I recently just finished the Cardcaptor Sakura manga and have been discussing it with a friend of mine, but they've only experienced the anime. So thank you for making this video in order to help the both of us.
I've watched the anime so many times and read the manga at least 4 times and yeah, I'm happy to see that I've noticed all of those things 😎 Great video !
2:42 I spat out my drink in shock at this line! 😂 I've only seen the anime and was thinking about reading the manga and I think that line alone has convinced me-
Here are a few small changes: Two are in the final battle against Eriol. Just like the anime, Syaoran helps Sakura channel her magic, but he ends up passing out too, leaving Sakura alone. I perfer this. In the opposite case, Fujitaka does not fall asleep due to being half of Clow Reed's reincarnation. Next, Tomoyo is also not present when Sakura makes the first Sakura Card. Again, I pefer this because poor Tomoyo (and too a lesser extent, Melling, but I do like her) was such a repeated victim of the card in the anime. Maybe it's just the much higher card count, but the anime also puts much more emphasis on Sakura collapsing after making Sakura cards, making it a bit more dramatic. I feel like, bar the first time, it's glossed over in the manga. Side note, but I really didn't like the addition of the Sleep card in the anime after reading the manga, it made things too easy and convenient. Meanwhile, I perfer Nadeshiko healing Sakura in the anime. It's more meaningful and impactful, but I like both versions. I just like the "dead mum cliche" was slightly played with via her ghost, though more in the anime. Ok, I'm going to stop comparing them now and say that I love both. It was ny first true venture into manga and anime (I adored magical girls as a wain and still do) and they still hold a special place in my heart. I actively sought out the sub and manga. The Nelvana dub, DBZ, "Yu-Gi-Oh", and "Pokémon" don't count IMO, due to how Americanised they are. The Nelvana dub became a gulity pleasure because of childhood enjoyment.
Excellent video Didn't know clow reed gave up his magic to sakuras dad only went back after watching all of CCS and Clear Card. You could almost say the timeskip is a preface for the clear card series. Hope they get to finishing CCS Clear Card Season 2 soon bit annoying having to read the rest of the story in the manga. I assume there's differences between Clear Card in manga and anime form as well?
CCS honestly as been puzzling me, even more more now that iv'e just completed my first read of the books...in there, Eriol tells Sakura that he waited since Clow's death for her in his 10 years old form for her to become the mistress of the cards.... How about her dad which is the other half of Reed. How does he not remember wandering for so long... At least a century i think.... Was he in stasis and then woke up at the right time? Then met Nadeshiko? Like yukito, he doesnt remember any family.... How did yukito get a house? How did Fujitaka became a legal citizen if he was born from magic without powers? How could the Reed estate stays empty for sooo long while Eriol was in england.... Or was he hiding in there all along?how did yukito enrolled at school out of nowhere? So much unanswered questions...
Great video! I love this kind of thing - even if I'm not that familiar with either version. Really makes me wonder about some of the changes, and why they make them. I guess there'd be a lot of reasons. Easier to animate/more visually appealing, 'um how about no pedophillia in our show for little girls'. To be a fly on the wall in those decision rooms though.. Real interesting stuff! Do you have a preferred version?
Yes! I like the anime better to be honest. It's really the only adaptation of a CLAMP manga that I think improved upon the source material, rather than failing to do it justice (such as the chobits' anime for example). Just the original anime and two movies that go with it though. The clear card arc anime is its own ball of confusion and disappointment. It's probably best to stick to the manga for that.
now I know where I got those information 😂 last year I re-watched the anime after 20-ish years. then after finished, I talked with myself like, "wasn't Sakura's father a part of Clow Reed or something?", "didn't Sakura give him a bear?", "didn't Syaoran confess in the playground?" I felt like I didn't watch all episodes, something is missing. But now I know why 😂😂😂 Because I borrowed the comics from an indie library 20 years ago. I don't have the comics which I plan to have now 😂😂 Thank you for the information!
UGH I HATE THE TEACHER.. like Rikka is a little kid so I don’t blame her, but the teacher is so weird.. ALSO I ONLY WATCHED THE ANIME… THIS INFORMATION WOULD HAVE BEEN SO USEFUL? 😭😭😭 7:22
I was so looking forward to this video cause it was needed due to the differences within the two, however your pronunciation of different characters name makes the video lose all the amazing information. You provided amazing information but stating their names rather English or Japanese is very bad.
I recently just finished the Cardcaptor Sakura manga and have been discussing it with a friend of mine, but they've only experienced the anime. So thank you for making this video in order to help the both of us.
Thanks for enjoying the video. \(^-^)/
tbh this is a masterpiece when you realize how deeply connected to xxxHolic and Tsubasa Reservoir this is
I've watched the anime so many times and read the manga at least 4 times and yeah, I'm happy to see that I've noticed all of those things 😎
Great video !
2:42 I spat out my drink in shock at this line! 😂 I've only seen the anime and was thinking about reading the manga and I think that line alone has convinced me-
Here are a few small changes:
Two are in the final battle against Eriol.
Just like the anime, Syaoran helps Sakura channel her magic, but he ends up passing out too, leaving Sakura alone. I perfer this. In the opposite case, Fujitaka does not fall asleep due to being half of Clow Reed's reincarnation.
Next, Tomoyo is also not present when Sakura makes the first Sakura Card. Again, I pefer this because poor Tomoyo (and too a lesser extent, Melling, but I do like her) was such a repeated victim of the card in the anime.
Maybe it's just the much higher card count, but the anime also puts much more emphasis on Sakura collapsing after making Sakura cards, making it a bit more dramatic. I feel like, bar the first time, it's glossed over in the manga.
Side note, but I really didn't like the addition of the Sleep card in the anime after reading the manga, it made things too easy and convenient.
Meanwhile, I perfer Nadeshiko healing Sakura in the anime. It's more meaningful and impactful, but I like both versions. I just like the "dead mum cliche" was slightly played with via her ghost, though more in the anime.
Ok, I'm going to stop comparing them now and say that I love both.
It was ny first true venture into manga and anime (I adored magical girls as a wain and still do) and they still hold a special place in my heart. I actively sought out the sub and manga.
The Nelvana dub, DBZ, "Yu-Gi-Oh", and "Pokémon" don't count IMO, due to how Americanised they are. The Nelvana dub became a gulity pleasure because of childhood enjoyment.
Great additions. Your absolutely right that the sleep card just being added for convenience. XD
I like most of the changes the anime made honestly.. 😅 But I would still keep some details of the manga..
Excellent video Didn't know clow reed gave up his magic to sakuras dad only went back after watching all of CCS and Clear Card. You could almost say the timeskip is a preface for the clear card series. Hope they get to finishing CCS Clear Card Season 2 soon bit annoying having to read the rest of the story in the manga. I assume there's differences between Clear Card in manga and anime form as well?
CCS honestly as been puzzling me, even more more now that iv'e just completed my first read of the books...in there, Eriol tells Sakura that he waited since Clow's death for her in his 10 years old form for her to become the mistress of the cards.... How about her dad which is the other half of Reed. How does he not remember wandering for so long... At least a century i think.... Was he in stasis and then woke up at the right time? Then met Nadeshiko? Like yukito, he doesnt remember any family.... How did yukito get a house? How did Fujitaka became a legal citizen if he was born from magic without powers? How could the Reed estate stays empty for sooo long while Eriol was in england.... Or was he hiding in there all along?how did yukito enrolled at school out of nowhere? So much unanswered questions...
And clear card is not answering them. (T-T)
@@otaple too bad!
Let's just go with Clow reed did it. Did what? Exactly
i dont know why but i liked the anime more than the manga (I read the manga but I still like it better)
Waahhh... 2003 I've watched anime ccs and ngayon ko lang ito nalaman utong pagkakaiba ng manga at anime!
I like the original manga the most
Great video!
I love this kind of thing - even if I'm not that familiar with either version. Really makes me wonder about some of the changes, and why they make them. I guess there'd be a lot of reasons. Easier to animate/more visually appealing, 'um how about no pedophillia in our show for little girls'. To be a fly on the wall in those decision rooms though.. Real interesting stuff! Do you have a preferred version?
Yes! I like the anime better to be honest. It's really the only adaptation of a CLAMP manga that I think improved upon the source material, rather than failing to do it justice (such as the chobits' anime for example). Just the original anime and two movies that go with it though. The clear card arc anime is its own ball of confusion and disappointment. It's probably best to stick to the manga for that.
now I know where I got those information 😂 last year I re-watched the anime after 20-ish years. then after finished, I talked with myself like, "wasn't Sakura's father a part of Clow Reed or something?", "didn't Sakura give him a bear?", "didn't Syaoran confess in the playground?" I felt like I didn't watch all episodes, something is missing. But now I know why 😂😂😂 Because I borrowed the comics from an indie library 20 years ago. I don't have the comics which I plan to have now 😂😂 Thank you for the information!
❤ this!
UGH I HATE THE TEACHER.. like Rikka is a little kid so I don’t blame her, but the teacher is so weird.. ALSO I ONLY WATCHED THE ANIME… THIS INFORMATION WOULD HAVE BEEN SO USEFUL? 😭😭😭 7:22
Ok, but why Cyran tho? xd
I'm sorry, it's so distracting...
does sakura get married in the manga ?
Nope. They are together but we don't get to see them as adults. So fans just logically assume they get married someday.
@@otaple thx ur so sweet for replying.
Could u plz make a list of marriage at end happy ending romance anime like inuyasha ,pardise kiss also manga
@@sakuraistrash2much Not sure about their anime counterparts but Fruits Basket, Spice and Wolf (novel) and Kamisama Kiss come to mind.
One difference is the man ga is a book lol😂
I was so looking forward to this video cause it was needed due to the differences within the two, however your pronunciation of different characters name makes the video lose all the amazing information. You provided amazing information but stating their names rather English or Japanese is very bad.
Man the Manga sucks.