That scene is actually so much worse because its reminiscent of what actually happened to children of poor families in the late 1800s when the original story takes place. Before the days of birth control, families would have tons of kids. And if enough if them didn't die in infancy or you didnt have a farm were you could work them to support the family, there were simply too many mouths to feed. So some parents would take the children that were old enough to work in workhouses and factories and basically sell them into indentured servitude. Thats why you see the donkeys all being sold to different labor camps and why you saw lampwick crying for his mother. Its was supposed to be representative of a child realizing he was being sold and calling out for her in desperation. The whole scene is a fucked up version of propaganda aired towards children with the message of "behave or else you parents might decide to sell you."
I was an 80s child and I STILL remember adults telling me to behave or I would be sold into slavery. It was told me 100% straight too, not as a joke. When you're a kid, you believe that crap.
In order for Pinocchio to become a real boy he had to eat a human so it was more like a horror story that Disney burned down and then to the liberty to make a completely different story@@sophiakalter5960
Love that lullaby but I can never listen to it without crying. I cried to it when I was 2 and I still cry to it now at 32. I play it every so often on UA-cam.
what's even more disturbing about the kid's film (other than the creepy owner of pleasure Island) was the boys who got turned to donkeys.....they never got to go home....I can only imagine how horrified they must've felt when they can't be anything more than enslaved boys turned to animals.
@@SpeakNay well, the coachman mentionned they'll be sold for working. In the book, Pinocchio is first sold to a circus and when he's a puppet again, he works for a farmer and recognize Lampwick as a donkey
Disney actually put that in the movie to try to warn kids about underage drinking and illegal activities telling them that there are consequences to those kinds of things
I mean, if that was why then they definitiley went aboit in a weird way. Being sold to slavery isn't a consequesnse of smoking, drinking, and playing all day.
@@DollSchmidt4429 they could have definitely made that connection clearer, at no point was it apparent that the characters were becoming addicted to anything. I'd thought the messege was about trafficking.
@@brown7180 I think the slavery part is more of a stranger danger thing mixed with the be a good scolar moral of them skipping school to go to pleasure island, either way you get the basic gist that giving into temptation and trusting shady strangers is not a good idea.
To this day i always wondered about all those kids that were transformed into donkeys??? 😳 Or how long they been doing it bringing kids to that island........🤔👀👀👀 When i was little it confused me
My sister was traumatized by this scene at 3 years old, long before I was ever thought about. They had to bring her out of the theater to calm her down.
The way you can hear him screaming as he loses his humanity. And the brilliant move to show the physical change as a silhouette on the wall, leaving much of it to the imagination of the viewer. 💀
It is disturbing... BUT more disturbing for me is either Rork's death in Atlantis the lost empire, or Hercules's near death in the end of his movie. Imagine being killed via crystallization or being aged to death in the span of minutes.
No, the most traumatizing scene is when that kid never turns back. I know i was supposed to be being taught not to gamble, drink, smoke and be a bum, but all i learned was "wow people are really wicked to make a movie like this! For kids!" I must have been 9 or something
What a maroon! He got a freaking talking puppet! Ya got a magical sideshow attraction that you can sell tickets to, and you wanna turn him into kindling?
That scene from The film "Pinocchio" by Matteo Garrone (2019) was traumatizing. The screams of pinocchio and the other boy were terrifing, since they were turning into donkeys
I can't imagine a single human being that wouldn't get marveled at a talking walking wooden puppet and either thing it's a miracle or a curse from a demon.. he would be either marveled or terrified in real world
In the version I read Pinocchio gets sold to the circus but doesn't perform well after the guilt of his actions sink in. So he's thrown off the cliff, the fish eat his donkey skin and the ringmaster lets him go free
It was a way for the author of the novel to satirize rural immigrants of Italy who were pouring into cities or sailing abroad to the land of milk and honey where the streets were paved with gold only to realize too late that there was no such thing and they’d become beasts of burden in a city or country they didn’t know or understand with no means of returning home.
The original version the first before it was rewritten after many people complained to the author add Pinocchio committing an act of self-harm from the branch of a tree. Like many fairy tales that we grew up with the original versions were horrific such as The Little mermaid also committing self-harm. Children being baked into pies and eaten I'm not certain but I think the Cinderella story which is in many cultures one of them has the wicked stepmother boiled alive. Can't even imagine you know your 7 years old working literally working all day and the entertainment that you get is this
Lesson Learned: Don't be an ass and you won't turn into one.
lol!
That’s one way to look at it lol 😝
Creative 😭😂🤣
😭 lmaoo
funny ahh 😭
This scene horrified me when I saw it as a child. It’s still pretty horrifying even now as an adult.
It did all us
I was like 10 and that stuff was normal to me like that crap wasn't scary at all
same here
Same here. Some Disney movies were so dark to me, I couldn't see their ending at all. 😢
@@cysshorts1529I thought it was cool lol
No the “they never come back as boys” and the pleasure island bit. Is by far the most disturbing scene
Especially after all of the nasty things being discovered about some other "pleasure islands" in the real world.
Yes it really scared me i felt so sick to my stomach. The truth is always hidden in plain sight.
@@hsabrae the coacher's face in this scene still scare me as an adult
In the end of book Pinocchio finds Lampsick, on edge of his death because of all that hard work, and comforts him in his last minutes.
You know the Disney version of it, is less horrific than the actual story.
Duh
It's still fun to see how Disney once kept some dark aspects.
That scene is actually so much worse because its reminiscent of what actually happened to children of poor families in the late 1800s when the original story takes place. Before the days of birth control, families would have tons of kids. And if enough if them didn't die in infancy or you didnt have a farm were you could work them to support the family, there were simply too many mouths to feed. So some parents would take the children that were old enough to work in workhouses and factories and basically sell them into indentured servitude. Thats why you see the donkeys all being sold to different labor camps and why you saw lampwick crying for his mother. Its was supposed to be representative of a child realizing he was being sold and calling out for her in desperation. The whole scene is a fucked up version of propaganda aired towards children with the message of "behave or else you parents might decide to sell you."
Indeed.
I was an 80s child and I STILL remember adults telling me to behave or I would be sold into slavery. It was told me 100% straight too, not as a joke. When you're a kid, you believe that crap.
That's not what it represents at all.
@@wanderinghistorian in my case I was told I'd be sent to foster care
I read the original book. it was pretty good, but i do believe him missing the midnight deadline to be back home wasn't his fault.
No. The most traumatizing thing is that donkeys were actually treated that way throughout the mediterranean.
Who gives a fuck
Revisited that movie recently. At one point, I just said that I imagine Pinocchio describing the events of the movie, years later, to a psychiatrist.
In the original book Pinocchio deserves all that
What did he do?
In order for Pinocchio to become a real boy he had to eat a human so it was more like a horror story that Disney burned down and then to the liberty to make a completely different story@@sophiakalter5960
@@sophiakalter5960 in order for him to become a real boy he had to eat a human so the original was closer to a horror story than a Disney movie
@@ryanhollstein4164meatcanyon?
@@Dingusoh I don't know that show
"Oh, so you bring the Donkey to the Slaughter House?"
.....
"So they can kill him quickly and humane?"
"...... nah, that's boring!"
It's probably to save money.
The donkey scene terrified me as a little girl and I didn’t watch the movie for years because of it.
Same
Nope. Dumbo baby mine is the saddest most devastating and traumatising part of Disney. that song still makes me cry.
Lion King was also extremely sad mufasas death was extremely heartbreaking
Same!!
Ikr
Love that lullaby but I can never listen to it without crying. I cried to it when I was 2 and I still cry to it now at 32. I play it every so often on UA-cam.
Bette Midler did a nice version of that song in the movie Beaches.
Farmer: I'm going to turn you into a firewood
Pinocchio: NUH UH
😂😂❤❤ yeeets himself back into the water 🌊
My dad would read me that book as a kid
Pfp checks out
"he yeets himself"
what's even more disturbing about the kid's film (other than the creepy owner of pleasure Island) was the boys who got turned to donkeys.....they never got to go home....I can only imagine how horrified they must've felt when they can't be anything more than enslaved boys turned to animals.
Did you hear the rumor saying Donkey of Shrek was one of these kids
🤯🤯🤯
@@Lonnii-zq5ne yes because he's a talking donkey. Which means he managed to escape before the transformation was complete
@@a.g.demada5263 where did u hear this? hahaha I'm down to know more hahaha
@@Lonnii-zq5ne I don't remember well but I think I heard of this
I'd say it's when the coachman is interviewing the donkey kids by asking their names
When I was a child, the most traumatizing Disney moment was the distressed quail in Bambi.
They have in bad for Pinocchio. This is when he was just a puppet.
That scene scared the shit out of me when I was small!
Yeah I feel bad for the kids who turned into donkeys
Somehow how I feel like that’s the part of Pinocchio that’s not talked about enough 😭 it’s so sad when you think about it
@@SpeakNay well, the coachman mentionned they'll be sold for working. In the book, Pinocchio is first sold to a circus and when he's a puppet again, he works for a farmer and recognize Lampwick as a donkey
Disney actually put that in the movie to try to warn kids about underage drinking and illegal activities telling them that there are consequences to those kinds of things
I mean, if that was why then they definitiley went aboit in a weird way.
Being sold to slavery isn't a consequesnse of smoking, drinking, and playing all day.
@@brown7180 supposedly that's supposed to represent how they became slaves to the addiction and also warn children about human trafficking
@@DollSchmidt4429 they could have definitely made that connection clearer, at no point was it apparent that the characters were becoming addicted to anything. I'd thought the messege was about trafficking.
@@brown7180 I think the slavery part is more of a stranger danger thing mixed with the be a good scolar moral of them skipping school to go to pleasure island, either way you get the basic gist that giving into temptation and trusting shady strangers is not a good idea.
@@ginogatash4030 that's true
This is more than asylem insane
After reading the original version of Pinocchio and what a heartless little psychopath he was, I have little sympathy for him.
I thought he was sold to a circus, first 😮
Yes, first he's sold to a circus
To this day i always wondered about all those kids that were transformed into donkeys??? 😳 Or how long they been doing it bringing kids to that island........🤔👀👀👀 When i was little it confused me
Well, normally, they're sold to farmers or mines.
There's a rumor saying Donkey of Shrek was one of these boys
Did anyone know that lampwick is donkey in the movie Shrek? An old lady got him and then sold him years later in the Shrek movie.
It can't be him because he diesn't talk anymore when he's fully transformed but yes, there's a rumor saying Donkey was one of these boys
@@a.g.demada5263 that's true 👍 maybe donkey is one of them and escaped B4 he totally transformed
@@Jaserad yes and that could explain why he can still talking
That scene traumatized me as a kid
Moral of the story: Almost every Disney movie based on a story or fairy tale has EXTREMELY dark origins.
My sister was traumatized by this scene at 3 years old, long before I was ever thought about. They had to bring her out of the theater to calm her down.
The way you can hear him screaming as he loses his humanity. And the brilliant move to show the physical change as a silhouette on the wall, leaving much of it to the imagination of the viewer. 💀
This scene never afraid me but yes, that moment is heartbreaking when we see his shadow
That’s something gingerbread story began
“Are you my papa now? Can I finally be a real boy?”
“Shut up drumhead”
And Walt Disney was like “ holy shit we gotta make a movie outa that”
It is disturbing... BUT more disturbing for me is either Rork's death in Atlantis the lost empire, or Hercules's near death in the end of his movie.
Imagine being killed via crystallization or being aged to death in the span of minutes.
This was my favourite movie when i was little
If you wanna have a bad time, look up Drew Blood - Pinocchio and the black pantheon. That's not the exact title, but you'll find it.
and the rarest sentence of the 2024 goes to! "when the farmer fishes him up he is furious that his donkey was actually a puppet and wants revenge."
Mine will always be the death of the ac unit in Brave Little Toaster. Damn, you want to experience trauma, there you go.
Yes, but at least the Master came back and fixed him, so the AC unit was alive and well again.
no, it's Mufasa's death, you can't convince me otherwise
Yeah that scene genuinely scared the 💩 out of me when I was 5.
Naked Pinocchio is cursed
IN ONE OF THE LIVE REMAKES, THEY HAVE THIS SCENE
It shows how often children aren't treated with dignity if left alone without trusted adults.
The real life animated movie has me traumatized and in tears as a kid 🙁
It's weird because me, I never was afraid of it
Bro really said "YEET"
Pinocio said "nah ide swim"
No, the most traumatizing scene is when that kid never turns back. I know i was supposed to be being taught not to gamble, drink, smoke and be a bum, but all i learned was "wow people are really wicked to make a movie like this! For kids!" I must have been 9 or something
Man that's a Story for a Warner Bros Cartoon!
The live action version use to give me nightmares
I was not prepared to see naked Pinocchio 😂
See we all agree that Pinocchio is a horrific disney movie/book?
What a maroon! He got a freaking talking puppet! Ya got a magical sideshow attraction that you can sell tickets to, and you wanna turn him into kindling?
I reads the OG Pinocchio at eight. Never forgot this scene or the hanging one
Dang imagine when we used to do this to real people
Pinnochio was so scarry.
Yup. Pinocchio is one Disney film I will NOT allow my kids to watch.
My third grade teacher, Mrs. Balding would read a portion of the original story to us every day during rest period. It was unforgettable!
This scene always horrified me but then the way the animated the water in the ocean scenes comforted me a lot
Ice cube : “I want revenge”
counterpoint: Mufasa death
In the 1st version of the book, Pinocchio gets hanged
Lampwick screaming "MOMMY" must have been Traumatizing. 💀
He had a talking wooden puppet, and he tried to sell him as firewood, that seems like a subpar deal.
That version of Pinocchio is absolutely horrifying
That scene from The film "Pinocchio" by Matteo Garrone (2019) was traumatizing. The screams of pinocchio and the other boy were terrifing, since they were turning into donkeys
imagine this scene was in the netflix pinocchio that would be horrifying
Why didn’t Pinocchio just say every time he lies his nose grows so then the farmer would already have firewood and Pinocchio would have to be sold
The most traumatizing scene from a Disney movie is from a book 💀
Pinochioh in the original book : skibili dum WOO
And people wonder why Atempted Murder was never put into the Disney Version.
That's so traumatizing I think I will have to call the helpline.
Nope, when tianas villain gets dragged to hell
Damn, that freaked me out as a kid. Not to talk about, Peter and the Wolf.
Dude never saw Old Yeller.
Yeeted, huh? Original book confirmed!
I’d love to see a horror movie of these fairytales that are true to the dark originals.
I can't imagine a single human being that wouldn't get marveled at a talking walking wooden puppet and either thing it's a miracle or a curse from a demon.. he would be either marveled or terrified in real world
The version from "The Adventures of Pinocchio" from 1996 was one of the scariest when i was a kid
I was actually surprised when I heard this scene traumatized people. I remember this being my favorite scene as a kid.
same!! I think it’s because I loved “a midsummer night’s dream” and this scene reminded me of it.
In the version I read Pinocchio gets sold to the circus but doesn't perform well after the guilt of his actions sink in. So he's thrown off the cliff, the fish eat his donkey skin and the ringmaster lets him go free
I wanna watch this movie again
I think mufasas dead was extremely traumatic it was so heartbreaking for kids and adults of all ages
Ok but more traumatic: the horse in the never ending story
What sort of psycho slaughters an animal by drowning??? Why? To prolong their suffering??
I cast polymorph on the puppet
It was a way for the author of the novel to satirize rural immigrants of Italy who were pouring into cities or sailing abroad to the land of milk and honey where the streets were paved with gold only to realize too late that there was no such thing and they’d become beasts of burden in a city or country they didn’t know or understand with no means of returning home.
The original version the first before it was rewritten after many people complained to the author add Pinocchio committing an act of self-harm from the branch of a tree.
Like many fairy tales that we grew up with the original versions were horrific such as The Little mermaid also committing self-harm.
Children being baked into pies and eaten I'm not certain but I think the Cinderella story which is in many cultures one of them has the wicked stepmother boiled alive. Can't even imagine you know your 7 years old working literally working all day and the entertainment that you get is this
Bro really said 🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴🐴
when I sail the real movie I was dead
So could donkey from Shrek possibly be one of the kids from Pinocchio
There's a rumor saying he is but if he can still talk means he managed to escape before the complète transformation
Even better then the movie
You know, I actually never understood why other people found the donkey scene terrifying, as I personally found it fascinating. 🤔
А теперь вспомним ту серию с ну погоди и робо зайцем😂. Just chek
"Nu pogodi robot rabbit"
Now that's horrifying
i am tramatised by the disney movie
The skeleton running away thing is real
Yikes. So many dark backstories with all the beloved classic kids stories.
do you know the oringin storytale of pinocchino's creator hated children so badly that he created this story