Has Macron failed to deliver democracy in France? - World Questions podcast, BBC World Service

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 98

  • @BBCWorldService
    @BBCWorldService  2 місяці тому +3

    Click here to subscribe to our channel 👉🏽 bbc.in/3VyyriM

  • @elroyrebello1712
    @elroyrebello1712 2 місяці тому +6

    Evelyn's question is the most crucial one for the current government.

  • @DudeNoEdge
    @DudeNoEdge 2 місяці тому +25

    When is France not in political turmoil lol

  • @MdAdnan-m1l
    @MdAdnan-m1l 2 місяці тому +10

    the last question from the lady was amazing. in my point of view, working and respecting opponents are the solutions of the current situation.

  • @HadjaHeatherBarry
    @HadjaHeatherBarry 2 місяці тому +8

    As I have an Excellent in Science Po ,I know the political Systems very well and I have voted Macron since 2017 but I am going with Melenchon in France 2027.Thanks for reaching out to me and God Bless

    • @karmatoys
      @karmatoys 2 місяці тому

      Yikes. I hope you don't have real estate to rent under a Melenchon government. They want to extend squatters rights to a point where it's not worth renting. And Melechon's antisemitism is dangerous.

    • @raphaelmauny3945
      @raphaelmauny3945 Місяць тому

      Oui le vieux 🧌

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 2 місяці тому +4

    No, it s the National assembly which is gone increasingly childish and irresponsible and the people thinking it should have more rights than duties.

  • @simakavousi6023
    @simakavousi6023 2 місяці тому +9

    Non of them have a solution and they are all in denial status.

  • @rmandel925
    @rmandel925 Місяць тому +2

    France is a paradise compared to the UK

  • @evetucek5185
    @evetucek5185 2 місяці тому +1

    I wonder if Obono would have condoned the use of violent rioting for weeks by the parents, family and friends of the kids that got murdered in the Bataclan

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

    Never question democracy, it's an important thing, it's our economy and it reprehends politics 🙏

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

    Democracy is everything we represent the protection of our family, culture is not questioned, it is a universal economy ☝️🙏

  • @boogalooinvestigator
    @boogalooinvestigator Місяць тому

    One of the pillars of democracy is the right to protest. Currently French citizens still have that right, and they're quite good at it... Unlike the UK where protest is outlawed and people can't be arsed anyway
    Viva La France

  • @Goku_4rscience
    @Goku_4rscience Місяць тому

    100% right what RN representive say about the rules and law regarding the roits

  • @AlaminMia-de1cu
    @AlaminMia-de1cu 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks Mehdi to deliver excellent question.❤

  • @mickeymouse-yd7bk
    @mickeymouse-yd7bk 2 місяці тому +4

    Po Science prestigious? Maybe in the past. But with todays selection, where skin colour is more important than talent......

  • @eurotop40
    @eurotop40 2 місяці тому +7

    Hmhmhm, BBC talking about democracy when British democracy is FA-A-A-A-R from perfect...

  • @shinyshinythings
    @shinyshinythings Місяць тому

    Evelyn has a great question, but politicians worldwide are paying attention to the ‘political consultant class’ which has been fanning out across the globe from the US and teaching them the politics of confrontation, disrespect, and disunity. It only serves one purpose, that of advancing antidemocratic causes.

  • @cartews4english321
    @cartews4english321 17 днів тому

    Evelyn❤

  • @peoplevrobot
    @peoplevrobot 2 місяці тому +3

    We really need Macron to go. France will probably not be able to avoid a political and economic crisis under other leadership, but clearly Macron's time is past and is just making the situation worse. He has nothing to gain to stay in power.

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

    There is a lot of economic problem, there are no problems or I told Ursula 🙏

  • @ThomaMONTI
    @ThomaMONTI 2 місяці тому

    Bridge Gate thanks old friend❤

  • @lmsxetj
    @lmsxetj Місяць тому

    isn't it that this table ronde a moderated screaming among the parties

  • @alexandervladimirov3939
    @alexandervladimirov3939 2 місяці тому +1

    What???😂 Is it the message from the state news company, where the head of UK was elected by nobody?😂Hahaha

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

    😊 Germany France England were united by a large universal bureaucracy not in decline on the contrary they were saved from inflation,

  • @hervegirard1949
    @hervegirard1949 Місяць тому

    Very great democratic exercice - all these french MP affording to show their level in english

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 2 місяці тому +1

    No, it s the National assembly which is gone increasingly childish and irresponsible

  • @KhanJan-j8u8h
    @KhanJan-j8u8h Місяць тому

    Can the world leaders help redefined the meaning of the word "Democracy"?

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

    😊 Always or declared democracy is a state that represents the condition classical politics the Vatican decides 🔨☝️

  • @TrFusion
    @TrFusion 2 місяці тому +1

    If I were to decide for France, I would reduce the number of fonctionnaires to one-fourth. One of the largest tax burdens comes from fonctionnaires, and their numbers in France are absurdly high. To make matters worse, their primary aim seems to be working as little as possible. For example, Japan has nearly double the population of France, yet the number of civil servants there is almost half that of France. Despite this, the quality of service at Japanese city halls is incomparably better than in France.

    • @shinyshinythings
      @shinyshinythings Місяць тому +1

      If we reduce the number of government workers their workload will only increase. It’s not logical. France doesn’t have the culture of Japan, efficiency is not a core value, and you can’t make it one by decimating the government workforce.

    • @TrFusion
      @TrFusion Місяць тому

      @@shinyshinythings "If we reduce the number of government workers, their workload will only increase." So could you please explain how workload would actually increase if we got rid of inefficient government workers who is truly incompetent or don't care of their work, constantly shift their work onto others, whether that's other public employees, private contractors? Wouldn't reducing these so-called "useless salary thieves" actually make things easier for the capable workers and faire for everyone? With such extreme inefficiencies with "wasted time", and the inability to correct these massive unfair practices in a society where hard work goes unrewarded, how can "Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité" truly be achieved? I would appreciate a detailed explanation with the explanation of what your core value is.

    • @marcGP-qk9gm
      @marcGP-qk9gm Місяць тому

      right In the bull eye

  • @GhislaindeTournemire
    @GhislaindeTournemire Місяць тому

    Sc Po, prestigieuse?… c’est l’école du wokisme …

    • @sennarghal691
      @sennarghal691 Місяць тому

      Ahaha il faut revoir tes fiches, je suis un wokiste et je t'assure que Sciences Po ne l'est pas 😂

    • @GhislaindeTournemire
      @GhislaindeTournemire Місяць тому

      @ pas de fiches. Juste un constat consternant.

  • @DanWest-i7y
    @DanWest-i7y 2 місяці тому +2

    As always, lies,fraud,deceit, manipulation,and a complete disregard for true French citizens. 😢

    • @monsieurgdavid
      @monsieurgdavid Місяць тому

      Suicidal tendances? Melenchon is as bad as Lepen for France

  • @peabase
    @peabase 2 місяці тому +1

    France is so ripe for the Sixth Republic. The UK should take note, too.

  • @Naughtyguiz
    @Naughtyguiz 2 місяці тому +1

    So more cheeps , that's this future democraty you really think about? 😂😂

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 2 місяці тому

  • @howidaalyan6005
    @howidaalyan6005 Місяць тому

    Hi France Assmbaly 2024
    Please Missels attack is main problems of global warming because to global warming has made climate change in the
    whole world .
    With Regards
    Ms.Howida
    -Young Scientist Award 2022 -Global Warming Research -
    Meetings International - Zurich - Switzerland.

  • @kantsagurung175
    @kantsagurung175 2 місяці тому

    France is the best country 💐

    • @Naughtyguiz
      @Naughtyguiz Місяць тому +1

      @@kantsagurung175 you hadn't ever seen nothing about this country's situation, so clean up yours eyes before saying bullshit !

    • @kantsagurung175
      @kantsagurung175 Місяць тому

      🤣 haaaaa Thanks,
      be happy and smile. Honestly I have been there 6 times and also visited so many parts of Europe. But I respect you and freedom of thought

  • @sohrabamiri7917
    @sohrabamiri7917 2 місяці тому

    How is France economic situation

    • @luloavic
      @luloavic 2 місяці тому +1

      A disaster.

    • @c.a.savage5689
      @c.a.savage5689 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@luloavic Not. Compared to USA, we're doing just fine.

  • @poldos0964
    @poldos0964 2 місяці тому

    yes

  • @HadjaHeatherBarry
    @HadjaHeatherBarry 2 місяці тому +1

    I think France is going to experience some drastic changes and we will experience France like President Obama who runs the world for eight years and still running the world.Thanks & God Bless !

  • @sandir-cz6oe
    @sandir-cz6oe 2 місяці тому

    Macaroni 👊👊👊👊👊👊👅👅👅👅👅

  • @susanzundel6231
    @susanzundel6231 2 місяці тому +2

    BBC news who can believe Them - Trump fans

  • @SunisaSeeson
    @SunisaSeeson 2 місяці тому

    🫵🥬🥕🥖🥐🍍🥑🍓🍏🫕🥗

  • @SunisaSeeson
    @SunisaSeeson Місяць тому

    1969

  • @ahmadjutt2266
    @ahmadjutt2266 2 місяці тому +2

    I am listen bbc video to improve English language

  • @variole9911
    @variole9911 Місяць тому

    Macron would have helped the situation by accepting a cohabitation with French Right like Mitterand did twice in his 14 years presidency

  • @HadjaHeatherBarry
    @HadjaHeatherBarry 2 місяці тому

    As a French American,I would like the France be like the United States as United States is the world first Power and all the Presidents should work like President Obama who are the best President world wide.Thanks and God bless !

    • @c.a.savage5689
      @c.a.savage5689 2 місяці тому +4

      You are aware, l presume, that Obama has not been president since 2016?
      Who is paying for your multiple comments?

  • @Frederique41
    @Frederique41 2 місяці тому

    If you cannot speak english fluently and pronounce the words properly, don't go on a panel!
    I know I should have more patience with non native speakers but sometime it is very hard to understand what they try to say - Speaking a language is more than just puting a bunch of words together!
    Imagine if an english speaker was invited on a panel where he/she needs to communicate in French and the pronunciation was as crap as what I heard whilst listening to this video. it would have been the end of the world.
    French people will tell this person off so I think French people should do the same when it comes to speaking in English.
    SPEAK ENGLISH!

  • @nabiollahkhodadadi4614
    @nabiollahkhodadadi4614 11 днів тому

    What a horrible guests

  • @HadjaHeatherBarry
    @HadjaHeatherBarry 2 місяці тому

    I think France has a great Democracy so far and I am going with Mélenchon on France 2027 and the democratie is going great so far.Thanks for reaching out to me.God Bless !

    • @c.a.savage5689
      @c.a.savage5689 2 місяці тому

      You are alone and obviously outside of France. Melanchon has zero chance of winning anything. And God has nothing to do with it.

    • @Naughtyguiz
      @Naughtyguiz 2 місяці тому

      So you tell so more sheeps for new france's democraty, that's your only reason that you think about! Go to bed o rather watch disney channel! 😂😂😂

    • @monsieurgdavid
      @monsieurgdavid Місяць тому

      You want to finish off the country?

  • @DoctorWu-sq6un
    @DoctorWu-sq6un 2 місяці тому +3

    Praise Allah for giving the world another home for Islam called France! Allah Ekbar!

    • @FreddieBlack-ho6iw
      @FreddieBlack-ho6iw 2 місяці тому

      Ah ah you’re so funny! Tell more joke please! 😂

    • @Lord_Vayne
      @Lord_Vayne 2 місяці тому +1

      Nouvelle croisade tkt même pas

    • @monsieurgdavid
      @monsieurgdavid Місяць тому

      You want civil war?

  • @davidorionrouge8502
    @davidorionrouge8502 2 місяці тому +1

    Failed to deliver ?he destroyed République