It makes sense to teach Jawi in Islamic class, sort of. It's not used for modern Malaysian writing, and Arabic script is necessary for reading Islamic texts. However, I said 'sort of' because I don't think Jawi, the Arabic abjad with Malaysian sounds, is actually necessary to teach. The abjad should be taught for writing Arabic, not Malaysian, unless people want to read historical Malaysian texts because they are researchers. After all, modern Malaysian uses Latin. What's the point of teaching modified abjad when the value of the abjad is for reading Arabic and Persian and not Malaysian? The Quran is in Arabic, not Jawi. Another thing about Jawi is how they write the letter P. It's an F with three dots. If Jawi was used instead of Latin, writing P as B with three dots is better, to make it match with Persian and Kurdish. Arabic scripts with additional sounds such as P and G are too inconsistent all over the world; it would be better if they wrote the non-Arabic sounds in the same way.
Yes!A Malay learn Chinese doesn't means he gotta pray to Chinese Gods.It sounds ridiculous&hilarious when these Chinese shouting there for disagreeing government to let our next generations learn other races their language alphabets.P.S it's our national language tho.
I came to learn about Jawi. Reading Wikipedia is tiring sometimes. As a religious Arab Muslim, I think writing systems should be chosen based on the ease of using them for their language. If Jawi is not good for writing Malaysian vowels, then use something else, such as Latin. Why? Because Arabic writing can be taught from a young age in school. Muslims in London learn to write both the Arabic abjad and English/Latin alphabet when they are five years old. That's why I'm okay with Latin script for Turkish.
He Doesn't very well about jawi Hey dude you know only jawi You know in India have arwi Jawi is Arab Malay Arwi is Arab Tamil But arwi is language and But We speak arwi language
@@shukriramlee The Aksara Beringin script was invented by Adam Damario in 2017. It is an alternative way to write in Indonesian. The characters were modeled from the twists of the hanging roots of the beringin tree (Ficus benjamina) - the tree is also a symbol of unity - which were then modified and simplified.
I prefer creating a new writing system from scratch(Which I did created one) because jawi is a little too complex and not different. I like a writing system that is simple to learn but unique in its own way and not borrowing from any other languages. Wouldn't it be great if Malaysia has a unique writing system that doesn't borrow from Sanskrit or Arabic or any other languages in the world?
A unique writing system will make learning foreign languages too difficult, and it will make it difficult for foreigners to learn Bhs Melayu. It's best if as many languages as possible use Cyrillic, because Cyrillic has the most diverse range of sounds while being a simple alphabet and not a complicated cursive script.
It makes sense to teach Jawi in Islamic class, sort of. It's not used for modern Malaysian writing, and Arabic script is necessary for reading Islamic texts. However, I said 'sort of' because I don't think Jawi, the Arabic abjad with Malaysian sounds, is actually necessary to teach. The abjad should be taught for writing Arabic, not Malaysian, unless people want to read historical Malaysian texts because they are researchers. After all, modern Malaysian uses Latin. What's the point of teaching modified abjad when the value of the abjad is for reading Arabic and Persian and not Malaysian? The Quran is in Arabic, not Jawi.
Another thing about Jawi is how they write the letter P. It's an F with three dots. If Jawi was used instead of Latin, writing P as B with three dots is better, to make it match with Persian and Kurdish. Arabic scripts with additional sounds such as P and G are too inconsistent all over the world; it would be better if they wrote the non-Arabic sounds in the same way.
Yes!A Malay learn Chinese doesn't means he gotta pray to Chinese Gods.It sounds ridiculous&hilarious when these Chinese shouting there for disagreeing government to let our next generations learn other races their language alphabets.P.S it's our national language tho.
I came to learn about Jawi. Reading Wikipedia is tiring sometimes.
As a religious Arab Muslim, I think writing systems should be chosen based on the ease of using them for their language. If Jawi is not good for writing Malaysian vowels, then use something else, such as Latin.
Why? Because Arabic writing can be taught from a young age in school. Muslims in London learn to write both the Arabic abjad and English/Latin alphabet when they are five years old.
That's why I'm okay with Latin script for Turkish.
Very well explained
Terbaik bossku
Thank you :D
Weh, aku nak guna video hang for presentation. Boleh tak?
Keep up! Tak sangka kawan aku jadi youtuber. Boom!
Yes, i'm agreed with yr opinion sharing.
Aw thanks. I'd appreciate if you can share the vid :D
He Doesn't very well about jawi
Hey dude you know only jawi
You know in India have arwi
Jawi is Arab Malay
Arwi is Arab Tamil
But arwi is language and
But We speak arwi language
How on earth this video in feed?Good video btw.
Assalamualaikum
Before jawi, the malay have kawi, before that pallavi, before that sanskrit, before that aksara incung/rencong.
Or it is the other way around...
Kawi looks so similar to burmese
Tulisan beringin is the purest Malay ancient writing. The writing look like kanji mix thai.
@@shukriramlee not ancient
@@balromasant
ancient1
/ˈeɪnʃ(ə)nt/
adjective
belonging to the very distant past and no longer in existence.
@@shukriramlee The Aksara Beringin script was invented by Adam Damario in 2017. It is an alternative way to write in Indonesian. The characters were modeled from the twists of the hanging roots of the beringin tree (Ficus benjamina) - the tree is also a symbol of unity - which were then modified and simplified.
馬來西亞中華加油！！！
👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
Thank u :)
I prefer creating a new writing system from scratch(Which I did created one) because jawi is a little too complex and not different.
I like a writing system that is simple to learn but unique in its own way and not borrowing from any other languages.
Wouldn't it be great if Malaysia has a unique writing system that doesn't borrow from Sanskrit or Arabic or any other languages in the world?
A unique writing system will make learning foreign languages too difficult, and it will make it difficult for foreigners to learn Bhs Melayu. It's best if as many languages as possible use Cyrillic, because Cyrillic has the most diverse range of sounds while being a simple alphabet and not a complicated cursive script.
boringgg...not interested in jawi...we reject jawi is right
We? How about those that wants to learn? Also maybe you didn't listen to him entirely. You're another ignorant person
So you are the type of people how reject knowledge
كڤالا باڤق اڠكاو
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
بودوه بن بابي