In all honesty there are several QBs you could probably make that argument for. With all things being equal, you really will never know. That's why there are probably 3 or 4 of them you could realistically call the GOAT and not be ridiculed for. He is one of them. Innovator, master, surgeon - Manning
Eli S I agree with you, but not 100%. I only say Brady because he's won more titles and such, but he also has a better coach and team than what Manning had. I think Rodgers will be up there when he hangs em up
Tbj585 here's my problem with the Rodgers argument. They've been singing his praises since day 1, and any TV or radio host you listen to now puts him in the top 3 or 4 QBs ever...already. He's won 1 Superbowl. Manning has won 2. Everyone pretty much just forgets about Manning. Not to mention Rodgers won't even sniff Manning's records. I would agree that Brady is probably the best ever if I had to choose one - if we're talking about just Superbowl/playoff wins. But are we? Then why is Rodgers in top 3? Not even close in career numbers and 5 less playoff wins than Manning and close to the same playoff winning %. I just think people forget quickly how great some players were for other flashy players now. Then the same things they held against Manning they discount for others.
He's just a better man than a football player he's honestly so humble and such a great man that that comes before him as a great football player that's right he's my favorite I can't believe it's been two years already Peyton
I wish everybody could just stop hating on Peyton.. And tom Brady as much as I dislike him the rivalry was amazing ... So many ups and downs ... Peyton meant so much to the city of Indianapolis and the colts it's unreal .. He took a dumpster fire and turned them into super bowl champions ... I'm sad we let him go but we gave him another chance to choose a team to finish his career with the Broncos and win another ring I always knew he would get ... Let's just be happy for greatness .. And I will go to my grave saying Peyton manning is the best Quarterback to ever step foot on planet earth
You kicked my Carolina Panthers ass in SB50, but I have to give credit where credit is due. You are one of the greatest to ever play the game and I am honored to have witnessed history while watching your throughout your career.
Invincible Speaker so did manning your point? The difference Brady actually contributed to winning his rings while mannings defense had to back up the mannings slack
Brady had one of the greatest coaches of all time. Along with some cheating in the process, the Patriots achieved their status because of Bill Belichick. Manning took 4 coaches to the Super Bowl. 2 of which were after his neck surgery. Greatest of All Time, Peyton Manning.
Gabriel Flores Ybanez ... He retired a Bronco. Thank the Colts for having no faith in him and letting him go to Denver so that we can win Superbowl 50 !!!!
Nic Van He never had a losing record with denver either two superbowl appearances in 4 seasons vs all the seasons with the colts? you guys had one super bowl win with you guys and one with us in a shorter time the only thing is the MVPs well of course he played with you guys longer. And i didnt think he would mention anything about Denver its about Indy 😂 And he had his best statistical season with Denver and an MVP in such a short amount of time. And he said he would always be a colt yet retired with the team who didnt think he was washed up.
When Peyton started.. the colts were rebuilding.. rookie team.. the colts were the most dominant team in the 2000's decade.. it is statically proven.. i grew up in indianapolis during that time.. i watched the colts superbowl win.. that team put indianapolis back on the map.. along with help to the city.. that team did great things for the people of indiana.. 👍👍👍
@@aaronvargas5498I know you wrote this 3 years ago but you can’t believe he did better things with the Broncos 😂. He literally rebuilt a team from the ground up and he produced on his own. The Broncos already had a good team when Peyton joined kinda what’s happening with the bucs rn then had a good team before Brady and then just needed a qb. Also Peyton played longer and was more dominant as a colt
The GOAT and not even close, Just for the fact that we need to judge players on individual accolades and not team winnings. If that's the case Peyton Manning is the greatest ever.
Brady isn’t the GOAT lol. Brady has had the greatest coach of all time (even though they both cheated several times 😴) not to mention a great defense. When Manning was a colt he had no defense. Then he went to Denver who had a great defense and won a Super Bowl with NO EFFORT. Tom Brady is the greatest clock manager of all time. Not thrower. Not quarterback. Clock manager
Baley Snell manning with the colts always had better WRs and a better running game, your point. And you do realize mannings defense carried him for both rings right? And please tim tebow coulda won the SB for the broncos in 2015. Manning is an all time choker nothing else
Lol the Colts dropped him and he went on to have multiple incredible seasons, one of which was the greatest season any QB in NFL history has ever had, and he did it with permanent nerve damage in his hand
Billy Bob Your logic is that if you win a champ you are better than another player. So by your logic Mario Chalmers is better than Patrick Ewing cause he won a champ
Sulafa Ahmmed so youre going with basketball references nice of course I see a link Im just sayin that Manning is no1 pick overall that means that he had the worst team of the league and bring it to a championship brady has been a late round pick with a super good team and the best coach the football have never seen (also a cheater) he always had help peyton was alone except for super bowl 50 (a super bowl that he deserves entirely but owe some of it to the defense in denver) but anyway peyton he is the record man the Goat and I would pick him over brady every day of the year
I bet the Colts sure are glad they fired the best QB they ever had for Luck so glad he won Superbowl 50 even if it was because of a great defense they were very disrespectful to Manning he built that stadium.
DustinCorvetteZr1 It wasn't out of disrespect. You can't have the number one pick that year and not draft Luck. Then you can't take Luck and sit him on the bench. Love Peyton, but at that time going, moving him to Denver was the best thing for him and Indianapolis. People forget that Indy was in a rebuild Luck's first year. Would you really want to stick Peyton into that system. No way.
usteeler81 exactly, he was drafted by the colts and refused to play for them because ownership was so bad so he played baseball until the colts traded him to the Broncos. Colts have the same crappy ownership that is driving Luck crazy today.
2PACLosAngeles yeah his numbers proved how great he was in the regular season those alone put him in the top three but not number one because of his playoff record.
he took 4 coaches to the super bowL that itself is very impressive.....
Peyton got carried for his 2nd ring
@@Justa5point0 why are you even here
I’m a huge colts and Peyton fan but yeah his first super bowl was earned a lot more than his second
Even my son can't compare to Peyton that's how good he is
Lavar Ball W
W's Galore
Lavar Ball W
Lavar Ball your a stud💪
Damn lavar ball up in here mate!
Peyton manning is one of the best of all time
Water is wet?
Not one of the best, The best.
Love you Peyton✊🏾 you will always be my favorite player
Justin Garrett same💯
"I Will Always be a Colt" - Peyton Manning ; Best Regular Season QB Of All Time , One of the Best to Ever Do It Without a Doubt!
The Goat 🐐
Definitely the regular season GOAT
Nah, that's Brady and this is coming from a Raiders fan. Hurts me to even admit this lol
In all honesty there are several QBs you could probably make that argument for. With all things being equal, you really will never know. That's why there are probably 3 or 4 of them you could realistically call the GOAT and not be ridiculed for. He is one of them. Innovator, master, surgeon - Manning
Eli S I agree with you, but not 100%. I only say Brady because he's won more titles and such, but he also has a better coach and team than what Manning had. I think Rodgers will be up there when he hangs em up
Tbj585 here's my problem with the Rodgers argument. They've been singing his praises since day 1, and any TV or radio host you listen to now puts him in the top 3 or 4 QBs ever...already. He's won 1 Superbowl. Manning has won 2. Everyone pretty much just forgets about Manning. Not to mention Rodgers won't even sniff Manning's records. I would agree that Brady is probably the best ever if I had to choose one - if we're talking about just Superbowl/playoff wins. But are we? Then why is Rodgers in top 3? Not even close in career numbers and 5 less playoff wins than Manning and close to the same playoff winning %. I just think people forget quickly how great some players were for other flashy players now. Then the same things they held against Manning they discount for others.
This shows no matter how many times you win a championship, nothing beats the feeling of your first championship! Let's Go Colts!
Peyton Manning is the goat he led a ok team to the super bowl and Brady always had a good team no comparison
Jaymoney Tv I hope your not saying the broncos are “ok”
StraightUp Madden Are you older than 8? Just a question. He led multiple Colts teams to the super bowl, one of which was just an ok team
I forgot that Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Emmanuel Sanders, and Demarious Thomas were garbage.
Oh don't forget that awful Broncos defense, Robert Mathis, and Dwight Freeney.
@@xbolt678 you just gonna leave Von out like that? The disrespect.
best point guard in MLB history no doubt.
Parthion Plays I'm dying here!!!!
He's just a better man than a football player he's honestly so humble and such a great man that that comes before him as a great football player that's right he's my favorite I can't believe it's been two years already Peyton
🐐. This guy and lebron are thee best example of greatness inside and outside the field/court.
Couldn't agree more!!!
I live in Indianapolis and my parents tell me when they saw Peyton manning win against the patriots to go to the super bowl against the bears
I lost some iq points reading that
Kaikoa Smith same
Kaikoa Smith same
i was your age when it happened
when?
Thank you for everything manning. I enjoyed watching you played. #fromapatriotfan
Dylan Lee respect
I'm not even a Colts or a Broncos fan and I love Peyton Manning. He's the true 🐐
You should read about what he did to one woman, before you say you love him. I like peyton but he has a pathetic past.
@@narghile7594 what he do?
Brady is the true 🐐
he will be know as the best colts QB-Falcons fan
this is like the only positive thing to happen to the colts in 2 years
Deserves one in Denver also. Peyton is the GOAT. Take that Tom
ricardo pozos-guzman no he doesn't lol idiot.
Oscar pULGARIN he probably started watching football 3 years ago lol
I hated playing against him in Madden. Dude would make like 30 audibles just to eventually call a run play.
Hell yeah smh
Will E.
fr😂
Omaha!
I'm a life long Bears fan but their was nobody else more deserving of a Super Bowl win against Papa Bear Halas' team than Peyton Manning.
I wish everybody could just stop hating on Peyton.. And tom Brady as much as I dislike him the rivalry was amazing ... So many ups and downs ... Peyton meant so much to the city of Indianapolis and the colts it's unreal .. He took a dumpster fire and turned them into super bowl champions ... I'm sad we let him go but we gave him another chance to choose a team to finish his career with the Broncos and win another ring I always knew he would get ... Let's just be happy for greatness .. And I will go to my grave saying Peyton manning is the best Quarterback to ever step foot on planet earth
Well deserved. Always love watching peyton change the play on the field and doing his thing.
Goat
You kicked my Carolina Panthers ass in SB50, but I have to give credit where credit is due. You are one of the greatest to ever play the game and I am honored to have witnessed history while watching your throughout your career.
Brady won his Super Bowls off field goals & a defensive int at the 1 yard line. That is all.
Invincible Speaker so did manning your point? The difference Brady actually contributed to winning his rings while mannings defense had to back up the mannings slack
Brady had one of the greatest coaches of all time. Along with some cheating in the process, the Patriots achieved their status because of Bill Belichick. Manning took 4 coaches to the Super Bowl. 2 of which were after his neck surgery. Greatest of All Time, Peyton Manning.
Billy Bob are you dumb? Lol you must not have watched them play lol
G.O.A.T. 🐐
I don't see Tom Brady bud
Peyton better than Luck now hand me W's
GJ Gaming Well duh
GJ Gaming W
L
Jk please don't hurt my family
Water is wet.
VV
Rip broncos fans
The 14 dislikes came from Broncos fans.
Gabriel Flores Ybanez Nope.
Gabriel Flores Ybanez ... He retired a Bronco. Thank the Colts for having no faith in him and letting him go to Denver so that we can win Superbowl 50 !!!!
@@johnnguyen3097 how’s that 5 year playoff drought going…
Never should've gotten rid of him Pagano and Irsay...😯😬
To just Shut everybody up, Brady and Peyton are the greatest QBs to ever play the game. Brady gon get his in New England. Goats
Peyton is such a great speaker. I could see him in some sort of political position in the future. He's humble and great, he's my fav.
4 words Greatest of all time
4 words... STAY OFF THE WEEDUH!
Broncos for life
Nic Van He did better those four years with the Broncos than what he did with the colts 😂 And he retired a Bronco 😎
Nic Van He never had a losing record with denver either two superbowl appearances in 4 seasons vs all the seasons with the colts? you guys had one super bowl win with you guys and one with us in a shorter time the only thing is the MVPs well of course he played with you guys longer. And i didnt think he would mention anything about Denver its about Indy 😂 And he had his best statistical season with Denver and an MVP in such a short amount of time. And he said he would always be a colt yet retired with the team who didnt think he was washed up.
When Peyton started.. the colts were rebuilding.. rookie team.. the colts were the most dominant team in the 2000's decade.. it is statically proven.. i grew up in indianapolis during that time.. i watched the colts superbowl win.. that team put indianapolis back on the map.. along with help to the city.. that team did great things for the people of indiana.. 👍👍👍
@@aaronvargas5498I know you wrote this 3 years ago but you can’t believe he did better things with the Broncos 😂. He literally rebuilt a team from the ground up and he produced on his own. The Broncos already had a good team when Peyton joined kinda what’s happening with the bucs rn then had a good team before Brady and then just needed a qb. Also Peyton played longer and was more dominant as a colt
Manning > Brady
brady is 11-6 vs peyton manning
peyton HGH
AmericasTeam True tho
AmericasTeam W
AmericasTeam at choking
Best QB in NFL history
I love this man!
🙏🏾🐐👑🏈🔫 #GOAT #TheSheriff #THEREALMVP&GOAT #THATSMYQB #MYALLTIMEFAVORITEPLAYER #PMONEY #18
What an amazing qb and person for what he has done for our great state.
Statue reveal at 2:18
PURELY the greatest quarterback ever
The GOAT and not even close, Just for the fact that we need to judge players on individual accolades and not team winnings. If that's the case Peyton Manning is the greatest ever.
Brady isn’t the GOAT lol. Brady has had the greatest coach of all time (even though they both cheated several times 😴) not to mention a great defense. When Manning was a colt he had no defense. Then he went to Denver who had a great defense and won a Super Bowl with NO EFFORT. Tom Brady is the greatest clock manager of all time. Not thrower. Not quarterback. Clock manager
Baley Snell W AMEN WWWWWWWWW
Stfu you moron, Indy had a good defense when they won the SB, Dwight Freeney, Robert Mathis, Gary Brackett, Bob Sanders
Baley Snell manning with the colts always had better WRs and a better running game, your point. And you do realize mannings defense carried him for both rings right? And please tim tebow coulda won the SB for the broncos in 2015. Manning is an all time choker nothing else
43-8 sounds like a great defense? TB12 the GOAT
Brady needs to thank the refs against the raiders in that playoff game
Lol the Colts dropped him and he went on to have multiple incredible seasons, one of which was the greatest season any QB in NFL history has ever had, and he did it with permanent nerve damage in his hand
I wonder if anyone Denver players or staff were there
he deserves more then a statute the greatest ever period
Y’all these Tom shady Bandwagons watch the rest 🐐
The Reason i was a Colts fan in San Diego
Was a blessing to be able to watch his entire career class act
I love you manning your my fraver nfl player and i will love so much
Nate W your English is awful
RazerBladeGamezz _ you are to
Nate W you didn’t even write that correctly either
RazerBladeGamezz _ you are doing it
🐐🐐🐐
#ThankYouPeyton 🐐🐐🐐🐐
Peyton is a MLG dude
NOW HAND ME DEM LETTERS OF DA ALPHABET
D
Manning > Aaron Rodgers > tom shady
Demetrius W
All 3>Dak Prescott
You forgot brees and Dan Marino
NFL fan L
anthony alfaro22 they're better than Brady as well
Better than brady
Liam Audet at choking
Billy Bob man you choking on the D of fcking cheater simce years
Billy Bob z Manning was better as a QB. He was a better thrower than Brady. But winning Brady
Billy Bob Your logic is that if you win a champ you are better than another player. So by your logic Mario Chalmers is better than Patrick Ewing cause he won a champ
Sulafa Ahmmed so youre going with basketball references nice of course I see a link Im just sayin that Manning is no1 pick overall that means that he had the worst team of the league and bring it to a championship brady has been a late round pick with a super good team and the best coach the football have never seen (also a cheater) he always had help peyton was alone except for super bowl 50 (a super bowl that he deserves entirely but owe some of it to the defense in denver) but anyway peyton he is the record man the Goat and I would pick him over brady every day of the year
Brady, Montana, Manning, Unitas, Elway. My top 5.
#rhank you peyton i LOVE you
Peyton for president 2020.yes!!!!!
Before Drew Brees joined the "GOAT" QBs of this era conversations I remember it use to be Manning, Brady, & Rodgers.
the NFL has not been the same since manning retired
Agreed
The true GOAT!!
Damn right he's a colt.
Man I miss Peyton Manning on that feild
Sorry , but the game is not like it was. Thank you Peyton for giving a lot of great memories.
I will always be a Colts BEST QB ALIVE 💙 lover you bro
i cant help but feel like this moment would mean more had he not been released by jim irsay . .
It was something special having him on the broncos... now.. siemian...
I'm a broncos fan and I like the legend Manning the sheref
alex Vasquez same I'm glad he came to the Broncos
Next stop Hall of Fame👍 Peyton disserves it
PEYTON MANNING BAAABYYY!
#GOAT🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈🏈
I'm still upset with the Colts for getting rid of him for luck
them nation wide commercials
The perfect football player
that moment when peyton and eli both have the same number of wins...
JoshuaWolfe what about mvps?
13 Years for the Colts wow
I bet the Colts sure are glad they fired the best QB they ever had for Luck so glad he won Superbowl 50 even if it was because of a great defense they were very disrespectful to Manning he built that stadium.
DustinCorvetteZr1 It wasn't out of disrespect. You can't have the number one pick that year and not draft Luck. Then you can't take Luck and sit him on the bench. Love Peyton, but at that time going, moving him to Denver was the best thing for him and Indianapolis. People forget that Indy was in a rebuild Luck's first year. Would you really want to stick Peyton into that system. No way.
Good Luck no pun intended Luck is shitty and he will never win a superbowl LOL I stand by my original opinion.
"I Will Always Be A Colt" Damn straight.
All Colts grow into Broncos 😉😉😉
Peyton goes down for the year Colts go 2-14.
Brady tears ACL team goes 11-5, Brady suspended for cheating team goes 3-1.
Once Brady retires he should get a statue
KNIFE N PRAY DrawingGamer he probably will. His day will come.
The sheriff < G.O.A.T
=*
Colts grow up to be Broncos. Elway, Manning, and Luck next!
Tyler Goudeau ummm Elway never played for the Colts.
usteeler81 exactly, he was drafted by the colts and refused to play for them because ownership was so bad so he played baseball until the colts traded him to the Broncos. Colts have the same crappy ownership that is driving Luck crazy today.
He should be wearing a choker for that pick 6 against the saints. What an underachiever.
GOAT🐐🐐🐐🐐
Solomon Kessington he's not the goat... he's the most dangerous QB in nfl history. MDQBINH
Manning 2020 for the White House
INDY COLTS STATUE OF PEYTON MANNING
INDY COLTS STATUE OF PEYTON MANNING
didnt even show the statue wtf
#cultforever #denverbroncosforever #Thankyou payton manning #Superbowl50champions
I love Peyton]!
Who loves Peyton Manning
Respect For The Sheriff
If You Do Like Peyton Watch My New Video About Him
He was a great qp!
Sasquatch is my nickname in athletics, does this mean I'm a colt? Oh no.....
#Broncosforlife!
GOAT
Brady is the GOAT, not even close.
Manning was the regular season QB, but he choked many times in playoffs.
2PACLosAngeles yeah his numbers proved how great he was in the regular season those alone put him in the top three but not number one because of his playoff record.
Class Act.
🐐
Second best QB
manning Montana. elway Marino Favre to me are the best to play the positions
Still wearing blue and orange 💯 let's go Broncos !!
make one in denver