The only choice I don’t agree with for the casting is excluding Naomi because that means that season 8 would be the only qualifiable season without representation on All Stars in this fantasy scenario, which is a little unfair.
I added the makeover challenge so that no one would have to get Ellie Diamonded in the finale, and switched up the order of snatch game, the club challenge, and the roast just to make more sense. However, if there is a jury, then there will be no ball.
Like I said, if there is a jury and there is no ball, then the roast comes after the makeover and Cracker and Shea are top 2, and Ben Naomi and Valentina are bottom 3. Shea eliminates Naomi, and we have a top 4 of Valentina, Shea Couleé, Miz Cracker, and BenDelaCreme. The jury would vote Shea and somebody else, and Shea would win hands down. Shea is the winner no matter what!
@@brickmariobros Kennedy won her original Snatch Game so with the right character she could be a lot better. Valentina's season 9 Snatch Game was also pretty good.
now this would be ALL stars. I like how more queens are getting a chance to redeem themselves but a big part of me still wishes all stars happened only once in a few years with only the biggest stars and instead there was some kind of returnee season for the some stars lol.
@@skyco5395 All Stars always had wild cards. Mimi Imfurst and Tammie Brown on AS1 had a bad run on their season and still came back, so why can't Serena?
I think producers would of definitely put Aja on over Morgan, they would of wanted their Valentina vs Aja drama. They even invited Aja back for all stars 4 for that but she declined
My big change would have been the gag of all gags. Ben loses to Kennedy in LalapaRusa. It’s a Janet song, Kennedy is one of the best lip syncers ever, and the front runner being eliminated by a queen she sent home would have been amazing television.
You gotta remember the pressure was getting to Ben after having to choose so many lip syncs. I think the self elimination would’ve happened pretty early on
Only about 11 months late, but I agree with you. She knew she had done what she needed to be an even bigger star, and that's all she wanted. "I'm here to show the world I still got it."
@@iandean1112But to be fair this would’ve been after 4 years from AS2. She would be coming to terms with possibly never being on the show again and she has said since then that she wants to come back someday, especially now that non-elimination all stars seasons are gonna be the norm most likely starting after AS9. I think there’s a chance she would chop but I honestly can see her sticking around this time, especially since her placements were more balanced (albeit she still won almost all challenges) so she wasn’t picking someone to go every single week yk?
@@user-mz2ne4yh2t LOL, right? I made the mistake of trying to give him/his videos another chance a week or so ago when I was _incredibly_ bored, and the “video” legit opened with him immediately speaking down to his listeners. I disliked that bitch and noped outta there within the first 3 minutes!! Hahaha. (FYI: I’m referring to the video as “that bitch”, _not_ Uckey. Although... hahaha. I kid, I kid!)
@@radlee974 fr, he has this way of talking that makes you feel like you are lucky for even listening to him, and his sighs every two minutes, i can't stand them, like, if you're so annoyed about making the videos you are doing willingly, why do you make them?? 💀
I genuinely feel like we'd get girls like Asia Ohara, Nina West, Crystal and Gigi, Brooklynn etc. if Allstars was every four years. the cast would be STAR STUDDED! also in terms of this cast, all I have to say is justice for Monique and Naomi!
i think dela and shea would've been double crowned. they're both amazingly talented queens with great track records, plus shea would've won season 9 had the lipsync for the crown format not been introduced and everyone including rupaul knows that. i don't think anyone would be mad about a double crowning this time, since they both actually deserve it.
in episode 3 trinity def would've sent gia home because she said on AS4 she was getting so fed up of gia's personality even by episode 2, and wished she had been in the bottom. Yes she wanted to play fair, but I reckon gia would've pulled some shenanigans as usual and been shady and rude to a few others (not to mention her snatch game was by far the absolute worst)
I feel gia was pushed by production to play a mean, conflictive character. I mean it's what puts food on her table, who can blame her. I'm still waiting for the open, sensitive Gia to let her talents shine through.
@@goldybiuvakaloloma2735 Yeah..... cause it's his fantasy lmao Your fantasy would also be biased because it's not an objective thing but rather subjective? You're pretty much just mad because someone doesn't share the same opinions that you do lmfao
For the Lalaparuza Dela vs Kennedy could be a double shantay and Valentina vs. Trixie could be a double sashay... That's the kind of gag I think they'd pull..
@@DragDetective bestie i’ll be honest i really wanna see the spreadsheets but paying for a spreadsheet is a bit of a reach. what else is on the patreon??
But like gia instead of naomi, for the drama i get it but if its an all stars 2 emulation all the queens had to place arpund 6th or higher. I know AS1 had Tammie and Mimi but still...
I think the divas lives roles would be Cracker- Amy winehouse Dela- Julie Andrews Gia - maybe Cardi B Kennedy - Pattie LaBelle Monet - Diana Ross (could switch w/Kennedy) Ongina - Ariana grande Shangela - Mariah Carey Shea - Janet Jackson Trinity - Reba or Celine Dion Trixie - Dolly Parton Valentina - Selena Quintanilla
I disagree with like 90% of these hypotheses but enjoyed this whole video. I love the concept of this, and it’s very well done. Makes me wanna do my own!
intro: this has no meaning it's just for play. 5 minutes in: you don't know how hard it was for me to make this decision; this is my sister, she's always been there for me and it breaks my heart that I had to do this.
The most likely cast imo would be Trixie, Shangela, Kennedy, Bendelacreme, Valentina, Monet, Trinity, Naomi, Shea and Cracker with and ongina/gia/Monique/Morgan for the 11th and 12th spaces
I disagree with the lalaparuza outcome. I kinda liked trixie's performance to The Boss. I think she only lost because she was lip synching against Diana reincarnated. And imma be honest Valentina is not a great lip sync her, as her kitty girl Performance was Lack luster. I understand wanting to shock people and sending home a fan favorite, but then I'd say have Kennedy send home Ben, as that's more believable and it has an even bigger effect. But that's just my thought process :)
Would love to see a fantasy football style of AS6, who you think will win/have the best track record based on previous seasons. Then we can go back and see how close you were!
I mean Jaymes Mansfield would prolly win since that season wouldn't have Shangela and Vanjie. Like, who would be her biggest competition, Kelly Mantle?
@@cinna_moonn I totally forgot that tempest was 1st out on S7, she's such a powerhouse as well. Maybe this season wouldn't be as Jaymes-centric as I once believed, but she's still my pick for the crown.
I was literally brainstorming what would happen if this had happened irl the other day, I would have put my faves from 3, 4, and 5 including the winners into it
I think that you can have either a 12 queens cast season or a returning queen episode, not both. To me, it’ll be perfect to have a longer season but I think it’s must likely to have one of these two situations. But overall, I enjoyed the season a lot
I’m gonna be a bit different here. My roster is Aja (gag, lots to redeem) Gia (villain) Naomi (great choice) Monet (it’s Monet) Derrick (great shade) Shea (lots to redeem) Shangela (it’s Shangela) Cracker (fan favorite) Ongina (huge gag) Monique (lots to prove) Trinity (huge force) Valentina (lots to redeem) DeLa (huge force) I think in 2020 Trixie wouldn’t do it since she doesn’t want to go back currently. Morgan would be saved with Sonique, Kennedy would be underestimated by production and scrapped, etc. I also did 13 queens because of AS6 having 13 queens. Loved the video!
This was good lol. I think with everyone agreeing on eliminating those who get rid of those with the worse track records would mean Dela would wanna keep up with the competition.
Plot twist: the narrator of this video is actually Trinity Taylor. I mean c'mon guys. Close your eyes and listen to the voice. Trinity can't hide that accent.
Who do you think everyone would get for the Divas live challenge. Obviously we know who the AS3 queens had and I think you made an excellent point about Valentina as Selena, and Shea as Grace Jones. Personally i think: Trinity - Madonna Gia - No idea.. Cracker - Cher Monet - Might have been Whitney Houston Ongina - Charli XCX maybe?? idk
So typically I’m not a fan of “fantasy league” type of content for any show, because I typically disagree with their choices, or there is a clear bias and/or no logical explanation for their choices. I like that you stated a disclosure at the beginning to essentially say this is your opinion and that it’s just for fun (other channels just make it seem like what their choices are is obviously the best - when sometimes it isn’t). All this to say, I agree with almost all your choices. The cast of queens and the eliminations! This was a really well done and thought out video!
Probably the top 5 being the top 4 with brooke or even vanjie if they push her (I would want A'keria as i love her but they love vanjie) or bring a queen back which would probably be Plastique after her elimination
@@ait8551 well maybe they would let plastique would come back in the make over challenge, but i do think that nina west would win the lipsync bcs silky doesn't have the story with yvie anymore...
My initial thought with the concept was, damn Season 9 would be Season 5 of this all stars and dominate the cast. Because how do you not have Shea, Trinity, Valentina on the cast
Here is my cast if RPDR was in 2020: 1) Shea Coulee 2) Bendelacreme 3) Monet X Change 4) Monique Heart 5) Miz Cracker 6) Kennedy Davenport 7) Valentina 8) Ongina 9) Mayhem Miller 10) Trinity K Bonet 11) Trinity The Tuck 12) Eureka WK1- Talent Show Top 2- Bendelacreme and Monique Heart WIN- Dela HIGH- Miz Cracker and Trinity The Tuck Safe- Everyone Else LOW- Ongina BTM2- TKB and Mayhem Miller ELIM- Mayhem Miller WK 2- Girl Group Challenge Top 2- Shea Coulee and Valentina WIN- Valentina HIGH- Monet X Change and TKB Safe- Bendelacreme, Miz Cracker, Trinity The Tuck and Eureka LOW- Monique Heart BTM2- Ongina and Kennedy Davenport ELIM- Val picks Ongina WK3-Unconventional Materials Design Challenge Top 2- Bendelacreme and Shea Coulee WIN- Shea Coulee HIGH- Valentina and Miz Cracker Safe- TKB, Eureka, Monique Heart LOW- Trinity The Tuck BTM2- Monet X Change and Kennedy Davenport ELIM- Shea picks Kennedy WK4- Jersey Justice Top 2- Monique Heart and Bendelacreme WIN- Monique Heart HIGH- Valentina Safe- Shea Coulee, Miz Cracker and TKB LOW- Monet X Change BTM2- Trinity The Tuck and Eureka ELIM- Monique would struggle but would save her S10 sister and eliminate Trinity WK5- Half Time Superbowl Rusical Top 2- Monet and TKB WIN- Monet HIGH- Shea Coulee and Monique Heart LOW- Eureka and Bendelacreme BTM2- Miz Cracker and Valentina ELIM- Monet would pick Valentina WK 6- The Roast of Lady Bunny Top 2- Monet and Bendelacreme WIN- Monet HIGH- Shea Coulee SAFE- Monique Heart LOW- Miz Cracker BTM2- Eureka and TKB ELIM- I think Monet would pick Eureka WK 7- Lip Sync Smackdown: Mayhem beats Ongina Kennedy beats Mayhem Kennedy beats Trinity and Valentina Eureka beats Kennedy Eureka returns to the competition WK 8- The Bitchelor Top 2- Miz Cracker and Bendelacreme WIN- Bendelacreme HIGH: Shea Coulee and Eureka! BTM 3- Monique Heart, TKB and Monet X Change ELIM: Bendelacreme pulls her infamous 'I'm going home' WK 9- The Snatch Game of Love TOP 2- Shea Coulee and Eureka WIN- Shea Coulee BTM 4- Monique Heart, Monet X Change, Miz Cracker and TKB ELIM- I think Shea would pick TKB WK 10- The Blue Ball TOP 2- Monique Heart and Miz Cracker WIN- Monique Heart BTM 3- Eureka, Shea and Monet ELIM- Monique would pick Eureka WK 11- The Makeover TOP 2- Monet and Shea Coulee (RPDR loves a good rudemption storyline) WIN- Monet BTM 2- Miz Cracker and Monique ELIM- Ru announces there will be a top 4 (Monet picked Cracker) Track Records for finalists: Monet: Safe, HIGH, BTM2, LOW, WIN, WIN, BTM3, BTM4, BTM3, WIN Monique: TOP2, LOW, SAFE, WIN, HIGH, SAFE, BTM3, BTM4, WIN, BTM2 Cracker: HIGH, SAFE, HIGH, SAFE, BTM2, LOW, TOP2,BTM4, TOP2, BTM2 Shea: SAFE, TOP2, WIN, SAFE, HIGH, HIGH, HIGH, WIN, BTM3, TOP2 The queens write verses for Kitty Girl and The Top 2 is Monet and Shea Coulee The Winner is WINNER WINNER CHICKEN TWO DINNERS: Monet and Shea both win AS3
If i were to choose my own AllStars 3 Casting. I will have 12 queens - Bendelacreme - Shangela - Trixie Mattel - Kennedy Davenport - Aja - Trinity The Tuck - Monet X Change - Naomi Smalls - Monique Heart - Valentina - Miz Cracker And Shae Coulee
If there was like a all all-star season my dream cast would be: ------------------------ 1- Shanel (AS1) 2- Tammie Brown (AS1) 3- Tatianna (AS2) 4- Katya, Coco, or Alyssa (AS2) 5- Kennedy Davenport (AS3) 6- Thorgy or Shangela (AS3) 7- Naomi Smalls (AS4) 8- Valentina (AS4) 9- Mayhem or Mariah (AS5) 10- Derrick or Ongina (AS5) ~These are AS6 so I may add the winner~ 11- Trinity K. Bonet (AS6) 12- Jiggly Caliente (AS6) Note- I would have LOVED to add other queens, but I decided to do queens who did one regular season and one all stars. Queen I would add if I did 4 season queens would be queens like Shangela, Manila, Latrice, even Bebe lol
i think if monet would pick Shea's lipstick if she won the lipsync because she was ready to vote out the strongest competition (manila) on AS4, which woulda been a gooooop! but ben still wins anyway :P awesome vid :)
i think they would’ve picked naomi instead of monet, since naomi was a finalist and is a very popular queen and monet, coming from season 10, was just not special
i love your videos sm. i watch them during my at home physical therapy sessions and theyre the perfect thing to listen to while i do my routine :) so relaxing but entertaining asf
imagine the war between the valentina and trixie stans after the lalaparuza...
Lesbians against gays let's go
That’d be iconic Valentina is that bitch
trixie fans would storm world of wonder no cap
I'd be a double shantay. Not deserved maybe but it would be
They literally are the same people lol
“obviously trixie is a horrible lipsyncer and monet’s gonna win!” I SCREAMED LMAO😭💀💀
I almost spit out my imaginary water a la Pearl
I was PISSED. I couldn’t say a word because when it comes to drag race he isn’t even wrong but it was so shady…
The only choice I don’t agree with for the casting is excluding Naomi because that means that season 8 would be the only qualifiable season without representation on All Stars in this fantasy scenario, which is a little unfair.
what's fair? LIFE IS NOT FAIR.
Yeah, that doesn’t make sense with my fantasy
Deservedly so,it was a rotted season along with season 7,10,11 and 13
@@CashelOConnolly season 10 was great
right naomi or chi chi need in
I think I'd take out either Morgan or Gia for Naomi. Considering every season needs its villain, I'd say keep Gia.
I added the makeover challenge so that no one would have to get Ellie Diamonded in the finale, and switched up the order of snatch game, the club challenge, and the roast just to make more sense. However, if there is a jury, then there will be no ball.
Like I said, if there is a jury and there is no ball, then the roast comes after the makeover and Cracker and Shea are top 2, and Ben Naomi and Valentina are bottom 3. Shea eliminates Naomi, and we have a top 4 of Valentina, Shea Couleé, Miz Cracker, and BenDelaCreme. The jury would vote Shea and somebody else, and Shea would win hands down. Shea is the winner no matter what!
My main comment keeps deleting!!
@@joeyhilliard5323 Why are you saying this in a reply section and not a comment section lol
@@inventions178 idk im fucking stupid 😂
Based on the cast, this probably would have been one of the worst Snatch Games, hands down
Shangela and Bendela say hi,
also if naomi made it to the cast, her wendy woudl be hilarious
Girl what? Shea, shangela, Trinity and bendela??
@@anusthing yeah, but also Trixie, Valentina, Kennedy, Gia.
@@brickmariobros Kennedy won her original Snatch Game so with the right character she could be a lot better. Valentina's season 9 Snatch Game was also pretty good.
@@michaelreffold3170 did you even watch the Kennedy’s and Valentina’s All Stars snatch game?
now this would be ALL stars. I like how more queens are getting a chance to redeem themselves but a big part of me still wishes all stars happened only once in a few years with only the biggest stars and instead there was some kind of returnee season for the some stars lol.
Except for Serena
I kinda want all stars to be just once in a few years too, but on the other hand I love when people come back and I just want more queens
All stars at this point is just "RuPaul's Drag Race: second chance"
it's not all stars anymore, like, how is serena an all star
@@skyco5395 on one hand, how dare u
on ghe other hand, i see ur point
@@skyco5395 All Stars always had wild cards. Mimi Imfurst and Tammie Brown on AS1 had a bad run on their season and still came back, so why can't Serena?
I think producers would of definitely put Aja on over Morgan, they would of wanted their Valentina vs Aja drama. They even invited Aja back for all stars 4 for that but she declined
Also Valentina would definitely be in the top over Shangela in the girl group episode
aja was called right back for all stars?
@@ytscrownjewell yes because Valentina said yes I believe. Aja said it before I think that’s the only source but not sure
@@ytscrownjewell yes but she declined, they also invited Latrice Royale to All Stars 3 before Bebe but she also declined
I thought it was the other way around, Valentina was invited to A3 for the drama with Aja but she did not accept
"We've seen Trinity lipsync How Will I Know before, and she did fine"
Me only remembering Manila's: 👁👄👁 sí!
My big change would have been the gag of all gags.
Ben loses to Kennedy in LalapaRusa. It’s a Janet song, Kennedy is one of the best lip syncers ever, and the front runner being eliminated by a queen she sent home would have been amazing television.
It would be so good pls
You gotta remember the pressure was getting to Ben after having to choose so many lip syncs. I think the self elimination would’ve happened pretty early on
Only about 11 months late, but I agree with you.
She knew she had done what she needed to be an even bigger star, and that's all she wanted. "I'm here to show the world I still got it."
@@iandean1112But to be fair this would’ve been after 4 years from AS2. She would be coming to terms with possibly never being on the show again and she has said since then that she wants to come back someday, especially now that non-elimination all stars seasons are gonna be the norm most likely starting after AS9. I think there’s a chance she would chop but I honestly can see her sticking around this time, especially since her placements were more balanced (albeit she still won almost all challenges) so she wasn’t picking someone to go every single week yk?
i just love the idea of how amazing the drama would be if gia was walking around with the cockiness of having won the first challenge
Clicked without looking who posted this and had a solid moment of "uckey sounds so cheerful today, weird"
LMAOOOOOOO, “hmmm, he's not speaking condescendingly to his audience here, what's wrong” 😂😂😂
@@user-mz2ne4yh2t literally thought "uckey doesn't hate his audience while agreeing with them. This is WILD"
I was wondering what happened to the accent lol
@@user-mz2ne4yh2t LOL, right? I made the mistake of trying to give him/his videos another chance a week or so ago when I was _incredibly_ bored, and the “video” legit opened with him immediately speaking down to his listeners. I disliked that bitch and noped outta there within the first 3 minutes!! Hahaha. (FYI: I’m referring to the video as “that bitch”, _not_ Uckey. Although... hahaha. I kid, I kid!)
@@radlee974 fr, he has this way of talking that makes you feel like you are lucky for even listening to him, and his sighs every two minutes, i can't stand them, like, if you're so annoyed about making the videos you are doing willingly, why do you make them?? 💀
I genuinely feel like we'd get girls like Asia Ohara, Nina West, Crystal and Gigi, Brooklynn etc. if Allstars was every four years. the cast would be STAR STUDDED! also in terms of this cast, all I have to say is justice for Monique and Naomi!
There wouldn't be any season 12 girls since the season would take place right after just like there wasn't any season 8 girls on AS2.
@@crism2176 well AS2 was taped before S8 so...
Crstal should never come back. I adore her but she'll go home early on an all stars season. let bygones by bygones and move on.
they probably would’ve picked miss smalls over gia
No, Gia is here for the trans representation
@@bartek7733 oh yeah they definitely would do that to make rupaul look less transphobic lmao
It would probably be Naomi over Morgan
The Monique Heart erasure she would have slayed here just as she slayed AS4
@@Char-sf4cg right! Same with Aja
i think dela and shea would've been double crowned. they're both amazingly talented queens with great track records, plus shea would've won season 9 had the lipsync for the crown format not been introduced and everyone including rupaul knows that. i don't think anyone would be mad about a double crowning this time, since they both actually deserve it.
if ever a double crowning was awarded, this would be the one. no complaints here!
The face crack I gave when you left off JuJuBee and Alexis until I remembered you leaving off returning all stars lol 😆 you got me gal lol
I really love Ben still being top 2 in almost every episode and WINNING as she should love it
as it is written, so it shall be done.
in episode 3 trinity def would've sent gia home because she said on AS4 she was getting so fed up of gia's personality even by episode 2, and wished she had been in the bottom. Yes she wanted to play fair, but I reckon gia would've pulled some shenanigans as usual and been shady and rude to a few others (not to mention her snatch game was by far the absolute worst)
I feel gia was pushed by production to play a mean, conflictive character. I mean it's what puts food on her table, who can blame her. I'm still waiting for the open, sensitive Gia to let her talents shine through.
So finally a season where Gia isn't leaving on Snatch Game episode. The girl has worked really hard on her comic timing.
There's no way in heaven or hell that either Trinity or BenDela would send Kennedy Davenport home over Gia, lol. Come on now..
right or that kennedy would lose to ben on a janet song like....his bias is ridiculous
@@goldybiuvakaloloma2735 Well... it's his video and his lil fantasy, if you're that mad about it then go and make your own video about it lmao
@@zaldigr863 and his fantasy is biased as hell lmao like i said
@@goldybiuvakaloloma2735 Yeah..... cause it's his fantasy lmao
Your fantasy would also be biased because it's not an objective thing but rather subjective?
You're pretty much just mad because someone doesn't share the same opinions that you do lmfao
He did say its just for storyline/production reasons.
Bendela still destroying all stars even with Shea, Trinity and Cracker lol
The Monet erasure
For the Lalaparuza Dela vs Kennedy could be a double shantay and Valentina vs. Trixie could be a double sashay... That's the kind of gag I think they'd pull..
And them the Valentina and Trixie fandom whould team up and hack WOW and Drag Race whould be cancelled lmao
I love these types of videos, “what if” videos are always fun
Honestly, AS3 had just greater challenges than the others.
I think it would be rlly cool if you included the spreadsheet/chart/placements of all queens in the end of the video
I have those all up on my Patreon haha
@@DragDetective bestie i’ll be honest i really wanna see the spreadsheets but paying for a spreadsheet is a bit of a reach. what else is on the patreon??
@@jasemilnes6970 right
@@jasemilnes6970 www.patreon.com/thedragdetective
@@jasemilnes6970 well if you don't wanna pay then just make your own 🤷
It's the Naomi erasure for me 😭😭😭😭.
It killed me bestie 😩
But like gia instead of naomi, for the drama i get it but if its an all stars 2 emulation all the queens had to place arpund 6th or higher. I know AS1 had Tammie and Mimi but still...
had her moments but just a skinny -bendy clothes hangers afterall.
Already know this is going to be juicy
When you said “this is a worthy successor to all stars 2” I felt that in my SOUL
Shea as grace jones in the divas challenge is something I didn’t know I needed 😍
im lowkey glad this didnt happen bc if trixie somehow managed to win with THIS cast......a civil war wouldve ensued
I think the divas lives roles would be
Cracker- Amy winehouse
Dela- Julie Andrews
Gia - maybe Cardi B
Kennedy - Pattie LaBelle
Monet - Diana Ross (could switch w/Kennedy)
Ongina - Ariana grande
Shangela - Mariah Carey
Shea - Janet Jackson
Trinity - Reba or Celine Dion
Trixie - Dolly Parton
Valentina - Selena Quintanilla
I think they probably would've bean a double shantay between Kennedy and Dela in the Lalapruza
Trixie would absolutely win a roast, her dry, deadpan delivery is just *chef’s kiss*
finally someone notices gia's amazing talent show performance. she SLAYED IT.
Shangela bottom two in a roast questionable 🤨
For the lalaparuza weren't the 2 winners of the last week's challenge immune. So wouldn't trixie and monet be immune.
I disagree with like 90% of these hypotheses but enjoyed this whole video. I love the concept of this, and it’s very well done. Makes me wanna do my own!
I thought Monet would eliminate Shea as she tried to eliminate Manila and might be strategic again👀
I think that Monet picked Manila that time for revenge since she picked her first to save her friend
Monet picked Manila as payback not necessarily strategy
I think this is spot on. I wish they did space out the All Stars seasons like this. Makes it more of an event!
intro: this has no meaning it's just for play.
5 minutes in: you don't know how hard it was for me to make this decision; this is my sister, she's always been there for me and it breaks my heart that I had to do this.
As someone who has seen Ben in The Hater's Roast, in the same show as Monet, Ben is one of the greatest roasters in all of drag race.
The most likely cast imo would be Trixie, Shangela, Kennedy, Bendelacreme, Valentina, Monet, Trinity, Naomi, Shea and Cracker with and ongina/gia/Monique/Morgan for the 11th and 12th spaces
FINALLY we are ready to address how terrible trixie is at lipsyncing
that was already addressed lmao
Even trixie said she isn’t good at lip syncing it’s been addressed
Saying that she’s not a good lipsyncer is literally one of trixies catchphrases, what world have you been living in💀
Interesting topic I never thought of this
All stars should be every two years maybe x
I would probably had put Shangela high on the roast, because she was hilarious in the Michelle Visage's roast the did on that cruise thing.
Monique not making it, america👀 i don‘t believe my ears
this would have been the best season in history hands down
Even though Valentina would eat Trixie- I can't forgive you sending her home 😭😭😭
I disagree with the lalaparuza outcome. I kinda liked trixie's performance to The Boss. I think she only lost because she was lip synching against Diana reincarnated. And imma be honest Valentina is not a great lip sync her, as her kitty girl Performance was Lack luster. I understand wanting to shock people and sending home a fan favorite, but then I'd say have Kennedy send home Ben, as that's more believable and it has an even bigger effect. But that's just my thought process :)
This is my AS3 2020 cast:
-Trixie
-Kennedy
-Bendela
-Shangela
-Monet
-Monique
-Valentina
-Shea
-Naomi
-Manila
-Latrice (yes, they come back)
Not Miz Cracker beating Trinity and Shangela beating Morgan in a LYP SINC. Choices.
LMFAO right tho?? 😂
I mean, Trinity did terrible in How Will I Know, and knowing how production works, they would NEVER let Morgan win
Would love to see a fantasy football style of AS6, who you think will win/have the best track record based on previous seasons. Then we can go back and see how close you were!
Fun idea. Bold of you to put Trixie Mattel on top for a scripted comedy challenge where the queens write their own jokes, lol!
I will love to see you doing a First Eliminateds Season
yeeess please!!!!
I mean Jaymes Mansfield would prolly win since that season wouldn't have Shangela and Vanjie.
Like, who would be her biggest competition, Kelly Mantle?
@@kannavz3494 i think Jaymes, Kelly and Tempest would be The top3, but for me Kelly Wins
@@cinna_moonn I totally forgot that tempest was 1st out on S7, she's such a powerhouse as well.
Maybe this season wouldn't be as Jaymes-centric as I once believed, but she's still my pick for the crown.
i think i would put naomi instead of morgan, but other than that this would be ALL STARS mama.
This is such a cool concept, have you considered doing AS1 without pairs or have you already done it?
I am still in the first episode but i need to comment: THANK YOU for putting Gia in the top 2, she really deserved in All Stars 4
I dont even like Gia but she CLEARLY should've gotten top 2!!!
This season would be so fun to watch
I was literally brainstorming what would happen if this had happened irl the other day, I would have put my faves from 3, 4, and 5 including the winners into it
A lot of these make great storylines as well, like Gia being in the bottom with Trinity after fighting about snatch game character
I think they should wait at least 2 years nowadays, but also release specials like that Christmas one
Shangela won the original Stand up challenge, because she does stand up, so I think that she would be top 2 of the roast
for me Trinity elimination was never happened in my vanilla fantasy
I think that you can have either a 12 queens cast season or a returning queen episode, not both. To me, it’ll be perfect to have a longer season but I think it’s must likely to have one of these two situations. But overall, I enjoyed the season a lot
Literally and with Shae and Trixie’s friendship before drag race this would be a fun season
I’m gonna be a bit different here. My roster is
Aja (gag, lots to redeem)
Gia (villain)
Naomi (great choice)
Monet (it’s Monet)
Derrick (great shade)
Shea (lots to redeem)
Shangela (it’s Shangela)
Cracker (fan favorite)
Ongina (huge gag)
Monique (lots to prove)
Trinity (huge force)
Valentina (lots to redeem)
DeLa (huge force)
I think in 2020 Trixie wouldn’t do it since she doesn’t want to go back currently. Morgan would be saved with Sonique, Kennedy would be underestimated by production and scrapped, etc. I also did 13 queens because of AS6 having 13 queens. Loved the video!
Seeing Miz Cracker and Shangela in the show would be awesome. Cracker is one of my favourite queens, as is Shangela.
I loved this video and the style
keep it up with ur amazing vids 💜
This was good lol. I think with everyone agreeing on eliminating those who get rid of those with the worse track records would mean Dela would wanna keep up with the competition.
Plot twist: the narrator of this video is actually Trinity Taylor. I mean c'mon guys. Close your eyes and listen to the voice. Trinity can't hide that accent.
IM NOT EVEN SOUTHERN
@@DragDetective 😂😂😂😂
Gurl... Take it easy. (In Alaska's voice)
I remember watching your fantasy seasons with no voice over and having to read everything 😭😂
Shangela the real winner of AS3. Trixie Basic Mattel was riggamorris winner because of her big fandom which benefit RPDR.
This was a trixie assassination plot 😂
Shangela in the bottom for a roast ?
Who do you think everyone would get for the Divas live challenge. Obviously we know who the AS3 queens had and I think you made an excellent point about Valentina as Selena, and Shea as Grace Jones.
Personally i think:
Trinity - Madonna
Gia - No idea..
Cracker - Cher
Monet - Might have been Whitney Houston
Ongina - Charli XCX maybe?? idk
Morgan's casting in AS3 other than the shock also had something to do with people thinking she was dead
Valentina and the curse of 7th even in a fantasy All Stars 🤣
My main question is if Dela had quit, then who would have won?
Shea Coulee most likely
Cracker by competition but if they just go by fans then Shea
Imagine Trixie does the Lady Bunny Roast as Lady Bunny from the past
How did Trinity have a worse track record then Monet? Trinity won Snatch Game LOL
My guess is that she was in the bottom twice when Monet placed low two times before getting in the bottom while Trinity had a win and a high placement
So typically I’m not a fan of “fantasy league” type of content for any show, because I typically disagree with their choices, or there is a clear bias and/or no logical explanation for their choices. I like that you stated a disclosure at the beginning to essentially say this is your opinion and that it’s just for fun (other channels just make it seem like what their choices are is obviously the best - when sometimes it isn’t). All this to say, I agree with almost all your choices. The cast of queens and the eliminations! This was a really well done and thought out video!
I’m obsessed w these type of videos
What if Yvie was eliminated due to her injury on S11?
I think that they would cut the story of vanjie and brook. Personally i think that brooklynn would have won
Probably the top 5 being the top 4 with brooke or even vanjie if they push her (I would want A'keria as i love her but they love vanjie) or bring a queen back which would probably be Plastique after her elimination
@@ait8551 well maybe they would let plastique would come back in the make over challenge, but i do think that nina west would win the lipsync bcs silky doesn't have the story with yvie anymore...
Easily Brooke would have won
My initial thought with the concept was, damn Season 9 would be Season 5 of this all stars and dominate the cast. Because how do you not have Shea, Trinity, Valentina on the cast
Here is my cast if RPDR was in 2020:
1) Shea Coulee
2) Bendelacreme
3) Monet X Change
4) Monique Heart
5) Miz Cracker
6) Kennedy Davenport
7) Valentina
8) Ongina
9) Mayhem Miller
10) Trinity K Bonet
11) Trinity The Tuck
12) Eureka
WK1- Talent Show
Top 2- Bendelacreme and Monique Heart
WIN- Dela
HIGH- Miz Cracker and Trinity The Tuck
Safe- Everyone Else
LOW- Ongina
BTM2- TKB and Mayhem Miller
ELIM- Mayhem Miller
WK 2- Girl Group Challenge
Top 2- Shea Coulee and Valentina
WIN- Valentina
HIGH- Monet X Change and TKB
Safe- Bendelacreme, Miz Cracker, Trinity The Tuck and Eureka
LOW- Monique Heart
BTM2- Ongina and Kennedy Davenport
ELIM- Val picks Ongina
WK3-Unconventional Materials Design Challenge
Top 2- Bendelacreme and Shea Coulee
WIN- Shea Coulee
HIGH- Valentina and Miz Cracker
Safe- TKB, Eureka, Monique Heart
LOW- Trinity The Tuck
BTM2- Monet X Change and Kennedy Davenport
ELIM- Shea picks Kennedy
WK4- Jersey Justice
Top 2- Monique Heart and Bendelacreme
WIN- Monique Heart
HIGH- Valentina
Safe- Shea Coulee, Miz Cracker and TKB
LOW- Monet X Change
BTM2- Trinity The Tuck and Eureka
ELIM- Monique would struggle but would save her S10 sister and eliminate Trinity
WK5- Half Time Superbowl Rusical
Top 2- Monet and TKB
WIN- Monet
HIGH- Shea Coulee and Monique Heart
LOW- Eureka and Bendelacreme
BTM2- Miz Cracker and Valentina
ELIM- Monet would pick Valentina
WK 6- The Roast of Lady Bunny
Top 2- Monet and Bendelacreme
WIN- Monet
HIGH- Shea Coulee
SAFE- Monique Heart
LOW- Miz Cracker
BTM2- Eureka and TKB
ELIM- I think Monet would pick Eureka
WK 7- Lip Sync Smackdown:
Mayhem beats Ongina
Kennedy beats Mayhem
Kennedy beats Trinity and Valentina
Eureka beats Kennedy
Eureka returns to the competition
WK 8- The Bitchelor
Top 2- Miz Cracker and Bendelacreme
WIN- Bendelacreme
HIGH: Shea Coulee and Eureka!
BTM 3- Monique Heart, TKB and Monet X Change
ELIM: Bendelacreme pulls her infamous 'I'm going home'
WK 9- The Snatch Game of Love
TOP 2- Shea Coulee and Eureka
WIN- Shea Coulee
BTM 4- Monique Heart, Monet X Change, Miz Cracker and TKB
ELIM- I think Shea would pick TKB
WK 10- The Blue Ball
TOP 2- Monique Heart and Miz Cracker
WIN- Monique Heart
BTM 3- Eureka, Shea and Monet
ELIM- Monique would pick Eureka
WK 11- The Makeover
TOP 2- Monet and Shea Coulee (RPDR loves a good rudemption storyline)
WIN- Monet
BTM 2- Miz Cracker and Monique
ELIM- Ru announces there will be a top 4
(Monet picked Cracker)
Track Records for finalists:
Monet: Safe, HIGH, BTM2, LOW, WIN, WIN, BTM3, BTM4, BTM3, WIN
Monique: TOP2, LOW, SAFE, WIN, HIGH, SAFE, BTM3, BTM4, WIN, BTM2
Cracker: HIGH, SAFE, HIGH, SAFE, BTM2, LOW, TOP2,BTM4, TOP2, BTM2
Shea: SAFE, TOP2, WIN, SAFE, HIGH, HIGH, HIGH, WIN, BTM3, TOP2
The queens write verses for Kitty Girl and The Top 2 is Monet and Shea Coulee
The Winner is
WINNER WINNER CHICKEN TWO DINNERS: Monet and Shea both win AS3
oh my god what a great season this would be
Really enjoyed this vid, xxx I’ve been a fan of rpdr since 2018, so I wasn’t even properly aware just how long the gap between the AS seasons were.
If i were to choose my own AllStars 3 Casting. I will have 12 queens
- Bendelacreme
- Shangela
- Trixie Mattel
- Kennedy Davenport
- Aja
- Trinity The Tuck
- Monet X Change
- Naomi Smalls
- Monique Heart
- Valentina
- Miz Cracker
And Shae Coulee
You did Trinity dirty in this. And Trixie would never won roast over Shangela.
Morgan is here because "they need someone to go home first"😂😂
I hope you know that 4 years from now we’re going to want an All Stars 4 lmao
stop because i love videos like this like a video essay type of thing ong
If there was like a all all-star season my dream cast would be:
------------------------
1- Shanel (AS1)
2- Tammie Brown (AS1)
3- Tatianna (AS2)
4- Katya, Coco, or Alyssa (AS2)
5- Kennedy Davenport (AS3)
6- Thorgy or Shangela (AS3)
7- Naomi Smalls (AS4)
8- Valentina (AS4)
9- Mayhem or Mariah (AS5)
10- Derrick or Ongina (AS5)
~These are AS6 so I may add the winner~
11- Trinity K. Bonet (AS6)
12- Jiggly Caliente (AS6)
Note-
I would have LOVED to add other queens, but I decided to do queens who did one regular season and one all stars. Queen I would add if I did 4 season queens would be queens like Shangela, Manila, Latrice, even Bebe lol
This was perfect. If there were a 13th queen it wouldn't be Naomi (SMH) it'd be either Thorgy, Blair, Mayhem, Aja, Monique, or Derrick.
i think if monet would pick Shea's lipstick if she won the lipsync because she was ready to vote out the strongest competition (manila) on AS4, which woulda been a gooooop! but ben still wins anyway :P awesome vid :)
Tbh, I would have had Kennedy stay, I couldn't care less of track record, when it comes down to one lip sync, that's what matters at that time.
i think they would’ve picked naomi instead of monet, since naomi was a finalist and is a very popular queen and monet, coming from season 10, was just not special
yes, especially considering this would be in 2020 and the season 10 hype would have died down
This video begs the question why some producer of RPDR thought it is a great idea to have an AS season every year
i love your videos sm. i watch them during my at home physical therapy sessions and theyre the perfect thing to listen to while i do my routine :) so relaxing but entertaining asf