Mister X What are you talking about? You do realize that Asian people are honestly close to never being in movies, shows, magazines, etc? They're barely represented. If it wasn't for the sudden spark for Asian boybands and animation then you'd forget Asian people ever existed in the U.S. It's not Anti anything. Just because people aren't talking about white people and to be more specific white Americans all the time doesn't mean that anyone is against them. If huge platforms and other networks were to be more diverse then maybe you wouldn't even be saying this.
Please ,I want you to tell me. Do Asian people living in the United States and Canada keep local manners? (Asians run away without paying money at restaurants.) (Noises loudly everywhere.） How many Asians with such bad manners? I have no experience of leaving Japan. Therefore, please let me know.
+jabbafo I am embarrassed because I am an East Asian. I'm sorry. Chinese hate Japan. Korean hate Japan. However, Chinese and Korean people coming to Japan are increasing year by year. I think that the burden on the US and Canada will be reduced considerably after 10 years.
The fact that overseas Chinese thrive in almost any part of the world is a testament to their adaptability and hard work ethic despite having the odds against them
I personallly have no problems with Chinese folks. I don't know very many in Dallas, Tx, but the few I have met seem nice. Unfortunately racism is really a hot issue in US right now. I really think the ONLY way people will chill out over it is if we encounter extra-terrestrials from some weird planet. Then we will all realize that we are one human family. We are a cosmic family. I wish we could all wake up to this truth and stop our incessant, shallow and petty bickering .
Mr Lord, Plano TX has the 6th largest Chinese American population in the US at 5% of the general population. We are planning to move to the area from Boston. Texas no. 1!
Nigel i'm not chinese. but people always have things to point with ASIAN of asian date white/latinos/black, then they still get hate. They get jokes & troll as hateful the,self, hate their own race, hate their own peoples!!! if they're out with others race or dating/married, people will saying they're want inbreeding and invasion!! they better stick with their own types Then if Asian American/UK (Asian western, born & raise or study & living, working in Western country) stick with their own people & their community. It's a natural thing, don't you think that. They're interacting with locals people as well. But somehow interacting to their own peoples (where their roots from) it still feel comfortable more. It's happen for anyone. Black and White, Latinos beside of interacting with all kind of race, it still feel more comfortable when they're interacting with their own kind. I argee Chinese or Asian living in Western country should speak locals languages. But don't you think you're too ridiculously when expect them do not learn & speak their own language as well (when they're around with their own peoples) btw, ALL asian who born & raise in Western speak English. mostly Asian don't speak English is old Asian, mature Asian cause it hard to them, but their kids speak English. and some student & Asian workers in Western have no desire learn speak English since their plans is not living rest life there. They're just there for short term working (5-10yo) then comeback their own country,etc... very Asian born & raise in US/UK speak perfectly English like it's their first langue, they're speaking English more fluently than their mother language i don't get what you talking about. But as Asian, i expect Asian (born & raise in Western) beside bond with locals, they better knowing their root language & cultures.
I LOVE THIS. PLEASE MAKE MORE!! More about the Chinese Diaspora in the Caribbean & in Latin America and how they contributed to cuisine and culture there :')
Thanks. I came to the U. of Texas in 1969 from Viet Nam (VN) for education. From 1969 to 1978, it was a hardship because discrimination in Texas. I got a job offer in California in 1978. Life is much better in California. Thx for your program.
The concept of paper sons (immigrating under an assumed name) and the forced separation, detention, and interrogation of Chinese immigrant families on Angel Island Immigration Station need to be highlighted in a future video.
I grew up in Cupertino, CA; there are many new Chinese folks who moved from China for educational opportunities and jobs. Unfortunately many of them drive extremely recklessly and discriminate the Asian American folks thinking we're less superior because we're not as "rich" as them. Hopefully things will change. Chinese folks are cool!
Love @dollyli'S storytelling in all of the series. Great stuff! I feel I learn more from the videos, rather than watching a feature-length documentary about the same topic.
All my Grandparents immigrated to the U.S. in the 1920 's . One family to Sacramento and the other family to C.T. , L.A. My mom's Family were Chinese Vegetable Farmers in Buena Park area , same as their livelihood back home . My Dad's father worked for Southern Pacific Railroad in Sacramento until retirement.My Grandpa in L.A.was President of the Wong Family Association......BING KONG TONG in CHINATOWN , L.A. My father served 2 years in the Koream War , and then worked at the for the USPS until retirement. My mom was a stay at home mom , raising 7 children. Sacramento River area reminds the Chinese immigrants of the PEARL RIVER and DELTA in Southern China , of the communities, water , farm land , weather of the home they left. Many were Fruit Farmers all along the Sacramento .. Delta area . This my journey ,.., of a 2nd generation ABC . , from the city , Toisan , Guangdong Province .
So interesting. Kind off topic but there are Chinese immigrants in so many countries, including Mexico. I was shocked as a Mexican american, you learn fun new things everyday about immigration.
Thank you so much for doing this. The story of the Chinese-American mirrors that of the Chinese-Canadian in many ways, including the Exclusion Act and immigrant quotas. I wasn't at all interested in this stuff as a kid, since I was far more interested in "being Canadian," but I've really started to explore this more as an adult.
My ancestors came to the in 1870-1880s. Drought in China, the damage from the Opium Wars destroyed local economy of Southern China.- so there was a great deal of unemployment in southern China. Until the Chinese Exclusion Act ... chinese could immigrate to the USA albeit a chinese immigrant could not be a naturalized citizen ...because of the 1790 Naturalization Act and its following extensions which was not repeal until 1952... Until 1952 only chinese descent persons born in the USA could be a US Citizen ... (this upheld by in the supreme court case Wong Kim Ark vs US in 1898)... I am a 4th generation American Born Chinese ....most of the chinese who left china from 1840 to 1888 came from Guangdong province and the seaports of Fujian province ... The earliest Chinese contacts with the outside world was done during the Zheng He Treasure ship campaigns around 1430s... Some Chinese who left the Manchu rule Qing Dynasty China did not go to Gold Mountain but went to South America, Central America, the philippines, Singapore/malaysia, indonesia, and Hawaii .. After the Opium Wars I and II - China was the sick man of Asia. .
This is helpful i love this video. that touches my soul for the Chinese immigrants living in the United States that era period and now CCP corrupting it's own country.
Please tell the kids in the mainland that Americanized Chinese food is not "fake Chinese food". I hate it when FOBs come over to the US and tell people that Chinese food in America is fake. They fail to realize the history behind it and the contribution that people made to the culture of American Chinese food. It has gone through a rich evolution since the first Chinese arrived in the 1850s. Just as how Chinese food in the mainland had went through its own evolution since 1850 to now. There are countless Chinese diasporas throughout the world each having a unique story along with their refined ways of cooking.
I stay permanently in USA because of discriminatory policy and re-entry denial of the country in Asia where I was born, grew up and educated. In paradox a lot of their citizens migrate to USA. The country encourage migation of their citizens to US for economic reason and while it pursue very strict immigration policy. It is nice for their citizens to migrate to US and other countries but not the other way around.
America has never really been all that great to immigrants which is odd to me. We have a horrible way of hating an ethnic group, and then welcoming them all the while hating a 'new' ethnic group. Look how the Irish and Italians were treated when they first came over. This tradition needs to end, and I feel that it is given that the control of information has been relaxed. No longer can you easily hide how horribly people were treated.
@ 2:05 she says,... "so the very people who were fighting alongside the Americans, were not even allowed to come into the country". The Chinese exclusion act should [probably] have never been passed (or even introduced). But Americans were in China, fighting for China, -not the other way around. So the argument is a false dialectic. And since we had just endured the great depression and were then entering another World War, you could not have expected Congress to take up the matter until after the war (of repealing or modifying the Chinese Exclusion Act).
i think it's misleading to group taiwan, mainland china, and hong kong all together (at least the way it was done in this video). ignoring the geopolitical issues of what constitutes a country, those 3 areas have very different histories/cultures and the reason mainland china individuals would immigrate to the usa are different than the other 2 at a given point in time. for example, in the 3rd wave section you mention that mao's policies very negatively affected life in china, then follow it by saying the USA changed its policies allowing more chinese to immigrate to the usa. you follow that section by saying the chinese immigrants in the 3rd wave mostly come from taiwan/hk. but that's really misleading because mao's policies affected people of mainland china, not people of taiwan and not people of hk. the people of taiwan during this time ran pretty much independently of china and hk was run by the british.
you're wrong in saying that these 3 area have "very different histories/cultures", if you know any history at all, these 2 place belonged to China since Ming Dynasty, and have shared every cultural aspect until the British colonisation of HK and civil war which broke up Mainland and Taiwan.... if you want to share an opinion at-least get your facts straight, or it wouldn't fly.
What SYL said is true. The truth is often viewed through selective history. If any, it will only be more accurate to say both countries had a gap away from China only recently. ( In considering the years in history. ) That gap doesn't erase everything that comes before the gap, especially the politic, culture and history which all 3 countries shared for a long time before the separation. The first comment is only accurate if the OP said for the past 50 years, all 3 countries have developed very differently in different ways in their economic structures. The only thing which is significantly different among these 3 countries since the separation.
These three areas have different cultures and histories? You know when these students study abroad. They consider themselves Chinese and they speak same language and celebrate Chinese New Year. You said we are historical and culturally different? And HK now belongs to china. Thank you.
What you're BSting isn't gonna change the fact that these people are the same: they all have been raised in Chinese culture, they all use Chinese characters, they all eat Chinese food, and they all have Chinese DNA. You pathetic anti-Chinese villain!!
The problem is that Chinese immigration is now so out of control that it is leading to problems throughout North America, Europe and Australia. Here in Canada cities such as Vancouver are almost exclusively Chinese.
Both White and Black people are unable to distinguish the Chinese identity. In the US Korean are mistaken as Chinese. Let us use the race coloured code. The European shares similar features. How did the European became American? These European do discriminate each other. The Italian is Deigo. The Polish are Pollack. The Irish are Catholic. What about the English? Most English migrants dropped their race and called Limey instead. There is confusion over people with features similar to people from China. So as a community Chinese is yellow people. Indian people are brown.
If you have the Spotify app, and if you would like to find out about an interesting podcast, then type in 'Successful Excellent - Bodily Security', and take heed to the warning 🤚
I love how a lot of the history of Black Americans (civil rights movement, etc) is interconnected with the history of Asian-Americans. Black Americans and Asian American have a long history together in America that is unfortunately unknown to the most of the current generations since it’s not taught in schools.
Because of current situations. The majority of immigrants from China, India and Pakistan are generally already wealthy before they move or are highly educated. India makes up the largest number of HB-1 visas dwarfing every other country except China who is close behind them.Also the very contro EB-5 Visa, which essentially lets you buy your way to be a legal resident is massively overrepresented by China. They make up 90% of all EB-5 visas. I can't speak for all cities but where I am from, in the metro area there is not much interaction between Asian communities and other POC communities. Black and Hispanic communities often live in the same area and interact regularly, whereas you rarely see the Asian community there
I think china will soon clamp down on emigration and try to slow it, they are looking a demographic crisis because low birth rates mean an ever aging population, they will try to stop people leaving
Chinese diaspora is actually a long process, in which might often involved thirds countries, and finally destination USA. Many Chinese are first in Southeast Asia or even India during WWI- WWII, and often time feel excluded/persecuted by the local political power when anti-Chinese sentiment rise.
Good video, life was hard in America for Chinese, Japanese and Korean communities. Sometimes I wish we the European Americans would treated our Asian Americans with love and respect, not with discrimination and killing, it is different as European Americans treated the Black African Americans. I like our Asian Americans that we have in this country to show lots of respect and love. America is a multinational country, and always will be.
I don't think you should have grouped Hong Kong and Taiwan together with mainland China. At the third wave time, HK was not governed by china at all. Taiwan has never been governed by the CCP and saying Mao's policies caused these migrants from HK and Taiwan isn't really accurate.
Dubat Pikachu As a pureblood Taiwanese, we actually respect Japan more than China. I literally shit on mainland China as much as possible and even say it out loud in public.
i think he meant the taiwanese natives, so he's basically not Han. Well people like that exists, who 'shit' on people base on their brith location, thats equivalent to racism (even worse, consider we're the same race), and thats what Charles is.
Do some researchers. Americans have a very narrow range of what type of immigrant they like. The further from white you are, the less they like you. And "white" is a moving goalpost with no fixed definition in order to maintain control in the country.
Americans dont hate immigrants, a portion has been manipulated into thinking immigrants are the cause of their economic hardship despite it being a litany of other factors such as outsourcing and automation. There are a portion who are just racist though. But you will find people like that in every country.
The USA was not created by immigrants. When European settlers came to America there was no country here. The white Europeans created a country here. They were not immigrants. They created the USA.
Really appreciating all the efforts AJ+ has been putting to Asian communities.
the video series show the hate and resentment against Chinese mainlanders
A group of people we honestly don't give enough credit too.
Mister X What are you talking about? You do realize that Asian people are honestly close to never being in movies, shows, magazines, etc? They're barely represented. If it wasn't for the sudden spark for Asian boybands and animation then you'd forget Asian people ever existed in the U.S. It's not Anti anything. Just because people aren't talking about white people and to be more specific white Americans all the time doesn't mean that anyone is against them. If huge platforms and other networks were to be more diverse then maybe you wouldn't even be saying this.
Please ,I want you to tell me.
Do Asian people living in the United States and Canada keep local manners?
(Asians run away without paying money at restaurants.)
(Noises loudly everywhere.）
How many Asians with such bad manners?
I have no experience of leaving Japan.
Therefore, please let me know.
+jabbafo
I am embarrassed because I am an East Asian.
I'm sorry.
Chinese hate Japan.
Korean hate Japan.
However, Chinese and Korean people coming to Japan are increasing year by year.
I think that the burden on the US and Canada will be reduced considerably after 10 years.
The fact that overseas Chinese thrive in almost any part of the world is a testament to their adaptability and hard work ethic despite having the odds against them
oy vey, but wat'bout the blakc!? we wuz kangz n shite.
Unlike the blacks. I will trade for a Chinese person.
That could be said of anyone.
What odds are against them? they got a brain
Where else have they thrived besides america and Britain?
My great grandpa is Chinese from Jamaica. I know, strange. Shout outs to my distant Chinese cousins.
You can come to China to meet your Chinese cousins.Welcome ！
@@hongmei6018 are you cute
Crazy VLOGS ur weird
@@hongmei6018 I can but not now considering all the racism going on in China against black people.
Say hello to your family~
I personallly have no problems with Chinese folks. I don't know very many in Dallas, Tx, but the few I have met seem nice. Unfortunately racism is really a hot issue in US right now. I really think the ONLY way people will chill out over it is if we encounter extra-terrestrials from some weird planet. Then we will all realize that we are one human family. We are a cosmic family. I wish we could all wake up to this truth and stop our incessant, shallow and petty bickering .
Yeah til they arrest you and make you a slave, wake up, take a look around, the world sucks and injustice is EVERYWHERE!
what about the Muslim
Mr Lord, Plano TX has the 6th largest Chinese American population in the US at 5% of the general population. We are planning to move to the area from Boston. Texas no. 1!
Nigel
i'm not chinese. but people always have things to point with ASIAN
of asian date white/latinos/black, then they still get hate. They get jokes & troll as hateful the,self, hate their own race, hate their own peoples!!!
if they're out with others race or dating/married, people will saying they're want inbreeding and invasion!! they better stick with their own types
Then if Asian American/UK (Asian western, born & raise or study & living, working in Western country) stick with their own people & their community. It's a natural thing, don't you think that. They're interacting with locals people as well. But somehow interacting to their own peoples (where their roots from) it still feel comfortable more.
It's happen for anyone. Black and White, Latinos beside of interacting with all kind of race, it still feel more comfortable when they're interacting with their own kind.
I argee Chinese or Asian living in Western country should speak locals languages. But don't you think you're too ridiculously when expect them do not learn & speak their own language as well (when they're around with their own peoples)
btw, ALL asian who born & raise in Western speak English. mostly Asian don't speak English is old Asian, mature Asian cause it hard to them, but their kids speak English.
and some student & Asian workers in Western have no desire learn speak English since their plans is not living rest life there. They're just there for short term working (5-10yo) then comeback their own country,etc...
very Asian born & raise in US/UK speak perfectly English like it's their first langue, they're speaking English more fluently than their mother language
i don't get what you talking about. But as Asian, i expect Asian (born & raise in Western) beside bond with locals, they better knowing their root language & cultures.
Chinese are terrible racists pal. You know nothing.
I always feel more connected to my history as a Chinese-American when I watch these kinds of videos.
uh... what the
Do you identify as an American? Is your loyalty to America or China?
Get back to your roots! Our history is important
we are family and have common enemy
dont be banana
I'm using this for a school project. Realllllyyyy helped thanks💕💕
I LOVE THIS. PLEASE MAKE MORE!! More about the Chinese Diaspora in the Caribbean & in Latin America and how they contributed to cuisine and culture there :')
Chinese in China America is for Americans
Thanks. I came to the U. of Texas in 1969 from Viet Nam (VN) for education. From 1969 to 1978, it was a hardship because discrimination in Texas. I got a job offer in California in 1978. Life is much better in California. Thx for your program.
So beautifully done. Thank U for this Dolly, AJ+!
i had to watch this video for school, and it was super helpful! keep up the good work
The concept of paper sons (immigrating under an assumed name) and the forced separation, detention, and interrogation of Chinese immigrant families on Angel Island Immigration Station need to be highlighted in a future video.
Congratulations on a very well made mini-documentary series. Very professional and is broadcast quality. Enjoyed it very much.
I grew up in Cupertino, CA; there are many new Chinese folks who moved from China for educational opportunities and jobs. Unfortunately many of them drive extremely recklessly and discriminate the Asian American folks thinking we're less superior because we're not as "rich" as them. Hopefully things will change. Chinese folks are cool!
Paul Tran BRUH, from what I've heard they discriminate against the Chinese Americans who came before them too. Da heck
paul, true that. The rich chinese kids are too spoiled. Same thing in canada too.
Paul Tran
NSA CIA MK ultra paid troll ALERT. You are a fake Chinese.
Inderjit Singh
I am from Canada and I don't see that at all. And you are not even Indian.
Paul Tran im an asian American myself and i would of punk those fools if they try to showoff and act all mighty.
Love @dollyli'S storytelling in all of the series. Great stuff! I feel I learn more from the videos, rather than watching a feature-length documentary about the same topic.
Lol i took a "23 and me"test after 36yrs i found out i have a lot of chinese, and i also have a half bro😮😮😶👌🈴️🥢🥡
All my Grandparents immigrated to the U.S. in the 1920 's . One family to Sacramento and the other
family to C.T. , L.A. My mom's Family were Chinese Vegetable Farmers in Buena Park area , same as their livelihood back home .
My Dad's father worked for Southern Pacific Railroad in Sacramento until retirement.My Grandpa in L.A.was President of the Wong Family Association......BING KONG TONG
in CHINATOWN , L.A. My father served 2 years in the Koream War , and then worked at the for the USPS until retirement. My mom was a stay at home mom , raising 7 children.
Sacramento River area reminds the Chinese immigrants of the PEARL RIVER and DELTA in Southern China , of the communities, water , farm land , weather of the home they left. Many were Fruit Farmers all along the Sacramento ..
Delta area . This my journey ,.., of a 2nd generation ABC . , from the city ,
Toisan , Guangdong Province .
Hi! Answer me
Please
Great video! I would love to see you do one about asians and the media, including the late '00-early '10s UA-cam boom
I love your videos Dolly, keep them coming please!
Keep up the good work! This is awesome!
Beautiful information of American Chinese History ....Thank you 🙏
Thanks so much! This was very well done.
It sounds like their should be a MLK statue in every Chinatown in America
mac berry absolutely
Magnificent video. Nicely done. Perfect. Thanks for sharing your culture . Make sure no one copy your Ideas. Remember ?
Thank you for making such an educational and amazing video! Keep up the excellent work.
So interesting. Kind off topic but there are Chinese immigrants in so many countries, including Mexico. I was shocked as a Mexican american, you learn fun new things everyday about immigration.
actually,People all over the world want to go to America, because this is the most powerful and rich country in the world，not only chinese.
I always learn something new about certain cultures and history this is really cool
Thank you so much for doing this. The story of the Chinese-American mirrors that of the Chinese-Canadian in many ways, including the Exclusion Act and immigrant quotas. I wasn't at all interested in this stuff as a kid, since I was far more interested in "being Canadian," but I've really started to explore this more as an adult.
@tiluu lmao 😂
Love this videos/series ❤️
Hello beautiful your smile is placelees
really informative! thank you
My ancestors came to the in 1870-1880s. Drought in China, the damage from the Opium Wars destroyed local economy of Southern China.- so there was a great deal of unemployment in southern China. Until the Chinese Exclusion Act ... chinese could immigrate to the USA albeit a chinese immigrant could not be a naturalized citizen ...because of the 1790 Naturalization Act and its following extensions which was not repeal until 1952... Until 1952 only chinese descent persons born in the USA could be a US Citizen ... (this upheld by in the supreme court case Wong Kim Ark vs US in 1898)... I am a 4th generation American Born Chinese ....most of the chinese who left china from 1840 to 1888 came from Guangdong province and the seaports of Fujian province ... The earliest Chinese contacts with the outside world was done during the Zheng He Treasure ship campaigns around 1430s... Some Chinese who left the Manchu rule Qing Dynasty China did not go to Gold Mountain but went to South America, Central America, the philippines, Singapore/malaysia, indonesia, and Hawaii .. After the Opium Wars I and II - China was the sick man of Asia.
.
This was such a great series!
Man these videos are awesome. Can you guys please do a video like this but for the Indian American Community??
According to your last bit, since 1990, Chinese no longer want to migrate to U.S. What does this tell us about China or U.S.?
who is your enemy?
Chinese : American
where do you want to move to?
Chinese : US
Please make video about filipino immigration and diaspora in the US too...
Why is Chinese Government so strict, insecure and act psychotic
I feel the background music. Top pick
I live in California there's a lot of Chinese people here in California.
This is helpful i love this video. that touches my soul for the Chinese immigrants living in the United States that era period and now CCP corrupting it's own country.
how did Al Jazeera come around too produce and fund this?
just curious
Fund? You mean pay the animator?
#Awesomesauce! Thank you AJ+!
Chinese people should come to the U.S. and start their own community's and apartments here like the other Asian's have
They do. It’s called Chinatown.
Thank you!!!
Hello
I teach in China. Can you add Chinese subtitles. A lot of mainlanders don’t know this history. I know they’d find it interesting.
Please tell the kids in the mainland that Americanized Chinese food is not "fake Chinese food". I hate it when FOBs come over to the US and tell people that Chinese food in America is fake. They fail to realize the history behind it and the contribution that people made to the culture of American Chinese food. It has gone through a rich evolution since the first Chinese arrived in the 1850s. Just as how Chinese food in the mainland had went through its own evolution since 1850 to now. There are countless Chinese diasporas throughout the world each having a unique story along with their refined ways of cooking.
Great video history on a very short time period I loved it...
Good job Dolly! very informative!!
I stay permanently in USA because of discriminatory policy and re-entry denial of the country in Asia where I was born, grew up and educated. In paradox a lot of their citizens migrate to USA. The country encourage migation of their citizens to US for economic reason and while it pursue very strict immigration policy. It is nice for their citizens to migrate to US and other countries but not the other way around.
Great series.
dang right there @3:50
that is bruce lee's era
4:31 what tiananmen square crackdown?
Excellent content!
great summary
I applied you for this excellent video and excellent coverage.
Hello beautiful your smile is placelees
please add a video transcript.
Show me something about Chineses in San Francisco and New York Chinatown....
I have been in both
But didn' t see much...
what was the fourth wave?
My mom was one of those people who came to USA and study at the 80s
Peace and love from Egypt I love USA USA USA USA USA USA
chinese ppl came to US for taking photos of IPHONE
What's wrong with her head? Stop moving it with every syllable
Mexican Taco Trucks and Chinese massage parlors in each corner
Chinese can't stay in china
America has never really been all that great to immigrants which is odd to me. We have a horrible way of hating an ethnic group, and then welcoming them all the while hating a 'new' ethnic group. Look how the Irish and Italians were treated when they first came over. This tradition needs to end, and I feel that it is given that the control of information has been relaxed. No longer can you easily hide how horribly people were treated.
Great program. I would like to see a review about the illegally immigration through The Darien Gap (Panama) by Chinese people.
Do you know the story about any Southeast Asian and how they came to America
@ 2:05 she says,... "so the very people who were fighting alongside the Americans, were not even allowed to come into the country". The Chinese exclusion act should [probably] have never been passed (or even introduced). But Americans were in China, fighting for China, -not the other way around. So the argument is a false dialectic. And since we had just endured the great depression and were then entering another World War, you could not have expected Congress to take up the matter until after the war (of repealing or modifying the Chinese Exclusion Act).
i think it's misleading to group taiwan, mainland china, and hong kong all together (at least the way it was done in this video). ignoring the geopolitical issues of what constitutes a country, those 3 areas have very different histories/cultures and the reason mainland china individuals would immigrate to the usa are different than the other 2 at a given point in time.
for example, in the 3rd wave section you mention that mao's policies very negatively affected life in china, then follow it by saying the USA changed its policies allowing more chinese to immigrate to the usa. you follow that section by saying the chinese immigrants in the 3rd wave mostly come from taiwan/hk. but that's really misleading because mao's policies affected people of mainland china, not people of taiwan and not people of hk. the people of taiwan during this time ran pretty much independently of china and hk was run by the british.
Jackimust good point
you're wrong in saying that these 3 area have "very different histories/cultures", if you know any history at all, these 2 place belonged to China since Ming Dynasty, and have shared every cultural aspect until the British colonisation of HK and civil war which broke up Mainland and Taiwan....
if you want to share an opinion at-least get your facts straight, or it wouldn't fly.
What SYL said is true.
The truth is often viewed through selective history. If any, it will only be more accurate to say both countries had a gap away from China only recently. ( In considering the years in history. )
That gap doesn't erase everything that comes before the gap, especially the politic, culture and history which all 3 countries shared for a long time before the separation.
The first comment is only accurate if the OP said for the past 50 years, all 3 countries have developed very differently in different ways in their economic structures.
The only thing which is significantly different among these 3 countries since the separation.
These three areas have different cultures and histories? You know when these students study abroad. They consider themselves Chinese and they speak same language and celebrate Chinese New Year. You said we are historical and culturally different? And HK now belongs to china. Thank you.
What you're BSting isn't gonna change the fact that these people are the same: they all have been raised in Chinese culture, they all use Chinese characters, they all eat Chinese food, and they all have Chinese DNA. You pathetic anti-Chinese villain!!
The problem is that Chinese immigration is now so out of control that it is leading to problems throughout North America, Europe and Australia. Here in Canada cities such as Vancouver are almost exclusively Chinese.
Canada doesn’t belong to white people. Only native Americans can say “Those immigrants are having direct effects on our country”
So you hate some one better than you?
@@warcraftSENSw Not at all, some of my best friends are Chinese but even they say that Chinese immigration is becoming a problem.
Indians are also considered Asian
Obviously
You first know the death toll of World War II, and then explain the relevant contents of China.
Both White and Black people are unable to distinguish the Chinese identity. In the US Korean are mistaken as Chinese. Let us use the race coloured code. The European shares similar features. How did the European became American? These European do discriminate each other. The Italian is Deigo. The Polish are Pollack. The Irish are Catholic. What about the English? Most English migrants dropped their race and called Limey instead.
There is confusion over people with features similar to people from China. So as a community Chinese is yellow people. Indian people are brown.
They love democracy
No shit.
Why is this on
how was school bro
and you didn't interview me.....
More please
Dude where is the 4th wave
I love chinese food.
Since when has USA become China country??I'm partly American and just to be told I'm not a native??
If you have the Spotify app, and if you would like to find out about an interesting podcast, then type in 'Successful Excellent - Bodily Security', and take heed to the warning 🤚
Dolly Li is kind of a cute lady not going to lie.
I love how a lot of the history of Black Americans (civil rights movement, etc) is interconnected with the history of Asian-Americans. Black Americans and Asian American have a long history together in America that is unfortunately unknown to the most of the current generations since it’s not taught in schools.
Girl no
How come POC never bring up Asia
Because of current situations. The majority of immigrants from China, India and Pakistan are generally already wealthy before they move or are highly educated. India makes up the largest number of HB-1 visas dwarfing every other country except China who is close behind them.Also the very contro EB-5 Visa, which essentially lets you buy your way to be a legal resident is massively overrepresented by China. They make up 90% of all EB-5 visas. I can't speak for all cities but where I am from, in the metro area there is not much interaction between Asian communities and other POC communities. Black and Hispanic communities often live in the same area and interact regularly, whereas you rarely see the Asian community there
Read Joseph Stillwell and the American Experience in China by Barbara Tuch man you Chinese Americans...
Asian American !! 👍🇺🇸 Every states have a China town and Korea town!
got some Chinese ancestry myself. interesting videos. keep up the good work
I think china will soon clamp down on emigration and try to slow it, they are looking a demographic crisis because low birth rates mean an ever aging population, they will try to stop people leaving
most hong kong people left for uk as it was a british colony
From extreme poverty population to a low income family. They just renamed it
Chinese diaspora is actually a long process, in which might often involved thirds countries, and finally destination USA. Many Chinese are first in Southeast Asia or even India during WWI- WWII, and often time feel excluded/persecuted by the local political power when anti-Chinese sentiment rise.
Hello Lisa
3.79 million chinese nd 3.19 million indian live in us
You guys all need to go back to china
Good video, life was hard in America for Chinese, Japanese and Korean communities. Sometimes I wish we the European Americans would treated our Asian Americans with love and respect, not with discrimination and killing, it is different as European Americans treated the Black African Americans. I like our Asian Americans that we have in this country to show lots of respect and love. America is a multinational country, and always will be.
Native Americans were Asian Americans too.
I don't think you should have grouped Hong Kong and Taiwan together with mainland China. At the third wave time, HK was not governed by china at all. Taiwan has never been governed by the CCP and saying Mao's policies caused these migrants from HK and Taiwan isn't really accurate.
My dad from hong kong and my mom from taiwan. We consider ourselves chinese so i dont see where you coming from.
SteelersFans99
United Chinese diaspora
Dubat Pikachu As a pureblood Taiwanese, we actually respect Japan more than China. I literally shit on mainland China as much as possible and even say it out loud in public.
Charles Lo
There is no such thing as a pure blood taiwanese ..
i think he meant the taiwanese natives, so he's basically not Han.
Well people like that exists, who 'shit' on people base on their brith location, thats equivalent to racism (even worse, consider we're the same race), and thats what Charles is.
Shout out to Hoi San Ngin!
Love it!=D
The violence is the most on second count,Light pollution from both ways
Too much head movement.
U can always go back there is no wrong time to do the .......thing...
Why would the americans hate the immigrants if the entire USA is made up of european settlers AKA immigrants? Wherez da logic
Do some researchers. Americans have a very narrow range of what type of immigrant they like. The further from white you are, the less they like you. And "white" is a moving goalpost with no fixed definition in order to maintain control in the country.
Americans dont hate immigrants, a portion has been manipulated into thinking immigrants are the cause of their economic hardship despite it being a litany of other factors such as outsourcing and automation. There are a portion who are just racist though. But you will find people like that in every country.
The USA was not created by immigrants. When European settlers came to America there was no country here. The white Europeans created a country here. They were not immigrants. They created the USA.
4:31 u mean didn't happen?
Chill.