant trekking industry, young elephants used for painting must be broken and experience the pain of the phajaan process. Over this time baby elephants are starved, shackled, and beaten, until their spirit is completely broken and will submit to the will of their captors.
www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-an-elephant-paint-is-cruel-not-cute/
Me too :(
@@monicaravichandran4015 h
I think this is the time to learn a lesson,save trees,save these innocent animals and save nature.
Ss
Sahi BAAT boli bhai
Now you are talking my friend 👍!
Better late than never.
And this is the time to stop painful learning elephants to make stupid and useless things like that
I know......pleaseeeeee pray with all my heart that abuse was NOT involved in this. I'm an animal activist and have read, heard, and witnessed some of the horrific treatment elephants endure for our entertainment. Its absolutely heartbreaking!!!!!!
I must admit, I could never draw that well. What an incredible artist!
its beautiful how much control these animals have over such body parts!
Repent and believe the gospel, this could be your last chance to be saved, God bless you
Same
@@jecaparaiso5477 no.
@@jecaparaiso5477ur parent should off u
I hope that Elephant lives 300 year more. God bless that Elephant 🙏
So if he didn't know how to draw he wouldnt deserve to live as long?
Watch vid read comments...ua-cam.com/video/HXhhdkOc9Bo/v-deo.html
Amen.
@@Smorgasvord Ofc. Who needs a fucking useless ele who can't even draw? Ridiculous.
yeah 300 years of slavery NIIIIIIIICE.
I hope this elephant is drawing with happiness, not in fear😇 god bless💗
Aayushi Maheshwari me too :)
Yasss.. the elephant is happy.. by the happy nodding I can say that 🤗
Von wegen gequält werden die Natürlich ist es nicht lebt ihr in eurer Traumwelt bloß die Augen verschließen ihr sollte Mal hinter die Kulissen sehen unmenschen
God bless you
The ear flapping is a sign of contentment n happiness. Calm down 🙄
The elephant is very smart. Extraordinary. That's wild they could do that
The elephants are not painting? The mahouts conveniently hiding on the other side of them guiding their trunks around the canvas. This is a long painful procedure for them. Their trunks have many nerve endings which hurts them to grip things in this case, a paint brush. These juveniles normally be playing together, but if they try to stray, they get pieced on the back of the ear, with a nail, one of the most sensitiveness parts of their bodies.
This is one of the most incredible things I've ever seen
Same
Agreed. Such intelligent animals. Makes me wonder what the elephants think about us.
Yeah..
They are being tortured to do this
:( this is not okay.
K. Lo No it not .... it’s fucking sad and cruel. You don’t think he just picked up a paint brush and started painting do you. no of course not he was most likely beaten into it
Not to be dramatic or anything, but I would die for this elephant
You truly are a heartfelt hero
This made me laugh. I just wasnt expecting it
ua-cam.com/video/3uh9W2Es7Ng/v-deo.html
🤔🤔
Seriously?
Respect
I feel so sad about seeing that TORTURE STICK (bullhook) under the painting stand. Elephant sees it all the time so (s)he knows that it’s goint to be used if the master is unhappy with the elephant’s work. This cruelty must be stopped.
I agree. It’s a shame knowing the pain and sadness these beautiful creatures are going threw. Truly a disgusting act of power.
Honestly humanity will cause extinction for other animals in the future if they keep treating animals like this.
Hah I'm the first reply in this box to not end the sentence with a full stop
@First Last If thats the case, then i hope it launches its convoluted escape plan soon.
that's bullshit , those stivks are to hold the canvas , or if the person get's atacked to be able to do something , ya'll delusional
Я и представить не могла, что животные на такое способны. Она рисует с удовольствием. Это невероятно и потрясающе.❤
Young elephants are tortured by a painful training process to “paint” please do not go as a tourist to these places.
Please do elaborate further. I'm curious.
You can google the subject and obtain a graphic description of the training process and how elephants are “trained” for any action.
I dont understand , they seam to be loved and happy, please explain, thank you
It’s so gross 😭😭they need to stop this !
@@grenda5 They undergo a process that includes being ripped apart from their mother shortly after birth, being whipped, being submersed and darkness and water for days on end, being starved, and being tortured to ensure that there Quote spirit is broken. This is not fake, hundreds of account have been reported of this. Elephants are wild, so they naturally won't do this. Please do not support this industry. For more information, look up on national geographic's article on wildlife tourism.
Hope they weren't violently coerced to learn this. These are amazing creatures and should be treated with respect.
@Homer if u read other comments it sounds like the trainer is nudging on their ear to move in certain directions
@Homer この映像CGですよ。韓国の芸術大学院生が制作したCG映像です。すごくリアルですよね（笑）
韓国の映像技術がどれだけ高いか分かりますねw
@@SP-nt2od 本当ですか？
@@maxgarz8576 本当です。日本人の私が言っています
@@SP-nt2od わかりました、すごいのCGね？ありがとうございます。
Someone needs to take action with this. Elephants need freedom. So sad😭
90% of zoo animals cant survive in the wild because of injury ore sickness and are set free when they are well so shut
@@theenjeneer2493 This actually isn't a zoo. The animals here are From the entertainment and wildlife tourism industry. Nothing like a zoo. They undergo a process that includes being ripped apart from their mother shortly after birth, being whipped, being submersed and darkness and water for days on end, being starved, and being tortured to ensure that there Quote spirit is broken. This is not fake, hundreds of account have been reported of this. Elephants are wild, so they naturally won't do this. Please do not support this terrible industry. For more information, look up on national geographic's article on wildlife tourism.
The Enjeneer They are NOT set free, after being in captivity they would not survive. The ones that are healed are usually in their own environment not in a zoo. That way they can be set free again.
@@eliseb5918 where did you get this information
@Yese 30 m.ua-cam.com/video/ITlo2ZBJOWU/v-deo.html
That's incredible. They must be the smartest animals. I don't even know how that is possible. I hope he is treated good tho. If you treat elephants bad you're scum. Imagine having a painting of an elephant painted by an elephant
I hope no tourture is involved in the process of training these elephants.
ofcourse there is sadly
there definitely is. it’s such a sad truth and no one ever talks about it. the torture and exploitation of endangered animals for tourism is just disgusting.
@@jaehaywardkent Oh I wasn't familiar with that
@@lazarusdouvos what is your source?, I mean, I want to know but no one in the comments has given a source yet
@@creepermanzombie24 this video shows u everything u need to know. it’s so upsetting. ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html
Elephant after 2 years:"hello friends, welcome to my youtube tutorial of how to make an elephant"
🤣😋🤣🤣🤣👍🏾best comment on here
Number 1: Get the elephants to shag
Number 2: Boom you have a new elephant
Great
😂😂😂
😂😂🤣
It's honestly beyond amazing,,,, but I hope and pray that there's no torture or any form of cruelty involved during the training 😭😭😭
Shut up asian culture hater
A lot of torture was involved When they were two, They were stolen from their families and had to go through the 'crush;' this video will explain better than I can upsetting footage. ua-cam.com/video/ibTJmYLLNOA/v-deo.html
Amen for that 🙏
@@enricoputrawijaya4591 The elephant is not painting. Maybe a line or two, but the mahout is guiding her trunk and inflicting pain to her ear, and maybe parts of her body to keep her focused and stay put. These elephants are miserable and depressed. This is no life for an elephant, standing there all day in the hot sun 7 days a week, then shackled all night. She should be roaming the jungle with her family. Not stolen from her family in which she was stolen by these people. ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html
Ever heard of south Asia?
Lol that elephant prays for death
I noticed that the first two elephants were drawing essentially the same picture. Interesting! That makes me think this is trained behavior, rather than spontaneously created art. It is remarkable, regardless.
If you saw what they do to make these elephants to just stand their, it would break your heart and probably infuriate you. They are not doing the painting. The mahout, hiding beside front legs where you cant see him, is guiding her trunk around. This is nothing but a tourist trap and cruelty to animals.
For all those commenting on how amazing this is, you have absolutely no idea what disgusting treatment they receive behind the scenes.
All you have to do is search up the "Phajaan".
Oracle thank u 😢
their tusks are removed as well
Thank you Oracle. As I watch the trick, I see how precise the elephant uses its trunk. It is controlled by the trainer!!!! I used to watch captive wild animals with fascination with their tricks until I realize how animal cruelty plays into the picture. Dolphins, killer whales etc. I did Google phajaan. I encourage the viewers to do so themselves. I also would like to hear from the trainers' point of view regarding the practice. And the elephant/human culture in Asia from experts. And the debate from both sides.
This exploitation of elephants, and of wildlife, for human entertainment should be banned and boycott. Very sad.
@@fabgirard1429 I agree with you. But with caution. Let's hear all sides of the debate. Think hunting licenses in developed countries.Trophy hunting in Africa. Commercial harvesting of krill in the southern oceans.
This is not natural to the animals, just imagine if you're being forced to crawl all the time, which is not natural to us human. We seen this as entertainment without realizing the process these animal had gone through....
So sad....😫
😟😫
@ö ô just curious, what shows that the elephant is enjoying this?
ö ô ok calm down. They were just asking because there is actually no proof of the elephant enjoying this. This comment is just trying to raise awareness whether it is true or not, because this happens. Also you don’t have to get so mad over a question-
@ö ô I was simply asking a question there was no need to be so toxic to us
@@intermedez stop being so fragile, this is the Internet, he's not even being that toxic. Keep crying kid
Я в восторге,первый раз вижу чтобы слон рисовал,и так чётко и красиво,какой молодец,наверно много трудов пришлось приложить,чтоб научить,смотрела,немогла оторвать глаз,это великолепно,умничка,учителя хорошие.
I wonder how many people know how cruelly they are treated in training. The truth is shocking to say the least. Do not be fooled by these people.
@ Cynthia Stogden. Dear Cynthia Stogden, please enlighten me. Thank you. I like elephants. They are not cruel like lions and tigers.
@@bhimsenluchooman4046 please read all the posts on here. There is a long one by some one who explains it all eloquently. Good that you lome elephants.
@ Cynthia Stogden. Dear Cynthia Stogden. Thank you. I will read and also google search on the subject. Happy new year to you and your family.
Bhimsen Luchooman lions and tigers are far from cruel, it’s the circle of life
Some are actually trained, not hit or anything. And if the elephant was hit or anything, the people could get arrested for animal cruelty. So yeah. But that's just my opinion.
That middle elephant there is clearly very happy, you can tell by the happy dance it does while waiting for the brush back
Holy crap.. Suda is literate!!!! 🤯
Thats what im saying. An elephant learning to paint in 2 months could only happen if the elephant is actually interested in painting. The happy dance tells me she is somewhat of a "prodigy" elephant, who truly loves painting. Im no elephant expert; but something tells me you could not get these result, in only 2 months, just by torturing an elephant into painting. Because If they could, unfortunately, more places would be doing it.
The intricacy and control in his trunk is jaw dropping. How he goes back on the lines so precisely ... Elephants deserve far better 😢
D truthing exactly my point too
Thank God someone else commented on this. So did I...I caught it immediately and stopped the vid, had to reason for a minute...we kill these animals for just their tusks? We're insane as a species...clueless.
@@mhillvo ..absolutely
Nah... looks like he is thoroughly enjoying his craft and his handlers are obviously fond of him.
He is special and he knows it 😇
@@mhillvo we didn't start it. Its been going
This is not okay! It looks so cute and innocent, but none of us know what they did to the elephants...
Probably the same thing they did to me when I was a kid... Alot of getting hit with a stick until I can do my school work right
Wita cha pin Amk, im so sorry... Is that true!?
@@ximonmc3077 it's true to most kids in third world countries, not just me
thet torture the animals ua-cam.com/video/d2AvHPKOS7k/v-deo.html
Wita cha pin Amk should’ve done it right in the first try kiddo
It's unbelievable.her concentration,attention to detail matches a human child.I'm absolutely flabbergasted,she's a genius.
She is trained to do the same painting and stroke. They are mistreated during training. This isn’t spontaneous
Amazing beautiful, God created such wonderful Animal, to do such a good drawing.
@@ashrafsalemi4064 the animal was trained to do
The same painting ober and over again dummy
All of these elephants were trained using TORTURE. Be aware of that! It's called Phajaan, Crush training, Torture training; it's done by BRUTALITY, 24/7, for as long as it takes for the people to crush the elephant's spirit and Will. It KILLS up to HALF of all captive Asian elephant calves, and is part of why Asian elephants are becoming extinct, including in captivity. Wake Up! Learn!
@@ashrafsalemi4064
Captive Asian elephants are forced by Torture training to work and obey man. It's not beautiful, they were FORCED to do this by TORTURE. Learn about Phajaan, also called Crush training, also called Torture training, which kills up to half of all captive Asian elephant calves. Every working elephant on the Earth, including those who are forced to paint, were forced through it, and they are abused with sharp steel hooks, knives, and other vile tools of abuse, and chained when they aren't working, shackled as slaves. It's Not beautiful. Please learn.
Elephants are truly wonderful, special beings!
Elephants drawing better then me 😊😊😊😊😋
😂🤣😁😃😄😀😆
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
হুম ভাই
me too!
😄😄😄😄😄
This made me sad because imagine how much pain they have been through
And how much paint...
but how do you know that the elephant wasn't taught by love and instead pain I'm not saying you are wrong its just a possibility
@@daniel_schmidt. r/woosh
@@StarStar-wx4tf What? This has nothing to do with r/woosh does it?
@@daniel_schmidt. ohh sorry!
My bad😐
I really really hope that the elephant was not tortured cuz that would just completely break my heart!!! 😣😭
they were probably "stimulated", especially since its more than one elephant doing it.
or they don't need much training and its something they are naturally prone to learn fast and easy to motivate, doubt it though >
Its in captivity what do you call that moron? Heart broken , youre not happy but I am!
ARMY BLINK What makes you think that idiot. People these days always keep accussing innocent videos of being torture.
Absolutely Right brother.
Ana Paula Rocha Campos well, the elephants are in fact tortured in order to make them paint, so that could be one reason.
You can see the sadness in their eyes... Guys, elephants don't have a natural inclination to paint. From our perspective this is a fascinating video, but in truth they are tortured by their trainers in preparation for their paintings and while during. The handler here is most likely employing a hidden nail in their hand and piercing the elephant's ear and tugging it to dictate where to direct the brushstrokes.
If its only entertainment you're here for, then know that this isn't an elephant that can paint, it's a human that can use an elephant to paint-like controlling a video game character.
And perhaps by itself that would be impressive, were there no animal abuse involved.
I love how carefully she puts the brush to the paper
She is beaten if she does it wrong - it is abuse ...
@@montyrayza7220 : Could U learn such like artistic painting after regular beating for a month , No and Never---- even Picasso was not to be able to paint like our Suda, dear. Bravo!
Suda is, perhapse, more artistic a being than Picasso even.
problem is that its always the same picture, meaning that someone has most likely taught the elephant through re-enforcement and that may be far from a pretty sight. You know its from the heart, when the elephant writes, "HELP ME, I am in Chinese re-education program!"
Our Dear Suda is Better than a Master painter, even... Bravo!
I can't believe it, elephant drawing picture... How intelegent he is... Love animals...
Ksi ahes
Elephants are most intelligent animals
@Hornyshark phajaan means
but without abusing and by kind you made them train its really good....beautiful creature ......i love respect animals
for those wondering, the elephant is guided on what to paint by the trainer nudging their ear in the direction thye need to move the brush. they were taught how to paint each image and every elephant can only do one.
that's what I thought
Ratatouille in real life
well i'm still incredibly impressed with both the elephant and the trainer.
so what?...can a dog do this?a cat or dolphin ,a really smart pig or horse? an ape?
@@davidjones-vx9ju of course not, as they don't have trunks...... but Iif they had trunks, they might be capable of doing similar feats with proper training...
Absolutely amazing. I'm applauding this lovely talented elephant. Please I hope they are well taken care of and no ill treatment or torture is meted out to those elephants.
I hope the elephant wasn't tortured when receiving his/her training
They would have been :(
Elephants don't paint or draw - they were trained to do this and sometimes that involves using torture/ physical pain. : (
yeah this is awful
Yes he is, and he is also during this video. The caretaker is hurting him with a pointy stick. Of course they don't show that.
Aw man it's not fair they have to go trough torture just for training :{
Now me, a human, cant even draw a human.
Thank you, Mr. Elephant. Very nice
I really, really hope there is no dark story behind this. This looks too good to the eyes!!! 16 minutes of pure cuteness, bliss.
Definitely is, they'd rather be eating leaves.
No. They are very depressed and miserable. These people bought them from a training camp where they are inhumanely trained to perform for tourists. The paintings are done by the elephants. The mahouts are doing most of the work and are constantly inflicting pain with a nail they have between his fingers. These babies were stolen from their families and I can assure you that the mother has ongoing sadness. Elephants share the same emotions as us. These guys work 7 days a week until closing and are shackled up all night. This video explains it all. It's mostly Spanish but hang on. You'll get it. ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html
we don't know but normally, painting elephants cannot be pressured or else they won't like to paint... if this elephant is an expert of painting, it may only be because he was set free to paint something...
those who are pressured to paint are normally not competent at all and will be less productive... yet this elephant seems pretty fine but as I said, these are my theories, we cannot be a hundred pourcent sure
Dark? You can not get Darker then this. forcing a wild animal to paint. How much beating goes into training?
@@keepwildinthewild Thanks. I just watched 2 mins of the link you sent...had to stop...couldn't bear to watch any more.
Suda painted with such careful deliberate strokes. She has that same right brain focus that a human has! I know, I am also an artist. She got deep into it and really enjoyed herself. This was so fun to watch! I am left with sheer amazement at the intelligence and emotion she demonstrated! ❤
I saw an elephant paint in Thailand. The trainer guided him the whole time, literally steerimg the head while the elephant kept his trunk stiff.
On this video, you don't quite see what the care taker is doing, but he seems to be always standing right next to the elephant when she paints something. My guess some kind of steering is going on there as well.
Maybe the elephants are okay with it, but it's certainly a tourist show and I would only buy / support such a picture if I knew for sure that it was drawn without human "blueprint" and that the paint (and whatever training took place) wasn't harmful.
I think each elephant is trained in a specific pattern so when they paint they only make that pattern for a reward.
When untrained elephants are left to paint by themselves, they tend to make abstract little flecks, splotches, and lines instead of trees and such.
Regardless of training or how intelligent elephants are, there's little evidence that they have any innate cognition for abstract images and relationships. In other words I doubt the elephant would even regard any relationship between it's own kind and the two dimensional image it drew on paper. But I'd be interested in reading studies on the subject.
Same, like I’m not against animals being trained as long as the animal is happy, healthy, and the training isn’t abusive or in any way detrimental to the animal, and that the animal has lots of free time to just chill
elephants arent self aware...they are following traiing, not painting a picture
@@donkey3187 yes they are self aware
Elephants are intellegent animals
They just need love and care.
Edit: Thank you guys for 187 likes. 😊😊😊
yes they are and fun fact: they are intelligent then all the sauropod dinosaurs or in fact ANY dinosaur
Well humans are also an animals but intelligent one
@@AussieInDistortedworld humans are creatures not animals
@@dash33r22 what?
@@dash33r22 mammals
I sure hope these elephant weren’t abused TEACHING them how to do this.
Hope Too
Karen Pearson unfortunately I have seen where people said they supposedly were 😔
Yes :(
Karen Pearson me to 😭 i pray for them this video broke my heart.
Kirsteph same here. Sad what mankind is capable of. 😢
This video is 14 years old and I'm only just learning an elephant can paint an elephant better than I can paint an elephant.... how is this even possible?????
Is It still alive 😭? Such a talented elephant WTF?! can it teach me?
Omg NEVER mind I'm hearing the elephants are tortured to be able to this stuff 😷 poor elephants
@mommyissue I dunno .... sounds to me like that elephant is living a better life than u are 🫢 can u plz explain to me how the hell u torture an elephant into having a talent or a skill as such ..... just how😂😂
@@mommyissue that's just pure speculation.
@@jovanleon7based on evidence
Omg this is amazing but I really hope she was not distressed or uncomfortable to do it poor baby I just wanna hug her
Impractical to hug an elephant. It's bi. Come hug me. I need it
@@saeed6811 I am a egg I am too small for a hug
@@saeed6811 down bad
She was and is beaten on a regular basis. Sleep well.
@@saeed6811 Ha!
I love how I'm getting recommended stuff about elephants painting elephants and a guy taking care of a baby monkey 😊💗
Omg saaaaame
KayLikesTheatre AndFood I did too
I get the same shit wtf? Like my recommended is filled with that dude with the monkey the dude with a bunch of tattoos right? Lmao
You got those baby monkeys videos too huh
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is one of the most amazing things I've ever seen. Such control and amazing intelligence. God bless the animals.
This is not a blessed animal.... this is an animal that has been severely abused by a human. Please look up Elephant Crushing...and have a tissue handy as well.
la inteligencia que te falta a ti...
Yes extremely amazing if you cheer for animals getting fucked by assholes. How braindead can ppl be right0
@@DaNNy_DodgeSpain ellos se terminan creyendo que son inteligentes, ellos ven solo lo que hacen, el producto final, lo que se ve en el video, no ven todo el recorrido, entonces sí, se engañan, se mienten, se creen sus mentiras de que sus logros son verdaderos y naturales... se creen que son los mejores por lograrlo... esto es como el ladron que consigue 1 millon de euros a punta de pistola.... será lo que quieras, pero inteligente, como que no.
Es esclavitud
The most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen. I cried as I watched, such a gorgeous elephant!
The elephant is not painting. The guy who never moves from her other side is forcing her trunk on the canvas. I've seen how they do this and how they are trained. Not pretty. This would make you cry.
Seems fun and all but imagine how they taught the elephant to do that. Lots of torture was propably involved. This is so sad!
@Payton Wright when an elephant bobs it's head like that, it means they are depressed. It most likely was beaten when it was trained to do this
So, when you see an elephant in a large forest attentively listening to Beethoven and moving in time, I guess you assume it was tortured to do that too?
I just love the way the elephant takes the brush so slowly and starts to draw with so much care.
It's amazing what you can make an animal or a little child to do. Isn't it fun to watch bears running around in the circus like their clowns. They really look like they're having fun & plus we get to enjoy watching them. Animals & children are here to please us & they really do.
Mate, the elephant just holds the brush. It looks gentle, because the carer must aim carefully with the line.
elephant is unhappy that people are cruel!!!!! poor elehant's....verrry upset!!!!!!!!!!!!🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
YOU CAN HEAR THE ELEPHANTS CRY. THE GUY BEHIND HOLDS THE ELEPHANTS EAR AND BETWEEN THEIR FINGERS IS A NAIL THAT THEY PIERCE INTO THE EAR IF THEY DO NOT DO IT RIGHT.
(sorry for caps its copy-paste)
I StM I
Oh really!?
And do you have proof that the man was holding the elephants ear?
Elephant’s paint is actually better than mine...
Same
Yes
Mine is better
I can't believe it drew the legs in first attempt
Yes i cant draw like him
I love elephants. Just imagine an animal, smart, strong and gentle… that’s the elephant. The elephant combines all positive qualities, all positive characteristics an animal can have! Huge respect to our big friends, I don’t know why people in India, Thailand, South Africa, Bangladesh or Indonesia treat them so badly. Just from their size I would feel quite intimidated so I would never dare to behave disrespectful to an elephant let alone mess with an elephant
elephants are intelligent creatures. Imagine what they feel when theire familiy is killed for their teeth.
Tusk, also that elephant is abused.
@@clichewolf save the elephants
@Asia Olszewska animals deserve better they so majestic
Why would I imagine that
@@girlgamesshakeel3458 sadly, i cant.
Wow because of this video, my life has changed. Thank you for the love and the joy you bring.
How your life is changed because of this video's which shows you's animals toucher.
Because of you I feel no shame and I tell the world, it's because of you
@@soytv5654
😀😁😂😃
this is song😀😁😂
Everybody gangsta till the elephant starts painting the Mona Lisa
Who painted the mona lisa?
_da vinki-_
*no, the elephant*
@@LiterallyEly da elephant*
@@smilingpiano79 thay was unnecessary and disrespectful
@@smilingpiano79 maybe you should acctually watch the videos instead of spending your time staring at peoples profile pics honey :)
Kira yoshikage*
Is there someone watching in 2024??
Suda, you are very great. Now I understood that Elephants do everything perfectly if trained well. But such training should not be painful to the elephants. If they are really tortured to learn this art, it is more painful to the viewers than being excited.
Manasa Keerthi no ingles yes espanish
Look this elephant has focus.Had it felt pain won't have learnt art.
I don't know about these particular elephants, so I wouldn't presume to say how they were treated. But, yes, in conditioning, the "bell" system is well known. Initially a creature is beate
or otherwise made to suffer, all the while the bell rings (or it rings at the beginning, I am not sure). After a while, only the bell is rung, and the creature behaves as if it had been beaten, so complies. It's a system that goes back as far, or even further than, the arabian knights etc.. I don't know if it would workl in a painting situation, though, and besides, something like thos could be done more successfully with a rewards system.I'm not surer the elephant is aware it is actually drawing itsalf, either, since it (a 2 dimensional line drawing) requires a primate's mental configuration. But who knows?
This is a wonderful video. Suda should always be protected and treated well. Suda has ushered in a new era for the elephants. Heartiest congratulations to Suda for learning how to draw, paint and write her name in English at a tender age of four. With proper coaching Suda might be able to draw and write more. I wish Suda a happy and a long life and good luck. Thanks.
Look up phajaan they’re tortured into doing this stuff
Lol, a happy life for Suda is already out of the question.
Well this was twelve years ago so I’m sure you can see how far she’s progressed if you search for it
If you think he's treated well, please investigate. What you will find will break your heart into a million pieces. Ask them how they BREAK ELEPHANTS.
"proper coaching"???? Get real, beat & torture them to achieve this! The mahout is controlling the Ele's trunk by pressing a nail into it's ear where u can't see it. Also, there are faint pre-drawn lines on canvass. They are just filling them with paint like a coloring book, forced to do it by mahout.
This elephant is more talented than the cringy Tiktok teens. i wish the elephant is safe ❤️❤️❤️
with u u-u
"TIKTOK BAD"
Tiktok is cringe, that elephant would make a better app than Tiktok
@@hi-zb3yn yep
@@hi-zb3yn tiktok bad, i'm laughing so hard i never heard that one before
I’m glad I came to the comments and wasn’t the only one who knew about this elephant. The keepers abused them to teach them how to paint, they would beat them if they didn’t do the correct thing, and eventually the elephant learned how to navigate certain things in order to not get beat. He knew if he drew a line in this way, and not this way, he would be okay.. such a smart fucking animal and its so sad to see that these creatures, that clearly have some sort of thinking process, abused for profit.. money is the root too all evil, and we’re seeing that more and more in everyday things and life..
I don't mind elephants taking over the world.
(●´ω｀●)Please see my UA-cam(●´ω｀●)
Fr
These elephants are tortured slaves of humans
www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-making-an-elephant-paint-is-cruel-not-cute/
Like elephants used in the elephant trekking industry, young elephants used for painting must be broken and experience the pain of the phajaan process. Over this time baby elephants are starved, shackled, and beaten, until their spirit is completely broken and will submit to the will of their captors.
@@travagamhsou3301 That is horrible 😞
@@angy529 it is
Idk why this made me cry but it did. I am a struggling artist and this animal reminded me how natural self expression is ❤️
Es gibt noch wunderbare Sachen. ..Die Vögel bauen mit Perfection ihre Netze. ..Die Bienen bauen auch Waben. .Wer hat sie beigebracht das? ?????
ua-cam.com/video/s9GIzRPWCow/v-deo.html not self expression
It’s not natural. Elephants are not naturally skilled with painting, this one was obviously abused. You should cry for another reason
I wont leap to conclusions of abuse, but clearly painting hearts and her own name isnt natural. An outline of an elephant I can possibly accept, but the additions make it quite clear it's taught to simply copy something.
Still very impressive, but most likely not natural.
HUG YOU TIGHT. 🥰💖🥰
I can't even paint as good as this beautiful elephant
@@normabailey1834 lol are you drunk? This is a video about elephants painting not politics
@@normabailey1834 Are you okay?
@@normabailey1834 I would just say something: Trump is racist, do u vote for a person that hates an person just for his skin?
Absolutely breathtaking. She seems to enjoy it, you can see her really thinking about where to place the next stroke of her brush!
I pity the elephant... he was trained but he didnt have his wild life to njoy in his way.. however suda u r an amazing painter.... i was focusing only on your eye.. u are very involved in that painting.. lovely
You fink he read you you comment?are you seriously?
@@1Амирхан obviously it's not for the elephant to read Sherlock Holmes
@@-eurosplitsofficalclanchan6057 ок...ок... Watson!
You can't deny the look in his eyes, and we can't really be sure.
Xin Quiote it’s a she
She’s abused.
Helen H Army?
Imagine if one of them drew " H E L P "
Oop
That would be really twisted.
Resolve that may be true in some cases and I agree that many have been through torture, I do not know if these ones have been tortured, but these ones did the paintings by memory, elephants can remember a lot
Resolve I don’t see it but u could be right ig but anyhow still very sad for many elephants out there
Resolve I do see the trainer, but I don’t understand the body language of the elephant. I know u could be correct, but I cannot tell so I am unable to know. 🤷🏻♀️ I’m in no means saying ur wrong, I’m just saying that I can’t tell and that’s it, sorry. Goodnight.
Worth the internet ,got tears 🥺🤍