Dany never wanted to leave the big house with the red door, Catelyn never wanted to leave Winterfell, Ygritte never wanted to leave that cave. And now they all dance with the ghosts. Valar Morghulis
Damn, this song makes me want to re-watch the whole series because it brings back all the feelings I had when seeing each episode for the first time. There's nothing like the first time watching GoT
I watched it again, in 4k, with my sister, it was her first time. I enjoyed soooo much, she didn't so much, but she liked it. I always cry on this song...
@darkonikolic2608 My husband and I actually did re-watch the whole series after I made this post, and it reminded me of how awesome it was yet also how sad it made me. I was always such a big Daenerys fan and wondered why they did her so wrong in the end, but binge watching the series made me realize how absolutely mad she actually was, those damned Targaryens! And poor John, he was just doomed from birth
I don’t know if I’ll ever not cry to this song. So many memories, so many emotions, the show didn’t end how I hoped but it was a hell of a journey. Ned, Daenerys, Lyanna, Rhaegar, Robb, Margery, Jamie and many others deserved so much better than they got. I guess I’ll always dance with their ghosts.
I wish I'd met you at summer camp. The way your mind works is just lovely. Thank You for sharing as I too find myself wanting to cry over this. People may laugh if they choose but I simply cannot help it.
Well said indeed. If i remember the journey i will one day rewatch GOT and enjoy it, though the last parts less so, but even in those there are good scenes and good actors.
I really hope House of the Dragon will bring back that feeling of early Game of Thrones seasons. I read Fire and Blood and the story is truly magnificent. Honour, death, love and family and every other aspect GOT made impeccable.
Respectfully, Ser, there is no story to Fire and Blood, its just a history. No dialogue, no POV characters, just a second hand recount of the fall of the Targs. If anyone on here thinks that's going to be akin to the first 4 seasons of GOT, then they surely haven't been paying attention....
@@jamien134 Respectfully, although there is no dialogue in the book there will be in the show and there is an possibility to bring back that early GOT feeling because dance with dragons is "game of thrones". If book is no story and just a history then they could just make an 10 episode documentary about the Targaryens. Looks like you haven't been paying attention.
Respectfully, I'm really curious and looking forward to how House of the Dragon will be in the future. But as a Fire and Blood reader, I know there are going to be a few elements missing in the HBO adaptation. The reason being is: the show doesn't start from the very beginning of Fire and Blood. From the trailers I've watched, HBO starts House of the Dragon's story from the Dance of Dragons (the Targaryen civil war that killed all their dragons). Well......all in all, whatever the shows gonna be in the future, I'll still watch it regardless of where it starts and give my opinion about it objectively. But that begs the question, though: If HBO is going to make a Game of Thrones sequel about the Targaryen house, why not start House of the Dragon (HOTD) from the very beginning? Why not start it from Aegon the Conqueror himself and his Conquest? I mean......don't get me wrong.......Dance of Dragons is a pretty good story in itself. Personally, I like it. The story about a family being split into two, they fight each other nonstop for years, etc. It was a hell of a rollercoaster ride for me. I almost cried when Rhaenyra died in the end of the Dance. Really though, never thought I'd get emotional reading about a family feud that involves nations, wars, and dragons. Back to topic, as a Fire and Blood reader, I feel that there are also many things that make the Targaryen history interesting rather than only the Dance of Dragons. Aegon's Conquest; Aenys I and Maegor the Cruel's civil war (this is really tragic); King Jaeherys I's rule (my favorite Targaryen king after Aegon I); King Viserys I's rule and the evens prior to Dance of the Dragons. Those are some events that transpired before Dance of the Dragons that have been written in Fire and Blood. And in my honest opinion, those events may be underrated compared to Dance of Dragons (sans Aegon's Conquest), but all of them have huge impacts in the Targaryen family. Overall, just like I said, I don't really mind if HBO wants to start HOTD with Dance of Dragons. It's their show, not mine. I'm just a diehard house Targaryen fan with a question and trying to point out that there are many more tragic and impactful events that transpired before the Dance of Dragons. I just hope HOTD won't stray to far from the Fire and Blood book int terms of storyline. And hopefully, in the near distant future, there will be HOTD season 2 or something of the sort, and they adapt the many events before Dance of Dragons.
We all are Jenny of Oldstones. When the series ends, in our minds we will keep dancing with the characters between the ruins of Winterfell and King's Landing, because we will never want to leave.
My exact thought process, this is the one week I am not complaining about the wait, bc I know that I should enjoy them being together in my mind before it is changed forever.
@@gabrielatopczewska6784 well thats because we all know that she is going to live till the end of the season or episode 5. All characters (or almost all of them) in Winterfell might die in the next episode.
This story is all about tragedy. Wherever and whenever you look in the books and series, people's lives are a tragedy of their own. For me, it's the deep message of the author, more than the question of war. This whole story just tells that everyone suffers and faces tragic events, decisions, actions, of their own or of someone else. A masterpiece which will mark our time and the 2010's, both the series and the books.
Megha Singh lol no, this may have actually been song by Rheagar for Lyanna and is based on his uncle (feel in love with a common girl and gave up his crown)
I miss you, dear Game of Thrones. It was the most unique show ever, gathered with friends every Sunday to watch every episode. What an amazing experience it was. I love you GoT and I miss you
yep i really liked that it showed the human side of everyone. The characters sitting around the fire talking about the past and brienne becoming a knight was really beautiful and well executed. Although there isn't really so much happening in this episode it's one of my favourite.
This whole season has felt like a Disney movie so far not just because of the lack of violence thus far just the way it's been directed feels completely different
As a book reader, I'm so glad they included Jenny's song. Her and the Prince of Dragonflies had one of the most tragic romances in Westeros. This song is a fitting tribute
Also, like a lot of Thrones lore, it can be pieced together from a number of sources (including the World of Ice and Fire). Prince Duncan (the Prince of Dragonflies) was the heir to the throne and set aside his claim in order to marry Jenny of Oldstones, a commoner. This song refers to the Tragedy at Summerhall, where King Aegon V, Ser Duncan the Tall, and the Prince of Dragonflies died in flames. Additionally, many of the wiki sites about Thrones lore are very informative
Fun Fact: Rhaegar sung this song at a royal tournament. It is said that this was the moment when Lyanna fell in love with Rhaegar. So basically, Jon was born because of this song. Excellent timing by introducing us to the song just moments before Jon tells Daenerys his origin at the grave of Lyanna!
It's also written about Jon and Daenarys' ancestors. Duncan Targaryen "the dragonfly prince" and Jenny of Oldstones, the common born girl he gave up his throne to marry.
That is GoT. With this song, it says goodbye. Goodbye to the things we knew and the characters we've been rooting for all these years. It is a way of making us realise this is the end. In a beatiful way. Thank you GoT.
This is exactly what the song represents. Not for the battles or the deaths. But the conclusion of 8 years of tears, laughs, suspense, love, torture, beauty, and memories. Thank you Game of Thrones.
This song is everything. 1. It's a final farewell to Game Of Thrones. 2. A tribute to Lord of the Rings as Pippin sung a similar song before Boromir's father.
@@reamusray790 It's pretty much the same, since Boromir and Faramir were brothers :) Anyway, I'm happy that more people thought of Pippin while listening to Podrick.
@@AlasEtéreas he had to. To fool one's enemies, one needs to fool loved one's first. Also, by not telling her he protected her as well. Should she have known, in case of her being captured, enemies of house Stark could have tortured her to gain knowledge about Jon's true identity. Ned couldn't have had let that happen.
naphaneal I also think Ned probably knew that if he told Catelyn the truth, she might some day let it slip because of her desire to make it known she was not a cuckolded wife and that Ned was faithful to her, even by accident. So he couldn’t risk it. All in all, there were several reasons to stay silent
A decade, a decade of GOT. I almost feel similar to how I felt before my dad died, I'm just not ready. This show has made me feel emotions I've never had evoked from watching a show on TV. I've read the books and watched every season 3 times and I'm still not ready to say goodbye, but as you so well put it. This was goodbye.
@@Cardiebee123 seriously? "Cleganebowl" was one of the most pointless bits of fanwank ever. The hound's death by fire was just one more check in a box that fit into the surrounding narrative about as naturally as a pickle in an ice cream sandwich.
TV4Fun2 completely agree just the scene on its own was well written only the hound vs mountain though the queens guard and the hands death was just stupid
Episode 2 was made to make us love the characters more than ever before. So that when they die (possibly in the next episode) it would absolutely kill us. THANKS DAVID AND DAN!
I think it was to have their final moments of happiness before facing death. I mean the Starks didn't see each other since episode 1 so now they are all there
This video having comments with so many likes in such a short time only confirms how big the fandom is and the legacy that the show left. GOT, you will always be famous.
@@NateThe_Great24 It still blows my mind that they actually think being in the crypt is safe. They surely won't be slaughtered by the resurrected Stark skeletons... Other than that, if they lose the battle or they need to retreat to Pyke, they will be utterly fucked in the crypts anyway, even if the night king decides to not raise the dead for whatever reason. In that case either the army will break into the crypts or they will starve to death.
Felt like some sort of a homage to the characters. Plenty are going to die next episode, it's going to be horrifying and emotional but still exciting. The Night's King is probably going to kill everyone in the crypt and raise them along with the already dead. If Jon had to meet his mother as a zombie... Jesus.
@@mattcruse495 It's an absurdist version of simply answering "more" to the same question. indicating that there is no upper limit. Making it absurdist makes it work better as a joke because answering "yes" is more nonsensical than "more" which could be meaningful in certain contexts. With "yes" it's clear nonsense since it doesn't match the question, and so the question is the setup for the joke, demanding an answer with fixed parameters, but instead of the expected meaningful answer to the question we get nonsense, but nonsense that still carries meaning that is easily to parse. So we get an answer that both subverts out dialectical expectation and indicates that the situation should be more extreme than what was even conceived of as being possible with the parameters of the original question. And it's a fairly simple joke, so it works well as a meme and can be transcribed to almost any other context. And now that i have explained the joke in this much detail, there is a good chance that it will never be funny to you anyway. Sorry about that :)
its 2022 Oct, still get goosebumps listening to this masterpiece. GOT will forever , i mean forever be my favorite TV series. even HOTD is good. but GOT was so strongly written , portrayed. i love every inch of this series, no matter the ending . i miss you Game Of Thrones.
@@juanmanuel2659 this song is to set peoples emotuons on fire. It tells the whole story of Game of Thrones minus the deaths. Fans will have this song to look back on, during the enternal night with out game of thrones
This clip is just brilliant. Jamie leaving Cersei and 'Never wanted to leave' in the background. Same with Ned leaving Catelyn at the Bran's bed. This very phrase says so much about all the characters. Ned who never wanted to be a King's Hand in the far South and Jamie who loved his sister till he realised she's a monster.
@@serenayale9729 the worst part about it is that cersei never loved him. it's so one sided, im so glad Jamie realized his worth after all the character development he's gone through. He deserves better then her and he's literally found someone better then cersei: Brienne.
It’s sad he died no doubt hating theon. When the main reason robb wanted to defeat the Lannister’s was to save Sansa. I’m sure robb, ned and even catelyn would’ve been beyond grateful for he did for the stark children
I finished all 8 seasons yesterday. This series is a heart healer. I enjoyed watching this series for the past two months. I'm missing this now. I'm missing that all seasons ended nd there is no more got to watch. This series made me to forget that I'm lonely.
Michelle fairly as cat was the best choice o am glad they recasted like holy hell thank the gods her and Sean where perfect although both deny that they actually bonded on the show Michelle gush’s about Richard Madden and how she bonded with him and Sean loved massie and Sophie but they both deny bonding much with each other either there both extremely great at acting cuz we get there whole relationship in 6 part they have less then 10 mins of screen time together but everyone ships them hardcore to this day. Or there is a mass cover up for. Something they actually really had because I am not buying her and Sean bean never interacted much cuz it’s just to get if chemistry .
More than three years later and this still brings tears to my eyes. It's good to be back in the ASOIAF world. Hopefully House of the Dragon reaches the heights Game of Thrones did. The first episode was fantastic. edit after the HotD season 1 finale: It, in fact, did match up. Ladies and gents, WE'RE BACK.
@@ultimatemayh3m768 I don’t think they could contractually, George locked them into creating all the episodes. They just wanted to rush it and go on to Star Wars(which was a complete shit show).
Finally a Game of Thrones song that is not related to massive murder. Just absolutely heartbreaking. Okay, so I just learned about what the song it is. And when I heard it again, this time I cried a lot more. It's a sad story, but unlike Light of Seven or Rains of Castamere, it's way more tragic and relatable. Poor Jenny.
The Ghost of Winterfell I got some bad news for you chief. This song is about the Tragedy of Summerhall: the doomed love of Jenny and Duncan, the false hope of righteous King Aegon, and the tears of the Ghost of High Heart, remembering the pain of it all.
@@AGH2401 that was an accident and a tragedy, not a butchery. So for Game of Thrones it is somehow joyful... but in the end it is just sad. We're living the end of an era. Game of Thrones era.
Jack Murphy Actor right? All my fave characters have made it this far but I know they won’t be here long. The only one I know will live is Arya since George always said it was his and his wife’s fave and he won’t kill her off
Say what you want about the last season but the music never fails, 3 years later and i’m still tearing up over this song especially when you know the context of duncan targaryen and jenny
![The Hanging Tree - MUSIC VIDEO - [The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Pt.1 Score (James Newton Howard)]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DqhOzH8QcH4/mqdefault.jpg)
Night King : *prepares for the attack *
Pod: *start's singing*
Night king: Hold on let him finish
Know we know why these whores didn't take money from him
After all those years
Night King: That's a lovely, lovely voice.
That is so true LOL
First a magic cock, now a magic voice, Bronn you better watch out. xD
@@pauloeduardo1012 I UNDERSTOOD THAT REFERENCE!
Pod singing this song shocked me so much. It was so unexpected yet so amazing.
I pulled over in the jewel parking lot to watch this episode.
Yes he has a good voice
fuck hbo man... they just did this for pod die in next episode
Unexpected? He kinda was the only option in my mind...
LOTR reference?
Everyone this episode: We're all going to die.
Pod: Let me drop my album real quick.
Man you had me🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is about the umpteenth time I've seen this joke made in the span of 20 hours.
sam Worthy *cough* unoriginal comment *cough*
:D :D :D :D
Pod-cast
The "She never wanted to leave" on Catelyn scene really tears my heart.
Mine too. She never wanted him to leave. 💔
Amazing actress….
Eh she was just being a bitch complaining about Jon, her death made me laugh none of it would've happened if she let Rob name Jon Heir
@@aliakapoorexcept she did in the books?
@@orphanedhanyou Well, sure. But they are referencing the Catelyn of the show, not the book
Tyrion: Anybody has any interesting things to say
Others: *silence
Tormund: I drank giants milk for 3 months
Tormund in the series: 2m tall
Tormund in real life: 1.83cm :D
BongieGER I don’t get it
You've got to attain the age😂
@@bongieger7871 fuck me didnt realise tormund was so small
BongieGER close enough !
This song in 7 years will be hard nostalgia for all of us
its been several months and im fucking crying already
mika 200 it already is 😭
It already is
Already feel nostalgic. Miss GoT so much!
Already is
Dany never wanted to leave the big house with the red door, Catelyn never wanted to leave Winterfell, Ygritte never wanted to leave that cave. And now they all dance with the ghosts.
Valar Morghulis
Wow, that's actually a beautiful summary
Valar Dohaeris
Valar Dohaeris
I cried
Valar Dohaeris
Damn, this song makes me want to re-watch the whole series because it brings back all the feelings I had when seeing each episode for the first time. There's nothing like the first time watching GoT
so real bro i’m here getting so many goosebumps
I watched it again, in 4k, with my sister, it was her first time. I enjoyed soooo much, she didn't so much, but she liked it. I always cry on this song...
@darkonikolic2608 My husband and I actually did re-watch the whole series after I made this post, and it reminded me of how awesome it was yet also how sad it made me. I was always such a big Daenerys fan and wondered why they did her so wrong in the end, but binge watching the series made me realize how absolutely mad she actually was, those damned Targaryens! And poor John, he was just doomed from birth
I'll do same man @@darkonikolic2608
i just started re-watching it all over again.... this really got me in my feels
HBO: How much emotions should we put in this song?
GOT: Yes.
eDAVOSheeran: Less.
STANNIS: Fewer.
GOT: All of them.
you can laugh all you want, but I put a tear or more to this song.
Too much for me, never wanted to leave..
This comment doesn't even make sense
The saddest thing is that rob will never know how regretful theon was for betraying him
Don't worry Theon will get to tell him real soon
Micisme86 Yes, in the next episode they’ll reunite :(
You, guys, are killing me :'( :'(
Beatriz Not like these characters.. they’re literally being killed off
The Wierwoods know, so I believe he already does.
"The ones she had lost" - shows Ned's beheading...
I'm not crying ,you are
Cloud 9 ?
Is that a devilman crybaby reference ?
Skadoodle?
@@deusdeusasmodeus Nope, that was said by Skadoodle, A Cloud9 CSGO Team Member
"And she never wanted to leave" - shows Ned leaving Winterfell and Catelyn crying. This song made me tear up damn it.
I don’t know if I’ll ever not cry to this song. So many memories, so many emotions, the show didn’t end how I hoped but it was a hell of a journey. Ned, Daenerys, Lyanna, Rhaegar, Robb, Margery, Jamie and many others deserved so much better than they got. I guess I’ll always dance with their ghosts.
genius ending I say
I wish I'd met you at summer camp. The way your mind works is just lovely. Thank You for sharing as I too find myself wanting to cry over this. People may laugh if they choose but I simply cannot help it.
Jamie?
Speechless, it was very beautiful..
@@yubakadi217 he changed...but Cersei as predicted was the death of him
This song will make people nostalgic after years and years.
IT already does
@@neldaalicialancastermoreno8431it really does..
So true ..
@Jacob Kay yeah...it pisses dany stans more
Not me this season is shit and its not cannon
when you see Catelyn and it says "and she never wanted to leave"
my heart
fuck Catelyn.
@@Gigusx just came to say that, fuck the bitch
@@Gigusx why?
@Волфсангел ok thanks , I never read the booka
@@Gigusx olmooonkk oj jinj. N
I miss you Game of Thrones.
IM A BIG FAN of the video you made for Dany! Literally one of the best videos I watched on Yt ❤️
How can anyone miss that post s6 garbage get real
Shame this show never got a Season 8
Season 8 is shit. This show don’t deserve that fucked end
@@appleratpipe He misses when it was quality
This song is gonna grow powerful over the years. Will bring a burst of nostalgic memories of GOT and events that aligned with your life.
this is actually so fucking real
Damn...so far you nailed it
Jamie: What about afterwards?
Bran: How do you know there is an afterwards?
Jamie: @_@
That's a death sentence right there
so we at least know Jamie's getting knocked off
Jaime will die protecting Bran and killing the Night's King, giving new meaning to the name "Kingslayer" That's my prediction
@@theonetruegriff Also I think he will become Azar Ahai by killing Cercei...
Jaime, Grey Worm, Theon, and Brienne are sooooo dead.
@@ivanbogdanovic5842 no, he does
Let's remember the journey, rather than the end
You have the most underrated comment in the whole section bro ❤️
Really touched my heart
Well said indeed. If i remember the journey i will one day rewatch GOT and enjoy it, though the last parts less so, but even in those there are good scenes and good actors.
I remember a lot of rob stark the character should not have died so mercilessly
Rob was my favourite he could have done a lot if he would have been alive
I wish everyone could understand this instead of just criticizing s8... the journey was epic
*Everyone this episode:* we’re all going to die.
*Tyrion:* I think we just might live..
Everyone- *laughs*
Watchout, that might be death flag for tyrion, or everyone else but tyrion
He said it after he talked to bran though. 😕
@@LILZINH0 bran cant see future tho. Only past and present
@@mehrabkhan1997 nah I'm pretty sure he can see the future slightly but it's very hard and can change at any time
I really hope House of the Dragon will bring back that feeling of early Game of Thrones seasons. I read Fire and Blood and the story is truly magnificent. Honour, death, love and family and every other aspect GOT made impeccable.
Respectfully, Ser, there is no story to Fire and Blood, its just a history. No dialogue, no POV characters, just a second hand recount of the fall of the Targs. If anyone on here thinks that's going to be akin to the first 4 seasons of GOT, then they surely haven't been paying attention....
@@jamien134 Respectfully, although there is no dialogue in the book there will be in the show and there is an possibility to bring back that early GOT feeling because dance with dragons is "game of thrones". If book is no story and just a history then they could just make an 10 episode documentary about the Targaryens. Looks like you haven't been paying attention.
Respectfully, I'm really curious and looking forward to how House of the Dragon will be in the future. But as a Fire and Blood reader, I know there are going to be a few elements missing in the HBO adaptation. The reason being is: the show doesn't start from the very beginning of Fire and Blood.
From the trailers I've watched, HBO starts House of the Dragon's story from the Dance of Dragons (the Targaryen civil war that killed all their dragons).
Well......all in all, whatever the shows gonna be in the future, I'll still watch it regardless of where it starts and give my opinion about it objectively. But that begs the question, though: If HBO is going to make a Game of Thrones sequel about the Targaryen house, why not start House of the Dragon (HOTD) from the very beginning? Why not start it from Aegon the Conqueror himself and his Conquest?
I mean......don't get me wrong.......Dance of Dragons is a pretty good story in itself. Personally, I like it. The story about a family being split into two, they fight each other nonstop for years, etc. It was a hell of a rollercoaster ride for me. I almost cried when Rhaenyra died in the end of the Dance. Really though, never thought I'd get emotional reading about a family feud that involves nations, wars, and dragons.
Back to topic, as a Fire and Blood reader, I feel that there are also many things that make the Targaryen history interesting rather than only the Dance of Dragons.
Aegon's Conquest; Aenys I and Maegor the Cruel's civil war (this is really tragic); King Jaeherys I's rule (my favorite Targaryen king after Aegon I); King Viserys I's rule and the evens prior to Dance of the Dragons.
Those are some events that transpired before Dance of the Dragons that have been written in Fire and Blood. And in my honest opinion, those events may be underrated compared to Dance of Dragons (sans Aegon's Conquest), but all of them have huge impacts in the Targaryen family.
Overall, just like I said, I don't really mind if HBO wants to start HOTD with Dance of Dragons. It's their show, not mine. I'm just a diehard house Targaryen fan with a question and trying to point out that there are many more tragic and impactful events that transpired before the Dance of Dragons. I just hope HOTD won't stray to far from the Fire and Blood book int terms of storyline. And hopefully, in the near distant future, there will be HOTD season 2 or something of the sort, and they adapt the many events before Dance of Dragons.
Seeing this comment after watching the first episode of HoD, I can't say it does!
@@samara.m584 Watch the second episode and then come back here...
We all are Jenny of Oldstones. When the series ends, in our minds we will keep dancing with the characters between the ruins of Winterfell and King's Landing, because we will never want to leave.
Bran: I am the memory of this world.
Every GOT fan: No kidding.
I'm crying with this comment because it's true.
Omg i had goosebumps after reading this
Crying inside .. .. nothing replace got and we always rember the north 😇😇😇😇
Great point. ❤️
S8E1: I am so pumped for this!
S8E2: I love this show so much!
S8E3 - I am not ready for this!!
My exact thought process, this is the one week I am not complaining about the wait, bc I know that I should enjoy them being together in my mind before it is changed forever.
@@Omega-yn7ex It's going to be brutal!
I'm already sad hahaha
More like:
1. Wow new season
2. Stop talking please, do something
3. Finally
@@amonara123 you don't deserve to be watching a show this good if that's your thought process :s
"And she never wanted to leave", the beginning of the end. I just loved how Ep 2 respected every character.
except for Varys. he got no credit at all, for the lord of the lights sake
@@gabrielatopczewska6784 well thats because we all know that she is going to live till the end of the season or episode 5. All characters (or almost all of them) in Winterfell might die in the next episode.
There's more emotion in this song than there was in the entirety of the final 2 seasons.
wahwahwah the show had a great ending but normies like you cant accept that
@@tehbombglides do you think chocolate milk comes from a brown cow
@@niofalpha lol i win and you lose hahaha caveman
@@tehbombglides Did you and i watch the same show?
@@niofalpha 😂😂😂🫡
This song is like, saying goodbye to many of our beloved characters.
This is so sad! :-(
Jaime is going to be killed, i can feel it.
I agree
@@IKIN_10 doubt it, what would be the point of the Bronn story arc
It is. A few of them will die in this battle. It reminded me when the titanic was sinking and they kept playing.
A man needs full length Podrick version of this song
HBO make this happen
"full length podrick." no i think a man does not need that! lmao!
A man needs to know what Podrick did with those prostitutes...
ClairReads He sang
A man has a point 💯
When she sings she never wanted to leave and cuts to Ned leaving Winterfell omfg im crying... 😭
This story is all about tragedy. Wherever and whenever you look in the books and series, people's lives are a tragedy of their own. For me, it's the deep message of the author, more than the question of war. This whole story just tells that everyone suffers and faces tragic events, decisions, actions, of their own or of someone else. A masterpiece which will mark our time and the 2010's, both the series and the books.
Could've shown Jon and Ygritte in the cave.
I think this whole song is from lyana Stark perspective 😅😅
@@meghasingh7195 you clearly dont know who Jenny of Oldstones is
Megha Singh lol no, this may have actually been song by Rheagar for Lyanna and is based on his uncle (feel in love with a common girl and gave up his crown)
I miss you, dear Game of Thrones.
It was the most unique show ever, gathered with friends every Sunday to watch every episode.
What an amazing experience it was. I love you GoT and I miss you
I watch it once or twice every year...bingewatch and yes it was one of the most unique shows ever.
The calm before the storm.
Ep2 was so wholesome. Bringing together so many characters almost as if to say it's their last night.
yep i really liked that it showed the human side of everyone. The characters sitting around the fire talking about the past and brienne becoming a knight was really beautiful and well executed. Although there isn't really so much happening in this episode it's one of my favourite.
It aint their last night it will just be a long night that they will have to survive
That's exactly what I think !!
Ep2 was one of the best episodes of them all. And the first really good episode after they surpassed the books...
This whole season has felt like a Disney movie so far not just because of the lack of violence thus far just the way it's been directed feels completely different
As a book reader, I'm so glad they included Jenny's song.
Her and the Prince of Dragonflies had one of the most tragic romances in Westeros.
This song is a fitting tribute
RedHeadRedemption agree! I was happy to hear Jenny’s song, :3
Is it really in the books? Any link to read the story of her?
@@sifisflisk7408 A Storm of Swords... Arya chapter in High Heart...
Also, like a lot of Thrones lore, it can be pieced together from a number of sources (including the World of Ice and Fire).
Prince Duncan (the Prince of Dragonflies) was the heir to the throne and set aside his claim in order to marry Jenny of Oldstones, a commoner.
This song refers to the Tragedy at Summerhall, where King Aegon V, Ser Duncan the Tall, and the Prince of Dragonflies died in flames.
Additionally, many of the wiki sites about Thrones lore are very informative
Neeeeeeeerd
Thanks for the happiest GOT episode ever guys.
Now we know what is coming next week.
we are so fucked damnit, episode 3 will fuck us up tremendously.
Next Episode:Calling of the Dead
Valar Morghulis
Death?
but we dont know how it is comin..
4 years after, April 2023 and this masterpiece randomly pops in my head.Nostalgic & I miss GOT, none other like it!
House of the dragon beats GOT any day at this point
Joe Biden is YOUR President.@@myturn926
@@myturn926definitely not. Don't be silly.
Fun Fact: Rhaegar sung this song at a royal tournament. It is said that this was the moment when Lyanna fell in love with Rhaegar. So basically, Jon was born because of this song. Excellent timing by introducing us to the song just moments before Jon tells Daenerys his origin at the grave of Lyanna!
I think he actually made her cry.
It's also written about Jon and Daenarys' ancestors. Duncan Targaryen "the dragonfly prince" and Jenny of Oldstones, the common born girl he gave up his throne to marry.
Some say he composed the song himself, turns out he was a musician.
@@ashlyns5746 yeah the song is about her..
Yeah, I've heard that too. Didn't he make her cry with that song?
That is GoT. With this song, it says goodbye. Goodbye to the things we knew and the characters we've been rooting for all these years. It is a way of making us realise this is the end. In a beatiful way.
Thank you GoT.
Your words are killing me 😢
This is exactly what the song represents. Not for the battles or the deaths. But the conclusion of 8 years of tears, laughs, suspense, love, torture, beauty, and memories.
Thank you Game of Thrones.
And she neeeever wanted to leaaaaaave
@@AprilTVru ...WE never wanted THEM to leave..(just another interpretation)..
Yep we are the ones dancing with the characters and we never want them to leave 😭
Season 8 episode 2. The last episode we saw all these characters together...
And the first
Seriously. I have a sinking feeling next week mofos start dropping like flies.
First and last of its name
I hope not 😭😭
I love them all and I'm not prepared for this
@@bagup_alpharetards noone is prepared for this, maybe even R.R. Martyn isnt.
If only they stuck the landing, this would have gone down as probably the greatest thing that ever hit tv.
Got is still top 3 or top 5 thing to ever hit tv considering all things 😍
It is still considered the greatest thing to ever hit tv.
Everyone : serious strategizing
Tormund : we're going to die
Also Tormund : GIANT'S MILK
Indra Servo 🤣🤣🤣
The big woman still here?
I killed the giant and slept with his wife
Loool
the ''never wanted to leave'' parts got me bawling my eyes out
Me too, it hurts so bad
Yeah it’s like unknowingly tears roll down!!
Yeah, so sad
X2
Same. Just stomp on my heart... 😭
Chills. This song should win an Emmy.
Heartbreaking yet so beautiful.
you mean a grammy?
@@Willbo_Swaggins97 thank you. Came to correct it.
you mean a jenny?
You mean an elephant?
Made by Georges RR Martin. Such a genius
I still come back to this masterpiece years later. It never gets old.
You will forever be written on our hearts Theon.
What Is Dead May Never Die!
But rises again harder and stronger...
I finally understand that quote...
@@madziorki24 do you know what doesn't rise?
@@minoites1313 Staph xD
@@mrmeow5446 and he paid dearly for that and made amends, it's called redemption. He died protecting Bran ffs
The scene with Brianne made me cry like nothing else in a long time. She's the embodiement of honor, justice and fairness.
Yes! Even your comment stirred the emotions! God damn man, an honorable life is the way.
It was so lovely finally seeing her smile
I agree, & when she smiled, I balled my eyes out like a baby
Too bad she's gonna die next episode.
Arcosian Cosine i think the same. Now her journey comes to an end. Hope Jaime stays with her in the moment of death.
This song is everything.
1. It's a final farewell to Game Of Thrones.
2. A tribute to Lord of the Rings as Pippin sung a similar song before Boromir's father.
3. A tribute and nod to all book readers and fans of Dunk & Egg's stories
Or to the Misty Mountains of the hobbit
Farimir*
Reamusray Faramir*
@@reamusray790 It's pretty much the same, since Boromir and Faramir were brothers :)
Anyway, I'm happy that more people thought of Pippin while listening to Podrick.
This song is just magic
the saddest thing is that catelyn will never know jon is not
a Ned's bastard son.
She was such a bitch about it, so its ok
Yeah Ned was wrong by keeping secrets within his own family. Ultimately that secret caused a lot of hurt both for Cat and Jon.
@@AlasEtéreas he had to. To fool one's enemies, one needs to fool loved one's first. Also, by not telling her he protected her as well. Should she have known, in case of her being captured, enemies of house Stark could have tortured her to gain knowledge about Jon's true identity. Ned couldn't have had let that happen.
naphaneal I also think Ned probably knew that if he told Catelyn the truth, she might some day let it slip because of her desire to make it known she was not a cuckolded wife and that Ned was faithful to her, even by accident. So he couldn’t risk it. All in all, there were several reasons to stay silent
Well, in the books she's not dead...
Everyone: how much goosebumps will you give us?
HBO: YES
HBO: How many can you get?
after reading this: none :D
Everyone: The 1st episode game me goosebumps!
HBO: Hold my bear!
“All Daenerys wanted back was the big house with the red door, the lemon tree outside her window, the childhood she had never known.”
oh god please stop i'm crying
@Joseph Stalin Stop beeing such an asshold
😢
STOOOPPPPPP I HATE JON SNOW FOREVER NOW.
@Joseph Stalin Just because season 8 was terrible doesn't make book!Dany's story any less sad.
I have just finished re-watching the whole series again and here i am crying again
*Wipes a tear*
This was goodbye, isn't it?
Antonio Francisco Magaña Gómez iam not crying. You are crying 😢
Yes. Death is coming
A decade, a decade of GOT. I almost feel similar to how I felt before my dad died, I'm just not ready. This show has made me feel emotions I've never had evoked from watching a show on TV. I've read the books and watched every season 3 times and I'm still not ready to say goodbye, but as you so well put it. This was goodbye.
It is...
It's goodbye
1:36 "From winter to summer and winter again." basically sums up the time we had to wait for season 8 :D
The show is back now. Find new jokes.
@@SuperMelvin555 damn, who shat into your breakfast
here in europe summer is about to start
Wod Katiten It was also the time that Game if thrones took place during
Mondo Kantables Winter is coming
I think we can all agree that this easily the best thing to come out of GoT season 8.
TV4Fun2 hounds death pretty good as well tbf the only scripting d+b got right
@@Cardiebee123 seriously? "Cleganebowl" was one of the most pointless bits of fanwank ever. The hound's death by fire was just one more check in a box that fit into the surrounding narrative about as naturally as a pickle in an ice cream sandwich.
And Ramin Djawadis ever-so-epic masterful score.
TV4Fun2 completely agree just the scene on its own was well written only the hound vs mountain though the queens guard and the hands death was just stupid
The only good thing
I don't care what people say about the show. Three years later this randomly comes up, I watch it and it still brings me to tears.
Predictions for next week:
• Dark
• Full of Terrors
After this episode? It will be terrifying.
The night is dark and full of terror
Beware, for the night is dark and full of spoilers
Whilst I'm writing this your like are 666, the devil works hard, but I work harder, 667 now! 😂😂
Melissandra did say she would come back from asshai to die in westeros.....just like varys.....
God I hate it when the show blatantly spoils
That was a tragic farewell for an episode... Good voice Podric...
Nobody:
Bran: The things we do for love
three eyed raven idiot
Nobody:
Jaime: Fucks sister in a tower
@david check above your head, you missed a joke flying by
@@Mankind5490 I think he was making a joke of his own
You guys are doing this meme wrong. The fact that "nobody" said nothing is a double negative. It should be "Everybody"
Got goosebumps when I heard this first time and it's giving me the same so far.
It will always give you
With this song, we can basically feel the end.
Jarvis i’m afraid this is a goodbye video to so many characters... we will see sunday.
Bran : "I can't be a lord of winterfell, I'm a three eyed raven."
Also Bran : "I'll take the crown."
BrAn ThE BrOkEn
🤢
Exaclty. King of Westeros isn’t the Lord of Winterfell now is it? 😉
Sultan PlOt TwIsT
@@midnitest0rm No it's not. North is a new kingdom.
Sultan that’s what I’m saying.
Episode 2 was made to make us love the characters more than ever before. So that when they die (possibly in the next episode) it would absolutely kill us. THANKS DAVID AND DAN!
Music makes it harder
I think it was to have their final moments of happiness before facing death. I mean the Starks didn't see each other since episode 1 so now they are all there
I though the same
The next episode will be so painfull !
@@FitzChevalry 1 of few to come
This video having comments with so many likes in such a short time only confirms how big the fandom is and the legacy that the show left. GOT, you will always be famous.
A perfect Farewell Song, I think it describes every GoT fan right now. What an incredibly beautiful song . Thank you for this piece of art !
thanks for calling me beautiful bro.. i am sure u r beautiful too
I love you guys
half the cast will die lol
It's even sadder when you know the backstory about Jenny of Oldstones and Duncan Targaryen
Such a beautiful song. Florence has the most haunting voice, just perfect for this song. Podrick's version is just as gorgeous too.
I had NO IDEA it was her until this popped up in my suggestions! I’m so happy to have found out!
Florence is amazing. She has the voice that is perfect for these medieval melodramas. There's so much emotion in it.
She doesn't have a magical cock though.
Season 8 episode 2: "FUN"
Season 8 episode 3:
"FUN-ERAL"
I laughed whenever they said "you'll be safe in the crypt".
True shit
Hahahah idk why made me crack up
Hahhaah
@@NateThe_Great24 It still blows my mind that they actually think being in the crypt is safe.
They surely won't be slaughtered by the resurrected Stark skeletons... Other than that, if they lose the battle or they need to retreat to Pyke, they will be utterly fucked in the crypts anyway, even if the night king decides to not raise the dead for whatever reason. In that case either the army will break into the crypts or they will starve to death.
This video is absolutely all over the place, and it's simultaneously equally devastating and fantastic. Why can it hurt me so good?
It is your story.
Our history.
@@CloudNoctis1 ?
"The ones who'd been gone
For so very Long "..... and Dany looking at Sir Jorah.....
*Damn. You broke my heart in Two*
The friend zone was never stronger
Ayy FR he loved her and died for her, but never got to be with her 😥😥💔. It kills me to see it happen.
@@TheBiakko Freinds can be much better and more loyal than lovers. This is a soild fact...
Amer Kanatri from the POV of the one who is not in love, sure...
Vitalyon yeah she needed him back to fill the friendzone
I don't know if I want to see episode 3 it's going to be crushing
Same with my boyfriend's cousin. Her favorite character was Rob.
u female right?
@@qckndrty1 yes, I am
Gotta wait a week anyway😫
what if the night king isn't coming to fight the north?
I just can't stop listening to it. Her voice gets under my skin.
Check out Pod singing it.
Felt like some sort of a homage to the characters. Plenty are going to die next episode, it's going to be horrifying and emotional but still exciting. The Night's King is probably going to kill everyone in the crypt and raise them along with the already dead. If Jon had to meet his mother as a zombie... Jesus.
I prefer Podrick's version though
Her voice gets into the bone marrow
You do realise the phrase “gets under my skin” means something is annoying. So why do you keep listening.
Even after watching entire show multiple times (including the end), this song still gives me goosebumps.
This one and Billy Boyd singing Edge of Night really are something special.
@@glacialimpala yes both the songs are full of strong emotions. LOTR and GOT both are masterpieces.
Mark my words. Next Monday we will come back to this video and cry our eyes out.
I already did.
I'll gladly do it again.
I started to cry yesterday, just in case
We will.
Im already cryinnnggg
Lets cry together as men..
Everyone meet here next week to mourn our beloved characters
As now their watch begins 😣😣
I suspect we'll need this far more four weeks from now.
their*
The Hoopman oh God
Agreed. Anyone else in favor?
More like,”and now their watch has ended.”
This song hurts in so many ways. It's a wound that'll never fully heal.
And will bleed again on a slightest word...
Then its a scar
@@nedavucicevic1585 because of what those two assholes did to the show?
@@aquere calling them assholes is a disgrace to all assholes around the world
Just like the last season!
I liked the whole series, even the ending. This song is beautiful, and nothing takes away the great memories I made while I watched it. ❤️
They grabbed our hearts with this episode. Next episode they’ll rip it out.
Snatched my soul with this Episode....
Truth.
Dylan Stump so true
Very true! That's how a life is... !
Iam not crying. You are crying.
Nobody died yet, but i'm already crying. Never would've thought a TV series could become so important to me.
The Umbers died.
Same here.
Being a fan is a deep spiritual experience. Although it breaks your heart it's worth it.
You should read the books
@@anf7285 but do I look like a fucking Umber to you ?? #ramsaybolton
musicians battle for the song of the year.
Podrick : hold my beer
Hold his "half cup" of wine too. :-)
Melissa Blackwood lol
More like:
Pordrick: Hold my super cock
@@mohanadhamadeh9821 magic cock*
This song was composed by Rhaegar Targaryen you know.
Wow. Even after all this time I still get chills from hearing her voice
So How much emotion should we add to this song?
GoT Team: Yes
Jaskaran Singh If there would be more emotion in this song, it would steal even more tears from us.
I never understand that meme can someone please explain it to moi? Please?
@@InsideJungle What's a few tears more?
@@mattcruse495 It's an absurdist version of simply answering "more" to the same question. indicating that there is no upper limit. Making it absurdist makes it work better as a joke because answering "yes" is more nonsensical than "more" which could be meaningful in certain contexts. With "yes" it's clear nonsense since it doesn't match the question, and so the question is the setup for the joke, demanding an answer with fixed parameters, but instead of the expected meaningful answer to the question we get nonsense, but nonsense that still carries meaning that is easily to parse. So we get an answer that both subverts out dialectical expectation and indicates that the situation should be more extreme than what was even conceived of as being possible with the parameters of the original question. And it's a fairly simple joke, so it works well as a meme and can be transcribed to almost any other context. And now that i have explained the joke in this much detail, there is a good chance that it will never be funny to you anyway. Sorry about that :)
@@ejensen it means if the answer is yes, the one who asking will do whatever he/she wants
I feel like someone needs to overlay pod's version of the song with Florence's version, I think it would be a beautiful harmony/duet
I agree, but not via an overlay.
And stretching the audio to play in sink will sound horrendous...
I agree
@@GrasshopperKelly "Sync", as in synchronous. Not "sink" as in "in the bathroom sink".
I think they should have just had him sing it to be honest.
Someone already did. Florence + Podrick collaboration look it up.
Endgame : Whatever It Takes
GoT : Never wanted to leave
Pijush A Sinha Return of the King: The Edge of Night
Gandalf : Prepare For Battle
The 10th Doctor: I Don't Want to Go
And now it begins
Helms Deep battle!
Always remember this show. No other could ever match it. The best for ever and ever.
Nop
First 4 seasons, sure.
Every season HBO did was great. I loved the ending. LOVED it. That girl needed killed off. She was pure evil. R.R made it right. Cheers.
Episode 2 : Not a single death
Episode 3 : Hold my beer...
Hodor: Hold the door :(
😭😭😭 I'm not ready!
*wine
@@l.a.picasa me neither... :'( bad things are coming
All of last harth and the last of house umber :/
Next year we'll be back watching this video and still crying over most of these characters' deaths. ^ 💔
next week, not year :P
But we're all going to die
I am having anxiety attacks thinking of next week's episode!! Please have mercy on GOT!!
I would love few skull crushing brutal deaths😋😍. Long time since I saw one in GOT.
Next year we'll be back listening to this song and will cry because Game Of Thrones won't be on anymore.
#NeverWantedToLeave
*Beautiful song.* It's like a funeral song for all the people who died in the show.
epSos.de who WILL die next week ^^
and for all who is gonna die
only Bran will survive, and he will write their story.. the others will all die..@@barthpaleologue
For the ones who die in episode 3
It means that they all are gonna die?? Hope not!
its 2022 Oct, still get goosebumps listening to this masterpiece. GOT will forever , i mean forever be my favorite TV series. even HOTD is good. but GOT was so strongly written , portrayed. i love every inch of this series, no matter the ending .
i miss you Game Of Thrones.
See you here next monday my friends...
Why do you all believe most will die??
how do you now there is going to be a next monday?
@@kerrfal cuz it's fucking game of thrones dude,everyone dies xD
KolTony nah we had that scene for feons redemption and he will now die protecting bran to fulfil his redemption
We are all going to get our hearts ripped out next week.
Podrick be like, "The world's gonna end.. lemme drop my soundcloud link real fast."
LOL
Lmao
i currently crying as i like comments bc the episode was too much
so... you just decided to steal a tweet and leave it on the yt comments.
@@ana-oq4go probably one of the most emotional episodes yet since we sorta know what's coming
THIS is how you build up a battle. Best part this isn’t even the finale.
That was my first reaction as well. It sounds so similar to it.
How can episode 4 5 6 top the emotional out come of 2 & 3
yeah but after finale there is nothing more, not like this... so sad
The song is not about the battle we are having next episode. Thats the trick.
@@juanmanuel2659 this song is to set peoples emotuons on fire. It tells the whole story of Game of Thrones minus the deaths. Fans will have this song to look back on, during the enternal night with out game of thrones
I watch it every once in a while to remember what a great show this is
This clip is just brilliant. Jamie leaving Cersei and 'Never wanted to leave' in the background. Same with Ned leaving Catelyn at the Bran's bed. This very phrase says so much about all the characters. Ned who never wanted to be a King's Hand in the far South and Jamie who loved his sister till he realised she's a monster.
Dr Mietek he always knew what she was and loved her anyway
@@serenayale9729 Right. He left her cause he isn't the oathbreaker anymore and 'promised to fight for the living'. So as she did
That’s Jon leaving after saying goodbye to Bran, no?
@@serenayale9729 the worst part about it is that cersei never loved him. it's so one sided, im so glad Jamie realized his worth after all the character development he's gone through. He deserves better then her and he's literally found someone better then cersei: Brienne.
freecitizen_explorer684 Cersei only saw him as a extension of herself. But he truly loved her and remained faithful to her. It is sad really
"One of the saddest things is Rob will never know how regretful Theon was for betraying him" :(((( man it hurts
So true!!!! One of the best comments..
and theon died thinking they'd lost
It’s sad he died no doubt hating theon. When the main reason robb wanted to defeat the Lannister’s was to save Sansa. I’m sure robb, ned and even catelyn would’ve been beyond grateful for he did for the stark children
Fuck Theon that cockless betrayer.
@@ShaneshaS she may find out in the books though.
April 2020. One year. Still hurts.
Same. Just been rewatching lots of clips and scenes from last seasons. The pain is still unbearable. :-(
Clone wars, it ended with a good episode unlike got 😭
It hurts badly more than the pandemic does 😥
A lot.....still hurts a lot
Crazy to think it’s already been a year since
I finished all 8 seasons yesterday. This series is a heart healer. I enjoyed watching this series for the past two months. I'm missing this now. I'm missing that all seasons ended nd there is no more got to watch. This series made me to forget that I'm lonely.
GOT-S8-E2 The Most Emotionally Happiest Episode
....In the history of TV series, i think.
And what you think about next??, totally opposite
I like to think it as the LAST emotionally happiest. The calm before the Storm.
One of my favourites of the series. Top 10 for sure
Bilal Hassan sadest
That Catelyn Stark scene with the lyric "she never wanted to leave" kills me, very deep.
@John Smith agreed. Her acting in the red wedding episode just took it to another level
Michelle fairly as cat was the best choice o am glad they recasted like holy hell thank the gods her and Sean where perfect although both deny that they actually bonded on the show Michelle gush’s about Richard Madden and how she bonded with him and Sean loved massie and Sophie but they both deny bonding much with each other either there both extremely great at acting cuz we get there whole relationship in 6 part they have less then 10 mins of screen time together but everyone ships them hardcore to this day. Or there is a mass cover up for. Something they actually really had because I am not buying her and Sean bean never interacted much cuz it’s just to get if chemistry .
I can’t believe Brienne being knighted brought a tear to me eye.
Next episode will make the Red Wedding look like a warm-up!😭😭😭
Me too, I literally cried
me too
Pussies. Cant wait for them all to die.
Tormund could have done that 10 times hahahah
It better not
More than three years later and this still brings tears to my eyes.
It's good to be back in the ASOIAF world. Hopefully House of the Dragon reaches the heights Game of Thrones did. The first episode was fantastic.
edit after the HotD season 1 finale: It, in fact, did match up. Ladies and gents, WE'RE BACK.
Yeah i also like the first episot of HOTD
but it lacks that sweet family feeling that was there in GOT
So far so good.
I will never forgive David and Dan for what they did
@@dannycarrier612 They could of easily gave the show to other writers if they were feeling fatigue . Instead they wanted all the glory and ruined it.
@@ultimatemayh3m768 I don’t think they could contractually, George locked them into creating all the episodes. They just wanted to rush it and go on to Star Wars(which was a complete shit show).
The footage when Podrick sung this song was the best in the tv business. Take a bow HBO.
100%
Bhushan Kadam they took the idea from lord of the rings which I am very great full for thank you GOT
Great nod to lotr return of the king pippins song.
Finally a Game of Thrones song that is not related to massive murder. Just absolutely heartbreaking.
Okay, so I just learned about what the song it is. And when I heard it again, this time I cried a lot more. It's a sad story, but unlike Light of Seven or Rains of Castamere, it's way more tragic and relatable. Poor Jenny.
The Ghost of Winterfell I got some bad news for you chief. This song is about the Tragedy of Summerhall: the doomed love of Jenny and Duncan, the false hope of righteous King Aegon, and the tears of the Ghost of High Heart, remembering the pain of it all.
AHGaming Oh dammit. But still, beautiful.
The Ghost of Winterfell “let her savour her song in peace. It is all she has left”
the bear and the maiden fair isn't about voilence
@@AGH2401 that was an accident and a tragedy, not a butchery. So for Game of Thrones it is somehow joyful... but in the end it is just sad. We're living the end of an era. Game of Thrones era.
I have to admit, i have never been more anxious and hyped about a TV show or Movie in my entire life, than i am for these remaining episodes of GOT
Me too.
Knowing your favourite character will most likely die. That sucks 😞
@@jackmurphy914 true. Thats life
#MeeToo
Jack Murphy Actor right? All my fave characters have made it this far but I know they won’t be here long. The only one I know will live is Arya since George always said it was his and his wife’s fave and he won’t kill her off
Say what you want about the last season but the music never fails, 3 years later and i’m still tearing up over this song especially when you know the context of duncan targaryen and jenny