CAN YOU USE R134a in R1234YF AC SYSTEM

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 161

  • @ElectricalCarRepairLIVE
    @ElectricalCarRepairLIVE  3 роки тому

    ⛐ Check out our Garage to see what tools we use and recommend:
    www.amazon.com/shop/worldmechanics
    ⛐ Subscribe and hit the notification bell by the subscribe button for new videos:
    ua-cam.com/channels/k_lcDzEWLs5fVRYceK3-9Q.html
    ⛐ Link to donate: gf.me/u/y59hvn

  • @onlygod5667
    @onlygod5667 5 місяців тому +8

    I use r134a on my yf recommended car and it works... it's still working fine as of now...been over 4 years now.

  • @jl456
    @jl456 2 роки тому +28

    They also said R134 wouldn't mix with R12 but alot of people did it and it works just fine for many years

    • @williamvaughan1218
      @williamvaughan1218 2 роки тому +5

      In fact a alternative refrigerant called freeze 12 is a mixture of r12 r134a r12 and hydrocarbons

    • @adamjankowski4315
      @adamjankowski4315 Рік тому

      Wrong, it was R142 which helped with oil suspension@@williamvaughan1218

    • @StandAgainstTyran100
      @StandAgainstTyran100 5 місяців тому +2

      Converted mine 20 years ago by slapping fittings on it and charging it. 20 years later it still works perfectly. Not one problem.

    • @salami99
      @salami99 Місяць тому

      the issue is the 134 will leak / is too small compared to r12

  • @johnperez93640
    @johnperez93640 Рік тому +8

    Ive seen 134 used in 1234 systems without any problems. Several different vehicles, all working just fine years later.

    • @robertinogg
      @robertinogg Рік тому

      Did you put the same amount of the refrigerant into the system?

    • @Сергейвич-с9о
      @Сергейвич-с9о 8 місяців тому +2

      -10%

    • @emmanuelalva6597
      @emmanuelalva6597 4 місяці тому

      @@robertinoggprobably not I’m sure the density and weight of both are slightly different. If you’re a math guy I’m sure there’s a conversion formula to give you a good number.

  • @Matp345
    @Matp345 7 місяців тому +8

    Thanks for the video. With the cost of 1234 ,the EPA can suck it. I'll use what works

  • @dagamer667
    @dagamer667 2 роки тому +13

    How do you calculate the charge weight for 134a from the spec 1234yf weight printed on the sticker under the hood? Or do you just go by the low and high side pressures with AC running?

    • @wisetow10
      @wisetow10 2 місяці тому

      Let me know if you found an answer to this. I’ve been trying to research but can’t seem to find any definite answers

    • @fnfastone
      @fnfastone 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@wisetow10 someone in the comments said if you want to switch to 134 then subtract 10 percent of total volume needed but can't verify

  • @KirksCoolAirAutoTV
    @KirksCoolAirAutoTV 3 роки тому +10

    The R134a pressure is a little higher than the 1234y so you have to be careful. If you make the pressure get too high with the R134a In the 1234y system it can black up the system and damage your compressor

    • @myboy051
      @myboy051 3 роки тому +9

      Only time that the pressure is higher is when the ambient temperature reaches 150 degrees or higher. However the pressure difference is very slight. I had to get certified for the 1234yf. The two gases are very similar.

    • @shayanpoordian8002
      @shayanpoordian8002 2 роки тому

      ​@@myboy051 do you think I can mix the two? like recharge my car with 134a?

    • @8wayz
      @8wayz 2 роки тому +3

      Volkswagen completely dropped the ball and put R134a in my 1234yf system. My Ac stopped working months after this repair. Gonna get a lawyer I think.

  • @Greywolf74
    @Greywolf74 Рік тому +3

    Now that youve been running r-134a for 4-5 years, hows it doing? Still working or did it ever develop any issues?

  • @hernanalvarado1707
    @hernanalvarado1707 3 роки тому +3

    How many cars have you replace the Ac system from r1234yf to r134, how safe is it? I’d like to try to do so on a 2017 Ford Escape se. Any extra advice ? Thanks for the video.

  • @HairyTheCandyMan
    @HairyTheCandyMan 3 роки тому +25

    Thanks mango dango! This was a good video! While R1234yf is better for the environment... it's hard to justify the outrageous price it costs. I'm tempted to vacuum out the refrigerant and convert to R134a like you have done.

    • @0815funkmaster
      @0815funkmaster 3 роки тому +10

      Do it....just another rip off

    • @HairyTheCandyMan
      @HairyTheCandyMan 3 роки тому +5

      I was afraid to do it initially since my car is a hybrid (they require a dielectric oil), but it worked perfectly! R134a works amazing!

    • @AndToTheRepublic4WhichItStands
      @AndToTheRepublic4WhichItStands 2 роки тому +9

      Better for the environment my arse.

    • @HairyTheCandyMan
      @HairyTheCandyMan 2 роки тому +2

      @@AndToTheRepublic4WhichItStands it's so beneficial I use a mask and breath it in daily

    • @AndToTheRepublic4WhichItStands
      @AndToTheRepublic4WhichItStands 2 роки тому +1

      @@HairyTheCandyMan r12 is the way to go

  • @scottysgarage4393
    @scottysgarage4393 Рік тому

    The factories implicitly admit the two work together. My sisters 2015 Fiat 500 is tagged for 134a...but has a 1234 low pressure port. They flat told us to charge it with 134a...

  • @manuelbover4816
    @manuelbover4816 Рік тому +4

    Did you have to change the oil out In you're compressor . Because they say 134 A takes a different oil. In the compressor.🤔

    • @AdInfitum
      @AdInfitum 4 місяці тому

      134a systems are backwards compatible with 1234yf oil. But not the other way around. 1234yf is more reactive, and will break down 134a oil, so they made a special oil that resists the breakdown from 1234yf, therefore still being able to lubricate 134a systems.

  • @freddaniali
    @freddaniali 3 місяці тому +1

    He is right, it works great, just have to remove all the old new stuff. All you are doing is violating a clean air act. LOL And as car guys you know how we all feel about that right??

  • @W1Z4RDCUDI
    @W1Z4RDCUDI 2 роки тому +2

    Do I still have to vacuum it out if my ax doesn’t work at all?

  • @EvilJ069
    @EvilJ069 Рік тому +1

    Jesus, not only does he have a very thick accent he talks so damn fast it's like the Micro Machines guy...

  • @adamdion5048
    @adamdion5048 Рік тому

    Beautiful explanation you answered my exact question in a very quick time , thanks brother 🤙🏼

  • @sammyvukovic4998
    @sammyvukovic4998 4 місяці тому

    Do you vacuumed the oil to?

  • @markvon9727
    @markvon9727 2 роки тому +3

    134A is less damaging to your AC components and costs much less.
    Eventually, when economies of scale catch up, the price of 1234YF will fall.
    However, other comments are correct: an individual who does this violates The Clean Air Act. Each violation is a $2,500 fine for individuals and $25,000 fine for companies.
    Will you be caught? Probably not. But the faster all vehicles and mobile AC units are converted to 1234YF, the faster the price will drop.

    • @slovakjakpica
      @slovakjakpica 6 місяців тому

      No it wont, because it under patent till 2030. Basically scam

  • @christo8472
    @christo8472 2 роки тому +1

    Hello ,I have a leak in my car ,R1234yf .I put nitrogen no find the leak my question if I use leak repair selalent how much I have to put ?

  • @Lordblackhawk1000
    @Lordblackhawk1000 Рік тому +3

    Backward compatibility will always work without any issues, forward compatibility is not. "For example - you can add R134a to a R1234YF system, but you can not add R1234YF to R134a system. Just like USB ports, you can go to USB 2.0 to a 3.0+ but you can not go from a 3.0+ to a 2.0, anyone saying otherwise is a Mechanic or a Federal shill. Plus you can always go back if needed, like if you were going to sell, by just doing a full purge of the system and replace.

    • @Matias-bw1eq
      @Matias-bw1eq Рік тому

      So can I just add R134a to my R1234YF ac system if I need to recharge it? And I don’t need to empty the system first?

    • @Lordblackhawk1000
      @Lordblackhawk1000 Рік тому

      @@Matias-bw1eq I replied but didn't get posted not sure if you received? (youtube) short answers is No , NO and yes you do, Good luck.

    • @Matias-bw1eq
      @Matias-bw1eq Рік тому

      @@Lordblackhawk1000 thank you, so if I empty the system first, it will be fine if I put the r134a product even if my car is supposed to use r1234yf?

    • @Lordblackhawk1000
      @Lordblackhawk1000 Рік тому +1

      @@Matias-bw1eq Np, As stated in my first statement all systems are backward compatible. Use Ac--Pro.v101, with needed connectors R1234yf to R134a (Seal, Oil and Gas)(low & high), unless you have all the necessary items separately, Good Luck.

    • @Lordblackhawk1000
      @Lordblackhawk1000 Рік тому +1

      Just FYI, the psi recommend pressure for R134a is acceptable, very slight difference from the psi of R1234yf. Not even worth stating, Research and Knowledge is key.

  • @slantedperspective
    @slantedperspective Рік тому +1

    How about propane in a modern system. It woeks in a r12 i know for a fact

  • @ihseo0185
    @ihseo0185 2 роки тому +2

    R1234yf 가연성 가스로 전방추돌로 에바 파손 및 불꽃 즉 스파크 점화원 있으면 화재가 발생 합니다. 대략 600~1000그램 가연성가스로
    부탄가스 600g 용 1.5 통이 연소되는화재...최근에 한국에서 발생 했네요

    • @rondellschuyler7074
      @rondellschuyler7074 2 роки тому

      Is the 1234F extremely flammable ? Thanks

    • @williamvaughan1218
      @williamvaughan1218 2 роки тому

      Not only that but the combustion byproducts include a extremely nasty acid powerful enough to etch glass

  • @hussienalhussien2342
    @hussienalhussien2342 2 роки тому +1

    I can put 134a in car us 1234yf ?

  • @BL3ND392
    @BL3ND392 3 роки тому +2

    I have a Dodge Charger 392 and where i live i can’t find r-1234yf they told me you won’t have a problem with r-134a and also about my warranty I’ve already voided my warranty i dont have a problem. Please tell me is it going to effect the ac compressor??

    • @C.O.SBurpees
      @C.O.SBurpees 3 роки тому +1

      Herd that they both use same oil so no

    • @BL3ND392
      @BL3ND392 3 роки тому

      @@billselby9294 yeah i heard of that it could brake the lines and probably have to spend more money on it

    • @BL3ND392
      @BL3ND392 3 роки тому

      @@billselby9294 just ordered a 900 gram bottle online for 80 bucks my car takes 709grams

    • @billselby9294
      @billselby9294 3 роки тому

      @@BL3ND392 sweet. Let us know how it goes.

    • @BL3ND392
      @BL3ND392 3 роки тому

      @@billselby9294 just filled her up now i can go out with my car in the afternoon staying cool

  • @jarredallen2016
    @jarredallen2016 Рік тому

    So, what you're saying is you literally don't have to replace any components to do this? What about the oil? Do you have to replace the oil with pag 46?

    • @char395
      @char395 Рік тому

      Oil is the same for both 👍🏼

    • @siryoink
      @siryoink Рік тому +1

      POE oil in the newer systems works with either. There's literally a Mercedes 2013 recall TSB that specifies NOT to replace the oil. Mercedes recalled a bunch of SL in europe bc the new stuff was flammable in crash tests, pumped the old stuff out, replaced hose fittings, refilled with 134a, and put new stickers on it.

  • @alexsamson9942
    @alexsamson9942 Рік тому +6

    Funny how so many comment this is illegal. Come to any freeway in California and watch nobody follow speed limit. Everyone is illegal haha.

  • @andrewadams1981
    @andrewadams1981 5 місяців тому

    I used it in my dodge Durango it it works fine

    • @andrewadams1981
      @andrewadams1981 5 місяців тому

      I've been mixing mine in my 20ll dodge over 5 yrs no problem at least not yet

  • @kookiethebear
    @kookiethebear 2 роки тому +3

    Not meaning to read like I'm making fun of the guy in the video, but I've never heard someone sound like they are talking underwater constantly. I feel bad for the guy.

    • @bh8146
      @bh8146 Рік тому +1

      How many languages do you speak?

    • @kookiethebear
      @kookiethebear Рік тому

      @@bh8146 At least 50, one for each state.

    • @jimlahey6938
      @jimlahey6938 Рік тому

      @@bh8146 i speak your mother native tongue

  • @Nickearl1
    @Nickearl1 6 місяців тому

    Fantastic video

  • @carsrcool7149
    @carsrcool7149 3 роки тому +1

    GOOD VID !

  • @bazg3426
    @bazg3426 2 роки тому +2

    There is one very good reason why you wouldn't want to swap to R1234yf with R134a, the compressor oil is different.

  • @jamesduffey4442
    @jamesduffey4442 2 роки тому +1

    The guy giving wrong advice about Freon he has no knowledge about is using the worst Freon you could ever use known as ac pro. It’s full of all kinds of bullshit that you don’t want in your ac system

    • @romorris
      @romorris Рік тому

      Who uses freon?

    • @EvilJ069
      @EvilJ069 Рік тому +1

      For someone claiming others don't know anything, you might look into how freon hasn't been used since like the 80's... Freon is R12, the generic term is refrigerant, other than R12 none of the refrigerants are freon

  • @jimmyramirez2272
    @jimmyramirez2272 2 місяці тому

    Did the R134a cool better and about how much better??????????? Is it worth the swap???????????

  • @Rodmanvt
    @Rodmanvt 3 роки тому

    PO597
    Thermostat Heater Control Circuit/Open.
    What's the fix X1 2014 E84

    • @myboy051
      @myboy051 3 роки тому +1

      The thermostat!

    • @EvilJ069
      @EvilJ069 Рік тому

      The "fix" is actually looking into the cooling system of the engine, not the internal HVAC which has absolutely nothing to do with the thermostat...

  • @neilasd3043
    @neilasd3043 3 місяці тому +1

    Why do people still use r134a its rubbish there is other stuff out there its being phased out in most countries....

    • @surjitsingh-zh9cd
      @surjitsingh-zh9cd 3 місяці тому

      It more cool than r1234yf 25%

    • @neilasd3043
      @neilasd3043 3 місяці тому

      @@surjitsingh-zh9cd much better stuff than r1234yf & r134a around & heaps cheaper..

  • @Salehyya
    @Salehyya Рік тому

    🍑 plug-in filters soon will be required by EPA 🤷🏻‍♂️.

  • @edwardmoody4253
    @edwardmoody4253 Рік тому +1

    This guy don't have a clue!!!!

  • @mr.k860
    @mr.k860 6 місяців тому

    Stop talking so damn fast. You'd get way more views.

  • @bert1913
    @bert1913 Рік тому +1

    You talk too slow

  • @brucemills9146
    @brucemills9146 2 роки тому +3

    I can't believe this is still posted. In the USA it is illegal to change over 1234yf to 134at is a $2,500 fine per offense government fine. What happens when the next owner takes it to the dealer and there a/c machine checks the type of Freon is in it.

    • @rich7447
      @rich7447 2 роки тому +10

      Nothing happens.

    • @brucemills9146
      @brucemills9146 2 роки тому

      @@rich7447 or they call the EPA TO COME AND CHECK IT FOR 2500 THEY WILL COME OUT AND TRACK IT DOWN TO WHO PUT IT IN ,IF IT IS A REBUILDER THEN THEY CAN CHECK OTHER CARS BY THE VIN NUMBER AND WHO NOW HAS THEM ,2500 PER CAR .

    • @rich7447
      @rich7447 2 роки тому +9

      @@brucemills9146 How are they going to figure out any of that. The only lead that they have is the previous owner who is not legally required to discuss anything with the EPA. Even goverment agencies need evidece in order to fine you.
      Shouting does not make an argument more compelling.

    • @brucemills9146
      @brucemills9146 2 роки тому

      say the car is 2018 ,it is a rebuilt wreck in order to get a title all that is on record tied to vin number. If a 2018 comes in with wrong freon in it where would think it happened ? it on recorded who repaired it .You must no been around when propane was used in place of r-12 in Texas 4 people died from fire from wreak they tracked it back to a repair shop and charged the owner 4 counts wrongful death. also in California a shop had 3 cars burn in wreaks 5 cases wrongful deaths now say they can't track you..

    • @joshuagrant6030
      @joshuagrant6030 2 роки тому +1

      @@brucemills9146 freon (r12 or r134) is nothing like propane as far as safety. Yes propane should never be used.
      The current comparison is far different from that.

  • @stephencurry3841
    @stephencurry3841 Рік тому

    Could i use r1234yf on a 2000 holden commodore

  • @ThisISTaee
    @ThisISTaee Рік тому

    Thanks for the advise but gahh damn are you under water ?!?

  • @christo8472
    @christo8472 2 роки тому

    You cannot put R134A into a compressors us R1234yf. because has mineral oil

    • @SSFarm.6373
      @SSFarm.6373 2 роки тому +4

      No PAG oil is used with both- mineral oil was in older R12 systems

  • @Iceburgg
    @Iceburgg 3 роки тому +3

    Cool video, but against multiple federal laws. Do at your own risk and don't publish a video about it.

    • @keithbaker1951
      @keithbaker1951 3 роки тому +3

      Fuck the fed tired of them fucking up what has been working for yrs they fucked up gas cans and we didn't say anything now they are fucking with my summer driving and my wallet this new shit sucks. We have no proof its better for the environment either we definitely have proof it costs 8 times more though.

    • @Iceburgg
      @Iceburgg 3 роки тому

      @@keithbaker1951 I agree with you your premise. But there is truth, you just may not like it if informed, I assume. We're always in a rush to manufacture for profit, but not everything that is made is a net positive. Just look at Roundup weed killer. That is very harmful for people and has been known to be so for over 20 years. It de-masculinizes make frogs (through research) among other things. Crazy read if you're interested. However, it is still legal in the States but illegal in every other major country. Got to thank the legal bribes, err lobbyists for that. Stay safe!

    • @richieschmidt6225
      @richieschmidt6225 2 роки тому

      The federal govt accepts lobbyist money from large corporations to make their proprietary refrigerants law, costing the consumer (that's you) to spend absurd amounts of money. So F**K the federal govt rules.

  • @nicksenior4032
    @nicksenior4032 3 роки тому +4

    its illegal to retrofit a new system to use R134a, I would not suggest this at all. and another reason I would not suggest this is the oil properties (yes yours may use PAG but many use PAO which is not compatible with R134a.) etc are not the same and you're just asking for a failure. please do NOT listen to this video.

    • @spideyboy2663
      @spideyboy2663 3 роки тому +1

      Certain types of PAO are perfectly compatible with r134a , specifically the type that is used in electrically driven compressors

    • @spideyboy2663
      @spideyboy2663 3 роки тому

      @@jeffperkins5310 which comment are you referring to ?

    • @spideyboy2663
      @spideyboy2663 3 роки тому +4

      @@jeffperkins5310 ah ok , I was about to say... Um I'm looking right at the spec sheet for Mahle refrigerant oils lol. PAO "AA1" & "AA3" are both compatible with either r134a or r1234yf , and r152a as
      well.

    • @spideyboy2663
      @spideyboy2663 3 роки тому +2

      @@jeffperkins5310 who said I was only explaining it to you ?

    • @spideyboy2663
      @spideyboy2663 3 роки тому

      @@jeffperkins5310 it's a public comment , so don't get your panties in a wad , are you always a douchebag ? Or just to people you talk to on the Internet

  • @melvinjroman4440
    @melvinjroman4440 2 роки тому +1

    Completly fault. This euro techs are way over his head. Doing wrong stuff and things will damage your car. Do not believe this. And am not some one to make just the comment. Am a Master Tech for 25 years. And the results will be bad on your system.

    • @ProdigePerformance
      @ProdigePerformance 2 роки тому +9

      Nobody cares. Your master tech answer has been disproven by many already lol

    • @bleuzarga2347
      @bleuzarga2347 2 роки тому +1

      Plz can you give as the sffects of 134a to the compressor

    • @sneal77777
      @sneal77777 2 роки тому +5

      Seen it work no compressor failure yet little ice cubes coming out the vent

    • @robertsironen1243
      @robertsironen1243 Рік тому +1

      Master bator tech

    • @melvinjroman4440
      @melvinjroman4440 Рік тому

      @@robertsironen1243 congratulations on your month! Sorry but we’re not allowed to discriminate to your gender 😂😂😂👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @corbindallasmultipass
    @corbindallasmultipass 5 місяців тому

    can you mix them?

    • @campersBR
      @campersBR 4 місяці тому

      Most of people say no. My ac is running low on r1234yf, got all the adapters and everything for adding r134a and now I'm in doubts if I should still go for it or not. Or else I'll have to buy a vacuum pump, oil and the lot.