Should India Engage with the Taliban I Addressing Pakistan as Common Foe I Syed Bilal Fatimi I Aadi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 тра 2024
- Should India Engage with the Taliban I Addressing Pakistan as Common Foe I Syed Bilal Fatimi I Aadi
#taliban #india #pakistan #deftalks
DEF Talks is a space for clear cut discussions on important subjects of current affairs of the world with a prime focus to the Indian Subcontinent. I cover issues related to conflicts, Geopolitics, Military Strategy and Foreign Affairs.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @deftalksbyaadi
Do support me by clicking "Thanks'.
PAYPAL ME: paypal.me/deftalks?country.x=...
UPI ID 8217078858@ibl
Connect With me and Interact
EMAIL: aadiachint@gmail.com
TELEGRAM: t.me/deftalksaadi
LINKEDIN: DEF TALKS BY AADI ACHINT
TWITTER: / aadiachint
Copyrights owned.
My humble question to the guest:
1. Did India stood with Russia when Russia invaded Afghanistan? Did India fight along side Russia? Did India supply arms, ammunition n personnel to Russia?
2. Did India gave any base to America when US bombed Afghanistan?
1. May be but the world politics was different at the time then today! if we know- India always provided humanitarian, medical and transport support. this includes the training and establishment of children hospital in Kabul, TATA buses and some other educational help with universities!
2. No India was the smartest game player in the region!
however, during British Raj, over 200 years, British used Indian soldiers as part of British military to attack Afghanistan- they were paid solders! after the loss of British in Afghanistan, and had the support of Afghans specially Pathans, until India was free nation!
Gandi and subsequent rulers of India seen Afghans as friends and supporters. a lot to unpack but in 20 centuries, India was and is the best friend of Afghans! If not, check the Pethans! see your Bollywood super stars! The Khans!
Indian culture, books, history is cherished in Afghanistan and still is! all the kings and presidents of Afghanistan were Pashtuns! they had best relationship with Indian governments! Afghanistan is mostly run by Tribal laws, and a mix of relgious laws! you can have Talib Pashtun but also mostly secular and even communist Pashtuns! dealing with pashtuns is straightforward! don't humiliate them and be honest in business dealings! That's it! they are like big brother in Afghanistan, once they are united, all other tribes unite with them.
Afghan are innocent peoples in his bilal ahmad point of view but if you saw the 1000 year history they always attack india punjab
1000 years ago everyone attacked everyone, even Indian kingdoms attacked other Indian kingdoms.
brother peace ✌️ we’re living in 21st century ,”Gade murde vakani ka kya fayda, “ going back to the past to the dark era of slavery 200 years ago then we should first start with Britannia …
@@Afghan1774 तुम हजारों साल पुरानी बुद्ध की प्रतिमा को तोड़ दो और हमें गड़े मुर्दे नहीं उखाड़ने की नसीहत दो यह चलेगा नहीं। तुम्हारा भाई ही इधर आके बोल कर गया ना कि जब रूस ने काबुल पर हमला किया तो भारत ने रूस का साथ दिया और जब अमेरिका ने हमला किया तो भारत अमेरिका का साथ दिया। गड़े मुर्दे हम उखाड़ रहे थे या तुम्हारा भाई उखाड़ रहा था?
Got to understand the afghan view of India in the new light
For yesteryear he says "Afghanistan ruled India".
For yesterday he says 'India, in the 80s & 90s should have joined Afghanistan against Pakistan, Russia, USA and the western interests "
For today he says "India should join Afghanistan against Pakistan, USA, and Russian interests"
Tomorrow he will say "Afghanistan should rule India again"
Actually India is always the target 😅😅
😂
😂😂😂😂😂
yep rightly said , i don't think another episode will happen with him
using divide and rule method ?? be aware that some Pakistanis Are using Indian names.
We still remember Prithviraj...we also remember Ghazni...we shouldn't ever forget that....we owe that to our ancestors.... Russians were not defeated in Afghanistan...they just withdrew in a disciplined manner as it wasn't worth it....
They were defeated that's why they left other wise they would have included Afghanistan into the USSR
Afghanistan lost its civilization and culture. They were 100% Hindu never forget that. Ofcource later they became Buddhist etc
They were never bound very tightly with Hinduism after Vedic clan of Gandhar migrated to punjab,their culture mainly comes from PashtunWali.
@@aditya_sharma3 my roots are also in the Peshawar region. Punjabi khatris mostly come from Peshawar area.
They became Buddhist pacifists hence couldn't resist the islamic invaders@@aditya_sharma3
So on and so forth, but currently they are Muslims. Nothing wrong with that
@@dipdipu nothing wrong with being a muslim. Are you out of your mind. They follow quran and the sunna. Read surah 9.29 and you will have your answer!
I think your guest has a very very good point … India must reconsider Afgan policy
Chacha 5000 saal pehle dwapar yuga tha hamare yaha socho satyuga kitna purana hoga😊
Love to hear Fatimi Sahib
Great job well done Mr said …
Adi be like to chacha- Bade dukhi hokar kehna par raha hai, yahi apka pehla or aakhiri show hai😂
Like who cares man
U think everything else s in hand of Indian media ?
Kind fool never seen before
Our anchors not like others to surrender or give false information and give credit to Indians like normal Pakistani UA-camrs
using divide and rule method ? be aware that some Pakistanis Are using Indian names.😂😂 shame on you all
SIR SAYED BILAL WELCOME.
FROM BHARAT..
Afghanistan did not rule India. They only ruled Delhi and its surrounding areas. India is older than 5000yrs. Recent archeological surveys at Dholavira and Lothal take Indian civilization to at least 40,000 years.
Most of the rulers came through Afghanistan to India and ruled India ...read the history
@@Sportsdesire-zk4shtrue but before rise of the Islamic religion. Afghanistan shared religious ties with Bharat in the form of Buddhism.
Neither in past nor in future, afgan has no plans to invade any country.
Yes, you are right! in modern history they only ruled Delhi. The last king who ruled Delhi was Timor shah, which was ousted by British east India company supported by local Rajas! and India became the british colony for two hundred years! also need to know that Afghans are not new people to the region! read Kushans, Indus valley civilisation Grecko Bactrian or Bacteria. for specific tribe like Pashtuns, read "The Hephthalites" Sveta Huna!
@@Sportsdesire-zk4sh No they did not .
RAA ne watt lagadi ISI ki😅
No love for Afghanistan and deep suspicion for Talibans. Relation needs to be managed carefully.
Like we Afghans blindly waiting for u Indians to give life
lol
U live in another world
@@Abid-ali_AFG But Afghans blindly waiting for food grains and medicines from India
@@Abid-ali_AFG India did give u life by providing food and medicines when no one else cared .But that doesn't mean India will forget the situations like Flight IC 814 in kandahar .That would be stupid and fatal .
@@Edwin-tz5np78 we never said to Indians to bring us food and we neither said it to anyone , so stop blaming us for this nonsense
@@spiekd None Afghan died because of food shortages and India help Afghanistan for their nonsense interests and we Afghans knew everything but we wwaitung for chance
Question to Mr sayed if you see the comment section the ..
As Indian we do sympathise to afghan people, whole two to three generations have been wiped out due to war with USSR and USA. We also believe there is historic ties between the countries (we had Kabuliwala story in school )
The fear from Indian perspective to do business/ establish connection is 1) If the society may be radicalised by extremist (Buddha statue been destroyed by taliban) and considering non Muslim kafir
2) Reconciliation with Afghan diaspora who were against taliban, how would you reintegrate them without repercussions.We see Afghan as strong man society. One person gets the power eradicates the loser. So this is hard to establish ties for business
Pukhtoon love India ❤
Indians cant trust anyone - It could be Al Takiyah afterall. We have had enough back stabbing within the country as well.
But the Talibans are called terrorists because they are oppressive on women and girls.
Adi! Bhagat Singh and Talibans are not similar.
After the Islamic Revolution in Iran in 1979, universities and schools were closed sometime between 1980 to 1983. no one knows about that because there was no social media that time
Insightful discussion
JAI BHARAT 🇮🇳
9:00 It's a pale excuse to say that you were used. Instead, simply say, 'Sorry, we won't do it again'. We will accept it as an Afghan promise.
Extremely valuable perspective
We should stand with Afghanistan after this eye opening interview
Very informative and very detailed podcast ! ❤
Jai hind Jai Bharat
We have ruled u more than 1000 years so don't forget that and u are one of us
Off course india should support Afghanistan.
Now Trump understood why we didn't put our boots in Afghan... Now Bharat is the most respected one...no1 player building Afghan... We're more than brothers.. Khan Abdul gaffar Khan... The frontier Gandhi 🙏
Fascinating insight
This gentleman spoke very well about Afghan perspective. I think we should listen to him. India should act to take back our lost land
VOICE IS PERFECT
Fatemi sahib is very knowledgeable person
Speaker is the Afghan natonalist having great intelligence ,well speak for his country ,diplomatic language ❤
Dear Indians. Get out and VOTE!!!!!
100% true.
Fatimi sab love you
Very Interesting. Thank You. Jai Hind
Adi bhai good going!
bring guest like him time by time, very good
Good perspective from the guest. If Afghanistan was prosperous, they wouldn't perhaps have become mercenaries. Anyday Afghanistan can be trusted more than Pakistan. Remember they did destroy their opium plants, which has really pinched Pakistan. The question is good governance - but in a poor country top leaders are bound to make their money. After all it happened in India that was not Bharat, and Pakistan is still at it.
Wonderful Eposode. Real Eye opener. Thank you.
Hi, please bring this person he is a very knowledgeable and brave person thanks
Aadi
It’s really amazing
We respect his views and we definitely love afghan peoples we always wanted to have good relationship with Afghans……and despite real facts as Indian point of biew we get terrorized In kashmir in 1948 and in 1990s but we forget that and still Indian government is giving Help ….will he still deny it ..!???…Kabuliwala my childhood one of favorite story …Indian and afghan had long freindship
1:13
Yaar inn muslmano ko har jagh Allah ko kyu Lana hai!??
BTW great show
Beach’s we believe in Allah like u Indians Believe in Jai Mata Ji
So u can’t force to stop other people’s religious views
@Abid-ali_AFG you are not muslim , you are hindu actually , Arab invaders converted your forefathers anfld took your women , if you really want to be on right side , leave islam
@@Abid-ali_AFG It is South Asian muslims who keep forcing their religious beliefs on others. I have never seen any Indian utter his religious slogans in the start of any program with a non Indian smh.
@@Abid-ali_AFG Beach I have never seen any Indian utter his religious slogans at the start of a program with any non Indians. This is something only the South Asian muslims do out of insecurity.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🙏
Kaabuli waala...a lowly individual, and we imagine a remote region where this person belongs as a childhood story.
Whether we are good or bad. But we have always loved afghani people irrespective of their religion or politics...every Indian have place in his heart for Afghanistan
Thank you, we love and respect Indians, ✌️
Great insight👌👌
How come Blochistan is Afgan territory. Is it claim to reach the sea and break the curse of being landlocked
Super work Aadi
We need to have more conversation with him.....
Very nice talk thankyou sir
intresting, afghan point of view on history and geopolitics.
❤ जय हिंद जय भारत❤
Hats off to the person and a nice Human being
Jai hind jai bharat
Yes we can hear you both
Great podcast. Very very information and such a new & difference propective😊🇮🇳
Very good analysis
जय भारत वंदेमातरम ❤
good talks adi dada.
Good
Heart to heart
Honest
Sir aap bhi roz ke shows dekhte hai?
Jai hind jai Bharat 🙏
Amazing
Now, We have to change the whole narrative. It's too heavy.
Thanks for this inside story "Aadi".
#Afgansnarrative
👍🙏
Excellent
I think he is very right
We can hear you both Adi
The Taliban does not believe in democratic values or human rights. Now they need food, money and infrastructure development. Only India can help Afghanistan at present, but not for ever....😊
Their way of living is more precious to them than the rights as prescribed by the UN. The rest of the world should stop imposing the western values on the countries that are more interested in practicing their traditional ways. Afghans know what’s best for them. People that highlight issues in someone else’s cultures usually have vested interests.
I disagree.
@@Agyaat_ It seems you are not aware of Taliban.... Afghan are good but the Taliban has a black record against human rights...
We can hear both of you clearly.
We can hear both
Problem from Aadi’s end. We could hear properly
Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🙏
Mr Fatimi deserve to be heard.he has a point,
This man knows a lot.
He has bundles of informations.
And to those Indians that are doing the negative comments i want to say we mean no harm or bad intentions this is not 12th or 15th centuries but remember this that America prints dollars but we didn't much care about Arabs are the same we don't care about.
Now if you guys want to go against us again you are welcomed we are afghans and we don't care about no one but friends and friends we never let down even if we have to sacrifice our everything.
Jai Hind. Jai Bharat. Jai Shri Ram
We need sir more frequently on this channel
Jai Bharat 🙏
He is amazing, love to hear more from him. he may not have some facts correct but that's OK, so do we all, due to our education syllabus created by fake historians who worked for a narrative. However, when he talks on problems of common people, he is absolutely correct. He also talks against the western narrative, its so difficult to find that. I would love to hear from him more.
This man seems a sensible Afghan.
Very new angle to look at Afghanistan.
مننه فاطمی صاحب تاسو باید په هندی کی ورسره خبری کری وای هغه درته وویل چی مونگه با هندی اوردو کی خبری وکو
🙏all🙏
This was a great viewpoint biased maybe but good
🙏
Why is he claiming Balochistan?
Mr. Bilal we love people of Afghanistan, and feel sad for your destruction by various entities. We hope your coming future was bright and healthy. Sir one suggestion pls. Literate ladies because educated mother handle their kids properly
mr. Patel. right now private institutes private English classes medical universities nursing schools are open for girls, women are working in certain places...I hope they open public schools and universities soon ... best regards from Afghan girl 🙏
After the Islamic Revolution in Iran in 1979, universities and schools were closed sometime between 1980 to 1983. no one knows about that because there was no social media that time..
Hmm
JAI BHARAT.
❤
Excellent knowledge and viewpoint I came to know about Afghanistan.
Mr Bilal is sounding positive.s
I wish all the v best to Afghan citizens. God bless them.
We have to see just our interest. And never believe anyone.
A very interesting discourse and perspective from Afghanistan's representative.
Towards the end, while signing off, he was not audible to us.
Other powers are already maintaining relations with the Taliban.
With all due respect this gentleman kept on venting for entire duration of podcast.
N i m sorry but u cannot compare Bhagat Singh with these ppl because Bhagat Singh ji was fighting for nation, not for radical ideology with consider women an camodity n not even human.
Also we don't need anyone's advice regarding our relationship with china.
thanks for hindi urdu episode
when one
why he didnt
be aware that some Pakistanis Are using Indian and afghan names.
they’re trying to use divide and rule method on social media 😂 ✌️
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
Sir I think you are patriotic person of afgan but as we are wounded civilization and lots of wounds from afgan to I think in large context you must become civilized first and over come the narrow mentality
And India is always with common masses vande Mataram Jai Bhawani Jai shivaji
No Audio