Is Tarawih and Tahajjud the Same Salah?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 чер 2016
- Title: Is Tarawih and Tahajjud the Same Salah?
Speaker: Shaykh Mohammad Yasir Al-Hanafi
Many people advocate a baseless view that tarawih and tahajjud are the same salah, their precedence for such claims not only lack any credible basis but rather such claims are evident to the confusion of these individuals. In this clip, Shaykh Mohammad Yasir al-Hanafi goes through a number of evidences to prove that tarawih and tahajjud are indeed two distinct and separate types of prayer. The explanations and reasons within this video are adapted from the research and findings of Shaykh Hafiz Zahoor Ahmed al-Hussaini (hafizahullah) whose book can be found here: islamicbookslibrary.wordpress...
Brought to you by the Hanafi fiqh channel.
Our facebook page: / hfiqh
Our twitter page: / hanafifiqh
Second channel: / hanafifiqhhd
Our blog: haq2012.wordpress.com/
Our Flickr page: www.flickr.com/photos/hanafifiqh
'Alimah Answers' sister's ONLY facebook page: / alimahanswers
sheikh yasir is a great scholar.this changed my views
MT scohlor? Lol
@@raselrahman6468 loooooooooool
Asif Ahmad lol venerating a person abve their position! His arguments are nt even n a student of knowledge level lol
@@raselrahman6468 exactly i think he's not got past medina book one
@@raselrahman6468 but some deobandis are crazy about him others like the one sat next to him molana Abdul haleem Saab deobandi has left him lolllll
20 rakaat taraveeh is better than 8 rakaat because for every sajda theres reward from ALLAH Jallashanuhu
As always - crystal clear and fact-based.
ماشاء اللہ ہدایت پانے والوں کے لئے بہت ہی مفید بیان ہے
اس بیان کو سن کر معلوم ہواکہ فرقہ اہلحدث لوگوں کو دھوکہ دینے کے لئے بغیر دلیل کے یہ کہہ دیتے ہیں کہ تہجد اور تراویح ایک ہی نماز ہے اور اس طرح جھوٹ بول کر بہت سے لوگوں کو ایک نماز سے محروم کردیتے ہیں. اللہ ایسے جھوٹوں سے امت کی حفاظت فرمائے.آمین
Good effort bro, may Allah help you and alike eliminate the biddah of 8 rakats from Muslims, Aameen!
laanatullahe alal kazibeen . Allah ki laanatain hon munkareene hadeeth per aameen.afsos kis dhataee say aaj muqallideen Ahadeethe Raool s a w ka mazaq urhatay inkar kartay hain aur Allah aur Rasulullah s a w aur sahabah karam per jhut bandhtay hain!!.inshaAllah is ka mazzah anqareeb sab chhako gao?!.
Salaam Bro, seems like you not a blind follower coz you started with cussing instead of tasleema. Anyway since you are a ghair muqallid, then you must know arabic and must have knowledge about hadiths. Can you please share your understanding about this issue and what you think is right and why?
BTW don't think about copy pasting.
Ma Shaa Allah .... Jazkallahu Khair brother
Subhan Allah, great clarification. Jazak Allah
My ustad
Absoloute legend
khan Listen to molana ishaq this is whole shit what he is speaking
@@prorecitarno thanks
May Allah bless shaykh muhammed yasir al hanafi! Smashed the Salafi creed in the previous videos. ❤️
blind follower
+Nazir Rashid what do you mean by blind follower? Please give vivid details.
😂
lol the only blind follower is u, of the biddah of 8 rakats taraweeh done by Albani
If tahajjud and Tarawih are 2 separate prayers, then according to this Usool, Rasool Allah pbuh prayed 23 (20+3 witr) Rak’ah tarawih and then in the same night the prophet pbuh prayed 11(8+3 witr) Rak’ah Tahajjud as it is already mentioned in the hadeeth narrated by Aisha Radhi Allahu Anha.
If we accept this claim then we also have to admit that Rasool Allah Sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam prayed Witr twice. Once in tarawih and once in tahajjud.
Where as Rasool Allah pbuh said “لا وتران في ليلة ”
“There is no two Witrs in one night.” [Sunan At Tirmidhi 470, Sunan Abu dawood 1439, Sunan An Nasai 1678, Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah 1101, Sahih Ibn Hibbaan 671]
There cannot be any contradiction in the Actions and Sayings of Rasool Allah sal Allahu aleyhi wasallam and hence it is incorrect to differentiate between Tahajjud and Tarawih.
Nazir Rashid clearly you didn't watch the video, since that hadith was mentioned in the video..
Not to mention that there is other ahadith that state he did tahajjud salah less and more than 8 rakats.
so why dont you do that?
Having 8 rakats 'taraweeh' goes against the Arabic language so why don't u use the narrations where our Rasool (s) used to pray 12, 16, etc..
why not take what Umar (ra) established? Which was 20 RAKATS
No one objected to the 20 rakats or as your leader albani likes to call it the "bidah" at the time of the sahaba.. so technically there was an ijma among the sahaba.
None of the 4 imams had the opinion of any less then 20 rakats taraweeh.
Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani (r) related from Imam Rafi (r):The Prophet (s) prayed 20 Rakats in Taraweeh on two consecutive nights with a congregation in Ramdhan. On the third night many more people gathered (for a
congregation) but the Prophet did not appear before them. In the morning the Prophet stated: ‘It occurred to me that this prayer (20 Rakats in Ramadhan) could become compulsory (Fard) upon you, and you would not be able to bear it.’
This narration related by Hafiz Ibn Hajar Asqalani, after relating it, he said: ‘There is a consensus amongst all the Muhadditheen that this narration is sound (Sahih).’ (Talkeesul Habeer Fe Takhreej Ahadith Rafi ul Kabeer vol 1, p119)
Since this hadith is sound by ijma, why do you still reject 20 rakats?
salaam walaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu. jazakAllahu khair shaikh. very nicely explained.
Mashallah . don't think anybody else prove that
Quick question did the word Taraweeh even exist back then?
Jazakallahu khair.. you have cleared confusion
The word taraweeh is not in hadith or Quran
As-Salamu-'alaykum. Will there be a separate video/series expounding upon evidences regarding the 20 or 8 rakaat issue for taraweeh. Jazak-Allahu-Khayran.
Alijma youtube channel will soon post one ... inshaAllah.
Assalaamualaikum, i would like to know if it could be possible to add english subtitles in your videos so you could reach out to more viewers. Your videos are very educational and detailed however I cannot understand much of the urdu. Jazaakallah
+اسمي YAHYA s. A. Bro the speaker translated himself in English what he spoke in Urdu so be relaxed
ua-cam.com/video/6jQ_fjZVR54/v-deo.html
S. A. Where is the link to that book mentioned in video as pdf format?
Masha Allah
Barak Allah fikum
first this man in the video says that tarweeh is sunnat muakkadah .
Sunnate muakkadah means act or worship that our prophet us to do contionously and never abondones it.
If the taraweeh after ishaa in congregation was sunnat muakkadah why would our prophet abondoned it after 3days. And prayed individualy and not in masjid
2nd Let him or can any boday have authentic hadith proving that, that night which our prophet prayed in masjid in jammaat or 3days was it just after Ishaa can u prove?
My dear, it is the regular Sunnah of Sahaba.... Hence moakkada
You guys need to worry about the dalael of reading Taraveeh 30 days (instead of 3) in Masjid( instead of home) with Jamaat (instead alone)
@@TheSigma192 brother now i have known the fact, and dont need to worry now, i got my answer, that thajjud, tarweeh, qiyum ul lail all are same given differnt names.
Our prophet has done it during the nights of ramadan for 3days in masajid with jamaat but due to fear of the same could become obligatery to us ie.his ummah he discontinued it to pray the same in masajid with jamaat. And prefered praying at home at during last hours of night and as he always use to to. And also instructed them to go home and pray.
In hadith he had said the best prayer after any farz prayer is the prayer which one prays at home.
So this taraweeh or tahajjud is nafil or say sunnah is better if prayed at home. And also it can be prayed at masajid coz it was done by our prophet, and whether for 30days or 3 days it doesnt matter but should be done in rightful, peacful way, and not in hurry like speed forward mode which is done and going on in most masjid which is worhtless.
amazing
4.23. .... here shaikh forger after 8 rakh people take rest for 3 Rakh
Where is the reference of the hadith of anas ra narrating that prophet saw prayed separately.
Assalamu Alaikum. Dear Sheikh, you mentioned the difference between Taraweeh and Tahajud. jazakallah khair. Please give the authentic hadith for Rasool (SAW) performed 20 Rakaths as Jamath?
You can also provide authentic hadith for Rasool (SAW) performing 8 raakat taraweeh with Jama'at for the whole month of Ramadhan... We are Ahle Sunnat Wal Jama'at following Ijma (of Sahabah RD.A).. and you are ignorance of Ijma... this is a reason you people are out of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jama'at...
Dear Sheikh, (1) this is a duty of a muslim should return his fellow muslim's Salaam(greetings). (2) I had a doubt in the number of rakaths so that i requested you to give an authentic hadith. I never mentioned in my post as Rasool (SAW) performed 20 or 8 rakath either for three days or four days or the whole month of ramdan. But you are claiming the taraweeh is 20 rakath. So this is your duty to provide an authentic hadith. (3) in my post i never mention i am an ignorant of ljma or Sahaba (R.A). then how you conclude as i am ignorance of ljma?
Dhayfallah Ali ‘Alaykum bi sunnati wa sunnatil khulafa ir rashidin al mahdiyyin’
Hold on to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the rightly guided khulafa
according to the scholars,we can follow the sunnah of the khulafah ar rashidin even if Rasulullah SAW were not doing it since he gave permission to do that.but do you think the sahabah especially Umar RA would not following the sunnah?
Ramadan mubarak. May Allah forgive our sins. According to the last post, I am also agree Umar R.A was a great sahabi and khaleefa. But I am asking the authentic hadeedh, where he order for his people to perform 20 rakaths?. Jazakallah khair
If you want authentic action, look at those who wrer present when the Prophet performed traweeh in three days.
yes.
I have an issue that needs clarification : Was Hz. Ali R.A body mounted upon a camel and the camel was let loose in to the desert? I would like an answer for Hanafi Madhab, that's the Tasawuf Hanafi please
Good bayan, Shaikh Yasir. But you forgot to mention that 'Tahajjud' in Arabic language means 'waking up from sleep' hence Tahjjud is the prayer which is performed after waking up from sleep. So clearly Taravih is not Tahajjud since there is no sleep between Isha and Taravih.
If I am to use this explanation, then our rasul (s a w ) did not understand the Arabic language,. How much did he pray.
Tahajud is different Salah
Tarawih is different Salah
Tahajud is for complete a year Salah
&
Tarawih is only in the month of Ramzan Salah
you are explaining the word taraweeh but is it in the hadis.
jk shaykh.
I miss why i was not in front of you bro...
Asad bin Amr االله رحمه related from Qazi Imam Abu Yusuf االله رحمه’ I asked Imam Abu Hanifa االله رحمه about the matter
of Taraweeh and what Sayyidina Umar had done in this respect. Imam Ahle Sunnah Wal Jamat Abu Hanifa
االله رحمه replied: *‘20 Rakats of Taraweeh is Sunnah Muakkadah.* Sayyidina Umar did not establish this from his
own accord, nor was he one to create innovations in the Deen. Rather, he was the greatest in his hatred of
innovation. *The order that he gave for the 20 Rakats of Taraweeh* , verily; there would have been an order of the
Prophet in this respect.’ (Marakeeyul Farah Ma’a Hashiya p334)
la howla wala quwwata illa billah!! don't be a muqallid (blind follower) follow the !Qur'aan and the Ahadeethe saheehah and correct your aqaed.who says that abu hanifah r a was imam ahle sunnah?!. are we obliged to follow any imam and leave Qur'aan and the saheeh Ahadeeth? did any imam said this that we must follow them blindly(do their taqleed)?? why u put all your errors on ghair muqallid imam abuhanifah and slander him for your faults???!!!. fear Allah and be proper muslim.
Abu Waseem what? the hanafi madhab has its methodology of interpreting "quran and sunnah" same with the shafi'i, maliki, hanbali..
correct my "aqaed" dont know how my comment had anything to do with aqeedah, for you to say such things.
Literally all sunni scholars of islam say that Imam Abu Hanifa (ra) was a part of ahle sunna..
quran and sunnah always has a interpretor, even salafis have many differences of opinon regarding issues, if one goes with one opinion but another goes with the other opinion is one leaving quran and sunnah?
the 4 madhabs having a sanad going back to the salaf unlike salafis. since this is the case your madhab is daeef.
many imams said that the layman or someone who is not on the level of itjihad should do taqleed.
and the irony, when you ask someone is a hadith "sahih" they will quote you a muhaddiths opinion of whether the hadith is strong or not, you never met any narrator of hadith, so you blindly following what scholars say about these narrators... guess we cant follow hadith anymore..
and when did i slander abu hanifa (ra)?
and why are you insinuating that im not a "proper muslim" the arrogance you have, do some tazkiyya, useless putting accusations on somebody on the last 10 days of ramadan
Although the prophet saws never used the word taraweeh and it’s not even in any hadeeth. The prophet has only ever mentioned the night pray as Qiyam ur layl. You have ignored completely the prophet and used fatwas for justifications. Agree with some points but definitely Allah has given us minds to look directly at what our prophet did as well and that will make us all love your explanations more.
May Allah tala guide you
Where is it written.
Most of your videos are just differences of opinions which causes conflict, Insha Allah now that it's Ramadan you will put beneficial videos up for your followers to benefit.
It's a "fiqh" channel
it is ahlul khabis who bring up the toipic with these innovations, so they need 2 clarify. search quranic treasures for general information in channel
the only problem we have with 8 rakat taraweeh is that its an opinion that came way after the salaf.
and due to extremists on that side like albani, have said we are innovators for doing 20, many people leave after 8 rakats taraweeh in the masjid,
this didnt happen 200 300 years ago, etc. the ones who caused the conflict in the first place was the salafis.
+Saleh al Kzstani they didn't behead bin ladens salafi head ? So why would they behead mine ? In fact they treated him as a guest and ate with him prayed with him. That's what Islam is .
Taliban kill innocent lives...
Taraweeh name was not given by Sahaba nor Rasool sas so how can you justify that it's 12 ?
musannif abe shaiba or bohot si riwayat mai tarawhi hai
Ahlus Sunnah do follow Quran, hadith and Ashabe-e-rasoolullah sallallahu alaihi wa sallam... So you guys can go along with Umar radiallahu anhu.
Hanafi alim and prominent scholar of hafan said...“8 rak’ahs taraweeh is authentically proven from the Messenger of Allaah (sal-Allaahu ‘alayhe wa sallam) and the narration of 20 rak’ahs is narrated with a weak chain and there is agreement of its weakness.”He also said,“According to my preference taraweeh and tahajjud are one prayer, although there are differences in their attributes.” [Faidh al-Baaree (2/420)]
Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani االله رحمه related from Imam Rafi االله رحمه :The Prophet prayed 20 Rakats in Taraweeh on two
consecutive nights with a congregation in Ramdhan. On the third night many more people gathered (for a
congregation) but the Prophet did not appear before them. In the morning the Prophet stated: ‘It occurred
to me that this prayer (20 Rakats in Ramadhan) could become compulsory (Fard) upon you, and you would not be
able to bear it.’ This narration related by Hafiz Ibn Hajar Asqalani, after relating it, he used to state:(صحته على متفق(
‘There is a consensus amongst all the Muhadditheen that this narration is sound (Sahih).’ (Talkeesul Habeer Fe
Takhreej Ahadith Rafi ul Kabeer vol 1, p119)
Brother....Pls do not copy and past from Google... you are showing me the comments of shaikh Ibn Hajar Al Asqalani االله رحمه comment... bring shahi hadith in which it says 20 is sunna from prophet saw or from omer ra. As hanaf claim..
Note: Anwar. Shah kashmeri debandi.. also accepted 8 is authentic not 20 rakh.
Shahul Hameed Al-Bayhaqi in al-Marifa
Has a narration from
Abu Tahir al-Faqih → Abu Uthman al-Basri → Abu Ahmad Muhammad ibn Abdal Wahhab → Khalid ibn Mukhallad → Muhammad ibn Ja^far → Yazeed ibn Khaseefah → Sa^eeb ibn Yazeed:
'In the time of Umar ibn al-Khattab (radiallahu anhu) the people used to observe 20 rak'ahs and the witr.'
Al-Nawawi (ra) said in al-Khulasa:
'Its Isnad is Sahih.'
+Anonymous
before doing copy and past from website first read the complete article.... was it authentic or not... if you spread wrong message with out knowledge then it will be big trouble on the day of judgement...
+Anonymous
if you are sincere in Search for truth. then the evidence of your own by looking at the books first then u will come to know how people misusing the islam
Salam brothers of hanafi channel.
no offence have you brother's ever considered a youtube live debate between deobandi hanafis and salafi wahabis.....like the debate with the ashari belvri and the salafi wahabi that was done this year in london on duaa through the prophet, both brought there evidence.
mutta imam malik had hadidth with golden chain tarwhw and tahajuud are same
please share
Sayeed Rizwan where is it
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Would it be possible for us to go through some books of the Hanafi Ulema with explanation rather than refuting madkhalis all the time. Real Salafis are free from them
in these issues ur both on the same page and equally misguided in fiqh! politricks is another matter
where are hanfis doing jihad and against who? their aqaed are similar to hindus like wahdatul wajud/halool .
Don't confused people.
Is tarawee word used in any sahi Hadith... .. Kindly see video of Mirza Ali.. U will be go to offer 8 rakht insha allah
Koi Batahe Ye Channel Kis K Mutalleq Hai
proof of asar and magrib was knocking
1) taraweeh is usually known as qiyam Ramadan and tahajjud is known as qiyamul layl. Like nawab siddiq, a famous ahle hadith scholar, has defined it
2) taraweeh is performed in the beginning of the night whilst tahajjud is performed in the last portion of the night, molana sanaullah amr tisri says tahajjud cannot be performed in the beginning of night.
3) according to most jurist taraweeh is sunnah muakkadah and tahajjud is mustahab. Ibn qudamah in mughni.
4) tataweeh is from sha'ar zahira as opposed to tahajjud which is done secretly. Imam shawkani in nailul awtar.
5) The legislation of tahajjud is done through quran, whereas the legislation of taraweeh is done theough hadith. Nasai vol.1 pg. 339
6) The prophet peace and blessings be upon him read taraweeh only for three days, then he stopped because it might become fardh, bukhari and muslim. Tahajjud was abrogated in makkah then in madina it became mustahab. Muslim Sharif.
The question is if tahajjud was abrogated then why would prophet fear that it will become fardh, this indicates that taraweeh is different than tahajjud.
7) The prophet peace and blessings be upon him, sahabas, tabioon, and mujtahidoon, all would read tahajjud after taraweeh, while the prophet said you should not read the same salah twice in a day.
The prophet according to muslim sharif, read privately, in his house after the taraweeh.
Even bukhari rahimahullah would read tahajjud after taraweeh according to allamah wahiduz zaman, a ahle hadith scholar.
Molana miah nazeer saab who is sheikhul kul fil kul of ahle hadith, he would read tahajjud after taraweeh. Mentioned in nataijut taqreer, pg.29
8) Muhaddithun gave different titles to each sala, even the fuqaha have given each one separate titles
i just skim this guys video because i dont wanna lend my ear and some corruption my settle in my heart
+Saleh al Kzstani wrong tafseer akhee giving your own interpretation of quran without knowledge! Allah was speaking about the kuffar and munaafiqoon who are obstinate and stubborn towards the truth!
***** not mine akhee...mazhabee all the way and i denounce the salafi manhaj
Ahkisssss yaar give it rest it's ramdhan don't be bunch of tattoo's be good to each other jzk xxx
your mazhab is similar to the buddist and hindus thats why your elders have trained you on wahdatul wajud/halool kufriah/shirkiah aqaed!!.even your self made imam abu hanifah r a has said about you lot that who ever does not believe that Allah is not Mustavi alal Arsh is a big kafir!! now what u say about that ? better repent and correct your aqaed..
Abu Waseem is not jahil rather he is paid from the stolen Zakat money to tell lie.
OH MY GOD! Allaah will always protect his Scholars in Mecca Madinah and does not need help from Group's or Movements who named themselves after Villages or Places in Far East India which is the Present Day Land of Statue Carving and Idolatry Worship.
Baseless accusations
Further more why don’t you answer his arguments?? There is ijma on the issue of taraweeh being 20
Hater
This is such a silly comment. Do you not know that the Ottomans were in control of the 2 holy Mosques for 500 years, which was replaced by the Sharifans, which was then replaced by Wahabis, groups which have wildly different beliefs.
Just tell me one simple thing! Which hadith says that follow "Sahih Hadih" and ignore "Zaeef Hadith"... Isn't this whole classification of Ahadith into Sahih, Hassan, Zaeef , Mozu etc. done by Muhadittheen and not by Prophet s.a.w.... so actually you are BLINDLY following and doing TAQLEED of Muhadditheen in this case (as you idiots don't have enough knowledge to make this decision yourselves)... Also what is your opinion in the events where one hadith is tagged as SAHIH by one Muhaddith and ZAEEF by others e.g. almost 25 ahadith of Bukhari are marked as Zaeef by Imam Muslim (who would you follow in this case??Bukhari or Muslim??)... So, please learn the USOOLUL HADITH before talking about hadith... Last but not the least, Allah has asked us to follow Sunnah (which is basically the usual practice of the Prophet and not exceptions) and not Hadith. So, where NABI S.A.W ordered a group of people to drink camel's urine according to a hadith in Burakhi, why don't you guys start drinking camel's urine as you follow sahih hadith? Basically Fiqh is science which was beyond the comprehension of the ignorants of NAJADEEZ who only see things in BLACK and WHITE. Salafism fails to deliver answers in many cases of IJMAH as QIAS as famously quoted that which hadith proves that BUFFALO milk is HALAL (btw majority of Pakistan and India consume buffalo milk for their dairy needs)...
So hazrat abu bakr in his time period never read this slaah nor sahaba lol they were coward right?
curse ✋ Taraveeh word never spoken by Prophet or Sahaba 😷 Taraveeh and tahajjud are same
You are ahlehadith. Give any authentic hadith which proves that the traweeh and tahajjud are same.
Ahsan Qasmi open up imam bukhari shahi he bring the same hadith under tahajjud and traweeh hadith min aisha r.a
mukarram haroon He clearly mentioned the differences in two different Hadith on Taraveeh and Tahajjuth 14:36
Ahsan brother first this man in the video says that tarweeh is sunnat muakkadah .
Sunnate muakkadah means act or worship that our prophet us to do contionously and never abondones it.
If the taraweeh after ishaa in congregation was sunnat muakkadah why would our prophet abondoned it after 3days. And prayed individualy and not in masjid
2nd Let him or can any boday have authentic hadith proving that, that night which our prophet prayed in masjid in jammaat or 3days was it just after Ishaa can u prove?
You are against the majority of the opinions. 9 out 10 scholars say the both prayers are the same for all intensive purpose.
The 4 madhabs say 20 rakaat, which majority are you talking about? 😂
@@basetnourestani1583 lol
assalamuvaalaikum....brother we all know that proof for a muqallid is nothing but the qaul of his imaam and the elite of deobandis also has the same aqeedah that nothing is hujjah against a muqallid except his Imam ..this is said by the likes of mehmood Al hasan, qasim nanotvi , etc....so please prove urself only from imam Abu hanifa ...and do not talk abt other imams ...whom u r not muwallid
Hey if you don't have an intelligent question stay quite next time. think before you write
+Ubaiydullah Nagoo indeed we are about Hadith....who follow the best of opinions of salaf......but the muqallid have limited themselves to one imam....whether he is right or wrong in any masla
shame on u and your mufties who leave saheeh Hadeeth for the qol statements of their blind followers mullahs?!.read the book of taqi usmani about hujiyyate Hadeeth u wil know what taqleed and muqallid is??.
***** no doubt muqallid is deffinitely ignorant like u who even does not know what is the Snnah and Hadeeth?!.where do u get the Sunnah from?? and what is the different in Sunnah and Hadeeth?!.stop taqleed and follow Qur'aan and Saheeh Hadees if u want to succeed..
Whom you follow, Albani in some and your desire in some currect?
sorry to say.. this person need schooling to understand religion islam in its true sprit... Don't give this Deoband explanation who every time used to defend their practices at any interest...
Keep Misguiding Ummah!!!
Jhuta moqallid,apne batil kheyal ko sabit kerne ke liye kitni mehnat,kahan kahan se dhund dhund ker la raha hai,sahi hadison ko chore ker kahan kahan bhatak raha hai.ashraf ali thanwi ne likha abu hanifa ghair moqallid,uska ustad uska baba ,Mohammed bin qasim aur unke sath 20000 thausand mojahdin sub ghair moqallid,sahaba ghair moqallid,400 hijri se qabal taqlid ka namonishan tak na tha,shah waliullah,hawala kitab hujjatullah balega,quranohadis men yeh word janwer ke liye aiya hai insano ke liye nahi,ab janwer yasir ka jhute,isne kaha sare mohaddis ne tarawih aur tahajjud ka bab alag alag bandha hai,sirf imam bukhari ne tarawih ka bab bndha aur usmen 8+3=11rikat batlaya ki ayesha r.a.ne fermaya isse zeyada nemaz Mohammed saw ne kabhi nahi perhi,imam malik ne mauta men qeyam ramzan ka bab bandha aur usmen batlaya ki umer r.a. ne kaab aur tamim dari r a.ko 11 rikat perhane ka hukum diya,lumbi rikaten aur nemaz seher ke waqt katum hoti jaldi sehri khate,usi mauta men likha hai ki umer r.a ke zamana men baaz sahaba 20 rikat perhte the lekin woh munqata yani zaif hai,o jahil beiman yasir humen manwana hai to rub ka quran ya Mohammed saw ki sahi hadis laa jo tum qeyamat tak nahi laa sakte,kisi aalim ya imam ka qaule hamare liye hujjat nahi o bewaqufe yeh tumhara manhaj hai hamara nahi
جھوٹے تو وہ لوگ ہیں جو دو وقت میں پڑھی جانے والی نماز کو بغیر دلیل کے ایک نماز بتاتے ہیں
ھھھھھھھھھھھا
Utter bullshit. Taraweeh & Tahajjud are the same. These are just the names given depending upon the period of time they are prayed.