Myanmar Military Coup Explained | Why did it happen | Who is going to benefit?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,5 тис.

  • @rouxzino
    @rouxzino 3 роки тому +295

    American here. This was the exact historical explanation and analysis I was looking for. Thank you so much and be safe!

    • @sumitaggarwal6653
      @sumitaggarwal6653 3 роки тому +14

      Hello from india. You have friendly neighbour countries. I know , America is facing problem of illegal immigrants from Mexico but overall peace at border. But here, we already have enemies at two fronts. One is pakistan, after defeating it in every war they are doing proxy war. Helping terrorists to smuggle through borders and funding some groups in Kashmir to create a situation of unrest. Other one is china which we all know it has expanist dreams, they are trying every way to destabilize the country internally like paying journalist,media organisations to write in its favour and accuse Govt. of not good relations. And also by funding terrorist group at Pak. border.
      I hope Myanmar doesn't become like them.🙏

    • @RobandJenny
      @RobandJenny 3 роки тому +2

      👍

    • @Anonymous-lu7xr
      @Anonymous-lu7xr 3 роки тому +1

      @@sumitaggarwal6653 You are an imbecile to understand the depth of the matter. First of all the Myanmar is facing its own internal political issues which has nothing to do with India, like no shit. They are fighting among each other inside their own home. Myanmar has no hostility towards India. Now talking about foreign enemies the India has got only two close border opponents Pakistan and China. Whereas, on the other hand America has got plenty of enemies including Russia, Iran, North Korea and numerous terrorist organizations all over the globe. Finally regarding illegal immigrants, I would say not as many infiltrators come to America every month that many comes to India every week via Bangladesh.

    • @far-middle
      @far-middle 3 роки тому +3

      He's wrong about China supporting the anti junta militias, they use the m-16 from what Ive seen. China definitely supported the military Junta when the UNSC voted on what to do about Myanmar.

    • @Anonymous-lu7xr
      @Anonymous-lu7xr 3 роки тому +1

      @@far-middle China too makes copy of m-16 under Norinco. Here you go :-
      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norinco_CQ

  • @akremix9246
    @akremix9246 3 роки тому +446

    I was born in Myanmar bt I'm studying in India and my wish is to change Myanmar love u all my Indian friends ❤️

    • @windofchange7806
      @windofchange7806 3 роки тому +4

      aman is an Aryan name, konyak is a tribe of Nagaland, and u said u were born in Myanmar.
      i am so confused 🤣

    • @condorX2
      @condorX2 3 роки тому +5

      I hope Myanmar can get back to normal soon.
      I'm just curious on what it would be like if everyone welcome the army after the coup with flowers.
      An alternative ending sorta thing.

    • @akremix9246
      @akremix9246 3 роки тому +34

      @@windofchange7806 remember a little knowledge is dangers, half of Naga's are in Myanmar you don't even know..

    • @akremix9246
      @akremix9246 3 роки тому +6

      @john lee sorry bro I don't say Nagaland, I say naga's

    • @impressnewgeneration.4040
      @impressnewgeneration.4040 3 роки тому +11

      Yes huge numbers of Naga people are living in Myanmar even before Indian get independent. Pray for them they need freedom like us 🙏🙏🙏

  • @aakashrangarajan2122
    @aakashrangarajan2122 3 роки тому +89

    LEGEND. You're doing the work that our news channels failed to do - Educating Indians about current affairs and history.

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @suzieb8366
    @suzieb8366 3 роки тому +181

    I am from the UK and was trying to find out why the situation is so bad in Myanmar at the moment and you have enlightened and informed me very well...thank you for your efforts, much appreciated. Lets hope Myanmar can reach a peaceful settlement soon and stop this violence and killing.

    • @blesseddaughter2610
      @blesseddaughter2610 3 роки тому +6

      Bro/ sis u can watch movie THE LADY u will know mo about myanmar tq.

    • @pentagram3
      @pentagram3 3 роки тому +3

      I know you're from innocent Europe, but you do understand that politics doesn't work like that right?

    • @suzieb8366
      @suzieb8366 3 роки тому +5

      @@pentagram3 I have no idea what your referring to. You maybe somehow think that MY WISHES have something to do with my knowledge of politics?

    • @pentagram3
      @pentagram3 3 роки тому

      @@suzieb8366
      You could say that, yes

    • @suzieb8366
      @suzieb8366 3 роки тому +3

      @@pentagram3 How presumptuous of you lol :o) lol

  • @everjoylamin7916
    @everjoylamin7916 3 роки тому +51

    One of the rare videos that shed proper light on the situation in Myanmar. Good job Sir! best wishes!

  • @estherl7329
    @estherl7329 3 роки тому +205

    Sir, thanks. I'm from Myanmar. Your explanation super clear, thanks once again

    • @stuarthastie6374
      @stuarthastie6374 3 роки тому +6

      Is your Internet working?

    • @aijul22
      @aijul22 3 роки тому +6

      Do u remember Rohingya

    • @lfckaran
      @lfckaran 3 роки тому +5

      @@aijul22 didn’t ask

    • @indranildutta2961
      @indranildutta2961 3 роки тому +16

      @@aijul22 Rohingyas r Bangladeshis they don't even look like Burmese

    • @aijul22
      @aijul22 3 роки тому +5

      @@indranildutta2961 wow India me betke chutia giri mat kar sale kuch kitab history ka padle

  • @Viraj_2305
    @Viraj_2305 3 роки тому +39

    You are one of the best teacher on UA-cam for my upsc preparation...huge love and respect for you, Sir!

  • @aryananand8275
    @aryananand8275 3 роки тому +21

    How this gentleman explained nicely in lucid way.That's amazing. No usage of tough words.

  • @beinghomoeopath1678
    @beinghomoeopath1678 3 роки тому +337

    Words can't express how much we are lucky to have you Sir....

    • @EasyUpsc
      @EasyUpsc 3 роки тому +2

      Right

    • @DivyaAcademy17
      @DivyaAcademy17 3 роки тому +2

      may be you have a listening problem.

    • @EasyUpsc
      @EasyUpsc 3 роки тому +2

      @@DivyaAcademy17 it seems u have just read half sentence

    • @deveshkashyap8518
      @deveshkashyap8518 3 роки тому +1

      Right❤️❤️❤️

    • @mmjn97
      @mmjn97 3 роки тому

      Indeed!!

  • @ares3343
    @ares3343 3 роки тому +97

    Very interesting and clearly explained video. However, as someone from Myanmar I do have to disagree about China not benefiting from this military coup. With many countries placing sanctions against this military regime, it will be left with almost no international partners except maybe Russia and China who have historically always backed the junta. China will be able to have a lot more bargaining power against an internationally isolated military government in Myanmar, whereas the civilian government may not be as easily influenced because it would not be sanctioned and isolated like the military regime. China continuously blocks any attempt by the UN to take action about the current situation in Myanmar because it has A LOT to gain from an isolated military regime in Myanmar.

    • @Kuasarakyat2
      @Kuasarakyat2 2 роки тому

      Modi send arms to the Rohingya to destabilize Myanmar!! 🤷

    • @sheintoshan
      @sheintoshan 2 роки тому +1

      yeah! That's true.

    • @gohanlopez5330
      @gohanlopez5330 2 роки тому

      Inviting China and Russia to the un was a huge mistake

    • @banedemonn
      @banedemonn 2 роки тому +10

      @Ares
      Bro, your analysis is to the point.
      China has been using Myanmar as buffer state for it's own selfish reasons and for sustaining unrest in northeastern part of India. Myanmarese Junta has been duped by China and is also maintaining unrest in Myanmar. China has an eye on the gas and oil reserves of Myanmar to mitigate it's shortage back at home. Also, through Myanmar China is eyeing to secure it's Sea lines of communication (SLOC) through Indian Ocean region(IOR). Alongwith this they have cleverly taken Coco island on lease to tackle Indian growing Naval power in IOR. They are using this Coco Island to gather Intel on QUAD and Indian maritime activities. Favourable Myanmar government will also Help China in leasing out some crucial ports in Myanmar to reduce it's dependency on Malaca Strait.
      The bellicosity and hypocrisy of China is growing day by day despite facing economic backlash back a home.

    • @bhonemyatpaing8790
      @bhonemyatpaing8790 2 роки тому +3

      Yes it also true but it was
      economic gain for china
      cuz china is no.2 economy
      in the world and
      superpower state just like india which is our two
      powerful neighbours.
      China is not also historcially
      backer of junta. During
      Ne Win times in 60s .
      US supported Ne Win coup
      Cuz PM U Nu is neutral and
      also taking communists
      to not take arms. And U Nu
      is also strong oppose to
      KMT( present taiwan )
      troops in our country's Shan state . So U Nu oppose US aid and recongize Mao government in mainland china and together they fight
      KMT in Shan State.
      So US supported Ne Win coup. When Ne Win came to
      power he wanted to show
      that he was also not puppet of US. so he is called himself
      Socailist and closed economy and make some
      no good economic policies.
      And also in his time
      Military got from battlefield to run bussiness. They are
      soldiers and not bussinessmen. Their militaric mind and polices
      make myanmar very poor.
      But behind the scene
      Ne Win fought communists
      Like BCP which is supported by China Mao .
      Only Deng Xiaoping time
      When China got along with US to fight Soviet.
      Myanmar got friendly with China. Please my brother I am also
      From Myanmar and
      I want to see my country
      to rise from these poor situations but We need to know and learn history and facts . Don't think Who bad
      and who right . We must think for ourselevs.
      In order to good coruse for our country economically and stable and to gain opportunities we need
      both india and china .
      Think for our country
      brother

  • @calmdownandwakeup9352
    @calmdownandwakeup9352 3 роки тому +47

    I love the way you present the information in a way where you stick to facts and avoid making assumptions, or acknowledge where assumptions have been made.

  • @Bando.Lethwei
    @Bando.Lethwei 3 роки тому +102

    Thanks sir. Please don't ignore us. We are being slaughtered by millitary dogs on daily basis. You might only heard of rohingya case. In fact , all Myanmar people ( 135 ethnic groups ) suffered the same under millitary dictatorship. By the way Aung San Suu Kyi ( pronounces Aung Sann su kyee ) . Thanks sir.

    • @jordank4790
      @jordank4790 3 роки тому +16

      Times have changed. This coup will not last long. We are with you.

    • @ztll9272
      @ztll9272 2 роки тому +1

      @@jordank4790 lmao...

  • @Gramsciii
    @Gramsciii 3 роки тому +166

    Legend is back with another intellectual video

  • @justonebyte3972
    @justonebyte3972 3 роки тому +153

    I am Burmese and thanks indians a lot for vaccines. I also like to read indian books and movies

    • @desertstar7199
      @desertstar7199 3 роки тому +1

      Many people are dying from the vaccine you are all rats being tested how can you be so foolish? It took 6 months to make , please do your research of what is in the vaccine , it’s just a flu 99.99 curable news media is paid by Hollywood.
      This is Agenda21/30 One World Order they want to depopulate please research what is really going on save yourself and others .

    • @alfredawomi2340
      @alfredawomi2340 3 роки тому +5

      @@desertstar7199 WoW are you even for real, huh! Don't mix everything in one basket and try to differentiate between good and bad. Just don't comment for the sake of commenting!

    • @alfredawomi2340
      @alfredawomi2340 3 роки тому +5

      Only way to free your people's from the Military Junta's, a Hero or a leader must rise up from the Armed Forces itself like Middle Ranking Army Officers or a High Ranking General alikes and than arrest those military Generals responsible for the Coup, if such actions takes place the Myanmar People's and the whole world will support them and hail them as heroes.
      So, do try very hard to reach this message in the Army and alikes.
      Love from India!

    • @Zeunknown1234
      @Zeunknown1234 3 роки тому +4

      @@desertstar7199 Looks like you have some disorder in your brain

    • @justonebyte3972
      @justonebyte3972 3 роки тому

      @@alfredawomi2340 nah,you sugesstion sounds great but what you don't know is,it's not just the generals who are abusive but also soliders,they had a habit of abusing ethnics ppl so they are also part of this coup. They even thrratened us to shoot us with live rounds on tiktok videos. It's not just the coup leader but also all abusive soliders that we should wipe out for all the good of ethnics. So that scenario of herioc general wont work upon soliders who were killing ppl passionately.

  • @gayatriektate4042
    @gayatriektate4042 3 роки тому +98

    No nonsense.. pure learning...👍🏻👍🏻 your channel is very good..

  • @sandeepamsingh
    @sandeepamsingh 3 роки тому +10

    You are the only teacher, I never want to miss a single word. Explanation plus slides and its effects are just superb, sir. I watch your videos on repeat mode, that makes me hard to forget facts.

  • @torqsportz
    @torqsportz 3 роки тому +85

    Glad you did this video. India has significant interests in Sittwe port, Kaladan highway and Trilateral highway. China has military base in Coco island near Andaman as well as the Kyaukpyu island in Bay of Bengal. Nice video!

    • @stuarthastie6374
      @stuarthastie6374 3 роки тому

      Soon have strong naval presence in Bay of Bangladesh...

  • @abrarahmad6370
    @abrarahmad6370 3 роки тому +3

    I am from Bangladesh, and tnx for this brilliantly organized explanation.

  • @yespls4184
    @yespls4184 3 роки тому +5

    Just watched your video about volcano types and now I'm learning about the Myanmar coup. You're the best

  • @princeofeartth
    @princeofeartth 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for providing this video. I have tryed to search for many videos to explain Myanmar’s conflict but none have been this clear and concise.

  • @forrestchristy6631
    @forrestchristy6631 3 роки тому +9

    This was a lot more detail than I was looking for - however, it's also damn impressive Amit. Absolutely stunning work. I did know about Aung San Suu Kyi, but I had forgotten. Thank you for the effort. This is a truly awesome video for those who might want or need to know the particulars

  • @delimate
    @delimate 3 роки тому +8

    Thank you for explaining the situation to the world. It helps a LOT.

  • @zincwick99
    @zincwick99 3 роки тому +30

    Thank you for your informative breakdown. We do not get any details here in Canada. We just follow the US. Sad.

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (Social media blocked those explanations as NLD spends millions of dollars to get that privilege) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @htethtetphyowai1754
    @htethtetphyowai1754 3 роки тому +19

    Thank you for making this vdo sir 🙏🏼 now we need help from the world 😢

  • @zongora123
    @zongora123 3 роки тому +6

    The best presentation of this topic I have found so far ! Thanks a lot for sharing you work !

  • @Nongbak706
    @Nongbak706 3 роки тому +4

    It's very much informative..now I knew why military coup is going on in Myanmar..thank u Amit Sengupta guruji.

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @athaninodaa4079
    @athaninodaa4079 3 роки тому +384

    Please don't sell yourself to the unacademy : hahaha ...you are gem sir

    • @sprouts2371
      @sprouts2371 3 роки тому +19

      You predict at this extent 😂😂😂

    • @thelearningzone2360
      @thelearningzone2360 3 роки тому +14

      Really harsh reality of today all teachers go there

    • @sprouts2371
      @sprouts2371 3 роки тому +11

      @@thelearningzone2360 business bro business 😳😳

    • @tanishqvishwakarma5552
      @tanishqvishwakarma5552 3 роки тому +22

      whats wrong in using our knowledge to earn for a living?

    • @athaninodaa4079
      @athaninodaa4079 3 роки тому +1

      @@tanishqvishwakarma5552 quality is needed brother

  • @debabratakundu9602
    @debabratakundu9602 3 роки тому +9

    Excellent lecture. Thank you very much , Respected Sir. Please, keep on uploading more lectures for UPSC CSE Exam Preparation.

  • @rachelarela2131
    @rachelarela2131 3 роки тому +5

    Thank you for making this vid sir, now I understand why it went this far. I'm from PH and got totally curious when I watched the news about it. Hoping for the better in Myanmar

  • @vamshiabhilash
    @vamshiabhilash 3 роки тому +6

    Your channel is like video version of Ensoclypedia your doing an amazing job bro.. No bgm no nonsense just straight to the point

  • @WorldPeaceAlways
    @WorldPeaceAlways 3 роки тому +5

    Brilliantly explained with Maps. This will be of immense value to students of IR

  • @nandeeswargattu2729
    @nandeeswargattu2729 3 роки тому +9

    Now clear in my mind after long days to understand what is going on that counntry thank you sir

  • @surajthakur6897
    @surajthakur6897 3 роки тому +18

    Absolutely brilliant..
    Explanation 10 on 10
    ..

  • @nachannachle2706
    @nachannachle2706 3 роки тому +7

    Masterclass, Amitji.

  • @elowmao3737
    @elowmao3737 3 роки тому +18

    Very informative as usual. Strongly recommend this channel to lovers of domestic and international current affairs.

  • @ThePierre58
    @ThePierre58 3 роки тому +5

    I love this video. Beautifully explained and informative. Thank you!

  • @amanawasthi4760
    @amanawasthi4760 3 роки тому +27

    Amit sir first video first like. Please make videos on 2021 prelims. I request. And one more request please don't join " Unacdemy let's eat it"

  • @uzmakhan5770
    @uzmakhan5770 3 роки тому +2

    I have never seen someone explaining concepts with such clarity. Thankyou sir for all the lessons you've provided.

  • @kithan9491
    @kithan9491 3 роки тому +9

    So informative and satisfying, thank you so much

  • @imkongchingbaphom3352
    @imkongchingbaphom3352 3 роки тому +4

    Sir,
    I have been going through your every updates, really you're great. I was little bit confused about why Military Coup has happened in Myanmar all of a sudden, even after the election has been declared with majority. Keep going, we support you while you're more supportive, teacher and mentor to us..

  • @rebeccatun881
    @rebeccatun881 3 роки тому +15

    Thank you for letting the world know about this.

  • @jamespettinelli6953
    @jamespettinelli6953 3 роки тому +3

    This is really well put together and easy to follow. A pleasure to listen to your presentation.

  • @bubu5012
    @bubu5012 3 роки тому +5

    You are absolutely right 👍. As myanmar, Thank u v much as now i have a link to explain to other why coup happen in myanmar.

  • @blesseddaughter2610
    @blesseddaughter2610 3 роки тому +3

    Sir u got new subscriber! coz of ur crystal clear, clean and clear voice... Tq sir,lol from Arunachal Pradesh...

    • @blesseddaughter2610
      @blesseddaughter2610 3 роки тому

      @Tumge Bagra Memo hahaha... LoL.... Eastern most india mh hy....jisme aap b aata hy...hope u enjoying with my reply. Those who listen SENGUPTA SIR lecture are branded mind, hope u r one of them.

  • @manmathabal5117
    @manmathabal5117 3 роки тому +6

    Best explanation as always 💐 love you sir love from odisha❤

  • @apsk2207
    @apsk2207 2 роки тому +1

    I'm Myanmar and thanks you. Your information are the most accurate out here.

  • @vizotheunuo7969
    @vizotheunuo7969 3 роки тому +3

    Soo cleard and audible..thank you...

  • @vickyhelgren6972
    @vickyhelgren6972 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you for your time to explain this I was trying to find out what was going on and why. Sending prayers for everyone. From Canada.

  • @rejithsrk
    @rejithsrk 3 роки тому +3

    Never miss any video of yours , you are a gem...

  • @tibuuso
    @tibuuso 3 роки тому +14

    I would like to point out that most people from outside of Myanmar gave too much credit on the "US sanction" for the transition of the "Partial Democracy". However, most Myanmar would say that the military leader was getting too old to manage his subordinate and he didn't want to be sacked like most dictators when he gets to a certain age. So transition to partial democracy only happened as per his exit plan. He also didn't immediately handover the goverment to the civilian and excluded the leading party NLD to participate for the term of 2010 to 2016. Instead, he made all top generals to force retire for the preparation of the civilian government and made sure that his subordinates including Thein Sein to lead the civilian goverment.

  • @renegadekitten4861
    @renegadekitten4861 3 роки тому +13

    Thnk you so much for sharing 🙏❤️ 🇲🇲

  • @tasfiamahin5777
    @tasfiamahin5777 3 роки тому +3

    Thank you for this helpful video! I am an IR student and it was very informative to me.💜

  • @tayphilp
    @tayphilp 3 роки тому +4

    Thank you very much , Mr Amit, for this clear explanation of the situation now in Myanmar. Kudos to your effort !!! :)))

  • @aungkyawkyaw5315
    @aungkyawkyaw5315 3 роки тому +5

    Thanks for sharing about my country sir🙏🏻many myanmar people were killed and arrested before like 8888 uprising in 1988 and saffron revolution in 2007.In this time we must win.
    #savemyanmar
    #wewantdemocracy

  • @rti020
    @rti020 3 роки тому +3

    So happy to be ur subscriber!! ❤️

  • @bharatbhushan8790
    @bharatbhushan8790 3 роки тому +1

    You are the best teacher on digital platform. The way you speak and having deep knowledge make us understand very clearly.

  • @Ratnabhsl
    @Ratnabhsl 3 роки тому +18

    Thank you for this explainer! I’m Nepalese Burmese and my husband is British Indian. He’s not very familiar with the Burmese politics and had been asking me to explain everything that’s going on. It’s such a complicated issue that I didn’t know where to start! I’ll forward this video for him.
    Well done in pronouncing Min Aung Hlaing. It isn’t an easy name to pronounce. Also, the “Kyi” in Aung San Suu Kyi, it’s “chi” as in “chillar (change in Hindi).

    • @sss-kd9md
      @sss-kd9md 3 роки тому

      What will your children be? Indo-Burmese-Brit-Nepali?

    • @Taporeee
      @Taporeee 3 роки тому +1

      @@sss-kd9md Her Children will be legendary

    • @sss-kd9md
      @sss-kd9md 3 роки тому

      @@Taporeee indeed.

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

    • @Taporeee
      @Taporeee 3 роки тому +1

      @@ပြောရဦးမယ် Sources?

  • @thantthirioo6147
    @thantthirioo6147 2 роки тому

    This is one of the best and simplest explanations about Myanmar's situation so far posted on UA-cam!

  • @BoyProdigyX
    @BoyProdigyX 3 роки тому +6

    This was very well done and thoroughly explained. Kudos!

  • @jayaprakashmanchi
    @jayaprakashmanchi 3 роки тому +8

    Wonderful information. I was really looking for this much information on google. Before that i got full details here. Thanks Amit

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @type_Kizuna
    @type_Kizuna 3 роки тому +7

    This was quite informative for me bc I was a bit confused what exactly happened there. It's kind of sad that there are people who still get killed in this point of time. I'm from a developed country so I don't get to see people trying to survive on a daily basis but I think that it's important to know what happens in the world.

  • @anant8342
    @anant8342 3 роки тому +2

    Amazing! Please keep this up. Loved how you also show screen shots of which news article you are referring to build credibility.

  • @neenuk1222
    @neenuk1222 3 роки тому +4

    Informative without ad's. Great one sir

  • @howtobuildwealth1016
    @howtobuildwealth1016 3 роки тому +3

    Very well form put videos with detail graphical representation. Great Job!

  • @richardho8283
    @richardho8283 3 роки тому +3

    Thank you for sharing your research and analysis. It is well delivered. Congratulations. We are benefiting from you.

  • @SavageMontreal
    @SavageMontreal 3 роки тому +1

    Great video. Excellent work with the timelines and visual aids. You made it all very clear. Thanks.

  • @oyinmodi6179
    @oyinmodi6179 3 роки тому +5

    Sir,,
    I'm post graduate in geography.. I have read about Amit sengupta in regional geography. Sir, are you that person ??
    Sir , your teaching wonderful.. thank you sir

  • @a.m8858
    @a.m8858 3 роки тому +1

    Wow, I had very little idea from media stories and now am fascinated! Amazing video

  • @iasvaishnavimishra6847
    @iasvaishnavimishra6847 3 роки тому +3

    Your voice is so soothing and the way you teach is amazing.
    Pure learning

  • @earlnoli
    @earlnoli 3 роки тому +1

    wow. best geopolitical analysis i have seen for this military coup.
    Thank you.

  • @Priyanka-623
    @Priyanka-623 3 роки тому +7

    Thank you, sir, for the clear explanation

  • @rinaroy7629
    @rinaroy7629 3 роки тому +1

    Only to listen your voice i have started studying civil service ..😘😘 thank you

  • @deostar60
    @deostar60 3 роки тому +4

    Sequentially well elaborated...to the point..

  • @angelriporapthap2919
    @angelriporapthap2919 Рік тому

    Seriously being a social science teacher this vid helps me to broaden my mind...thank you sir

  • @vintiagrawal476
    @vintiagrawal476 3 роки тому +11

    Pro tip: Whenever having a headache just listen to his voice, and the headache will soothe itself. Petition to make him the voice of male google assisstant and male siri.🥺❤️🥺❤️🥺❤️🥺❤️

    • @banothupraveennaik9343
      @banothupraveennaik9343 3 роки тому

      hat male voice..sir is not slave of americans ## Indian has ability to show brown supremacy ## rather white supremacy

    • @yespls4184
      @yespls4184 3 роки тому

      Right?! I find his voice very relaxing. Indian accents in general I find really soothing

  • @eonaalythia8525
    @eonaalythia8525 3 роки тому +4

    This is very detailed explanation! Thank you

  • @vinayverma1821
    @vinayverma1821 3 роки тому +5

    Gud evening Amit sir thanks a lot for this video , please make a video on NAM(Non alligned movement and it's relevant in today scenario)

  • @jothong1929
    @jothong1929 3 роки тому

    Veey clear ..thank you Sir

  • @AboiToday
    @AboiToday 3 роки тому +4

    Well Done & Thank You for being informative.

  • @frankb2602
    @frankb2602 3 роки тому +5

    Another precise assessment. Thank you, sir!

  • @lemvaiphei7779
    @lemvaiphei7779 3 роки тому +4

    What an insightful information! Thanks alot.
    I am in love with your contents.

  • @sarahdagrosa7944
    @sarahdagrosa7944 3 роки тому +1

    Honestly, fantastic video! Really well explained, easy to follow, great graphics. Perfect. Thank you for your hard work!

  • @georgejoseph3299
    @georgejoseph3299 3 роки тому +4

    This was so useful for my UWC application!

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @ShubhamSharma-jw1to
    @ShubhamSharma-jw1to 3 роки тому

    Sir i am watching you teaching first time. And the effective way you adopt to teach. It is incredible. Great job sir Thank you so much

  • @minhan2990
    @minhan2990 3 роки тому +25

    I am from Myanmar. Thanks for making this video, Mr.Amit. If you could add the posittions of leaders according to constitution of Myanmar, it would be so much helpful to open new eyes. (According to constitution, No one is on the head of General, not even president.) Thank you, I wish to see your upcoming research videos.

    • @nupurgautam1
      @nupurgautam1 3 роки тому +2

      Hope you guys stay safe. Sending you good wishes from India...

    • @oggypilestro6343
      @oggypilestro6343 3 роки тому

      You people deserve everything you're experiencing amd more

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      (It is not true that General is more senior than the president. President, 2 VP's, Speakers of two parliamentary chambers, 'illogical' state counselor, sr. general, etc.) It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @kenliboje012
    @kenliboje012 3 роки тому

    As i saw a pic of the Myanmar refugee then started searching yt for what's happening there, after a couple of videos here i am, u do make super understable of it...thnx a lot👏

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @salmankhandeshmukh
    @salmankhandeshmukh 3 роки тому +17

    Sir Please Make A Video On 15th FINANCE COMMISSION Recommendations.

  • @mangnuraj
    @mangnuraj 2 роки тому

    great infomation. Im a burmese. I didn't know most of the information untill this video. fighting!!!

  • @269211
    @269211 3 роки тому +4

    Great presentation, clears up the complete situation

  • @iCitizenTube
    @iCitizenTube 3 роки тому +2

    Excellent geopolitical analysis. You should produce another video on the specific issue of the religious aspect of Myanmar problems and the real story of the Rakin state.

  • @KakashiHatake-sw2sy
    @KakashiHatake-sw2sy 3 роки тому +30

    Come on man , Myanmar saw peace only after 2016 & then here we are again.

    • @minato3297
      @minato3297 3 роки тому +1

      yes, we start knowing what is happening in the world just after 2016.Now military want to brainwash us again.

    • @maryclayton2983
      @maryclayton2983 3 роки тому

      Bs. Easy mission disarm.

    • @golammorshed7260
      @golammorshed7260 3 роки тому

      Lol it was not peace when they slaughtered hundreds of ethnic minorities

    • @jirfe
      @jirfe 3 роки тому

      What about rohanya peoples

    • @joni1405
      @joni1405 3 роки тому

      There was never peace. There's been continued war in Kachin State and the Rohingya ethnic cleansing/war with the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army. Peace only existed for the Burmese, the army was still fighting everyone else.

  • @inco9943
    @inco9943 3 роки тому +2

    watching from the UK - great channel !

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @aungkha5868
    @aungkha5868 3 роки тому +5

    As a Burmese I can assure you almost all facts in the video is genuine and really reflect what’s happening on ground. The only wrong thing in the video is MM junta and China have close ties. MM top generals were importing jades, Ruby and timber illegally to China and benefiting a lot from it. They also allowed China to contract deep sea ports and dams, in exchange for enormous bribes. Also China FM met With junta just a few days before the coup, in which most believe the junta asked for china’s veto at the UN Security Council. In conclusion China is in huge favour of the coup, as it can do what ever it want in MYANMAR exchange for bribing the army generals.

  • @Manjitkumar-jo8tj
    @Manjitkumar-jo8tj 3 роки тому +2

    First i love your voice,second content is perfect and third way of explanation is superb.

  • @oldyeller9849
    @oldyeller9849 3 роки тому +5

    It’s interesting how so many of us now find we no longer trust reporting from Yahoo, Al Jazzera, CNN or even BBC and come to sources like Amit to find out what’s really going on. Thank you for this excellent analysis sir!

  • @Kupar_1
    @Kupar_1 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir🙌🙌😇..This helps me alot..keep going

  • @preetikaushik1333
    @preetikaushik1333 3 роки тому +9

    Ur voice is so mesmerizing ,l got to ur video by chance and now l m regularly following it

  • @Hari-hg5km
    @Hari-hg5km 3 роки тому +1

    Your videos are very helpful for my geography preparation. Thank you so much sir.

  • @gmailgmail1010
    @gmailgmail1010 3 роки тому +3

    very informative, and quite neutral. Let Myanmar handle its own affairs, 'cause seems there's not a better way. I think the world will just have to wait.

    • @ပြောရဦးမယ်
      @ပြောရဦးမယ် 3 роки тому

      It's good that he has compiled the history, geography and some known facts about Burma’s politics. However, he spoiled the good work inserting totally false assumptions that are very important to explain the current conditions. Who told him that there are "no evidence of voter fraud or malpractice"? Everybody could see voting irregularities in detail in which more than ten million votes were illegally channeled into National League for Democracy's column. (NLD spends millions of dollars to get access privilege to block news in social media.) In hundreds of townships, more votes were cast than the voting population, hundreds of thousands of people voted for NLD thrice or twice and also dead and illegal people voted. The assumption that members of the main opposition party voted for NLD is ridiculous. As a matter of fact, more than 24 opposition parties complained with the army about the dirty tricks of the ruling party NLD well before the elections. After the elections also, they asked the army to intervene in the disputes because the army should be the honest broker who initially transferred power to NLD after 2015 elections. There were demonstrations in many towns by thousands of people against elections fraud.
      Due to complicated political conditions, the Burmese army has to take over the reign of the country a few times after Burma’s independence in 1948 and then held free and fair elections that elected civilian political parties with NLD being the last one. Political observers widely predicted before the 2020 elections that NLD would win the elections but it won't retain the majority due to failures during its five years in power. It will have to invite one or more coalition partners to achieve the majority. NLD leader Aung San Suu Kyi, although she is a carpetbagger, is so dictatorial and arrogant that she would by no means accept any coalition partners. The party discreetly decided to steal votes even to the consternation of the Elections Commission which testified later that they didn't own the whole voter lists. At the request of more than two dozen opposition parties, the army asked the NLD to explain the irregularities a few times. The NLD neglected them and remained mums for three months. When the NLD pushed ahead to convene a parliament and form a new NLD government without any clarification, the army asked the first vice-president to transfer power temporarily to the army in accordance with the constitution. NLD leaders were then arrested. The army promised to hold a free and fair election in a year.

  • @Ritiz_Singh
    @Ritiz_Singh 3 роки тому +1

    Greatest of Greatest Explanation👌🏻👌🏻 All view points cleared and well analyses