You all are completely ignoring the fact of homelanders powers. That's why I would be a good fight. Judge Holden has an advantage because of his intelligence.
@@The_Mad_Titan_420Judge Holden was once found with a 12 year old girl naked in his bedroom. He also gives out candy to kids when he comes to a new town. Kids also start disappearing when he comes to town
Judge Holden acts more like a homelander who has absolutely won. He really can and does do whatever the f*ck he wants. Why? Cos he's truly free. He has nothing to lose. Homelander still has his fans, his humanity, and will always be under Vought's thumb. Once homelander truly breaks free, he could be more terrifying than the judge.
@@mahmosii Oh ok that part was sad you shoulda said that in the original comment cuz I thought you were talking about his adult life, which none of that requires sympathy.
@@dellmaxson2184 Unless we are taking it by the comics lol, Black Noir is the reason Homelander turned psychopathic after eating a baby and SA'ing Billy Butcher's wife (Actually this video should have been Judge Holden vs Comic Book Black Noir because he is also a suspected pedophile.)
@@polk-tr7uv Quality of evil: Holden Quantity of evil: Frieza Both are complete monsters without a shadow of a doubt, but the Judge is evil incarnate in his universe while the DB universe has multiple villains just as bad as Frieza (Cell, Kid Buu, Zamazu, and others). Further, the Judge’s actions are just more vile on an individual level on average, at least imo. However, the Judge has never blown up a planet killing billions of innocent people and animals, thus Frieza takes quantity as Frieza has done that (again, not unique for DB but still).
@@ZCommander Well what do you think of Kid Buu his evil is even more than the rest like Cell or Frieza or Zamasu unlike the rest he is literally a representation of pure evil and has no emotions literally has no goals like the rest to be limited evil
Noir was more close to Holden than Homelander and even then he’s barely as sinister, evil, and diabolical as Holden who does it out of enjoyment, fulfillment, glorification, and downright belief because he just can
I wouldn't say barely, being around Holden was a 50/50 percent chance of survival, even children had a small but real chance. Black Noir would just do anything to get Homelander hated on, SA someone's wife eat a baby on camera you name it.
@@CalciumEcho1000 So I read the comics, and I'm still confused. Why did Black Noir rape Butcher's wife Becca specifically? They were coincidentally just by pure chance on a vacation they had saved for in Florida. Billy at that point was just a Joe Schmoe veteran who was going to settle down with his wife. No connects of any kind to Vought or superheros. Did Black Noir just go around door to door raping people's wives in the hopes they would eventually turn into the punisher?
Comic Book Black Noir is a better comparison, He ate a baby, SA'd Billy Butcher's wife and killed her, also he killed a ton of people and got Homelander accused of the crimes.
Homelander at least has a reason. It doesn’t justify any of his actions but u get why he ended up such a mess. The judge is just evil cuz he feels like it. Like he’d be a super villain in the boys comics that’s how bad he is. Homelander just has more power and even then it’s theorized the judge isn’t even a human, he’s just evil in the shape of a man. A more fair comparison would be darkseid or mephisto or literally the devil. Homelander is evil cuz he’s very childish but can get away with whatever he wants and basically just loses his temper. He’s still super evil but Holden literally has no reason to do what he does. He just feels like it. As far as I can tell there was no tragic upbringing and yes the Wild West sucked to live in but he causes misery just cuz he likes it. Homelander may not be above SA when he feels like it which is the closest he’ll get to being on holden’s level of evil but when he causes suffering it’s either cuz it’s more convenient, is reckless and doesn’t like it when consequences are included or he just doesn’t like someone. The judge will do all of that and get a priest shot just because he got bored
Holden has another thing going for him in the evil department: given his dialogue in the book, many people, such as the Vile Eye, consider Holden to be the Devil of the McCarthy-verse.
Homelander was raised to be a killer but judge Holden just is one because he literally could have had many successful careers but chose to be a killer just by the thrill of it Jude Holden is the living embodiment of evil
The judge really didn’t get much of a backstory, so you really can’t compare them in that way. But the simple answer: Holden is the epitome of the word Vile, while Homelander is basically a man child with an alarming amount of power. Apples and oranges.
Holden has transcended evil he sees the world for what it is and his brand of amoral nihilism sets him apart from normal villains. Is he in fact the personification of War itself? Home lander was broken as a child by Voight and is basically a ten year old in an indestructible body . I think Holden is the most evil although he wouldn’t see it that way . John due to Stars acting is pitiful figure craving the love he never received as a child .
I think the Judge is more evil than the qu sense the species had their own beliefs and religions not to mention if the judge was as powerful as the qu he would do way worse then the qu.
Judge Holden takes the cake imo. He’s a terrible person, but also has a sane head on his shoulders if you know what I mean. Meanwhile, Homelander is loose in the head and doesn’t always understand what’s going on with people. Like, him being shocked from A-train’s betrayal says it all.
Homelander is just a broken person, if he would raised well by healthy parents he could be super hero, Judge is pure evil and he actually likes doing it
Eh you should read into him a bit. Judge is such a brutal asshole and he kind represents perfectly the disgusting hypocrisy of humanity where evil is allowed to go rampantly unabated under the law. He is generic but he does the "Satan in human form" really well. He's the epitome of "I'm rich and powerful so I get to kill and torture you, but you don't get to kill me because I'm lawful".
Homelander,easily. People love hating homelander,people respect villains like Omniman,Vader,Thano,and Joker,while nobody respects HL,and straight up hate him,plus most people have no idea who Judge Holden is
I'm sorry, but there are only 4 characters in fiction that I consider pure Evil and forces of nature. Forces that blow in like an evil wind that dismantles and obliterate anything in their paths. And Homelander doesn't hold a candle to any of them: Michael Myers Anton Chigurh Hannibal Lecter And Judge Holden.
Homelander is simply more physically powerful than the Judge, and then again the Judge seems to be really surprising and almost invincible in his abilities, so even there we don’t know, but in terms of evil, the Judge is much more brutal, and his evil is wayyyy less justified.
@@DEvoureign I finished the season 4 finale the other day; YOU clearly haven’t read blood meridian otherwise you’d realise what a stupid comment you just made
@@DEvoureign Right, I don’t know homelander but I’ve seen seasons 1-4 of the boys 🤣 you know the judge R words babies right? And cuts off their scalps?
@@strongman5243 Doesn't Plutonian have a tragic backstory aka He got tossed from one foster home to another after his families discovered his powers. Several rejected him out of fear, and one mother even killed herself. And then there are the circumstances of his birth - he was originally an alien probe that took on a human baby's form after reacting to the powerful emotions of an insane woman who had killed her child, which might have corrupted him from the start. He also lived in the woods as a feral child, known as the Wolf Boy, for a time. He was already severely psychologically damaged by the time things began looking up which did not negate nor heal any of the damage he went through prior. When he finally gets to a (relatively) stable, functional home, his new father's moral strictures also unintentionally give him a massive sense of entitlement, which is ultimately the final straw on a teetering tower of psychological issues. Pretty sure Holden is more evil.
@@strongman5243 Not denying that. But the fact he has a tragic backstory means that he isn't pure evil. He can't really be called the incarnation of evil like this Holden guy.
@@plasma7819 If take the route of Holden being the antichrist... Homelander gets fucked. If we take the route of a tall human Holden is fucked. The fact is we do not know what Holden is... He doesn't age sleep drink or eat, so they really can not be compared.
We're talking about evil personified VS a man child that gets upset sometimes. Easy question to me
Yeah. He’s literally supposed to be an allegory for the devil.
Homelander is a rapist
homelander just wanted some milk
@@Zimbobrokemothers milk
You all are completely ignoring the fact of homelanders powers. That's why I would be a good fight. Judge Holden has an advantage because of his intelligence.
Holden: does kids
Homelander: doesnt do that
Well folks i think we have a verdict
This is true if our moral belief is petty = evil
Does kids??
@@The_Mad_Titan_420 Yeah when they say the embodiment of all evil…they hold nothing back.
@@The_Mad_Titan_420Judge Holden was once found with a 12 year old girl naked in his bedroom. He also gives out candy to kids when he comes to a new town. Kids also start disappearing when he comes to town
@@anonomit8229 Bro 💀
Holden could defeat Homelander because he claims he'll never die, he dances, dances in the Moonlight, he says he'll never die, and everyone loves him
Of course, For whatever exist without his knowledge, exist without his consent,
Homelander is just stronger, smarter and better
@@LevelRevelsHe says he will never die, he dances in light and shadow
@@LevelRevelsHe stands at 7 ft, he never sleeps, he says he will never die, he never sleeps the judge.
He also never sleeps, because he’s always on the grind, the judge. He is edging… edging… he says he’ll never come….
The judge is the devil when homelander is a man baby.
while*
the judge if the god of the universe if you pick up on the gnostic references in the book
Evil Writing.
By Crime Rate:HomeLander.
Evil Ambition:The Judge.
Winner:Holden.
Is this even a debate? Homelander is broken, judge is just his universe’s devil on Earth
homelander is a child murderer
Judge Holden acts more like a homelander who has absolutely won. He really can and does do whatever the f*ck he wants. Why? Cos he's truly free. He has nothing to lose. Homelander still has his fans, his humanity, and will always be under Vought's thumb. Once homelander truly breaks free, he could be more terrifying than the judge.
I agree
I’d still rather encounter the “true homelander” atleast he won’t touch me without my consent
@@zxtwist True. You can also save yourself by not being afraid of him or outsmarting him.
@@zxtwistSay that to Becca
@@Passarium-1195 homelander would have nothing to lose. You can't reason with people like that. You'd have no leverage.
Holden would make Homelander look like a legit superman.
Homelander is just a sad situation. But it is what it is. 😕
Will you explain your comment?
I think we must have watched different shows
@@dellmaxson2184 I'm talking about his traumatic past of being treated as a test experiment.
@@mahmosii Oh ok that part was sad you shoulda said that in the original comment cuz I thought you were talking about his adult life, which none of that requires sympathy.
@@dellmaxson2184 Unless we are taking it by the comics lol, Black Noir is the reason Homelander turned psychopathic after eating a baby and SA'ing Billy Butcher's wife (Actually this video should have been Judge Holden vs Comic Book Black Noir because he is also a suspected pedophile.)
A broken tragic character who never had a chance to be anything but who he is vs literal evil incarnate.
Gee I wonder who is more evil
It’s a good thing you found this video then! 😁
@@pineguin008Can you make the Video Judge Holden vs Freezeh Dragon Ball Who is more evil
@@polk-tr7uv Judge Holden wins this round, he obv is much much more evil.
@@polk-tr7uv
Quality of evil: Holden
Quantity of evil: Frieza
Both are complete monsters without a shadow of a doubt, but the Judge is evil incarnate in his universe while the DB universe has multiple villains just as bad as Frieza (Cell, Kid Buu, Zamazu, and others).
Further, the Judge’s actions are just more vile on an individual level on average, at least imo.
However, the Judge has never blown up a planet killing billions of innocent people and animals, thus Frieza takes quantity as Frieza has done that (again, not unique for DB but still).
@@ZCommander Well what do you think of Kid Buu his evil is even more than the rest like Cell or Frieza or Zamasu unlike the rest he is literally a representation of pure evil and has no emotions literally has no goals like the rest to be limited evil
Crazy that the one that Has Superpowers,was genetically engineered in a Lab and believes himself a God is by far the more humane one between the 2
Noir was more close to Holden than Homelander and even then he’s barely as sinister, evil, and diabolical as Holden who does it out of enjoyment, fulfillment, glorification, and downright belief because he just can
Yeah comic black noir vs judge holden would be competition, not a man child though
I wouldn't say barely, being around Holden was a 50/50 percent chance of survival, even children had a small but real chance. Black Noir would just do anything to get Homelander hated on, SA someone's wife eat a baby on camera you name it.
@@CalciumEcho1000 So I read the comics, and I'm still confused. Why did Black Noir rape Butcher's wife Becca specifically? They were coincidentally just by pure chance on a vacation they had saved for in Florida. Billy at that point was just a Joe Schmoe veteran who was going to settle down with his wife. No connects of any kind to Vought or superheros. Did Black Noir just go around door to door raping people's wives in the hopes they would eventually turn into the punisher?
Ah yes, because Homelander raping Becca and trying to harvest Maeve’s eggs were both definitely just him throwing temper tantrums.
I haven’t seen the previous seasons of The Boys, but when did Homelander tried to harvest Maeve’s eggs?
@@litlitten8751 The latter half of season 3
@@jameslough6329 ah thank you
This is a stupid debate homelander is still broken deep down
Judge make Homelander look like a saint
When your real competitions are an "Evil Supercomputer" and "Human Harvesting Aliens", there really isn't much else to say.
Comic Book Black Noir is a better comparison, He ate a baby, SA'd Billy Butcher's wife and killed her, also he killed a ton of people and got Homelander accused of the crimes.
"It'S NoT evEn CloSe"
man child vs the devil.
yeah this video was destined to be one sided.
Homelander at least has a reason. It doesn’t justify any of his actions but u get why he ended up such a mess. The judge is just evil cuz he feels like it. Like he’d be a super villain in the boys comics that’s how bad he is. Homelander just has more power and even then it’s theorized the judge isn’t even a human, he’s just evil in the shape of a man. A more fair comparison would be darkseid or mephisto or literally the devil. Homelander is evil cuz he’s very childish but can get away with whatever he wants and basically just loses his temper. He’s still super evil but Holden literally has no reason to do what he does. He just feels like it. As far as I can tell there was no tragic upbringing and yes the Wild West sucked to live in but he causes misery just cuz he likes it. Homelander may not be above SA when he feels like it which is the closest he’ll get to being on holden’s level of evil but when he causes suffering it’s either cuz it’s more convenient, is reckless and doesn’t like it when consequences are included or he just doesn’t like someone. The judge will do all of that and get a priest shot just because he got bored
A man who'll steal his son's milkshake vs the literal devil, this is a tough one guys
Both rap.
Eminem, Snoop, and Dr. Dre have meet their challengers
Holden has another thing going for him in the evil department: given his dialogue in the book, many people, such as the Vile Eye, consider Holden to be the Devil of the McCarthy-verse.
I trust homelander more with my life
Homelander is the consequence of evil
Holden is the embodiment of evil.
I'd rather have Homelander than having Holden.
Now do homelander evil vs A.M evil or homelander evil vs the QU evil
Coughing baby vs baby scalper
"Baby scalper" JESUS CHRIST.
Judge Holden would literally make Homelander cry
Nah he can't
Homelander was raised to be a killer but judge Holden just is one because he literally could have had many successful careers but chose to be a killer just by the thrill of it Jude Holden is the living embodiment of evil
Holden makes Homelander look like an Angel
The judge really didn’t get much of a backstory, so you really can’t compare them in that way.
But the simple answer: Holden is the epitome of the word Vile, while Homelander is basically a man child with an alarming amount of power. Apples and oranges.
Yo PineGuin Please make a Video on Villains From Fiction that are Worse than Homelander and Compassion!
Homelander is a saint compared to atleast 40% of villains
I think therefore I AM, I AM
Crying baby vs Atomic bomb
Homelander is probably capable of being more evil but he's kinda all talk the judge does that shit.
Holden has transcended evil he sees the world for what it is and his brand of amoral nihilism sets him apart from normal villains. Is he in fact the personification of War itself? Home lander was broken as a child by Voight and is basically a ten year old in an indestructible body . I think Holden is the most evil although he wouldn’t see it that way . John due to Stars acting is pitiful figure craving the love he never received as a child .
Tbh if we mixed both of them together I’m pretty sure we are screwed
How about this question about who is more evil? Judge Holden or Art the Clown?
HYDROGEN BOMB VS COUGHING BABY
Do the qu form all Tomorrows vs holden
I think the Judge is more evil than the qu sense the species had their own beliefs and religions not to mention if the judge was as powerful as the qu he would do way worse then the qu.
I think qu and am are better comparisons.
@Noname-mi1oo the qu are character*s*
Oh if they switched rolls like if we gave judge Holden homelanders powers I don't think I need to explain how bad things would go
A.M is the most evil character in all of fiction
The qu i think are more evil to be fr
@@badcontentdaily maybe
@@badcontentdaily it’s debatable
@@badcontentdaily The Qu weren't even the most evil in their own universe. The Gravitals were worse.
@@whatsmynameplease i mean they both did it to just do it
Judge Holden takes the cake imo. He’s a terrible person, but also has a sane head on his shoulders if you know what I mean. Meanwhile, Homelander is loose in the head and doesn’t always understand what’s going on with people. Like, him being shocked from A-train’s betrayal says it all.
I thought Holden was the worst book antagonist...until I heard about A.M. ...
I wholeheartedly believe they are on almost perfectly equal footing, which is crazy for a child predator and a non-child predator
Homelander is just a broken person, if he would raised well by healthy parents he could be super hero, Judge is pure evil and he actually likes doing it
If Homelander truly let go of his humanity and embraced his mirror self he'd be about as bad as The Judge
Can you please make video Who is more evil judge Holden or a.m.
Erebus : *yawns* we all know who the real evil is and all I need to do is just breath to rile people up😈
I AM not sure man,cuz the status Qu of evil cannot be changed with only them
The judge is a true problem and Homelander gets scared of those who consider him as nothing ☹️
If anything homelander can relate with AM thier evilness more or less comes from hurt which turns into wrath judge is just the devil's son
Holden is more evil by all of existence. Absolutely zero contest whatsoever.
Homelander has issues.
Judge is an issue
Character: John
Evilness: Judge ofc
As a villain: John
Idc what you say and tbh holden is overrated in terms of writing
@Monk_Chud I love holden actually change my minx
Eh you should read into him a bit. Judge is such a brutal asshole and he kind represents perfectly the disgusting hypocrisy of humanity where evil is allowed to go rampantly unabated under the law. He is generic but he does the "Satan in human form" really well. He's the epitome of "I'm rich and powerful so I get to kill and torture you, but you don't get to kill me because I'm lawful".
For a more fair comparison you’d have to use Homelander from the comics, who got bored and lasered a hole into the presidents skull so he could… yk…
Homelander,easily. People love hating homelander,people respect villains like Omniman,Vader,Thano,and Joker,while nobody respects HL,and straight up hate him,plus most people have no idea who Judge Holden is
translation: I have no idea who holden is
You have an Omni-man pfp, enough said.
@@GrandRegentSScratch You have a video about invincible,nuff said
@@sunshineandrainbows69 Translation:🤓
@@finchatforharambe905 why are you mocking him? he’s right though isn’t he?
who asked for this video
I’m not even using “who asked” as an offensive term, like literally who did user-adrsilva123 think was more evil?
Who’s more evil, AM or Judge Holden?
I'm sorry, but there are only 4 characters in fiction that I consider pure Evil and forces of nature. Forces that blow in like an evil wind that dismantles and obliterate anything in their paths. And Homelander doesn't hold a candle to any of them:
Michael Myers
Anton Chigurh
Hannibal Lecter
And Judge Holden.
Homelander cutting him half with his laser powers 🦸🏻
The influenced Anti-Christ Vs. Probably worse than Satan
0:38 Scalp-hunting.
Can you do am vs all tomorrow
To see who is more evil
My idea is that while Judge Holden is inherently evil and has always been evil--if you know you know--Homelander was made evil.
Not a fair question, homelander doesnt do evil things because he enjoys it. Means to an end for him. Judge is just the devil.
Judge Holden is worse than Homelander since the latter is at least tragic and can care for others.
Homelander is simply more physically powerful than the Judge, and then again the Judge seems to be really surprising and almost invincible in his abilities, so even there we don’t know, but in terms of evil, the Judge is much more brutal, and his evil is wayyyy less justified.
do Holden vs Joker
Holden is the literal embodiment of the devil
Juged holden vilany makes homelander look like superman
Holden may as well be the devil himself.
The judge the pudifinal tips it
Homelander would win in a fight against edp here 🗿
0:13 wiild
Is this even a debate ofc judge
This is not debatable in the slightest. Homelander is Jesus compared to Holden 💀
You obviously haven’t watched the boys 😂
@@DEvoureign I finished the season 4 finale the other day; YOU clearly haven’t read blood meridian otherwise you’d realise what a stupid comment you just made
@@zxtwist i didn’t make a stupid comment lol you obviously don’t know homelander
@@DEvoureign Right, I don’t know homelander but I’ve seen seasons 1-4 of the boys 🤣 you know the judge R words babies right? And cuts off their scalps?
@@zxtwist noir ate babies lol 😂
Homelander is a saint compared to Judge Holden
Why is this even a question?
how about judge holden and black noir in comics?
Definitely noir
@@strongman5243no I would say Holden but it‘s close(not really one is a child rapist)
@marwintrey black noir aka homelander ate a newborn baby so it's definitely ridiculously close.
@@MarwinTreu Child rapist and child cannibal, probably is pretty close since Noir ate a newborn baby once.
Plutonian is worse than homelander or Holden
Homelander, yes. Holden? No. Holden is the darkest side of all the awful people, to put it lightly.
@@quanghuynguyen7957 Pluton revels in the suffering of others, and he is more evil because of how many people he has killed.
@@strongman5243 Doesn't Plutonian have a tragic backstory aka He got tossed from one foster home to another after his families discovered his powers. Several rejected him out of fear, and one mother even killed herself. And then there are the circumstances of his birth - he was originally an alien probe that took on a human baby's form after reacting to the powerful emotions of an insane woman who had killed her child, which might have corrupted him from the start. He also lived in the woods as a feral child, known as the Wolf Boy, for a time. He was already severely psychologically damaged by the time things began looking up which did not negate nor heal any of the damage he went through prior. When he finally gets to a (relatively) stable, functional home, his new father's moral strictures also unintentionally give him a massive sense of entitlement, which is ultimately the final straw on a teetering tower of psychological issues. Pretty sure Holden is more evil.
@@DragonKingMadaraUchiha he does have a tragic backstory but deeds he had done are far worse
@@strongman5243 Not denying that. But the fact he has a tragic backstory means that he isn't pure evil. He can't really be called the incarnation of evil like this Holden guy.
Comic Black Noir >>>
black noir ( comics) or the judge
Still the Judge Holden beats him in terms of motive.
@@promeneuzivotu117Nah comics Noir is a different breed
@@finchatforharambe905 yes but in Black Noir's mind he is doing what he was created to do.
Nah he still enjoys the things he did. @@promeneuzivotu117
@@stachpema452 yes but still he had a motive unlike Judge Holden who does it for the fun of it.
Holden not even close lmao
Is not Holden persofonication of evil?
not even close how the fuck are they similar
Comics Black Boir by far.
This is a joke right?
AM
BRUH
1st🎉
Homelander would easily Manhandle Holden......in terms of evil....Holden
Homelander couldn't man handle anything. He says he never sleeps. He says he never dies.
@@alayctv5342are we really trying to power scale judge Holden now? You’re re tar ded. He’s just a tall human.
@@plasma7819 excuse me I didn't understand, can you repeat again? Why you talk so weird bro? 😂
@@alayctv5342 “repeat again” “why you talk” pot calling the kettle black. If you can COMPREHEND that term
@@plasma7819 If take the route of Holden being the antichrist... Homelander gets fucked. If we take the route of a tall human Holden is fucked. The fact is we do not know what Holden is... He doesn't age sleep drink or eat, so they really can not be compared.