WOW! I'm 64 years old and I just had a very thorough history lesson that absolutely was not only very detailed and educational but also astounding regarding the involvement of the U.S. Government Intelligence Agencies! 😲😲😲😲
I would say that Terrorism is only created by Pakistan and also West's blunder by providing supplies and arms to them. Not only West but also China, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and even Egypt and Israel also. India knows it very well. Even though they defeated USSR but Western countries had thrown themselves on the mess.
It's very polite of the Narrator to pick up the thread inserting ' Osama Bin Ladin'.....I suppose this keeps his spot in the Algorithm. But by now , with very few pomp and whistles ringing , you must realize you are giving OBL...status of a magician who just by ...(?)..... challenged the whole West . As it is both countries are a shamble of cards toppling and now a vacuum. OBL long gone ......Suicide bombing ended.( Actually that makes 0 sense then and now would be making sense , l guess Islam no longer dreams of Virgins in heaven , with so much porn via Phone ) This is the saddest story on Earth . God cannot be happy about it.
not only this, he also predicted the western economic (oil) crisis due to it’s sanctions on Russia look at the irony west wanted to create economic crisis in Russia instead it backlashed on west itself question is when will the west learn their lessons, stop interfering with other nations and making conflicts for their own gains
I’ve been trying to wrap my head around what’s happening and why it happened and no other news outlet came even close to what I learned from your video. SUBSCRIBED
As an American I can see that my 16+ years of education was equivalent to about three or four years wherever you were taught. No universities in the USA will hire you because their students would not need to sit through years of classes for what you can deliver in one half hour. Thanks so much. KY. USA.
@mic mic bungee tenth grade......? Some of this... Most of this was not included in two separate classes at University level. Total cost $300usd in 1978. Now it would cost over $1000usd for less information and 14 weeks in classes for an hour a a day. USA = education for profit. Just like our wars.
@a unlike some people who have no self awareness and constantly serve as an example of how NOT to be... Some of us are pointing out the areas for improvement.... Not left, not right..... FORWARD
I get disheartened what university education is in a first world country. The content is usually thought at highschool level in some undeveloped countries.
This information is available in open source but it is so peppered all over the place it is hard to make sense of it. Great way to put the puzzle together.
I must say this is very informative i appreciate ur knowledge. I am indian/bangladesh descent born in the states and served in the u.s. navy for 15 years. I was their in afghanistan for 10 month. One thing i woukd say many west need to understand is their islamic ideology. Despite the political issue by govt, they fail to understand that u cant make a muslim nation become democratic over night. As a former muslim i know well of their mindset. The islamic text says in their koran, by law, they can not be friends with non muslims unless it benefits them. Im sure u heard the word "taqqiya" alot. Which is also we see the many problem with muslims in europe as they grow u see their true colors come out. I luv the fact that u brought up it was pakistan that created isis and al quida because for so long muslims that dont wanna accept the truth of their ideology will say the u.s. made isis and al quida when they are doing exactly what their ideology teaches.
A great video. Thank you for creating it and sharing that impressive timeline. We could never expect that level of strategic thought from our mainstream media. USA
Throughout the world Russ, in every country they associate with, it's always U.S. self interests all the way, regardless, heartlessly. It's the powers that be Russ. The American people don't have a clue about this and often wonder why they are hated worldwide.
I like how you mentioned cinematic pieces being used to alter perception. A lot of people don’t even realize it. For example, US movies made in Hollywood used to be good stories but in 1994 when a movie came out showing the oppressive nature of the Chinese Communist Party, China threatened the entire US movie industry. They threatened to no longer provide exports of cheap products needed for creating movies to the US and so the entire movie industry spread the word that no depiction of China is authorized without running it by China first. Think for a sec, when have you ever seen a movie in the last 20 years that didn’t show China as some super metropolis with highly advanced technology. It’s all a farce. There’s no telling what else we’ve been shown indirectly that has molded our perceptions
@@samuelmontypython8381 Well, people don’t need much to survive… In all seriousness, what most people do in their lives are within the government’s boundaries. When I said the illusion of freedom, I meant the freedom of thought and access of information.
@@xtzhao2196 but do you understand what would happen then? War. This is the case we often see in history when it comes to countries with elections. That’s how hitler came into power. And what about now? We have the United States, and it’s been at war (direct and proxy)… most of the time. You think the us’s collapse will come without some kind of conflict? The us is already in a proxy war with Russia.
Very insightful, and very sad what is happening now in Afghanistan. The average American would never want to see our allies and helpful friends in harm's way. I'm horrified at the way this withdrawal has been handled.
Misery mongers what is it We wonder why the world is such a mess all us so called Plebs would rather live in peace but whether it's Britain and France in the first world war double dealing the Jews and the Arabs or further down the path America and Russia it seems that we seem to always burden with A class of meglamaniac Who endorse their will on the Smaller countries and now you,ve got a new wolf warrier player on the block I,ve got an idea they should all piss off and let people live in peace Hey I,m not that naive I know that there is only one son of man who can ever bring peace to this world of ours ( yes my choice of words was on purpose ) when I said " Son of Man peace for his sake or else some fool could get it into their heads to Push I,m not going any further I think we all understand the consequences
That was an amazing journey of things I learned just now. Mind blown. I have been following the events in Afghanistan & have not heard anything as insightful as your video. Thank you, I will be watching more of your videos in the future.
Not all the news channels, nor all the political analysts and experts succeeded in helping me understand this complex situation in the way that THIS presenter has. Take a bow, Amit!
@@karthik_k.j not exactly, but we believe in what is said rather than what is true. My point is if we don’t have any issues inside our country(peace & prosperity) then our image will grow in front of other countries. Just an example why people from India move to US and never return?
@@prakashkumar-gf8by Well Pakistan is a terrorist nation. And problem is not that India or Pakistan is poor. Many countries are poor, like Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam etc but they don't sponsor terrorism, like Pakistan does
Great explanation! I'm laughing so hard at "Pakistan is the founding fathers of all the Afghan chaos" 😂 Also, never thought that the Pakistani are great businessman, it created demand when its service as a war-broker no longer needed by training those religious militancy in Afghanistan and Kashmir. The way I see it, they outsmarted the US for 20 years..
It might flatter the Pakistani's to think they out smarted the US for that long. But the US never trusted Pakistan to begin with and both sides had clear sight of exactly how far to trust each other. The US had to balance the need to 'ally' with Pakistan to have air bases, etc while attempting to defeat AQ and the Taliban. The US knew full well that the Pakistani governments were playing both sides at the same time. An opinion reinforced when it turned out Usama had been hiding in Pakistan for years!
They always do that.... The american know that, but let it happens . Because there are corruptions inside the CIA. They gave money also to afganistan. Billions. Some going to CIA pockets. They just dont care if afgan only has ghost army... They know, but dont care
@@johnsmith-mv8hq they know, but they go along for 20 years. Using US tax money to support afgan gaverment and pakustan goverment because some of the money going to CIA, president of the US pocket.
Well if we no longer take moral and ethics in consideration , then yes , Pakistan will even sell their wife for money. But what they don't know that taliban are noncalculable this strategi is coming back to bite them .
Super informative! I've always been confused about the whole Afghan debacle but now more in the loop thanks to this very interesting and informative vid. Many thanks.
I've always wanted to use time lines in history debates....but was too confused by the amount detail and chronology to sift through. You have inspired me ...thank you
Yes. I was living in the region since about 2000-2001..for about ten years...all this about Pakistan sponsoring terrorism is spot on.... My home near Islamabad was not far from Osama's home in Pakistan..my home in Kashmir was right in the midst of other terrorist organizations..I spent much time in Murree...I've understood all this for years...but you have done an excellent job of vocalizing it very well... I have a new theory, that Biden is trying to get us out of the region completely and focus on opening all of Central and South America ..hence the wide-open borders..
Seems to me you were all over the place. Absence of Evidence Is Not Evidence of Absence. Once they were found in the White House with your president Ronald Reagan with a tag of " like a founding fathers of America" .
🤣 Murree is in punjab not is kashmir. Osama was in Abbottabad not in Islamabad. Bro are you dumb that Pakistan would terrorists homes among normal citizens?
Once upon a time " Terrorists and Taliban" are called Mujahideens because they were fighting for USA & CIA against Soviet Union. They were funded, trained and weaponized by CIA and YES Pakistan made big mistake by getting involved in it, but not anymore, ABSOLUTELY NOT. Osama once the favorite mujahid of CIA was living in Abbottabad and not in Islamabad.
I would say that Terrorism is only created by Pakistan and also West's blunder by providing supplies and arms to them. Not only West but also China, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and even Egypt and Israel also. India knows it very well. Even though they defeated USSR but Western countries had thrown themselves on the mess.
AlhumduliAllah, Taliban are great warriors and just human beings,they deserve to govern the Afghanistan totally on Islamic system based on peace,mercy and justice. Believe me Islam gives more respect and love to women than the West.For Taliban about women watch their interviews and don't fall in propaganda. Taliban has the potential to maintain peace and justice in Afghanistan. Long live Taliban Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan May Almighty Allah help Taliban in establishing the Islamic system in Afghanistan and may Almighty ALLAH bless them with ultimate mercy, happiness, health, wealth,peace and many more beautiful blessings. Regards, Peace and justice lover. Anti-oppression and just person.
did you even understand and watch the whole video?? lol at the end its a clear strategy to leave. why? who are afghanistans neighbouring countries?? the enemies of the US. why not unleash the wildlings on them! lol
@@thewildcardperson The USA is a great country. Unfortunately your current President and it's administration is a total xxxx xx(words removed to avoid being banned).
My understanding what happened in Afghanistan is the result of geopolitical interest between USSR and US at first place, as a child growth in 80's I watched TV a lot alongside with my family and our favorite was news, world news broadcasted by gov't TV. It's almost everyday we heard about the Kabul situation and Mujahiddin groups. But never really understood the complexity of the Afghan issue in such details. Thank you Sir for making the video, this is world history lesson which every history teacher and student should know. Now I can argue people who blames US exit causing the chaos in Afghanistan.
I've been in the process of researching and pursuing information myself to understand as best as I can this situation. I will continue to view more after this video. I agree with you! I've researched many different sources so far with different perspectives and narratives. So far this video is a culmination of everything I've come across with the exception of a few. Of course they were a more American leaning perspective. I'm only a quarter way through this video so far!
@@mangokane11 America is adept at narrative building using Western media, Hollywood etc... whilst the guys on the other side use their own channels to float their agenda packaged in a way that attracts a lot of sympathy, so most of the articles the we see ends up being biased either way. However, I felt the person who made this video has tried to analyse the issue objectively. Whilst it does not answer all the questions, it readies your mind to think in the right direction...
@@lj7149 yup. It's about emotions right? Emotions are very powerful and also easily susceptible to manipulation because of the thought process being affected or " triggered " causing irrationality. Too bad most people don't understand that as you do! Stay aware and safe! Aloha!
@@jijyat7956 Its not about idea , its about view point and he explained his point with proofs and fact . And this shows, how ignorant of you for not to welcome other people's opinion. As far as my idea is concern , I pretty much agree to his ideology, unless you have a more solid point to proof against it.
Man after 1 year of Taliban take over everything you said in this video is proving to be right. Tehreeke Taliban is kicking ass of Pakistanis left right and center. USA is again involved in another indirect conflict with Russia using Ukraine as a proxy. India is providing aid to Afghanistan and China is building relations.
I love this video! So logically based and insightful. I plan to build a historical event database to run pred analytics for situations like this. Going to write a textbook and curriculum called history's mysteries. I hope to start on it soon in my free time.
🙏 such crystal story explaination. Just woww. Bringing up Vietnam story as that really effected the thoughts. Thank you for good content and lots of hours into it. Extraordinary work with map learning, history and everything. Thank you so much
Thank you for explaining this, very detailed explanation and insight. This has never been taught in our high schools despite its importance in our understanding of the Middle East and the world.
Everyone who did a little research and knows about Afghanistan knew that Afghanistan will go into the hands of the Taliban. Nothing surprising there Anuj.
@@thestoryofindia9357 They took over Afghanistan because of one thing...... Joe Biden's incompetence. This wouldn't of happened if Trump had still been in office. Ask Soleimani why
@@ToolFist598 Matt, everyone was expecting Kabul to fight back and show resistance at least for a few months. Without any logistics, pay, and direction the Afghan forces gave up and went back home. There were people who told the U.S that they need to train a more diverse army. The majority of the Afghan army is Pashtun and the majority of the Taliban is Pashtun. The only hope is the vice president of Afghanistan Ammrullah Saleh who did not flee and will not! He is in Panjshir valley gathering a resistance force with the sons of late ''Lion of Panjshir'' Ahmad Shah Massoud.
@@thestoryofindia9357 Because a major part of the training they received required air support from the US but Joe Biden wouldn't even allow that to happen or even allow contractors in to work on aircraft for them. This current US admin is an emberrassment to our country and I feel sorry for the civilians over there that are suffering the consequences of our current inept, corrupt administration.
Many Americans wanted our soldiers out of Afghanistan after it was clear the goal went from revenge to Nation building after 2yrs in. Once Pakistan coughed up Bin Laden, the US citizens really petitioned for our troops to get out. The majority doesn't care what other countries are doing. Now I'm even more weary of that last round of $10M for gender studies.🤔 This has got to be the best summary of our stupidity thus far! Great job and keep putting all these amazing historical lessons. 👍
India will divide in to 28 pieces,,,at the moment half kashmir administered by pakistan and occupied other half by india any time pakistan will capture it by sending nuclear missiles towards india...godi media gay hindus love Pakistan from Dhaka Mirpur Bangladesh ♥♥♥♥
I was constantly checking your Chennal, For this analysis! it's just amazing sir ❤️ Please keep posting Geopolitical Videos more frequently 😁, these are far far better then any Bollywood movie.
Thanks a lot sir, I have watched western TV for years and never understood things like you have explained in 60 minutes. It's like 2 years of western TV equals to 60mins from you clear and precise
Yes, albeit, biased just as every and as much as the media. Presenter touts the Pakistna and India war as liberation of Bangladesh when it was the wicked Indira Gandhi which spearheaded those efforts to cause weakness in a young nation. The Khalistan movement he credits Pakistan with, well he failed to mention how India used Sikhs to fight their dirty wars against Muslim Pakistan and the sand bagged them. Over time when the Sikh community reozed the game, they started the movement for an I dependent Punjab State. Additionally, as an American, I am also offended that now the USA has pulled out of Afghanistan, India is crying foul foul...but is more than happy to lick our boots for their own agenda and toss us aside when they feel Daddy isn't paying tgel much attention. In the end, its every nation for itself and I get that, but it is sickening to see people such as this presenter who comes across as if he is providing accurate and unbiased facts, when it is just like anything else, muddled with biased propaganda with half truths.
@@MrSoothsayer हमें पढाया कक्षाओं में भी जाता है फिर भी हम संस्थानों और शिक्षकों से नोट्स की आशा करते जैन क्योंकि उनके लेखन में हमारे तुलना में अंतर पाया जाता है ।
In my humble opinion, the withdrawal of the US forces is a clear strategy. When the US forces were there in Afghanistan, the neighbours of Afghanistan i.e Iran, Pakistan, China, central Asian countries backed by the Russians were playing cat and mouse game with the American using Taliban which is more or less a loose cannon. Now, the US turned the tables in them by putting the problem of instability into the playground of Afghanistan's neighbours. Further, the US sitting remotely can use tribal warloads and factions of the Taliban to create problems for Afghanistan's neighbours in a cost effective manner and not putting their men on the ground. Here, India is the biggest loser as of now. India needs to prepare for the worst and prepare for war in an extreme situation.
@marigold well put. The grand strategy of the US is to prevent coalitions of power. The US does this by strategic interventions from Central America to the Middle East, and soon will reach into space. The “deep state” thing is laughable but ironically somewhat correct- American grand strategy on a global scale transcends party lines in US politics. The strategy will remain as long as the US has no rival superpower on the scale of the USSR. And please don’t start with China as that rival… the rival cannot be economically dependent on its foe.
@@AmitKumar-zy9ug Trump was executing American grand strategy that has been in place since the 1940’s. Smart? Maybe in that he saw the obvious conclusion and went with it - but then his hated rival Biden executed on that deal. Why? Because it fits the strategy. So I don’t call him smart but it was probably the obvious and right choice to do a deal.
Great video. Though I don't agree with you on 2 points- 1. Taliban will give a 'payback' to Pakistan- They completely are hand in gloves with PK govt. The reason is that the PK air force and army are currently helping the Taliban via cross-boundary operations to overtake the AF govt. Sunni majoritarianism is another common point. 2. Taliban don't care about Uyghur Muslims/Balochs - they have realised that the most important thing is 'survival', which requires capital/resources(which China via PK can provide them). Taliban structure is mostly of a tribal clan (local heads at district level), this will lead to no 'centralised ideology' resulting in widespread corruption (here China can come in). India should stay alert at this point, for the tip of scale can shift to either side.
1) not completly true, watch youtube channel called Defensive offence by Major Gaurav Arya, he shared groud about this topic, 2) some what agree with you 95%, rest there is possiblity some of members dont listen and could start movment, if some kind of movment started it would be hard for china, thats why they already met taliban few days back would have made agreements
You take your own time in making content and it is totally worth the wait. I am no professional to comment on your fact checking but the feeling it invokes to know more about stuff is what makes you stand apart. Suggestion- whatever you show in the video, could be posted on the website too. It will be really handy for reference. Thank you :)
@Faz Assir 😃😃 you are so brave man. He is a terrorist minded.. let him give one small answer why pakistan never develops until now and not going to develop even in future. If they spent all the money and aid from US for their development , they would not be in shitty state. Every paisa they invest in terrorism only.. karma will come back..
Yes, this is just what I have been looking for. Please start a news channel that just takes you through the major points and history of each of the conflicts in the world. When any big news breaks just give us the breakdown (This'll make you rich). The news articles online are just rambling nonsense. They're difficult to understand, there is no depth, they don't answer the important questions and they usually have a political agenda. Use a timeline like you did, give the major plot points and motifs of the players involved, and the resolution of how the situation has come to be in the present. Please give us the real facts. Thank you, great video.
He does that whenever he gets time. He basically teaches Civil Service aspirants in India and we have a paper of International studies under which we need to understand & know major international events and geopolitical shift. And world history to some extent.
Excellent video & information! Complicated but very well & clearly explained! Thank you! I never knew all of that but now I do! 🙂👍🦅 Personally, I surely pray & hope for more Worldwide Peace! May G-d help US All! 😇🕊
WOW! I'm 64 years old and I just had a very thorough history lesson that absolutely was not only very detailed and educational but also astounding regarding the involvement of the U.S. Government Intelligence Agencies! 😲😲😲😲
What's so astonishing? The US has the track record of nurturing terrorist groups and having that backfire on its people.
Ya thanks for making this video . It's very detailed and too the point. No filler just substance.
I would say that Terrorism is only created by Pakistan and also West's blunder by providing supplies and arms to them. Not only West but also China, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and even Egypt and Israel also. India knows it very well. Even though they defeated USSR but Western countries had thrown themselves on the mess.
Dang! Same here. I’m 73, a former history major, and i ain’t never got a history lesson like this… what a waste of time and money 💰
30:37, OMG...........Amit you predicated it much before the Ukraine - Russia conflict. Hats off to your intelligence.
It's very polite of the Narrator to pick up the thread inserting ' Osama Bin Ladin'.....I suppose this keeps his spot in the Algorithm. But by now , with very few pomp and whistles ringing , you must realize you are giving OBL...status of a magician who just by ...(?)..... challenged the whole West . As it is both countries are a shamble of cards toppling and now a vacuum. OBL long gone ......Suicide bombing ended.( Actually that makes 0 sense then and now would be making sense , l guess Islam no longer dreams of Virgins in heaven , with so much porn via Phone )
This is the saddest story on Earth . God cannot be happy about it.
did he tho?
damn, great prediction, great intellect 👏🏻
not only this, he also predicted the western economic (oil) crisis due to it’s sanctions on Russia
look at the irony west wanted to create economic crisis in Russia instead it backlashed on west itself
question is when will the west learn their lessons, stop interfering with other nations and making conflicts for their own gains
@@Kenneth_James lol just look at the video
30:36 You predicted the Ukraine situation at that exact moment! You are very trustworthy! Keep it up!!!
Noticed the same.
Yep and he also predicted about taliban will give payback to Pakistan for using them for years and it's happening.good analysis based on facts
I’ve been trying to wrap my head around what’s happening and why it happened and no other news outlet came even close to what I learned from your video. SUBSCRIBED
Thank you...and your voice is awesome...
Where you been living under a rock?
As an American I can see that my 16+ years of education was equivalent to about three or four years wherever you were taught. No universities in the USA will hire you because their students would not need to sit through years of classes for what you can deliver in one half hour. Thanks so much. KY. USA.
India is packed with such brilliant minds.....I m proud to ba an Indian
@mic mic bungee tenth grade......? Some of this... Most of this was not included in two separate classes at University level. Total cost $300usd in 1978. Now it would cost over $1000usd for less information and 14 weeks in classes for an hour a a day. USA = education for profit. Just like our wars.
@a unlike some people who have no self awareness and constantly serve as an example of how NOT to be... Some of us are pointing out the areas for improvement.... Not left, not right..... FORWARD
I get disheartened what university education is in a first world country. The content is usually thought at highschool level in some undeveloped countries.
I LOVE AMIT SIR SOOOO MUCH 📩💳📤✉️📤📤💸
Nice work breaking down an incredibly complicated geopolitical situation into easily digestible bits.
This information is available in open source but it is so peppered all over the place it is hard to make sense of it. Great way to put the puzzle together.
Well done! What a wonderful explanation. I wasn't even bored for a second. Wish history can be taught in the same manner in schools.
Indeed. Same for me.Great people
I must say this is very informative i appreciate ur knowledge. I am indian/bangladesh descent born in the states and served in the u.s. navy for 15 years. I was their in afghanistan for 10 month. One thing i woukd say many west need to understand is their islamic ideology. Despite the political issue by govt, they fail to understand that u cant make a muslim nation become democratic over night. As a former muslim i know well of their mindset. The islamic text says in their koran, by law, they can not be friends with non muslims unless it benefits them. Im sure u heard the word "taqqiya" alot. Which is also we see the many problem with muslims in europe as they grow u see their true colors come out. I luv the fact that u brought up it was pakistan that created isis and al quida because for so long muslims that dont wanna accept the truth of their ideology will say the u.s. made isis and al quida when they are doing exactly what their ideology teaches.
You are absolutely right sir.
Al Qaeda and lS are products of Saudi Arabian religiou - geopolitical policy
My man on point love from India
A great video. Thank you for creating it and sharing that impressive timeline. We could never expect that level of strategic thought from our mainstream media. USA
Very informative. As an American, we are never taught this kind of detail in the greater middle east.
Truth is always better
Throughout the world Russ, in every country they associate with, it's always U.S. self interests all the way, regardless, heartlessly. It's the powers that be Russ. The American people don't have a clue about this and often wonder why they are hated worldwide.
ua-cam.com/video/70TWtIJdOiY/v-deo.html This video has the true intentions
You are not even thaught that Afghanistan is not Middle East.
@@roystonboodoo7525 what about UK?
I like how you mentioned cinematic pieces being used to alter perception. A lot of people don’t even realize it. For example, US movies made in Hollywood used to be good stories but in 1994 when a movie came out showing the oppressive nature of the Chinese Communist Party, China threatened the entire US movie industry. They threatened to no longer provide exports of cheap products needed for creating movies to the US and so the entire movie industry spread the word that no depiction of China is authorized without running it by China first. Think for a sec, when have you ever seen a movie in the last 20 years that didn’t show China as some super metropolis with highly advanced technology. It’s all a farce. There’s no telling what else we’ve been shown indirectly that has molded our perceptions
Just like Americans living in the illusion of freedom.
@@dznuts123 feels pretty free to me 🤷♂️ I mean we could use with less taxes though
@@samuelmontypython8381 Well, people don’t need much to survive… In all seriousness, what most people do in their lives are within the government’s boundaries. When I said the illusion of freedom, I meant the freedom of thought and access of information.
@@dznuts123 Leave them in that illusion only if their food and drugs have not run out yet lol.
@@xtzhao2196 but do you understand what would happen then? War. This is the case we often see in history when it comes to countries with elections. That’s how hitler came into power. And what about now? We have the United States, and it’s been at war (direct and proxy)… most of the time. You think the us’s collapse will come without some kind of conflict? The us is already in a proxy war with Russia.
Very insightful, and very sad what is happening now in Afghanistan. The average American would never want to see our allies and helpful friends in harm's way. I'm horrified at the way this withdrawal has been handled.
American citizens must become aware so they direct the government on these matters
If only my history teacher taught the class like this probably my class would understand the world much better thanks
Misery mongers what is it
We wonder why the world is such a mess all us so called
Plebs would rather live in peace but whether it's Britain and France in the first world war double dealing the Jews and the Arabs or further down the path America and Russia it seems that we seem to always burden with
A class of meglamaniac
Who endorse their will on the
Smaller countries and now you,ve got a new wolf warrier player on the block I,ve got an idea they should all piss off and let people live in peace
Hey I,m not that naive I know that there is only one son of man who can ever bring peace to this world of ours
( yes my choice of words was
on purpose ) when I said " Son of Man peace for his sake or else some fool could get it into their heads to
Push I,m not going any further I think we all understand the consequences
Theachers are there to endoctrinate the stupid.
Not to bring them Up.
Absolutely right...
So basically every masterminds of Taliban is trained by CIA of USA .... So we should blame USA for sponsorship terrorism in afghanistan
Agree with you, I hated History exams, but history is an interesting subject if someone explained like this.
First time ever in my life i found history interesting because it went straight thorough my head without any confusion.
Biri Esther... That's because he explained it in it's correct order according to time.
I am more confused ! As per presenter all world leaders and intelligence agencies were so stupid to follow Pakistan dictation?
Totally agree
This guy is Good 360°
Exactly the plot twist one
Was just Awsmmmmmm....!!!
Amit explained and predicted the events pretty accurately.
Thank you!
That was an amazing journey of things I learned just now. Mind blown. I have been following the events in Afghanistan & have not heard anything as insightful as your video. Thank you, I will be watching more of your videos in the future.
Thank you for an very informative video. As an American I really hope we stay out of the middle east and deal with our own problems.
Not all the news channels, nor all the political analysts and experts succeeded in helping me understand this complex situation in the way that THIS presenter has. Take a bow, Amit!
"After living in caves for 20 years, they're not going to be that easy to control" 😂😂😂😂
This gentleman aided me in connecting the precarious dots by a rational analysis.
In his terms, now he is doing a narrative building to show Pakistan a terrorist
@@prakashkumar-gf8by Isn't Pakistan a state-sponsored terrorist nation? And only a narrative is needed to disclose it?
@@karthik_k.j not exactly, but we believe in what is said rather than what is true. My point is if we don’t have any issues inside our country(peace & prosperity) then our image will grow in front of other countries. Just an example why people from India move to US and never return?
@@prakashkumar-gf8by Well Pakistan is a terrorist nation. And problem is not that India or Pakistan is poor. Many countries are poor, like Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam etc but they don't sponsor terrorism, like Pakistan does
@@warpdrive9229 🧢 stop lying on Pakistan foolio. You really don’t know your history goofy. 😭
Such a great video. Appreciate the research and making it easy to understand.
Great explanation! I'm laughing so hard at "Pakistan is the founding fathers of all the Afghan chaos" 😂 Also, never thought that the Pakistani are great businessman, it created demand when its service as a war-broker no longer needed by training those religious militancy in Afghanistan and Kashmir. The way I see it, they outsmarted the US for 20 years..
It might flatter the Pakistani's to think they out smarted the US for that long. But the US never trusted Pakistan to begin with and both sides had clear sight of exactly how far to trust each other. The US had to balance the need to 'ally' with Pakistan to have air bases, etc while attempting to defeat AQ and the Taliban. The US knew full well that the Pakistani governments were playing both sides at the same time. An opinion reinforced when it turned out Usama had been hiding in Pakistan for years!
They always do that.... The american know that, but let it happens . Because there are corruptions inside the CIA. They gave money also to afganistan. Billions. Some going to CIA pockets. They just dont care if afgan only has ghost army... They know, but dont care
@@johnsmith-mv8hq they know, but they go along for 20 years. Using US tax money to support afgan gaverment and pakustan goverment because some of the money going to CIA, president of the US pocket.
Well if we no longer take moral and ethics in consideration , then yes , Pakistan will even sell their wife for money. But what they don't know that taliban are noncalculable this strategi is coming back to bite them .
@@FeelGoodTve sell their wives??haha what a lame joke
There are more foreigners in comment section than Indians .. Amit as a teacher is crossing national boundaries .. Respect !!
Just 4 min in and I’m surprised I haven’t heard about this channel before! Such amazing analysis! Subscribed straight away
Here comes the Hero 🔥❤️
Taliban after watching this
"Even we didn't knew all this"
Nice 😂
nailed it
U don't know but they know everything 🤣
😂
Hahahaha
Super informative! I've always been confused about the whole Afghan debacle but now more in the loop thanks to this very interesting and informative vid. Many thanks.
I've always wanted to use time lines in history debates....but was too confused by the amount detail and chronology to sift through.
You have inspired me ...thank you
The only Indian analysis that put US on a negative side😁 👍.... Thank you Sir.
Yani Khan sir ki video nahi dekhi.
@@rajatdani619 Khan sir overrated
US will actually end terrorism there by leaving.
ua-cam.com/video/kk_xNR_ho18/v-deo.html
...
WION also has the same stand!
Yes. I was living in the region since about 2000-2001..for about ten years...all this about Pakistan sponsoring terrorism is spot on.... My home near Islamabad was not far from Osama's home in Pakistan..my home in Kashmir was right in the midst of other terrorist organizations..I spent much time in Murree...I've understood all this for years...but you have done an excellent job of vocalizing it very well... I have a new theory, that Biden is trying to get us out of the region completely and focus on opening all of Central and South America ..hence the wide-open borders..
Seems to me you were all over the place. Absence of Evidence Is Not Evidence of Absence. Once they were found in the White House with your president Ronald Reagan with a tag of " like a founding fathers of America" .
🤣 Murree is in punjab not is kashmir. Osama was in Abbottabad not in Islamabad. Bro are you dumb that Pakistan would terrorists homes among normal citizens?
Once upon a time " Terrorists and Taliban" are called Mujahideens because they were fighting for USA & CIA against Soviet Union. They were funded, trained and weaponized by CIA and YES Pakistan made big mistake by getting involved in it, but not anymore, ABSOLUTELY NOT. Osama once the favorite mujahid of CIA was living in Abbottabad and not in Islamabad.
Maybe Pentagon wants to shift focus to the Asia Pacific
I would say that Terrorism is only created by Pakistan and also West's blunder by providing supplies and arms to them. Not only West but also China, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and even Egypt and Israel also. India knows it very well. Even though they defeated USSR but Western countries had thrown themselves on the mess.
Video made three weeks ago. And the government folded in a few days. Great video sir.
Another conflict zone? it gave me goosebumps. The zone is Ukraine now?…
Absolutely
This class was so awesome. I’m not really interested in history of the world but this got me interested because of a sound teaching. SMH 🤦♀️
Sir it’s not only informative but very bold at the same time. A tight slap on the face of chaotic and escapist U.S.A .
we are the best name me a better country
AlhumduliAllah, Taliban are great warriors and just human beings,they deserve to govern the Afghanistan totally on Islamic system based on peace,mercy and justice.
Believe me Islam gives more respect and love to women than the West.For Taliban about women watch their interviews and don't fall in propaganda.
Taliban has the potential to maintain peace and justice in Afghanistan.
Long live Taliban
Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan
May Almighty Allah help Taliban in establishing the Islamic system in Afghanistan and may Almighty ALLAH bless them with ultimate mercy, happiness, health, wealth,peace and many more beautiful blessings.
Regards,
Peace and justice lover.
Anti-oppression and just person.
did you even understand and watch the whole video?? lol at the end its a clear strategy to leave. why? who are afghanistans neighbouring countries?? the enemies of the US. why not unleash the wildlings on them! lol
@Srinu Agree with your point, " why all Muslims want to go to western countries and live"?
This guy must be a troll, nobody is this deluded.
@@thewildcardperson The USA is a great country.
Unfortunately your current President and it's administration is a total xxxx xx(words removed to avoid being banned).
My understanding what happened in Afghanistan is the result of geopolitical interest between USSR and US at first place, as a child growth in 80's I watched TV a lot alongside with my family and our favorite was news, world news broadcasted by gov't TV. It's almost everyday we heard about the Kabul situation and Mujahiddin groups. But never really understood the complexity of the Afghan issue in such details. Thank you Sir for making the video, this is world history lesson which every history teacher and student should know. Now I can argue people who blames US exit causing the chaos in Afghanistan.
I'm from srinagar kashmir...ur knowledge crystal clear..💚
Brilliant perspective. One of the best explanations of the Afgan situation I've come across. Well done and thank you!
I've been in the process of researching and pursuing information myself to understand as best as I can this situation. I will continue to view more after this video. I agree with you! I've researched many different sources so far with different perspectives and narratives. So far this video is a culmination of everything I've come across with the exception of a few. Of course they were a more American leaning perspective. I'm only a quarter way through this video so far!
@@mangokane11 America is adept at narrative building using Western media, Hollywood etc... whilst the guys on the other side use their own channels to float their agenda packaged in a way that attracts a lot of sympathy, so most of the articles the we see ends up being biased either way. However, I felt the person who made this video has tried to analyse the issue objectively. Whilst it does not answer all the questions, it readies your mind to think in the right direction...
@@lj7149 yup. It's about emotions right? Emotions are very powerful and also easily susceptible to manipulation because of the thought process being affected or " triggered " causing irrationality. Too bad most people don't understand that as you do! Stay aware and safe! Aloha!
What an explanation !!!! 👏 Past, present, future of Aghan war, how beautifully summed up in 30mins... Thank You sir
Watching after 8 months of release of this video. All predictions made then, are working spot on. 😊👍
I started this video with zero knowledge and now as it end ,I feel like, I know it all, what a great explanation sir👏👏.
Thank you so much🙇♀️❤
Yeah, because you are an ignorant! And follow people’s idea. Not yours
@@jijyat7956 Its not about idea , its about view point and he explained his point with proofs and fact .
And this shows, how ignorant of you for not to welcome other people's opinion.
As far as my idea is concern , I pretty much agree to his ideology, unless you have a more solid point to proof against it.
@@jijyat7956 pretty much how they all are now
OMG! What a great discussion! Finally, Thanks a lot.
Man after 1 year of Taliban take over everything you said in this video is proving to be right. Tehreeke Taliban is kicking ass of Pakistanis left right and center.
USA is again involved in another indirect conflict with Russia using Ukraine as a proxy.
India is providing aid to Afghanistan and China is building relations.
You tube understood how desperately i wanted to know what exactly is happening in Afghanistan, it directed me to this page!! Glad!
You have gathered great piece of info and narrated extremely well and easy to understand. Appreciate your work.
Sir, I must say you are underrated.. Kudos to this Video.
I Love this video, informative and has no blaming, bias nor support to any political discourse. Not like how media covers the issue.
A 30 minute documentary/analysis that is worth watching. Full of context and substance.
You hit the nail on the head about the US . I'm gonna be listening to you more often. People are beginning to wake up.
The way you explained was so clear & crisp to the point.. One of the best channels i always wish to watch👌🔥🙏
Well someone said the truth by connecting all the dots in the chronological order. Well done Sengupta. Bravo
THAT WAS AN OUTSTANDING WAY TO EXPLAIN THE SITUATION .....
Great respect for all indian journalists who are brave, intelligent and always spread the truth.
Our Hero never fails to impress us with lot of added information. A great Fan of all your videos sir. Thanks for sharing the knowledge ♥️
Strategically important points covered by Amit Sir by connecting dots.Thanks
Amazing. Your prediction came true 🙏. When you said that Afghan government will fall shortly. 👍🏻👍🏻
I knew this man has huge talent to express the true scenario, for the whole crisis I searched it with Amit sir...
I have never seen any youtube channel like yours that explains each and everything clearly and interesting manner.
Was waiting for this… thank you
Wow wow wow! That was simply brilliant. You cleared so many doubts of last 30 years. Hats off 🙏🙏✌👍👏👏👏❤🇩🇪
That was the clearest analysis I've seen on this subject
Now it all makes sense to me
Much awaited. Thank You sir❤️🙏🏻
You deserve a standing ovation!! This was succinctly and clearly spelt out.
Now Amit Senugupta Sir is known Worldwide 🌍
Finally someone showed up and explained it very well. Very easy to understand so now we all should say
#Sanctions Pakistan #sanction USA
Now you know where ur tax $ goes
Amit sengupta ,theLegend on the planet giving us perinially refined lectures😛
I was eagerly waiting for this sir. Thank you so much
This is the reason of why we Afghans love Indians so much. Amit sir always stay happy and blessed and share these informative lectures with us.
Sir, please make a video on "How India can tackle China?" in Indian Ocean Region and in Northeast,ladakh,etc.
Yes..please Amit sir
Please do
By voting BJP
🤣🤣🤣
I love this video! So logically based and insightful. I plan to build a historical event database to run pred analytics for situations like this. Going to write a textbook and curriculum called history's mysteries. I hope to start on it soon in my free time.
By.
Good luck. Much needed!
🙏 such crystal story explaination. Just woww. Bringing up Vietnam story as that really effected the thoughts. Thank you for good content and lots of hours into it. Extraordinary work with map learning, history and everything. Thank you so much
This was very informative for me and remember I live in Jamaica,this clip open my brain to the real happening in afghanistan.thank you.
I come here for voice ASMR. I turn his videos on & sleep peacefully for the runtime! 😌😌❤️
I was waiting your video sir on the afghan Taliban issues...finally it comes.
Thanks sir as always😁💟
Why is everything being true whatever you are saying? Amazing boss
Thank you for explaining this, very detailed explanation and insight. This has never been taught in our high schools despite its importance in our understanding of the Middle East and the world.
Because its a biased view depending on which side of the war that country was in
Hatts off to you Sir for such an amazing lecture on this topic so precisely 🙏🏾
23:21 he said "Afgan govt will fall shortly". and this is what happening today. WTF
If you do your research and look at he big picture, it was obvious and logical.
Everyone who did a little research and knows about Afghanistan knew that Afghanistan will go into the hands of the Taliban. Nothing surprising there Anuj.
@@thestoryofindia9357 They took over Afghanistan because of one thing...... Joe Biden's incompetence. This wouldn't of happened if Trump had still been in office. Ask Soleimani why
@@ToolFist598 Matt, everyone was expecting Kabul to fight back and show resistance at least for a few months. Without any logistics, pay, and direction the Afghan forces gave up and went back home. There were people who told the U.S that they need to train a more diverse army. The majority of the Afghan army is Pashtun and the majority of the Taliban is Pashtun. The only hope is the vice president of Afghanistan Ammrullah Saleh who did not flee and will not! He is in Panjshir valley gathering a resistance force with the sons of late ''Lion of Panjshir'' Ahmad Shah Massoud.
@@thestoryofindia9357 Because a major part of the training they received required air support from the US but Joe Biden wouldn't even allow that to happen or even allow contractors in to work on aircraft for them. This current US admin is an emberrassment to our country and I feel sorry for the civilians over there that are suffering the consequences of our current inept, corrupt administration.
Your analysis is one of the best ....
Thank you..
Very comprenhensive and explained a lot of my questions on the current conflict in Afghanistan!
It's been days . i was really waiting for a new video
Thanks Dear Amit. Now I am truly and thoroughly knowledgeable. Even the British in the 17th or 18th century left Afghanistan
ah man this gave a me whole different perspective in looking at the story
Many Americans wanted our soldiers out of Afghanistan after it was clear the goal went from revenge to Nation building after 2yrs in. Once Pakistan coughed up Bin Laden, the US citizens really petitioned for our troops to get out. The majority doesn't care what other countries are doing. Now I'm even more weary of that last round of $10M for gender studies.🤔
This has got to be the best summary of our stupidity thus far! Great job and keep putting all these amazing historical lessons. 👍
“Never wrestle with pigs. You both get dirty and the pig likes it.” ― George Bernard Shaw
Cannot thank you enough sir!! It's so very insightful. International relations keep on getting complicated and you enlighten us as it does.
India will divide in to 28 pieces,,,at the moment half kashmir administered by pakistan and occupied other half by india any time pakistan will capture it by sending nuclear missiles towards india...godi media gay hindus love Pakistan from Dhaka Mirpur Bangladesh ♥♥♥♥
Great lesson on geopolitics
@@mohimprincekbr8814 😂😂😂 Do u forget 93k surrender 😁😁
I was constantly checking your Chennal, For this analysis! it's just amazing sir ❤️
Please keep posting Geopolitical Videos more frequently 😁, these are far far better then any Bollywood movie.
Thanks a lot sir, I have watched western TV for years and never understood things like you have explained in 60 minutes. It's like 2 years of western TV equals to 60mins from you clear and precise
Yes, albeit, biased just as every and as much as the media. Presenter touts the Pakistna and India war as liberation of Bangladesh when it was the wicked Indira Gandhi which spearheaded those efforts to cause weakness in a young nation. The Khalistan movement he credits Pakistan with, well he failed to mention how India used Sikhs to fight their dirty wars against Muslim Pakistan and the sand bagged them. Over time when the Sikh community reozed the game, they started the movement for an I dependent Punjab State.
Additionally, as an American, I am also offended that now the USA has pulled out of Afghanistan, India is crying foul foul...but is more than happy to lick our boots for their own agenda and toss us aside when they feel Daddy isn't paying tgel much attention.
In the end, its every nation for itself and I get that, but it is sickening to see people such as this presenter who comes across as if he is providing accurate and unbiased facts, when it is just like anything else, muddled with biased propaganda with half truths.
@@blueearth3313 bulla triggered
@@blueearth3313 ok Pakistani
Sir, I have a humble request if you could provide your lectures in PDF format also. It would be very helpful though.
+1
+1
+1
अब यहां पर सब कुछ बता तो दिया फिर किसलिए पीडीफ में?
@@MrSoothsayer हमें पढाया कक्षाओं में भी जाता है फिर भी हम संस्थानों और शिक्षकों से नोट्स की आशा करते जैन क्योंकि उनके लेखन में हमारे तुलना में अंतर पाया जाता है ।
In my humble opinion, the withdrawal of the US forces is a clear strategy. When the US forces were there in Afghanistan, the neighbours of Afghanistan i.e Iran, Pakistan, China, central Asian countries backed by the Russians were playing cat and mouse game with the American using Taliban which is more or less a loose cannon. Now, the US turned the tables in them by putting the problem of instability into the playground of Afghanistan's neighbours. Further, the US sitting remotely can use tribal warloads and factions of the Taliban to create problems for Afghanistan's neighbours in a cost effective manner and not putting their men on the ground. Here, India is the biggest loser as of now. India needs to prepare for the worst and prepare for war in an extreme situation.
So you agree Trump was smart to make the deal?
turned into a proxy war.
@@AmitKumar-zy9ug the US presidents at least seems to be a dummy to me mostly echoing the position of their deep state.
@marigold well put. The grand strategy of the US is to prevent coalitions of power. The US does this by strategic interventions from Central America to the Middle East, and soon will reach into space. The “deep state” thing is laughable but ironically somewhat correct- American grand strategy on a global scale transcends party lines in US politics. The strategy will remain as long as the US has no rival superpower on the scale of the USSR. And please don’t start with China as that rival… the rival cannot be economically dependent on its foe.
@@AmitKumar-zy9ug Trump was executing American grand strategy that has been in place since the 1940’s. Smart? Maybe in that he saw the obvious conclusion and went with it - but then his hated rival Biden executed on that deal. Why? Because it fits the strategy. So I don’t call him smart but it was probably the obvious and right choice to do a deal.
Great video. Though I don't agree with you on 2 points-
1. Taliban will give a 'payback' to Pakistan- They completely are hand in gloves with PK govt. The reason is that the PK air force and army are currently helping the Taliban via cross-boundary operations to overtake the AF govt. Sunni majoritarianism is another common point.
2. Taliban don't care about Uyghur Muslims/Balochs - they have realised that the most important thing is 'survival', which requires capital/resources(which China via PK can provide them). Taliban structure is mostly of a tribal clan (local heads at district level), this will lead to no 'centralised ideology' resulting in widespread corruption (here China can come in). India should stay alert at this point, for the tip of scale can shift to either side.
1) not completly true, watch youtube channel called Defensive offence by Major Gaurav Arya, he shared groud about this topic, 2) some what agree with you 95%, rest there is possiblity some of members dont listen and could start movment, if some kind of movment started it would be hard for china, thats why they already met taliban few days back would have made agreements
Boy oh boy this guy is very intelligent .
Excellent video!! Clearly exposed who are all the culprits behind Afghanistan problem
You take your own time in making content and it is totally worth the wait. I am no professional to comment on your fact checking but the feeling it invokes to know more about stuff is what makes you stand apart.
Suggestion- whatever you show in the video, could be posted on the website too. It will be really handy for reference.
Thank you :)
Once God has come with new lesson, i feel like an school boy, i like to call Sir Amit Sengupta
One of the best videos on Afghanistan’s crisis!!
@Faz Assir 😃😃 you are so brave man. He is a terrorist minded.. let him give one small answer why pakistan never develops until now and not going to develop even in future. If they spent all the money and aid from US for their development , they would not be in shitty state. Every paisa they invest in terrorism only.. karma will come back..
Yes, this is just what I have been looking for. Please start a news channel that just takes you through the major points and history of each of the conflicts in the world. When any big news breaks just give us the breakdown (This'll make you rich). The news articles online are just rambling nonsense. They're difficult to understand, there is no depth, they don't answer the important questions and they usually have a political agenda. Use a timeline like you did, give the major plot points and motifs of the players involved, and the resolution of how the situation has come to be in the present. Please give us the real facts. Thank you, great video.
Hell be putting his life in danger
@@nastyc6052 How?
@@rcorp4144 u think the government will let anyone expose them,whistle blowers get silenced bro its reality
He does that whenever he gets time. He basically teaches Civil Service aspirants in India and we have a paper of International studies under which we need to understand & know major international events and geopolitical shift. And world history to some extent.
Very insightful and well researched - thanks Amit. 🙏🏼
Best lecture I have seen on Taliban.....❤👏🔥🔥
Excellent video & information! Complicated but very well & clearly explained! Thank you! I never knew all of that but now I do! 🙂👍🦅
Personally, I surely pray & hope for more Worldwide Peace! May G-d help US All! 😇🕊