Universal Audio Apollo vs Presonus Quantum | Do Audio Converters Make a Difference?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 гру 2021
- Gear I have in my studio. I get all my gear at Sweetwater. (affiliate links). Thank you for supporting my channel!
SSL Origin - imp.i114863.net/4edbBZ
SSL Fusion - imp.i114863.net/EaqG92
SSL UF-8 DAW Controller - imp.i114863.net/qnAXGn
SSL UC-1 - imp.i114863.net/QOJ3xY
Empirical Labs Distressor - imp.i114863.net/rngeK3
U/A Apollo x16 - imp.i114863.net/BXKrYL
Switchcraft Patch Bay - imp.i114863.net/doLjrQ
Wes Audio NG Bus Comp - imp.i114863.net/6bexvE
Wes Audio Titan - imp.i114863.net/EaKyQ4
Wes Audio Dione - imp.i114863.net/b3aVRx
Black Lion Audio Bluey - imp.i114863.net/e4rdG1
This channel is all about my journey of setting up and mixing in an analog / hybrid fashion. Come with me as I purchase and set up all the gear that is involved with my studio. If you are into hybrid and/or an analog workflow then welcome!
I also have a website with more content & my mixing services
www.mixingmusicanalog.com
For more mixing, mastering, recording training visit
www.homerecordingmadeeasy.com
If you are interested in learning how to mix music using a DAW and plugins only then check out my mixing membership "Mixing Made Easy".net.
www.mixingmadeeasy.net
For "in the box" mixing, mastering, plugin demos etc.. visit my UA-cam channel
/ homerecordingmadeeasy
Where I get all of my gear, Sweetwater of course! They have the very best customer service in the business! The next time you need anything for your studio, please consider using my affiliate link below. You don't pay a penny more and you are helping support what I do here. I thank you in advance!
imp.i114863.net/c/2224454/792...
If you mix "all in the box", check out my online training which includes a FREE 90 min mixing course. www.homerecordingmadeeasy.com
Whoa! I really enjoyed your video. You did a great job setting up this comparison and you are concise with your dialogue. I'm very much looking forward to the follow up video.
Keep up the great content!
Wow, thank you!
Another thing to keep in mind is that when you run a mix through a console 2 times in a row, the SSL components could react slightly different between the two passes. Analog gear does that as well
Great video as always! Very honest and informative! Thank you so very much!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Hey Dave please Keep up the great work your doing in 2022, God Bless you and Merry Christmas and have a Blessed New Year.
Thank you my friend. We will see how things go on this channel moving forward.
Thanks Dave, a great comparison and I feel personally that using your ears for the gear rather than looking at the marketing goes a long way. Great video as ever!
It sure does and 99% of people don't get that concept. If I told everyone which was which I would be most people would say the Apollo sounded best because of the price tag. Its human nature....LOL
@@MixingMusicAnalog right? On topic but different scenario, I recently got an Apollo usb in great condition for $350, so I couldn’t pass it up. Of course they send you all of these coupons and I wanted to dive into buying a bunch, but held off as I demoed a variety from other developers as well, so I could hopefully only get the ones that there are no replacement for. Honestly, in the end, UAD had some better offerings in some plugs, but some others sounded better to my ear as well at half the cost. Just had to keep reminding myself that just because UAs are more expensive doesn’t inherently make them all better than the competition.
@@MixingMusicAnalog Im Still rockin 2 x Original FW Apogee ensembles (still work under 10.14 and thus far 11.. Thanks to Core Audio System wide drivers)....They still sound 'most excellent" Thats my excuse.
@@MixingMusicAnalog I don't know which was which ( Presonus or Apollo) and I'm an Apollo x8p owner. I do know that "very" slightly #2 sounded better to me and I was listening in my studio. Contrary to what someone else said, A person that is trained to listen will hear a difference. Now whether that difference is preferable or not to the other is a matter of personal taste. But as I said I know which sounded better to my ear. I'd love to know which was which.
Great preparation and presentation, Dave!
Thank you!
Great reference video, understandable education, easy to understand an relatable. I appreciate the knowledge!
Peace an blessings be upon you!
Much appreciated Thank you for your support!
I use RME fireface 800s. I bought a Quantum for my live rig and love it. I would have no issue recording and mixing with them. They are amazing!
Thanks for sharing!
Thanks great video. I think the differences are very slight, although I did hear a slight difference in the mid frequencies. Mix 1 was a little warmer around 3k-5k, and mix 2 was a little thinner
Interesting!
Loved the test!! I couldn’t tell the difference and have no idea which is which hahaha but that’s good I guess so that there’s not a quality difference! I would definitely sell the Apollo’s and buy 2 Of the presonus so I have money to buy some outboard gear such as effects units!!! Great video and loved how in depth you went with it. Thank you!!! Merry Christmas!!
Thanks for watching!
I’m at my day job right now listening to this on my iPhone earbuds and if I CAN’T notice the difference at all between both of them through these earbuds were I listen to music everyday and I already know if a mix is good or not than PreSonus is doing a great job. When I get back to my studio I’ll give this video a second listen through my studio monitors.
Thank you for these types of videos. I wanted someone to compare that Quantum to a higher end converter.
I got the Quantum 26x32 which is $999 and to me the conversion is great but the best part of these Quantums is the total integration with Studio One. They are built to be controlled mainly through Studio One. You barely have to enter Universal Control.
If you end up getting 2 Quantums I would highley recommend buying an external Word Clock so you Can push those converters to it’s limits. Get the Black Lion Audio Micro Clock MKIII XB Master Clock.
Thanks again.
Ok, thanks
Love the set up guys. This set of videos really helped me make up my mind to upgrade my ageing firewire Focusrite interfaces (Liquid Saffire 56, Saffire pro 40 and Octapre) which I use to plug all my hardware synths into so that I can use them like 'plug ins'. I recently purchased a new M1 MacBook Pro Max which Focusrite are no longer supporting, driver wise (the infuriating cause of all my interface de-commissions!). Ended up with the Quantum 2626 which is a great value proposition and seeing you guys happy to convert the input/output of a ~£40k SSL desk really makes the case that these quantum interfaces are disrupting the traditional high end audio game. The cherry on the cake is the 2626 has 2 adat ports (2 ins and outs) that allow me to use my old Focusrites in 'standalone' mode giving me 16 more inputs/ouputs. Latency is also non existent when recording. :)
I am glad the video has helped :)
Thanks. can’t wait for the upcoming video could save me big $. I am upgrading my studio soooooo you next will be most helpful. Sincerely, Pops Fitch
You got it Pops!
2 things. 1-First. 2-They, to me, sound exactly the same and i look forward to one day owning a quantum when the day comes such a device is needed in me studio. And thank you for all your vids i really enjoy your content and your way of explaining things. Also i would love for you to do a full mixdown of a song youve recorded. They are my favorite type of videos regarding audio recording, when an engineer goes througj the entire process from tracking notes to final mastering.
I have done a mixing down on the in the past
Cool I just got the 48x48 its on the truck coming my way. Cant wait to get my patch bay working. I've been staring at my analog rack all year trying to get it into my daw n not having enough IO.
Congrats on your purchase.
That’s one nice sounding mix and music.
Thanks
Your timing on this vid was fantastic for me. Currently have a 16 sum set up using two Apolo x8. Was going to get a x16 for 32 sum set up until I saw the price increase . Then was looking at the 48 from presonus. To my ears in my studio I really could not hear a diffreance. For $1500.00 I will give a shot and can always return it. Would use my Apolos for tracking and 48 for sum mixing with hardware is my thought. I have plenty of uad dsp for mixing but seance I went to a sum set up with hardware I use way less plugins . Appreciate what do here . Very insightful.
Thank you Scott!
As a studio one user for the last 5 to 6 years (so tired of people asking me why I don't even open pro tools anymore), I would have to say for the bang for buck it would be the quantum. My dream interface is an Apollo, but some of us are on a 9 to 5 budget lol. Great vids my guy, I've been learning and most importantly relearning a lot of things I've forgotten over the years of going from analog to completely in the box
Glad we are helping and serving a purpose
this is Charlie - formerly of AudioScape; I remember you well - you're AWESOME! ANYHOW! This is an AWESOME test! I wasn't familiar with the Quantuam4848 but DANG - that thing would be PERFECT for my needs. All that yummu I/O & beautiful conversion for only $1500 - INSANE!
That being said, I "THINK" I hear a slightly more punchy/solid kick drum & SLIGHTLY more glued kick/bass gtr relationship in MIX 2. Reading through the comments and I see the majority of folks weighing in are favoring MIX 2 but then exclaiming the high-end sounds better/different/etc - to my ears, everything from basically 120hz and up is IDENTICAL - but the difference I'm hearing in the 120hz-ish and down area could certainly be biased by wayyyyy too many other factors - perhaps because the track is green? Or because it's kind of in the center of the video? Or because you started with Mix 1 first?
Everyone kind of catch my drift? Hahaha... please let me know which is which! Honestly, it really doesn't matter at the end of the day though - way way way to close to make an unbiased judgement and because this is YT and my eyes/visual cortex is involved - I simply can't help myself... and yes, I DID close my eyes, in a dimly lit room, as I always do when trying to critically listen 😜😜
Cheers brotha and thanks again! 😎✌❤
Thanks Charles! I love Audio-Scape equipment! They make really wonder gear and affordable prices!
I did hear a little more punch in mix 2. Kick specifically. Also I felt the vocal push toward a hair in a nice way. There was something in the low end or low mid area in mix 1 that worked for the bass and possibly the littlest bit more depth and space overall of the track in mix 1. No matter what mix is which, the difference wasn't big enough to spend an extra $7,500 on the UAD Apollo's to my ears. Both sounded great
Thanks for watching!
@@MixingMusicAnalog No way can you tell the difference and I had on my Beyerdynamic headphones for this test on and I am an Apollo user, like Mr. Dave said, "Everyone opionion matters! but on the conversion on both units, they both sounded the same
I agree, the green sounded more defined and cleaner.
$7,500 for an Apollo? Who are you buying gear from?
I Agree, the attack of the kick and bass together was noticeable punchier, not a lot but enough to discern. eek I have two apollos and haven't looked at the end of these videos, but I'm afraid of what I'm about to find lol.
I instantly heard more top end in mix 1! It's subtle but undeniable to me.
Great!
I feel the green waveform sounds more open, snappy and has more definition on the high end. I like it better. To me there is a difference. Let's see next week which converter corresponds to the each track.
hummm, interesting
I agree with you, I know that UA sound 😂
Of course. Green always sound better.
Incredible video Dave thank you very much for everything you are sharing and teaching us ... I think it would have been interesting to invert the phase of the tracks ... there then we would hear if there is any difference ... once I did that experiment exporting Mixes of logic and pro tools to see if there is any difference in the software and to my surprise it was completely silent when reversing the phase ... but it would be great if you can share part of the tracks that you printed so we do that experiment ... May the successes continue for you and your work! Cheers!
no reason for that. Its two different units with different component inside so there has to be some difference right? The point is....can you actually hear the difference. 98% of people listen with their eyes and not their ears. they see me muting and unmuting and are telling them selfs they hear something different.
@@MixingMusicAnalog Do we need " reasons" to do a curiosity test ?😁
I mean, it would be interesting to hear whats going on with these 2 units...
Or in other words, what parts of the spectrum is " missing" if you pay 1/3
of the price ?
Please ? And Merry Christmas Dave !
@@MixingMusicAnalog
of course ... what I want to get to with the proposal I made was to actually know exactly what the difference is ... but I understand your point and you are very right ... I hope I can see more about how the tests you are doing are progressing ! Cheers!
I think mix 2 does sound a little better especially in the high frequency region. Also with the depth of the drum room and overall marrying of all the sounds together. Somewhat subtle though.
Thanks for watching!
Incredibly informative video! We had to wait a long time for something like this. For me track 2 has a bit more "information" and relaxed quality. Both sound good. But as a studio manager I would buy track 2
Glad it was helpful!
I have to say I hear practically identical both mixes. Probably one of the in the solo part sounds to me different, like less fat, but the rest is the same for me. Thank you fr the video.
Thanks for watching!
For me, there is no difference between the conversion of both. Tks for this test! Congrats.
Thank you!
I love my Aurora Lynx N. Love your channel brother great job.
Much appreciated! I never used the Aurora Lynx but I have heard they make great products
@@MixingMusicAnalog Once you try the Aurora I promise you ain’t going back to anything else. They really do sound fantastic.
I enjoyed the vibe Thanks
Thank you
I listened through on my Yamaha HS8 speakers while watching and then listened again with my screen just out of view. When I thought I heard a change I'd look over to see if you had switched. Every time I looked over, you had switched. The green mix seemed to be a bit more open and wider. I would look when I heard the stereo image collapse a bit and you'd be on the purple mix. But I'm not a pro and not as trained in the ears as some. What I was hearing was very subtle so I'm willing to accept that I'm just hearing things. As for which is which, I have no idea but I preferred the green mix. I don't usually nerd out about such minor differences, but this one was fun!
Thanks for watching!
Honestly, I love my 4848 and feel like its one of the best purchases I've made in a whiiiiiiile. They're also DC coupled if you want to get some CV into your modular gear!
Thanks for watching!
OK, Wow thats Was Really, Really good, Im blown Away,This Comparison Gives so much light on the subject of sound, and Listening Practices, I Honestly Cannot Hear any Difference Between the 2, This Was A ReallyGood Practice, And Hope's It proves Well, Great Job.
Thanks for watching!
Reading the comments is really interesting. It is truly amazing how we all hear things differently and if you listen long enough, you can convince yourself of just about anything. LOL...I did not put the audio on an analyzer or do a null test because if I did that you all would use your eyes to decide which one was "better" and not your ears. We will do a video like that in the very near future just so all the tech geeks and enjoy that sort of data. The bottom line is how does it sound in the first 3 mins of listening. Does it sound the same? Some of you say yes, others say they hear a difference. Either way I think this was pretty intresting
To me #2 has smoother highs
I don’t know man. These comments seem to be like 90% in agreement that #2 sounds wider and a bit better, but that they’re both great. Not a $7000 difference obviously. But still a difference nonetheless.
I personally hope #2 is the Quantum, I’m all for an underdog story
@@quiquepuche6393 Yea. Number 1 is a little muddy. The SSL might of changed up the sound.
The purple track sounds a tiny bit more expensive IMO.
I don't hear a difference.
What a well made, detailed and thoroughly enjoyable video, not to mention very informative! In regards to which sounded better, here is what my ears heard; the green sounded slightly more punchy, had a bit more clarity while being slightly more airy. The purple was a bit more subdude and mellow. While both sounded amazing, if I were to pick one, I'd go with the green. Now, I can't wait to discover which was which unit! Also, I'm about to subscribe. :)
Glad you enjoyed it! Welcome to our family!
@@MixingMusicAnalog Thank you!
I watched the mutes carefully for the first minute or so (which sounded exactly the same to me), and then closed my eyes and listened even more intently for the rest of it. To my ears there were no perceptible changes in the quality of any of it. I admit, I don't know exactly what I was listening for... when it comes to AD/DA conversion, but my gut tells me that if I'm listening that intently and can't discover any differences at all, then that bodes very well for the value of the PreSonus.
Thanks!
I feel I could do more with the green version. The purple does not have the low end clarity the top end sounds dirtier. Can't wait to hear the answer. I went with a ferrofish A32 connected to an RME Raydat.
Thanks for watching!
Awesome shootout vid! They sound close enough to me to NOT spend the extra 💰. One other plus with the Q4848, especially with a configuration like yours is that you can use one of your 3 UA’s via ADAT on the Q4848 and have 48 ins and outs. I actually use an older Apogee AD16x with my Q4848 seamlessly. 👍🏾👍🏾
Great tip! thanks for watching!
Mix A sounds slightly brighter than B but they both sound perfectly fine. Thank you for sharing Dave, this was a great comparison because I have been on the fence about the 4848 but not anymore it doesn’t matter which was which the difference is so slight I will go with what my budget can afford at the moment.
Thanks for watching!
@@MixingMusicAnalog You’re welcome I am behind in viewing your videos I have much to catch up on. Thank you for always providing such great insight.
Great video. I have a quantum 4848 and I've been wondering if I'm missing out on anything by not spending thousands more. This answers the question and I'm really happy.
I would not say you are missing out, especially if you dont need the interface for recording capabilities
I do use a merging anubis and Burl b2 ADC and they are the few AD interfaces that can handle the high output of the Neve Portico MBP when running your master hot. A lot of prosumer interfaces will clip when limiting my master hard. Both Merging and Burl have a soft clip option just in case I get too wild with the levels
Thanks for the info!
Man that Burl gear sounds amazing! I had the pleasure of hearing a 32 i/o mothership configuration with an API console and was spellbound.
its a pity you didn't do a Null-test. That way you can tell the difference between the converters. I'm nowhere near my headphones or monitors, so I can't tell much about the differenec listening on laptop speakers. You did a nice job on this test, keep the videos coming!
no reason for that. Use your ears, not your eyes. That is what this video was all about. Keeping it simple.....how does it sound? That's all that matters.
Awesome test. First I didn’t look at the screen when you was A-B them, put on a cheep per of headphones that I use to reference my mixes and only listened. I couldn’t tell the difference.
EXACTLY! I did that this morning after being away from the video for a few days. I listen back on my Bose headphones and I sat with my eyes closed during the entire playback and I could not tell where I was switching between the tracks. To my ears, there is no difference between the two.
Same for me volume match perfect couldn’t tell which is which 💯👌🏽😁
I have on some great ear buds, the JBL Reflect Minis and I put my phone down and just listened. There’s one part where the vocal harmony stood out but it wasn’t something I would’ve missed while mixing. They are very close, it doesn’t matter which was which because Unison pres are amazing as is Studer A800 and Ampex 102.
The Apollo interfaces does not limit what I do.
Thanks for watching!
Love the song and both options sound good to me, but I hear more depth/harmonics on the first/purple option.
Ok, thank you
@@MixingMusicAnalog Loving this discussion. Took the eyes closed challenge and I can hear the difference when focusing on the bass. Probably couldn't get it 100% of the time as it is that close. I'm listening with ERIS 8" monitors.
Wow this is crazy I honestly didnt think i would hear much of a difference but it is definitely noticeable. Whichever 1 green one is sounds better, the highs sound smoother and clearer and has a good presence to it. Im guessing the 2nd one (green 1) is going to be the Apollo. Just cause the price tag lol, im sure if mixed they would both come out sounding great though.
You must have "golden ears"...LOL
I listened without looking at the screen. And Concluded that it wasnt Noticeable enough to justify a Purchase so big if you are starting out. this does certainly close the Gap for those without the budget! Great Video
Thanks you
Thank you!!!
You're welcome!
We all have different ears. We just have to look at what works for us as well as how much we are willing to spend. Sometimes price isn't a issue meaning like the more something cost is not always the best outcome and sometimes less isn't the best way to go as well. I think both sound good. I'm downsizing to an satellite because I've had a few Apollos that I didn't use much other than for the plugins but I used other interfaces to track with along with I used a lot of my waves plugins to mix with and UAD to master with. Thanks for your insight its all helpful!!!
Good points!
Great video. Have an Apollo X8. Don’t use the preamps anymore, so have been thinking about moving to X16 or similar to connect more analoag gear. But then which to choose that gives me the best conversion.
I think the B was slightly brighter and more open, but I’m not listening from my studio, so I’m not sure. I would recommend the free HOFA 4U+ plugin for this kind of blind test. It’s really great.
Thanks for watching
How is it possible you have so few subscribers? Great channel and appreciate your personality as well - jealous of the SSL and and NG bus comp 😮 cool shoot out - my x16s sound okay - but are way too expensive. Once I started tracking with the Burl and then started mixing through Dangerous dac/adc 🎉 it was a huge difference… definitely sounds way better - “open” comes to mind. UA has been resting on the selling point of their plugins for a long time. I was so heavily invested from the past that I just also went with something that I knew. If I could do it again it would be RME for the I/O and Dangerous for the rest.
Thank you for watching and for the kind words!
This is a great series. I did the test blind for the first half to avoid bias. I do hear a difference on my head phones, but I can't say which one is better. Most of the time I liked the second track better. I hate being subjective, but here goes: The second track had a little more space - that's about it. Depending on what was going on in the song, the 1st one sounded better sometimes. No $7500 difference, for sure! Now I'll watch the next videos to find out which converters were on which tracks...
Thanks for watching!
Tbh I don't think I can hear a difference. But like you say we do have a tendency (or at least many of us) to listen with our eyes. And I can tell that because: When I listen and pay attention to you switching channels I think I can hear a difference, but as soon as I close my eyes I have no idea which one of them is playing or when you switch. So that only means that I'm imagining stuff right?
Thx a lot for taking the time to make this video. And other videos. I instantly subbed. I have subscribed to so many other ppl on UA-cam too but I find it harder and harder to find something without clock baits or real good info/learning material. Keep it up and ill watch everything you post and comment and like. I'll even advise my colleagues to watch your channel. 😉👍👏👏👏
Thank you very much! This channel is all about being is honest and un-biased as possible. It also serves as a learning experience for us. There is no one on UA-cam that is showing hybrid mixing in the way we are trying to show it, so we really appreciate all the support and the kind words. Unfortunately, when it comes to analog equipment there are a lot of people who get down right nasty and personal and I spend quite a bit of time deleting comments and blocking people from this channel.....LOL
I use a Allen & Heath gl3300 and will definitely be purchasing a presonus quantum 48 after watching this video! 🙏🔥
Good choice!
For me and my 90's soundcraft spirit live board, I prefer to maximize the outgoing signal from the interface, so I have to use less gain on the board and - supposedly - carry less noisefloor. I just minimize console gain as much as I can because readjusting gain is a PITA!!
On the SSL, a large part of the sound is driving the preamp.
THANKS!
You're welcome!
Listening on my entertainment system speakers, I believe mix 2 is the UAD. Their conversion has a bit of a boost in the highs and more punch in the lows, they aren't a totally flat converter. Additionally I noticed more separation in the mix elements, and a wider stereo image in mix 2. I'll try to check later on my studio monitors. I'd like to hear a null test as well. UAD conversion , while they spec well, is not the most transparent or "flat" in frequency response when compared to other high end options. It's definitely not Lynx, but not nearly as colored as a Burl.
I null tested my x16 to my Dangerous AD+, using the clock from the AD+, and phase aligned them down to 1/64th of a sample using Eventide alignment plugin, they null down to about -60db or so, but then there is a audible information that is clearly not nulled.
Ok, thanks!
Very subtle differences. though I find mix 2 is brighter. Thanks for sharing this video. I don't know which is which but Presonus is good sounding too.
Thanks for watching!
Love ur videos. My dream is to have a semi pro home studio and record / mix bands.
You can do it! If I can, so can you
I hear the purple one to be just a tiny bit smoother and the green one slightly edgier. There is a subtle difference. Which one u like more..that's individual taste..both are close but the purple one felt just a little easier on my ear..I go for that 💜
Thanks !
Great comparison, in my humble opinion both sounded great but I personally felt a little more clarity in the higher mids on mix 2, so I could tell that mix 2 could be the UAD and mix 1 the Presonus but I could be wrong.
Wait until you see Dave's deep dive analyses video, coming next week. For everyone that "thinks' they hear a difference, that video may change your mind.
Oh boy, I feel the same about Mix 2. Felt more relaxed to me and better, more accurate lows. Perhaps we’re all wrong!!!! Lol. Looking forward to Uncle Daves next video on this! :-/
Can't wait to see next episode
In the mix, dbu output is less than -6 dB. The converter shows your best performance in Master at approximately 0 dB. for mixing is good and easy . but for master you can use Mastering Converter like LYNX , ANTELOPE , BURL and ... .
Thanks for watching!
I think I prefer the purple even thou I imagine I can here more transients on the green. I sure hope the purple is the presonus so I just buy that one becuase I'm in the verge of getting an interface with more line inputs than I have today.
The results are coming soon
Mix 1 sounds a little bit darker. The transient information has more punch on mix 2 and it’s a very tiny bit brighter.
Thanks for watching!
Agreed. That’s what I heard as well. I’m guessing that if you can hear a difference on UA-cam, the difference will be more apparent sitting in the studio since UA-cam compression can mask fine details.
I’m not sure that I would call mix 2 overly bright or the other being irreparably dark. Meaning that the differences could be compensated for with a little eq.
I thought the same
Almost identical but if there's anything that I'm self convincing that I heard , was a bit more of an scooped out sound on the green track and a bit more bottom in the purple one.
Thanks for watching!
Nice video and nice test! To be honest I heard no difference with my DT770. But I'm no high-end guy. I think regarding converters all recent mid-range interfaces should do a proper job since "inside" there is technically nothing "magical". But just my opinion. So the 4848 seems to be a really fair deal if you need plenty of IO like for your use case or if you want to connect lot's of analog gear. Thanks for your video, will now read the comments and wait for your unveiling of the solution. Thanks and best regards, Stefan
Thank you for watching!
The first mix to me at least sounded with a little lift in the low mid area.
Specially between the bass and some range of the kick.
Both sound great and I'm pretty sure that with both units, results can be great.
However, if I had to choose one to keep with I'd choose the first mix.
Great vid!
Fair enough!
Feel the second ooooh so slightly beefier and a liiittle more spacey but overall, VERY similar. Would have to put in maybe 30 more tracks to start having a perceivable difference. Probably the second is the Apollo but tbh, for the price difference, the Presonus is rocking it whichever it is!! Great vid, thanks for sharing!
Thank you for watching!
Wouldn't say either is better - all personal preference and will get the job done.
To me, the differences are in the stereo imaging of the a/d.
Green sounds more wider. Red sounds more center focused.
Similar to when i tested the prism to lynx hilo. both can work - lynx has a wider image and clean, prism is clean with a slighttt color but narrow image. imo of course.
Appreciate vids like this - thanks for sharing.
Thanks for watching!
Purple sounds more open in the stereo field and it has more present transient information, specially in the drums.
Great! Thanks for listening
The green track is my favorite... Somehow more open and 3D like! I wonder which interface it is? Good video Sir....
one day, I'll reveal which is which
I'm using a 4848 to track electronic drums, then the appolo rwin to do guitars, keys and vox, its working out well,
NICE!
on my speakers it sounded like the green mix (mix 2) was a little more saturated...it just sounded a little fatter (in a good way)...like someone else said, both mixes sounded really good and at the price difference the Presonus seems like the way to go!!!! BTW, happy StudioOne user here too...great DAW!
Thanks for watching!
Mix 2 sounds slightly deeper and the stereo image sounds slightly wider to my ears. Fidelity wasn't less per se on mix 1, but the imaging sounds just a touch more open on mix 2.
Thanks for the great content!
Thanks for sharing!
Green stem for me - sounded more open, better separation of parts, slightly better overall clarity, slightly better transients. Just seemed a little more engaging and exciting overall?
Some said the purple sounds like you say the green sounds
The difference is negligible, especially considering the tracks are basically flat/raw. Any differences would easily disappear once both were actually mixed.
You did a great job trying to mitigate any outside influence of the console etc
Thanks John!
Amazing content
Thanks!
I have two 4848's and basically eliminated my need of patchbays. I really like them. I also have an Apollo QUAD (silver) that I updated to thunderbolt. I daisy chain all three together, utilizing one of the QUANTUMS as my clock for the Apollo. I also have UAD PCIe and USB OCTO cards. I've got the two systems running seamlessly.
Excuse me ,did you daisychain Apollo and Presonus using thunderbolt cable?!?! :/
NICE!!
I listened closely last night and initially I liked mix #1 better. It seemed to be clearer. As I continued to listen to all aspects of the mix, mix #2 started to sound overall larger and warmer. Although I think both versions are fine, I would be interested in knowing which mix came from which interface. This was a really good shootout.
You can have apollo and 4848 running at the same time running in studio one?
@@fattohead I would like to know if this is possible? Can we chain it wit UA interfaces?
To my ears, the green mix definitely sounded more open, and the center was more defined. When the purple mix would play, it made me miss the green mix. In other words, sonically speaking, purple mix sounded good, green mix sounded great!
Fair enough!
I like the Green mix. Bottom end is slightly thicker. Vocals are slightly more forward. Greens mix has slightly more sizzle. I’m listening on studio monitors.
Ok, thanks
Mix 1 sounds more open to me, I believe it's Apollo. But the difference is so, so small that it does not justify in any way paying the difference in value. Thanks for the amazing video, you gained another subscriber.
Hey Thanks! Welcome to the family!!
I’ve been looking at the quantum 4848 for the last couple of months, I’m in the same boat as you I don’t track through the uad plugins I use hardware,so that side of the apollo is redundant if what Barry Johns says is true that the new apple chips are so fast that you can set your buffer to 32 and forget it , then there is no need for dsp for me in the audio interface,and it’s time to sell my uad apollo
Thanks for watching!
Very nice! Thx for doing that. Where do we get the answer ? I feel the mix 2 is slightly brighter. It excites the ears a bit more, but overall I feel the first mix is a bit more balanced and once mixed might work better. Just a theory.
The answer is coming soon. We have a couple more videos to do for this test first, subscribe and hit the notification bell to stay up to date!
25:00 The GREEN sounds better just by attentively listening through the AUSTRIAN AUDIO HI-X55 headphones.
Their higher frequency spectrum is similar to the famed KRK6000 twitters, which utilize K45 (i might be wrong) yellow focal twitters and they are superb!
The qualities of the "MIX2" are silkier and sorta grouped into a cohesive silk sound, whereas "MIX1" is just that but without silk, and also sounds as if a very very transparent bus compressor got suddenly bypassed. Maybe if the "MIX1" got raised 0.1db gain it would change the A/B difference, but in this current case my ear prefers the "MIX2" as sounding more as a whole, sounding kida 1% more saturated altogether!
Thanks for watching!
Mix1 = PreSonus Quantum
Mix2 = Universal Audio Apollo x16
- - - - -
I was on Apogee / switched to Universal Audio Apollo = after a month I sold and left for Apogee Symphony I / O Mk1 - happiness !!!
- - - - -
if I have the console I dream of (Solid State Logic Origin / Solid State Logic Duality 48channels /// I would EXACTLY be on = Apogee Symphony I / O Mk2 TB 32x32 + Apogee Symphony I / O MKII TB 2x6 SE and get the best sound in the world for a lifetime
- - - - -
thank you for such a job! for your important videos !!!
Thanks you for your support
If they sounds good they are good 👍 I’m leaning towards 1. But I would be happy with either
Thanks for watching!
Listening on monitors here in youtube 4K. The green sounded a bit smoother and the mix was more melted together with that track versus the purple track where the instruments were sticking out a little bit more and it sounded a bit harsher. Overall I got the impression that track two was more expensive sounding, if that make any sense to other then my self and I mean in terms of sound coming out of the speakers not the actual price. I hope the green track is quantum since I've been looking in to the unit but that would not make much sense when looking on the actual price tags of the units. Also you could see more transient information on the green waveformes in studio one which is a good sign for me personally. About the mixes in them self it felt like something was distorting in them and personally I would not change the gainstaging that drastically on the in and outs I would dial both back little
Ok, thanks for watching!
As a Quantum user I have been really impressed with these units. I hear minor differences between the two tracks. I defiantly don't hear $3,000 worth of a difference so UA needs to get a clue.
Thanks for watching!
I'd love to hear a null test between these two.
Coming soon
@@MixingMusicAnalog Good news. I wondered the same.
Definitely more low end presence, warmth, and clarity in the 2nd Mix. As a diehard Presonus/ Studio One user using an 1818VSL my guess is that track 2 is an Apollo. I hope Im wrong and I get to go buy a quantum.
When using the Quantum, what was your block size set to via Universal Control? I wonder if this has anything to do with the quality or if there is a similar setting on the Apollo.
Setting were the same
I have no idea what is what.. the purple mix 1 sounds slightly more open. Anyway you put it they are both great and the value for money of the Presonus blows the Apollo out of the water. I have two silver quads and the Apollo 16x in my studio with my API console. I also have a octo satellite.
I’m also currently toying with Luna so I can’t really sell my Apollo’s. But if I only used Studio One and did not need my Apollo preamps I probably consider going for the Presonus interface.
Thanks for watching
To me as i listened there was a bit of difference in the low end, it felt a bit more punchy on the kick from the mix 1 compared to mix 2. Otherwise I couldn't hear much difference between the 2. I am also fighting a bit of a head cold so ears are stuffed up, but the high end was nice and smooth between the 2 as well. Would love to know which was which.
listen with your eyes closed.....can you hear when I am switching the tracks?
I would say purple has an immediate air around it especially the drums that go away when switched, which in terms of superior conversion tells me it's the Apollo. I hope I'm wrong too because we're looking at a cost effective solution for mobile band recording lol.
You'll have to wait and find out
Fan of the green mix
Thanks for watching!
Really digging the Santana and Rob Thomas vibe. The artist is really good. Which if you think about it, if that's all I heard from this video, you did your job and it doesn't matter which I/O you choose.
Thank you
@@MixingMusicAnalog quite welcome my friend.
I do hear Mix 1 has a bit more low end on the kick drum ( it was more noticeable there ) but pretty similar both mixes.
Thanks
Green sounded warmer to me. Initially, more natural. Mix 1 seemed more stressed in the high-end. Image-wise the green seemed to have more material in the center which made Mix 1 seemed to have a wider image and sound more open. But the more I listen, I feel like I could listen to purple more times and not fatigue.
Thanks for watching!
Well done! I'm getting old so I may not be able to really hear much of a difference. That said, my experience in audio tells me: 1) Presonus and 2) Universal Audio. If that isn't the case then it sounds like you're going shopping with the money made selling those UA's. That still might be a good option considering the two are so close in sound, unless you intend to record classical music or jazz (I'm assuming my guess is accurate).
I don't know, maybe you are correct, maybe you're not.
I think 1 (purple) is the Apollo and 2 the Quantum. To my ears 1 has better resolution, separation and depth. 2 sounds more smeared and 2D to me.
Ok, great!
that's funny because I thought the opposite. Do you have room correction? I thought the green had clearer bass response and tighter top end. Can't wait to hear the results!
i suspect you are correct
I found that the random switching between versions had a large impact on my listening. I would have preferred to listen to the first 10 seconds of each then the next ten seconds etc.
Is it possible to post those files or a portion of? More importantly I would like to hear you assessment. Thanks
not posting the files, sorry